#Business Housing affordability is a key issue in the US presidential election, with Pew Research finding that 69% of Americans are concerned about housing costs. Pierre Debbas, managing partner of real estate law firm Romer Debbas, joins Wealth! Host Brad Smith to discuss how the candidates, former President Donald Trump and Vice President Kamala Harris, vary in their approaches to housing affordability. "This is one of the most important topics going into the election," Debbas says. He outlines each candidate's relevant campaign promises, starting with Harris. "She is proposing a $25,000 down payment assistance for those below a certain income threshold. I think that the intention of this is an excellent intention, [but] my fear is that the additional liquidity and cash will just increase pricing further," Debbas says, explaining that housing affordability isn't just a question of "more government-assisted funds to help people buy. It's more so how do we create more housing stock. Part of her proposal that I actually really like is that she's coming up with tax incentives to incentivize developers to develop housing for those in the primary resident average median home price of $427,000 in the country. That's an excellent sentiment." On the other side, "President Trump's proposal predominantly has been about freeing up federally owned land to help developers access cheap land to create more housing. And [while] again well-intentioned, [it] doesn't move the needle." Debbas highlights that the Federal Reserve's ongoing rate easing cycle could help housing become more affordable.
It's one day to election day, less than 24 hours,
and what's shaping up to be a very tight race.
Affordable housing remains a top issue for voters.
A recent Pew Research Center survey
found 69% of Americans were, quote,
very concerned about the cost of housing.
That's up from 64% in January.
And we're taking a look at both candidates' proposals
to deal with housing and whether either could actually
address the problem.
Joining us now, we've got Pierre Debas,
who is the managing partner at Romer Debas,
one of Manhattan's leading real estate law firms.
Great to have you here with us in studio.
Thank you, thanks for having me.
Absolutely.
Let's talk about this a little more.
I mean, one of the major things that we're tracking
is the plans from either candidate here
and where either of them could make a dent
in housing affordability.
What are your anticipations?
You know, I think that this is one of the most
important topics going into election.
And when you look at both candidates' proposals,
start with candidate Kamala Harris.
She is proposing a $25,000 down payment assistance
for those below a certain income threshold.
And I think that the intention of this
is an excellent intention.
My fear is that the additional liquidity in cash
will just increase pricing further.
So it's not just merely a, okay, we need to issue
more stimulus or more government-assisted funds
to help people buy.
It's more so, how do we create more housing stock?
So part of her proposal that I actually really like
is that she's coming up with tax incentives
to incentivize developers to develop housing
for those in the primary resident,
average medium home price of like $420-something
thousand dollars in the country.
That's an excellent sentiment.
That's something that I think we need to hammer home
and I think something that should have been done yesterday.
Now, flip the script to President Trump's proposal.
President Trump's proposal predominantly has been
talking about freeing up federally-owned land
to help developers have access to cheap land
to create more housing.
And good, again, well-intentioned,
but doesn't move the needle.
How much federally-owned land can we give?
We're roughly five million homes short
of current demand levels, right?
So I don't know how much federally-owned land
you're gonna give up to meet that,
but it's not gonna be enough.
On the positive note, interest rates
is part of the massive problem in our market.
So if you look at the last four and a half,
five years since the pandemic,
you've had prices appreciate well over 50%.
Now, in the last two years in particular,
interest rates went from 2.5, 2.7% range to 7%.
So it's a two-pronged problem.
How do we create more stock
and how do we address the affordability
by bringing rates down?
So which candidate will be more aggressive with the Fed
in helping rates come down?
So far at the moment, it seems like President Trump's
been more of a vocal critic in terms of the Fed policies.
So I think both come to the table with something positive,
but neither's coming up with the proper solution.
It's interesting because it's also going to come
to some of those down-ballot votes that are cast as well,
because that is going to be what eventually moves the needle
on turning campaign talk into actual sustainable results
here as well for potential homebuyers.
As you think about the market right now,
and especially for the new homebuyers that are waiting,
and I think we have some of the stats here
just around what that behavior is looking like,
how do you anticipate new homebuyers
are going to be the critical piece
of what the housing market looks like
over these next few years?
My fear is that the barrier to entry
is going to be way too high for them.
And my biggest fear is that this generation
will not be able to afford a home.
And home ownership is largely the predominant wealth driver
for your average American, right?
They don't really have many other assets than that.
You pay off your mortgage over the course of years
with amortization, all of a sudden,
20 years down the road, you have a seven-figure asset
or close to it that's free and clear.
Now, what I think really needs to happen,
we need to regulate Wall Street's involvement
in the housing market, their investment
in acquiring hundreds of thousands of homes.
It's actually, it's funny,
when you talk about the election tomorrow,
that's one of the few things
both Republicans and Democrats agree upon.
There's a bill proposed in the House and the Senate
that hasn't been pushed far enough.
The bill was proposed about a year ago
that would limit Wall Street to only owning about 50 homes
and anything more that they would have to sell.
I think that that has to be passed immediately,
and then that would provide additional supply
in the housing market.
It will also reduce competition in the future,
and any incentive that you give developers to develop,
I'm actually a huge advocate as a real estate lawyer
for having restrictions on the deeds
that limit the transferability to only primary occupants.
So, I always say, if you buy a second home
or you buy an investment property,
we don't really care about that segment
of the market right now, right?
Because the situation's so dire for your average American
that we need to focus in terms of
how to reduce the barrier to entry
and let them have the American dream of home ownership.
What type of incentives would you like to see
for home builders as well?
I mean, you're clearly evaluating everything
from the existing homes all the way out
to the land that is available to build on,
and for a lot of the new home builders,
they're trying to figure out, okay,
where are the new plots of land that we need to go purchase
to be able to build on top of,
and ultimately close that supply,
the lack of supply, I should say, that we have right now.
It's an excellent point,
because when you look at inflation,
the cost of building has gone up so significantly
that in a theoretical world, what I'm saying is great,
but we also have to make it profitable
for developers to incentivize them to do it.
So the way, in my opinion, to do that is through tax breaks.
They pay capital gains tax or income tax.
If you were to build a certain number of homes
in a zoned area, like I had a theory
that we had opportunity zones came up years ago.
Why not create a program similar to opportunity zones
where you look at areas where there's
a significant shortage of supply,
if developers develop, say, 10 homes
that are limited to the medium home price in that area,
maybe half of their tax bill's waived.
Gains tax is cut by half, income tax is cut by half.
That way, they're getting enough profit
where it incentivizes them to do it,
and we solve a problem of creating supply
for those who need it.
Pierre Debas, who is the managing partner at Romer Debas.
Thanks so much for taking the time here with us.