Unfortunately, the S&P 500 Just Changed Forever

Financial Freedom
10 followers
#finance
#financement
CHAPTERS
0:00 The $100 look-through
1:19 How top-heavy is the S&P 500?
3:26 Why you own the same ten companies in every fund
4:14 What changed in June: SpaceX and the index rulebooks
6:58 The 1965 chart
9:12 What history says when the top ten stumble
11:22 Ten tickers, one trade: the AI spending cycle
14:39 The 5 minute X-Ray
15:41 Your three paths
17:20 The Coast FI stress test
18:16 Run it and tell me your number
AI Generated·May contain errors
The S&P 500 has changed and there is a simple way to make sure that you stay ahead of it.
No time waster. Let's get into it.
You put $100 into an S&P 500 index fund tonight.
About $38 of that $100 goes into 10 companies.
The other 490 companies split the remaining $62.
That is about 13 cents each.
So the average company in the top 10 gets roughly 30 times the money
of the average company in the rest of your fund.
And we buy that fund because we want diversification.
Now here is what happened this past June.
The company that decides what goes into that fund
was asked to change for the biggest IPO in history.
It said no.
Three other index providers, well, they said yes.
There is one chart from 1965 that completely changed how I think about all of this.
It's the reason I'm not panicking.
And it's also the reason I'm not fully relaxed.
And I'll show it to you about halfway through.
If you are new here, I went from $200,000 in debt and absolutely clueless
to becoming a self-made millionaire and leaving my job in my 40s.
And the S&P 500 is a large part of my portfolio.
Now here is why this matters to you.
The more of your money that sits in a few names, a few companies,
the more your plan depends on those companies.
At the end of 2025, the top 10 stocks made up about 40.7% of the S&P 500.
That was the highest in the modern record.
Today, it sits near 38%.
So if you hear somebody say that the market is more concentrated than ever,
right this very second, well, it's close.
But it peaked at the end of last year and has actually eased down a little bit
as we've been going through 2026.
But I still want you to see how unusual 38% actually is.
In 1999, at the top of the dot-com bubble,
10 stocks made up about a quarter of the index.
In 2014, it was 18%.
So now we're talking about one and a half to two times what it looked like
at moments people are still calling crazy.
And it shows up at the single stock level as well.
I mean, we're talking about NVIDIA, right?
NVIDIA alone is 7.48% of the S&P 500 as of the end of June.
General Electric, if you all remember that one,
I've talked about that one before on the channel.
The biggest company in the index in 2000 was 4.1%.
So no one stock today carries about 1.8 times what the poster child of that era did.
A little bit honest here.
Let me back up.
Concentration by itself doesn't tell you that the market is broken.
Those companies earn their size.
Morgan Stanley, in fact, found that the top 10 companies in the total U.S. market
were about 27% of the market value at the end of 2023,
but earned about 69% of the economic profit.
These companies were generating a large, disproportionate share of economic profit.
These companies are good.
So the question is what it means for you to own such a large slice of them
without ever deciding to.
Take that $100 example one step further,
because the S&P 500 fund is only one place that this shows up.
Think about a very normal person.
Not me.
I'm a weirdo.
They have an S&P 500 fund in a brokerage account,
a target date fund in the 401k,
and maybe QQQM or something like that, like a tech heavy fund,
because it worked so well.
Every one of those looks like a separate decision.
Every one of them is buying the same 10 companies.
Let's be honest.
That's called look through exposure.
You don't see it on your statement
because your statement shows fund names, not individual holdings.
And I'll show you how to see it at the very end.
But I promised you something changed back in June.
So let's talk about that.
Here's why this matters to you and to I.
The index you buy is really one company's opinion
about how that market is.
And that opinion just split three different ways.
So we're talking about SpaceX.
At the IPO price, that made it worth roughly $1.75 trillion.
One of the biggest companies in the country overnight.
And that set up a very interesting question
that nobody actually faced until that point.
Do the big index funds wait a year to buy it?
Like the old rule book tells them to?
Or do they change the rules?
S&P 500, the company behind the S&P 500 said,
no, we're not.
We're going to require 12 months of trading history
and positive profits.
And it said in writing that being big isn't good enough.
And that also is not a good enough reason to skip that rule.
Three other index providers went the other way and fast tracked it.
Some of you may know this.
NASDAQ 100 added it in July.
And the total market indexes added it in June.
So in plain English,
if you own a Vanguard total market fund like VTI,
you own SpaceX.
If you own a NASDAQ 100 fund like QQQ, you own SpaceX.
If you own an S&P 500 fund like VOO or SPY,
you don't, at least not yet.
But how much do you earn?
Some of you may love that idea.
Some of you might be like, I don't want SpaceX.
Well, it's a lot less than you might expect,
at least so far as of the recording of this video.
Only about 4% of SpaceX shares actually trade publicly.
So in the total market fund, it's under 0.2%.
Not much of anything, right?
In the NASDAQ 100, it started around 1.3%.
And the September rebalance on the 22nd, just recently,
jumped to 2.82%.
One company under 0.2% in one fund and nearly 3% in another.
This may change as we go along,
but it's worth knowing at least right now.
The earliest SpaceX can join the S&P 500,
well, that's June 2027,
and it has to be profitable to get in.
So reported figures right now show a loss of about 541 million last quarter.
That's the thing we got to watch.
And I'll come back to it in just a minute.
Both sides are real.
S&P's rule protects you from buying a brand new listing on day 15.
Fast entry means your fund doesn't miss a giant company.
And if the stock does great in that first year,
a fund that set out misses it.
Now, I'm not going to tell you who's right here.
That's not the point of today's video.
But what I'm going to tell you is this.
So here's the bigger question.
If 10 companies run this much of your fund,
what happens if those 10 companies stumble?
And that is where this chart from 1965 comes in.
S&P Dow Jones went back and looked at the top 10 stocks
in the S&P 500 in June of 1965.
Together, they were close to 40% of that index.
That's about where today's top 10 sits.
Then they followed those 10 companies
and everything they turned into through mergers
and spinoffs for the next 60 years.
By mid-2025, that group had gone from about 40% of the index to roughly 4%.
Three of them went bankrupt.
All 10 ended up as a much smaller slice of the index.
And the S&P 500 did great anyway.
Now, that is a key point that people
who clicked off of this video early are going to miss.
The 10 biggest companies in 1965 all lost ground.
The index kept compounding.
And the reason that the index kept doing what it always does,
it was replaced by the giants with the new, bigger companies.
Companies fall out.
New winners rise in.
And the fund automatically holds more of whoever won last.
I've talked about this before.
Remember how I did a post maybe,
for those of you who are on regular viewership
that come back to the channel, I appreciate you.
You're going to remember the story about Sears.
I found one.
There's still like one out of five in the entire world still operating.
And the thing with the Sears company is
it was one of the founding members of the S&P 500.
Now it's like all but bankrupt.
It's not even in the S&P 500 anymore.
So, I mean, that's a cool thing about saying,
well, instead of putting all my money into that company
and letting it go bankrupt, I put my money into the index.
And then it naturally cleanses out as companies falter,
just like what we just talked about.
And if you're new here,
let me know your favorite S&P 500 fund.
Drop it in the comments.
I look forward to seeing which one wins the comment debate.
But if you haven't started investing at all and you're like,
yeah, I don't have an S&P 500 fund.
Look, one of my favorite investing apps is Webull.
The reason I like it is it's flexible
and you can do recurrent investments.
And right now they're giving you up to $3,600
in bonus fractional shares when you get started
and deposit your first $100 to trade.
Well, this is going to sound like doom, okay?
But I promise you it's not going to be doom.
Stick with me here.
Here's why it matters to us.
If the top 10 companies as we know them today stumble,
what you own depends on how much you own of everything else.
So let's talk about March of 2000.
The S&P 500 fell about 49% over two and a half years.
And it took almost five years to get back to even on the price.
Now watch what happened to the same 500 companies
when you weight them equally.
In 2000s, a dollar in the S&P 500 turns into about 91 cents.
That's a lost decade.
A dollar in the equal weight version of the same index
turned into about $1.64.
Maybe I need to...
Oh, wait, before you go and sell your index fund
and try to hop into some equal weight thing,
here's the other side of it.
Because I promised you no doom here.
Right now, it sounds like a bunch of doom, doesn't it?
Well, in 2023, 2024 and 2025 combined,
the S&P 500 returned about 86%.
The equal weight version returned about 43%.
So opposite effect here.
If you moved to equal weight in 2023
because you were worried about concentration,
you left 43 points on the table.
The biggest companies were also delivering
the biggest earnings growth.
So you can argue that they're overweighted
and you can argue that they've earned it.
And the timing warning is the one that matters most to me.
After 2020, everybody said concentration was at a peak.
It was not.
They kept going for years.
Being right about the direction and wrong about the timing
has cost a lot of people a lot of money.
I can't say that enough.
That is truly a problem worth remembering.
And that is why I've spent so much time
looking at this stuff and also doing these videos
because there's so much hype
and there's so much doom out there
in the headlines, in the news articles,
in the other YouTube videos
that make people whiplash themselves
because they're like,
oh, well, if this piece of news says this,
maybe I need to sell out now and buy
or sell out and just sit on cash.
Meanwhile, you just missed like a rip up
and like that could be thousands of dollars
you left on the table,
which brings me to the part
that actually made me sit up a little bit
when I was looking at this
because there is a reason
that these 10 companies moved together.
If these were 10 unrelated businesses altogether,
owning a lot of them would be a lot safer.
Like, for example, let's say we have like a bank,
a grocery chain, let's say a railroad.
We're going to go old school here
and maybe a drug company.
All have different customers, right?
And all have different cycles
because they're not the same thing.
But look at what a lot of the top
of this index today has in common right now.
It's a spending cycle, is it not?
The four biggest cloud companies
are guiding to roughly $720 billion
to $745 billion of capital spending in 2026.
Amazon, about $220 billion.
Alphabet, which is Google, $195 to $205 billion.
Meta, $130 to $145 billion.
Microsoft, $175 billion.
And a lot of that lands as revenue for the chip,
memory and networking companies
that sit right below them on the list.
One company's spending is another company's sales.
Now, Goldman's chief equity strategist,
his name is Ben Snyder,
said that AI investment spending
is driving about half of the S&P 500 earnings growth, 50%.
Here's one example of how big the spending is.
The last 12 months,
Amazon brought in about $161 billion in operating cash flow
and spent about $169 billion on property and equipment.
That's a company spending everything that it's making,
and then some.
Everybody is focused on AI.
Some of you think I'm AI.
I promise you I'm not.
I am literally sitting here in my studio.
I am actual, right?
So when several of the biggest companies in your fund
are making the same exact bet,
and half, a dozen more depend on them making it,
the top of your index behaves less like the 10 separate stocks
and more like just one giant trade.
If the spending keeps going, everybody in the chain wins.
If any of the big buyers slow down,
it's going to ripple right down through the top.
And I can't tell you which one it's going to be.
I can't tell you where it's going to go.
And nobody can.
People might try to act like they know, but they do not.
It may absolutely pay off.
And it could be the biggest productivity story of our lifetimes.
On one hand, you have people saying that AI is going to destroy us all,
and it's going to be absolutely a mess.
And then you have government that could step in,
and maybe they start regulating it,
and it pulls down some of that stuff.
And then on the other hand,
you have like, it ended up being a fad,
fell apart, and guess what?
We're back into another lost decade
like we were back in 2000 with the big internet boom.
Remember the dot-com bust?
A lot of you may not
because I talked about this before too.
Under 35 years old,
you haven't been through a prolonged crash.
I'm talking about one that lasts multiple years,
takes five years to recover.
There's massive layoffs,
and everybody's like, oh my God, what is happening?
That hasn't happened since 2008.
Before that was 2000.
I mean, we're talking about one extreme of the next.
Biggest productivity boom?
Or hang on to your butts.
I call this my x-ray.
It's the five-minute check from the start of this video.
Step number one,
write down every fund that you own
across every account that you have,
whether it's your taxable account,
your 401k, IRA, HSA, whatever it is, look at it.
Include the target date funds.
Hopefully you already have this all
somewhere in a net worth tracker
that you can pull up and say,
okay, here are all of my accounts.
Let's look at the holdings.
Step two, look at each one of the top 10 holdings
of each fund that you own.
Every fund company publishes this for free
on their fund page.
If you like the idea that I point you to free stuff
and I don't try to hide things,
drop a like on the video.
Step three, add up how much of your total portfolio
is sitting in the same five or six names.
You might be surprised.
When I did this for my own accounts,
I found I had more of one name
than I'd ever chosen to hold,
and I never picked it.
It was just sitting inside of all my different ETFs.
At the time of my first X-ray,
NVIDIA was the main event.
Once you have your number,
you have three paths,
and each one has an actual trade-off,
and I can't tell you which one to do.
You've got to think about this yourself
and always consult a financial advisor if you need to.
Path one is to do nothing on purpose.
You can accept cap weighting
and you know what you own.
Like for example, I purposely have VTI,
and I know I have SpaceX and all that other stuff,
but I own the whole market.
And then on the flip side of that,
I have QQQ.
Now, why?
Because they're kind of overlapped a little bit, right?
Well, QQQ is my tech tilt.
I'm actually being bullish toward the future
and AI and all that kind of stuff, right?
Just a little bit, not massively,
just a little bit.
But I'm okay with that.
Given the 1965 chart,
that could be a completely reasonable choice.
The trade-off is that you accept concentration risk,
including the spending cycle that we just talked about.
And this is why I like to kind of remind myself
and reread the book,
The Simple Path to Wealth by J.L. Collins.
If you haven't read it
or you haven't listened to the audio book yet,
go grab it right now.
It's awesome.
It's linked in the description below.
Path two is to rebalance your risk.
That can mean equal weight like the RSP,
which costs about 0.20% a year
compared to about 0.03% for a fund like VOO or IVV
or something like that.
That's about 17 basis points more
and it comes with more trading inside the fund
and different tax treatment.
Or it can mean tilting toward a small cap value
or international or something like that.
Just know that roughly 40% of the companies
in the Russell 2000 earn no profit at all.
So be selective, not just cheap.
And remember 2023 to 2025,
when that tilt cost a lot.
Not something I'm doing,
but it may work for other people
based on their risk and what they're looking at.
Path number three is to stress test your plan
inside your own portfolio.
This is my favorite
and it's where the Coast 5 math comes in.
Take your portfolio.
Let's say it's $1 million.
See what happens over the last decade.
I mean, your $1 million,
if you contribute no more,
drops quite a bit.
But there's another point to this.
You hold on, maybe even keep on investing.
But even if you don't,
see how it like kind of recovers
and now you have like a lot more money.
So sometimes you just need to stress test
and treat this as a stress test
and skip the forecast reading.
It's a way of asking
if the next 10 years look like the worst 10 years,
does my plan still work?
Do I still feel comfortable with these numbers
if that happens to me?
That's what you got to figure out.
And you can get this also for free.
It's linked in the description.
Here's what I want you to do.
Run the x-ray on your own accounts
and then drop your number in the comments.
What percent of your portfolio
do you think is sitting in the top 10?
Guess first, check then,
and then tell me how far off you were.
Now your financial adventure is going to continue
by watching this video up here next.
Keep building your sharp money
and I'll see you on the next video.
