The Eastern Roman Empire, Explained

Ancient Explained - History Clearly Understood.
17 followers
57 Video Views·Jul 28, 2025
We begin on a Monday, the 11th of May, AD 330, for on that day the great city of Constantinople
was consecrated. This was to be a new imperial capital, bustling and beautified with treasures
from across the empire, created in conscious imitation of Rome itself. Not for nothing was
New Rome one of its many names. Constantinople shifted the focus east, and after the Roman
Empire's permanent division in 395, it was very much the beating heart of the eastern lands.
In casual speech it was common to hear it called just the city. Often when someone said
I'm going to the city, there was no need to clarify that Constantinople was their destination.
And that phrase, to the city, in Greek is istinbolim, something that its later occupants
would adapt into a new name. Istinbolim would one day become Istanbul.
The Eastern Roman Empire, out of the way of the brunt of the barbarian invasions,
ruled richer provinces with more easily defensible borders. So the east survived while the west fell
away. But by the second half of the 5th century, the international situation had settled down.
Come the 6th century, however, and the Eastern Romans made a bold play to recover the western
provinces. Armies were sent to Africa, Spain, and Italy. The war for the old heartland was
particularly long, lasting two decades. Ultimately, bad luck and bad policy meant
these reconquests were a disaster for the empire. The strains of war coincided with plagues,
natural disasters, and freak climate events which undercut the economic strength of the empire.
Longer borders spread the armies thin. More often than not, the treasury was near empty.
For decades after the reconquests, emperors were forced to play whack-a-mole with the
empire's enemies, focusing on one group, only to be attacked by another. Paying enemies to go away
was a core part of imperial policy, but while sparing the armed forces, it put further strain
on the treasury. This delicate balancing act finally tipped over into disaster when the armies,
exhausted and poorly paid, mutinied and murdered the emperor in 602. Civil war swept over the
empire, as did the Persians. Their armies penetrated as far as Egypt and Anatolia.
God help the Romans. This is what it said on some coins of the early 7th century.
Maybe he did, because remarkably, they recovered enough to defeat the Persians
after decades of war. In the hour of victory, overwhelmed with elation, many foresaw a glorious
new era of Roman power. But like fighters high on adrenaline, they didn't realise quite how badly
wounded they were. So when a new enemy emerged from the deserts of Arabia, and inflicted a
series of stunning defeats on them, imperial defences crumpled with dizzying speed.
These new foes were the Muslim Arabs. They first struck out of Arabia in the 630s,
and by the 700s they had stripped the empire of two-thirds of its territory,
bottling them up in Anatolia. But if two-thirds of the empire fell,
why didn't the remaining third go the same way? Partly the answer comes from the empire's evolving
military tactics and smart use of its new geography. Head-to-head fights had rarely
gone their way, and the Arabs now enjoyed superiority in resources and manpower.
The Romans had to play defensively. The Taurus mountain range,
which all invaders of Anatolia must pass, shielded the empire's eastern flank.
But their new strategies did not involve creating a firm line of defence.
Instead of blocking an army's passage, which would necessarily involve a risky battle,
the eastern Romans relied on extreme defence in depth.
They let the enemy invade, all the while harassing their foraging parties,
straining their lines of supply, and laying ambushes when they felt they could get away with
The people of the provinces would flee, taking their cattle and valuables to secure holdfasts,
and as the invaders went deeper into the land, they found their problems of supply growing worse.
This strategy resulted in constant damage along and far inside the frontier,
turning it into a no-man's land. Yet it also prevented the Arabs from establishing bases
west of the Taurus range. Revenues had collapsed perhaps to a quarter of what
they had been before the Muslim conquests. As a result, the military had to get cheaper
and less professional, relying increasingly on militia levies who gathered for training
and campaigns at an allotted time of year. Soldiers seem also to have taken on the
responsibility for sourcing their equipment themselves, and some lands became earmarked
for the upkeep of soldiers. It has been noted that in this era,
the Eastern Roman Empire was not really much of an empire at all, in that it no longer ruled over
many subject peoples. Instead, with the exception of its dwindling Italian territories and the
fringes of Armenia, most of its people spoke Greek, and called themselves Romai. Roman citizenship
had been universal since 212, and during Late Antiquity, the Greek word for a Greek person,
Elinet, came to be associated with paganism and the worship of pagan gods, in contrast to the
god of the Christians. Gradually, as Christianity took over, Greek speakers shed their ancestral
name, and increasingly leaned into their Roman identity. The dovetailing of Roman and Christian
identities left less room for Greek ones, at least initially. Still, this would not change
the dominance of the Greek language in the East. By the 7th century, it had essentially
completely displaced Latin in law and government. Only for some ceremonies, such as after the
coronation of a new empress, would they drag out the occasional Latin phrase. In this case,
the people of the palace would crowd round the newly minted empress, and cry out,
Good, good, to show their approval. Knowledge of Latin grew weaker, though it was never lost,
mirroring the situation of Greek in the Latin-speaking West. This language barrier
caused especial problems when debating the intricacies of Christian theology,
as minor misunderstandings or differences of translation accrued to cause major grievances.
For now, this wasn't too much of a problem. In Italy, even as imperial authority atrophied,
the emperors expected obedience from their popes, and largely got it. When one pope tried to
challenge an emperor's ruling, he was arrested and exiled to Crimea. But as the empire continued
to lose ground in Italy, and theological controversies drove a wedge between Constantinople
and Rome, the popes did eventually wriggle out from under the imperial yoke. By the end of the
8th century, popes were issuing their own coins and dating documents from the start of their tenures,
like kings did. The popes also had the advantage of being far away from Constantinople.
Other high-ranking clergymen were not so lucky. Throughout their conjoined history in the Roman
Empire, the church was largely subordinate to the state. What the emperor asked for, the church
gave. When the emperor really wanted something, the church could delay and disapprove, but it
could rarely stand in his way. Imperial meddling was commonplace from the outset. Emperors could,
in essence, fire the patriarch of Constantinople, the most prestigious clergyman in the land,
by summoning a council to depose him. Technically, the emperors were limited in their choice of
patriarch to three candidates submitted by the church. In truth, they could appoint whoever
they wished. One emperor made his brother patriarch, another appointed his own son at
the ripe age of sixteen. Emperors could even alter certain aspects of religious doctrine
within limits, if they were prepared to weather the criticism,
again by summoning a council to rubber-stamp their decisions.
Iconoclasm, a doctrine which limited the worship of icons, is a good example of this. It was
introduced, then declared a heresy, then reintroduced, then declared a heresy once more.
Every shifting of the tide was brought on by the rulers. Men of God could and did complain mightily,
but they could do little else. It's important to note, however, that iconoclasm never excited
strong opinions outside of a small subset of society. The average Josephus was unaffected.
By contrast, rulers who messed with more sensitive articles of faith did so at their own risk.
When one 5th century emperor tried to roll back the Chalcedonian creed,
it instantly blew up in his face. The people of the capital,
outraged, almost immediately forced him to reverse course, and the emperor was deposed shortly after.
The emperor who first introduced iconoclasm had come to the throne in 717,
at the low point of Eastern Roman fortunes. A few months after his rise to power, the Arabs
besieged Constantinople with 80,000 men, perhaps more soldiers than the entire population of the
capital by this point. But thanks in part to the strength of its formidable walls, the city was
saved. Successive emperors then oversaw a slow recovery. They started scoring more victories
over their enemies, even while suffering their fair share of defeats too. In the middle of the
8th century, they established professional full-time units to serve as the core of the
army on campaign. However, Rome and Ravenna slipped from their grasp in 754. In their
defence, Italy was of far less strategic importance than the Balkans or Anatolia,
yet the loss of Rome would have consequences. The papacy was untethered from the empire,
under threat from its neighbours. Constantinople had ultimately been unable to protect Rome,
so the popes looked elsewhere to the Franks for protection.
And in light of its material weakness, the papacy continued to assert its spiritual dominance,
something that was to prove increasingly contentious for the Eastern Romans.
One of the papacy's characteristics was a generous interpretation of its own powers and authority,
and one such arrogation took place in 800, when the pope gave himself the right to crown Roman
emperors. In that year Charlemagne, the king of the Franks, was hailed as Imperator Romanorum
in the old capital. A momentous new precedent had been set, initiating the first of many
challenges to the Eastern Roman Empire's legitimacy. But while having western competitors
was an unwelcome and offensive development, co-rule between imperial colleagues was actually
a well-established feature of the Eastern Roman monarchy. For the most part, it was used by
emperors to establish the legitimacy of their heirs, so princes could be crowned very young
indeed. One prince was made co-emperor when he was just four months old. There was no limit to
the amount of co-emperors one could create, and at one point in the 920s there were at least five
emperors at once. It just so happened that around the 920s the run of western emperors petered
out, for there was no one strong enough to claim the title. Meanwhile, in spite of occasional
setbacks, the Romans of the East were recovering their strength. In 867 their greatest dynasty,
that of the Macedonians, took over, and they would take the empire to a new pinnacle of glory.
The biggest threat came from the Muslim Caliphate, but that began to fragment during the 9th and
10th centuries, allowing the Romans to push the frontier back. The economy grew, and prosperity
increased as raiding across Anatolia became rarer, allowing for the pay of ever more full-time
professional units. Bulgaria provided a major challenge in Europe, but its resources were
simply not on par with that of Constantinople. Yet this was no mad rush. The pace of conquest
was glacial, only gradually speeding up through the 10th century. By the year 1000, the empire
dominated its immediate surroundings in the Middle East, and was then waging a protracted war to
subjugate Bulgaria. Soon this dominant position, hard won after so many centuries of struggle,
was lost with bewildering speed. As the 11th century wore on, the pressure began to mount
again. Three new enemies arrived. From the north came the Pechenegs, nomads of the steppe,
from the west came the Normans, and from the east came the Turks. Fighting on three fronts
drained the empire's resources, or the emperors of this period were fairly lacklustre. But the
hammer blow, when it finally came, did not come from any external enemies. It came from within.
This is perhaps a good time to talk about legitimacy and succession in the Eastern
Roman Empire. The Eastern Roman monarchy differed from more traditional types,
in which your bloodline was what mattered most, on several points, with many of these differences
stemming from the fact that the Roman Empire was born out of a blurry transition
from republic to monarchy. There were no set succession laws, although if a son existed,
he usually always inherited his father's throne. Secondly, pretty much anyone could have a crack
at seizing power. The Macedonian dynasty itself was founded by a peasant.
Merit played a large role in determining an emperor's worth. Thirdly, the imperial state
had never entirely shed the notion of being a public patrimony, a shared commonwealth that
had the emperor as its supreme head, but not its owner. He had the responsibility to protect the
people's welfare, to govern well, and any failures in this department could dramatically undercut
the ruler's legitimacy. Of course, this might seem applicable to other monarchies too.
Incompetent rulers are just less respected, but the Eastern Romans gave their rulers far
shorter shrift than most. Usurpers and rebels were ten a penny in Eastern Rome.
The instability inherent in a system that punished slip-ups so harshly
meant that upheaval was common, and dynasties were often short-lived. In fact, it took seven
centuries for the Roman Empire to produce a dynasty that ran unbroken from father to son
to grandson to great-grandson over four generations. The first to do so was the House
of Heraclius in the 7th century. This has led to claims that theirs was not a dynastic state,
which might be pushing it a bit too far. The phenomenon of dynasties was often encouraged
and grew more common as time wore on. All this put together meant that an emperor's
rule was often stress-tested, to use the words of one historian. Challengers would try to snatch
the throne from incumbents if they smelled weakness. In relatively peaceful times, this
was a minor hindrance. In moments of crisis, when the emperor was thought to be weakened,
or when the imperial authorities were distracted, it could lay the empire low.
This was what happened in the wake of the Battle of Manzikert, perhaps the most famous defeat in
Eastern Roman history. In 1071, the emperor himself was captured by the Seljuk Turks,
although his forces had not actually suffered many losses. Still, the defeat spawned a chaotic
period of civil war. The emperor in question was generously released by the Turks, only to be
blinded by his own countrymen. Meanwhile, as the chaos began to spin out of control,
the Turks decided to enter Anatolia, and ambitious imperial generals carved the provinces
into statelets for themselves. It took the empire less than a decade to lose Anatolia.
Only after much struggle did the emperors barely cling onto their European lands,
facing down several invasions by Normans and Pechenegs, and Asia was now nearly entirely
lost to them. Having suffered such titanic losses, the Eastern Romans needed help to
recover their lost lands, and to this end the emperor appealed to the Pope for assistance.
He got a bit more than he bargained for. What followed was the First Crusade,
an unprecedented outpouring of religious fervor and violence that swept over the Holy Land,
helping the empire to recover western Anatolia along the way. This crusade soon had its successors,
adding a new and unpredictable dynamic to the swirl of imperial geopolitics.
Great strides were made in rebuilding the empire's strength. A trio of capable emperors,
grandfather, father and son, ruled in succession from 1081 to 1180. Yet this renewed flowering
of imperial power proved ephemeral. When the last of those three great emperors died in 1180,
the empire entered a tailspin. Revolts detached outlying provinces, and a succession of weak
emperors ruled. Then in 1203 came the greatest cataclysm of all. An army of crusaders championing
the cause of a Roman prince attacked Constantinople. Egypt was their destination,
but self-interest diverted them to the largest city in Christendom. And then their diversion
became permanent. A year later they fell out with the prince they had put on the throne,
and smashed their way into the city. Constantinople was sacked and burned.
For three days, rampaging soldiers defiled the queen of cities.
The sack of Constantinople by the crusaders sits somewhere on a graph of rising hostility
between the Eastern Romans and Catholic Europe. Religion was one aspect of this. Not only did the
Romans adhere to their own branch of Christianity, they were also much less likely to accept the
Pope's claims to religious dominance. And since the turn of the millennium,
an increasingly muscular papacy had asserted itself in the West. Under the banner of reform,
the Popes had rooted out practices they deemed unworthy of the Church.
And then they had taken on the German emperors. What's more, they had won, excommunicating one
Kaiser for his troubles, and forcing him to commit penance. By contrast, the Emperor of the Romans,
or of the Greeks, as the Popes often wrote in their letters, was something of an outlier,
standing guard over a Christianity that differed from the Pope's vision.
There was a brief flare-up in 1054, when rival prelates from both sides excommunicated each
other. But this was a relatively minor spat that became exaggerated in hindsight.
The excommunications were soon reversed, and the emperors continued to enjoy connections and
occasional alliances with the Popes in Rome. What would come to be known as the Great Schism
was not very great at all. However, 1054 was not nothing. It highlighted that there were
very real issues of faith that could break out into mutual condemnation, even if this time things
were quickly papered over. The Crusades also caused friction, as Western Europeans got to
know their Eastern co-religionists. The goal of course was cooperation, but miscommunication was
common, and conflict was too. Unlike the Crusaders, the Eastern Romans never developed an ideology of
war, and their relations with Muslims were conducted accordingly, often to the chagrin
of the Crusaders. Pragmatic truces with Muslim powers drew the ire of passing Crusaders,
and for every Crusader that went on to stay in the Holy Land, many more returned home to Europe,
spreading anti-Eastern Roman sentiments. Relations with Venice took a dramatic turn
for the worse during the second half of the twelfth century, as commercial rivalries drove
one emperor to arrest thousands of Venetians in 1176, and drove another to oversee the killing
of thousands more in 1182. The Venetian Republic went on to play a starring role in the Empire's
mutilation in 1204. But the sack of Constantinople was not a mere symptom. It in itself turbocharged
the hatred felt by and for the Westerners. Henceforth, there could be no going back.
In the wake of the sack, the Empire fractured. Successor states sprang up along the peripheries,
while the Crusaders controlled the heartlands. Decades of turmoil followed, until the Splinter
State, based in Western Anatolia, recaptured Constantinople in 1261, and by then the damage
was done. The capital was a ruin, while the Empire was severely weakened, constantly under attack by
enemies. Which now included the Popes themselves. Although the Pope initially condemned the attack,
the Papacy soon realised that this was a perfect opportunity to bring Orthodox Christianity
under its sway. So, from their seat in Rome, the Popes set about bringing the Eastern Roman
Empire to heel. Their chief aim was religious, not military, dominance. And so, although they
blessed further Crusades against them, they were really gunning for Constantinople to accept
Catholicism. In the end, the constant pressure proved to be too much for the Emperors.
For the first time, in 1274, the Emperor bowed to the supremacy of the Pope and Catholicism.
This was horrifically unpopular with almost everyone in the Empire, understandably so.
The past decades of turmoil and war, of constant attack from their supposed co-religionists,
had poisoned attitudes. The religious union was soon reversed, but the Emperors were forced to
come back to it as the Empire's situation worsened. The Turks, including a small Ottoman Emirate,
were on the march, evicting Eastern Roman garrisons from their cities across Anatolia,
and eliminating the last Imperial territories there.
Again, the Emperors were fighting on all fronts, yet they also took horrific,
cost-cutting measures. The fleet was disbanded, ceding the seas to the Empire's enemies,
and the ragtag army was frequently defeated in battle. The downward trend continued,
even as some lands in Europe were recovered. In the end, the tendency for civil strife tore
the shriveled Empire to pieces. A brutal civil war in the 1340s reduced it to just Thrace
and other outlying regions. The Empire was now finally irreversibly doomed.
It was just a question of when it would fall. The strength of Constantinople's defences,
combined with large doses of luck, allowed it to survive for a remarkably long time in
its diminished state. Finally, the Ottoman Turks captured Constantinople on the 29th of May,
AD 1453. I'd like to take a moment to thank all of my Patreon supporters and YouTube members.
It's really your support that makes the channel possible. In particular,
I'd like to thank my one Augustus-tier patron, Average at Best, my Caesar-tier patron,
Mule Cherkary, and my two console-tier YouTube members,
The Gaming Scrolls, and Dan Smith. Thank you all very much, and have a nice day.
