Can Brain Explain Mind? | Episode 204 | Closer To Truth

Truth exists
11 followers
We know what it means to see and hear.
We know more than we know anything what our inner experience feels like.
Now, how is it possible that that inner experience is literally clumps of brain cells?
They're flowing chemicals and electrical impulses.
The two things, inner experience and brain cells, seem so radically different.
So, what is it about the brain that enables scientists to claim that they can explain the mind?
The issue torments my soul, if I have one.
Can brain explain mind?
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn, and Closer to Truth is my journey to find out.
For proper biologists, it used to be that studying the mind, or consciousness,
was off-limits, outside the scope of real science.
They could tackle brain function, of course, but mind?
Well, no.
That was too loose, airy, too philosophical.
Professor Christoph Koch takes consciousness seriously.
He seeks what he calls the neural correlates of consciousness.
We meet in his lab at Caltech.
Christoph, many non-scientists think that consciousness cannot be explained by brain
function. You talk about the neural correlates of consciousness. What exactly does that mean?
People, let's see, in the West, since 2,300 years, at least Plato and Aristotle,
have wondered about consciousness, and so many people think it's something that can't be addressed
by science. I think nothing is further from the truth. We've decided, okay, let's not worry about
these endless philosophical debates, and let's avoid that by focusing on something that almost
everybody, no matter where they fall on the ideological divide, can agree on, and that is
the correlates of consciousness in the brain. What we mean by that, there will be parts of your brain
that correlate with any one specific conscious thought or memory or intention or belief. So,
when I feel me, when I feel sad, when I have a toothache, all of those different conscious states,
there will be correlates. We can ask, which circuits in which particular part of the brain
is necessary for this specific conscious sensation, which molecules, which synapses,
which axon, which wires, what happens in sleep, what happens in dreaming, what happens in anesthesia
when the person is put asleep, what happens in coma? You are careful to distinguish between
correlation and cause. Yeah, for several reasons. When you talk about causes, then you're taking a
position, and you're really saying, well, this is what causes this, rather than this is what
correlates with. And then you get, what exactly do you mean by causation? So, A, at the ontological
level, we prefer to stick with the more neutral correlation. But you're forcing them to admit
that the correlation is absolute. Except with philosophers, you always find people who disagree.
So, there are some people who say the entire project of finding causes or correlates of
consciousness in the brain sort of is doomed. You're not going to find anything interesting.
And consciousness, it's not only in the brain, it's not only in the body, but it's the entire
interaction of the living brain with the living organ in its surround, and you can't localize
consciousness to any one component. But still, they have to admit that what you're seeing is
correlated to whatever the specific conscious event is. Yes. So, I guess what they would say,
yes, it's correlated, but so do many other things correlate with consciousness, and this isn't going
to help you that much. While we think the project is to find ever more precise correlates, to ever
make that relationship between conscious perception in your head and some brain states ever more and
more precise. So, ultimately, we can begin to do this in a very crude way. We can put electrode in
a patient and then you can stimulate. This allows us to ever more precisely pinpoint
consciousness to specific neuronal populations in the brain.
Kristoff has made the neural correlates of consciousness serious science by discovering
what's happening in the brain in real time when subjective experiences are sensed or felt.
When I did my doctorate in brain research 40 years ago, it's what I dreamed of. But correlation
is not cause, and the correlations thus far describe specific sensations. Can we get a full
theory of mind or consciousness? Sticking still with pure biology. Rodolfo Linas has a full theory.
He explains the swirl of consciousness by swirling circuits in the brain. Rodolfo is a leading brain
scientist from Bogota, Colombia. He's chairman of physiology and neuroscience at New York
University. We meet in Bellevue Hospital. What do we know about consciousness from a brain point
of view? Yes. Can we relate what we know about the function of the brain with the existence of
consciousness? And the first thing that happens is that we immediately remember that we exist as
human beings in two enormously different states. The states of being awake and states of being
asleep. Everybody sleeps. If you don't sleep, you die. Okay. Now once something wonderful happens,
when you sleep, you disappear. Your brain doesn't always create you. You are one functional state
of your brain, which we call being awake. Okay. So if you were to say, you know, what is the
difference between being awake and being asleep? And this tells us something about the nature of
consciousness. The answer is yes, it does. And the answer is beautiful. The thalamus and the cortex,
the thalamus is a central nucleus inside the head that connects to the cortex. The cortex is a huge
area of nervous system that goes back to it. So we have this circular event that is continuously
going on. So it's not like the thalamus fires every so often when the stimulus comes in. It's
always going on. I think of it as a vortex, something that is continuously like your heart.
It never stops for as long as you live. The brain is never quiet. So there's this circuitry. It's a
thalamus and so on. And the frequency tells you whether you exist or not. It is that beautiful.
And it is almost, if you wish, pardon me, that simple. So if your rhythms are slow,
you don't exist. There is no consciousness. So what is it that's happening with your
conscious? You're actually allowing certain areas of the cortex to be active and others to be
non-active. Now you call this a mindness, a mindness state. So what happens is when you
correlate what's happening in animals or in us, you find that this state is the state in which
mind is generated. If you could remove the bone and actually see the brain looking at it, you
will say, aha, I see what you're thinking. You can see it electrically. And then you can indeed see
that, yes, the granularity increases. So conscious state is a state of high granularity in the
functioning of the thalamocortical system. Definition, no problem. Okay, how does that help
to put the whole things together? Well, the visual system and the auditory system and so on have the
same granularity and have the same rhythm. So you can superimpose now. So you get a binding.
Dynamic binding, because there's coherence in this particular type. So you have a temporal
coherence with similar frequencies that bring different modalities, sight, sound,
other things together, memories that get a binding into one conscious entity. So this vortex,
this continuous is me, is you. So I have a book called Eye of the Vortex. And that is how the
system works. This vortex, this dynamic process, that this celebration that we call consciousness
is in fact a dynamic property of the anatomy of the system. Eye of the Vortex. To Rodolfo,
this is consciousness. The continuous electrical circuitry between the thalamus in the center of
the brain and the cerebral cortex that covers the brain. This is how consciousness works.
And what consciousness is. Can it be that simple? Before I inquire of philosophers,
I must ask whether mind or consciousness can exist outside of biological brains.
My question, how can brain explain mind, gets more complex for highly advanced machines.
Or as futurist and visionary Ray Kurzweil puts it, non-biological intelligences.
I meet Ray in his office in Boston. I think fundamentally consciousness is its own
sense of our own awareness and is a synonym for subjectivity. And science is a synonym for
objective observation and then making deductions from there. And there's a gulf between objective
observation and subjective experience. We really can't objectively assess the subjective experience
of another entity. We may look at an entity and look inside its brain, which may be biological,
non-biological. We may see that it's building models of its own experience. It may be
making decisions just like the way a human does. It may have these feedback loops.
But is that just a simulation of a human being? Is it really having conscious experience or is
it just some automatic process? Now, we just assume that other humans that are acting conscious
are conscious. But that's just an assumption. That actually breaks down when we talk about animals.
Some people assume that animals aren't conscious. They're just acting by instinct, which is some
primitive machine-like mechanism. And other people feel that animals are conscious. We'll
have this when it comes to machines. Now, we don't yet have machines that appear to be conscious.
You may meet a virtual person in a video game that says, I'm angry or I'm happy. They don't
yet have the subtle cues that will really convince us that they're really experiencing these feelings.
My prediction is that these entities will be so sophisticated and so subtle and will have the same
complexity as human beings, in fact, will be based on reverse engineering the human brain,
that when they say I'm happy or I'm jealous, they really will have those subtle cues and
will believe them because they really will be acting just with the same subtlety as human
beings. Are they really conscious? Some people assume that though you have to be biological will
say no. Other people will say yes. I think we'll be convinced by them. And if you accuse that
system of being not conscious, it may get mad at you. It'll get mad at us and it'll be very
smart and it'll make us feel bad and it'll convince us that it's conscious. But you talk
about fundamentally, philosophically, there's no way to prove that it's conscious. Some people say,
well, it's just a machine and therefore it's just a simulation and a simulation isn't reality.
And so that's a philosophical issue. Is there a difference between a true simulation that captures
every aspect of a process and the real thing? So we can certainly study a lot of
issues with how the brain is processing emotion and these different feelings. But fundamentally,
we can't really grasp the essence of consciousness as a scientific subject because
there's this gap between subjective experience and objective observation.
Ultimately, says Ray, machines will appear to be conscious. Every test of consciousness,
they will pass. There will be no way to tell the difference between a machine and a human.
But are these non-biological intelligences really conscious? With inner subjective experiences in
their own private insides? We can never know, says Ray. And I think he is right.
A true consciousness detector is in principle impossible. This chills my spine. What then
is mind? I've hit the limit in science. I turn to philosophy. When I think of philosophy of mind,
I think of John Searle. John's a professor at Berkeley and he follows the facts wherever they
lead. I call my view a biological naturalism because it says the mind is a biological
phenomenon and it's part of nature. The materialist says physical reality is all the reality there is.
It's all physical particles and fields of force. The dualist says there is a part of reality that's
irreducibly mental and I want to preserve both of those. Now, how do you do that? Well, step number
one is you take the brain seriously after you've first established that consciousness really exists.
There are some people who try to deny the existence of consciousness, but that won't work
because the way that we typically get rid of things in science is by showing that there's
an illusion of color, an illusion of solidity, an illusion of liquidity, but it reduced to something
else. But that won't work for consciousness because where consciousness is concerned,
the illusion is the reality. If it consciously seems to me that I'm conscious, then I am
conscious. All right. Number one, we accept consciousness as real and irreducible. Now,
step two is you start to ask, well, like anything else in biology, what causes it?
Conscious states are caused by neuronal processes. Step two, all of these conscious states,
everything is realized in the brain. It's all going on in the brain in a certain piece of
neuronal architecture. And this runs counter to a whole tradition we have of discussing these things
that say consciousness can't have a spatial location, but we know in fact that it does.
And with current imaging techniques, we're actually able to discover where certain conscious
processes go on. So does that mean like step three then says that consciousness is a function of the
higher brain systems, that these brain systems that you can see light up in these images?
Exactly. Exactly. That is, you see, if you go through these steps, it's real,
it's caused by brain processes. Then what you're going to find is that the brain processes that
cause specific conscious states are likely to be architecturally specific to certain parts of the
brain. Okay. So what's it do? It functions causally. I have a thought in my brain and guess
what? It produces words coming out of my mouth. I have these intentions to answer Robert's questions
and this actually causes behavior. So there isn't any question if we just look at the facts now and
forget about the philosophical tradition that consciousness functions causally in producing
behavior. Think of it as an ordinary biological process that happens to go on in the brain
in the way that digestion happens to go on in the stomach and the rest of the digestive tract.
Here's the problem I have with the consciousness digestion analogy. Consciousness is not like
digestion. Maybe the perception of vision is like the digestion. Maybe the hormonal systems
are like digestion. A lot of things are like digestion, not consciousness.
Yeah. Well, all analogies break down somewhere and there is a disanalogy between consciousness
and digestion and that is in an ordinary sense, once we get a complete knowledge of the causal
structure of digestion, we do an ontological reduction. We say digestion is nothing but
all of these processes, but you can't do that with consciousness because consciousness has this
subjective or first person ontology. Its mode of existence is to exist only when it's consciously
experienced by a human or animal subject and you can't get rid of that. So typically,
a causal reduction leads to an ontological reduction. In the case of consciousness,
you get a causal reduction, but no ontological reduction. Consciousness is special because it's
the only thing we know in the universe that has this subjective or first person ontology,
but that's just how nature turned out. My slogan is always, don't say anything that's obviously
false. It's obviously false to say that consciousness doesn't exist. It's obviously
false to say there's nothing there but third person objective properties. It is essentially
qualitative and subjective, but it's false to say therefore it's not part of the physical world. Of
course it's part of the physical biological universe, but it is special. It has this unique
feature of ontological subjectivity and that's how nature turned out. We can't pretend that
didn't happen. That's just the way the world works. To John, consciousness is real and
irreducible, caused by brain processes, realized in the brain, and functions causally.
But if John is right, I'm troubled. Because consciousness would then be the only thing in
the universe that is causally reduced to brain function, but not ontologically reduced.
Mind as caused entirely by brain, but not existing as brain? Can cause and existence be so radically
different? What's going on here? I need something more. David Chalmers, an Australian philosopher of
mind, has something more. For decades, there had been a progressive demystification of consciousness.
Then, along came Dave. Dave, how do you see the brain becoming conscious?
I think we need to distinguish between the project of finding neural correlates
of consciousness and neural explanations of consciousness. So right now, the science is
developing really very fast in exciting ways, narrowing down the neural correlates. We find
out that certain cells in your inferior temporal cortex are firing when you're conscious of certain
images visually, and we might eventually be able to find a massive co-variation between the two.
But nothing there yet is providing anything like an explanation of why we're conscious.
Well, we're beginning to see some very sophisticated things. We see cells that react if my hand is this
way, and don't react if it's this way. Mirror neurons that will look like I'm doing something
when I watch somebody else doing something. It seems irrational to have so detailed correlation
and one not being the cause of the other. Maybe one is the cause of the other. Maybe
the brain is the cause of consciousness, but cause and effect are different things. My hand
hits my other hand. One thing caused the other thing. They're two different things. If my brain
causes my consciousness, then consciousness is something distinct from the brain. The materialist
view, the reductionist view, is that all there is to consciousness is the brain. That requires
something much stronger than correlation. That requires identification, saying there's just one
thing here, not two. But this study of correlations, it's always correlation between two different,
separately observed things. We observe the brain, and we observe our state of consciousness. So
everything we've seen so far is completely consistent with there being two different
things here. And we haven't yet got anything like the kind of explanation that would unify
them into one phenomenon. Maybe consciousness emerged as some add-on phenomena at some point
that got selected for in the process. And to say why it happened is the same thing to ask is,
why aren't the planetary cycles perfectly round? Well, there are some things in science
that we don't have to explain. Those are the fundamental laws. And at a certain point,
explanation stops. Those things have to be taken as a brute. If that's what we have to do for
consciousness, if we have to take this fact that brain processes and consciousness go together as
a brute fact in the same way, then all I say is we should take the same attitude towards it
as we take in physics. We should acknowledge that as a fundamental law, not to be further
explained. So I think that what we get out of all these experiments is a better and better
understanding of the laws that connect consciousness with the underlying processes in the physical
brain. But nothing about this shows that that's all that consciousness is. Why should any of that
stuff be accompanied by subjective experience? You can know about all that without knowing what
it's like to see red, what it's like to fall in love. That's a principled gap. It's not just a
matter of how much neuroscience we know now. Now, could there be an utterly amazing scientific or
philosophical revolution that so far none of us can yet contemplate? Sure, I can't rule it out,
but we've just got to do the best we can for now. To Dave, no matter how much neuroscience we learn,
we will never explain consciousness.
No matter how good the correlations of brain to mind, they could never literally be mind.
There is something extra in consciousness which can never be explained by anything physical,
chemical, or biological. Dave gives me what I need, but what I need may be a friend that's false.
Most scientists explain mental activity in the purely physical terms of brain function,
while others contend that consciousness must be more, and they suspect unknown,
radically new kinds of laws. Still others wonder anew if mind has existence beyond the brain
and is a wholly different kind of stuff. Can neuroscience explain consciousness,
reducing mind to brain? Or does mind maintain an independent existence, an irreducible element
of reality? Of only this I am really sure. The choice is stark. Mind is only brain versus
mind is more than brain. And the choice leads us closer to truth.
