What Things Really Exist? | Episode 304 | Closer To Truth

Truth exists
11 followers
My night thoughts are about the simplest of questions.
What things really exist?
Why does this bother me?
Why does this obsess philosophers?
Because when you think deeply about the things of existence,
you see everything anew.
We accept the physical world of particles and forces,
but what about the mental world of thoughts and ideas?
The platonic world of numbers and logic?
The spirit world of God or gods?
I find myself longing for more than one world,
something beyond the physical.
But what I want and what really exists has no connection.
I must not fool myself with foolish hope.
I'm Robert Lawrence Kuhn, and Closer to Truth is my journey.
To Sir Roger Penrose, a distinguished mathematician,
the question, what things really exist, is profound.
He has strong views about the number of worlds
or the kinds of existences which compose reality.
We meet at Oxford University.
It's very important in understanding the physical world
that our way of describing the physical world,
certainly at its most precise, has to do with mathematics.
And that mathematics has to have been there
since the beginning of time.
It doesn't have any location in space.
It doesn't have any location in time.
Some people would take it not to have any existence at all,
but it's hard to talk about science, really,
without giving mathematics some kind of reality
because that's how you describe your theories
in terms of mathematical structures.
It has also this relation to mentality
because we certainly have access to mathematical truths.
But I think it's useful to think of the world
as not being a creation of our minds,
because if we do, then how could it have been there
before we were around?
How can the mathematics have been the creation of minds
and still have been there controlling the universe?
So I think it's very valuable to think
of this platonic mathematical world
as having its own existence.
So let's allow that and say that there are
three different kinds of existence,
the normal physical existence, the mental existence,
and the mathematical world, which seems to be out there
in some sense conjuring itself into existence.
And then there's the relationship
between these three worlds,
which I regard as very mysterious.
I sometimes refer to this as three worlds
and three mysteries.
And mystery number one is how is it
that the physical world does, in fact, accord mathematics,
not just any old mathematics,
but very sophisticated, subtle mathematics,
to such a fantastic degree of precision?
Mystery number two is how is it
that when you have physical structures of the right kind,
and here I'm referring very specifically
to human, living human, wakeful, healthy brains,
probably many other animals, I would say,
also have this quality of mentality.
And somehow it's evoked when the structures
have the right character, whatever that is.
So there is, mentality seems to have this deep relation
to certain kinds of physical structures.
And mystery number three has to do with
our access to the world of mathematics.
It's something that you certainly can't describe
in terms of purely computational activity.
There's something outside that involves
in our appreciation of mathematics.
Even just knowing what the natural numbers,
zero, one, two, three, four, I could say that, you see.
And you can explain to a child,
and you can have Sesame Street things with different things,
and they get the idea.
They know what they're talking about.
They know what numbers are.
Yet how do you know what they are
if you can't describe in a finite set of rules
what these numbers are?
There's another feature about this,
which is that in each case,
it's only a small part of one world,
which encompasses, seemingly,
the entirety of the next world.
If you look at any mathematical journal,
it's full of things
of absolutely no relevance to physical activity.
So it's a small part of the mathematical world
which seems to encompass
the behavior of the physical world.
And it's a very small part of the physical world
which seems to evoke mentality.
And it's only a small part of our mental activities
which relate to mathematics.
Now, the typical scientific response to that would say,
okay, the mental world is just an expression
of the physical brain,
and so it's an artificial phenomena.
And mathematics is very nice,
but it's something that human beings have invented
to sort of describe the physical world.
To a mathematician, you might take
that the mathematical world somehow is the one,
because somehow it has to be there, you see.
It sort of creates itself out of nothing.
Or you might say, well, no, no, it's mentality.
That's where all our knowledge comes.
That's everything ultimately has to do
with our consciousness.
And everything else is then explained in terms of it.
When you look at these three worlds,
is it just as a description of reality,
or is there some sense of real, independent existence?
I don't necessarily regard this as a sort of ultimate picture.
I think that in some sense,
there are different aspects of reality,
and that the true reality, in some sense,
encompasses the whole thing.
To Roger, three kinds of worlds exist.
Physical, mental, and mathematical, or platonic.
A small part of each world generates the other.
Three worlds, three mysteries.
I find myself drawn into Roger's worlds,
seeing new realities.
But realities, or metaphors?
Are Roger's mental and mathematical worlds really real,
or more a manner of speaking?
This is the stuff of metaphysics.
Peter von Inbragen is a leading metaphysician,
a philosopher who seeks deeper realities of existence.
We meet in the philosophy department at Notre Dame.
Peter, in trying to get to the reality beneath the appearances,
the question that can be asked is,
what is there, or is this even a legitimate question
to ask what things are real?
Plato, you know, thought that the things that we see around us,
the things that people would normally say exist,
hardly exist at all.
What really exists are things that,
well, what exists more firmly than this chair
would be the kinds of things that mathematicians investigate.
Geometers working on triangles and spheres,
and geometrical figures and constructions generally.
Something that the physical world that we're in,
these barely real things around us merely imitate.
Some philosophers say we're completely right.
At least everything we believe about what there is is right.
All those things that are dreamt of in our philosophy.
Some say we're completely wrong.
Some say that time and space aren't real.
Some say that matter isn't real.
How can we take this mass of things that may be real
or not real or exist or don't exist
and give it sort of a taxonomy to organize it into categories?
I would say that there are attributes or qualities
or properties of things in addition to the things themselves.
After all, we say that there are when we say such things
is that spiders and insects have many properties in common.
That's to say that there are properties
that belong both to spiders and to insects.
Having an exoskeleton, for example.
It seems to me that if you analyze what we say,
it's hard to make sense of what we say being true
without the supposition that it commits us
to the existence of these abstractions.
And does that mean these abstractions
have some real existence that are eternal?
Imagine an omnipotent God.
You can mention any set of consistent properties to him
and ask him to create something
that brings those properties together in one thing.
But where do the properties come from?
I think the properties are just there.
Something that even God just has to deal with.
This is the set of properties that there are,
which is not to say that they're the set of properties
that anything has.
The properties, you might think of as ways things could be
or possibilities for the way objects are.
Those possibilities have to be there.
So it doesn't trouble you that God is overwhelmed
with all these abstract objects that he finds himself with
in their mutual eternal state.
I don't see why there shouldn't be a mind that was capable
of offering complete and equal consideration
to all those objects at once.
To Peter, things that exist can be categorized
as either concrete objects or abstract objects.
And concrete objects can be further categorized
as either material, like us, or immaterial, like God,
if there is such a thing.
My head is floating.
I need someone to plant my feet back on the ground.
John Searle is my man.
No abstract or immaterial objects for him.
A tough-minded philosopher at Berkeley,
John is a realist who takes on all who aren't.
We meet at his home near the campus.
John, you believe there's one world,
the world that we see, and that's kind of it.
Other people say there's a spirit world, two worlds.
Some others say that there might even be three,
with a platonic world of numbers and universals,
and some people have four.
You'd have a physical, a mental, a spiritual, a platonic.
I mean, these seem to multiply.
Well, I think it's a sign of intellectual laziness
if you allow your realities to multiply.
Just describe the facts, and then what you'll find
is that the facts of the empirical reality,
the things you can see and find out about in the sciences,
they form a unity.
There's a single universe that we live in.
Now, there are two reasons why people want to reject that.
On one hand, they want to say,
well, no, there's a mental reality
that's in addition to that, and I think that's a mistake.
It's not necessary to postulate a different realm
in order to account for the existence of consciousness
and intentionality as biological phenomena.
However, another reason that they make this mistake
is they see, well, clearly there are mathematical entities,
and mathematical entities don't occupy space,
they don't function causally,
so it looks like they must be in a different realm.
And I think that's a confusion as well.
If there are two horses in the field,
well, how many things are there in the field?
Is there just this horse and that horse,
or is also the property of horseness?
And is there then the property of twoness?
And there, I think, now we have to do
a little bit of philosophy of language.
The fact that makes it the case
that there are two horses in the field
is the same fact as would make it the case
that the property of horseness is twice instantiated,
or that the property twoness is instantiated
by one set to set of horses.
Those are just three different ways of saying the same thing.
There isn't any additional fact which is postulated
by talking about numbers or properties.
It's just a manner of speaking.
All that makes wonderful sense and well thought out,
but that whole process of thinking,
if there were never anything,
if there was no universe, no laws, no nothing,
zero, that still would have been true.
The temptation always in philosophy
is to suppose that there must be some deep mystery.
How can there be an infinite sequence of natural numbers
stretching out forever and ever?
How can they be timeless?
And the way to get out of all these mysteries
is to bring it down to real life cases.
Numbers are to count with.
So if you can count, then you've already got numbers.
And if you've got numbers, then you can imagine a world
in which no one was able to account,
but you still want to be able to say,
well, all the same, there are still these numbers.
But the mistake is to think that there's some deep,
profound truth about a mysterious realm
that you've postulated.
What you've done is describe a feature of our language.
Do numbers exist?
Of course, but that's a manner of speaking.
It doesn't mean that in the field,
there are two horses plus the number two.
Why am I so bothered by this?
I hear what you're saying, I understand what you're saying,
but I still think eliminate everything
and numbers still exist.
I can't get out of that.
Well, but then that's a mark of the philosopher.
The mark of the philosopher is to be obsessed by questions
that don't seem to have any practical interest
and which most people don't worry about at all.
I'm trying to get you to see that we have a natural urge
to ask this question in this way,
but the way to solve the question
is not to give a direct answer.
Yes, numbers are way out there, you just can't see them.
Or no, numbers don't exist at all.
Both of those are wrong.
Both of those make the same mistake.
The way out of it is to see how we actually work
with the numerical vocabulary
and how the way we operate with that vocabulary
naturally generates an infinite sequence of natural numbers
which are not themselves spatially located
and they don't have any weight.
So if we take some of these worlds that are postulated,
we have our physical world, which we all subscribe to,
mental world, we eliminate
because we don't need it to have consciousness,
spiritual world, if you believe in some God or something,
you need, but you don't need it,
and the platonic world of universals and numbers
is in a sense a matter of speaking from our language.
Exactly, it's an artifact of our discourse.
It's not a special metaphysical realm.
So you're just comfortable living
with our one little world now.
Well, it's the only one I've got.
It's a poor thing, but it's my own.
John grounds his philosophy on facts.
And as he sees the facts, they all come from one world,
the physical world, the real world of science,
and there is no other.
My head, trained in science and logic,
tells me John's right.
My hope, rooted in sense and intuition, impels me beyond.
Suppose there were a God.
Still, what about abstract objects?
They would seem to exist with or without God.
William Lane Craig is a Christian philosopher
who believes in God,
and he is bothered by abstract objects.
Bill, we always hear that God is the creator.
Okay, sounds simple.
But what is the creation?
What is a world?
Well, I think the doctrine of creation means
that God is the source of all reality outside himself,
that apart from God,
everything else has been brought into being by God.
Now, what is everything else?
Well, it would include all reality,
whatever realms of reality you might think it exists.
It would be all physical, concrete objects.
It would be time and space themselves.
It would be any realms of spiritual reality
that you might believe exists,
such as angels and other spiritual beings.
And it would include any sort of abstract objects,
if you think that those sorts of things exist.
Like mathematics, 2 plus 2 equals 4.
Yes, like sets and numbers and propositions and so forth.
How about things like causation or logic,
operations among ideas?
I would see things like logic
as grounded in the very mind of God himself.
So, everything outside of God himself,
God is responsible for.
And this is a vast number of things,
anything that we can conceive of
and anything we can't conceive of.
Well, anything that exists.
I mean, there are, in a sense, fictional entities.
For example, Sherlock Holmes.
I don't think Sherlock Holmes exists.
So, God doesn't bring Sherlock Holmes into being
unless you think that Sherlock Holmes
is some sort of abstract object, as some philosophers do.
So, everything that exists owes its being to God.
And I would say was brought into being by God
at a specific time,
which implies that the creation or the world
or reality outside of God has not always existed.
I think that most people don't understand
that the idea of creation
is inherently bound up with temporal considerations.
These things are not just dependent upon God
for their being, but they were brought into being by God.
Since Bill believes that God created everything
that exists out of nothing,
this must literally be everything,
which includes abstract objects.
But how?
Somehow, Bill believes,
abstract objects must be grounded in the mind of God.
Any other ideas out there?
To John Leslie, a Canadian philosopher,
what really exists is astonishing.
He starts with consciousness, which seems normal enough.
But then where does he take it?
For example, you could be a believer in God
who thought that the world would not have been created at all
had it not been for consciousness.
You can even defend the theory
that nothing could actually be real
unless there was consciousness involved.
It could be that, for example,
the entire structure of the world
is a structure thought by an infinite mind.
Or it could simply be that you could defend the view
that even at the level of very simple systems like atoms,
there is a very obscure sort of consciousness.
If you were a pantheist,
you could think that absolutely everything exists
inside a divine mind,
that the structure of the physical world
is the structure of the thoughts in a divine mind.
I myself can't think that the universe would have any value at all,
either positive or negative,
if consciousness were absent from it.
I believe also that if you want to understand
why the universe exists,
you ought to take seriously Plato's notion that it exists
because it's better that it exists than not.
That's to say, it's something which is a worthwhile part
of an infinitely rich situation,
which is the supreme good.
And that supreme good would engender consciousness in some way?
The supreme good would itself be the existence of something
which was infinitely wide-ranging in its consciousness,
which would know among other things the structure of our world
because our world is something which is worth knowing about.
And this puts me, you might think, in the same sort of camp
as a lot of people who think God is a divine person
who then creates all sorts of other things.
I myself go for the view
that there exists an infinite number of divine minds,
each of which knows everything worth knowing,
because in this way we have a situation
which is the best possible situation
and is precisely what you'd expect a force
of creative ethical requirement to create.
Some people think of God as a divine mind
which carries in itself the structure of our universe,
that what physicists investigate is structure always,
and they have nothing to say as to whether the structure
is the structure of thoughts in the divine mind.
I take that theory very seriously.
You could call the whole infinite collection God,
or you could use the word God just for the God
in the infinite mind in which you exist,
or you could say that the word God shouldn't be used here at all.
Infinite divine minds, each knowing everything worth knowing,
all existing because it is good to exist.
John's vision is the grandest of all,
which of course does not make it true.
Here's my landscape of what might really exist.
Six kinds of worlds.
World one, the known physical,
extended with better theories.
World two, the unknown physical,
expanded beyond our wildest imagination.
World three, the mental,
where consciousness is fundamental,
the building block of reality.
World four, the platonic,
filled with forms and numbers and logic,
existing forever, even if nothing else ever had.
World five, the non-physical,
populated by non-physical beings,
be they angels and demons, souls and spirits.
World six, the spiritual,
an ultimate God-plane existence.
No world has unanimous support.
Each world has passionate prophets.
What do I think?
What really exists is more than world one.
Something beyond the known physical is real.
That's the best I've got.
For now, that's Closer to Truth.
For complete interviews and for further information,
please visit closertotruth.com.
