Why California Home Insurance Market Is at a Critical Juncture | Rex Frazier

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
3.7K Video Views·Feb 19, 2025
California’s insurance market is at a critical juncture as insurers pull back from high-risk areas, leaving homeowners with fewer options. Rex Frazier, CEO of the Personal Insurance Federation of California, explains the factors behind the crisis and the changes needed to keep coverage accessible.
"The insurance industry still believes that California wildfire is insurable," Frazier says. "We don't need special government programs to make that happen, even in the face of a hotter, drier climate."
Los Angeles fires have highlighted
the importance of having good insurance.
Many homes in California that are close to fire zones
are getting non-renewal notices by insurance companies.
At the same time, insurance companies are saying
they cannot survive in California.
So the whole insurance space has become a mess.
Today we sit down with Rex Fraser,
who's representing the insurance industry.
He also helped the regulatory body in California
back in the day in his career.
Rex is gonna tell us how we got into the mess
we are in with home insurance.
And what's the way out?
I'm Siamak Khorrami, welcome to California Insider.
Rex, it's great to have you back on, welcome back.
Thank you, thank you for having me.
It's a tough time for your space now, right?
Insurance space.
And you represent some of the largest insurance companies
in California.
We wanna hear from you what's happening.
There is a lot of payment going out.
How are these insurance companies doing?
Well, the good news is insurance companies
are prepared for these large Los Angeles fires.
And the insurance commissioner is doing a regular survey
of claims payments.
And I believe yesterday or today,
they will announce that a month after the fires,
insurance companies have advanced $6.9 billion
to victims of these wildfires.
So it's an enormous amount of money going out quickly
to help people fund their temporary relocation costs,
as well as advances for the portion of the personal property
that they've lost without any type of inventory.
So that's the first easy step.
The second step is gonna be much harder,
which is the cleanup.
There's the first stage of the cleanup,
which is removing toxic materials.
Think about all of the EV batteries that have just burned
or all the different chemicals
that might be present on these lots.
So the EPA is gonna have to oversee
the cleanup of these lots.
And then you'll have the removal of the debris,
which could potentially kick up other pollutants.
So the first step is just getting money out to people
when they're traumatized
and in need of immediate financial help.
The second step, long before we're talking about rebuilding,
is just cleaning up these lots,
and that's a difficult process.
Is insurance gonna be involved in any of that?
Well, there is a debris removal coverage
typically in an insurance policy.
However, the federal government has indicated
they're going to assume those costs of debris removal,
which is good for California policyholders
because that reserves money
that can be used for other purposes,
particularly rebuilding their home,
because there's always a concern,
did someone buy enough insurance?
Are they going to have enough proceeds in their pocket
to be able to rebuild?
Because after a major catastrophe,
you have a concept of demand surge.
Everybody's asking the limited pool of contractors
all at once to rebuild.
And so prices generally go up quite a bit
when it comes to rebuilding after a mass disaster.
So if you don't have to spend as much money
on rental housing,
if you don't have to spend as much money on debris removal,
then it benefits policyholders
because there's more money available.
Now, insurance space in California
has been under a lot of stress.
You have come on the show,
we have had other guests on the show,
and there's been a lot of challenges with this space,
and probably will change.
But we want to hear from you what's really going on
in California insurance market right now.
I was on a radio interview with a BBC reporter,
and at the end of the interview,
she told me I was a bummer
because I always have to say these tough things.
But I'm happy to at least be able to say one good thing,
is that the insurance industry still believes
that California wildfire is insurable.
We don't need special government programs
to make that happen.
Even in the face of hotter, drier climate,
where we could have more valuable property near a brush
that can be more likely to be engulfed in flames,
wildfire is still insurable in California.
And so we disagree with voices who say
that we have an uninsurable future.
We don't believe that's true.
But we need a system that allows companies
to bring in enough money
so they have the ability to insure people
in the highest risk areas.
And that's just simply what we've been deprived of,
at least for the last 13 years.
And it really started around 2010.
We had a new insurance commissioner come in
who just decided he was gonna hold rates down.
And so for eight years, we had very little movement in rates
and instead of doing what every business does,
which is gradually increase your prices
as you have inflation,
and people can adjust their budgets along the way
and no one really notices
how much more expensive things have gotten,
we didn't have that in the property insurance market.
We had a decade of suppression.
So then when we started having these massive fires
in 2017 and 2018, companies were ill prepared
to deal with some of the realities
of these catastrophic fires.
And so that's why people have seen these big jumps
in their bills.
It feels bad because it's all at once
instead of having been over an extended period of time.
And that was a self-inflicted wound
that California policymakers,
principally at the Department of Insurance made.
And it's good to remember that
because we can fix that going forward.
And we should fix that going forward.
But right now we're in a stage
where companies are just trying
to get their capital back in place,
trying to make sure that they can keep
their existing promises.
Because remember, insurance is a promise.
It's a promise to be there when people are at their lowest
and they need financial support.
And so, so many people focus on,
well, wouldn't it be good to stick it
to those insurance companies
and make sure they can't charge as much?
Well, if we do that,
then they're not able to serve high risk areas.
And it makes it less likely that they can answer
in a time of need, like what are we seeing now?
In a month, the insurance industry
has just put out $6.9 billion to LA wildfire survivors.
That's what we want them doing.
And so we have a series of changes
that we need in state law to make sure
that the insurance industry is ready
to confront this hot or dry future
that we think we'll face.
So essentially, what you're saying is that
the cost of this, so the insurance companies
will insure the houses, you know,
and the value of these homes went up a lot.
Probably the cost of rebuilding went up significantly too.
In the last, it's been the last 15 years, right?
So, but the insurance rates didn't go up as much as-
They did not.
And if you just think about how insurance company,
well, first of all, your viewers may not know,
California is one of the few states
that has profit and price controls on property insurance.
So if an insurance company wants to change its price
up or down, they can't just change their sign
like a gas station does and charge a different price.
They have to go to the California Department of Insurance
and work through a very complicated formula
for what is a permissible rate level
with an approved profit level.
And so you would hope those decisions
would be speedily made, but the Department of Insurance,
you know, they have a lot of work they're doing,
but right now it could take between six months and a year
to change your, get approval to change your rate.
So imagine an environment where the cost of rebuilding
is going up and that means that insurance companies,
they're gonna be paying more to rebuild people's homes
and what do you do if your revenue doesn't keep up
with that?
Well, you have to start making tough decisions about,
well, what's the amount of risk of our customers
that we can face and that we can support?
Because what we don't want is for insurance companies
to have too much risk in their business
and not be able to pay the claims when they're needed
and ultimately have a company be bankrupt.
Then where are we, right?
We still have to pay those claims
and when a company goes bankrupt,
what happens is the rest of the insurance industry
passes the hat.
They give that bankrupt insurance company
enough money to pay the claims,
but then the way state law works,
100% of what those companies paid
when they were passing the hat,
they turn around and collect from their customers.
And so we all end up paying it in a scenario
where one company goes down, their customers are vulnerable
and then we all chip in and that's how those customers
get taken care of.
So we don't want a system that fails
to ensure insurance company solvency.
And the duty of the Department of Insurance is twofold.
On the one hand, their job explicitly in statute
is to make sure rates are reasonable and fair.
But on the other end of the spectrum,
it's to make sure that those rates also support
a solvent company that can make its promises good.
And so they have to keep companies in that zone
of being strong, but having reasonable rates.
And so I think over the last decade or more,
the problem has been there's been too much focus
on just pushing these rates down
and not enough focus on making sure companies are solvent.
And when company's capital is under stress,
what do they do?
They have to react.
And that's when they start pulling back
from the highest risk areas
that are gonna produce the most claims.
So is this why a number of homes in the Palisade
lost their insurance right close to the fire time?
After the big Northern and Southern California fires
of 2017, you started to see some market reaction
and some companies started to pull back.
Then after the big fires repeated in 2018,
then you started seeing the general market pull back.
But it was really only in areas of super high wildfire risk.
And it wasn't perceived,
at least in the California legislature
as a statewide problem.
It was a problem of availability
that hit very high risk areas,
but it wasn't like most people even knew in California
that there was a problem.
Now, as those problems have gotten deeper,
now it's becoming much more of a statewide problem
that hits more and more people
who don't think of themselves in high risk areas, for sure.
And now you mentioned these companies.
So the pendulum has swing,
the state has been really on the side of the consumers
to the point where insurance companies are losing money.
Is that correct to say?
Well, I would argue they're not on the side of consumers.
That's a sort of false reality
is pushing companies into a hazardous financial condition
on the side of consumers.
No, it's irresponsible.
And so the Department of Insurance
can be on the side of consumers
by making sure that insurance companies exist
between the two realities of you have to have enough money,
but their rates are regulated and they can't be too high.
So there's no virtue in artificially suppressing rates
to the point where companies have to pull back.
Imagine other areas.
So right now everyone talks about eggs
and if it's $9 for a carton of eggs,
well, what if we told grocery stores,
you can only charge four and a half dollars for eggs?
Do we think they would sell them?
And then will we criticize them when they don't sell them?
If you told a realtor,
you can't earn 3% on this transaction,
you can only earn one and a half percent.
Do we think they would keep their same staff?
Do we think they would keep their same marketing budget?
When they wouldn't do certain transactions
because it was no longer financially feasible,
will we criticize them for that?
We told banks they can only charge half the interest rates
they're charging now,
and all of a sudden they don't make risky loans,
will we criticize them for that?
So it's the same thing here with insurance.
We've had a system of keeping rates at a level
that do not allow companies to go into the highest risk areas
and as that's dragged on and on with no relief,
it has degraded the financial condition
of a number of companies.
And so we have to turn that around,
but the good news is we can.
Our sponsor today is Shenyun.
There's been some negative press on Shenyun recently.
Shenyun's mission is to revive ancient
and traditional Chinese culture.
Shenyun performance started by a group
of Falun Gong practitioners in New York.
Falun Gong is a spiritual and religious group
which believes in living by truth, compassion,
and tolerance, putting others first.
The Chinese Communist Party, CCP,
has been persecuting it since July of 1999 in China.
Since Shenyun started, CCP has been targeting it
in the U.S. and across the globe
by playing different kinds of schemes
to cancel the shows or impact the performance.
The current negative reporting originated
from some Chinese social media accounts.
And we know that CCP has given a new directive
to go after Shenyun and Falun Gong in the U.S.
by turning the public opinion against them.
If you hear something negative on Shenyun,
make sure to do your own research and your own due diligence.
Despite all of CCP's campaigns against Shenyun,
the show has managed to grow significantly across the world.
I highly recommend you go see it.
I've been going to it for the last 14 years
as they change the performances every year.
They're coming back to California.
Make sure you go see it.
Now, before we get into the turning around
and what it takes, you mentioned the profits
of these companies are regulated,
and most people probably don't know that.
Can you tell us how it works?
Well, as you can imagine,
California has a rigorous price and profit control system.
So in the regulations for the Department of Insurance,
there's a provision where companies,
because the Constitution requires
they be permitted as price-controlled companies
to earn a reasonable rate of return,
the state formula has to acknowledge that,
that they have a constitutional right
to a reasonable rate of return.
We have a Constitution, the Fifth Amendment.
Everyone always thinks about the Fifth
as not incriminating yourself,
but there's another provision
that says government cannot take from you.
And so the U.S. Supreme Court in 1930
established a very clear principle
that endures to this day,
that insurance companies or any price-controlled group,
when the government is controlling their prices,
the government unconstitutionally acts
if it prevents that company
from earning a reasonable rate of return.
So as a result, the California regulations reflect that,
and there is a profit component in those regulations.
But it's limited, and it's really as small as it can be
and still being constitutionally defensible.
So it's not as if we're earning,
or insurance companies are earning
big Silicon Valley triple-digit profits.
That's not the way it works.
Profits are controlled in California,
and that's one element of a formula
that otherwise is pretty tight.
And there may be people who love that,
and they say, great.
Is it a certain percentage?
Yeah, it's a percentage that varies
depending on different market results.
But it's not as if companies are permitted
in their rates to earn 10%, 15%.
That's just not allowed under California law.
So is it even less than 10%?
Yeah, yeah.
So it varies over time.
But, you know, so some people are gonna be happy about that.
I understand where they're coming from,
but it's also self-defeating if all we ever do
at every turn in that rate formula
is to make it harder and harder
for companies to do business in high-risk areas.
So when these price increases don't get approved,
and then that level of profit threshold is calculated,
is that causing the insurance companies to look at,
say, okay, these are the risky areas.
For us to survive, to make that minimum profit,
we have to not take on this risk.
Yes, so if companies are trying to get rate adequate
to support their existing risk in their portfolio,
and they feel that their rates are not adequate
for that level of risk, they can either raise their rates
and keep their customers, or they can get rate adequate
by removing the highest-risk customers from their business.
And we don't want to do that.
We shouldn't want companies to only be able
to be rate adequate by reducing risk out of their portfolio.
But that's unfortunately what has happened.
There is another component to this,
which is the California Fair Plan,
which it seems like when people are not getting
the insurance from the regular companies,
then they have to go to the Fair Plan.
Can you explain to us how the Fair Plan works?
Yes, so the Fair Plan, it's not a government program.
There's no California Treasury behind it.
The Fair Plan is the insurance industry.
And when an insurance company gets a license
to do business in California,
they are forced under California law to join the Fair Plan
and subject themselves to the rules of the Fair Plan.
And so the statute's funny.
It talks about the Fair Plan being a private,
non-voluntary association of insurance companies.
You're forced to be a member of the Fair Plan
when you do business in California.
So the Fair Plan, they have the money they have.
They try to make money through premiums coming in
and investment income.
And under California law, the more investment yield you make,
the lower rate you can charge,
is the way the statute works.
So we want them to earn high investment yields
because that keeps rates lower.
But when they don't, rates have to go up.
That's the way the law works.
And so the Fair Plan, then they purchase insurance protection
from other insurance companies around the world.
That's called reinsurance.
And so you pay some money
to have a greater pool of money available.
And so that magnifies how many,
it increases how many policies that they can issue.
But if and when the Fair Plan runs out of money,
there's no state backup.
There's no federal backup.
It's the insurance industry.
And so California law requires the insurance companies
to just, on an unlimited basis,
keep giving the Fair Plan money to operate.
And so that guarantee poses an existential threat
to the insurance companies doing business here.
So for these fires in Los Angeles,
each company's already paying its own claims
for the customers where they've collected premium.
And then the Fair Plan, they have customers too.
And if the Fair Plan doesn't have enough money,
they ask the insurance companies,
hey, I know you're already paying those claims over there,
but pay ours too.
And that's what happened.
And so the Fair Plan has asked the insurance commissioner
for the authority to collect $1 billion
from the insurance companies
when they're already paying their own claims.
So allowing the Fair Plan to grow,
it may provide someone insurance in the short term,
and that might help close a real estate transaction,
and that's a good thing.
But all it does is defer resolution of the problem
that we should already be addressing,
which is how do we have the regular companies
continue to do business at robust levels
and not have people go into the Fair Plan?
Because the Fair Plan, it's a high-risk pool.
Its rates are always going to be higher
than the regular companies.
And so why not just let the regular companies
charge what they need to charge?
It's still subject to price controls from the state,
so it's not like they can do whatever they want.
But why not let them charge a reasonable rate
that lets them stay in high-risk areas?
Even if we let them charge much more than they charge today,
it's still gonna be cheaper than the Fair Plan.
So what have we accomplished
by holding these admitted market company rates down,
sending a bunch of people into the Fair Plan
where they pay a lot more,
and the Fair Plan policy just is not as robust
as what you would get from a regular company?
So we're telling people, we should be self-satisfied
because we've held these prices down
on these insurance companies.
Oh, but by the way, you have to go to a place
where you're gonna pay more and get less.
That's not sound public policy.
And didn't they change the rules
where now the Fair Plan can come to the policyholders
after a certain threshold
and get the policyholders to chip in if they?
When an insurance company, under current California law,
when an insurance company goes bankrupt,
what happens is the insurance industry,
through a different group
called the California Insurance and Guarantee Association,
the insurance industry will make sure
that the claims on that insolvent insurance company
are paid.
But the way California law works
is the insurance companies pass the hat.
They make sure the policyholders
of the insolvent company are taken care of.
But then the insurance companies turn around
and 100% of what they paid
to take care of that insurance company,
100% of that, they turn around
and they collect that from their customers.
Right.
Now the problem is the Fair Plan's
not subject to that situation
because the Fair Plan technically can't go bankrupt
because they can always call on the insurance companies
to top them up.
And so the Fair Plan statute doesn't answer
what happens when insurance companies
have to get assessed by the Fair Plan.
Like right now they have a billion dollar assessment.
So the insurance industry is going to provide
a billion dollars to the Fair Plan.
So what should happen after that?
Well, if we were treating this
like it's an insolvent insurance company,
then the insurance companies would turn around
and collect that billion dollars from their customers.
But the statute is silent on it.
And so the current insurance commissioner,
he's tried to provide leadership on this issue.
And so he put out a bulletin saying,
look, in any given year,
for the first billion dollars of assessments
that the Fair Plan calls on the insurance industry,
the insurance companies,
unlike with the Guarantee Association,
where you can collect 100% of that back
from your policy holders,
the insurance commissioner said for that first billion,
insurance companies are permitted to recoup 50 cents
or 50% of what they paid to the Fair Plan.
And then if the assessment in any given year
is bigger than a billion dollars,
then it resembles the normal system
where the additional assessments paid,
then those insurance companies can collect
from their policy holders on a 100% basis.
Now, of course, we advocated to say for that first billion,
it should be 100% recoupable,
because this is money coming out of one company
that already has its own claims,
and they're gonna be just paying money to the Fair Plan
for business that they decided upfront
they were not able to financially support.
And so you look at that and you say,
how sustainable is that?
If year after year,
there's going to be upwards of $500 million
drained out of the insurance industry
that goes to the Fair Plan
if they would have year after year assessments,
how is that sustainable?
And how is that not going to degrade
the insurance industry so much
that those companies start to suffer,
be unable to do business,
and then more people have to go to the Fair Plan?
So essentially, what you're saying is that
the prices are fixed in California for insurance companies,
the profits are fixed.
So essentially, the consumers have to pay anyway,
at the end of the day.
Because everything else is fixed, right?
Absolutely.
The consumers that have to go to the Fair Plan
in the first place,
they have to pay more than they should.
And then if the Fair Plan runs out of money
and comes to the insurance industry to get topped up,
then all of us as individual consumers,
we have to pay too.
You have to have enough money to pay these claims.
That's the bottom line.
Unless people would talk about,
well, we're gonna use state money or something like that.
But nobody in Sacramento, I assure you,
is pledging the California Treasury
to back up insurance claims.
So we have a system now where,
because of our rating system,
it's driven a whole bunch of Fair Plan growth
that's unsustainable.
How much has it grown significantly, right?
Well, the traditional resting point for the Fair Plan
is about 125,000 policies statewide.
The Fair Plan was formed after the Watts riots
in the late 60s,
where you started to have availability issues
in Southern California, principally in Los Angeles County.
And over the course of the Fair Plan's existence,
it's been primarily for the five big
Southern California brushy counties
where you get seasonal Santa Ana fires.
And so the Fair Plan,
there's been parts of Southern California
that have been hard to insure for decades now,
and they've been Fair Plan folks,
and we haven't really thought about it.
125,000 homes in a state as large as ours,
it has never been a big thing.
But as the Fair Plan has grown,
it's suffered a lot of growing pains.
It was a small staff.
They're now being asked to deal
with all sorts of premium coming in,
all sorts of policies that they're issuing,
giant amounts of claims.
They've never had a deal.
And we heard that they're responding slowly to this fire.
Well, it doesn't surprise me
because they're really being asked to go
from a tiny organization six or seven years ago
to trying to be an organization
that can do what more muscular
statewide insurance companies can do,
that they've been adequately staffed up
for a long period of time.
So it wouldn't surprise me
if they're slower than a normal company
because they're still growing.
The Fair Plan was never meant
to have a half a million homes in their portfolio,
which is what they eclipsed at the end of last year.
So they've grown by over three times
what they've been for decades.
And now to the extent that they have to move quickly,
I'm not gonna make mistakes for anyone
or make excuses for anyone,
but now that they've grown so much
and now they have all these claims
they've never had to deal with before,
it wouldn't surprise me that they've got some catch up to do.
And there is, for our audience to understand this,
there is admitted insurance companies and non-admitted.
Can you explain those and what's the difference?
Yeah, so when you get a license
to do business in California as an insurance company,
you get what's called a certificate of authority
and the state is admitting you to do business here.
As part of that, you agree
that if someone is angry with you,
they can haul you into a California court
and they can sue you.
You submit to California's court jurisdiction.
You submit to the California Department of Insurance
being able to audit you at any time
and to control your prices.
And your profit, right?
Profit. Absolutely.
And so that's what being an admitted insurance company is.
It just means you're licensed
and fully subject to California's jurisdiction.
Well, for decades, California law has recognized
there are certain types of risks
that are very hard to find a company to satisfy.
The traditional example was Lloyd's of London
insuring Joe Montana's arm.
You know, is a normal insurance company
gonna insure an NFL football player's arm?
No.
There's certain type of businesses
that are hard to insure.
A bowling alley.
We allow people with really slippery shoes
to have big, heavy balls throwing them around.
It's a lot of liability there.
So there's lots of examples where the admitted market
cannot fully satisfy the demand for insurance
and so there's a special process to export that risk
to a non-admitted company
where you technically are covering a risk in California
but the transaction takes place outside of California.
So again, going back to Lloyd's of London,
you're doing a transaction under the laws of London.
If you wanna sue them,
you have to go and sue in a London court.
And so the non-admitted company,
traditionally what would have to happen
is you would have to show as a customer
you had been declined three times for a risk.
Then and only then would you have access
to the special safety valve called the non-admitted market.
Several years ago, California allowed more immediate export
to the non-admitted market
and today you can just really go right to it.
Now, it hasn't been that big of a deal
because insurance companies, as they've been pulling back,
it's pretty easy to show that you need some other help
if you want an alternative to the fair play.
Now importantly, non-admitted companies,
they're not subject to California's price or profit controls
because they're-
They charge a lot more?
Well, they charge the market rate
as opposed to the state-controlled rate.
So of course it's gonna be higher.
They're not subject to our price and profit controls
because they're not physically present in California.
We can't just reach out and tell insurance companies
in other places, abide by California law.
They're not subject to our court jurisdiction here.
And what about the pay, paying,
when it comes to covering losses?
Well, I mean, they're reputable organizations,
but it's harder
because they're not physically present in California.
And if they go bankrupt,
that process, that guarantee association process
where all the insurance companies pass the hat
to take care of the customers
of the insolvent insurance company,
if you're with a non-admitted company,
there is no guarantee association.
They have what they have.
And so there's a lot of need for the non-admitted market,
particularly when you're talking about
a giant home in Montecito
that you need 15 or $20 million of insurance for.
Well, the average company in California
is not gonna be able to satisfy that risk.
So a lot of times you're going to specialist companies
around the world on a non-admitted basis
because they're the only ones
who can fulfill your unique requirements.
So there's a reason why we allow non-admitted companies
to do business here, but it's on a limited basis.
And the more healthy the admitted market is
with price and profit controls,
well, customers will go to them
instead of paying the unregulated prices
in the non-admitted market.
Now, Rex, I'm sure you've been talking to the executives
at these insurance companies.
You have also been talking to the insurance commissioner
and you have been in this field for many years.
What's the fix?
Well, the current insurance commissioner
deserves a lot of credit for being courageous
and saying tough things
because they're sober and realistic,
whereas the previous commissioner
just didn't want to do that.
As I noted earlier, the previous insurance commissioner,
he just simply was focused on holding rates down
and he didn't really have to deal
with the consequences of that decision.
And so in 2018, when the current insurance commissioner,
Commissioner Lara, came in,
we had two huge fire seasons in 17 and 18
that we're dealing with,
and he had to figure out how can we move forward.
And so he announced what he terms
the sustainable insurance strategy
that has three components
that we think are the necessary components.
Obviously, he includes things in there that we don't love,
but that's the nature of a negotiation and compromise.
But one is that companies have to be able to price
to the risk that they insure.
And if we have a false price
that doesn't allow them to charge enough to insure a risk,
well, we know what happens, right?
They don't insure that risk, they pull back.
So the insurance commissioner announced
that we have to modernize
our archaic antiquated pricing system.
Because remember, our regulations were developed
in the early 1990s when we were still using fax machines.
And those are the rules we have today.
And they've gotten old and in two principal respects,
they're outdated and we're the only state in the country
that rates in these ways
that don't actually reflect actual costs.
And the biggest frustration, we talked about it,
I believe last time I was on,
is how do we project future wildfire losses?
Every other state says,
well, we can use sensitive forward-looking climate models
that help us to predict what the fire conditions
are gonna be in the future.
But in California, we're the only state
that holds onto this notion
that to predict how many wildfire claims
we're gonna have in the future,
we look backward and we average them out
over the last 20 years.
So Commissioner Lara, he agreed to change that rule
and just to do what every other state does,
which is to allow forward-looking projections
that take into account a hotter, drier future.
And so it shouldn't have been a hard decision,
but in California, there's always gonna be a critic
and there's always gonna be someone saying,
no, don't change the rules.
That's just a giveaway to the insurance companies.
They can say those things,
but look where we are now with our current rules.
We're not in a good place.
So the first thing in the sustainable insurance strategy
is to allow pricing to risk,
and the commissioner is in the process
of updating those regulations.
The second thing is when a company goes for a rate filing,
they have to be able to get a decision quickly.
In 1988, when the voters passed Proposition 103
that imposed these price and profit controls,
there was another part of Prop 103 says,
but don't worry, this'll be a fast process.
If a rate filing's not approved within 60 days,
it shall be deemed approved.
Well, we didn't get the second part of that deal.
We only got the first part.
We got the controls, but we didn't get the fast approvals.
And so now if a company gets an approval
within six months, hallelujah,
but more likely it's gonna take nine months or a year.
So how in a time of rampant inflation,
when your underlying costs are going up
and you can't change your prices for six months
to a year at a time, and you're just supposed to lose money?
No, that's not what companies do.
They start to remove the risk out of their portfolio
because what happens is the longer it takes
to get that rate increase,
now you've got inflation eating into the benefits
of the rate increase.
And so what do you do?
You turn around and you make another filing
and you can never catch up in this current system.
So the part two of the commissioner's reform
is to create a system where we can start
eventually getting the promise of a rate approval
down to 60 days.
And so he has a new rate filing system
that we are waiting on them to unveil
where we can get through the process more quickly.
And then third, the third plank
of the sustainable insurance strategy
is to remove the ability of the fair plan
to bankrupt the insurance industry.
And that's where he put out his executive order
that announced for the first billion dollars
of fair plan assessments,
insurance companies can only collect 50% of that
back from their customers.
And then after that, they can collect the rest
from their customers.
We didn't want the 50%, but that's the nature of a deal.
And that's the situation we're in.
So companies believe in a system
where you can get a real price on a real basis
without the fair plan bankrupting you,
we think that is a sustainable future
to ensure wildfire in California.
Just to understand this correctly,
if there is a rate increase and it's too much,
and you guys don't have as much damage,
there's not as much, let's say we have a few good years,
then you guys will have to lower your rate eventually, right?
The way California law works,
yes, the way California law works,
it says no rate shall be approved or remain in effect
if it's inadequate, excessive, or unfairly discriminatory.
So the Department of Insurance at any time
is able to look at an insurance company's numbers
and say, hey, we noticed
that you've been making a lot of money.
We think your rates are too high
and they can haul you into court
and they can order you to lower your rates.
And they have done that.
So we, you know, now what they don't normally do
is say, hey, we think your rates are inadequate
and we want to order you, you know,
we want to order your rates up
so that you'll be more solvent
so that you can insure more people.
They don't focus on that side of the equation,
as I noted earlier.
Their job should be dual,
to make sure there's enough money
to insure everybody in California
and also to make sure that rates are not excessive.
So in a sense,
the way the California insurance system works,
consumers can have confidence
that whatever rate they pay is regulated
and then the profits are limited.
So the insurance companies
are not taking a lot more than they should
because eventually, even if you have a good year,
a few good years,
you probably have to,
somebody's going to monitor you guys' profits.
That is what happens.
And evidence of these rate and profit controls
having an effect is just look at
what the average premium is in California
versus the rest of the country.
We're not a high premium state.
Now, I know people experiencing
these big double-digit rate increases.
It feels bad because their budget is thrown out of whack.
But we should have had a bunch of small increases
over the last 15 years, but we didn't.
And so as a result,
now these rate increases are coming in bigger chunks
than they should be.
But even with these rate increases,
you look at a low-cost state like Louisiana,
it costs on average $2,200 a year
for homeowners insurance in Louisiana.
Here, it costs about $1,500 on average.
Now, of course, someone's going to say,
well, I live in a high-risk area.
It costs me $3,000 or $4,000.
And that's undoubtedly true.
This is an average
because there's people in urban LA
who are going to be paying $1,000
because under our law,
no rate shall be unfairly discriminatory.
You're not allowed under California law
to make one customer subsidize another customer.
It's the way the law works.
So on average, though,
California is a relatively low average premium state.
And do we think it costs more to rebuild a home
in Louisiana than it does in California?
No, of course not.
But yet their rates are demonstrably higher.
Same with Texas, same with Florida,
because they've been dealing with hurricane risk.
You go to Colorado,
they're just starting to have the fire problems we have,
and their rates are much higher than California.
So we just do not charge as much in California
as in other states.
And there's a consequence to that.
Because remember, the department should be looking
at both sides of this equation
rather than just trying to push down rates.
Now, I will say that this commissioner,
I think he's been realistic about the situation we're in.
And I think he has tried his best
to balance the two poles here,
make sure companies have enough money, but not too much.
And so I give the current administration credit
for at least trying to be sensible
about modernizing an antiquated system
and protecting the consumers while doing so.
I wish we had this earlier.
We didn't, but that's where we are.
So we're in a situation where it feels to customers
who are paying these huge increases,
it feels to them like, oh my gosh,
this is an outrageous price I'm paying,
and rates are only going up.
But then insurance companies look at this and say,
but just look at the national numbers.
We're nowhere near a high-cost state at this point.
Is it fair to say the previous years,
the insurance costs didn't go up
because we didn't have major wildfires or major catastrophes
so the previous commissioner didn't think about that?
Well, we know he thought about it
because we requested multiple, multiple times
to update the regulations to make sure
that in times of low fire risk,
when we know what the future holds
is gonna be high fire risk,
should we just wait and wait and wait
till we allow rates to go up until there's a big fire
and then say, oh, there's a big fire.
Now it justifies you to charge a bunch more.
That's our current system.
Our current system says, well,
if you have 10 years of good luck and low fire,
we're not gonna let you raise your rates.
Even if you're saying,
but I'm going into higher risk areas.
I'm going into areas I know are gonna burn
in a hotter, drier future.
The way our rules work now, you get no credit for that.
And we have developed in more higher risk areas.
Absolutely.
So companies, they continue to grow in high risk areas,
but yet because we had 10 years
of relatively low fire activity before 2017,
you couldn't raise your rates
because that's the way our sort of feast
or famine system works.
If there's no fires, you can't justify higher rates.
If there's a fire, you can justify enormously higher rates
that you never would wanna charge.
The one thing I can say about our current system
is it's always wrong.
It's always producing a rate indication
that's either too high or too low.
And so what we've been advocating for over a decade
is it doesn't matter if we have five years of low fire
or five years of big fire,
we should be looking ahead
to what the future is going to be
and have models that are sensitive enough
to make sure that you have adequate rates
during times of low fire activity.
But after massive fires, your rates don't spike.
And that's what forward-looking modeling does.
It provides stability that we desperately need now.
So essentially, consumers need to know that,
that their insurance rates should go up
on a regular basis with inflation,
whatever cost of rebuilding.
As any other good or service.
I mean, what business in the United States
is able to go for extended periods of time
without increasing their prices?
It doesn't make any sense.
We don't ask that of any other business
in the United States.
And so if we have extended periods of time
where companies cannot keep up
with the costs of doing business,
what are they gonna do?
They're gonna react by taking the highest cost elements
of their business and no longer serving them.
And that's the situation we're in.
This is utterly predictable,
but fortunately, we can fix that.
Now, Rex, you were just testifying in D.C.
about these insurance issues, right?
Can you tell us what's the perspective
across the country about what's happening in California?
Yes, so this week, I testified
before the House Financial Services Committee,
the Subcommittee on Housing and Insurance,
and they were really trying to get their arms
around what's happening in California.
And there, it did not feel as contentious
as California feels.
These were people of good faith
just trying to understand what's going on
and how can we help,
what type of money needs to flow immediately,
and then what should we do for the future.
They were very focused on mitigation,
what should be rules for hardening homes,
what should be rules for making sure
that your property is as safe as possible,
should there be rules for how communities rebuild back.
Congressman Waters, Maxine Waters,
was asking should we restrict where cities
and counties are able to permit building?
So we certainly got questions like that.
And what materialized was really how hard
the conversation is gonna be
about how we rebuild in Los Angeles.
Do we just rebuild the way that we did,
or the way that we previously have done?
The Los Angeles Times had an excellent historical article
within the last week where they talked about,
you know, once upon a time there was the Bel Air fire
and it burned through these hills,
and the reaction was, hey, we need to be careful,
we need to upgrade our building materials,
and we need to not develop in some of these areas.
Then over time, people forget there was a fire there.
And you get new elected officials who say,
yeah, we ought to allow development there.
And so we just have built into a very dangerous environment.
And it's not the insurance industry's position
to say whether that was good or bad.
It's our position, it's our job to say
what's the consequences of those decisions?
And price is the dominant signal there.
And if folks wanna live in a high brush area,
well, it's probably gonna result in a higher insurance cost.
And my view is I think we ought to want that signal
so people, they can make their own decision,
and then they can pay an appropriate price.
And if the state won't let that price be charged
by the insurance company,
well, the insurance company's not gonna do business there,
and that person's gonna have to go to the fair plan,
or they're gonna have to go to a non-admitted company.
You mentioned, Rex, that it's not as contentious in D.C.
Yeah, I mean, it probably helped.
It was a closed-door, no-media hearing
where people didn't have to get up and pound the table
and show their constituents how tough they were.
So it was much more the way it would be in your home
at your kitchen table where you're just talking
about an issue, and people could be normal,
and they could say normal things.
Out here in California, it feels much more contentious.
There's just a lot more active lawyer community.
There are specialized lawyers that are able to intervene
in these rape filings, and then they make millions
of dollars challenging these rape filings.
And they're not incentivized to get the process done quickly
because then they can't make as much money, right?
So we just have a very adversarial system here
when it comes to insurance rating
because we allow, really, in my view,
a lot of times, a duplicative force.
You've got these lawyers coming in,
and a lot of times, they just repeat
what the Department of Insurance position is anyway,
and then they wanna get paid for that.
And so that slows things down quite a bit.
Now, no other state really has a system like that.
And in these other states, it's just not this constant
fighting about trying to get to a reasonable rate.
It's just a lot more reasonable.
Maybe because of the history of insurance in California,
some people have doubt about insurance companies.
And how do you guys come up with a price?
I mean, you can never dissuade someone
that wants to be uncharitable in that way.
An insurance contract is a contract,
if it's auto, for six months.
If it's homeowners, it's for a year.
It's not a bank account.
It's not a deposit the way you do with banking.
So the notion of saying I've put money in every year
and I wanna get something out
the way you do with a bank,
that's just not an appropriate analogy.
That's not what insurance is.
Every contract, the insurance company is getting paid
to take the risk that they're gonna have to pay you
a much larger sum of money.
And so the system works because we all take that exchange.
We all pay a small amount of money
in order to be protected if we face a gigantic loss.
And so a lot of people focus on, well,
how much does it cost?
They focus on how much it costs
until they have a devastating event in their life.
And then what do they focus on?
Well, how much am I gonna get paid, right?
And so the very same people who may have been critical
about what they're paying,
then all of a sudden they're gonna say,
well, I should be getting a lot more insurance proceeds.
And it's like, well, how much coverage you buy
affects the price that you pay.
And if you wanna buy more coverage
so you'll be more protected after a fire,
you're gonna have to pay more upfront.
But we do encounter a lot of people
who want to pay as little as possible
and they want a much larger payout than they purchased
and then they're mad at the insurance company
and feels like they're being mistreated.
That's a difficult situation,
but California law requires insurance companies
to justify their rate level.
Importantly, it also requires insurance companies
to set up special investigative units
to root out and detect insurance fraud
because if insurance companies just pay fraudulent claims,
well, that's gonna lead to higher rates.
Take money from everybody else.
And it's gonna make all of our rates go higher.
So the Department of Insurance
has 200 gun-carrying peace officers
that do complicated fraud investigations and arrests.
And they audit the insurance companies
to make sure that the insurance companies
are actively fighting fraud.
And if insurance companies are not, they get in trouble.
And the state says, hey, insurance company,
you have an obligation to fight fraud
to keep your rates down, right?
So there are a lot of conditions
on how insurance companies do business,
not just the price and profit controls,
but on the claim side, it's a sensitive process.
You have to make sure you give people what they're due,
but you also have to be alert enough
to stop someone from getting more than the contract allows
or else you get in trouble from the state.
So California has very sophisticated laws,
in a sense, from all sides of it.
Oh my gosh, we have plenty of laws in California.
We don't, for insurance, honestly, we don't need new laws.
At this point, the insurance commissioner
has quite a broad set of powers
and we just need a responsible decision maker
in this very powerful position
who can take all of these rules and make them workable.
And so we've been grateful, at least this commissioner
has been willing to try to figure out the right balance
of keeping companies solvent and keeping rates in check
and making sure that companies are financially able
to serve as many people as possible.
I do fear, as we move on to rebuilding in Los Angeles,
I think there's gonna be a whole lot of hard questions
about how we rebuild, how close should buildings be,
how much brush should be taken out.
When you start talking about brush removal,
people get angry.
They move to a certain area because it's beautiful
and now you're gonna take out part of the beauty.
So I think we have a lot of tough decisions ahead of us
about if we're going to allow a bunch of expensive property
to be built on these hillsides
that have all sorts of burnable brush,
how do we want that building to happen
so we just don't have this terrible tragedy happen
30 or 40 years from now?
And so the insurance industry funds
what's called the Insurance Institute
for Business and Home Safety, IBHS.
They put out considerable science last year
on best practices for building a home
and within the next few months,
we anticipate they'll put out best practices
for how you build or rebuild neighborhoods
to reduce the likelihood of once a home catches on fire,
how do you stop it from jumping from house to house
and have an urban conflagration
like we just had in Los Angeles.
And some folks may say,
well, don't tell us how to make our local decisions.
And we at least view our obligation
to share the science we have on what's the best way
to build a resilient home and a resilient neighborhood
and reduce the likelihood of these catastrophic events.
So we look forward to sharing that research soon.
Rex Frazier, CEO of Personal Insurance
Federation of California.
It was great to have you on California Insider.
Thanks for having me back.
Let us know what you think of the insurance crisis
in California and is it solvable?
You can always reach out to me
at siamacaliforniansider.com or comment.
We always read all of your comments and emails.
We'll see you next time.
