Ancient Therapy for Modern Problems: Stoic Philosophy Explained

Ancient Explained - History Clearly Understood.
17 followers
Once upon a time, I went through a very nasty breakup and my mental health really suffered.
I was in a bad place until I went to see a therapist who knew a lot about Stoic philosophy.
Stoicism is an ancient philosophy and it's having a bit of a moment. The Daily Stoic has over 2
million followers on Instagram, there's an international Stoic convention called Stoicon
and a New York Times bestselling book about Stoicism called Discipline is Destiny.
Great title for a club night. YouTube tells me what my subscribers have been searching for
on the internet and as a group your number one most searched term is Stoicism. Number three
was Marcus Aurelius, the Stoic philosopher who wrote The Meditations. This philosophy is a
movement and I have a philosophy degree so let's do it. In this video I'm going to tell you what
Stoicism is, how it helped me, and where it might be leading you astray. So please make yourself
comfortable, lie down on the couch, and tell me about your moment.
English.
Let us begin with Marcus Aurelius since he's probably a lot of people's intro to Stoicism.
Marcus was an ancient Roman. He was born in 121 AD and he was Emperor of Rome from 161 until his
death in 180. By all accounts he was a pretty decent guy. The bar for Roman Emperors was low
as long as you don't murder your mum and shag your sister you can't go far wrong and he's one of
our major sources for Stoic philosophy. Marcus did not invent Stoicism. It actually comes from
ancient Greek philosophers like Zeno of Kittian, Aristo of Chios, Cleanthes of Assos, and other
minor characters from House of the Dragon. But we don't have anything written by the OGs, original
Greeks. One of the only things we know about Cleanthes of Assos is that he was really jacked.
Somebody wrote that down and it survived but not a lot else. Everything we know about Stoicism
comes filtered through the Romans and they may not be reliable. For example one of our other
sources is the Roman politician Cicero and he tells us a lot about Stoicism but he was arguing
against it so he might not be portraying it accurately. Cicero also wrote his philosophy
as dialogue between characters which is just really pretentious. I mean who the heck does that?
Imagine if 2000 years from now the work of every philosopher ever had been lost and future
scholars had to reconstruct their ideas based solely on this show. That's kind of analogous
to the situation we're in here. They'd be going, well is she portraying them accurately? Why is she
dressed like that? Where's the guy who used to present it? Was that her brother? A lack of
reliable sources is one of the drawbacks to doing ancient philosophy but on the other hand I really
love it because this stuff was written almost 2000 years ago in another country in another
language by people who lived unimaginably different lives but it's still capable of
making me go, oh yeah I get what you mean. It genuinely gives me a really beautiful sense of
the oneness of humanity. It's like getting a high five across time. I love it. The Meditations isn't
really a philosophy book per se. It doesn't build to a conclusion or argue for a specific point.
It's just a collection of notes that Marcus wrote to himself that he probably didn't expect anyone
else to ever read. That's because in the ancient world philosophy wasn't a university course the
way we might think of it now. It was more like self-help. It was supposed to improve your life.
Philosophy was not merely a subject to write or argue about but one that was expected to provide
a design for living. A set of rules to live one's life by. This was a need not met by ancient
religion which privileged ritual over doctrine and provided little in the way of moral and ethical
guidelines nor did anyone expect it to. That was what philosophy was for. So I'm going to skim
through Marcus here. I'm going to pull out some key stoic concepts and teach them to you and of
course I have compiled them into an internet friendly numbered list. Number one, the dichotomy
of control. This one's pretty simple. Control the things you can control. Don't worry about the
things that you can't. If you're an addict or you know an addict you might recognise this idea from
the serenity prayer popularised by Alcoholics Anonymous. God grant me the serenity to accept
the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can and the wisdom to know the
difference. The key for Stoics is there's only one thing you can really control and that is
your judgments about the world. For example Marcus says imagine somebody insults you and you get
really angry. Take a step back. Have you really been hurt by what they said? No.
What's happened is they've insulted you and you've made a judgment something like
and you've reacted to that not the insult itself. You can change that judgment if you want to
and you can let that anger go. If you are pained by any external thing it is not the thing that
disturbs you but your own judgment about it and it is in your power to wipe out this judgment
now. That's not an easy thing to do which is why you have to work at it. This is something that
other Roman Stoics like Seneca and Epictetus said too. You've got to train yourself to take that
step back and examine your feelings every time you experience a strong emotion. It's worth
mentioning in the 21st century we are very used to thinking that feelings and judgments
are separate things. You've got your feelings, those are your moods, emotions, desires, your
vibes. They're all over here in a pink heart shape. Those are for girls and they are gay because
over here inside a blue brain shape that's where you've got your facts, judgments, reasoning,
beliefs, Jordan Peterson, big mind activity. That is for men and it is not gay. Ancient Stoics didn't
think like that. For them feelings have a judgment inside like the stone inside a peach.
In technical philosophy language we say that emotions have cognitive content and Stoics said
you have to make sure the judgments inside your feelings are true. For example, a while ago I had
a big audition for a TV series and I was really anxious so I took Marcus's advice and had a step
back and realized that inside my anxiety was a judgment and that isn't true. If I don't get this
part there'll be other auditions. I can let that judgment go and immediately I felt less anxious
which is great but from the Stoic point of view the more important thing is that I brought my
judgments into line with reality. I'm facing things as they are not as I imagine them to be
and so I have become more rational. Concept number two. Virtue is the only good. For Stoics being
rational, having accurate judgments about the world is the only thing you need to have a good life.
So follow this example with me. Imagine my agent calls me up tomorrow and says you got the part
and I think fantastic I'm so great and I get really arrogant. I'm reacting to that judgment
but it's not true. So that good news has been turned into a bad thing. For Stoics if I don't
have accurate judgments about the world it doesn't matter if I get good news or fame or wealth or
opportunity they won't do me any good. The only thing that really matters is virtue which is to
say having correct judgments about the world. The happiness of your life depends upon the quality
of your thoughts. Therefore guard accordingly and take care that you entertain no notions
unsuitable to virtue and reasonable nature. This idea overlaps with concept number three.
Living in accordance with nature. There's two sides to this. The first is what we just talked
about making sure that your judgments align with reality. The second is living in accordance with
human nature. The Stoics said that humans are social creatures. It's in our nature to live in
communities and be good to each other. They regarded mankind as one brotherhood in which
every man possesses a spark of the divine. Each one of us is a part of this universe from which
it is a natural consequence that we should prefer the common advantage to our own. For just as the
laws set the safety of all above the safety of individuals so a good wise and law abiding man
conscious of his duty to the state studies the advantage of all more than that of himself
or of any single individual. The fourth and final Stoic concept I want to pull out here is
the sage. The sage is a Stoic master. Sometimes they mean a literal person like Socrates and
say he's a sage. Sometimes it's more of an ideal to strive for. The sage lives perfectly in
accordance with nature. They have no false judgments about anything. They are never overwhelmed
by strong emotions because they've trained themselves to step back every single time.
Even when times are tough. Even if their agent calls and says you didn't get the part.
The sage doesn't multiply their suffering by adding false judgments like it's over for me.
Instead they face reality as it is and so they are able to cope with adversity. So those are
the major concepts in Stoic philosophy. If you skim through Marcus Aurelius or you watch videos
like these on YouTube those are the notes that you're going to hit and that is all kushti.
But this is Philosophy Tube. I want you to watch this video and then go and sign up to my Patreon
so that I can make more of them and I know that you're not going to do that unless I earn it.
You don't sign up to my Patreon because you want to hear me summarise Wikipedia.
You sign up to my Patreon because I go the extra mile in extra style.
Stoicism is supposed to be a guide for living a better life which prompts the obvious question
does it actually work? But before we get into that I want to talk about why the original
Stoics believed this stuff. This is the extra material. The deep lore that podcasts and
articles don't usually talk about. Stoic physics. The people of the ancient world didn't have
particle accelerators and radio telescopes and all the things that we have to make sense of
the universe but they were curious and clever. They had some theories about what's going on here
and the Stoics were no exception. The Stoics said there's two kinds of things in the universe.
There's matter which is passive and then there's this other active principle called the Logos.
And the Logos is kind of like the force. It's an energy field found in all living things. It
surrounds us, penetrates us, binds the galaxy together. It's the rational principle which orders
the universe. The Logos is made of a special physical substance called
Pneuma. The Greek word for breath. Pneuma is a combination of air and fire. Two of the four
fundamental elements and it's blended through everything. Objects have it. An axe has Pneuma
that gives it the power to cut. Plants have Pneuma that makes them grow and reproduce.
Animals too. Pneuma gives them movement and perception. And we have Pneuma in us. It makes
your blood warm because it's fire. It makes your heart beat. It lets you think and be rational.
It's what your soul is made of. And when you die, the Pneuma leaves you. You get cold. You can't
move or think anymore. The Pneuma in you is dispersed back into the cosmos. Because the
Pneuma is blended through the universe the same way it is in us, the universe itself is alive.
And not only is it alive, the Stoics believed the universe is intelligent and it's happy.
Which I think is just a really sweet idea. The universe is thriving. She's smiling. She's happy
to see you. She's moisturised. She's four and a half billion years old but she still looks great.
If you read Stoic philosophy, including Marcus Aurelius, you'll notice that they use a lot of
very big words interchangeably like God, fate, the world, the universe, Zeus, the gods, the cosmos.
The reason they do that is because in Stoic physics those are all the same thing. And if I
could briefly turn this show into Bible studies tube, any Christians in the audience might be
thinking, this sounds awfully familiar. The Gospel according to John opens with the phrase,
In the beginning was the word, and the word was God, and the word was with God.
In the original ancient Greek that's,
Logos is the Greek for word. John is saying that this Stoic idea,
the force that orders the universe, is the same thing as the Christian God.
If you translate that phrase into Latin, you get,
which you can find carved on statues and churches around the world, and written above the gate of
the school where I studied theology. By the way, if anyone in the audience is upset at my
ancient language pronunciation, then I would simply remind you that,
Now, all of that physics is bollocks. There is no such thing as Pneuma, the universe is getting
less ordered over time, there are many more elements than four, your blood is warm because
of chemical reactions in your body, and your heart beats because of electrical activity in
your sinoatrial node. But the point is twofold. Firstly, Stoic philosophy was based on the latest
science of the day. The science was wrong, but they weren't mystics or fools, the people of the
ancient world were intelligent, just as much as me and you. High five! The second point is that
Stoic physics informs Stoic ethics. When they said that your judgements need to align with reality,
they mean the things that happen to you literally impact your soul, and you need to literally move
your soul in such a way that it aligns with the world. When Marcus Aurelius said there is a share
of the divine in all of us, he means it literally. These days a lot of people would probably
interpret that stuff as metaphor. I would hazard a guess that people getting into Stoicism now
probably aren't engaging with the deep physics. They're using it as self-help, because Stoicism
is supposed to make your life better. Which brings us back to the obvious question, does it?
Being Stoic is sometimes associated with toxic emotional repression. Men having no feelings,
never asking for help. Becoming the perfect warrior, cold and ruthless, living by your
strength alone, uninhibited by foolish emotions. It's Dragon Ball Z. Masculinity is a subject about
which I know more than I should, but less than some of you might think. I studied it for a number
of years but I never quite had the natural talent. And I want to reach out to young men,
help de-radicalise them, offer a positive role model. We're doing LeftTube again, remember that
from like five years ago? Well we're gonna bring it back. Somebody call Hbomberguy. What's he up
What have I become?
This Stoicism for Bros, Broicism if you will, is based on a misunderstanding of what Stoics
actually said. You can't get rid of all your feelings. For example, when I go too hard on a
night out I often get depressed the next day. You can't philosophise your way out of a hangover.
There are some emotions which are, for want of a better word, physiological, and a sage would still
have those. It's not about having no feelings, it's about having feelings that align with reality.
So the wise sage might say, I feel really depressed today, but I know that's just
because I had a big night on Molly down at the Darsen Superstore. This too shall pass.
Still, the Stoics described the sage as somebody who is never overwhelmed by strong emotions.
Epictetus advised his followers to become so detached that they could treat the death of a
child like the breaking of a cup. And you might think, oh that doesn't sound like a particularly
nice way to live. We can call this the romantic objection. Isn't it good sometimes to get carried
away by passion when the blood runs hot and the champagne is cold and you're alone in a hotel
room with somebody who you probably shouldn't kiss but you both feel like you just kind of have to?
The romantic objection is that overwhelming passion is needed for a good life and if you
follow Stoicism you'd be missing out on that. The Stoic response here is to pretty much bite the
bullet and just say no. A good human life does not include moments of overwhelming passion because if
they're based on incorrect perceptions they will lead you into trouble. You might feel as if
but you won't literally explode. You'll be sad but you can probably live with that.
When you have virtuous emotions there's no overwhelming romance but there's also no
overwhelming grief or anxiety. Virtuous emotions are aligned with the real world which is the best
and indeed only place that human beings can live. If you're very clever you'll already have noticed
that there's a lot of overlap between Stoicism and CBT. That's cognitive behavioral therapy
not the other kind of CBT. CBT is a talk therapy invented in the 20th century inspired by Stoicism.
Patients are encouraged to identify underlying beliefs which might be affecting them and
substitute those beliefs for something else. So just like Stoicism it focuses on the cognitive
element of emotion. CBT is what I was sent for when I went through that breakup. I was very
depressed and my therapist encouraged me to find the belief underneath that depression.
Eventually we wrote it down and I thought that isn't true so what if we substitute that
for something else?
At one point I asked her but why do I feel this way and she said well does it really matter?
We could spend years psychoanalyzing your dreams or your childhood and eventually we'll come up
with something like oh your mother didn't breastfeed you enough as a child or whatever
but you're still gonna be left with the same question which brought you to therapy in the
first place namely what are you gonna do now? Are you gonna accept the real world
or not? And this leads us to a criticism of both CBT and Stoicism. Is there a danger
that we're encouraging people to accept things that they really shouldn't have to?
Hi I'm Kelly Slaughter the founder and CEO of Sciope. I'm an entrepreneur but I'm also a mom
and I know that juggling all those responsibilities can cause stress. Stress is the number one cause
of employee sick leave in America. So what if there is a way to hack your stress response?
Reducing employee stress whilst keeping them in work. Introducing Sciope a solution for your
business whether you're a multinational conglomerate or a mom-and-pop store.
Our story began when I was running my previous company Express. We were making facial recognition
software for law enforcement and a number of employees came to see me in my office and said
they didn't agree with the work we were doing. They wanted to change their conditions. They even
threatened me with unionization. And at the time I was also experiencing stress because
I was in the process of buying a third home so I was really able to sympathize. I started reading
about the scientific causes of stress and I learned that stress is caused when an individual
reacts negatively to challenges. And I thought what if there is a way to reduce employee stress
without compromising productivity? That's when I had the idea for Sciope. Sciope uses artificial
intelligence to bring the practice of cognitive behavioral therapy to your workplace. When faced
with the problem of employee stress a lot of founders use these patronizing solutions like
putting a ping-pong table in the office or letting employees pet a dog. Those solutions don't work.
Cognitive behavioral therapy is where scientific study meets ancient wisdom. A solution that works.
When your business signs up to Sciope you'll gain access to our suite of software apps including our
artificially intelligent therapist. Employees can schedule regular sessions to hack their stress
and our AI therapist offers genuine solutions. Employees can stay in work while they stress
hack. You can also set measurable goals for them to work towards and Sciope will monitor their
progress outside of sessions. Sciope is proven to minimize employee absence due to sickness
and helps create a healthier happier working environment. As a mom it's my belief that you
can't put a price on health. Sciope starts at $12,997 a month per employee so don't delay.
Use Sciope for your business today.
The British philosopher Mark Fisher said it's no surprise that people feel anxious,
angry, and stressed when capitalism works us and the planet to death just so the five guys who own
everything can make 0.3% more profit this quarter. We all pretend that feeling bad means you have
some kind of brain problem and Fisher says that's like living next to a smokestack and saying here's
five ways you can cough more quietly at work. It fundamentally misunderstands the problem.
People are angry, lonely, depressed, anxious and they're right to feel that way not because
they're broken humans but because their situation is inhumane. The solution isn't therapy, it's
politics. Not the cigar of Sigmund Freud, the cigar of Fidel Castro. Capital makes the workers
ill and then multinational pharmaceutical companies sell them drugs to make them better.
The social and political causation of distress is neatly sidestepped at the same time as discontent
is individualized and interiorized. What we originally need is a new politics of mental
health organized around the problem of public space. This is a version of what philosophers
call the passivity problem. Stoicism says you can only control your own internal judgments
but there is a world out there and it needs us. Would a sage ignore climate change for instance
or systemic racism because they can only control their own internal states? Doesn't accepting things
as they are serve the needs of the powerful? Now there is a possible response that Stoics could
make here. They could say that when it comes to climate change for instance not taking action
would be contrary to our nature as creatures who live on planet earth. So you could make a Stoic
argument for sustainability. They might also say that Marcus Aurelius was emperor of Rome for 19
years and that's not really a job that you can do if you never take action. You can be a Stoic
and still stand up to injustice. Can you though? Can you really? Because there's one section of
the population who might have something to say about that.
The ancient Stoic's attitude towards women is a subject of some debate. On the one hand there is
some relatively progressive stuff. The Roman philosopher Musonius Rufus said that marriage
is a partnership built on longing rather than just pumping out babies. He says that women should be
educated and that we should be allowed to study philosophy. Like a lot of ancient writers he also
said that men and women have the same genitals just in different arrangements. Oh Musonius you
were wiser than you knew. On the other hand all the Stoic philosophers were men. There were women
in the ancient world who were renowned for behaving Stoically but all the sources we have
were written by men, they only quote men and they're addressed to men as well. Often young men who are
seeking wives. There's even a funny bit in Musonius where a student comes to him and says Musonius
why should I get married? Wouldn't a wife get in the way of me studying philosophy? And Musonius
essentially says shut up nerd! Why don't you go and philosophize some pussy? And if we read on a
bit in Musonius a bit of a theme starts to emerge. A woman must be a good household manager and a
careful accountant of what is advantageous to the household and a director of the household staff.
I claim that these qualities are especially likely to belong to a woman who pursues philosophy.
He also says Stoicism's emphasis on resilience and self-development will help us when it comes to
nursing her children from her own breast and serving her husband with her own hands and to do
without shrinking things that many think suited to slaves. Would such a woman not be a great help
to the man who married her? An adornment to her relatives? A good example to all those who know
her. So women should be educated not because it empowers us but because it enables us to better
serve our husbands. We can be virtuous but the proper manifestation of female virtue takes place
inside the home. You too can take the tradwife movement to its logical conclusion by installing
a vomitorium. Musonius is relying on a trick here that some people still use today.
Separate spheres of excellence. Men are good at some things and women are good at other things
and there's nothing wrong with admitting that, is there? You're not one of those weirdos who
thinks that we shouldn't tell the truth about sex, are you? So no, we're not misogynists. We don't
hate women. We love women. Women are strong. Women are nurturing. We're the best at being
wives and mothers. The trick is one of those spheres is politically subordinate to the other.
The male sphere contains all the levers that control society. The female sphere is stuck
at home with the kids and no tar bene. Men decide what those spheres are. Lest I be accused of
cherry-picking, it's not just Musonius. Seneca and Epictetus said that women lack self-control.
Zeno of Kittium said that we should be held in common and wise men should try to father children
with us whenever they chose. If any wise men would like to give it a go, feel free to call me,
but in the meantime, no tar bene secundo. Zeno assumes that men choose women, not the other
way around. But so what? We all understand that nowadays you have to take the good bits from
ancient philosophy and leave the other stuff behind, like with the physics. So when it says
mankind, read in humankind. And yes, okay, but having to do that presents an extra barrier for
women who want to get into Stoicism now. The modern Stoic movement welcomes women and has
prominent women in it, but it still recruits mainly men. Author and philosopher Sharon LaBelle says
that might be because we have to do the extra work of adapting it for us. In order to belong to the
world, females must cherry-pick and adapt texts, discussions, and thought systems to include and
apply to us. A female ontological perspective is one that can easily embrace the values of
passion, emotion, and intuition. We need, I believe, to integrate these into our modern Stoicism
while being true to the spirit of Stoicism's essential worldview. Otherwise, for lack of a
better way to say it, modern Stoicism will be too unilaterally Stoic. There's another group of people
who might like to be included as well. Slaves. The ancient Greeks and Romans regularly enslaved
people and, again, the Stoic sources have a bit of a mixed view on this. On the one hand, they
believed in a brotherhood of man or community of humanity. They did reject the idea that some people
are born naturally suited for slavery, which is better than some ancient authors. Looking at you,
Aristotle! On the other hand, they never opposed slavery per se. Like Seneca says you shouldn't
beat your slaves, which, yes, true, you shouldn't beat your slaves, but I feel like it would be
better to not enslave them in the first place. Seneca also argues this in quite a strange way.
He says, well, everybody's a slave if you think about it. Some people are slaves to lust or greed
or ambition. Aren't we all slaves on the inside? And yes, that's very poetic, Seneca, but some people
are also literally slaves in the sense that you force them to work for you and you never paid them.
Seneca also said that you shouldn't force your slave to shave his beard and then dress him like
a maid and have him serve you at the dinner table and then have sex with him, which, weirdly specific
example, Seneca. I mean, like, yeah, don't do force femme maid play with your femme boy slaves, but, uh,
again, I feel like the bad bit of that is the slavery. The rest sounds great.
The passivity problem kind of comes back here in a broader sense. A feminist philosopher might say
that it's hard to develop your rational soul unless you are guaranteed some external goods,
like political liberty. Goods that can only be had in a society which rejects gendered hierarchy
and slavery. It's pretty hard to cultivate reason and virtue if you're treated like a second class
citizen. All of this stuff is meant to help people live good human lives, but if you're a slave or
a subjugated woman, you kind of can't live a good life. But once again, the most powerful stoic
response is just to go, nope. It's all well and good for Mark Fisher to talk about freedom or
feminists to talk about liberty, but those things won't do you any good if you don't have the virtue
of reason. You could have political liberty and be in mental chains because your judgments about
that liberty are false. By the same token, you could be in literal chains and be the freest person
in the world if you are a sage. And if that sounds counterintuitive, well, if it was easy,
everybody would do it. We're starting to get down here to fundamental questions about what a good
human life looks like, which is, of course, what this is all about. That's the question I had when
I first went to that therapist all those years ago. Despite my therapist telling me it wasn't
important, I did wonder where I acquired this belief. I asked myself, if I picture somebody
telling me this out loud, who do I picture? And I realised, with a bit of a shock, that the reason
the breakup had affected me so much was because the relationship I had with my therapist was
