Democrats in Olympia have resurrecting an old, widely discredited policy to address Washington’s housing crisis: rent control (HB 1217). In the long run, this so-called solution has made housing more expensive wherever it’s been tried, and is rejected by economists across the political spectrum. The reason housing is expensive in Washington is because we have the fewest units per family in the nation. Under the Democrats’ failed leadership, our state has made it difficult and costly to build homes. The state can’t legislate away the law of supply and demand. If we want housing to be more affordable, we need to build more homes.
contrary to what the good gentleman from
the 21st said what we have done in this
chamber with
Supply will pale in comparison to the
damage this policy will do to supply I
use the analogy again Madam speaker of
stabbing somebody in the back with a
12-in knife and then pulling it out an
inch and saying that you're helping them
Madam speaker this is a 12in knife of a
policy on Supply and everyone you and I
and our colleagues
admit that we have a supply crisis in
this state and we have got to turn it
around Madam speaker how do we get
here why do we have this problem I can
tell you as somebody who's been a
housing provider for 30 years we have
not always had this problem this is a
new problem for the state of Washington
and now we're trying to fix it with a
policy that is going to make it
absolutely
worse it is not going to provide
stability the only stability and
predictability that we're going to have
Madam speaker is that I can guarantee to
you that tenants rents are going to go
up 7% every year year-over-year and that
we will be back again Madam speaker in
another
session to fix it yet again I want to be
really
clear that this bill will not stabilize
the housing market May I have permission
to read Madam
speaker please proceed if it's relevant
stabilization the definition is to make
something
steady and unlikely to change
change this bill Madam speaker does the
absolute opposite of that it's going to
destabilize our housing market it's
going to choke off
Supply this is a great
bill it's a great bill for
Idaho it's a great bill for
Montana and it's a great bill for
Arizona because just the hint of this
bill is causing our developers
to start moving towards those States
economists all agree this is not a
housing solution it's a self-inflicted
economic wound we have the sixth highest
rents in the nation and we are last dead
last in housing units per capita so this
is a real problem and I fear that this
law is going to have the exact opposite
effect of what we are intending it's
very well intended we we want to help
people here that's why we're all here
but this law will probably cause
landlords in this uncertain environment
to go ahead and Bank the 7% every year
because they don't know in this
uncertain environment what we will do as
policy makers one of the biggest
concerns I have with this legislation is
the fact that it uh doesn't have a
different rate for underaredsky
and it was that price when I bought it
and I have not raised it in several
years because this particular tenant has
had a number of health and uh Financial
challenges and I just haven't had the
heart to do it and should I ever need to
do maintenance or major Renovations on
this unit it will be very difficult to
do so over the last 45 years we've seen
the failed rent control policies of San
Francisco and yet more recently we've
seen in Minnesota St Paul when you look
at St Paul they implemented rent control
in
2021 that rent control was only
3% and that 3% uh was so devastating
that the market imploded rapidly 80% of
the builders stopped building there
Madam speaker I had this article it says
Austin rents tumble 22% from peak of
massive Home Building spree Austin Texas
rents are going down 22% you know why
because they built 50,000 units in 2
years how did they do that man speaker
may I read
again again please proceed if it's
relevant Texas capital has become the
poster child for Advocates who say the
only way is by building more homes and
while other cities run Progressive
including San Francisco and Chicago and
might I say right here in Washington
state they face criticism because
they're not focusing on what they should
be doing that's removing the the the
barriers to creating more Supply Madam
speaker please I implore you please vote
with me no on this bill let's do better
for the people of Washington state to
great great stability by creating Supply
not another problem vote no