Hey everybody, Tom Bilyeu here. On today’s episode of Impact Theory, we’re tackling a question that’s got the entire financial world buzzing: Has the AI bubble already popped, or is the real reckoning still ahead? With eye-popping numbers pouring out about AI companies like Anthropic—think $518 billion in committed spending, staggering operating losses, and multi-trillion dollar valuations—it feels like we’re living through a modern-day dot-com boom, but on an even bigger, riskier scale.
We’ll dig deep into how historic debt-fueled exuberance might be repeating itself, why everyone from investors to regulators is struggling to see where all this capital is actually going, and what happens if the growth projections underpinning this AI revolution don’t pan out. I’ll be joined by Jeff Snider, who brings his no-nonsense, data-driven perspective to the table, and we’ll walk through not just the raw numbers but the mechanics, the political currents, and the tangled financial web connecting Wall Street, tech giants, and shadowy private credit deals.
We’re talking about the risk of cascading market failures, the role of regulatory capture, and whether the AI gold rush is setting us up for tragedy or transformation. Is this truly a once-in-a-civilization leap forward, or are we jogging straight into another era of economic pain? Grab your notebook—this one is essential listening for anyone who wants to understand the future of tech, finance, and society itself.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The video examines the AI industry's current trajectory, arguing that while the technology is transformative, the sector is characterized by a dangerous financial bubble. By comparing current trends to the dot-com crash and the 2008 crisis, the speaker warns that unsustainable debt, circular financing, and a massive gap between revenue and spending create a high risk of systemic collapse.
Let's ask one question.
Has the AI bubble popped?
Jeff, take it away.
This time is different, they said.
I can't believe they say that every time,
but this time is different.
This is not gonna be the dot-coms,
because the dot-coms, we had a bunch
of money-losing companies all over the marketplace,
and this time, we've got these massive businesses
that are entirely profitable.
It's not gonna be like the dot-coms.
Let me tell you why it's,
the idea that this time it's gonna be different
sticks around, because things change just enough
that it will be a slightly different flavor.
It's gonna come at you from a slightly different angle,
but the reason that that always ends up being a joke
is that there are physics to the economy.
They're very complicated.
It's very hard for us to track all of them,
because it interfaces with humans and how they feel
and how they act individually and as a collective,
and so it becomes a very complicated system,
but the reality is it is mechanistic.
This is the part that people lose sight of.
You lose sight of the mechanisms
of the economy at your peril.
This is why you can look at something
like the eternal accumulation of debt
and know that it's just gonna be a problem,
because you can not pay it back.
There's really only two ways to not pay it back.
You can just not pay it back, a hard default.
That's gonna break the system massively,
and then you've got a soft default, which is inflation.
They both have very knowable consequences
that you can strategically prepare for,
so anyway, understanding how we end up
with people just not being able to escape the temptation
of I can feel that something is different,
and so I can't just use the old playbook.
They're right about that.
The entire way that we invest is changing.
We're moving into a new regime, I think,
and so you do have to go, okay, there's something new here.
There's something different, but at the same time,
the fail states are mechanistic,
and so you gotta watch out for them.
Yeah, right.
Honestly, given what we know today,
I mean, we kinda had an idea,
but what we know now today,
I really hope that the AI bust happens sooner.
I mean, tomorrow.
I hope this thing starts tomorrow,
because the longer this goes,
the more devastating it's gonna get down the road.
This is the second person that we're now hearing say this.
Is Jeff the biggest voice in finance?
No, absolutely not.
He's definitely a niche guy, but he's pretty smart, man.
He understands the economy.
I've had him on the show.
I've watched a ton of his videos,
so this is not some crackpot
in some random corner of the internet.
This is somebody who's looking at the math,
and they're saying, uh-oh,
if you share his base assumptions,
I'm gonna challenge one or two of them as we go,
but if you share his base assumptions,
you can actually build the mental model
of why he is so worried about this.
AI is hoovering up all the capital in the world,
and it's subjecting itself to the mechanisms of debt.
And so, historically speaking,
people that take on this kind of debt,
which this really is unprecedented,
but people that take on an extraordinary amount of debt
for a revolutionary new technology,
meaning it's not been propagated through everything yet,
history is brutal.
And you're going to get hammered.
So what he's looking at is,
bro, if this just grows and grows and grows,
it's just going to get worse,
because, and this is where Michael Burry agrees with him,
the amount of capital from investors
that will get destroyed is biblical.
AI is gonna be a game-changing technology,
but the amount of money it's gonna take to get there
and the fact that not everybody's gonna win
and not all these numbers are gonna make sense
means that there's going to be a bust at some point,
and the longer this goes, the bigger it gets,
the more trouble there will be down the road.
I like that take, which is basically,
what we know about companies is they come and go.
And sure, there are going to be winners,
and those winners will probably last
for decades and decades,
but there are gonna be losers in this timeframe.
We've never not seen that.
And so, given how much capital is getting pulled in,
and we know that some are gonna go away,
some amount of this capital,
up to and including the vast majority of it,
remember dot-com bubble, we draw it down like 90%, yeesh.
So, you're guaranteed there's gonna be some amount of loss.
It's just a question of who exactly
is going to lose the money.
And so, given that we know it's going to happen,
the sooner the better.
That statement in isolation actually is true.
Well, Reuters reported last night that Anthropx,
one of the stars of the AI bubble,
its S1 was leaked to Reuters.
So, Reuters basically gave us some insight
into one of the biggest names in AI,
but previously we had no information.
I mean, these are private companies,
and then once they go public,
they undertake an IPO and raise money
through the public marketplace,
they gotta start reporting things,
and as they start reporting things,
they tend to leak out.
And so, that's where we are.
Anthropx S1 leaked through Reuters.
Reuters gave us a bunch of numbers that allow us to,
like I said, start to put some numbers
and start to put together a case
for where this AI thing is gonna go.
And look, the numbers are just absolutely staggering.
And like I said, I really hope the bust happens sooner
rather than later, because the longer this goes,
it just gets more and more insane all the time.
And this time is not different,
including the structure of the AI bubble.
And we'll get into all the details there,
but let's get into what Reuters reported,
what was it, late yesterday?
Just a whole bunch of, you know, just,
I mean, like I said, we kinda knew this was taking place.
We knew it wasn't gonna be pretty,
but if you see the number right there, 518 billion,
that was just-
518 billion, man, of dollars that are already promised.
And remember, they can't just back out of it.
No matter how bad the company does,
they're still going to have to pay that figure.
It's just insane amounts, half a trillion.
So Anthropx IPO prospectus, the S1,
surging costs and also huge losses.
What they, oh, let's start out from the beginning.
Revenue grew 12 fold to nearly 4.6 billion.
So that's pretty good.
That's last year, 4.6 billion.
All right, given the, like,
scale of the numbers that we're talking about,
4.6 billion probably doesn't sound like a lot,
but the reality is it is very impressive.
That's revenue, man.
And given where they were just a year before,
that is really a fast growth rate.
I've heard people say that it's truly unprecedented.
Even if it's not truly unprecedented,
they are in the absolute upper echelon,
and it may be the fastest that a company has grown.
It's very, very impressive.
When you start looking at, like,
maybe not by percentage, but by absolute dollars,
it's staggering.
12-fold increase, that fits with the description of AI.
However, their operating losses,
and this is just their operating losses, were 8 billion.
Okay, so this is where you have to understand
operating losses.
So we're going to talk about paper losses in a minute.
The paper losses can be big
without really being something
that you have to worry too much about.
This is going to be the one knock
that I'm going to really make against Jeff's analysis here,
and part of what should temper your thinking.
But operating losses is real talk.
So that's like, how much did you have to spend
on employees, on equipment, and things like that
in order to actually make that money?
And the answer is significantly more
than what they brought in.
So if you have to spend, whatever, 12 to make five,
I think it's a little bit different than that,
but that's directionally correct,
you have a bad business.
This is what's known as default debt.
So by default, the company is dead.
It is not yet profitable.
Certainly not of these numbers,
at the time of these numbers.
This is all 2025, remember that.
So we're deep into 2026.
We have a lot of unaudited financials,
but we don't have a full year of 2026.
But that's going to be a big part
of what should temper some of your fear.
So it took them nearly five billion in revenue,
but they had to spend 12 billion in expenses.
So 12 billion in expenses to create five billion in revenue,
and that wasn't even, that's just the start of it.
The real big one, as far as losses are concerned,
overall, when you factor in spending
and capital expenditures, $42 billion loss in 2025
on $4.6 billion in revenue.
And these aren't even the worst numbers out there,
the worst.
Okay, so now we've got to talk about this number,
because this is really where you have to start
digging deep and say, okay, for the narrative,
42 billion compared to 4.6, what a gap, this is so crazy.
But the reality is that a lot of that,
in fact, all of the 42 billion
is what's called a non-cash paper loss,
meaning this is not actually dollars and cents
that are leaving their bank account now.
This is about the fact that their shares
have gone up so much in value,
and a lot of the deals that they've done
basically put them on the hook
where they might end up having to buy those shares back.
And so now you're in a situation
where they may end up having to buy back shares
at a much, much, much, much, much higher valuation.
And so yes, technically, that money they're on the hook for,
but depending on what the deal is,
that could be years down the road,
and so it's not necessarily a today problem,
but they do have to market to market.
So that's where this starts to look
a little bit scary on paper.
But the real thing that you want to be thinking about
right now is just that, the 4.6 with an $8 billion loss.
That is real.
That's like your real cash deficit
that's leaving the business.
And so that is what we're gonna be benchmarking
against what's going on in 2026,
and I'll talk a little bit more about that in a minute.
Number is 518 billion that's already been committed,
committed as far as spending over the next couple of years.
That's not next year, it's not this year,
but it's over the next couple of years.
Half a trillion.
These people have 4.6 billion in revenue last year,
and they've already committed half a trillion dollars.
This is a big reminder
about what people actually think is going on in AI.
Listen, it's disruptive for all of us.
I think everybody is aware.
Nobody's like sleeping through AI,
but I don't think people understand
the size of the bet that we're making,
and you become numb to the numbers so quickly.
This is why earlier I was forgetting,
wait, was it less than 100 million or less than a billion?
It's like the difference between those two is massive,
but we're getting so used to hearing these huge numbers
thrown around, trillions of dollars.
Dude, these are massive amounts of money.
$518 billion have looming over your head
is absolutely insane, but what the market is saying is,
guys, this is a once-in-a-civilization moment
where we are transitioning away
from humans being the only source of intelligence,
so it takes 18 years and a whole lot of fingers crossed
to get something that is really smart,
and then you've gotta try to convince them
to come work at your company.
You've gotta convince them just to be in your country,
let alone work for your specific company.
Now we're going into an age where we can spin up
thousands, tens of thousands,
hundreds of thousands instantly, right?
There were tens of thousands of agents
that were self-replicating
in the whole Hugging Face disaster,
so we can spin intelligence up now so quickly,
and the only thing that's stopping us is compute,
and the only thing stopping compute
is our ability to bring on the data centers,
the energy, and then raise the capital for it.
So right now, from a liquidity,
a global liquidity perspective,
you've just got this big Hoover
that's like a black hole that is sucking up all the money,
and everybody's just ******* throwing their money at AI,
like, yes, please, God, let me invest more money,
borrow more money, let's go crazy,
and everybody is so convinced
that this transition is going to happen
on a reasonable timeline
that they are being really,
from where I'm sitting, reckless.
And so, yeah, don't lose sight
of what that $518 billion is really saying.
It's crazy.
So you can see why this is a debt story.
Now, Anthropic has already raised a pile of money
through equity markets.
I think it was 80-some billion to the last equity,
and that equity,
the last time they went into the equity market,
they were valued at around $950 billion,
almost a trillion, let's call it a trillion.
So they're a trillion-dollar valuation.
They're going to do another equity raise,
which is why we're talking about Anthropic right now,
the S-1,
which they're hoping to get a two-trillion market value,
a two-trillion market value
for a company that has five billion in revenue,
40 billion in losses,
and half a trillion in already committed spending.
You see what I'm saying here?
It's not that the AI bubble is...
Oh, and by the way,
we might lose control of civilization,
just to add that.
So don't forget, in their S-1, it says,
hey, as one of the risks that we have to disclose,
we could end humanity.
That ---- is crazy.
Priced to perfection.
It is priced to ultra-perfection.
There's absolutely nothing can go wrong.
And the more information we get,
the more you just have to shake your head.
Like I said,
hope the AI bust comes sooner rather than later.
Then we can clean out the bad stuff,
get the numbers back on track,
and get the economy on a road
where it can actually get to
where everybody's trying to take it with this AI stuff.
I get the sentiment,
but let's look at the last time that this played out.
If you go back and look at what happened
during the dot-com bust,
it ended up being 20 years of pain.
So be careful what you wish for.
Again, I understand the sentiment.
He believes it is going to happen,
and given that it is going to happen,
let's make it happen sooner rather than later.
But I think the reality is
that we need to be looking at some way
to slowly deflate the bubble
rather than just say,
all right, let's let this crash and burn,
or like Michael Burry said,
that let's hope that there is basically a cataclysm,
that the markets fail to launch these IPOs
so that we don't usher in Skynet,
and we don't destroy any more investor value
than we absolutely have to.
That is a very, very brutal scenario if those,
I mean, if we're talking about trillions of dollars lost,
holy bejesus, it will set back the economy
for a very long time.
Yeah, it's gonna be a game changer.
I keep saying that.
It's absolutely the case.
It's a long run, gonna be very productive, very positive.
However, getting there is going to be very messy,
and the more mess it's gonna get,
it's gonna get that way
because we didn't stop it soon enough.
The question is, what do you mean?
How are we going to stop it?
This is just individual investors deciding
that they are or are not going to invest.
This is individual banks deciding
they are or are not going to loan.
This is individual lenders deciding
that they are or are not going to pull their money
into some sort of private vehicle like a blue owl
so that these guys can keep getting access to the capital.
There's no way to stop this
other than to get people to look at the information,
but again, there is this, but I can see the opportunity.
I know where this could go.
This is gonna be a little bit different than last time,
and that's why I think getting the individuals
to stop before something happens is very, very low.
So let's dig a little bit further into what was reported.
You can see Reuters reporting on the losses.
It's not really the losses that we need to worry about.
Yes, they do.
They did have to put in there that, yes,
one of the risks of their technology
is that maybe it could end humanity.
That's a whole separate topic
that we don't need to get into here.
Suddenly, the scaremongering among AI.
I'm not saying that there aren't tremendous risks there,
but there's a political agenda behind all of that.
I think you do have to get into it.
The reason you have to get into it
is to understand the play that's being made right now.
There's gonna be a big political collision.
You've got, these two are avatars for a bigger movement,
but I'll just sum it up with,
we'll get right back to the show in a second,
but first, let's talk about what it means
to actually be visible in today's day and age.
When you build something public,
whether it's a business or an audience,
anything on social media, you become a target.
This is something that legitimately keeps me up at night
because our data isn't just on the obvious broker sites.
It's on old news portals, public forums,
obscure directories, places you would never think to look.
That's where Incogni's exposure scanner comes in.
It hunts down your personal information
across the wider web, not just the 420 plus broker sites
Incogni already removes your data from automatically.
They can't harm you if they can't find you.
Go to incogni.com slash impact
and use code impact for 60% off an annual plan.
Try it risk-free for 30 days.
That's incogni, I-N-C-O-G-N-I.com slash impact
and use code impact.
We'll be right back to the show in just a second,
but right now, let's talk about a problem
the military couldn't solve with willpower.
Picture a soldier making life or death decisions
after 36 hours without sleep.
This is high stress, there's obviously no margin for error.
The military needed their people thinking clearly,
even under conditions that would break most of us.
So they funded a $6 million Department of Defense
research contract to find the answer.
What they found was ketones,
the brain's most efficient fuel source.
That research became Ketone IQ.
Ketones cross the blood brain barrier
and fuel your neurons directly.
They enhance mitochondrial function
for longer mental stamina.
I take it for interviews, before writing,
before I do coaching, and I can feel the difference.
Visit ketone.com slash impact
for 30% off your subscription order
or find Ketone IQ at CVS stores nationwide
and get $5 off your first six pack for a limited time.
And now let's get back to the show.
Anthropic and OpenAI are playing a regulatory capture game
that is going to pit the Democrats against the Republicans.
And what you're gonna see both in the midterms
and in the lead up to the 2028 changeover
is you're going to see the Democrats say,
the Republicans are being reckless.
They're getting sucked into this money at all costs.
We're competing against China,
but it's really just about making them rich.
That's gonna be their narrative,
that we need control, we need an anti-state.
And that is very real for the industry.
If you're an investor and you're looking at AI
and you're thinking, okay, I've got choices.
I can invest broadly, I don't know who's gonna win,
or I can get very specific
and I can make an infrastructure play
or I can make a play on the specific companies.
And the question becomes, who's gonna win all of this?
Is it gonna be winner take all Anthropic and OpenAI
precisely because they're able
to get the Democrats reelected in 2028
and they start passing legislation
that gives them regulatory capture.
No other players are gonna be able
to make it into the space.
And now those guys are driving and in command
and they start capturing all the value.
Or is it gonna be, nope,
they're not able to convince voters.
Voters stick with the Republicans.
The Republicans in 2028 maintain power
and they keep running the playbook right now
of we wanna make sure that we're beating China.
We wanna make sure that we are capturing
all of the upside in the markets,
that we're getting AI in the hands of kids.
Remember, Trump accounts are a big part of this.
Absolutely brilliant move.
We wanna get everyday Americans.
We wanna get this technology in their hands
in the form of shares that they get simply for being born.
And now they get to go on this ride.
And so why would we ever want to diminish the US
in comparison to China by slowing down the innovation,
which is exactly what will happen
if the government steps in?
Why would we ever want to not have open source?
We wanna make sure that the cost of this is going down
so that Americans benefit from actually engaging
with the technology.
This really is one of the most consequential questions.
One of the, like it's happening in plain sight,
but because everybody's lying about what their motives are,
but it's very important what's happening
in this Doomer debate.
And even as an investor,
you're gonna be forced to make a decision
based on what you think is going to happen
because you're gonna,
the value is going to accrue in very different places
whether they get the regulatory capture or not.
And if they don't get regulatory capture
and you've got China continuing to run their playbook
of using these open weight models
to try to chip away at the way that they're driving revenue,
which by the way is already starting to work,
these guys are now shifting away
from just like token maxing as people were calling it
over to this API model.
And so we're already seeing the realities
of the business environment beginning to influence
the models that these guys are using
for how they're actually gonna generate revenue.
So all of these things are extremely consequential.
And if on the other hand,
you get the Republican stay in power
and open source remains a thing,
you're gonna get the cost or the benefit, excuse me,
accruing to the infrastructure layer
because the companies will sort of come and go.
You'll eventually get big guys end up staying
and just do something better than everybody else.
And then they'll have a lot of momentum
and scale on their side.
But it's a very consequential fork in the road
that none of us can see exactly which way we're gonna go.
But you're gonna have to, as an investor,
have some sort of strategy
that takes that into consideration.
But as far as the IPO goes,
they have to throw that in there
because the SEC makes them.
They have to talk about every material risk
that could potentially harm the stock,
therefore the public needs to be informed.
The Anthropx technology could end humanity as we know it,
at least throwing that in there just out of due caution.
But really-
It's not just due caution.
It's part of their strategy, power as proof of,
or danger, excuse me, as proof of power.
This time is never different.
You have a brand new technology
that requires a capital expenditure build-out,
a sustained CapEx boom,
or on the other side, sustained CapEx spending.
What a scale we've never seen before.
It's crazy. We know that.
So Anthropx gave us a half a trillion figure
just for this one company where they wanna go.
So we know that their spending
is gonna be absolutely ridiculous.
The reason why they continue to get money
and continue to get all this attention
and continue to get equity investors
salivating at the prospect of investing in their IPO
is that this is the other part of it.
Again, in every single technology bubble,
every single, it doesn't even have to be technology,
every asset bubble, you have this open-ended future
where spending is a little bit more predictable,
but revenue, we can extrapolate revenue to whatever we want.
And yes, all revenue extrapolations are parabolic.
And it's not without legitimate reasons for being parabolic
because the winners in these technology races
tend to see parabolic growth.
Yeah, but they do get a little ridiculous.
This is something where the historical trend is,
people put like, if I capture 5% of the market,
then it's gonna equal this.
And it basically never comes to fruition,
but it doesn't mean that they won't experience
absolutely mind-blowing growth.
And this is, when you look at 2026,
these guys are on a legitimate tear.
Now, we're gonna need those financials to be audited,
but I would imagine if they're off,
they're not off by a lot.
So they are growing very fast.
As we need to spend, spend, spend in the initial years,
and eventually the parabolic growth in revenue
will get to the point where it outpaces spending.
And therefore, as the parabolic revenue continues to rise
at an extreme rate, spending left behind,
suddenly this technology becomes ultra profitable.
They can pay back all of those old loans.
We can pay back our equity investors.
We're making enough money to make these extreme valuations
worth every penny that people are paying for them.
But in order to do that,
in order to have any prayer of those two curves crossing
or those two lines crossing,
they have to invest a ton, a ton of,
they gotta get a ton of debt and some equity, like I said.
Staggering, unprecedented amount.
They already raised some money,
Anthropic did, through an IPO,
but they need a vast majority of debt.
So if they've got half a trillion in commitments already,
let's say they get roughly $100 billion in equity,
the revenue's gonna advance,
but I mean, not nearly fast enough.
So let's say they get, just to be generous,
let's say they get 50 billion in revenue.
What did I say, 100?
That's a wild amount, by the way.
And for 50 billion, which is a staggering sum of money,
for that not to be anywhere near enough is so dangerous.
Billion in IPO equity,
that leaves 350 billion for the debt market
just to cover the half a trillion
that we know about right now.
That's likely to grow, by the way.
No reason to believe that half trillion
is only gonna be a half trillion
over the next couple of years.
And then we have to have all these other questions.
So you can see where these numbers
just get absolutely ridiculously insane.
And really, the entire issue,
again, at every single bubble,
this time is not different,
is all about that curve.
Yeah, this is where I hope you're looking at your screen.
Which is still growing parabolically in the second curve.
If it doesn't grow nearly as fast enough,
suddenly you've got a bigger problem.
You still have parabolic growth,
and maybe you get to profitability down the road,
but your profitability isn't as profitable
as you hope for today.
And in between, if your revenue doesn't get as parabolic
as you initially extrapolated,
that means you're gonna need more debt,
and a ton more debt,
because every little bit of delay on that curve
adds a couple hundred billion more
to your overall debt pile.
And it also leads to higher uncertainty.
The further out in time that it goes
where these two lines cross,
the more debt investors are gonna say,
eh, the probability of you being able to pay me back
is looking less and less likely,
especially before we get into
any kind of shocks or volatility.
But the further the extrapolation deviates
from its intended path,
the further it deviates from the current projections,
the more the debt market's gonna say,
yeah, no, thank you.
And when that happens,
when you don't have the level of profitability that you need
and the level of profitability that you need
just continues to grow and grow and grow
because of the amount of debt that you brought on,
the amount of service that you have to do to that debt,
now you really run into a problem
where it doesn't even take anything catastrophic happening.
You can be growing at an unprecedented rate.
You can be setting records and still go out of business.
If you need debt to cover the shortfall
and you don't have sufficient revenues,
now you're on the hook for those payments.
Those aren't going anywhere.
That's the problem.
Even if their growth rate slows,
you can still end up being put out of business
just by the debt that you have to service.
So when you look back through history,
what you see over and over and over and over and over again
is the same thing.
Unjust exuberance where, not unjust,
poorly timed exuberance and you overdo the debt
and then the revenue ends up coming in,
but it doesn't come in fast enough.
A ton of money gets obliterated because those debts go bad.
And then the inheritance generation
that comes in afterwards goes,
wow, thanks for building all these data centers.
We're now going to make use of them.
It's crazy.
And so this is the big bet.
That curve, as he said, is exactly what matters.
How fast does the revenue trend up?
And that's not even the only thing.
We also have to factor in costs are going to likely go up.
The 518 billion is probably the best case scenario here.
All of these companies are competing
for a limited amount of equipment,
which are driving up prices already,
which means the 518 billion is the lower bound
for what Anthropic is really estimated.
So costs go up.
Revenue maybe doesn't grow as fast as projected.
And suddenly there's a huge amount of uncertainty
where the point of profitability comes in,
which means the debt market stands back and says,
we don't know if we're going to get paid back.
Therefore, we're going to start slowing down
what we're doing.
It raises a number of potential frictions for a system,
the AI bubble system, the AI capital expenditure boom,
whatever you want to call it.
It raises a number of frictions
that makes it more difficult for that
to get to where it needs to be
in order to make all of this work.
And we've heard a number of skeptics from the very beginning.
I remember IBM CEO, I think it was last December said,
there's no way these numbers work.
This is what they're talking about.
What they're talking about
is these overly optimistic extrapolations
where the parabolic growth easily outpaces spending
and therefore outpaces predictable spending.
That's what they sell you on.
Parabolic growth and revenue, predictable spending.
Eventually everybody's happy
because the green line goes much faster than the red line.
Profitability for everybody.
That is the case, but not likely the near term
and not likely in the short run, especially when-
I'll point everybody back to the CEO of Cisco
after the dot-com bubble
and the numbers that he was dealing with
were way, way, way lower than this.
His was like 10X or something.
And so he was like,
you guys made decisions as investors
that were absolutely insane.
Think about how right my business had to go.
It had to go perfectly for 10 years.
It had to be like, I wasn't paying anybody any money,
that everything was just every dollar
that we made went straight to shareholder value.
Like, what were you guys thinking?
There was no way that was ever going to come to pass.
And the numbers that we're now talking about with AI
are just ridiculously higher than that.
So when he says that everything is priced to perfection,
it's a, I think, far better way to say it is
it's not realistically priced.
And just because something isn't realistic
doesn't mean that it can't happen.
My own company, Quest Nutrition,
grew by 57,000% in our first three years.
In manufacturing, that is like,
nobody in their right mind
would ever say that was going to happen.
I even remember living through it,
being absolutely terrified every month
because you have some things you have to buy
so far in advance that you're like,
God, are we really going to,
like, if I have a six-month
or even four-months was like a really big one.
If I have a four-month lead time
where I've got to spend the money today
but it's not going to arrive for four months
and I've been doubling every month,
am I really going to double four more times
before that stuff arrives?
And so I've got to buy month one,
month two, month three, month four,
all assuming that this kept up.
Can you really bear doing it?
Because if you stall out at any point in that growth,
now you get yourself into some real trouble.
So, and the numbers that we were looking at
just were not on the scale.
So, yeah.
And going back to 2008,
the thing that killed Lehman Brothers
wasn't some acute event.
What killed Lehman Brothers was the Euro dollar market
was suddenly very skeptical.
And so they just were like,
we're not going to loan you guys overnight money anymore.
And that was it.
That's all it took, put them out of business.
And so when you get a debt market
where no one person thinks
that they're the one making the decision
to kill the AI bubble,
they just go, eh,
like we're not willing to do it in that amount,
or we're not willing to do it at that rate,
or whatever it is that they decide
that they're not willing to do.
And now all of a sudden, literally,
there's nowhere to get the cash from.
Then you go out of business.
The credit market,
the credit cycle turning in the wrong direction.
You can also appreciate with a higher uncertainty
exactly why this thing is priced to absolute perfection.
Everything needs to go right.
Spending needs to be controlled and predictable,
has to go on a predictable path.
The revenue has to come as projected and extrapolated,
which is another problem
because nobody has any frigging clue
what revenue is going to look like.
And there's a number of risks to it.
For Anthropic specifically,
what about the lower tier models, the lower cost models?
Maybe more of the business sector decides
we don't need to pay for frontier models.
Let's use some lower cost models
and control our own budgets.
We don't know what happens with a macroeconomic downturn.
That could push the revenue curve further out
into the future, less parabolic growth.
There's a whole number of factors.
And like I said before, spending is a huge one.
And just think about what's happening right now
with the interest rates on the tenure.
Up, up, up, up, up, up, up, up.
And this is a big part of it.
These guys are just competing for the same pool of cash.
And so now they're creating a problem for each other.
As the debt goes up, or sorry, as the cost of the debt,
so the actual bonds themselves, as that goes up,
everything is getting more expensive.
Then consumers are pulling back.
Is AI going to be one of the things that they pull back on?
Do we get this battle between the Fed
and the entire AI industry where they go,
bro, we've got to beat China.
You don't understand.
This is a winner take all.
We're just going to keep going, keep going, keep going.
So now you've got the Fed
trying to break the back of inflation
by telling people stop borrowing so much money.
You've got the entire AI movement saying, nope,
we're going to keep borrowing this money,
which then means that the Treasury
is basically competing with everybody,
trying to get the people to come and buy the US debt.
And the more that they have to raise rates
in order to be enticing to get people to come buy that debt,
then the more you get this inflationary arms race
between the Treasury and the AI industry
that's being made worse by the Fed,
who's trying to do the very thing,
which is break the back of inflation
that they're creating and making worse.
And so, boy, we've got, these are questions,
none of this is like a guaranteed, but hot damn,
do we have a series of questions that have to be answered
and they're going to be answered
in the most economically violent way you can imagine.
Because somebody borrowing the just money coming in
so fast and furious, somebody's going to lose.
518 billion today could be 618 billion next month
and it could be a trillion dollars
by the time we get to the middle of next year.
I wouldn't be surprised.
All of these things need to go exactly right
in order for all of these numbers
to have even a small chance of working.
And the more that it seems unlikely,
the more credit investors are going to say,
sorry, I don't think so.
And the more credit investors pull back,
well, we'll get to that.
That's all it takes.
Like I said, the further on we get in the boom,
the worse it's going to get down the road
because these numbers just get bigger and bigger and bigger
and they get harder and harder and harder to justify.
But a lot of this has to do with the specific structure
of the AI boom here.
And it's not really all that different from the dot-com era,
at least much of the dot-com era.
I've said this too.
You hear people all the time say, this is a debt story.
Well, the dot-coms was also a debt story
to a significant extent as well.
But this one is much, much bigger debt,
much, much bigger reliance on the credit system as a whole
and all parts of the credit system,
including the stuff that we used to bring out
back in 2006, 2007, and into 2008.
Not making the same comparison,
not saying we're going to repeat the 2008 crisis.
It's just that all of that stuff,
the SPVs, the special purpose vehicles,
are central to this case,
just like they were the mortgage bubble a generation ago.
And the Anthropic is no different.
Over the last couple of months,
we've heard these massive private credit deals
have been put together with Anthropic at the center of it.
And I'll diagram and get through it in just a second here.
Another key point here,
which shows this time is not different,
is everybody's involved.
You know, one of the reasons why you have these credit cycles,
the upswing and then the downswing,
the downswing part of it is because
everybody's tangled up with everybody else.
It's not like you have discrete parts of it
that can be separated and compartmentalized
as the cycle turns to the downturn.
You can protect yourself over there
because everybody over here has nothing.
No, it is absolutely entangled.
Everybody's entangled up with everybody else.
There are guarantees everywhere.
There are collateral deals.
There's distributed debts, which-
We talked about this a while ago.
So you've even got Nvidia getting in on it,
saying, hey, look,
our chips are gonna be worth a lot more
going into the future.
And so we're gonna backstop people.
I think it was up to 25%.
So if our chips go down in value,
we'll cover that gap up to 25%.
So when he talks about,
like all of this stuff is interconnected,
that is about one of many, many, many examples
that people have started mapping out
all the circular financing.
Ed Zitron is somebody that's doing a really good job
of showing how incestuous all of this funding is,
that these guys are basically lending money.
So if you've got, let's say,
Nvidia lending money to Anthropic,
knowing that Anthropic is gonna take the money
that they just lent them and buy their chips,
now you just have Nvidia gave money to themselves.
And so it's like, wait, hold on.
Was there actually new wealth that was just created?
Not sure.
So yeah, this stuff is so tangled up.
I don't even think people know
who owes what exactly when, where.
Like you need AI literally just to track
all of the connections.
I guess that I'll get to in just a second.
And this deal that we're talking about here
and a bunch of other deals that are related to this
are no different.
The SPVs are back.
Under the specific one that Anthropic put together
a couple of months ago,
I believe it was in early June or July,
Broadcom is backstopping some of the payments
with their, what is it called?
Residual supply or residual value support.
Residual value support's the term
that everybody's been using
because Wall Street's great
about putting together slogans.
It's basically nothing different than a backstop,
like you said here.
Backstopping payments on some of the debts.
The debt that was specifically put together
through private credit,
you can see we've got Broadcom,
which is the guarantee.
Morgan Stanley arranged it.
Apollo's involved.
Blackstone's involved.
Basically, everybody gets involved in these deals
because Wall Street loves these types of things
on the way up.
Well, they also have to, man.
There's just so much debt to be bought.
Residual value support,
which means that if Anthropic doesn't make its payments,
because let's face it,
it's a company with $5 billion in revenue
and $500 billion in committed expenses.
If somehow they fail to make up their payments,
the Broadcom is guaranteeing part of the loan,
which has the effect of allowing Broadcom
to use its reputation and credit profile
to cheapen the debt that ultimately benefits Broadcom.
Yeah, but Anthropic is basically the customer.
This stuff only goes so far.
Look at what's happening to Oracle.
Yikes.
Oracle right now has been downgraded,
is one step above junk grading
because they're so far out over their skis on debt.
Go through some diagrams.
But first, so you can really see what I'm talking about.
Let's go back to the .com era
so you can see why it's really not different.
And I brought this up about a month ago
when we went through Nvidia.
It's really the same kind of thing.
But back then,
it's some of the biggest technology companies
that were very profitable.
These are firms that had a long business profile.
The idea that .coms are all a bunch of small,
money-losing companies.
In one sense, that was true,
but you had Nortel and Lucent in particular,
and many, many more who were doing basically
the same thing we're talking about here,
but in a different way.
They provided essentially direct loans to their customers.
All right, so one of the big arguments right now is,
all right, listen, .com, totally different.
These guys were basically fake.
They weren't making any money.
Everybody was just so hyped about the internet.
You put .com on something, and it's going to be big.
But AI, AI's different.
There's a ton of money that's being made.
Yes, it's true,
but it doesn't matter that there's money being made.
The only thing that matters is that graph.
You've got debt.
Debt is a ticking clock,
and the clock is counting down.
You need revenue by that certain point.
If you don't have more revenue coming in
than you need to service the debt,
you go out of business.
So, yeah, ain't just that.
Customers, because their customers had no money.
They were like, in this scenario,
the customers are like Anthropic,
and Nortel and Lucent are like Broadcom and NVIDIA.
Broadcom and NVIDIA established businesses,
massive growth, so they got profitability.
Their numbers look good, longstanding profile.
Anthropic, just like the .com names of a generation ago,
basically no track record, no revenue.
We hope that their parabolic growth
actually comes to fruition,
but we don't really know the case.
So in order for the smaller .com businesses back then,
or Anthropic these days,
to be able to buy the equipment from Nortel and Lucent,
they're gonna need to borrow the money.
And so Anthropic is borrowing the money from Wall Street,
but also borrowing the money in different ways.
But back then, we didn't have the SPVs to the same extent.
They were there, but they didn't have them
to the same extent back in the late 90s and early 2000s
that we do to these days.
So Nortel and Lucent did the same thing
that we just talked about with Broadcom
in order to make the loans more economical
so that Nortel and Lucent's customers
could buy their products.
They went into the bond market
and borrowed the money themselves
and then redirected those loans to their customers
who then used those proceeds to buy the company's products.
Here's the big problem that I have with all of this,
and this is my big problem with a lot of things,
politics, world affairs, certainly the economy,
is if you want to take huge risks
that anybody in their right mind would stop you from taking,
all you need to do is come up with a very compelling story
that people can hold onto,
they can explain to their friends,
and then you make the reality so complicated
and so hard to track that the vast majority of people
just aren't gonna track it.
And that is where we are with all of this financing.
Like, even spending time on this stuff,
it's hard to keep up with
because the next deal's gonna come out
and it's gonna have new weird things,
somebody's guaranteeing it, backstopping it, ah.
It just gets so wild so fast
that there's no way to regulate this
and stop it from happening.
It's so big and so complex that, yeah,
this is how this stuff becomes a systemic,
a risk of systemic failure.
Very simple, and in theory, it's very elegant,
but you can already see the problems
of where this could all certainly fall apart.
If the money stops coming into Nortel
because the numbers don't look as rosy
as Nortel told Wall Street or Bank of New York Mellon,
which is one of the biggest investors in Nortel,
or Lucent, the same thing,
the house of cards comes crumbling down,
which is essentially what happened.
Because all of those extrapolations back in the dot-com era
were way, way, way too optimistic.
The spending was also overly optimistic,
but the revenue growth just didn't happen
nearly the way that it was projected through Wall Street
and through everybody else in the financial media
and everybody who invested in it.
So once the money starts to dry up,
customers start to dry up,
but Nortel is now on the hook for their customers.
All those equipment deals that were done,
not only do they have less revenue coming in
because their customers are all bust,
they also have the back loans
when they were funding their customer purchases,
which is why Nortel and Lucent aren't around anymore.
They went bankrupt throughout the decade of the 2000s.
It got kind of messy there, but-
And remember, we're already starting to see distress
in the private credit market.
So you've got Blue Owl, BlackRock.
These guys are starting to have oopsies on their books
because they're already finding
that some of the loans that they made have gone bad.
So it's not like we don't see those early cracks.
Neither one of those companies survive.
And that's the basic framework that we see here.
When I say this time is not different,
this is what I mean.
The only real true difference,
which is in this case from a macroscopic perspective
isn't a meaningful difference,
is that these companies,
the modern version of Lucent and Nortel,
in this case Nvidia or Broadcom,
you can substitute Broadcom in there,
they're not making these loans directly.
They're making guarantees, which make it similar,
but they're not making the loans directly.
Instead, we've got the shadow banks,
we've got the private credit providers,
at least the asset managers.
The asset managers,
they help set up these special purpose vehicles,
the SPVs that we just talked about.
They get funds from equity investors,
wealthy individual institutions.
They sell bonds into the marketplace.
They borrow money, they create leverage.
They basically use all of their resources
to gather as much debt and equity investments
as they possibly can.
And keep in mind, a lot of this stuff came about
because after 2008, regulators came in and said,
all right, you guys are unhinged, man.
We cannot do this anymore.
We're gonna regulate you guys.
We gotta get you back in line.
And yes, sure, but just like with anything,
what that does is it does not make the demand go away.
If you can't make the demand go away,
the demand is gonna manifest somewhere else.
And so what we ended up doing
is creating all this market for private credit
where people can go in, aggregate their funds,
and say, yeah, we're willing to take this bigger risk.
But then more and more people pour in.
It seems like the opportunity to take advantage
of this hot new thing, AI,
and so all the traditional lending isn't touching this stuff
because it's a little bit bigger of a question mark.
And so it just finds its way elsewhere.
And then we start financializing everything,
packaging it up, and selling it into places
that it really shouldn't be sold into.
But it's all complicated enough
that people don't really understand what's happening.
And you don't realize just how exposed you become
to all of this stuff.
This is why, man, I truly am empathetic to people
that have the Jeff Snyder, Michael Burry approach of like,
hey, can we just make this fail now
so that whatever damage is done is confined to this?
Because I can see that you guys are too ******* stupid
to realize you need to pump the brakes a long time ago.
So let's just smash a few people in the face
and then we can start approaching this
in a far more sensible fashion.
That is where I'm like, everybody needs to understand
what they're exposed to.
Like when you guys start thinking about
how exposed am I to AI?
You really want to start thinking about
how to break this stuff out.
We talked about this in one of our recent Deep Dive Reacts
where I'm saying, listen, there's really two different ways
that you can be approaching this stuff.
You can say, okay, I completely believe in this industry
and I want to go all in, and now you're very exposed
and if it hits, you're gonna make a ton of money
and if it doesn't, you're really in trouble.
Or you can understand what are the mechanisms
of why somebody like Trump, who we were looking at,
why is somebody like Trump moving away
from some of the hotter tech stocks
and into things like Visa and MasterCard,
which are basically like toll chargers.
And no matter how much inflation is,
those guys are gonna get their percentage
and so they're gonna grow as inflation grows.
The same thing you should be thinking about now.
It's not like you necessarily want to have zero exposure
to AI just because it is growing so fast,
but boy, oh boy, do you want to limit your exposure
and not just be like, there's no way it can fail.
There are a thousand ways this thing can fail.
And then they're the ones that are making the loans
to the customers, which are in this case,
the anthropics of the AI cycle.
So they're making loans to the AI customers
who can then use those proceeds
to buy the products from Nvidia
or buy the products from Google,
all the chips or Broadcom.
What is it called?
The Google TRU landscape.
They have all these fancy terms for it,
but it's basically the same thing.
The same thing is we're borrowing money
to fund customer sales, customer capital expenditures
so that they can then buy the products from these companies
who are providing support
because they want to make sure that these deals get done.
Again, these small businesses, just like in the dot-com era,
they have no track record,
they have no real revenue to speak of.
They're tremendous risks.
If they went into the debt marketplace themselves,
they would be charged a huge interest rate.
So instead, to cheapen these loans,
to make these extrapolations have any prayer of coming true,
they have to make the interest rate as low as possible.
So Nvidia or Broadcom,
they have to get involved with these guarantees
because these companies have absolutely no track record.
They have no collateral other than what they can pledge,
which is the stuff that they're actually buying,
in this case, the chip.
So basically, Wall Street came up with a way
this residual value support to create collateral
out of the products that all of these technology companies
are buying from the other companies that are supplying them
and supplying in one way, the debt.
So we have a company like Anthropic
that buys a bunch of chips from Broadcom.
They pledge those chips.
They actually don't,
the debt's a little bit, the structure is different,
but we don't really need to talk about that there.
Talk about that here.
The chips that they buy from Broadcom,
they post that as collateral to the SPV
so that the SPV makes a cheaper loan.
And then Broadcom or Nvidia,
whatever the company happens to be,
stands by with this residual value support,
which is essentially recognizing that the equipment
that is posted as collateral
has a very uncertain value to it.
And a lot of these chips depreciate very quickly.
And you don't, as a lender,
the last thing you want
is to have an uncertain value of collateral,
uncertain collateral value
because the whole point of collateral is to be protected.
And the whole point of having collateral to be protected
is because you're offering a lower rate
than you otherwise would for the amount of risk
that's actually being undertaken.
So basically, Broadcom and Nvidia have said,
we'll guarantee the value of those chips
because they're thinking
if the customer doesn't live up to the obligation,
they can't pay back the loan,
we'll take the equipment back,
the chips or whatever else the equipment is,
servers and a bunch of everything else,
maybe even data centers themselves,
we'll take them back
and we'll either sell them in the marketplace
or more likely we'll repurpose them
with somebody else who can pay.
So they're thinking that there's no loss to them
because they can just take their equipment
and resell it or reuse it.
The SPV is made whole
because they have the value of the equipment
that these companies are buying,
the smaller companies are buying.
And they also have the residual support,
the residual value support
from these bigger established firms
who say, we're gonna make sure that you get made whole.
And it all seems to work really, really well,
so long as those two lines
actually live up to the projections.
The green line grows parabolically,
the red line grows in a predictable fashion.
They cross early enough
that it leads to a huge enough profitability opportunity
that it's not completely uncertain
and completely discounted down to nothing.
And so we have a bunch of debt
that's being raised and funding,
basically the same circular structure
that we saw on the dot coms.
Shout out to Jeff Snyder, man.
This guy's really fantastic.
We've got all the major pieces
that I wanna make sure that you guys are aware of right now.
It's a huge bet.
Everybody needs to understand
the architecture of the world is changing.
This is gonna be a timing question.
And given how much uncertainty there is
in terms of any one person's ability
to map where all of this debt is
and how many question marks stand over the entire industry,
we don't know how all of this stuff
is gonna be played out.
So there's one last thing that I wanna talk about,
and if you can pull this up, I believe it's in the doc.
When you look back at what ended up being the disaster
of the 2008 great financial crisis,
it was just people lost faith.
And once you lose faith, you don't make the debt available.
When the debt's not available,
you can't meet your obligations.
And that was debt just overnight.
Literally, I'm just not gonna give you the debt overnight.
And so you can imagine when somebody has debt
that has to be paid back over a very long period of time,
they have these massive outstanding obligations
that right now is all ready for one company,
half a trillion dollars,
you can imagine that this starts getting uglier and uglier
where people just go, you know what?
I'm just not sure how this is gonna wrap up.
And I wanna play this clip
because I wanna remind everybody
how much uncertainty there is.
We're all convinced it's gonna be big,
but it's very difficult to say
exactly how it's gonna be big.
It's very difficult to say
how it's not gonna be a problem
in terms of damaging the job market.
And just because we've got a bunch of machines
that are doing cool things,
are people gonna be out of a job?
And if they're out of a job,
what's that gonna do to the broader economy?
And if the broader economy is taking a hit
because we're getting productivity,
but it's out of bots,
and we don't have any mechanism
to sort of figure that out from a UBI,
like what is this?
There's just a lot of question marks.
All right, so let's hear it from our lead minds.
Sorry, the question was about age of abundance.
What's the job of the future?
Because people looking at this
will be worried, particularly laptop jobs.
What are they gonna do in the future?
Well, I think it is worth highlighting
the positive benefits of AI, which will-
Pause it for a second.
That's the most political thing
I've ever heard in my life.
So she said, no, no, no, for real,
like what jobs are people gonna actually have?
People that are using white-collar jobs,
they're very afraid.
He, I don't know whether he couldn't hear it or what,
but he basically sort of preps her,
was that a question about the age of abundance?
No, ************,
it wasn't a question about the age of abundance.
It was a question about what am I going to do?
I've got a job.
It's me on a keyboard.
What am I gonna do with my life?
And yeah, he switches the frame, but keep going.
An age of abundance where we don't have
just a universal basic income,
we have universal high income.
How exactly?
Yeah, people speak about medical benefits.
I think the, but maybe it's worth a bit more about that.
Is it?
It's not the question.
When you have robots and you have super intelligence,
it means that everyone in the world
can have better medical care than anyone here, including me.
Okay, so I think you guys get the idea.
So you've even got now somebody like Elon Musk,
who normally is just gonna give you an engineering answer,
is like, let's talk about the age of abundance.
And honestly, let's talk about the age of abundance.
But if you've got people that are asked
to give more and more and more debt over time,
and they're not seeing that the projections are being hit,
you're gonna lose that confidence.
And so what we all have to be paying attention to
is given the projections that they're putting out there,
given the fight over liquidity
that you've got going on between a government
that's running $2 trillion a year in debt,
has $40 trillion behind the scenes of Fed
that is raising rates because they think inflation
is being caused by something else
that isn't being caused by.
If Bill Ackman is right and you have inelastic demand
and that they're just gonna keep going crazy,
taking on this debt, building out the data centers,
all of that, the question marks will begin to stack up.
So this is one of those times
where I'm not expecting the industry
to get itself under control.
I'm just talking to you guys as individuals.
Make sure that you think through
how do you have some exposure
to what is clearly the greatest transformation of our time,
but understanding that historically speaking,
this is gonna look something like the dot-com boom and bust
where it is going to be the real thing,
it is going to change things,
and people are gonna get extraordinarily wealthy.
But the people that won the most
were the people that had dry powder when everything crashed,
still believed in the thesis,
put money in, and then rode things up.
And given just the historical precedent for that,
you could be wrong,
which is why you don't want zero exposure,
but man, history has a brutal way of reminding people
that these are mechanisms.
And if one of the mechanisms is,
oh, people just have to be scared enough
not to loan you money, doesn't take a lot to get there.
And then that breaks things.
And given all the other stuff that we've talked around
that are also influencing this, ooh, buddy.
Yeah, I'd be very thoughtful about your confidence
in going all in on something.
All right.
If intelligence does get commoditized, though,
and models are kind of becoming interchangeable,
do you think, where do you think the durable profit accrues?
Is it more in the electricity companies, cloud providers?
Where do you think?
If that ends up being true,
and you've got open-weight models, no regulatory capture,
then it will be who's got the best product
at the best price.
That's gonna be a huge part
of what makes it quote-unquote the best product.
And if these guys aren't able to drive their own cost down,
disrupt themselves, then the durable value
is gonna end up at the infrastructure layer.
I mean, it's a tale as old as time.
So the infrastructure certainly feels like
it is likely to be a safer bet.
You may miss out on some of the upside,
but the odds that something happens
where we don't need any infrastructure is very low.
But the thing that worries me about the infrastructure play
is I wonder how much of this is gonna go to space.
And so if it ends up going to space,
are the same infrastructure companies
gonna be the ones that win in space,
and so it's sort of geography independent?
Or is that gonna be a fundamental shift,
and it isn't like, oh ----, my money was in debt
on a very specific New Mexico data center.
That didn't happen, I'm in trouble.
Or are people being more broadly distributed than that?
So that goes back to that series of question marks.
But AI is not going anywhere.
It's really a question of where is that curve?
But that curve is everything right now.
If you like this conversation,
check out this episode to learn more.
Investors are looking at how the government
is treating the economy, and things are not adding up.
If you don't understand this,
then you are definitely gonna get hit by something.
For 26 weeks in a row, the US government.