Insurance Final20,000 Californians Lose Insurance Every Month: The Truth About FAIR Plan Growth | Rex Frazier

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
4 Video Views·Nov 1, 2025
Many Californians are realizing after wildfires that their insurance doesn’t cover what it costs to rebuild. In this episode, industry experts Rex Frazier and Robert Anderson explain how shifts in state rules and market practices left many homes underinsured. They also show how small choices made when buying a policy can determine whether a family recovers or faces lasting loss, and what this means for the state’s growing FAIR Plan.
Today we sit down with multiple insurance experts to find out what's happening with insurance in
California and we also get some tips on improving the insurance policy plan with as little possible.
Some of the fire victims they're getting 20 percent less than the value of their homes.
Absolutely and 20 percent may be a good deal. Okay lots of people get a lot less than that.
You started to see massive fair plan growth and you don't want massive fair plan growth. You're
going to pay more and you're going to get less. That's the market of last resort. If the fair
plan runs out of money there's no state bailout. I'm Siamak Karami. Welcome to California Insider.
Rex it's great to have you back on. Welcome back. Thank you for having me back. There is a lot
happening with insurance in California and you represent the industry on the home side
things and on auto. A lot of people that got impacted in California by the fires they're
realizing that they're underinsured. They don't have enough to cover for the losses that they got.
What are your thoughts on this? Well it's a chronic issue. It's not the first time and I'm sure this
won't be the last time we have to deal with this issue. It really has a history to it. In the late
80s we had the Oakland Hills fire and at that time the average insurance policy was called a
Guaranteed Replacement Cost Policy and the nature of that promise from the insurance company was
that no matter how much insurance someone purchased from the insurance company the insurance
company's responsibility was the same. They have to rebuild that home to pre-loss condition and at
that time we used to get sued for what was called over insurance where people would allege that
insurance companies were forcing them to buy too much insurance because they knew even if they
bought less amount of insurance the insurance company still had to repay their home. And so
after the Oakland Hills fire when we had these Guaranteed Replacement Cost Policies in the
marketplace we had our first elected insurance commissioner elected in 1990 and it was the first
time we had an elected insurance commissioner just really beat up the insurance companies to pay well
beyond what they thought was the amount they should have to pay and they did. They paid several hundred
million dollars more to rebuild those homes than they thought their contracts required. Now that
made a lot of people happy whose homes were rebuilt but there's a consequence to that and the market
moved away from what was called Guaranteed Replacement Cost and the nature of the insurance
contract completely changed. It changed to what's called a Limited Replacement Cost Policy where
people buy a certain amount of insurance and you know in advance what's the maximum amount an
insurance company will pay. So it's no longer guaranteed to put your home in a pre-loss condition
it's you buy a certain amount of insurance. And so that change to a Limited Replacement Cost Policy
really was a reaction to the way the state had handled the aftermath of the Oakland Hills fires.
So then what's the nature of the promise when there's a Limited Replacement Cost Policy?
It's that an insurance company will rebuild your home up to a dollar maximum and so then how do you
figure out what that dollar maximum will be. And under California law the one person that has a
choice of how much the insurance policy will be worth is the customer. The insurance company
doesn't choose that amount the customer chooses the amount of insurance. And so what does that
process look like? So typically someone who's shopping they have to be aware of what construction
costs are like in their area. Is it going to cost $300 a square foot to rebuild your home after a
fire? $400? $500? What's the right number? Well again California law says the insurance company controls
all aspects of the drafting of a contract except one thing and that's how much. How much insurance
is involved and that's the customer's choice. And so an insurance agent sitting at a table wants to
be helpful and what's the way that transaction goes? They might say well how much do you want
to buy? And a lot of people might not have any idea what it costs to rebuild a home.
Because it's not really the cost of the land or the value of the house. It's not the market value,
it's not the cost of the land, it's what would it cost to have someone come onto your property
and rebuild that home after you lose it. And typically a lot of people will say I don't know
how much should I buy? And the agent will say well that's your choice. We do have access to estimator
tools that can show you what houses in this area typically cost to rebuild. Given is it all custom?
Is it tracked? Does it have granite? Does it have linoleum? You know they go through and these
tools that you can use will give you a replacement cost estimate and insurers are permitted under
California law to say well we subscribe to this service and here's what their data suggests but
use that as a starting point in making your decision. And then people have to make that
choice. And so you can imagine at the time of sale people probably want to pay as little as possible.
But then their house is burned down and they want the biggest possible claim check that you can get
because what happens after a mass fire, if it's not a one-off home kitchen fire let's say, if it's a
mass event where a thousand or two thousand homes are burned there's just not enough contractors to
go around and so prices go a lot higher. And there are features in insurance policies called extended
replacement costs that will give an extra percentage beyond the amount of insurance you've
purchased if it's a mass disaster. And that feature is designed to help deal with demand surge.
But there still are circumstances where you have unbelievable prices. Like look at what's
going on in Los Angeles right now. The prices between Altadena and the Palisades will probably
be different for what it takes to rebuild a home but we're hearing of bids of a thousand dollars
a square foot to rebuild a home in the Palisades. Well what person would have bought a thousand
dollars a square foot amount of insurance? So for a thousand square foot home you have to buy
a million dollars of insurance coverage? Who would have done that in advance, right? And so it's a
hard issue because we do sell limited replacement cost policies for a reason, because of what has
happened in the past. And so it's just critical for people when they're making this important
decision about their most, you know, probably valuable asset that they hold, take seriously the
decision you make up front about how much money do you want available when disaster strikes. On the
fires we also heard from some that it's confusion about the smoke damage. You know, some people
are not getting as much as they thought they would get from smoke damage. And what are your
thoughts on that? It's a tough issue. So the standard form fire policy, so California law,
says what exactly must be included in every fire insurance policy sold. And one of the things the
fire insurance policy must cover is smoke damage. Now the law doesn't say exactly what that means,
it just says, hey insurance companies, you have to cover smoke damage. And that's in every policy.
And so, you know, imagine a big fire like we just had this year, and there's a lot of wind we know
because it was heavy, windy conditions, and now you've got smoke and ash that can travel a
significant distance because the wind is so heavy. And so you could have homes that are 5, 10, 15
miles away that are nonetheless inundated with ash, and smoke goes through the home, and it's
clearly a problem that the insurance company should adjust and pay. Now not every smoke claim
is created equal. You know, there are some smoke claims where it's obvious this is a home that
wasn't burned down, but it's very near where the fire was. There's ash everywhere. Every nook and
cranny of the home has smoke damage ash. And in that case, it's a pretty easy call for the
insurance company. You really need to clean that place up. At the other end of the spectrum,
we have examples where people might be 25 miles away, and the wind wasn't even blowing towards
their house on the day of the fire. And they don't make a claim until just before the deadline
to make claims. And in fact, a bunch of people make the claim at the same time because there's
lawyers or public adjusters who send a postcard out saying, hey, don't miss your chance to
file for a smoke claim due to that fire a long time ago. Now's your chance. And then companies
will get a whole bunch of claims from the same area all at once, very late in the game, very
far away. That's a less likely to pay type of claim versus the one where they make a claim
immediately. It's very near the fire, and it's no doubt. Those are the two ends of the spectrum.
And so obviously, most of the cases are in the middle. But each one of these situations is very
different for companies to figure out how should they react. Now, a lot of people, it'd be easy
for them to say, just pay the claims. Well, we can do that. But then you have to step back and
say, what is the system cost associated with that? What does it mean to pay the claim? Does it mean
you do a wipe down and a steam cleaning? Does it mean you have to take the wallpaper off and
put new wallpaper in, new living room set? Does it mean you need to completely change the HVAC
system so all the venting and tubes are different? What is the level of cleaning
is a hard decision that there's no law. There's no language in a policy that answers the question.
Most of the time, these smoke claims are settled because you have people of goodwill
who just want, you know, a policyholder wants a fair resolution and the company wants to make sure
that they're not spending too much on every claim such that their losses go way up and then they
have to go to the Department of Insurance and ask for a rate increase. And now, if we pay too much
on smoke claims, then the whole policyholder base is going to have to pay a lot more for insurance.
So there's a trade-off here. The more we press for smoke claims to be paid when they're questionable,
not the obvious case, those claims get paid. But the cases where they're questionable,
then we have system costs go up. What should be required to use some diagnostic tool that
analyzes the microbes, you know, down to the point where it's a $10,000 exam that you have to do and
now the cost of insurance claims go way up and we all pay more. Those are sort of the balancing items
that I think we all have to figure out as a society and certainly the insurance commissioner's
office is trying to figure out what's a fair resolution so people get value out of their
insurance policy. But we don't have claims costs that overcompensate in situations where you have
to do a bunch of cleaning or a bunch of replacement of property that's not really necessary and it
drives up the cost for everyone. Because there's no doubt the price of insurance is going up
and while California, relative to the rest of the country, is still not an expensive state,
the average premium in California is about 20th highest in the country. If you are in Texas or
Louisiana or Florida or even Colorado, it's significantly higher on average to buy homeowners
insurance there. But nonetheless, our prices have been going up over the last few years
just because the losses have been so big and companies have had to deal with inflation and
other things that drive up the costs. So while we're dealing with premium increases now, you have
an issue like smoke claims come up and there's a trade-off here. You want to make sure people can
live in their home and particularly if they've got some type of respiratory condition where they
really need additional resources to make sure that smoke is not going to harm them. But if we go too
far and make the cost over-expensive and we over-replace things that aren't really needed,
then all of our prices are going to go up. And so the Department of Insurance currently has a smoke
claims task force and it's got all parties represented and hopefully we can come up with
something that takes care of the people who need to be taken care of but do it in a way that doesn't
just lead to even more price increases on the average person. You mentioned that every time we
have these losses, prices would increase. How does it work? Doesn't these insurance companies make
profit and sometimes they take risk, right? Does it have to always turn into price increases?
Under the old system, it did. That's the way the regulations were drafted. That's what we objected
to and we've, gosh, we've asked for 10 years to update our system. But under the old system,
the way it worked is the price an insurance company could charge was based on, in part,
what their historical loss experience is. And so when you have a big event and you pay out a bunch
of money, then the way the department's rate formula works, you would have a higher indicated
rate and you would go to the department and you would get permission to charge more.
And we don't believe that is the sound way to at least look at catastrophic wildfire
because we had a system that said just take the average losses paid out over the last 20 years
and if they go up, then you get to charge more. If they go down, you have to charge less.
And insurers were keen to point out every other state has rejected that and California was the
last state to hold on to that method. And technology has increased and companies are,
they now have access to more complicated, catastrophic models that help them predict
in the long term what type of rate level that they need. And so finally, in the last year,
the state of California has allowed companies to use forward-looking models that look at where
the homes are that you're insuring, what's their building quality, what's the proximity to fuel,
what are the wind conditions there, and you can start to prepare better to take care of those
future losses. Now importantly, when you use those models, they're not based on historical
experience. So if you have a big loss, it doesn't change your rate need. It doesn't change what you
can show to the Department of Insurance that you need to charge. And so it gives stability. And so
in all likelihood, you're going to have some price increases to get up to where the rates need to be,
but then after a big fire, rates don't change. So those regulations are just done this year,
under Commissioner Lara's Sustainable Insurance Strategy, which is a really big reform. It was
the first modernization of insurance regulation in several decades. And so the Department of
Insurance took two years to draft extremely complicated regulations. And when I say
complicated, as someone who's had to read them all, very complicated. But it took two years to
and finalize those regulations. And I want to say at the end of July, they were available for
companies to finally be able to use. And so we now have five insurance companies that have made
commitments to right business in higher risk areas if they get to use these new tools,
both these forward-looking models, as well as use an approximation of their cost to pay for
reinsurance that they have to buy, which we can get into what that is. But importantly,
the state said, okay, insurance companies, we'll modernize the way that we allow rates to be made,
and we'll catch up, frankly, with the rest of the country, because we were the only state that did
it this way. But in exchange, you have to make sure you stay committed to high-risk areas.
It's a quid pro quo. You want access to modern rating tools, you have to right business in
high-risk areas. And so it's not as if our members love that. They believe they ought to be
able to price accordingly and not have to make those promises, but that's not what the state
offered. And so we now have five companies that have taken the state up on that. The first company
was Mercury Insurance, and other companies you may know, USAA, and other companies have now filed
under these new rules. So the Department of Insurance is starting to review those filings,
and hopefully they get done. And the faster they get done, it'll give the market more confidence
that the Department of Insurance is serious about this new system. And then if you make a filing,
you'll be able to get a faster approval, because those approvals can drag on. They can be six
months up to a year or even more. And so it's hard if you have to wait a year to change your prices.
And so my hope is that the Department of Insurance will be able to conclude these
filings quickly and show the marketplace that they're serious about this new system,
and they're serious about setting the conditions so that companies can return to this market,
because right now we have unavailability that's unacceptable, and too many people are going into
the market of last resort, the Fair Plan. Is the insurance industry back, and is it
recovering? Can we say the crisis is over? I don't think we can say the crisis is over, but
I would push back a little bit and say it's not that the insurance company's back. The insurance
company, other than two companies, never left. Every insurance company in the marketplace, except
two, have remained this whole time, but they've restricted where they can do business. So none of
them left, but certainly some of them started doing business in lower volume in high-risk
communities around the state, and it was really a dispute about what's a proper price they're
permitted to charge under our rate laws versus where can they do business. If you have a high-risk
clientele, but you have a rate level that's not going to support the claims that come out of those
areas, you're going to go bankrupt. Were they losing money? In a sense, you came on and you
shared some information with us. Things changed starting in 2017. We had both northern and
southern California fires that were devastating, and then in 2018 we had a repeat, both northern
and southern California, and 24 years of underwriting profit was gone in two fire seasons.
And so after the first year, after 2017, there was not a huge market change. That's the nature of
the insurance business, particularly when you write catastrophic wildfire. You know there's going to
be many years of no fires, and you're going to be profitable, but you're really like a squirrel,
putting away nuts, waiting for the tough times. And that's the nature of doing what's called low
frequency, high severity insurance. That's what catastrophic wildfire is. You collect money for a
long time, and then you pay out a whole bunch of money infrequently, but you have to collect money
during those good years in order to be ready for the bad. So after 2017, I think most insurers just
looked at it like, wow, that was a terrible fire year. And they knew because both the northern and
southern California fires were caused by utility infrastructure, that after they paid the claims,
they would get some of the money back from utilities. They never, insurers never get 100%
back from the utilities after a big utility fire, but they might get 40 to 60% back. And so they
looked at that and said, wow, this was big. It cost a lot of money. We're going to get some of it back
over the years, you know, because it takes time to get paid back by those utilities. And then they
just moved on. But then when it happened again in 2018, and they were utility related, that did
change the market. I think at that point, insurance companies looked at, well, our rates are pretty low
because they had been held down by the previous insurance commissioner, Dave Jones, for his whole
eight years as commissioner. And so you had rates that were relatively low. Then you had two years
in a row of these utility fires. And I think companies started to wonder, is this sustainable?
Can we get under California's rate rules? Can we get enough rate approved? And what's going to
happen if these fires keep happening every year? And are utilities going to be able to get their
infrastructure under control? And you see in really May of 2019 is if you dig into the data,
you can see that was the first month where the fare plan started to grow 4% in a single month,
May 2019. And I think that's when companies started to really doubt, do I understand what's
going on in California? Is this a viable marketplace? Can I get adequate rate? How
are we going to deal with these utility fires? And you started to see companies pull back.
Now, two companies left, one only really catered to high net worth clients. So their population
was very small. And the other was just a small company. But other than that, every single
insurance company has stayed. But it took a little while for the slowdown in the market to
really get the attention of policymakers. Initially, it was just a lot of people in rural areas,
California being a blue state, a lot of the problems were in red counties. So that got a
little bit less attention in the legislature as well. And it wasn't really until I would say,
I guess it was the spring of 2023, when State Farm finally announced that they were going to
stop writing new business. That's when policy... Completely, like they want to...
Yeah, they would keep their customers. And they're such a big company, they write 20%
of the premium volume. So it's a big deal if the biggest market player can no longer take new
business. So they stopped taking new business. Now, they kept the vast majority of their
customers, but they stopped writing new business. And then the next week, there was a San Francisco
Chronicle article talking about, well, all states done the same. The largest publicly traded
property casualty company in the country. A week later, you have news, not just that it's State
Farm, but it's all state. And after that, I think legislators really started to pay attention.
Governor's office really started to realize, wow, we have a problem here. We can't have these big
national names that everybody knows not writing new business because who's going to pick up the
slack. And so the second largest company, Farmers, was just inundated with applications the month
after State Farm's announcement. And so they eventually had to put a cap on how many new
policies they can accept. Because as you take more business in, you have to have more capital
to support that growing business. And where do you get that money? You have to buy basically
insurance from another insurance company that's got a reinsurer in order to shore up your finances.
And that is expensive to do. It can be expensive. And so Farmers had to then put a cap on its new
policies to 7,000 policies a month. And who else is going to take that after State Farm at 21 percent
and Farmers at 15 percent? The next largest company is 7 or 8 percent of the market. So once
that dynamic started to happen, you started to see massive fair plan growth. And you don't want
massive fair plan growth. You're going to pay more and you're going to get less. And the fair plan,
for your viewers that may not know what it is, it's the market of last resort. But it doesn't
have a huge amount of regulated capital that the Department of Insurance monitors and says,
oh you need more capital. It has the money it has. And the way the fair plan is designed, it's not a
state program. It's a private association that every insurance company has to join as a condition
of doing business in California. Statute says it's a private non-voluntary association of insurance
companies. And so every company doing business here must be part of the fair plan. If the fair
plan runs out of money, there's no state bailout. The insurance companies have to take money out of
their coffers and give it to the fair plan. So the more the fair plan grows, the less it's able to
deal with a massive fire, then the more likely the fair plan is to run out of money and turn
around to the insurance companies and say, hey you need to give us money. And then the insurance
companies turn around to their customers and say we need to recoup this money or else if we keep
getting fair plans assessments it's going to bankrupt us. And so pretty soon we have a system
where you have an underfunded fair plan with too many policies and insurance companies recovering
that money from their customers and you have low and medium risk customers starting to subsidize
fair plan business. And that's not viable. So the people have less risk they have to pay for.
They'll get surcharges on their insurance policies, absolutely. And this has happened already, right?
It happened with the L.A. fires. The fair plan, they assessed the insurance industry $1 billion
after the January L.A. fires. And so under the law, the insurance companies, they have to just
pay out of their own finances half of that. So the insurance companies had to eat $500 million
of loss out of their surplus, which makes them less strong. But they're permitted under the law
to turn around and take that other $500 million of the fair plan assessment and add that to their
policy statements and collect it from their customers. And that happened last year, this year.
That happened this year. Is the fair plan still growing? Fair plan, last statistics I saw, it's
22,000 policies a month, you know. The historical resting point of the fair plan, it was created in
1968, the historical resting point is about 120,000 policies statewide. That's where it's
120,000, 125,000. These are the riskiest things that nobody want to insure, right? Yeah. In the
late 60s, when the legislature created the fair plan, it was really a Southern California brush
facility. So think Topanga Canyon, Malibu Canyon in Los Angeles, where there's no access by fire
trucks and you've got all this dry bush and you get the Santa Ana winds rolling in there and you
have massive fires, that's what the fair plan was designed for. And really it was Ventura,
San Bernardino, Orange, San Diego, LA counties. That was the dominant policyholder base of the
fair plan. Well, that started to change in May of 2019. You started seeing fair plan growth
in the Sierra Nevadas, in big Alpine territories. So now it was no longer a sagebrush,
oily kind of creosote bush facility that the fair plan was looking at. You have a bunch of
giant trees and you have a fire like in paradise that is the most horrifying thing you can imagine
with fire that is unbelievably powerful and tall and can consume a community. Totally different
kind of business. So the fair plan has been growing wildly in the mountains and really
its policyholder base has changed quite a bit. But importantly, for a facility that was 125,000
policies statewide, it's now over 600,000 policies and growing at over 20,000 policies a month.
So it's still growing very fast. It's still growing very fast.
Meaning people are still losing their insurance, essentially.
Yeah. The last two years, the growth has been in low and moderate hazard areas.
So most of the high risk areas, probably those customers are already in the fair plan.
And as the market has continued to have dysfunction, you start having people who
really shouldn't be in the fair plan. They never were. They shouldn't be. But for a variety of
reasons, insurance companies haven't been able to serve all of those customers and their only option
if they want to buy a new home, close an escrow is to go to the fair plan. And it's an unsustainable
growth that we have to stop. Now, under the commissioner's new regulations, we're happy to
see five companies have made filings where they're going to write in higher risk areas and they're
going to be willing to grow. And the hope is that, again, if those filings are approved quickly and
you can give confidence to the market, other companies will come into the market and say,
it's time to grow again. We have to have that growth or else we're not going to start slowing
down the fair plan policy count. Now we go to Robert Anderson, who's an expert witness for
court cases on insurance on both sides, whether on the insurance company side and on the client
side. He's going to give us some expertise inside this industry. We have been hearing from some of
the fire victims that they're getting 20 percent less than the value of their homes from insurance
companies. Absolutely. And 20 percent may be a good deal. Okay. Lots of people get a lot less
than that. There's a real problem when you have a major disaster like the Palisades fire and the
Eaton fires in Los Angeles. All of a sudden, everybody needs somebody to build a house and
there's only so many contractors out there and they scramble to be able to get them. So
prices go way up, typically sometimes 20 to 40 percent. Building codes get changed quite
frequently. I know there are a lot of places in California right now where maybe even have,
depending on the area, even have sprinklers in your house or you have to have special kinds of
roofs or you've got to do all kinds of things. So when you go through a period of time and a lot of
houses have been around for a long time, those codes keep changing. And so when you're building
the house over again, if you had a total loss and you had to build it over again, you've got
a problem there because the codes have been going up, up, up, and up. So the house you've got to
build to replace it is a house that's much different than the house you had originally
because of all the code upgrades. The regular policy gives you like 5 or 10 percent of the
value of the house for that. But I've seen many, many times when that value is 30 or 40 percent
more because of the codes and nobody really ever talks about that. And as a broker and so forth,
they just sort of forget that. But you look, you know, we had several fires in Santa Rosa right
now. I looked at the, you know, the various code upgrades. I could actually go on to the various
cities in Santa Rosa. I mean, in the thing and actually see what the code upgrades were and how
you know, over 25 or 30 years, it could be 30 or 40 percent more expensive house because
to rebuild the same thing, you have to go through a new code. And how does that work in a policy?
Because people get insurance, they assume that they're going to get what they have.
Well, let's be written, it would be like 5 or 10 percent would be code upgrades. Okay. So
one of the things that I do is in testifying against insurance brokers, if I'm in that
position or supporting them, and sometimes they're doing their job right. You have a situation where
you could buy some things very, very cheaply. Okay. As an example, code upgrades. Okay. I have
code upgrades on my house. I have like 40 percent more. It's the maximum I could buy.
Okay. So that means anything in our house has been there for quite a while. So I mean,
anything that's been changed and so forth that costs me to build something new, I could have
bought that, you know, it's like $300 or something. You can buy it as a part of your policy. Yeah,
okay. Then the second thing is every policy has the ability to have what they call
the extended replacement costs, which gives you more money to pick up the increased value of your
house. But, you know, it can be minimally 10 percent, but you can buy 20 percent, 30 percent,
40 percent, 50 percent more for peanuts. You know, so in my particular case, I've got a 50 percent
more than the house actually sort of presumably will be worth for this extra cost. And it costs
me like 100 bucks or something to get that on my policy. So there's lots of little tweaks in there
that don't get explained properly to the customer because, you know, the agent wants to make a sale
and, you know, he's competing with lots of other companies with big names and people just look at
figure that's the right number. And it's almost always low. It's very unusual that a house would
be insured for more than it would cost to build it. I mean, the amount of over-insurance is almost
none. Nobody's really telling you usually about all these little things you could do rather cheaply
to actually get the number boosted up for replacement costs without increasing your
premium. So if you move from $600,000 policy to a million dollar policy, whatever that percentage
is, that's what you would typically pay. But you can get it other ways, like I was talking about
with a code thing and with also with something called extended replacement costs. Instead of
paying that proportion on your premium, you know, for 100 bucks or something, you can get this and
people don't know about it. So even though they have insurance, it's not enough and it won't cover
them, but they could buy a little bit more. Yeah, for nothing. I mean, relative to the premium price.
Okay. What are your thoughts on the Fair Plan? The Fair Plan is a very stripped down policy. People
don't have any idea. You know, it basically covers fire insurance in California and, you know, all
the other things that might happen like vandalism or water damage or anything like that that you
typically get in a homeowner policy, you get fire insurance. And then the other problem is most
agents don't really know what is in a Fair Plan. So I'm a State Farm agent and I've all of a sudden
been told by State Farm, you know, policy is coming up November 1st. We're not renewing that policy.
So that agent who's never dealt with a Fair Plan before gets another policy for the same amount of
money for the building, but doesn't realize, oh, there's no contents coverage, there's no vandalism
coverage, there's no water damage coverage, and there's a big long list of things that it doesn't
cover. A lot of people that got a Fair Plan policy just got the bare minimum and all the other things
that would be covered in their policy, they might not have gotten replaced. So there's a lot of
confusion over that aspect as well. Now, the X factor is that when one-fifth of the market is in
trouble, that makes a solution hard to come by. And so State Farm has been involved in a protracted
rate application with the Department of Insurance and an outside lawyer group has gotten involved
and they slow things down. And so unless State Farm is going to be part of the solution,
how do we have a market-wide comeback when a fifth of the marketplace is in trouble?
Right. So we have to get State Farm through their rate filing, get them to a rate level where they
can start to stabilize their finances and get to the point where they can start writing new business
again. And then hopefully between State Farm and farmers, if they can start to grow, there's
certainly pressure from the state on all state to start writing new business again because they've
had that moratorium. If you can start getting these big companies to start growing again,
then we can start to slow down the growth in the Fair Plan and eventually start to reverse it
so that all these people who shouldn't be in the Fair Plan, they can get out and they can be with
a company that they're comfortable with. But importantly, we can also then eliminate the
dynamic of the Fair Plan running out of money when there's a big fire and then a bunch of low
and moderate risk customers are forced to pay more on their bills because that subsidy is just,
that's not a way that I think society will accept that indefinitely. Before we move on with the rest
of this interview, let's take a look at some key headlines in California's section of Epoch Times
newspaper this week. Governor Newsom admits that he's considering a 2028 presidential run.
Transportation Secretary is taking away $160 million over illegal truck drivers that are
getting licenses in California. As you recall, there's been two incidents of illegal truck
drivers having accidents causing deaths. There is a big battle between California and federal
government over this. California State Senator Scott Wiener is launching a campaign to unseat
Nancy Pelosi. Now, Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi had planned to run for 2026 election. When we reached
out to her for comments, her staff told us that she's focused on her role right now. There was a
council member in Arcadia in Los Angeles County whose political consultant turned out to be a
CCP agent. When you look at a story like this, what's happening in Arcadia, that we have been
covering how the Chinese Communist Party has influence everywhere, not only in California,
across the nation and across the globe. These are the type of stories that you only get them from
the Epoch Times news page. We have a lot of insiders that give us information about what
the Chinese Communist Party is doing in California, in the U.S. and across the globe. And we have
brave reporters that are willing to put their lives on the line to tell the truth, even though
they have had death threats. Make sure to subscribe to our newspaper today. You can click on the link
below. It's only a dollar for first few weeks. And let us know what you think of the paper.
The companies, the insurance companies, keep asking for these increases, rate increases,
and sometimes they're in double digits. There's a lot. Californians haven't been used to paying
this much for insurance. How can people ensure that these rates are fair? California is one of
the handful of states that's called a prior approval state. In a lot of states, they're
so-called file-and-use states, where a company just tells the state, hey, we're going to increase
our rates. We're filing our plans with you. Just wanted you to know. And then they move on and
increase their rates. Well, California, we don't operate that way. In a prior approval system,
a company is not permitted to change its rates until it makes an application with the Department
of Insurance and gets an approval. And until then, you have to stay at the rate that you're
currently permitted to charge. And so the prior approval system is governed by a very complicated
set of regulations that I assure you your viewers could not make it through a page without falling
asleep. It's very complicated. Imagine every conceivable component of an insurance rate
has been reduced to dozens of pages of regulations. And so there's a pretty rigorous
rate approval process, where in the old days, when you would file paper applications, it'd be
thousands of pages. And you would file them in a filing office in LA or in San Francisco,
and they were giant. Now, at least it's an electronic portal where you can submit this.
But the justification behind each rate application is stunning. Certainly, if not the most rigorous
in the United States, in the top. So you have to explain why you're...
You have to explain what's your expense. You have to explain what's the commission you're
going to pay agents. What's your overhead? What's your advertising? Every single component.
What do you expect your claims to be? And that's where actuarial science comes in,
where you have to say, what's the frequency and severity of future claims?
If it's a highly inflationary environment, you're going to go to the department and say,
hey, we need higher rates because we're going to be paying more to repair automobiles. And
we're going to be paying more to rebuild homes. Or if the economy is really heating up,
more cars on the road leads to a higher frequency of crashes. So we're going to be paying more.
And so there's an actuarial debate about where your future trends are going to go. There's also
the question of, you have a bunch of claims now. Are they going to mature higher than they are,
lower? Are you going to be paying more for those existing claims? And so you also have to tell the
department about, we think our existing claims, by the time we finalize them, they're going to
really jump in value or not. And so you argue about that as well. And so honest people can
have differences of opinion when you're talking about actuarial judgment and what you think the
future will be. And as a result, you've got analysts and actuaries at the Department of
Insurance who would look at the same data as a company actuary and say, we don't agree. We don't
think that inflation is going to go up so much. So we're not going to let you charge more or as
much as you want. And so that process, even though the law says any rate approval not approved within
60 days shall be deemed approved, that's not the way the law actually works in practice.
On day 59, the Department of Insurance will tell an insurance company, we're not ready to approve
it in 60 days. And if you don't waive your right to that approval within 60 days, we're just going
to send you off to litigation and we're going to get an administrative law judge appointed and
we're going to litigate this matter. And that's going to be a year anyway. So every company as
a matter of course waives their right under the law to a 60-day approval. And so how long does it
take? Well, in a good circumstance, probably six months. There are of course terrible cases of two
or three years of a rate filing languishing. And it's hard to pinpoint the reason. The people at
the Department of Insurance, they have heavy workload and they're trying their best and
they feel like they've got this charge to protect people from higher rates. So you understand where
they're coming from. But there's a price to be paid for being over-aggressive in holding rates
down. Because then if it takes a long time, by the time a company gets maybe half of what it requested,
if that took a year, they're just going to turn around and file a rate filing again. And in the
meantime, they probably won't grow and they might even shrink. So there's a push and pull. So they're
not writing policies and then people have to go to FairPlan. Now is there a model where the profits
of these companies is calculated? Is there a cap on how much you can make? Oh yeah, there's a profit cap
in the regulations. And it varies depending on the then present value of different fixed income
instruments. It's a complicated formula, but there is a profit cap in the regulations. And importantly,
the way the law works is the higher investment income a company makes than the lower rates
they're permitted to charge. So if someone wants to say, oh, those insurance companies,
they're making all this money in the market, blah, blah, blah. They can say that, but then
they have to charge less. The regulators will come and see that income and say,
you have to give that money back. They can't say give it back, but they can say going forward,
you have to charge a lower rate. So the way the law works is it says no rate shall be inadequate,
excessive, or unfairly discriminatory. It says no rate shall be approved nor remain in effect.
And so the Department of Insurance at any time can come to a company and say, well, we've been
looking at your data the last couple of years and you've paid out very little and you've made a
whole bunch of money and they can order you into a process where they order your rates down. And
that does happen. I know it's easy to be angry at big premium increases that you might have to pay
to an insurance company, but it's the most rigorous system really in the country.
And the Department of Insurance at any time can challenge a rate that's in effect and outside
groups can. They can petition the Department of Insurance saying company X, they should be
charging less. And the department has to look at that. And so it's a robust price control system
that's really unlike any other state. And it takes a really long time to get through the process.
Rex Frazier, California insurance expert. It was great to have you.
Thanks for having me back. I appreciate it.
We hope that this damages will go away and this is the last time we're facing something like this.
Well, I hope next time we meet, my report will be a little rosier.
Let us know what you think about the insurance situation in California. You can email us at
siamak.californiansider.com or comment. We read all of your emails and comments.
I'm Siamak Khorrami. This is California Insider. We'll see you next time.
