#finance #financial Intel used to be the most dominant chip maker in the world having conquered the world of PCs thanks to their deal with Windows computer makers. But this deal actually turned out to be their worst nightmare as it led to copious amounts of complacency. The effects of this complacency didn’t show up for decades to come, but in retrospect, it’s extremely obvious. First, Intel missed out on the mobile revolution, having underestimated the adoption of smartphones. Then, Intel started losing CPU market share to AMD after the impressive launch of Ryzen. They bled market share for a couple of years before they completely dropped the ball with GPUs. In a last-ditch effort, Intel decided to bet an extraordinary $100 billion on their in-house foundry business, but this too has fallen flat on its face. This video explains the slow and painful downfall of Intel and how complacency slowly eats away at any company.
March 23rd, 2021. Intel's new CEO, Pat Jelsinger, stands in his studio. The camera crew bustles
around him as he prepares to address the company and share his strategy. A plan to save Intel.
The tech giant had once ruled industry, yet recently, they had been beaten down time and
time again. Morale within the company was at rock bottom and investors were losing patience
as the stock had been going sideways for over 20 years.
Intel needed a savior and the board believed they'd found one. The cameras began rolling
and everyone watches eagerly. The new CEO unveils his strategy. Great companies are able to come
back from periods of challenge and come back stronger and more capable than ever.
IDM 2.0 is an elegant strategy that only Intel can deliver and it's a winning formula.
This was Intel's moment. Employees, investors, and the board had total faith in Jelsinger.
They were going to take back the industry and rise to the top once again, yet that's not how
it played out. Less than four years later, Intel is in flames. Jelsinger's perfect strategy has
backfired, costs are being cut, the stock price is plummeting, and Jelsinger has been forced out.
This is the story of how Intel destroyed itself.
First, we need some context. Intel has been falling behind their competitors for decades,
despite creating the world's first commercial microprocessor chip, the Intel 4004, along with a
long, long list of breakthroughs. They completely ignored the boom of smartphones and even when
Steve Jobs offered them the chance to make chips for the iPhone, they declined. According to them,
the margins were too small. But that's not all. They also totally underestimated GPUs,
thinking they were a niche product for gaming and instead focused on CPUs.
Needless to say, with crypto mining and especially AI, they were very, very wrong.
They also completely underestimated AMD's comeback with Ryzen. So why the lack of foresight?
Well, Intel slowly became complacent. They were such an integral part of PCs with their deal with
Microsoft Windows, aka Wintel. They made billions from this, but this also made them blindsided when
PC sales began to slow in the 2010s. To call Intel a slow mover would be an understatement.
They needed a radical change. They needed a bold new strategy. They needed Patrick Jelsinger.
In early 2021, the board appointed Jelsinger as CEO, and there was reason to be confident.
Many giant companies fall into the trap of appointing someone with accounting or general
business experience into the role of CEO. Intel themselves had done this for most of the 2000s,
but Jelsinger was different. He had been an engineer at Intel for 30 years and even led
VMware as CEO. He was the lead architect on the 486, Intel's first x86 chip, which is still a huge
part of computers today. It wasn't just the board either. Intel staff was ecstatic. Even those
inevitably laid off by Jelsinger believed he was the right person for the job. So what was his plan?
As he addressed the company, he laid out his vision to put Intel back on top.
We are setting a course for a new era of innovation and product leadership at Intel.
We will use IDM 2.0 to design the best products and manufacture them in the best way possible
for every category we compete in. But what even was IDM 2.0 and how is it going to save Intel?
Well, Jelsinger was betting big on something called foundries. These are massive manufacturing
plants where microchips are manufactured. Chipmakers like Nvidia and AMD design their
own microchips, but they outsource their production. Intel, however, designs and
produces their own chips, and now they are going to massively expand this production.
Why? Well, when you look at the benefits, it makes a lot of sense. With Intel falling behind,
they needed a huge way to catch up, specifically to TSMC. TSMC is a gigantic chip producer based
in Taiwan, which holds over 50% of the global foundry market. In fact, they just recently
crossed a $1 trillion market cap. But TSMC was unique. They didn't design their own chips.
They only produced chips for others like Nvidia or Apple. There are very few options for foundries,
and pretty much everyone relies on TSMC in some capacity. They made the most advanced chips,
yet Intel, who only made their own chips, were falling far behind. Intel needed to catch up.
They already had their own foundries, which exclusively produced their own chips,
but with this investment, they were going to produce chips for everyone else as well. External
customers meant more money. Jellisinger said, IDM 2.0 is an elegant strategy that only Intel can
deliver, and it's a winning formula. Intel was in a unique position, being the only chip manufacturer
in the United States. And the US government saw this as the way to defend American chip superiority.
The Senate is now on the verge of passing a major bill to produce the production of crucial
microchips right here in America, so that the US doesn't need to buy them from Asia,
specifically Taiwan. With the chip sack soon passed, Intel alone would have access to billions
in funding and subsidies. The stars were aligning, and Jellisinger was optimistic.
Intel has its best days in front of us, he said. Yet, it wasn't a small bet. Intel needed to invest
over $20 billion to enact IDM 2.0, and there'd be many more costs after that, adding up to a total
of $100 billion. But this could put them back in the game. Intel had become too reliant on
consumer desktop CPUs, leaving its revenue tied to market conditions. Even a small ripple in
demand could cascade into a tidal wave, shaking the entire company. They needed to diversify.
IDM 2.0 was Intel's lifeboat. Investors were confident, and after Jellisinger took the reins,
Intel's share price jumped to $64, the highest in two decades. Everything was going great.
Intel was set up to take on the world. Yet, before things even began, the cracks began to show.
The plan was excellent, but Intel still had a massive problem. One of the most important
factors of a semiconductor is its process size. The smaller the process, the more transistors
can fit on a microchip. More transistors means faster speed and less power used.
In the 2010s, Intel announced a massive breakthrough. Their chips were going to have
10nm process nodes, and they were going to be ready in 2016. Extremely impressive,
but there was a problem. A few years went by, and the semiconductors were nowhere to be seen.
There was delay after delay. Despite Intel's aggressive plans, they hadn't laid the groundwork
and were trying to shrink the semiconductors with the same old technology. Their revolutionary 10nm
would eventually be pushed back to 2019. This would have been impressive in 2016, but keep in
mind, Intel isn't the only one making semiconductors. By 2019, this breakthrough was already out of date,
but it gets even worse. Heaps of the chips they were producing at 10nm were defective,
so they had to push back their next innovation, 7nm chips from 2021 to 2023 or even later.
But why couldn't Intel keep up? What was causing all these delays?
While other foundries had adopted a new technology, extreme ultraviolet lithography or EUV,
Intel however had tried to innovate without it. They were extremely aggressive and optimistic,
yet hadn't laid the foundation to support this leap forward. In 2021, as Intel began IDM 2.0
and building the new foundries, they were still simultaneously fixing their massive failure,
still trying to deliver these 10nm and 7nm semiconductors. Things get even worse however
when we look at TSMC. Since they were producing semiconductors for all kinds of clients,
they were far more experienced than Intel, who only manufactured their own chips. Not only that,
TSMC had adopted EUV technology early along with Samsung, and by this point, TSMC was producing
chips with 7nm, 5nm and even 3nm processes. As Intel built its foundries spending
$20 billion, they were eager to capture some of TSMC's market share. But they began to notice
something. Despite all the hype and excitement, the demand wasn't nearly as high as they thought.
In fact, they were struggling to capture new customers. But the explanation is pretty simple.
Intel was falling further behind and it was apparent to everyone. Other tech giants just
didn't trust them, especially compared to TSMC. Intel was aggressive, but they got too far ahead
of themselves. Now, they were playing catch up and it was impacting their new IDM strategy.
At a time when manufacturing was getting harder and harder,
we set a more and more aggressive goal said Intel's past CEO, Robert Swan. We prioritized
performance at a time when predictability was really important. Intel's new investment was
off to a troubling start, but things were about to get much worse.
Intel differed significantly from TSMC in a very important area.
Though it was more than just their chips or manufacturing, it was something at the heart
of each company. TSMC spent a huge amount of time and effort with their customers.
They had a reputation for this, decades of it. TSMC's foundry was dedicated to external parties,
so keeping customer trust is their top priority. They even say so on their website. With Intel,
however, it's much more complicated. They struggled to build trust with other giants
like Apple or Nvidia. Part of it came from a conflict of interest. Intel manufactured chips,
but it also designed them. Naturally, they would prioritize their own chips over external partners,
who despite manufacturing for them were actually competitors. As such, companies like Nvidia
didn't exactly trust them, so getting their business was unbelievably difficult. Other
companies like Apple had abandoned Intel altogether in a dramatic fashion. The two
companies used to have a strong partnership, but in 2020, Apple announced it would start using its
own custom silicon for its Mac products. Apple silicon will make the Mac stronger and more
capable than ever, said Tim Cook. Yet, behind the scenes, this was really a breakup. A former
Intel engineer revealed that the quality assurance of Skylake, one of Intel's general processors,
was more than a problem. It was abnormally bad. We were getting way too much sighting for little
things inside Skylake. Basically, our buddies at Apple became the number one filer of problems
in the architecture. And that went really, really bad. When your customer starts finding almost as
many bugs as you found yourself, you're not leading into the right place. Apple was becoming
more and more frustrated with missed deadlines and issues and decided enough was enough. I mean,
just think about it. Why wouldn't you use the company making better products with more
advanced technology with no conflict of interest with better customer service? At that point,
marginal price differences are irrelevant. The answer in this industry is not price,
but customer service. To make matters worse, the trend Intel banked on had played out its natural
and unfortunate course. The 2020 surge in semiconductors was slowing down and had now
hit a slump. What everyone wanted now was GPUs, not CPUs. So not only was Intel fighting to win
back customers, but the industry itself and the trend they banked on was failing them.
By this point, Intel had poured billions into foundries. They set out to build two in Arizona,
but also needed to invest to upgrade their existing plants. 3.5 billion in New Mexico,
3 billion in Oregon, 350 million in Costa Rica, 7 billion in Ireland, and over 10 billion in
Israel. It's estimated Intel had spent over 100 billion dollars in its new strategy,
a strategy that wasn't pulling in revenue nearly as fast as it hoped. There were some big contracts,
even from Nvidia, but by this point, it was years into the strategy. To solve this problem,
Intel had to take drastic action. In 2024, with a lack of customer trust and revenue,
they created an independent subsidiary for its foundry business. The idea was to completely
remove bias and conflict of interest from manufacturing. Then came the cost-cutting.
Intel announced 10 billion dollars in cost-cutting. 15% of staff would be removed,
15,000 jobs would be lost. Despite this move of good faith and a contractor-produced chips
for Amazon's AWS, it was too little, too late. By the end of 2024, their share price had fallen
to just over 20 dollars, the entire company had turned unprofitable, and staff morale had fallen
once again. Enough was enough. In December 2024, Intel announced the abrupt and sudden retirement
of Patrick Gelsinger. Most suspect however that the board had fired him. It was so sudden that
the board didn't even have a successor in mind yet, they just knew that it was time for Gelsinger
to go. And Gelsinger's troubles aren't over just yet. Intel is now suing him and seeking to reclaim
the 207 million dollars he earned as a salary. The claim is that he hid the mismanagement and
failure of his foundry strategy from investors, and it really seems like the foundry strategy
was doomed from the start. They had made mistakes prior and they were trying to spend their way out
of a core issue instead of tackling their foundation. In the early days of Gelsinger's
plan, critics believed that an 11th hour spending spree won't rectify its years of manufacturing
mistakes, and they were right. Intel may still be able to turn this strategy around,
but based on their track record and entrenched mindset, I'm not so optimistic. Another American
giant that has completely lost their way is AT&T. Check out this video to learn more, but until then,
I'm Hari, and I'll see you guys on the next one.