Supreme Court Forces Trump to STOP Deporting Gang Members: Explainer

Facts Matter
2.9K followers
469 Video Views·Apr 23, 2025
🇺🇸 Try The Epoch Times here: https://ept.ms/RomanSale
🟡 Claim your free Gold from American Hartford Gold: https://ept.ms/3biH9MN
Episode Resources:
🔵 Supreme Court Stops Deporting Gang Members
https://ept.ms/Blocking
🔵 Proclamation 10903
https://ept.ms/PROCLAMATION
🔵 Sam Alito Opinions
https://ept.ms/AARP
🔵 Emergency Application
https://ept.ms/Emergency
-
© All Rights Reserved.
On a previous episode, we discussed how
the US Supreme Court ruled in Trump's
favor in an immigration case, a case
that involved the deportation of illegal
aliens present here in the US. However,
that earlier case that we discussed, it
was won by Trump on a technicality.
Basically, the lawyers of the illegal
immigrant, they decided to file their
case in Washington DC rather than in
Texas where the man was being held. and
therefore the case was dismissed because
it was brought forth in the incorrect
venue. But very notably in that earlier
case, the underlying legal issues at
play were not actually examined. The
question of whether the Alien Enemies
Act could really be used against
Venezuelan gang members, it was not
really ruled on. However, that all
changed late Saturday night. That was
when at 12:55 a.m., basically 1:00 in
the morning, the US Supreme Court issued
an unsigned order. You can see it up on
your screen. Blocking the deportation of
alleged Venezuelan gang members, at
least for the time being. Let's go
through the details of the order
together, how it came to be, what it
means in the short term in regards to
Trump's deportation plan as well as what
it might mean in the long term. And
before I forget, I will mention that the
Epic Times is having an Easter sale.
Well, they had it and they extended it
for a few extra days. And so if you've
been on the fence about trying the Epic
Times, you want to subscribe. You're
looking for a source of solid news that
doesn't spin narratives or present only
one side of the facts and not the other.
You're looking for a really robust
source of information, especially during
the second Trump administration when a
lot of legacy news outlets have sort of,
let's say, gone off the rails. Well, try
the Epic Times. It's only $1 a week. And
again, now's a great time because the
Easter sale makes it a dollar a week and
that'll be over soon. So if you want to
try it, I'll throw the link. It'll be
right there in the description box
below. Just click over there. It'll take
you to a landing page. You just put in
your details and you can try the Epic
Times for yourself. I'm sure you'll love
it. Now, getting back to the Supreme
Court decision, let's start with a bit
of background on this particular case.
Soon after assuming office, President
Trump signed into effect something known
as Proclamation 10903. You can see it up
on your screen. That proclamation
officially declared that the US
government officially designated Trender
Aaragua as a foreign terrorist
organization. Now, up until then,
Trenaragua was known to just be a
Venezuelan gang made famous when members
of that gang were caught on camera
harassing people who were living in an
apartment complex over in Aurora,
Colorado. But on March 20th of this
year, that all changed. Here's
specifically what Trump's proclamation
said regarding this gang. Quote,
"Trander Ragua is a designated foreign
terrorist organization with thousands of
members, many of whom have unlawfully
infiltrated the United States and are
conducting irregular warfare and
undertaking hostile actions against the
United States. Trenderagua operates in
conjunction with cartel delezles, the
Nicholas Madura regime sponsored narot
terrorism enterprise based in Venezuela
and commits brutal crimes including
murders, kidnappings, extortions, and
human, drug, and weapons trafficking.
Trenderwa has engaged in and continues
to engage in mass illegal migration to
the United States to further its
objectives of harming United States
citizens, undermining public safety and
supporting the Maduro regime's goal of
destabilizing democratic nations in the
Americas, including the United States.
Now, the language used in this
proclamation was very particular and it
was tailor made to tie the actions of
this Venezuelan gang with the current
Venezuelan president, Mr. Nicholas
Maduro. This connection is important
because by making it, the Trump
administration allowed itself to invoke
the Alien Enemies Act signed into law
all the way back in the year 1798. This
act allows the sitting president to
deport anyone who is not an American
citizen if they're from a country with
which there is a declared war or an
attempted invasion or predatory
incursion. And so by highlighting this
connection between the Venezuelan
government and trenda, it makes what's
happening arguably a form of state
sponsor predatory incursion, which is
the prerequisite for the invocation of
the alien enemies act, which is exactly
what President Trump did, writing
further down in this proclamation that
quote, "I direct that all alien enemies
described in section one of this
proclamation are subject to immediate
apprehension, detention, and removal,
and further that they shall not be
permitted residents in the United
States. In practical terms, this meant
that all members of this gang who are
Venezuelan citizens who are at least 14
years of age and who are not also US
citizens or green card holders, they are
now subject to immediate removal. And
that's exactly what started happening.
Using this pretext, the Trump
administration began rounding up illegal
aliens and sending them on flights
either back to Venezuela or if that
didn't work out to that large detention
center that was recently built over in
El Salvador. However, not all of these
alleged gang members are just letting
themselves get kicked out of America.
Some are choosing to actually fight
their deportations in court. And along
that line, last week on Friday, April
18th, the ACLU filed an emergency
request to the US Supreme Court on
behalf of two Venezuelans that they were
representing legally. The two
Venezuelans were both facing
deportation. And so the ACLU, they asked
the Supreme Court to immediately block
the Trump administration from being able
to deport their clients. You can see the
emergency appeal up on your screen. This
was the one that was filed with the US
Supreme Court and it was called AARP and
WM versus Donald J. Trump. And just for
your reference, AARP and WM are the
initials of the two Venezuelans who I
would have to assume want to remain
anonymous given the fact that in the
whole document their name does not
appear even once. Regardless though,
their main argument is that these
Venezuelans are not being given due
process. Many of the notices that
they're receiving from the US government
are in English, while many of the
detainees don't even speak English. They
speak exclusively Spanish. And then also
they are questioning the legality of
using the Alien Enemies Act at all in
the way that it's being used. Here's
part of what the ACLU wrote in their
application. Again, that was sent over
to the Supreme Court. Quote, "To date,
at least 137 Venezuelan men have been
removed under the proclamation and are
now in El Salvador in one of the most
notorious prisons in the world, possibly
for the rest of their lives. Whether
most or perhaps all of these previously
removed individuals lack ties to Trender
Aaragua remains to be seen because the
Trump administration secretly rushed the
men out of the country and have provided
no information about them. But evidence
since these individuals were sent to El
Salvador flights on March 15th
increasingly shows that many were not
quote unquote members of Trenderwa. Such
false accusations are particularly
devastating given our clients strong
claims for relief under our immigration
laws. Interestingly, the ACLU also used
the example of that man who was wrongly
deported back to El Salvador and who the
Supreme Court said the US government
should facilitate his return, but the US
government said our hands are basically
tied. The El Salvador government is not
going to send him back. And they use
that as an example for why this
application should be granted. Because
if these people are deported to El
Salvador and then it turns out they were
quote unquote wrongly deported, they
likely will not be sent back given that
earlier example. All right, just to
pause here for a super quick moment.
Listen, it's obvious that the financial
system is not looking too great after
being pumped up with trillions of
virtually free government dollars for
many, many years now. Well, the stock
bubble might actually burst in the near
future. And in that process,
unfortunately, it could take away the
nest egg of anyone who happens to be
exposed to it. And so, consider taking
this opportunity to diversify into
something which is beyond the grasp of
Washington DC and Wall Street, physical
gold and silver. And the best company to
use in my opinion is the sponsor of
today's episode, American Hartford Gold,
who I should mention is also my own
personal gold and silver bullion dealer.
And besides myself, they have thousands
of five-star reviews from other
Americans. And they also have an A+
rating with the Better Business Bureau.
And working with them is rather simple.
They have a huge selection of coins,
bars, and rounds to choose from. They
have super friendly staff who you can
call and they can set up either gold
delivery directly to your doorstep or
they can even set you up in a gold IRA.
And then lastly, best of all, if you
tell them that Roman sent you, they will
throw in a free gold coin with your
first qualifying purchase. So give them
a call. The number is
8662422352. That's
866242-22352 or you can simply text
Roman to
65532. I'll also throw a link to their
uh web page. It'll be down there in the
description box below. And then the ACLU
went on in their application to request
the Supreme Court immediately halt
deportation proceedings, not only for
the two men listed in this lawsuit, but
also anyone in the same class as them.
Meaning they're requesting that all
alleged Trend Ara members have their
deportations halted as well. Here is the
specific request they were making.
Quote, "Removal without sufficient
notice and time to seek habius relief is
in clear violation of this court's
decision of April 7, 2025 in Trump
versus JG." That was the earlier case we
discussed in our previous episode.
Applicants therefore respectfully
request an immediate order from this
court barring any removals of proposed
class members. Without this court's
intervention, dozens or hundreds of
proposed class members may be removed to
a possible life sentence in El Salvador
with no real opportunity to contest
their designation or removal. Emergency
relief is necessary not only to preserve
the status quo and prevent permanent and
irreversible harm to applicants, but
also to preserve the court's
jurisdiction in light of the
government's position that it need not
return individuals, even those
mistakenly removed. We ask only that
this court preserve the status quo so
that proposed class members will not be
sent to a notorious prison in El
Salvador before the American judicial
system can afford them due process. And
indeed, as I mentioned at the very top
of the episode, in an unsigned order
that was issued at roughly 100 a.m. on
Saturday morning, the US Supreme Court
acquiesced and they granted the
emergency appeal. The order, which you
can see up on your screen, was very
short. It was just a few sentences long,
about half a page, and it simply said
the following quote, "The government is
directed not to remove any member of the
puditive class of detainees from the
United States until further order of
this court." Now, notably, while this
order from the Supreme Court itself is
unsigned, at the very bottom, it does
mention that two justices dissented,
justices Clarence Thomas as well as
Justice Samo. And to that end, on the
next day, which was Easter Sunday, Sam
Alto published his own dissenting
opinion. You can see it up on your
screen. The descent was joined by
Clarence Thomas. And aside from saying
that it was legally questionable whether
the Supreme Court could actually block
the administration from deporting these
alleged Venezuelan gang members, it also
questioned the odd timing of the order
itself. Here's specifically what
Samolita wrote in his dissenting
opinion. Quote, "In some, literally in
the middle of the night, the court
issued unprecedented and legally
questionable relief without giving the
lower courts a chance to rule, without
hearing from the opposing party, within
8 hours of receiving the application,
with dubious factual support for its
order, and without providing any
explanation for its order. I refused to
join the court's order because we had no
good reason to think that under the
circumstances, issuing an order at
midnight was necessary or appropriate."
And then aside from the timing of the
order, Sam Alolo went on to list some of
the problems that he saw with the legal
rationale as well. Here's what he wrote.
Quote, "It is not clear that the Supreme
Court had jurisdiction. It is
questionable whether the applicants
complied with the general obligation to
seek emergency injunctive relief in the
district court before asking for such
relief from an appellet court. Meaning
that it appears that the ACLU
essentially jumped steps to get to the
Supreme Court ASAP." He continues, "When
this court rushed to enter its order,
the court of appeals was considering the
issue of emergency relief, and we were
informed that a decision would be
forthcoming. This court, however,
refused to wait. The only papers before
this court were those submitted by the
applicants. The court had not ordered or
received a response by the government
regarding either the applicant's factual
allegations or any of the legal issues
presented by the application. And the
court did not have the benefit of a
government response filed in any of the
lower courts either. The papers before
us, while alleging that the applicants
were in imminent danger of removal,
provided little concrete support for
that allegation. And then lastly,
although the court provided classwide
relief, the district court never
certified a class. And this court has
never held that class relief may be
sought in a habious proceeding. Now,
obviously, some of the problems he
highlighted here are a bit legally
technical, but in plain English, in
short, he was saying that between the
midnight timing of the order and the
scale of the relief granted, as well as
the underlying situation that was
playing itself out, Samo said that this
was an unprecedented move by the high
court and perhaps it was an overreach.
However, his position was in the
minority and therefore the deportations
have been blocked. Now, moving forward,
it's not exactly clear how this will all
play out. It could be that the ACLU will
have their day in court, and only once
their case concludes will this ban on
deportations either be lifted or made
permanent. That part is not exactly
clear. Again, the order from the US
Supreme Court, that very short half-page
order that you can again see up on your
screen, it simply said that the people
who belong to the puditive class of
detainees shall not be deported by the
government until further order from the
US Supreme Court. Meaning to the best of
anyone's guess in a practical sense all
Trender Ragua members are currently safe
from deportation at least until the US
Supreme Court decides otherwise. If
you'd like to go through the details of
this case in greater depth, I will throw
the proclamation from Trump, the
application from the ACLU, as well as
both the Supreme Court order and Sam
Alto's descent. I'll throw the links to
all those documents down into the
description box below. If you are the
type of person that likes to dig into
the weeds, and all I ask in return is
that as you're making your way down
there to that description box, take a
super short detour to smash those like
and subscribe buttons so that this
content can reach ever more people via
the YouTube algorithm. And also,
obviously, this is an evolving case.
This is an interim step. Obviously, this
is not the final decision. In the near
future, either deportations will once
again be allowed or they won't be
allowed. And so, we'll know once a
decision has been made one way or the
other. I'll make a follow-up episode
giving you that update. Until then
though, you can find those links down in
the description box below. And I'm your
host, Roman from the Epic Times. Stay
informed and most importantly, stay
free.
