California's housing costs are more than double the national average, and the inventory of homes people can actually afford to buy keeps shrinking. Hundreds of laws have been passed. The entry-level home has largely ceased to exist. So what actually changed?
The redevelopment system California dissolved over a decade ago did more than move money. It created a framework for local collaboration, predictable financing, and anti-displacement protections built up over 60 years. What replaced it, Patterson argued, was built on different assumptions entirely.
Tia Patterson, president and CEO of the California Community Reinvestment Corporation, joined the show to explain what the conversation about California housing keeps missing.
Despite all the laws and talk about affordability of housing in California,
the needle is still not moving. Today we sit down with Tia Patterson,
who's an insider in this space, who worked in the California government.
She's here to tell us why, why we can't produce affordable housing, good housing in California.
We're thinking in the terms of units, as opposed to the people we want to help.
There are people that are building, because they're figuring out how to pencil and how it
works, but you don't see folks building entry-level housing.
Think about it. When's the last time you saw a $300,000, $400,000 house?
It doesn't exist. People only saw the money from a redevelopment perspective,
but they didn't understand that redevelopment agencies had certain powers.
I'm Tia Mack. Welcome to California Insider. Tia, it's great to have you back on. Welcome back.
Thank you. Thank you for having me back.
We want to talk to you about housing, and there's a lot of discussion about housing in California.
You know the cost is almost more than double the national average.
Yes.
It's becoming a huge issue for us. Despite all the laws, hundreds of laws have been passing,
people are not seeing any relief. Can you tell us what you're seeing?
I think over the last several years, we have seen a number of new laws pass.
I think at some point, though, you have to stop and evaluate and measure the impact
of the laws that you've passed. And I don't know that the policymakers take enough time
doing the evaluation and impact and oversight. We see a lot on the front end with the legislating
and making the laws, but you have to spend just as much time on the evaluations. You have to know
what works and what doesn't work. And right now, I think there's critical data and critical
information that we just don't know because we haven't spent the time doing some of that.
So we really don't know what's going on.
There is a lot of that. As a lender, I know what my portfolio has in it. I know where it is.
I know what it's regulated at. I know whether it's a performing loan or non-performing loan.
The state of California should have similar data. You should be able to regularly go back
and evaluate your programs. Are your programs cost efficient? What was the original goal of
that program? Is it meeting that original goal? And I don't know that we spend enough time on the
back end after a law is passed to measure that impact to see if it's truly working.
So we're passing the law, we're intending to help a community or build more housing,
and then we don't go back and look and see if it did work or not.
Yes.
Meanwhile, the inventory of housing is not going up.
No. To actually move the needle, it's going to take a number of things. It's not just about
funding. It's not just about regulating. It's about how do we provide certainty to the folks
that are actually going to be delivering on the housing. It's how are we collaborating
with our partners? Are we, the state of California and local government and the developers,
are we all aligned and moving in the right direction? Are we providing certainty? Are
we leveraging private capital? Are we deregulating? A lot of the laws that we've seen over the last
several years have asked local government or mandated local government to do certain things.
Well, local government approves the housing. They approve the permitting processes,
but the actual building of the housing, that has to be at the developer level.
And so, there are reasons why local government may not be permitting the housing. The cost of
the permitting, the developer impact fees. So, are we aligning revenue and incentives to all
align ourselves to move in the right direction? When the state of California and local government
are not aligned and you're not incentivizing those local governments that are pro-housing,
that's how you're going to move the needle. When you're all aligned and speaking the same
language. And right now, I think sometimes we're working at cross-purposes with one another.
We heard that some cities were suing the state. They didn't want the mandates.
Can you tell us more about that?
So, there are cities out there that are recalcitrant, that are just not going to do
the right thing. But do we want to really spend our resources on going after cities that are not
doing the right thing because they just don't want housing? Or do we want to align ourselves
with the cities that are doing the right thing and ensuring that they have the incentives and
the motivation to do the right thing? And so, instead of focusing on the cities that are doing
the wrong thing, because we have, what, 400 cities in the state of California, 58 counties.
Not all of them are bad actors. So, let's work with the good actors. Let's spend our time with
good actors. Let's spend our resources with the good actors and align that so that we're moving
the needle. I think sometimes we just focus and spend too many resources on going after the bad
actors.
And what about the developers, the connection
between the developers and the cities and the state?
I think there is a misperception that developers are making a whole lot of money that the state
isn't necessarily thinking about what risk those developers are taking on. Now, whether you are a
market rate developer or an affordable housing developer, there's a certain number of risks that
you're going to take. On the affordable housing side, we have put in enough resources sometimes
to help mitigate those risks. But on the market side, what are we as a state policy local government
doing to mitigate that? I think we have focused on certain segments of the affordable housing
and our resources to certain segments when really we should be thinking holistically
for a broad range of housing. Whether we're talking about homeless shelters,
entry-level home ownership, supporting that whole range of housing and housing types.
Some of them you may not want to provide subsidy to, but you may want to deregulate it so it's
easier to build. And I think what happens is we're not looking holistically at the whole system and
real estate and the whole market and what is needed. And if we policymakers thought more about
what are the market needs and what can we do and what should our approach be to support those
market needs. I think there's a mismatch and misalignment sometimes that goes on.
Do you think developers not have enough certainty to come into California and build here? Because
other parts of the country, they are somewhat building a lot and in some areas the prices
have gone down significantly. Right, well in California it is definitely more difficult
to build. Our building standards are two to three times higher than other building standards.
Most recently we had some CEQA legislation that passed and so hopefully developers will get a
relief off of CEQA if you don't know your audience. But CEQA is the California Environmental Quality
Act and often it was used as a sword instead of a shield. So instead of defending and protecting
and notifying about certain impacts to the environment, you would have folks come in
and bring a lawsuit to stop development. Well when you stop development, that risk falls on
the developer and now there's more time and time is money and so the uncertainty of that
is a risk that developers were often taking. So now that we have the new CEQA legislation that
has passed, perhaps we'll now see some relief on the developer side to eliminate some of those risks
and make that more certain for a developer so that they don't have to consider the extra time
and the uncertainty of whether or not they're going to be sued via a CEQA lawsuit. So we'll
see where that goes. That was just recently, so that was the last legislative. So it's fairly new
but I think it's something that we should be looking at and evaluating to ensure that are
we seeing fewer CEQA lawsuits? Are developers seeing more certainty because now they have this
law? But it's something we will definitely need to evaluate. What about other ideas because we
have been covering some of these ideas on the show and a lot of these ideas come across either
on the ballot or statewide or they come by city. So like something like transfer tax or the mansion
tax that LA has, a bunch of other cities and counties are looking into it. How does that
impact development? Well funding and resources are definitely part of the equation to help move
the needle and when your funding or your finance resources are uncertain, you have a stop start
that also adds extra risk. So what you have seen is you've seen a lot of local governments
come in and use transfer tax and different mechanisms to bring funding to the table to
support affordable housing. And you saw a lot of that because of the loss of redevelopment dollars
which was an ongoing type of a revenue stream that provided some certainty. You also see the
state of California coming in with bonds. They're hoping to get a 10 billion dollar bond on the
ballot this year. They've passed both policy sides of the house and so they're hoping to get that on
but by the deadline to have that on to the ballot. Part of the issue when the state comes in with
resources especially bond funds, it's one-time funding that lasts a certain amount of time.
And with that funding the state is putting that money out on a competitive basis
and choosing project by project. I'm not sure that's the right approach.
A better approach that may help you with some efficiencies and may help you with reducing costs
would be to push those funds down to those local jurisdictions that are doing it the right way,
that are planning for and permitting for housing. Now they have the dollars ready to incentivize the
developer to come in and build the type of housing that fits within the plan of what they're
trying to move and approve. I think approving it at a project by project level with state dollars,
I think that creates a certain amount of efficiencies. Whereas if those dollars were
closer down to the people who were actually approving the projects, you would definitely
get some efficiencies there. Kia, you mentioned redevelopment agencies and we didn't have this
type of housing problem 20 years ago. It wasn't this bad. Can you tell us what happened? I think
people only saw the money from a redevelopment perspective but they didn't understand that
redevelopment agencies had certain powers. We spoke about what is needed to move the needle.
Can you tell us what they were before for people that may not know what these agencies were?
So redevelopment agencies were part of the California constitution which allowed
them to set a base year for property taxes and as property taxes grew the amount of money that came
over that base year was called tax increment financing. You were able to take that revenue,
those property tax revenue, and bond against it and use that revenue to pay those bonds back.
You had to be in a blighted area so and you had to have public participation to approve that area
and so redevelopment agencies were a creature of kind of urban redevelopment to eliminate blight
and a portion of your redevelopment dollars were supposed to be set aside for affordable housing
so you could use it for public infrastructure. This was across California? This was across
California and it was tax increment financing and you'll see other states and even other jurisdictions
countries using tax increment financing but that was one way in California that we provided for
affordable housing. If you take into account the number of redevelopment agencies the number of
project areas and that were creating or kicking off tax increment financing and the bond revenue
that was received there was um folks had a certainty that there was going to be about a
billion dollars a year available for housing. These were the developers? The entire community
knew there was an industry that throughout the state of California we're going to have
about a billion dollars a year and those revenue those resources are going to be given out at the
local level to help eliminate blight. The city redevelopment agency, the city partnering with
the city, the redevelopment agency partnering with the city, the redevelopment agency partnering with
the county but under redevelopment law it wasn't just about the money it was statutorily created
forced collaboration so when those redevelopment projects were approved you had what was called a
project area committee so you had to have community people who lived in that community advising you
on that project so there was a whole mechanism of where all of the taxing entities had to come
together all of the local jurisdictions had to come together and the community had to bless it
to ensure that it was okay and it was consistent with whatever plan that redevelopment agency had
to adopt so yes the certainty of the money was truly beneficial and is needed but also that
forced collaboration was essential the housing policies that were built into redevelopment
they had anti-displacement laws and if you took out one housing you had to build back
two new housing so all of those laws over 60 years worth of industry standards were built into those
laws and so when you wiped out redevelopment it wasn't just wiping out the money it was wiping
out infrastructure that supported housing and it wasn't just affordable housing you could do
anything because some of those dollars that increment that was coming in was pretty flexible
you could use it for operations the part of the money that wasn't bonded but just the flow
operations rental subsidies down payment assistance so you could do anything to
support anything from a homeless shelter to entry-level home ownership under that redevelopment
matrix public infrastructure sidewalks streetscapes signage streetlights all of those
could be funded using redevelopment dollars and once again you had communities that came in and
supported that so you couldn't bring a project to be approved if it hadn't gone through kind of the
community process so when the state of California has come in with its new dollars whether it's
affordable housing sustainable communities whether it's bond dollars whether it's general
fund dollars the state has tried to come in and backfill from that money that was
eliminated with redevelopment but its approach has been on a project by project level so you
have the state of California picking individual projects whereas under redevelopment those
projects came in from the bottom up and got approved and married with the financing and the
cities wanted them and the cities wanted them it had gone through all of those processes
and there were there was a framework so your redevelopment project um had to be consistent
with your city's general plan it had to be consistent with your regional housing needs
so there were all of these things from the bottom up because the state had dictated certain of these
parameters but it was the bottom up as opposed to top down the way we are funding affordable housing
post redevelopment the state is coming in and picking individual projects from a top
down approach as opposed to a bottom up approach and that's one of the misalignments I think that
is going on. So did the money go away from the redevelopment agencies? Once they dissolved the
redevelopment agencies and started winding down those agencies as the bonds were being paid off
you couldn't continue to get bond revenue and so that tax increment those base years
all of that had to stop so that money all then started flowing back to the state started flowing
back to the schools and so the state of California one of the reasons why they wanted to eliminate
redevelopment is because they didn't want to have to backfill for the school share because
when the redevelopment agencies were capturing that tax increment they were also taking the
school share of the property taxes and the statutory formulas for any of the other taxing
entities so the dollar amount that the redevelopment agencies were getting once they
were eliminated that property tax flow started going back to the original entities and then the
state of California didn't have to backfill for the school's share so that's why that was the
biggest reason why. So we heard that they were eliminated because they were not needed because
of the housing the financial downturn and the housing prices were low. Well but if you know that
that wasn't really the case the case was is that it was the state wanted more money the state
wanted to stop backfilling for the school share that they were having to pay the schools because
the money was going to the redevelopment agencies right because that wasn't the first time the state
had tried to take what they called it ERAF shifts education augmentation relief fund but it was when
redevelopment agencies would give back the state the money that the state had to pay for the school
share so over a number of years the state had come in and told the redevelopment agencies
we want you to shift some of that money that you're keeping back to us as a state to backfill
for the money that we're losing so there had been a number of those times that had happened
and the governor had asked for them to voluntarily contribute their money and they said no so
redevelopment wouldn't have gone away had those redevelopment agencies probably voluntarily gave
some of that money back because every time the state was having some kind of a budget crisis
and if you remember when it was a state budget it was a state budget issue and that was a way in
which they could say we're going to save on that money that we're sending out because of
redevelopment agencies by eliminating them and because redevelopment agencies did not want to
pay the state that money that's why we ended up in a lawsuit and via the lawsuit the state supreme
court said you know what state statute created redevelopment agencies a state statute can
eliminate them so you're gone. Do you think we need to bring them back? I think from a fiscal
standpoint there are very difficult discussions that would need to be had
and it is what is the revenue sharing between the state of California and its local jurisdictions
you need property tax to pay for municipal services those services are not free and I
think this is a difficult conversation that needs to be had because it's related to Prop 13
and so as jurisdictions grow and their municipal budgets become larger what are we talking about
and how are we going to share in those property tax revenues so that that local jurisdiction can
pay for their municipal services this is also related to affordable housing because every
affordable housing that is approved it may be exempt from property taxes as part of the financing
so you want local jurisdictions to approve affordable housing which is exempt from
property tax but you're not sharing any revenue or ensuring that that local jurisdiction can pay
for municipal services so one of the ways in which local jurisdictions are now paying for municipal
services are that they are across the board charging developer impact fees so developer
impact fees for affordable housing developer impact fees for market rate housing but that is
one of the ways in which jurisdictions are helping to augment their general fund for the lack of
property tax or lack of revenue sharing from the state of California and so those developer impact
fees are now also impacting the production of housing across the board because there's no
standardization of developer impact fees. To sum it up from what you're saying is the state wants
the cities to approve development of affordable housing but they are not taxed so they're tax
free so the cities need to generate some income somehow so they're imposing higher fees or big
development fees on everything that has to do with housing and as a result of it developers
don't want to build it doesn't might not it may not pencil it may not pencil in some cases those
developer impact fees there's studies showing that it can be thirty forty thousand dollars per door
and that can make or break a project that you're trying to approve if you're trying to get financing
to approve that specifically if it's affordable housing if you're having that added cost that
means you just have to go find extra subsidy from somewhere else and that's where you get your
transfer taxes and some of your other things that are coming in to try to come in and subsidize that
so there's this constantly chasing of the dollars when what really needs to happen is a
difficult conversation about revenue sharing and how we're going to pay for some of these things
what about other regulations we're talking to people in the housing space
california has a lot of regulations if you're building something new you have to have solar
you have to have certain windows or environmental systems that that you don't consume too much
electricity what's the cost and impact of that on housing i think it multiplies because each time
you put on an extra layer you're adding extra costs california has the highest building standards in
the nation bar none so those extra building standards um are costing money when you have
the solar requirement or all electric buildings all of those things are going to cost money and
so there needs to have a discussion about trade-offs is the benefit of this regulation
outweigh the need for more affordable housing or more housing period we have a lack of supply
and we know that we're going to continue to have a lack of supply unless we can do something to
incentivize the building and reducing the cost and so a conversation where you're talking about
cost benefit analysis and actually weighing that cost and that benefit if you know and this is
going to be very facetious and sarcastic but if a regulation is saving a teaspoon of greenhouse gas
and you're costing an extra 15 to 20 thousand dollars a door that benefit may not outweigh
that cost and so having some very difficult conversations about trading off and benefit
and cost there is a book out the ezra klein put out about the abundance how we need to think about
our resources of abundance as opposed to a scarcity and that we need to understand that
every time we want to add a layer a new regulation something new that we think is going
to be beneficial that that is going to bring down the ability to move quicker the ability to move
more efficiently the ability to reduce costs and so a real thoughtful analysis uh we know the there
is a need to increase the supply of housing not just affordable housing but across the board
what do we do to provide more certainty what do we do to provide make sure that we're collaborating
all throughout the process with the developers with the local jurisdictions at the state level
so we're providing certainty we're de-risking we are supporting and collaborating and moving with
all in the same direction and there may be some regulations that need to be rolled back
yes we want to be clean and green but we also want to reduce homelessness yes we want to be clean
and green but do we want that to be at the cost of all of our children moving back home and living
with us and unable to afford and teachers having to drive miles because they have to live out on
outskirts from where they're teach so there's some real thought that needs to happen to cost
and benefit and what trade-offs we're willing to make do you think that's driving the cost of
housing higher or do you think a lot of people are not building because it just doesn't add up
are people still building and charging more for it or are there a number of people that are not
building I think it's probably a mixture of both there are people that are building because they're
figuring out how to pencil and how it works but you don't see folks building entry-level housing
there's not a whole lot of entry-level housing that's being built think about it when's the last
time you saw a three four hundred thousand dollar house brand new three four hundred it doesn't
exist like I remember as a kid growing up my mother's first house it was 850 square feet
two bedroom one bath she was able to buy that as like a single mom with a first-time homebuyer
program they're not building those houses those are houses they were building in the 70s for first
time entry-level home ownership and what does it take to get a developer to build a 1,000 square
foot house right now the average size of a house being built is 2,400 square feet at a cost of
seven hundred thousand dollars so what if we built a thousand square feet at a cost of four
hundred thousand dollars what is the government's role in supporting that where should the government
be in supporting that type of building based on what you're saying these type of regulations
it might make it not easy for people that are building those smaller because you still have
to have the solar panels you still have to have all the all electricity so you might as well build
a luxury home and then sell it for twice as much and then the people that are looking for an entry
home they don't have other options they're priced out right there are no options um there's also
the entry-level homes used to also consist of condominiums and townhouses and because of
construction defect lawsuits and insurance requirements you don't see a lot of new
condominiums being built you don't see a lot of apartment rentals they're apartment rentals but
for home ownership there's not many there's not many that are being built and so how do you
incentivize condominiums townhouses and higher density home ownership housing so that you can
get to the entry level and so there are there are discussions going on about reviewing construction
defect laws and doing some of the things that need to be happen um but as we pass these laws
we also need to pause and evaluate how impactful they really are and we don't do enough because
they have side effects they have side effects there may be some unintended consequences
developer impact fees transfer taxes all of these things that people are trying to bring the table
and you think about rent control people think they're solving a problem here but you may be
creating a problem here and what i mean by that is rent control on the first person that lives there
is going to protect that first person that lives there but there's no thought to whether or not
the person that's living there has an income issue we're not saying we're going to rent control you
based on your income it's just rent control and then what does that rent control do to the market
when someone else wants to buy or or build or rent or be a landlord so you have to be thoughtful
once again and balance these things perhaps rental subsidies need to be on the table
as opposed to rent control is there an opportunity to marry rental subsidies with market rate housing
to bring the costs down and so everything should be on the table and reviewed because it's not
going to be just one answer it's going to have to be multiple things thoughtful and balanced.
So Tia there's a lot of discussion a lot of frustration a lot of young people want to get
into housing and some people are moving out of state with all this discussion what really needs
to happen for things to change in California with housing? Difficult conversations it's not
a soundbite that's not a press release but really difficult conversations and you have to bring all
of the people to the table we have to start with a common set of facts right now I don't think we
have a common set of facts and it the person bringing the people to the table has to be kind
of a trusted objective party whether that's academia and investigative journalists but it
has to be someone that's willing to say let's all start with a common set of facts let's understand
what the problem is we're trying to solve let's understand that it's not one size fits all and
let's have a menu of options of where we can solve the problem in some jurisdictions it may be entry
level home ownership in some jurisdictions it may be affordable multifamily housing but a flexible
revenue source that's pushed down to the local levels that allows those local jurisdictions
that are approving to then incentivize the developers to come to the table because local
jurisdictions aren't building the housing state of California is not building the housing developers
are building the housing what do we know that developers need they need risk mitigation they
need certainty they need to understand that when I bring this for to get permitted that you're going
to approve it within a certain amount of time and I can start building so local government has control
of some of those things so make sure your regulations are incentivizing the approval
and the building of that project state of California reward those jurisdictions that
are doing that but difficult conversations need to be halved had to be able to align that
oftentimes right now the state of California is going through a reorganization process
probably needs to happen but a reorg as to who's managing the housing resources is just one part
of the equation because that does not solve the problem right now we have multiple housing
programs that provide funding for housing and you've got to marry all of these different funding
sources but all of those different funding sources may have different objectives so unless you're
talking at a program level to say how do we ensure that these programs are not conflicting with each
other you haven't solved the problem so that's what I mean when I say a flexible pool of money
if I have a program that is supposed to reduce vehicle miles traveled for my housing and I've
got another program that says we want this to be the deepest targeted most affordable housing
well those policies may conflict with one another cause log jams and not necessarily work together
and so you have a developer who's trying to marry all those funding sources who now the programs are
now conflicting with each other and what happens when you have conflict and log jams increased costs
and so until you align your programs and your objectives who's managing it is kind of an
afterthought so that real evaluation needs to happen and in order to have that real evaluation
you have to have difficult conversations. And Tia you got into this you have your personal
experience with housing right you have a passion for this can you tell us about it? I do so I have
experienced in my life everything from homelessness to having watched my mother purchase her first home
and there was a fire that happened when I was a small child I was beginning elementary school
and we became homeless for a number of years so we went from the family home that my great
grandfather had built in the central valley to homelessness living so it was a five-bedroom home
to a living with my great aunt who had a two-bedroom house so all of us living in her little
two-bedroom house. My mother was a single mom she had two girls myself and my younger sister
we were able to get on the list the waiting list for public housing so we had affordable housing
that we were able to live in that my mother could afford. In the mid-70s the federal law changed
to allow a single woman in her own name to get a mortgage and she paired that with a
down payment assistance program and she was able to buy a house when I was going into junior high.
I have personally had those lived experiences to see where housing can break generational cycles
of poverty where the ability to have move-up housing can change the trajectory of people's
lives and so to the extent that what I do on a day-to-day basis which I'm very passionate about
to see people who can come from living on the streets to have a possibility to have like a
graduate level degree because they've had housing as that stabilizing force that's why I get up and
go to work and do what I do it's because something I truly believe in and if you put people first
and you think about I want people to live in safe sanitary and decent housing and how can I as
government or policymakers support the individual I think you'll have a change in our narrative and
the change in the way we see things. Right now we measure impact on how many units did we build at
what affordability levels okay but how did you change and impact someone's life and once we
start collecting the data that we can really tell a story I think that's the change in narrative and
the change in approach that we need to take. So for you when you were growing up did you sense
the difference when you guys bought the home was that a sense of security for you or
was it for your mother? It was probably for my mother but I'll tell you what I think was the
difference in my life. The public housing that we lived in it wasn't like the projects that you think
of. It was four units of affordable housing in a mixed income neighborhood. The woman who lived in
apartment one was a senior citizen who we used to go to her house after school. Her son was the chief
of police. He would stop and have coffee with her every morning and on our way to school my sister
and I would be sitting with the chief of police like two little poor girls whose mom was working
at Sears and Roebuck was having coffee with the chief of police but it was a mixed income community
so I never grew up thinking if I go to college. I grew up thinking when I go to college but that's
the impact of living in a mixed income community because you see folks with a upward mobility
trajectory. So the folks I had gone to school with in elementary school a lot of those folks
carried on to when I went to junior high school people kids in my neighborhood when my mom was
able to buy her house I went on to junior high and high school with that same group of kids and it
was mixed income like you had kids whose parents were on the free lunch program my sister and I
were on the free lunch program and kids who were on their way to college and we were all in the
same class. We didn't know I didn't even know that I was poor until I got ready to fill out my
financial aid paper. So I'm filling out my little what do you call it the FAFSA your federal student
aid and I'm sitting at the dining table filling out my FAFSA and I'm like oh this can't be right
my mother's like oh yeah that's right and I'm like below the federal poverty level how is that
possible but my mom was oh my god my mother is incredible individual how she had the forethought
to raise my sister and I with the mental capacity to be to know when we go to college not if we go
to college and to surround us in a community that believed in that like the whole village it takes a
village to raise a child that's how she raised my sister and I but when you have state policies
that create 100 affordable housing at 120 units in concentrated areas of poverty
where's that move up where's the ability for those folks to be able to move and purchase
their first home so if all of our state housing funding is going for permanent supportive housing
homeless housing where's your entry-level home ownership what happens when that person who's
living in that affordable housing becomes over income they have no place to move so they stay
we don't evict an over-income person from low-income housing and often low-income housing
is the best housing on the block in the concentrated areas of poverty so we're
thinking in the terms of units as opposed to the people we want to help and so if we switch that
narrative and think about in terms of the people we want to help and how do we want to make their
lives better you're homeless today but we want you to be self-sufficient tomorrow and we want
to make sure that our system supports that but that's not the approach that we're taking we're
thinking of units produced when you can do both you can produce but also be producing move up
housing it is much cheaper to build a unit that is regulated at 50 percent of the area median income
than it is 30 percent of the median income so build off 50 percent units and then provide the
folks at a lower income with some sort of rental subsidy to make up the difference so that that
development then pencils out that takes system-wide changes that takes aligning your actual programs
to meet the needs of the market as opposed to programs specifically that this program is going
to help veterans this program is going to help homeless this program is going to help eli how
about one program that helps all of those various people that get sent down to the local level and
say here are your parameters you go build the housing and figure out how to incentivize the
developer tia patterson it was great to have you back on thank you thank you so much and thank you
for having me back do you think we're on the right path with housing in california or do you think we
have to change make sure to email us at siamak at california.com or comment we really appreciate
all of your engagement that matters i'm siamak this is california insider we'll see you next time