Ludwig Mies van der Rohe panel interview (2001)

Ancient Explained - History Clearly Understood.
17 followers
44 Video Views·Apr 13, 2026
A look into the work of famed architect Ludwig Mies van der Rohe, with The New Yorker architecture critic Phillip Johnson and the organizer and co-organizer of the “Mies in America” and “Mies in Berlin” exhibitions in New York, Phyllis Lambert and Barry Bergdoll.
Ludwig Mies van der Rohe has been called one of the greatest architects of the 20th century.
In the 1950s and 1960s, he was arguably the most influential architect in the world.
He designed buildings that reshaped cities and changed the idea of space.
He enjoyed two successful careers, one in Germany, the other in the United States.
As a modernist, he revolutionized the American city skyline with his signature steel and glass
Now, for the first time ever, the Museum of Modern Art and the Whitney Museum of American Art
have coordinated complimentary exhibitions celebrating Mies' work.
Here is a look at the two exhibitions.
Here, Mies also constructed the now famous German pavilion.
Seldom in the history of architecture has a structure been so influential.
Interpretations of the pavilion are as varied as the reflections on its surfaces.
However, its function was to serve as a symbolic ceremonial space.
Through its expanses of plate glass, Mies allowed the ceremonies within to be clearly visible,
a concrete expression of the democratic aspirations of the young Weimar Republic.
At the opening ceremony, a government commissioner said,
we wished here to show what we can do, what we are, and how we feel today.
We do not want anything but clarity, simplicity, modesty.
Joining me now is Barry Bergdahl, co-organizer of Mies in Berlin at the Museum of Modern Art.
Phyllis Lambert, the director of the Canadian Center for Architecture.
She organized Mies in America.
The Whitney and Paul Goldberger, the architecture critic for the New Yorker magazine.
I am pleased to have them here at this time.
This is what Paul Goldberger said at the beginning of his piece about Mies.
In 1954, when Phyllis Lambert, an aspiring architect and the daughter of Samuel Bronfman,
the head of Seagram was asked by her father to decide
who should design his new headquarters on Park Avenue,
she considered every big name from Frank Lloyd Wright to Corbusier to Louis Kahn.
She chose Mies van der Rohe because she wrote,
the younger men, the second generation are talking in terms of Mies or denying him.
43 years after the bronze and glass Seagram building was finished and 32 years after his death,
they still can't stop talking about him.
Having said that, let me just talk about him a little bit more
before we talk about these two wonderful exhibits and how they became coordinated.
What is it about him?
I think that there is this internal sense of his own being
and that convinced at 19 years old, 20 years old,
one of the top philosophers in Germany to build a house by him
and that radiates throughout his buildings.
Mies was a person who was an autodidact.
He learnt to read philosophy and science and he had an extraordinary eye
and he was not interested in architecture as such.
He was interested as part of the epoch
and so it is this overwhelming sort of sense of what the society is,
what the moment is and rather than any particularity.
I mean, like Le Corbusier is working on the connection between man,
well, inches and feet and mathematical and refractory rights growing out of the ground,
Mies is worrying what is the essence of our time
and so I think it's this sense of a metaphysical sense of the world
that's within him that makes the extraordinary quality of his buildings.
Most people believe the Seagram Building is one of the great buildings of our time
and second, the best thing he ever did.
Do you believe that?
I don't think it's the best thing he ever did,
but I think it certainly is the great building.
He did because I think it's hard to pick out one building.
The most extraordinary building I think he did was the Farnsworth House
because that was such a leap from what he'd been working on at IIT,
these steel and brick and glass buildings
and he was learning how to put steel together.
He was working at the same time with his students to do clear span structures,
that is a huge space without any columns intervening
and he was able to put these together in this tremendous leap
and from there on he developed the clear span buildings
and at the same time he was building that,
he built the 860 Lakeshore Drive which was a very important building,
but it was a step in the way of what he was working on.
He was an evolutionary architect, things moved forward
and I think it's wonderful in the images that you show that you took
from the very beginning to the very end,
the Barcelona Pavilion, well the beginning of his great, great work
and the new National Gallery because that shows,
I think, that tremendous transition that he'd made.
Let me just bring Paul in on this because he wrote that
but most people seem to say you should see this almost chronologically
if you go to both of these exhibitions.
Do you agree with that or not?
It's certainly stronger if you see it chronologically
because you discover that there's a myth that Mies is perfection,
absolute, complete, rational perfection.
In fact, it was struggle and angst just like any other art,
great artist is full of struggle and angst
and both of these shows show us he's really connected to the culture,
not disconnected from it and he brought in a lot of influences
but they were distilled through that extraordinary metaphysical sense
that Phyllis was talking about into this thing
that I think more than any other architect,
he created the image of what modern is.
What modern is both in the popular sense,
the layman's image of modern
but also in the highest and most profound,
critical and art historical sense of what modern was trying to do.
How would you characterize that?
I think it was a sense of lightness, thinness,
freedom from a sort of heaviness
and a sense of bulk and mass and weight
and also freedom from the most traditional forms of decoration.
And reduction to the purest.
Reduction to purism, exactly.
Although he was not always as absolutely and completely pure
as he or his followers like to pretend, of course.
That's one of the great things that these shows also show us
is how in fact Mies could decorate with the best of them,
he just did it in his way.
These two exhibitions,
what do you hope they accomplish?
Well, I think you've set it up here in a certain way
is how do you take on something that within three minutes,
we all agree represents the essence,
the modern, the 20th century and look at it afresh.
So we hope that it would be possible
to think again about and with Mies.
And so to have taken the almost contrarian point of view
let's deny the less is more and do two exhibitions,
which has led to all sorts of commentary inevitably
in those two catalogs seem to really run in the face of it.
But it was in a sense to say,
could we conduct an experiment,
cut Mies in two and say these two 30-year careers taken apart
will allow us to open up the questions all again.
But then let me ask both of you as curators
who put these two together,
what new comes out of this,
both in terms of the combination of this,
what new understanding about him,
what's fresh about it?
I think everything from his development,
which as Paul said,
one sees him as someone who's struggling,
who's connecting.
We tend to the sort of postmodern Mies
that we've had up till now,
not that these two exhibitions,
I think don't bring us a new postmodern Mies
has been a reductivist Mies
that has taken almost all of the cliches out there
readily available and kind of accentuated them.
So to discover a Mies who's reaching out
to connect with the avant-garde,
to connect with the most diverse kinds of experiments
about self-consciousness,
about space,
a whole range of types of building types
just to bring in even unexpected buildings
that he was involved with.
Unexpected context,
one begins to see a mind in formation
and a much more diverse production
that doesn't allow you to settle
into the three or four cliche images.
I think when one gets to the three or four cliche images,
they're seen with the sort of materials
that these other perspectives bring to them
so that the Barcelona Pavilion
can be looked at anew maybe.
Yeah, but I think that because you did
a terribly important essay in the exhibition
and that is Mies in the landscape and the landscape.
Mies has always been seen as somebody
who's completely unrelated to the context
that he was working in and to the environments.
I think that's one of the things that this show,
these two shows,
brings out absolutely.
Your show, too, very much.
Yes, absolutely.
There's a very good essay in the America Catalog
about Mies and urban context, too,
which is really the equivalent in a way of Paris.
But come back to your point.
I mean, just elaborate on that
in terms of landscape and his own thinking about that.
Well, I think Mies always said,
and it's true,
he said,
nothing is special.
The buildings I build are an idea
and they're not tailored to each situation,
which is absolutely true.
But at the same time,
can you imagine Seagram in Chicago
and can you imagine the Chicago Federal Center,
this very powerful, black, serious in New York City?
You see, so that these buildings,
there is a relationship to the context
in which these buildings are.
In a way, he always brings his buildings
into the city on a platform.
He establishes that, I learned from your show,
at the Real House.
I mean, this is extraordinary.
You know, I thought that he-
Was this the first house in Germany?
Yes.
And then, of course, at IIT
with that marvelous flying carpet
sort of image of the campus.
But this is where he learned to insert the building
into the city, which he called a jungle,
you know, that went on and on.
But you had to find how you could make
a marvelous place in that city.
And this is what he's doing.
So he's not doing what Le Corbusier did,
was tabula rasa.
Right.
Knocking everything down.
Or he is actually making discrete places
in the city that are open,
and yet they are part of the city at the same time.
You could put these all over the city.
You could put them in different cities.
And there's a kind of a sense
of connection between them.
And this is what is extraordinary.
You know, there was a time, I think,
when Mies was really the enemy.
In the enemy of the avant-garde and architecture.
In the late 70s and the 80s in particular,
in the age of postmodernism,
when everyone was talking about going back to history,
we were so turned off by all of the wretched buildings
that were imitations of Mies.
You know, not Mies's own work,
like the Seagram building,
but the garbage on 3rd Avenue
that was a knockoff of Mies,
that it led to a reaction against all things modern.
And then, in those years,
nobody really looked carefully at Mies
because he was seen as the sort of progenitor
of all this horrible stuff,
even though, in fact, his own work was very different.
Now we've come far enough, I think,
so we can look back at the original.
Did the postmodernists make that distinction or not?
They tended not to,
or occasionally they would, just for the record.
They'd say, oh, of course, we know he's a great architect,
but look at all this terrible stuff,
and it's really important
that we do different kinds of buildings now.
But in the end, it was a criticism of all of them.
In the end, they were thrown together
more than they were put apart,
and the notion that a modern building,
a Miesian building in particular,
is like this glass.
It's just a pure object dropped down there,
as opposed to something that really relates to things
and creates space in between,
like the little space between these books, in fact,
which actually has meaning.
The way these books lie on the table
is almost very Miesian,
and you can feel some space.
Now we can look at that more.
We can think about that more
because we've gotten away
from the whole postmodern reaction.
Take me, go ahead.
I think one of the most fascinating things
of your juxtaposition of the real house
and the Venturi's mother's house,
which one also thinks is almost identical
in date to the Seagram's building,
is to think that Venturi is launching that critique
right at precisely that moment,
but your juxtaposition says
we should perhaps rethink
even about that moment around 1958.
They're brothers under the skin on some level, exactly.
And the other night,
there was a program at the Museum of Television
where they rebroadcast a 1986 film
made on Mies's centennial year,
the veritable moment not to be doing Mies,
and we went there rather dreading it,
and one of the most incredible moments
was an interview with Robert Venturi in 1986,
and he said,
the thing I most regret is having launched
Les Isabours,
I think that one has a lot to learn from Mies,
and this was in 1986.
So having gone there dreading it,
maybe we should have been talking to Venturi 14 years ago.
Here is the arch-postmodernist,
even if denying it now,
actually very early,
ahead of the curve,
wanting to rethink Mies.
The interesting thing about Mies, too,
is I just went to see the Blake exhibition.
You talked about it there.
I did, you're right.
Well, there was this complete connection
between the two, Blake and Mies,
because Blake was against rationality,
and he knew,
he said, this is too rational.
You have to have creativity,
and Mies, exactly the same thing.
He was not this rational being,
you know, that everything was logically.
There was always this poetry.
There was a naivety in his work,
which was extraordinary,
and he was not this ready-made,
out of the head of Jupiter person
who was just laying down these buildings,
and this is what is so extraordinary.
He talked about Ford.
He was fascinated in the 1920s.
Everybody was fascinated by this mass production,
and he said, yes, but it's too mechanistic.
He said, we have to have our feet on the ground
and our head in the clouds.
Can you define this philosophy?
We've talked around it that comes from him.
A philosophy?
Yeah.
Did Mies have a philosophy?
Did he have?
He talked really about,
I think, it's the internal thing.
He didn't talk about it much,
but he would describe his buildings.
It's always fairly much a description
of what the pieces are in the office in Chicago.
I was speaking to Gene Summers,
who was his right-hand man for 17 years,
and I said, did Mies ever talk about his philosophical intent?
He said, no.
He was interested in making things clear.
He was interested in the structural architecture.
Clarity.
There were these two levels that he was on.
But they had qualities that he never talked about,
but he could convey in the work that nobody else could.
Then there's a serenity to a Mies building
that is not present in most imitation Mies buildings.
But he wouldn't talk about it.
He wouldn't talk about it particularly.
He wouldn't talk about the achievement of serenity.
Although I think when Phyllis talked about
his dislike of mechanistic things,
that was as far as he could go to say that.
It's very interesting that the images you showed at the beginning
all had figures in them, which is right.
Because in fact, people feel right inside a Miesian space.
They don't feel that it excludes them
the way so many modern spaces do.
There's something about the way the human figure is in that space
that feels as perfect as the presence of the human figure
in any kind of architecture throughout history, I think.
It is as natural and right.
But I think there's a connection there.
If one could say, I want to put my finger on a Miesian philosophy,
it is the hard one where he takes on this.
There's a kind of crisis of confidence
in this issue of the technological.
But it doesn't lead to a retreat from the technological.
He emphatically says, this, the 20th century,
is the moment of a technological transformation of society.
It cannot be denied.
It cannot be undone.
But we need to both struggle with it, transform it, and transcend it.
And so there's a kind of,
there's a realism in the sense of wanting to deal with
what he will over and over again call the facts of the epic
with this desire towards spirituality,
towards a sort of restoration of something
that might be either lost or in danger,
but without nostalgia.
And I think that that is one of the reasons
why he suddenly seems to be of such contemporary relevance.
Express that again, because I want to make sure I understand.
This grappling with the issue of the technological,
but yet a seeking for spiritual values
and a sort of acceptance of the facts of the era.
Because what he says in that comment,
and again, as you say, not declared in a lecture,
but in his philosophical notebooks to himself,
is that we agree with the means but not the end of Ford.
So in other words, the steel building is this.
We have to accept the rolled steel section,
but we don't accept it as something
that we don't need to struggle with
to try to bring to some reflection
about some kind of universal, some essential
that goes, I think, to what you're talking about,
about this putting the empty space that is to be occupied
by someone who's going to come
and have some kind of experience
that's not programmed, but it's created in a certain way.
Let me talk about, go ahead.
There's a sense of humanism in all of it, I think,
always an ever-present humanism,
although that's not a word Mies himself used.
I think it's one we can apply now after the fact.
You always sense that these spaces were made for people
and for human life and human society to go on within them,
which is very different from what happened
with a lot of the architecture that followed Mies.
But it's interesting the way he even draws.
He never does these mechanical views of buildings
that are called isometrics.
He always draws perspectives from the ground.
And he asked photographers
when they were doing the photographs, from the ground.
This is where people perceive.
He was interested in the body
and how the body moved through these buildings
and how the body perceived the spaces they were in.
The other reason it's so relevant now,
and this is what Barry was talking about, I think,
is that we're now at another kind of revolutionary moment.
When Mies developed his work,
we were at a moment of tremendous technological development
and a sense of things being very new.
Now, with computers and cyberspace
and a whole different technological revolution,
we're right now thinking again
about how that will change architecture
and the lesson of Mies,
that it will change architecture completely in one sense,
but it does not have to change architecture at all
in another sense,
which is to make a civilized enclosure for human use.
To be able to have both of those things is important.
I've thought about this question earlier.
I'm going to ask you now,
where are we now in terms of architecture?
Let's take ourselves away from Mies
or use Mies as an example.
Where are we today?
Is there some sense,
picking up on what Paul just said,
a look at where we are?
There was some excitement here because of Venturi.
He's got an exhibition, you know.
And an exhibition of Frank Gehry.
Frank Gehry is at the Guggenheim,
and here we got two museums devoted to Mies.
Where are we in architecture?
And is there some sense of search?
Because, and let me just sort of,
you know, you've got a generation.
If Mies was a generation,
then moving to,
he was representative of a new generation coming on,
you know, and then you have another generation
that came after him,
I would assume,
the whole sort of Gang of Four and all that.
And then, where are we today?
I think that he himself felt
that architecture would change again.
When there was a new kind of technology.
And he said this,
and he said,
then there'll be something new.
And he's always talking about something alive
and something new.
So all this dead stuff,
it's not alive, it's not new.
But I would think that the kind of attack
that Frank Gehry has on his work is very much.
The kind of attack he receives.
No, no, the attack,
the way he approaches his work is using this technology.
He does buildings you could not have built
before the computer was there.
It's because not only the design on computer,
but it's actually the fabrication of the parts.
It was tried in Sydney with the Opera House.
It was a tremendous struggle to do that.
And so I think that this is sending architecture,
I don't know where it's going to go,
how it's going to go,
but it certainly is something new.
There's simply no question that it's something new.
But the attitudes towards humanism,
I think that you talked about,
of Mies' work,
I think people are beginning to understand.
I hope that that's one of the major things that comes out of it.
His attitude towards humanism.
Yes.
Tell me when you met him,
what was he like?
You know, he was amazing.
I had spoken to all sorts of architects
and they always criticized everybody else.
That hasn't changed.
And I asked him,
there was so much question about the Corbusier,
and I asked Mies,
you know, what about the Corbusier?
Everybody said he couldn't build in New York
because he already had something else.
And he said,
but of course he's a wonderful artist.
Of course he could build in New York.
Yeah.
You know, and he was the most generous man.
And he was,
the sense that I talked about with Real
and this 20-year-old man
convincing a major philosopher to build his house,
there was still that sense of his own being.
And he was also very funny.
He had a great sense of humor.
This is seen in drawings that he did.
And the way he would,
you know, when he had one or two martinis,
it took the edge off his shyness.
I think he was enormously shy.
He was shy.
Yes, oh yes.
And of course he also had trouble with the language,
which he didn't speak any English when he came to America.
He must have been desperate for it.
And yet he learned.
One of his people who worked with him said,
you know, it took us so long to work something out
because he'd say,
now how do you say that in English?
Now how do you say this in English?
Now how old was he when you were?
How old was he?
Yes.
70-something, 70.
Let's see.
Well, I can figure it out.
Early 70s.
72.
When you hired him to do the Seagull Bill.
When he, yes.
And he was,
there was a gentleness about him
and there was nothing didactic about him.
There was nothing, he didn't do this or that.
He always said, well, try again and try again.
It was always this kind of a gentleness.
There was no harshness.
All right, let me take a look at some things we have here.
Start with, this is a real house.
At first, I think the exhibition that we did at MoMA
is an attempt to, in a way,
give you a context to think about this building
as one that is denying,
there's already this complete stripping way of decoration.
I think we look at it at the beginning of the 21st century
as a kind of nostalgic little cottage.
The thing that's amazing when you encounter it
in the suburbs of Berlin
is that unlike all of its neighbors,
it's stripped of all ornament.
And Mies is already pulling out
a kind of essential order out of that building,
but it's not only an order that implies
that the building is made up of a rational number of parts
and a rational building method,
but he opens up and voids the last bay of the building
where the window is missing,
all the way over to the right
to frame a view of a landscape that's yet to come.
Next slide, next is the Bismarck Monument Project.
Just reflect on this.
Baron?
Well, this is, I think, this element of Mies
that runs right through his life,
which is simultaneously an exploration of the new
and a kind of basic conservatism.
And it's always almost like a way to kind of pull on him.
And I suppose, too, if we look back
at the beginning of the 21st century,
that's one thing that makes him such
both a prototypical modern,
but an untypical modern in this
sort of struggling with traditional values.
For who would expect that one of the first competitions
of a future modernist is to celebrate the unifier,
the militaristic unifier of Germany?
Yeah, but that's not his choice.
But I think that what is so interesting in this
is also that sense of repetition
that comes back in the mullions of the building.
And that he's playing with a rhythm
that's deliberately too narrow.
It's a kind of spacing of rhythm
that has almost musically
to deal with the scansion of the eye
rather than the fundamental necessities.
Okay, the next one is a Pearl's House again,
and one he's well known for.
What should we say about this?
There's a sense of sleekness in all of these, actually,
and a sense of tight surface pulled across.
Well, that one, when you get close into it
and you see the capitals on the columns,
I mean, he's...
But that one little opening, that hole,
I mean, that is absolutely extraordinary.
Reduce the classical detail
till it's boiled down to its thinnest essence.
But you find that opening, that hole,
in the Farnsworth House,
you know, and in the Seegum building underneath it.
It's almost a puncturing of a kind of space
inside the perfect geometric element
that becomes a kind of...
almost a viewing place for you to look out
so that that one violation of the perfect geometry
becomes the place that positions you
vis-à-vis the exterior of the environment.
One could take it all the way up to the lobby at Seegum.
It certainly draws you in.
Yes.
The next one is the...
This is Acrola Mira.
Yeah, that was a...
The Villa Project.
Yeah, that was a full-scale model.
And what to me is interesting
is that these, beginning in America,
drew to think.
But then he got to a point
where he just made models,
and the use of models in his work
was just a very, very...
He drew to think.
Yeah, that's interesting.
All right, next we'll see,
as I started to say,
the Werner House.
This is about when, Paul, do you think?
Werner House, Bari...
Do you know the exact date?
1913, I think.
1913.
So just a few years after Real.
Right.
Outside Berlin as well.
This is just in the suburbs of Berlin.
Interestingly, right next
to the Pearls House,
there's the famous story of Mies
going to visit the Pearls House
after the Second World War,
one of his few return trips to Germany.
And he was taken around
to rediscover this early villa culture
that he had been part of.
And he acknowledged the Pearls House.
And although over your shoulder
is the sort of neo-Biedermeier
of Werner House,
he didn't even turn around.
And so there was a kind of editing
of the career that went on with Mies,
which is one of the themes of the show,
to reverse the editing.
But he edited it himself.
He edited it himself.
And then the Miesian acolytes
encouraged even more of that editing, of course.
And the point of the editing was what?
To do what?
It was to suggest that this was a pure
and perfect rational architecture
that developed almost like
Athena springing from the head of Zeus.
Yeah, I think that an avant-garde architect
didn't have any connection
to traditional architecture.
Yeah, I got you.
Next is a glass skyscraper project.
This was when again?
1921.
This is 22, I guess.
Well, what he's actually looking at here,
and he talks about it,
is the reflection of glass.
He said, if you took a big, large pane of glass,
it became very boring.
And so what he's working on here
is how he actually had plasticine.
He put these long pieces of glass
into the plasticine
to be able to see what he was doing.
And here, of course, you see a proto,
I would say absolutely proto idea of structure,
because God knows what that structure is.
It's some sort of a central column
with cantilevered floors on them,
which simply couldn't exist.
But it's an idea.
And so you see a sort of yearning
to go towards a structural architecture.
And he said, you know, buildings,
when he showed this one,
the other skyscraper,
he said, buildings in construction
are so absolutely wonderful.
They're so overwhelming.
You see the skeleton frame.
And then when they put the stone all over them,
they completely disappear.
The power goes.
And so this is what he's working with.
Okay, the Weisenhoff apartment is next.
Well, that's part of the large project
that he edited.
This is that he was the designer,
not designer, the master planner.
But this is interesting,
because you see he's completely covered up
the steel.
You wouldn't know that's a steel building.
The only reason you would
is because the verticals are so minimal.
The Hermann Lange house is next.
Well, this is interesting.
Of course, this is not the Hermann Lange house
in a sense,
because this is one of Thomas Ruth's photographs
of the Hermann Lange house.
So this is already a sort of artist responding to,
and one feels it.
But he's responding in a way
that kind of has resonance with Mies
in as much as he's blackened the windows
in a certain sense.
So Mies' play with transparency and opacity,
although in certain moments
you see right through the building
as though it weren't there.
So that kind of solid screen transparency,
oscillation that Mies was interested in
is something that I think Ruth has picked up on
and made almost accentuated in these photos.
Okay, the next is a German pavilion.
This is a Thomas Ruth picture.
Yes.
Of the new one then.
No, yes, the reconstructed one, yes, absolutely.
All right.
Well, of course, that has all the elements
of what would be happening
is the plane of the roof
and the plane of the podium.
To be seen later.
Pardon?
To be seen later.
Yes, absolutely.
Of course, the podium was already there
in the real house,
but here there's really so much, it's so clear.
Okay, well, I think that's what's so fascinating
in the real house, of course,
is on a steep hillside.
So he needs it in order to create a place
for his building.
The Barcelona pavilion is on a flat fairground,
but yet his first instinct
is to carve out the place
where he's going to make his building
simultaneously to separate it,
but then also to reconnect it in that way.
So the first instinct is always
to almost inscribe the territory.
Okay, the next to the new National Gallery in Berlin.
Well, this is his last building
and there are actually two buildings
that were put together.
The 20th century gallery at the bottom,
which is a permanent exhibition
and the exhibition pavilion at the top,
which was to be for temporary exhibitions,
and this is exactly how the place works now.
It's the idea that he's finally got
to his pure space, pure steel,
structure and space together.
This is only steel and only glass, this building.
There is nothing else that intervenes.
You see some exhibition pieces
that are in the exhibition now.
And it is, when you come up from it,
this is at the back of the garden,
but when you come up from,
you see it on the podium,
here the podium is very strongly accentuated.
And again at that podium,
and you mount up to this thing
and although it is going like
when one rises to a temple on a hill,
and it's not a temple on a hill,
you see the city reflected around you
and you are in the building
and you are able to walk
in a sort of serpentine,
anywhere you walk, there's a freedom.
And I think the sense of freedom
in Mies' work was extraordinarily important.
You mentioned earlier the Farnsworth House.
Yes, indeed.
Before we take a look,
just give me some sense again
of why this is so important in his evolution.
It is so important in his evolution
because he had struggled to find out
how you could really put steel together.
It's the first expression of a building
that is pure steel and pure glass.
And he worked with the spaces.
It's also a building where there are no columns
that intervene in the space.
The columns are on the outside.
And so it is a building in which the space,
the continuity of space,
and space that keeps on unfolding on itself
when you're in the building,
and the building also in the landscape.
The fact that the building,
there are two planes,
and then third plane, which is lower,
which is how you rise up into the building.
The importance is that he said himself,
he said in 1933,
he described the fact that
the fact that you could use steel or concrete
and plate glass allowed you to do work
that you could never do before,
that you could have space that you never had before.
And he said, we will not give that up.
And he said, it also allows you
to connect to the landscape.
And this building really,
that was a kind of specification
for what this building is.
It was designed as a weekend home?
Yes, exactly.
In putting together these two exhibitions
at these two museums,
how much conversation?
Yes?
We didn't.
We were so busy.
I mean, we knew that we were doing this,
but we were so busy
trying to understand what we were working with.
There was so much work to be done
just looking at the material,
analyzing it.
Yeah.
But we never had a chance to speak.
Now, I think the fact that-
No one wanted to pick up the phone and say-
We had no room to do it.
But was there anything about competition here?
None.
I think there was a scientific experiment
where we've said,
okay, you do Berlin.
This career divides almost exactly in half.
Three decades in Germany,
three decades in the U.S.
The archive is enormous.
The issues of making one think about it
anew are enormous.
We each take our 30 years.
We'll compare results.
See you in two and a half years.
Let's have the same opening date.
And by the way,
this is the size of the catalog.
As you can see, we agreed,
at least on the dimensions,
if not the thickness.
Just look at this.
There you go.
And so then we came back together.
And the exciting thing-
No conversations in between.
No sense of you won't believe what I just found
or what conclusions I just came to.
Not really.
Who I just talked to.
No, just indications that we were still excited by it.
And that the astounding thing was,
rather than having complete burnout
after such a long project,
that the day when the opening came,
we were going to be able to go
and visit the other half of the career
and see what the other team had come up with
and also see this extraordinary thing,
to be involved in someone's biography
and decide that you're going to
not exactly put blinders on,
but that you're going to,
in the case of the Berlin show,
that you're going to say,
my biography doesn't need resolution.
I'm only going to deal with
the portrait of the artist as a young man.
What's the difference in the man you knew,
just if you could confine yourself
to what this was about
and the man you discovered here?
What's the difference in the man?
I think the difference in,
even for the public,
as I did when Phyllis invited me
to come for an early preview of her exhibition,
and I walked into the first gallery
and there was a table filled with books
and a row of paintings on the wall.
And my first thing was to say,
oh, well, we have paintings in our show
and books in our show
because Mies was becoming an intellectual
and involved with the art world also in Berlin.
But we didn't put them in the first gallery.
And then it struck me immediately
as there it was.
Here was a man who packed up
the essence of a world for himself,
brought it to America,
and there it was in the first gallery
in the Whitney show,
and had decided for himself,
these are the issues
that really are essential for me
to deal with now in architecture
in a new land,
and I'm going to deal with them.
And one sees this extraordinary process unroll.
And all of the themes are recognizable from Berlin,
but the entire context,
as well as the very personal aspect
of that intense search.
I think you've captured the view.
Okay, but before I go back to Phyllis,
tell me what themes you were talking about
that's come out of Berlin.
The themes of interest in new technologies
and new structures,
the building as a search for authentic structure,
but also as a kind of frame
for a relationship to the outside world,
this realist confrontation with technology
that we've talked about,
as well as an interest,
and this was a surprise, I think,
for both of us,
a profound interest in nature,
both in relationship to landscape,
but also in relationship
to natural science research.
That, to me, was the amazing thing,
was I remember at the study center
at the CCA about four years ago,
one of the scholars that said to me,
what was Mies' relationship to the context
that he was in?
I said, no.
And then I was, I've moved that day.
And that's a marvelous way to say it,
because it became so evident and so strong.
And so when I knew about various essays,
something about the landscape,
that's about all I knew.
And when I read his essay
and I saw the show and I said,
this is absolutely extraordinary.
It was there.
Yes.
So what would you say today,
in answer to the question
about his relationship to landscape?
I mean, other than what you've already said here.
What was his landscape?
You wouldn't say none,
you would say what?
I would say that it was tremendously,
he was tremendously conscious of this.
All right, let me take a look
at some continuations of Mies in America.
This is Lake Shore Drive
for anybody who's ever been to Chicago.
This is a fascinating image,
because 860 Lake Shore Drive is on the left,
and 900 Lake Shore Drive,
900, 910,
900, 910 Esplanade as it's called.
But just stop here,
because don't go too far away.
Because you can see how clear
the skeleton structure is.
I do not believe that
that's what Mies really finally wanted.
It's like the figure,
the cover of Gay,
which is a gentleman magazine,
which he had a building
that was much more like the one on the right,
the dark building in the city,
the mysterious building,
the interiority of the building.
And this is,
even though that building
is not a great building in itself,
the two buildings,
this is the building
that led to the Seafront Building,
that he was going to take the skin,
not have the skin stuck to the structure,
but the skin away from the structure
so that you have a much richer play of light,
of realizing that there is a structure
and there isn't a structure.
There's a mystery to Mies,
which I find is fascinating,
that you find these buildings,
you find in the National Gallery,
and in that mystery of that space.
Mystery of space.
Yes.
Okay, the next one is,
again, Lakeshore Building,
Lakeshore Drive, 860 Lakeshore Drive.
This is an exterior of the lobby.
Yes.
Well, this, again,
is that great plaza
that joins the two buildings.
And the way the columns
come down to the ground,
and then there's this,
look,
there's a whole huge structure above that,
you know,
so that there's a kind of a definition
of an openness,
and then the enclosure that is above it
is astounding,
and you see the photographs this way.
Okay, coming up now
is the Seagram Building.
Well.
On the left is Phillip,
and on the right is Mies.
Well, there's a small photograph
in the exhibition
just after the building was built
in which you see the building
set on its plaza.
And the fact that
people always talk about the Seagram Building,
they do not talk about the Seagram Building
as being a precinct within the city.
They don't see the fact that
the Four Seasons are at the ground level,
which is, you know,
sticking out where Mies has his hand,
right on the top of,
well, actually it's a part of it,
and at the ground level,
that there is a presence of life,
a presence of human existence.
And after the Seagram Building,
Seagram Building is really two buildings.
It's the long bar building behind
and the tall building in front,
and then set on this,
in this precinct, on this podium.
And all his buildings afterwards,
the Federal Center,
the Toronto Intermediate Center,
there was always a number of buildings
playing against each other,
sliding from sort of a,
still the romantic German idea coming through.
And then there is always a pavilion,
whether it's a bank pavilion
or whether it is a post office,
which is a presence of human existence.
Paul Wise is a great building.
It's a great building for so many reasons.
It's a great building
because of its extraordinary beauty,
perhaps more than anything else.
The proportions, the materials,
the presence in the city,
as Phyllis said, it's a presence.
It's not just a, it's a place.
It's a presence.
The plaza, which exists
not just to set off the building,
although that was part of the reason,
but also to be a place unto itself
and to connect to other things,
the way it connects to the racket club
across the street and everything else.
You know, it's interesting.
Somebody once said, critically of Mies,
that Mies never uses diagonals,
which are much more naturally part of human life.
We sort of tend to walk in,
but in fact, part of his genius
was to make us the diagonals, in effect.
You know, if you look at the Seagram Plaza,
there are no diagonals
because we are the diagonal as we cross it.
And we feel within that beautiful enclosure
that he's made,
which is really one of the greatest outdoor rooms
that's ever been made
in certainly in the 20th century in New York.
So it's beautiful and great
for those and other reasons as well.
The next slide shows you the lobby.
And the connection to the racket club.
How beautifully he tied that building
into the city around it.
It's not stepping apart from the city.
It really is connecting.
It's just not connecting by imitation.
It's connecting in a different,
much more subtle way.
And you know, the magical thing is
that when you walk towards the,
through the open,
you come through the glass,
through the open lobbies,
which you go on to the Four Seasons
and you see reflected in the glass wall
of the Four Seasons,
you see both the racket tennis club
and also you see the Picasso curtain
so that you have this conflation,
a sense of this whole cycle of the space.
Even on a very simple level,
it's one of the only buildings
in which almost every building
built by a real estate developer
in New York at that time,
the elevators were turned.
So you would walk in the lobby
and then have to make a 90 degree turn
and wait in a kind of dark corridor
for the elevator.
Mies set the elevators.
In fact, you walk in the front door
and there you are.
So while you wait,
you actually look out
and see the light that was described.
Also, every last detail of that building
was designed specially for it.
Philip Johnson, who is Mies's associate
on the project,
designed the faucets in the bathrooms.
Nothing was taken out of the catalog.
Everything was made particularly for it.
It was an opportunity to do that.
Yes.
That was the thing.
It was a new time.
You couldn't use a drywall at that time.
It was really very interesting.
A lot of primitive technology.
Here is what Philip Johnson said
in a recent conversation,
Philip at 95 talking about Mies.
He did the greatest buildings of his time.
I mean, they still,
you go back and you earn it all
in the skill,
greatness of the design.
What was it about the designs
that you thought made them great?
I can't make it as clear as I can
with a copy of a Roman.
He made the original building.
He didn't need any figures to help.
What was the relationship
between the two of them?
Well, Philip, when Mies asked him
to be the co-architect of the building,
Philip said he almost cried.
And the relationship was,
I don't know, it was a complete,
Mies was the most cordial man
and he would never had
a difficult relationship with anybody.
There was a little scene
between the two of them
that had been talked about,
but that was incidental.
It was, I think, too much probably drink.
And it happens.
Yes, it happens.
But it was completely cordial.
But Mies was the architect
of that building in every way.
And, you know, interesting
that you talked about the plaza,
because Mies went back to Chicago.
It's a complicated reason
of the AIA and professionalism
in this country
where the professions try to keep...
The AIA, American Institute of Architects.
Where they try to keep the Germans
or foreigners who came
into the United States
out of the professions.
I mean, there was a...
And so Mies was not accepted
in the AIA in New York
to have his license for New York
because they didn't feel
that he had an appropriate
high school degree, OK?
So Mies went back to Chicago.
They told him he could take
a high school leaving test.
Mies went back to Chicago
and Philip then worked on the plaza.
And in working on the plaza,
he made the whole thing in water.
He put water over the whole plaza
and had just a path
going into the building,
your diagonal.
Of course, this was impossible for Mies
because the freedom was gone.
Right, of course.
That's a great story.
That's a wonderful story.
I never heard that story.
That's amazing.
And it makes the point, doesn't it?
Yeah.
Well, the amazing thing,
as you were saying,
is that what the sequence building
puts everything on stage.
The plaza doesn't only put
the building on stage.
It puts both the city...
On stage.
And then alternatively,
those who were in it on stage.
So three steps up from the street,
you know, are just amazing.
They just elevate you,
bring you on stage.
Indeed.
Paul, you...
Philip was...
Philip Johnson was Mies' greatest acolyte
and the person who really did the most
to raise his reputation here.
Did a show at the Museum of Modern Art in 1947,
which helped bring him
to international attention as well.
But like so many acolytes,
he simplified, oversimplified
what he was trying to honor.
And I think that was really the problem.
That was what we saw
in what you've just said about the plaza, in fact.
That he...
Philip, for a very long time,
supported the view of Mies
as this pure, perfect rationalist
and didn't pick up
or chose to ignore
all of the subtle aspects
of his character and his architecture
and his influences
that these two shows have now
so brilliantly brought to the forefront.
What did Mies think was his greatest achievement?
Well, I think that for what he thought
and what he said,
he talked about rational architecture
and what he really did,
I think that he wanted to do an architecture
that everybody else could do,
but that's not it either.
I don't know what he thought
was his greatest achievement,
but I think that the quality...
Each building that he did,
that was the best building he ever did.
When he did Crown Hall,
he said that was the best building he'd ever had.
And then when he did
the new National Gallery in Berlin,
that actually, he had done a building in concrete
which was very similar to that
and another museum in steel,
very similar to it.
And then he didn't build them.
They were projects.
And then he found it was a building he had to build.
I think for Mies
that the Clearspan Building was the most important.
And I think that those Clearspan Buildings
have a much greater variety
and possibilities within them
than the skyscrapers.
The skyscrapers, he went through a few stages
and then he got to where he thought that was right
and from there on in,
he had no real interest, I think, in them.
But he kept on through his whole life in America
working on the Clearspan Building.
And I would think that having Berlin,
his crowning glory,
and I think that everything he was working on
was towards Berlin
because it was all the things we've talked about,
the building on the podium
and the structure,
but it was the mystery of the building.
And it was the extraordinary space in the building.
And I think that that was everything
he was driving towards.
I think it was the last word you said.
I think it was a creation of a kind of space.
I think one of the problems of the Miesian legacy
is it's much easier to focus in on the structure
and the thing of the building
rather than to understand the mysterious art
of making the spaces both within and without
and only separating them by a glass pane,
either opaque or transparent.
And both are dependent on each other.
I think there are very few people
in all of architectural history
who have actually created a new architectural language
and Mies was one of them.
And to not only create that language,
but then to be able to make of it
things that are just almost indescribably beautiful
and that keep pulling us back to them
over and over again,
make you want to look at them,
go in them,
feel the space,
feel the texture
and just be made serene and happy by them.
That's an extraordinary achievement.
My thanks to Paul Goldberger of the New Yorker magazine,
Phyllis Lambert,
director of Canadian Center for Architecture,
organizer of Mies in America,
Museum of American Art,
also Barry Bergdahl,
co-organizer of Mies in Berlin,
Museum of Modern Art.
He's also at Columbia.
Thank you for joining us.
We'll see you next time.
