Opening Bid Unfiltered is available on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
The world of collectables — from toys to unopened card boxes — remains red hot. And when you want to know anything about collectables, there are only two places to head: one, the new collectables hub on Yahoo Sports. And the second is serial entrepreneur Josh Luber. Luber co-founded StockX with Dan Gilbert, owner of the Cleveland Cavaliers. StockX revolutionized the trading of luxury goods by applying stock market principles—transparent bid/ask pricing and anonymous transactions—to sneakers and collectibles. Luber has since gone on to found toy collectables outfit ghostwrite. Luber hopped on the Opening Bid Unfiltered podcast mic with Yahoo Finance Executive Editor Brian Sozzi to go deep inside the collectables growth market.
All right. Welcome to a new episode of the Opening Bid Unfiltered Podcast.
I'm Yahoo! Finance Executive Vendor Brian Sazi.
And I'm really jazzed up about this episode.
I most of you don't know this.
I'm a little bit of a a collectible fan.
I try to collect what I can.
I'm probably not collecting the right things.
That's why I'm bringing in my featured guest for this episode.
Ghostwrite founder and CEO Josh Luber, who also co-founded StockX.
And Josh, this is one of my most prized collectibles now.
This is the Starbucks Barista.
I'm just going to show it to the camera like a dumbass.
I took it out of the box.
Stupid, right? And you can tell me on this.
You know, I don't know how much long term value Starbucks collectibles
are going to have.
So, you know, I don't want to throw too much shade
if they're going to go too far down that path.
But I mean, it's such a phenomenal like microcosm of like the entire world
right now that like this is the one we put on the table
and not like a baseball card or like parachutes or something like that.
So it's great.
It was either this or some random Funko out of my collection.
And then, you know, I got to give, you know, the the I forgot
what it was, but Lexus Ohanian.
I talked to a big collectibles guy, talked to him a couple months ago.
And I'm like, Lex, I just found all of my Batman trading cards
that I pulled, I think, in the late 80s.
Like, yeah, dude, they're worthless.
I'm shocked. Like, I can't believe it.
Why are these not worth anything?
Everyone, you know, we're about the same age.
Every single person, every single at least guy, our generation
goes through the exact same thing, where they find all their cards
in their closet, they call up somebody who's in the know
and they're disappointed when they find out they're all worthless.
And I mean, like, the answer is, is the answer is econ 101.
It's just supply and demand.
It's most basic.
And back then, they just flooded the market with that stuff,
not at any idea.
And we all go through it.
I mean, like, literally, we all go through it.
There's literally a line somewhere in deep in a footnote of the white paper
of like, yeah, if you're 47, don't know what you're talking about.
Like, this one's for you.
Like, you know, and that's fine.
They're like, we all go through it
because that's what it was like in the 80s and 90s,
where they didn't understand about scarcity and supply.
And did you flip did you flip your cards?
I I'm back in cards more heavy now than than I've ever been.
You know, when I left StockX, I actually went
and I created fanatic collectibles with Michael Rubin.
So that company was bigger, faster, crazier by everything.
And so I got to be like full scale back in it from, you know,
from a kid in the 80s and then come back in the hobby in 2018, 2019.
It was just like it's been phenomenal.
I mean, it's like I buy and sell cards every single day right now.
And and it's just a blast to like be back in that hobby.
All right. So I thank you for briefly mentioning your career.
I want to skip that because I want to get. Yeah, I know it's not.
It's not fun at all.
So the other thing and I want to get to this white paper,
38,000, 30,000 word white paper you just dropped. I loved it.
Another thing I found in my closet ahead of this, I remember Pogs.
Yeah, of course.
I have OJ Simpson Metal Pogs, Star Pog that I used to use in school.
Should I be holding on to this stuff?
I don't know.
You know, this is the other part of this is that there's so many different,
you know, little niches around collectability.
And like I never collect the Pogs.
I don't know what the market's like for it.
Like, maybe, maybe. Right.
Like, you know, that that's like a perfect there's there's so many,
you know, parts like that.
You know, I'll tell you a really quick story.
So when I was CEO of StockX, we were at Nike.
This is like year two.
And I was giving a talk and it was like 300 people in the room.
And we were talking, explaining StockX and everything else.
And we sort of get to Q&A.
And there's this guy all the way in the back of the room.
It's a huge room.
And he's like, really, really wants me to pick on him.
And I finally choose this guy.
And he goes, I just want you to know, will you guys get to banjos?
I'm your guy.
And I was like, OK. Right.
And like, that's the thing is like that guy collects banjos and the whole thing.
And I'm sure.
So I don't know. Find the banjo Pog guy and we'll figure out how much it's worth.
But is that how a lot of your time is spent?
Like you have you do something that like you can instantly relate to people
like you and I were sitting here already talking about collectibles and Batman cards.
Yeah, well, that's also just our generation, right?
Like, you know, but it's like our generation is now the people
that are sitting here at the head of Yahoo and we're making companies
and stuff like that.
And so we get the ones that, you know, you just mentioned like
we finally have money, Josh.
We got to go buy the things we wanted.
That is exactly what happened.
The whole market like just reset because we could go out there
and buy the Michael Jordan card we couldn't afford when we were kids.
So, yeah. All right.
So the the blind box vacation, everything awesome white paper
I read from top to bottom.
One thing that stood out to me
and this kind of plays into my what are my thinking on these Batman cards?
The price of legend cards are not like they're not going up, right?
Well, that's a that general statement misses the sort of next letter down,
which is like it depends.
It depends on, you know, are there some legend cards that have been,
you know, rebuilt with scarcity and collectability in mind?
Or are there just, you know, cards that have have too much volume?
But that's OK.
I mean, there's a wide range that some cards are meant to,
I don't say be worthless, but not to be worth thousands of dollars
and tens of thousands of dollars
that anyone can go in and get a Larry Bird card or Michael
or Magic Johnson card.
So Michael Jordan card is still going to be super valuable, or it depends.
Well, and it depends.
You know, you can go find a Michael Jordan card for a buck, right?
On the other hand, the most expensive card that ever sold
was a Jordan card sold six months ago for almost 13 million dollars.
So, you know, for the for the collectible noob out there,
what does it mean?
What did you mean by you?
This is the year of the blind box.
You know, I think at this point,
everyone is familiar with Lububu, or at least the word.
You know, I was so late on Lububu.
I was so late on it.
I'll say my I have a 13 year old daughter and and I held off forever.
And I was like, listen, you are not going to be the last one on a trend.
Like, there's no way.
And, you know, you got you're the coolest dad.
And my wife, my wife was like, come on, just like let her have the thing.
I was like, all right.
So, yeah, I mean, Lububu really showed
kind of the rest of of the world,
the power of of of blind boxes, the power of of gamified commerce.
Right. Because and by the most of the stories about Lububu
focus on Rihanna or K-pop or TikTok or, you know, and and that stuff's all true, too.
But like at the core of it,
the mechanic was you didn't know what color Lububu you were going to get.
You didn't know if you were going to get the black one, which was the secret.
And it wasn't that rare.
It was one out of 72.
So when you look at, you know, the rarity of trading cards,
you know, the Jordan that sold for 13 million dollars is a one of one card.
That's it. The only one.
So it really opened up a lot of companies to see that.
Oh, wow. Like that's a really simple mechanic.
And we can incorporate that into our business in a lot of different ways.
And I also say there is something about, you know, you and I sitting here
talking about as kids and everything we collected.
So largely male dominated thing, you know, for us as kids doing it.
Lububu opened this up to the other half of the world.
Yeah. Right.
And so now you have both half the worlds that are into the gamification of it.
And then you have all these companies
like Starbucks and Lidz and Le Creuset and all these other companies
that are now trying to figure out, well, how do we do that?
How do we get the hype of it?
Yeah. Which is, you know, what? Yeah.
But that's the thing.
And now you have these other companies trying to figure out
how do we get the hype and excitement and, you know, and dollars
that PopMart flew in over that period of time.
Why? I want to before we get more into this white paper,
what makes these things take off at the end of the day?
And it's most simple and simplest form.
This is a damn cup.
Yeah. That is made out of glass.
I look at Lububu.
It's it's a it's a thing.
How do these become instant collectibles
or how do they capture the zeitgeist out of nowhere?
Yeah. I mean, look, it really is just supply and demand.
And the demand half of the equation
works when you hit that intersection of culture and commerce.
Right. Where were you?
I mean, look, Starbucks, what percentage of the population knows Starbucks?
I don't know. All.
So you just you have a world where like Lububu,
you had this intersection of Rihanna and K-pop and all this other stuff.
And again, culture and commerce and those things apply.
But it is just supply and demand at its most basic level.
And so just even forgetting how rare something is,
if there's more demand for something than their supply,
that product is going to sell for more.
And so that's the like I said, this is Econ 101 at its most basic.
Are today's Lububus going to be this generation's versions of my Batman
cars like 20 years from now, totally worthless?
No, Lububu is is already Beanie Babies.
Like they've already gone through the full cycle
that took Beanie Babies six, seven years to go through.
That's because of, you know, the Internet and everything,
you know, of why our economy was faster than it did in the 90s.
But but that's because Pop Mark didn't intend
and didn't manage Lububu to be a collectible like trading cards or you know.
And so they were happy to just make as many as they would make
and people buy them.
And the fact that they resold for more, that is a function of the secondary
market, which Pop Mark's not trying to do that.
They're just trying to sell as many products as they can,
which is in the 80s.
They were just trying to sell as many packs of Batman cards as they can.
Yeah, it's true.
Why is the card market?
You know, in 2018, 2019,
trading card market started to come back.
A lot of people looked at
the pandemic and the Last Dance documentary as a sort of moment
where we're trading cards in Quebec and the whole world went crazy in 21, right?
And trading cards went crazy in 21,
just just like everything else, and then came down just like everything else.
But the core collector part of trading cards are still there.
And trading cards have fundamentally built in
true supply and demand, true scarcity.
And so as faux financial assets, right, they still have that
that, you know, inherent disconnect between supply and demand.
Lububu, they just kept making them as many as they would make.
And so, you know, this also, I think there's something about,
you know, sports and, you know, the evolving nature of sports and content
and everything we know about sort of how content is going to change with AI.
I mean, there's like there's so many like different parts of this.
But like at the core of it is when more money comes in,
they want the products that are most rare, that are that are most,
you know, valuable.
And so it's the top of the market that is going nuts.
I mean, we've had six of the most expensive card sales
in all time in the last six months.
You know, all these cards at over five million dollars.
So and that's only going to continue because you just have this
like natural scarcity that exists.
If I think back 15 years ago and I bought 100 shares of NVIDIA,
I probably wouldn't be here having this conversation.
That's right.
I would be I'd just be chilling, to be honest with you.
Like, what is that, I guess, card or cards today that are emerging
that could be the next big thing?
Well, you know, as you may know,
Fanatics took over the trading card licenses a couple of years ago.
And I was part of that, but they just
they acquired the licenses a couple of years ago,
but they just started using them.
So only a couple of months ago, they released their first fully licensed
basketball set.
Topscoring basketball is the first time that Topps has made basketball
cards and fully licensed basketball cards in trading cards.
You need two licenses.
You need a license from the league and then the players.
And and then they'll also take over the NFL license at the end of the year.
So what we're going to see by the time we get to the end of 26 is a kind of
like steady state trading card industry.
We're now the people that are in it.
You have Fanatics that makes the majority of the cards
and you have PSA that does the grading and then you have the marketplaces around it.
You have an economy that has a ton of money,
a ton of like very mature companies that understand,
you know, how to grow and what.
But like it is it is like almost day zero from from the market as a whole.
So it'll be very like how many what percentage of NBA fans collect basketball cards?
I don't know.
It's got to be like less than a fraction of a point.
Right. And so now that the leagues and the teams are our partners
in these companies, the same way that sports betting,
you're going to walk into arena and can be able to bet on games.
When you walk in, you walk in and be able to buy trading cards
when you walk in at your seat.
So which is a short way of saying like the whole market is still very, very early.
Specifically, you know, that's a it's a much tougher question
to identify what part is going to be looking for my next investment.
I know what I'm trying to like.
I know I'd be very careful not to do that.
Do that one off line.
But but it is, you know, the whole industry is is is pretty nascent
in terms of when you look at the other industries of the same size
and how sophisticated and how well they are.
I mean, we just started marketing a hobby for the first time ever this past year.
The first time there's ever been trading card marketing,
you know, is only in the past year.
And so it's you know, it's a it's a very interesting time
to look back in a couple of years and see where we're at.
All right. Hang with us, Josh.
We're going to go for a short break. We'll be right back.
All right. Welcome back to Opening Bid Unfiltered.
I'm Yahoo!
Finance Executive Editor Brian Sazi having a fun chat here
with Josh Luber, Ghostride founder and CEO, StockX co-founder.
And I got before we even get back to the conversation,
got to give a shout out to Yahoo Sports.
They have a new collectibles vertical on their site.
I mean, this thing's awesome.
Can I just plug my own company for once?
I would like to think that I helped start that.
You know, I've been pushing the people behind the scenes
that you guys should be covering.
Ryan Spoon. I mean, he's a legend in collectibles in his own right.
That's right.
You know, I've known Ryan for a very long time
and I'm trying to move the Bear Bricks out of his office
and Ghost into his office.
You should see his office. I have to take you back.
Oh, you've seen it?
Oh, yeah, I've seen it.
And we're slowly filling up more and more Ghost than there are the Bears there.
But yeah, I mean, you know, as collectibles become more and more,
I don't want to say of a real industry,
but as a larger and more robust industry, you guys should be covering
the same way that you cover every other industry.
So true. Before I get into what you're doing here at Ghostride,
so I went to StockX.
I go in there from time to time.
And for the first time, I saw boxes of cereal on the website.
I mean, and I'm like, I had to ask Josh about this.
What food is now collectible?
Well, you know, there's a I don't know.
There's maybe about a half a dozen of those boxes.
What happened was a couple of years ago,
some of the cereal companies started to have asked some of the large
fashion designers to redesign some of the boxes.
And I think the first one was when Cause, who's a famous artist,
did one of the boxes.
And then what happens is they design the box.
It could sell out.
But what happens is collectors say, oh, I'm going to hold that one aside.
And then, you know, someone else wants it.
It's just, you know, again, it's just supply and demand.
But but those are collect.
Those are collaborations with artists and designers and other people.
I have one.
I think it's like an ambush when ambush is a Japanese
streetwear company.
I have like an ambush.
I don't know where do you keep all these?
What what is your collectibles collection even look like?
I really should put that up as a thing.
It's like Ryan's office, except times whatever large number
you want to put behind it. Yeah. Where do you keep all this stuff?
Well, I moved to Austin.
So, you know, when I used to live in New York, it was much different.
I live in Austin now, so I can have, you know, multiple rooms for this stuff.
Nice. All right.
So take us through Ghostrite, what it is and what you're working on.
So I left Fanatics Collectibles in summer of 22
after we acquired Topps, brought a management team.
And, you know, it's three years from four years almost from now.
And I left for the very specific purpose of can we create
the mechanism of trading cards, but use a different form factor?
And so Ghostrite is a collectible toy brand.
But, you know, it's funny.
We should we should you want to open on? Yes, I do.
OK, all of this is right up my alley.
I try. I don't portray it on TV, but like this is who I am at my core.
OK, so here. Thank you.
So this is the WNBA set, which is actually live right now on our set.
This is a blind box.
There's multiple different forms of Ghostrite.
And I should really have one to show before we open it.
But this is like a box of trading cards where this is with the WNBA set.
So we're going to look for different players in here.
Paige Becker's rookie ghost is a big one or Asia Wilson, Sabrina,
all the top players.
But what we really want are the rare variants.
And so there's a gold version that has a gold crown that's number to 10.
There's a chrome crown that's number to five.
There's a fire box.
Like, do you know? I don't know.
No, I that would be a really big problem if I did.
But but the from a value standpoint, you know, when we did
the Major League Baseball set last year, the Shohei Ohtani Fireground,
the one of one, so the most rare of the best player
sold on the secondary market for forty four thousand dollars.
It's a two inch piece of plastic.
But this is the whole thing.
What's a trading card trading cards, a little two inch piece of cardboard.
Right. And a piece of plastic.
And so it's the exact same idea is we take all the mechanics
of trading cards and use a different form factor.
Unfortunately, we have licenses
with the NBA and Major League Baseball and WWE and UFC.
So let's let's open our box.
Can I open it? Like, I'm afraid I don't feel like taxing or something.
That one's yours. This one's mine.
So is there a right way to oh, you just rip it open?
There's a little pull tab on the top.
So we again, we what we really want are rare variants.
But it would also be like the gold.
Yeah. So you'll see if there's a shiny crown.
There's it's very much like trading cards where there's a
there's a number to 50, a number to 25, a number to 10, a five and a one.
Oh, I love it. There's no more wrapping here.
And then there's a little gold.
So this is big. This is cool.
This is so on my alley.
My friends, longtime friends know this is right on my alley.
All right. Now I just got to open it.
So there's a little. Yeah, there's a there's like on the side.
Hmm. Yeah.
Yeah. Where's the team coming here?
Let me open this.
Yeah, there's it should be like a little notch on.
See, this is like real time, guys.
Oh, here we go.
Right in front of my face. I had it backwards.
Oh, so. All right.
So that's so this is.
So there's no gold crown.
There's no shiny crown.
So that means this is a base.
This is like a standard ghost.
Nice weight. These are cool.
So, man, there's a lot of work that went into figuring out
like what should the shape because the the shape is the brand.
Have you seen the larger ones in Ryan's office?
So the Undertaker and Brian? Yeah.
Like, you know, it can be a WNBA player.
It can be Undertaker. It could be a basketball.
You know, we did one last week that was it was a pencil.
But so if you look on the bottom of the foot, it'll tell you how many exist.
And so the bottom of the foot will tell you.
So there's there's it was when it was manufactured and then 800 means
that one's out of 800.
So there's 800 base.
And then if it was a gold crown, it would say 10 number, just like trading cards.
And so I got Nafisa Collier, who's probably the
maybe the second best player in the league right now.
And that's all right.
So this is our fourth set.
We've done WNBA, NBA, Major League Baseball, second version WNBA.
But NBA comes out next week during All-Star,
then Major League Baseball, then WWE.
And like this again, I can't can't start stuff.
This is just a box of trading cards.
It works the exact same way.
And so the secondary market for the rare ones, you know, the
the Caitlin Clark gold number to 10 sells for four thousand dollars on eBay.
Wow. I just want to take you.
So Brian, I just opened this. I took it out of the box.
I have not felt that unboxing experience.
So I really think since I opened cards, it's one thing to get an iPhone.
You see the you know what you're getting. Yeah.
There was just something to this experience.
I got to think on a little bit more that I have not experienced
since maybe I got that OJ slammer for my pogs like back in the day.
You know, but like, yeah, I got this.
I mean, do people trade these? Yeah.
And this is what I said.
This is like how this is why that feeling that by the way,
the whole white paper is about experience.
It's not about products, right?
This is this not like the gambling industry exists.
This is how all of this, you know, I mean, the short version of like,
you know, 140 pages
is that you have the normalization of gambling becoming more and more common
to the point where now with prediction markets, right,
where prediction markets, you now basically bet on anything.
And it's made gamified commerce that much more normalized,
the point where, you know, you can basically bet on any product, right?
Any blind box, you can create that that experience.
And that's what Lububu did is it made it.
So the most simple version is what am I going to get?
What's coming out of here?
And that that level of excitement when you take it another level
and now you have true collectability in here, where if you get, you know,
the goal, by the way, there's a 15000 hour bounty on the page.
Becker's one of one. Right.
So what you may be in this box, it may be in this box.
Yeah, we I truly have no idea. Right.
Actually, here, let's do one of those.
I've got to do one more.
So this is the NBA box from our last set.
So what we really want out of here again is as a rare variant.
But there's a Wemby in here, Steph.
There's also, by the way, we have a famous fan.
We just trade. We just steal from trading cards.
So in the WNBA set, the famous fan is Lena Waithe.
And the NBA set, the famous fan is Eminem.
So there's an Eminem wearing a Pistons jersey that you could get as well.
So I you know, you're my new friend.
I've determined that. And I want to share this with you.
I actually also went recently went digging for my 80s McDonald's toys.
Now, there's a ton of these things on eBay.
I get it. And I'm not expecting to get rich off of them.
But there was something about these toys.
Yeah, I still have like 75 of them at my house.
Well, you know, the McDonald's Pokemon stuff has been nuts
and they're about to release a new one.
Really? Oh, no gold.
No gold crown.
But Jason Tatum, that's a win.
Oh, Steph Curry.
Steph Curry. Like, wait, I do want to trade.
Only because I have many Steph Curry's already.
But yeah, there's very few moments in the past 20 years of my life
that I was I've been able to actually be human.
This is one of them and has morphed into something really cool.
And plus, I got a little color match going on with the face.
This is this is awesome.
So let me I have some rapid fire ones.
The best way to invest in a collectible.
The simplest way to invest in a collectible is unopened Pokemon boxes.
That's the simplest way.
Your holy grail collectible and why?
Well, I have a Shohei Otani card
that is most people would acknowledge as maybe his second best card ever.
I think it's his best card ever.
Regardless, I paid about 100 grand for it a couple of years ago,
and I've had multiple offers over two million dollars and I've turned it down.
And I think that it's
I think I think it might legitimately be the best trading card
in the history of trading cards.
And and I just got super lucky that I happened to buy this one card
at this one time.
And Otani is Otani.
So you buried with this thing or are you just at some point
you're going to just have to sell it?
No, no. I mean, I'm in it for 100 grand.
So, you know, I mean, I have a lot of other cards, too, but that one.
And like and this is how it happens is like I'm not paying two million dollars
for a card, but if I get lucky and, you know, you have a card
that goes from 100 grand to two million, like this is where the market's obviously.
You know, by the way, I have other stories that we've gone the other way.
So, you know, don't don't focus on the wins here.
Not that easy. But yeah, that Otani card's a monster.
All right. Next one.
LeBron is probably nearing retirement soon after he retires.
What do you think the market looks like for his card sneakers?
You name it. Hats memorably.
Yeah, it doesn't change at all.
And same thing is like, you know, when B cards are just astronomically expensive
because his whole career is basically already built into the price
because we see of what he could be.
And LeBron is I mean, his whole career has been written.
So it's already baked in his price.
He won't his cards won't change when he retires.
I will say to be a little bit morbid when Kobe died,
his autograph cards went up in value, actually everything went up in value,
but particularly his autograph cards, because now he can no longer sign.
And so you have a little bit of that that happens when an athlete dies.
But for the most part, most athletes, their cards, their prices already built in.
I mean, you could argue that Cooper Flagg's price is already built in.
I mean, not to be I paid $80,000 for Cooper Flagg card last week.
I think it's a monster card.
And I think you can have the same like trajectory as that Ohtani I just bought.
But like, that's wild, right?
Like, he's amazing, but he's also played, what, 40 games.
So, yeah. Last one.
And what is the fascination with these Honus Wagnus cards?
Now, I ask you this because I have grown up seeing this one photo on a card.
You know what I'm talking about?
Of Honus Wagner.
And there's just something about this.
What makes this card so valuable?
Yeah, this is like you can't have a better story about story.
I mean, this card, which is a tobacco card from 1909,
Honus Wagner was one of the first five people inducted into the Hall of Fame.
He was most people consider him to be the best player of baseball's
like first generation.
But the card was very rare at the time.
There weren't a lot of men made.
And just over the years, it's developed this mythology.
Wayne Gretzky bought at the time in 1991,
he bought the most expensive Honus Wagner ever.
It was like $450,000 in 1991.
So you have this just mythology that has been building for a decade,
excuse me, for a century.
And and so, you know, how many exist?
No one really knows.
There's only 37 that have been graded by PSA.
So maybe there's like 50 or 60 that exist.
But yeah, I mean, if if that
Ken Kendrick, who's the owner
of the Arizona Diamondbacks, owns the one that Wayne Gretzky owned,
which is the one that's in best condition,
if that card ever went to market, $50 million, probably.
That's awesome.
Well, I could do this all day.
I have to go.
It was a real treat to meet you.
Glassman, thanks for having me.
Where can I get those like big Ryan Spoon, like Ghost Rites?
Yeah, absolutely.
Yeah, yeah.
All on Ghost Rite dot com.
All right. I appreciate it.
Good to see you, Josh.
Thanks for having me.
All right.
That's it for the latest episode of Opening Bit Unfiltered.
This was my favorite episode
I've done in like six months.
And we've been cranking these things out, guys.
Continue to hit us with that love on YouTube, Spotify, Apple,
Amazon Music, iHeartMedia and probably 30 other places I'm forgetting about
right now. Thank you so much.