California’s electric vehicle market is starting to shift as key incentives come to an end.
In this episode, we speak with University of California–Davis professor Daniel Sperling, one of the driving forces behind the state’s clean-car policies, about how reduced support is impacting the market and what it could mean for California’s clean-car goals.
Views expressed in this video are the opinions of the host and guests and do not necessarily reflect the views of The California Insider.
0:00 Intro 01:09 – Losing HOV access and federal tax credit 05:10 – Zero Emission Mandate Realities and Reactions 09:54 – Does California have enough energy for mass electrification? 11:50 – Electric Trucks and Buses 15:17 – Real-life policy making versus academic theory 18:19 – California’s Low Carbon Fuel Standard 24:25 – Fuel Costs and Policy Impact 27:49 – How California’s air quality leadership set global standards 31:44 – Is zero-emission realistic for everyone? 33:33 – California as a world model. Impact on Europe, China, and US national policy 37:38 – Refineries and Gas Supply 40:58 – Political and economic implications of declining local oil production 42:51 – The Risk of Gas Shortages 44:08 – Policy Making Behind the Scenes
Electric cars in California are losing the HOV lanes
and the 7,500 federal tax credit is going away as well.
The state was planning to go zero emission by 2035.
Did California make the wrong decision?
Our guest today is Dr. Daniel Sperling,
who's a key policymaker behind the zero emission movement.
He's here to tell us what was happening behind the scene
when California was making this mandate.
I think that was important,
but the downside of that is it got a lot of people upset.
It felt like government was telling them what to do
and it created a backlash.
California does have its own unique fuel standard.
You have been part of this.
Can you tell us more about that?
That's probably my most important contribution of my career.
Some people argue that this is increasing the cost of fuel.
That's how Tesla happened.
Tesla would not exist today
if it weren't for these credits
that it was able to sell to the other car companies.
When they first started selling their Model S,
they were making about $20,000 from credits
that they sold to other car companies
for every car they sold.
I'm Siamak Khorrami.
Welcome to California Insider.
Daniel, it's great to have you on.
Welcome.
Thank you.
Pleasure to be with you.
You're a big player
in the low carbon emission movement in California.
You have been behind a lot of the policies.
So we want to hear from you what's happening with the EVs
and then we get into your discoveries in the other fields.
Well, it's varying tremendously
across the country and across the world.
So there's a lot of pushback.
With the Trump administration,
they're taking away a lot of the rules.
But so the question is,
there's policy on the one hand
and there's the market and consumers on the other hand.
And they're related, of course.
And the politics and the policy are to roll back
the requirements and the incentives
and the regulations at the national level.
And they're also forcing California to do it.
On the market side, it's still a small market.
Actually in California,
about one fourth of the vehicles sold are electric vehicles.
The big question going forward is, is there inertia?
Are the companies going to keep marketing them?
Are people going to keep buying them?
Or are people just going to say,
well, there's no incentives
and President Trump doesn't like them,
so I'm not going to buy them.
We don't really know.
This is the big uncertainty.
I think if I was going to forecast,
I'd say the most likely is it's going to stay flat
for a couple of years, maybe slightly diminish.
Because the car companies, these are global car companies.
The rest of the world is transitioning to electric vehicles.
These car companies can't just say,
we're going to give up on electric vehicles.
They've made massive investments.
They have massive markets around the world.
They're not going to let it go.
So the question is, how much are they really going to stick
with promoting electric vehicles in the US, in California?
And how much are they going to possibly back off a little?
They're not going to back off a lot,
but they'll probably back off a little bit.
And we're seeing announcements like that.
How much losing HOV lanes and the tax credit,
the 7,500 tax credit means to this market?
A lot of people have bought electric cars
because they get access to the HOV lanes,
especially down here in LA, I have to say.
All the traffic.
All the traffic, all the freeways.
I know a number of years ago,
one of our PhD students did an analysis and said,
having access to an HOV lane was worth about $4,000.
And that's on average.
So many people valued it much more than that.
So I'm both an academic and a regulator policymaker.
I had 16 years serving, holding the transportation seat
on the California Air Resources Board,
appointed by Governor Schwarzenegger and then Governor Brown,
and then went through into the Newsom years.
So I've got a lot of experience seeing the real world,
but also looking at it in terms of what's the science?
What's really going on?
And these incentives have had some effect,
but I think it's overstated how much effect.
I think it's almost more psychological.
It's signaling.
Because if they see and they read that the government
no longer is supporting electric vehicles,
whether through carpool lanes or incentives,
then people say, well, maybe I shouldn't buy one.
But if everyone's saying, this is the future,
this is what's good for you,
this is what's good for California,
what's good for America, what's good for the world,
then a lot of people, okay, I'm kind of with history here.
I'm not going against history.
In terms of the state wanting to go zero emission by 2035,
was that an unrealistic goal
or was it realistic in your opinion?
Okay, I was one of the leads
on adopting that regulation, that requirement.
So the way I look at it now is,
okay, a few thoughts on that.
One is by saying that we are going to 100%,
the good news is it sends a signal
to all the different stakeholders and parties
that they need to start making adjustments,
the electric utilities, the fleets that buy cars,
the cities that do the permitting and provide parking.
So it didn't send a signal that this whole ecological system
has to coalesce around it.
And so if you said 80%, they might've ignored you.
So 100% was putting a stake in the ground
and I think that was important.
But the downside of that is it got a lot of people upset.
It felt like government was telling them what to do
and it created a backlash.
And so in the end, it was probably a mistake
to make it so aggressive and absolute
because the reality is it could have been changed anytime.
In fact, I expect that within a few years
if it had stayed in place, within a few years,
they would be going back to amend it and say,
okay, well, maybe not 100%, maybe 80%
because there are circumstances.
Some people really, an EV just doesn't suit them
or they're politically so ideologically opposed,
they're never gonna do it, they're gonna create chaos.
So at the end of the day, if I went back,
I would make it a soft 100%
and then making it understood that it was flexible.
But there was one other mistake about it
and this is an important thing for us in California.
Like all people, we're parochial.
So when California adopts a requirement,
other states have the option to either adopt California
or adopt the national requirements.
And so something like 12, 13 states
adopted California's requirement for 100% ZEVs in 2035.
And the reality is they had almost no chance of meeting it.
So if it was just California,
I think we could have come close
or might come close to 100%, but the other states not.
California, we've invested a lot
in building charging infrastructure.
We have the HOV, we had the HOV lanes for EVs.
We really did, we had all of our governors
from Schwarzenegger on all saying,
this is the right thing to do,
this is what we're going to do.
The messaging was clear and transparent and strong,
but that didn't happen in other states.
A few other states, maybe, but no one like California.
So we should have been less parochial.
We should have said, okay, what we do in California
is most important in terms of being a leader.
What we do for climate change in California
is really not so important
because we're only 1% of the world's problems.
But if 30% follow us, now we're having a big impact.
And so we should have been more aware and sensitive to that
and made some accommodations
so that other states would be able to follow us
honestly and realistically.
What about the infrastructure side of it?
Charging's a funny thing
because most people that buy electric vehicles,
at least so far, they have a house
and they can charge at home.
And people that have a house and charge at home,
like 85 to 90% of their charging is at home.
They do very little public charging.
So it's almost psychological.
It's like, I want to see, I want to know
there's chargers out there in case I run out of juice.
I want to make sure that there's somewhere to charge.
And so a lot of it's psychological,
but psychology is important.
That's how people make decisions, right?
And that's what we have to be sensitive to.
But we are getting to the point
where people that are buying them
live in apartment buildings, live in condos,
where they don't have easy access to charging.
What about the infrastructure?
Do we have enough energy for something like this?
We've spent many decades focused on efficiency
and very successfully.
So we always said to the utilities,
make sure that energy is used efficiently
and that way we won't need extra capacity.
So the whole regulatory system, the policies, the rules
was all built around having fairly steady
electricity consumption.
But now we're saying,
not only do we need more electricity for cars,
we need it for trucks,
and even more, we need it for data centers and AI
and electrification of buildings has taken place.
So now this whole paradigm
of how we treat electric utilities is transformed
and the utility, the whole regulatory structure,
the whole mindset, the bureaucracies,
they're not prepared for that.
They've not been set up to build more capacity.
And that's the struggle we're having now.
And the bigger problem is with data centers right now,
more than with vehicles,
because that's increasing much faster rate
than the electricity being used by vehicles.
So we'll see how that plays out.
You'll see there was a law just passed
or it's gone to the governor
that will connect the California grid to the other grids,
to the other states around us
to create a more robust electricity grid.
You know, we had the thing that we got all this solar
and wind, which has been great,
but we have too much solar at four o'clock in the afternoon,
three o'clock in the afternoon,
but then these other states need it.
So now we'll be able to transfer it to the other states
and make money from it,
as opposed to they were giving it away
for almost free at times.
This was very ambitious, right?
To go electric or buses.
And some regions are doing that,
but they're facing difficulties, right?
Right.
What were you guys thinking about trucks?
Okay, while I was there,
we adopted a rule that said by 2035,
a large number of trucks need to be electrified.
So it was 40% of the big rigs, the long haul trucks,
and 70% of the more medium sized trucks.
And I think that was fairly reasonable
because it turns out that some applications of trucks
and cars make more sense for electricity than others.
So for trucks, you look at those Amazon,
FedEx delivery trucks,
they go about 100, 110 miles per day every day.
So total huge amount of mileage they do,
but not that much and not too much in any one day.
So you can get a truck with a smaller battery.
So batteries are what's really expensive,
smaller batteries.
And so that means the truck costs a lot less
and you're using it so much
that you save a lot of money on energy
because the electricity is cheaper
than the gasoline or diesel.
So the application,
the delivery van application is a no brainer.
I mean, you saw Amazon made a purchase of 100,000 of them
a few years ago from Rivian
because that's a perfect application for it.
Now those big long haul trucks,
that's more problematic because they go long distance,
you need massive batteries,
charging is difficult and the batteries are heavy
so you can't carry as much
because there's a weight limit for the trucks.
So I think what we did back in, I believe it was 2020,
I think was a good rule.
But then they got carried away,
the regulators got carried away.
They changed it to be a requirement for 100% truck
of all trucks by 2036.
And I think that was a mistake
and that's where they went too far.
It was after I left, by the way.
And of course now they're both thrown out
by the Trump administration.
So it's unclear what's going to happen
with the trucks at this point.
It's clearly going to grow much more slowly.
It's going to continue growing in the delivery truck range,
you know, these trucks that are 10,000 to 15,000 pounds,
smaller vans, you know, that make deliveries.
That's going to continue because it makes sense cost-wise.
The companies make money, it's a winner.
And the drivers like it, you know, it's quiet, it's smooth.
There's a driver's love,
the drivers compete to have the electric trucks.
I've talked to many of the UPS and Amazon drivers
and they all say they want the electric one.
But without the requirement
for the manufacturers to sell them,
and right now there's also not the incentives,
the market is going to be pretty flat for a while.
And it's going to be limited more to those, you know,
trucks like the Rivian electric trucks
and then Ford makes this transit van
that's very popular, electric also.
But the rest of the applications are going to suffer.
There was a point where they wanted to,
for every truck that would come into California,
then there needed to be X amount of electric.
Like for every nine or 10 trucks you would bring in,
you had to be one electric, right?
What I learned in the regulatory world,
so when I was an academic and I studied,
did lots of research on air pollution and electric vehicles.
And so when I joined the board in 2007,
appointed by Arnold Schwarzenegger,
I thought this job is going to be a piece of cake.
I know everything that needs to be known,
you know, typically arrogant academic, right?
Well, I got there and I probably knew 20%
of what I had to know
because it gets so hard to do good policy.
You know, when we decide as a city, a state, a country,
what's important,
figuring out exactly how to deliver on it is really hard.
You know, there's this book, Abundance by Ezra Klein.
He talks about how, you know,
California has really tied itself in knots
by not providing permits,
not streamlining the permitting of new infrastructure,
you know, high-speed rail is the poster child they use,
but they don't come up with solutions.
You know, what do you do about this?
You know, what's important to us?
How do we come up with ways
of making sure people are healthy?
How do we make sure that, you know,
just sticking in my swim lane here,
how do we make sure the communities are not suffering,
you know, adversely,
that are near ports and railroad stations and so on,
near warehouses?
How do you make sure that we really start reducing
greenhouse gases and be a leader,
but doing it in a cost-effective, smart way?
And they don't have answers in that book.
And it's, you know, it's a bestseller.
Everyone embraces it.
I go, okay, great.
You know, I largely agree, but what do we do about it?
And that's, so, you know, the question about exactly
how do you orchestrate this transition
to electric vehicles?
Because in the end,
electrification is going to happen for sure.
It's, you know, it's a good thing,
not only because it reduces pollution and greenhouse gases,
but it also because economically,
it's the best thing for the consumer, for the country.
So it's not, we're not quite there yet.
You know, in some cases like the Amazon,
we are, they are there.
It is, makes sense in every single way.
But for a lot of applications, not.
And so we're kind of trying to figure out,
you know, how do we move forward?
You know, not too fast, not too slow.
You know, the Goldilocks moment.
California does have its own unique fuel standard.
You have been part of this.
Can you tell us more about that?
I'm glad you asked that
because that's one of,
that's probably my most important contribution of my career.
Back in 2007, Governor Schwarzenegger contacted myself
and a professor from Berkeley, Alex Farrell,
and said, you know, we just adopted this law
about, you know, climate change,
and we've got to do something about the fuels.
And in his mind, it was like, okay,
we want to help out agriculture in California too.
But he said, can you two come up with a policy
or a regulation that will help us in this transition?
So I spent, he and I spent like six months
with a team of about 15 to 20 graduate students,
postdocs, professors, and we came up with a plan.
And we worked, okay, this is an example
how you can do good policy.
So I'm a big believer in transparency,
but sometimes it goes too far.
So we met with all the oil companies,
the electric utilities, the NGOs, the environmentalists.
We met with the Canadians
because they had a lot of oil
they were exporting to California,
and they were worried we were going to regulate it
out of existence.
We spent six months meeting on Saturdays during the week,
and we came up with this plan.
We passed it over to the Air Resources Board,
and they ended up adopting it
almost exactly how we designed it.
And it was really vetted.
So what this does is it says,
we are going to reduce the carbon footprint
of our transportation fuels.
And what it does is it tells the refineries,
every year you have to reduce the carbon intensity
of your fuels just a little bit.
And if you can't do it or don't want to do it,
you can buy credits from someone else.
So the someone else would be someone
that makes sells low-carbon natural gas,
like the dairy digesters, dairy farms in the Central Valley,
or from the electric utilities
selling electricity for electric vehicles.
It's been, at first it was very controversial.
In fact, almost everyone hated it, I have to say.
It was kind of disappointing,
and it was almost destroyed and blocked by the legislature.
But over time, all these different entities
started to realize there was value to it.
So SoCal Gas started saying,
oh, wow, now we have a path to the future.
We can buy this low-carbon natural gas,
what we call renewable natural gas,
and we can put it in our pipelines,
and we can stay in business.
And utilities, it gave them an incentive,
and the biofuel people gave them an incentive.
And so it became very popular and very effective.
And one of the outcomes has been two oil refineries.
I know you want to talk about oil refineries.
Two oil refineries actually shut down their oil refining
and switched to biofuel refining,
what we call renewable diesel.
And this is just in the last couple of years or so.
So now in California, when you buy diesel fuel,
75% of it is not from petroleum.
It's from biofuels, from plant matter.
It's not fossil.
And that's kind of something
that people don't talk about or know about.
So, and that was because of the low-carbon fuel standard.
And so it's kind of a, I'm a policy wonk,
or I became one as I got older.
And something that's happened with regulations,
what we've learned is
you don't want command and control regulations.
No one likes to be told what to do, right?
Whether you're an individual buying a car
or a company selling oil
or a company selling cars or trucks,
you don't like to be told what to do.
So what we do now is we give them a performance standard.
Okay, so you got to reduce your emissions X amount.
And we don't care how you do it.
And if you can't do it,
you can buy credits from someone else.
So what it does is it harnesses market forces.
It's a market, it's a capitalist approach.
So it's combining the old command and control
with the markets.
And what it does is it really allows companies
to innovate, it gives them certainty.
So it gives them, that's how Tesla happened.
Tesla would not exist today
if it weren't for these credits
that it was able to sell to the other car companies.
So Tesla was using these credits
and it was getting funding?
Yeah, so in that case,
so we've done this with a whole bunch of different policies.
So the Zero Emission Vehicle Program
has what we call tradable credits.
The emission standards have tradable credits.
And the low carbon fuel standard
is a tradable credit program.
So the low carbon fuel standards
is just for the fuel suppliers.
The other one is just for the vehicle suppliers.
So I did switch gears a little bit,
but with the vehicle, Tesla exists only because of that.
Because when they first started selling their Model S,
they were making about $20,000
from credits that they sold to other car companies
for every car they sold.
So that was subsidizing them building each car?
Yeah, it was cross subsidy,
but it wasn't taxpayers paying for it.
It was a cross subsidy between companies.
Now, in terms of the cost,
some people argue that this is increasing the cost of fuel.
What are your thoughts on that?
The question about cost of fuels is a tricky one
because the cost of oil, it jumps all over the place.
You know, it was only a number of years ago,
it was $140 a barrel, went down to $30 a barrel.
It jumps all over the place.
So that's one little insight.
The other is we've made our vehicles so much more efficient.
When I was a kid, our cars got about 11, 12 miles per gallon.
Now they get 30 miles per gallon or more.
So therefore, one gallon of gas
goes three times as valuable as it was when I was a kid.
So yes, when we adopt these policies,
it does increase the price of gasoline a little.
But the cost of fueling our cars
is now probably cheaper than it's ever been in history,
going back many decades.
Per mile, is that?
Per mile, per mile, yeah.
How much we spend for fuel per mile.
But it's not a politically correct thing to talk about
because affordability is the big issue,
which is illegitimate.
I mean, there's a lot of people
really hurting in this state.
We've created a very inequitable society
here in California and the US,
and that really troubles me.
But the gasoline price,
I'm not sure that's where we should be
from a pure economic or societal perspective.
Before we get to the rest of this interview,
this is a time to look at some key headlines in California.
In our Epoch Times newspaper this week,
California state is passing a law
to allow ride-share workers to unionize.
Workers who work for Uber and Lyft now,
they can unionize.
Before they couldn't do that
because they were not full-time employees,
and now the requirement has been removed.
Governor Newsom is saying he's gonna cut funding
to universities who comply with Trump administration.
Trump administration is asking universities
to limit international students,
freeze tuition increases for the next three years,
and not have preference on gender and race
when it comes to admissions and hiring.
California state ends Kamala Harris' two-nancy law,
punishing parents.
There was a law that passed in 2011
that punishes parents
if their kids are missing 10% of school
and the parents could face $2,000 fine or a year in jail
and get a misdemeanor for it.
The lawmaker mentioned that these policies have failed.
If you find these headlines interesting,
there is a lot more in our newspaper.
Not only California News, National News International,
and China, and all the stories,
we put a lot of effort in making them balanced
and include different views.
Get a subscription today for $1
by clicking the link below and let us know what you think.
Now let's go back to the rest of the interview.
You mentioned that California took these standards
to actually show the world what can be done.
You were hoping 30, 40% of the world would follow.
How much of it was to change the world
and how much of it was to impact the local air quality?
So when we started talking about regulating pollution
from vehicles, it was all about local air pollution.
And it was Los Angeles area
and then secondarily the San Joaquin Valley
because they are the two most polluted areas in the country
and used to be among the most polluted in the world,
now much cleaner than it used to be.
But you guys did a great job at that.
CARP has done an amazing job on cleaning up these areas.
Like the air in the freeways in Los Angeles
is better than any other country,
a lot of other countries that I've lived in.
Yeah, I travel a lot.
You go to any Asian city, it's much worse than here.
You go even to European cities,
many if not most of them are as bad or worse than LA
and LA started off being far, far worse.
So actually air pollution
is one of the most biggest success stories
of the human race, what we've done last 50 years or so.
A gasoline car today is 99,
when it's sold is 99% cleaner than it was 50 years ago
before we started doing emission controls.
It's a massive engineering success story.
And even diesel trucks,
we'd sometimes talk about diesel trucks.
Trucks are also probably,
they're about 97, 98% cleaner than they used to be.
So now what happened is,
starting about 20 years ago,
the legislature passed the first law
that said we should pay attention to climate change
and greenhouse gases.
And it was specifically for vehicles.
It was, I believe, 2002,
Fran Pavley was the legislator that led it.
And starting at that time,
gradually these regulations and policies for vehicles
started to include climate change,
greenhouse gases as part of it.
It was a balance of the two.
Because at the end of the day,
if you go electric, you're solving both problems.
So electric is kind of the panacea in a sense.
And right now, politically,
it's gotten really complicated
because the Trump administration
wants to get rid of any rules dealing with climate change.
They say, yeah, air pollution is fine.
To deal with air pollution, that's good and fine,
even though they're relaxing some of those as well.
And so partly, the creativity that's happening
in the policy world
is how do you recraft these policies and rules
and incentives solely in terms of air pollution,
at least until the end of the Trump administration.
But that's where we are now.
And pollution now in California
is mostly not from vehicles.
It's come in some places like at the big warehouses,
like in Riverside, where you have so many trucks,
big trucks coming there, and some of them are older.
You do have some significant pollution there,
and there's a lot of people that live near those
because they put those warehouses near neighborhoods.
So that's a real problem.
Ports, in the ports,
you've got the problem that the ships coming in,
some of them, a lot of them are very polluting.
They use, they used to use this,
well, they do use mostly what's called bunker fuel,
which is the poorest quality oil.
It's like the bottom of the product,
the worst products in the refineries.
They just put it in ships.
You mentioned that we made the cars 99% cleaner,
but that 1%, some people argue that that costs
so much more to do, to go 100%.
What are your thoughts on that?
If you look at the vehicle
and you're looking at the pollution from it,
the more you reduce it, the harder it tends to get.
Not always, but generally.
Now, yes, the last few percent
are always gonna be the hardest.
Okay, I'm gonna say something I'd probably,
when I was on that cardboard, I wouldn't have said,
is that if we were only concerned about local pollution,
we probably could stick with gasoline cars
because we've gotten them so clean
and we can make sure they stay clean.
And I have this vague memory that only 20%
of all the air pollution in California
comes from the motor vehicles, even though there's-
So that's so low now.
Yeah, it's from all these other sources.
There's so many cars going and coming.
So they're 99% cleaner, but of course,
there's many, many more than there used to be.
So it's not all together, they're not 99% cleaner.
But if we're interested in climate change,
reducing the pollution emissions from the car,
the nitrogen oxides, the hydrocarbons,
that doesn't do anything for reducing climate change
and greenhouse gases.
So that's why we've-
You went to the zero emission.
That's why we went zero emission.
And you guys are doing this with a goal
because California has one,
you said 1% of the emissions of the whole world, right?
And you were doing this to set an example
so the rest of the world will follow.
Did they do that?
Did you see any progress from the rest of the world?
California indeed has been a leader
in the sense that others have followed.
So about the same time as California,
as CARB was doing 100% by 2035,
Europe was doing the same thing.
And Europe, I spent a lot of time talking to the Europeans.
In fact, my institute, I have a center in Paris
in Europe because we're trading experiences.
Part of this is the world has become more connected.
And so we were exchanging lessons learned
and they were really encouraged
that we in California were doing it.
It gave them the confidence to also move ahead.
The same time, we spent a lot of time with the Chinese
and we took our California experience
on how to regulate vehicles to the Chinese.
And the Chinese really followed the California model
to reduce pollution and move to electric vehicles.
They did the electric vehicles part better than we did.
So what California does, everyone does pay attention to it,
both because it's a large market,
but also because it's a model that others follow.
And actually now Europe has gone past us,
China has gone past us.
Why do you think people follow California
based on what you've seen?
People follow California
because California was the first major government
in the world that really tackled the air pollution.
So this was back in really in the 1960s
because we did have horrific air pollution.
Everyone tells stories about how,
you couldn't see the mountains, you couldn't.
My wife grew up in LA.
She said, there were many days
that you weren't even allowed to go outside,
to play outside, that you would get, you would feel sick.
And there's lots of research that shows
it's really affected people's lung capacity,
haven't been exposed to that.
So California really was a leader
in dealing with air pollution.
It had good reason to do it
because the problem was so bad in LA.
First of all, California was a leader globally
and then the rest of the country followed.
So 1970, Richard Nixon was president.
They adopted the Clean Air Act
and that was premised on what California had already done.
And part of that Clean Air Act in 1970 said,
these are the new rules we're gonna adopt.
EPA is gonna adopt national rules,
but you, California, because you're already a leader,
you've institutionally set up everything,
you've got a problem, you're sophisticated,
you can do even, you can go your own way.
As long as it's more aggressive than the national.
And so since 1970, California has adopted
its own emission standards for air pollution
that is more aggressive than the rest of the country.
And many other states followed it
because they had severe air pollution as well.
And then Japan followed, Europe followed,
but California was the first entity,
governmental entity in the world
to really take a strong stance in dealing with pollution.
And part of it was research,
because no one even knew
where was the pollution coming from.
Was it coming from the trees?
That was the kind of famous Ronald Reagan story.
Was it coming from cars, refineries, dry cleaners?
How much of it was coming and how did it form?
So the research community of California played a huge role
in providing the scientific foundation
for California taking a leadership and doing smart policy.
Because you can do stuff,
but you can do it stupid or you can do it smart.
And if you know what you're doing and you have the science,
you'll do it more smart.
Not always as smart as it could be or should be,
but smarter than it would be otherwise.
Now, speaking of refineries,
one of the things that we've covered a lot on the show
is the situation with refineries and gas supply.
There's a number of them that just announced
that they're leaving, they're shutting down.
One is shutting down,
the other one is just gonna import gasoline.
And we are hearing that importing is complex
to importing gasoline is more complex than importing oil.
And what are your thoughts on that?
Well, California is kind of a unique case.
One is that we're kind of an isolated fuels market,
because we do have a pipeline that goes to Arizona,
but basically we don't have any connection
to the main refineries on the Gulf Coast
and Texas and Louisiana.
So we're kind of physically isolated in terms of pipelines
and pipelines are the cheapest way to move it.
We're also isolated in the sense
that we have this air pollution problem.
So we've adopted rules to make the gasoline cleaner.
So the oil, so the refineries in California
make a special kind of gasoline,
a little bit cleaner than the normal gasoline.
And there's very few others in the world that do it.
So now you've got, you know,
this kind of isolated market, isolated industry.
And at the same time,
we're being aggressive about moving away from oil,
you know, moving to electric vehicles.
So how do you manage this?
And it's really complicated.
So the governor, he got a little too enthusiastic
about accelerating the transition to away from oil.
And he realized at some point that the transition
was not going to happen as fast as he had it in his mind.
And the result, you know, he was putting caps on profits.
He was making it difficult for the oil companies
in many ways.
And they said, okay, if you don't want us here, we'll leave.
But then there was a realization by the governor
that that's not a good thing either.
He issued an order to the California Energy Commission
to figure out how to manage this transition
in a smarter way that's less disruptive.
So that's what's going on right now.
And there's been a lot of meetings
between the oil industry and government
and regulators and the local governments
and air quality managers.
And I think, so there were a whole slew of laws
that were passed in the September legislative session
in California, 2025.
So they're working out a transition.
And I think that the transition is gonna be more respectful
of the oil companies that, you know,
demonize them and punish them and expect them to say,
okay, fine, we'll just take it, you know, we're fine.
You know, that's not how companies or people operate, right?
So they're working out deals with the oil companies
to try to keep them.
And it's gonna be, there's a lot of ideas.
I'll come back in a while and we can talk about it.
We can talk about that.
In terms of oil production in California,
some of the industry experts have come on the show
and told us that we are buying oil from all these countries
that are, usually they don't have really good governments,
but at the same time, they're shipping this oil
using this bunker fuel and we could produce it.
We could have it from here.
And that money will come into California
instead of that money going overseas.
What are your thoughts on that?
To a tiny extent, that might be true, but mostly not.
Because the oil fields in California have been drained.
It used to be, we got something like 80% of our oil
in California, and now it's down to 20%.
And the oil produced in California is really low quality.
So part of the problem is we built our refineries
to handle really poor quality crude oil.
And, you know, you gotta clean it up and refine it
and get new different products from it.
And so the oil production part of it
has become a pretty small industry.
It's important politically because Kern County,
where a lot of that production is, depends on that industry.
And so there's a lot of political pushback in Kern County
to preserve the oil industry, preserve production.
So they're going to, you know, there's proposals
to allow the oil companies to build more oil wells,
but it's going to be a minor amount of oil.
It's going to be more that it's going to slow down
the fall off of production rather than really increase it.
California just can't, doesn't have the ability
to really greatly increase production.
Some people are concerned with the refineries
that are leaving the state or might be leaving the state.
Is there a possibility for California to have gas shortage?
I would say there's a possibility of a shortage,
but it won't mean we're lining up at the fuel pumps.
It'll mean that there'll be some price spikes
for gasoline and diesel, probably mostly gasoline.
So that is a possibility.
And that's what the governor's most worried about
is the price spikes.
But there's going to have to be compromises, let's say.
You know, it might be we have to compromise
a little bit on the quality of the gasoline.
We might have to import some gasoline
that's not quite as clean as what we have here, for instance.
Do you think the state will be flexible?
You know, end of the day, there's no politician
that wants to be there when gasoline prices go up.
Remember, even Joe Biden was doing everything he could
to keep oil prices down, you know,
even at the same time that he was promoting climate change
and everything else.
So the result of that is I think California
will be flexible enough to make sure
that there's no dramatic spikes.
In terms of policymaking, how is it to be in that shoes?
In CARP board members, you know,
the Air Resources board members,
you guys get criticized by some people,
some people really like you.
How does it work?
So I'm mostly an academic.
I'm not used to being in the public eye, right?
Like 15 years ago, we did a revision
to the Zero Emission Vehicle Program,
you know, before the 100% one,
and I was seen as a leader of it along with Mary Nichols.
The LA Times did a story about how I had this conflict
of interest because I had funding from car companies
and my research institute,
and that therefore I was compromised
and who was I to be adopting regulations
because it wasn't reflecting the public interest.
And that was something that was scary to me,
you know, to be written up, you know,
featured, you know, targeted, you know, in the LA Times.
And my boss, Mary Nichols, the chair,
who is very experienced said,
people know you, people respect you,
you have a lot of credibility, let it go.
Don't, you know, don't make a big issue out of it
and it'll go away.
And she was right.
So I gained a little appreciation for politicians,
you know, when they're doing damage control,
how do you deal with it?
But it's kind of frightening for someone like one of us,
you know, me, to be targeted like that.
When you were making these policies,
were you concerned getting it wrong?
Yeah, when you're up there and you're making the decision,
you feel a tremendous responsibility.
You want to do it right,
but you do need to be sensitive
to how it's going to impact people.
So my wife, who was actually vice chair of CARB at the time,
she came from industry and her job always was,
for every regulation came up, she said,
okay, what does that mean for the small businesses?
What does that mean for the small companies?
How is it going to affect them?
And so we had those, we had a lot of pillow talk on that,
but, you know, we as a board address that a lot
and it is a heavy responsibility.
You want to do the right thing
and balancing what is, seems like an important goal.
So actually what you learn is there's a lot of goals.
So CARB's goal is air pollution and climate,
but it's increasingly also equity.
But also you need to worry about economics.
You need to worry about jobs
and balancing all of that is hard, is really hard.
And we, you know, I know I personally struggled
with that a lot.
Wanted to make sure that what we were doing,
you know, wouldn't come back to bite us,
you know, in the sense of being a bad regulation
or politically bad or, you know, getting,
and we worried about the credibility of the institution.
You know, one of the things that really troubles me
in today's world is we need strong institutions
that are respected, whether it's a judicial system,
whether it's the Air Resources Board, it's a legislature,
you know, we, as a society, we're not gonna function well
if those institutions aren't strong and respected.
And that was a special responsibility, you know?
And so I did have some concerns about going too far
in some cases, and that weighed heavily on me.
UC Davis Professor Daniel Sperling,
it was great to have you on California Insider.
It's been a pleasure sharing this forum here
with you, because this is so important,
what we're talking about.
Let us know what you think about this interview
with Dr. Daniel Sperling.
You can always email siamak.californiansider.com
or comment.
We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami, this is California Insider,
and we'll see you next time.