Ep23: Can Americademocratization theory bringabodemocratization in China? @Professorming
strategy.insights. professor ming
351 followers
Program Topics:Misuse of Democratization Theory
主持人: 明教授
Host: Professor Ming
Can Americademocratization theory bringabodemocratization in China?
美國的民主化理論..能讓中國民主化?
Democratization Theory Misuse: US Strategic Failure on China
民主化理論的濫用..美國對華策略失敗
"Strategic Misjudgment: CCP's Deception and US Policy Failure
戰略性誤判:中共的欺騙與美國的政策失敗
US Strategic Awakening: From 3C to Confrontation Firs
美國的戰略覺醒:從3C到對抗優先
#professorMingStrategyInsights # Ming Juzheng# Strategyinsights
#DonaldTrump #CCP #ChineseEconomy #XiJinping # Xiaoping
#WindowofOpportunity #UkraineWar #MaoZedong
#明居正#明教授韜略天下#韜略天下中國#共產黨#中國經濟
#川普#中共高層#中共官場#習近平
Updated every Monday at 9 PM.
每周一晚間9點更新
Please support by liking, sharing, and subscribing
[Music]
good morning ladies and gentlemen
welcome to Professor Ming's strategic
insights the topic I'm going to share
with you today is how the United States
misuses the theory of
democratization and how the effect
United States policy toward communist
China in our previous program we talked
about that in the eyes of the Americans
that the communist China is the only
country that possesses the economic
military technological and diplomatic
capabilities to challenge the rule-based
international
order question is China was quite
backward 30 40 years ago or three or
four decades ago and how do communist
China acquired these capabilities to
challenge this International order uh
all through these years well it's
ironical to say it's thanks to the
United States for many years the United
States has been offering all kinds of
helps ironically speaking it is the
United States that has been providing
help or assistance to communist China in
various Fields then the next question is
how and why the United States help China
acquire these capabilities well we have
to go back to the history of Cold War uh
toward the 1960s and early 70s that the
Soviet Union has acquired a u a nuclear
Arsenal almost as powerful as that of
the United States so United States felt
very much threatened in order to deal
with the Soviet Union Nixon and KRA came
up with a strategic idea they want to
win over China communist China to
confront uh Soviet Union so that's what
they call the Triangular politics some
people refer to it as the normalization
of relations between China and the
United States a few years later can
President Carter uh Jimmy Carter he was
not very successful in handing his job
but he wanted to uh uh to get to win a
second turn
he want to get re reelected but with
very little credit for him to rely on so
he came up with the idea of establishing
official relations with mainland China
or communist China and abandoning Taiwan
and that's how the United States and
China had begun their interchanges and
cooperations in many
areas after that a few years later we
saw Clinton Bill Clinton at the very
beginning of his presidency he was
struggling
over one issue the uh most favorite
Nation status to to China to come into
China whether it should be linked with
Chinese U achievement or Chinese record
in human rights after struggling for a
while Clinton decided to delink the two
elements namely China will get most
favorite Nation status despite of his
human right records then after that it
was somewhere between Clinton and Bush
the old Bush that communist China had
access to WTO World Trade Organization
it was admitted to the organization as a
full member during this period of time
roughly 30 years running from early
1970s to the turn of the century the two
countries have been engaging in U
cooperation and uh exchanges and almost
all the areas such as um e economic and
trade uh
technology uh news report medical
research culture and
education and even space programs of
course that's not just uh simple
cooperation and uh exchanges they are
strategic considerations Behind these uh
these efforts the first one is of course
uh as I just mentioned to win over China
to confront the Soviet Union and second
one it involves great uh business
profits or great business interest for
the two countries of course for the
American side uh included of course and
the third one is a rather uh interesting
one it is based on an anticipation of a
developed economy will eventually lead
to democratization for China and this
anticipation or expectation of
democratization comes from a misuse of a
theory the theory of democ
democratization in order to explain this
misuse of the theory and brief
introduction of the democratization
theory is in order in the nran economy
or what we call the pre-industrialized
society basically they adopt monarchy as
their political system and that's
probably the majority of the cases it
was the Industrial Revolution that
brings about a major change it gave rise
to a booming economy uh booming business
activities and then eventually led to uh
social changes the biggest change in the
in the society in in human society at
that time was the uh the structure of
the social classes or the composition of
the social classes and the most
prominent part of the social change is
probably the increase of the middle
class some call it the
buasi they demanded more uh because they
have more more money the first thing
they wanted from the the king or from
the Kings is of course uh tax cut they
didn't want to pay that much taxes to
the Kings because the kings were
probably wasted and lived a very
luxurious life and then go to war and
fight some unnecessary enemies and
things like that so first thing is uh is
tax cut the second thing is they uh
along with that that that demand they
want to have more say about politics
they criticize the policies adopted by
the by the Kings or by by by the state
anyway so along with that again they
demanded um uh freedom of speech they
want to say more things about
everything then they want the right to
together and they want the right to form
associations all kinds of associations
clubs anything in the society and
following that they want the right to
demonstrate and to uh and to
protest and after that they want the
right to to strike they don't want to
work that much or they want to use
strike as a as a weapon or as a leverage
against their
capitalism so um in the in the academic
Circle we call these changes in society
with one with one concept we call it
liberalization the process I just
described last for perhaps a few decades
a few decades later the middle class
decided and they discovered that the
liberalization is not enough they want
something more they want more
participation in politics or in the
process of
politics they want to uh elect uh
somebody who can speak for them in the
parliament or in the Congress they want
somebody to speak for them to make laws
for them which are uh in in their favor
just to protect their interest or even
to promote their interest so uh
eventually they got the the right to
vote and gradually this right to vote uh
expanded and um Extended to what we
called Universal seage then along the
way we welcome the coming of modern
political parties and eventually the
class or some people from the middle
classes still are not happy or with the
process they think they want more they
want to become parliamentary members
they want to become
congressmen so
gradually we witness the coming of
democratization so let me summarize what
I just said for what just happened first
we witnessed the Improvement or
advancement in
technology which leads to a booming
economy and then leads to uh the change
in the social structure and then
eventually it leads to change in
politics so we summarize them as the
process of liberalization and
democratization so this is basically a
rough SC rough uh description of what we
called the theory of
democratization which I called classic
theory of
democratization I'll explain it later
historically the uh process we just
described happened uh first in the
United Kingdom UK then it spreaded to uh
Northern America then to other countries
in Western Europe and to Northern Europe
and basically it took them uh about 100
years sometimes a little bit longer in
some countries anyway from 1 to 200
years the the process completed but we
must call attention to to one thing
these examp this process of
liberalization and democratization did
not happen just in Europe or in in
America it happened in other countries
such as South Korea and Taiwan so if it
applies to U uh North America Europe and
some Asian countries like Taiwan and
South Korea why do we call it a
misuse there are two reasons for
it first first in the academic Circle
people tended to think that's the only
way to democratization or the only path
to
democracy and secondly they mistakenly
think that applies to all the
countries but that may not be the case
here I can offer a few sets of counter
examples the first set of counter
examples happened in uh Eastern Europe
and the former Soviet Union namely the
former Communist States or socialist
States
uh in between
1989 through 1991 and 1992 we witnessed
the uh the claps of the Communist
regimes in countries like Poland
Hungary uh East Germany
Czechoslovakia Bulgaria Romania
Yugoslavia Albania the Soviet Union and
lastly
Mongolia except for a few exceptions
there's very little um middle classes
people existing in these countries if
you really want to pinpoint it I will
probably argue that uh East Germany is
the only country that has a sizable
middle class and it played a role a
major role in the process of
democratization of that country but in
other countries we really did not see a
sizable middle class in Poland for
example it was the solidarity that
played the the role of the agent of
democratization and we all know that the
solidarity composes of primarily the
workers or the working
class and in the Marxist jargon the
proletarian or the proletariat in other
former communist countries the major
agent of democratization is the general
public or the general masses in short
the process of democratization in these
communist countries do not match the
classic democratization Theory or put it
the other way around the classic
democratization Theory does not explain
the process of democratization of the
former Communist States the second set
of counter examples happened in uh two
2003 that's what we call the color
Revolution involving countries like
Ukraine Georgia Lebanon and Gan and the
third set of country example is what we
call the Arab Spring which began in the
year 2000 involving countries like
Algeria lib Egypt Yemen and perhaps Iraq
in all these cases I I guess it's fair
to argue that the the middle class is
missing from the uh from the scene
namely uh the agent of democratization
in these countries was not uh the middle
class rather it's a general
public and uh in interestingly that
communist China provided another set of
or another line of
interpretation they argue it's all the
Strategic plot manipulated by the United
States they call it the peaceful
Evolution or peaceful Revolution against
these countries having said that let me
take this opportunity to clarify myself
a little bit I'm not saying that this
classic theory of democratization is
incorrect well I'm saying is that it has
its limitations first it's not the only
way to democracy there are other ways or
other paths to democracy and secondly
it's not applicable to all the countries
in the world because different countries
have different initial conditions so
they may not be universally
applicable and it is this uh misuse of
the the classic democratization theory
on the part of the United States in an
attempt to promote the change in
communist China and eventually leading
to democratization as they wish so as I
see it it's a um good intention but it
comes with a bad result because this
misuse will lead to a strategic
misjudgment and communist China is sure
enough to seize the opportunity to
deceive the United
States and to strengthen itself as we
pointed out before
currently communist China is using two
words the Ukraine war and the world in
the Middle East to tie up the hands of
United
States and to undermine European
countries and of course Russia so to sum
it up we must have a clear understanding
of this misuse of the U democratization
Theory therefore we must alter our
strategic judgment about communist China
thereby changing our strategy and
policies to communist China currently
the American government is saying that
their relations or their policy toward
the uh to communist China is cooperation
competition and confrontation our
probably suggest to change the ordering
of these three seats into
confrontation competition and
cooperation okay I think that's all I
want to share with you today I hope you
like our program and I'll see you next
time
[Music]
