The Definitive Old Forester BOURBON RANKING!

Brandy Channel
12 followers
1 Video View·Feb 4, 2025
We broke open every Old Forester Bourbon we could get our hands on to see which is our absolute favorite. let's see if Old Forester 1920 or Old Forester Birthday Bourbon win.
Welcome back. We're the Bourbon Junkies.
Tonight we tackle most of Old Forrester's lineup.
Which Old Forrester is the greatest one ever? We'll figure it out.
The one that's not here. Intro.
Unfortunately, we don't have a President's Choice right now.
It's the only thing we don't have. And the Old Forrester
rises on here because all these are Bourbons.
So, these are the rules.
These are the most recent releases of all of them.
It's all of the new labels of Whiskey Row.
It's the newest 117.
And you even got new ones of these too.
Yes, those are new.
And then the 117 is the Bottle and Bond,
which is the most recent one.
And this is the 2022 Birthday Bourbon.
So, this is the current day.
Which one's the best one?
Shout out to Zach Raymer of Bourbon Kingdom
for hooking us up with the 117 too.
We have 10 bottles of Old Forrester.
We're going to use a very simple scoring system.
Sean gives each drink a number between 1 and 100.
I do the same. And then we total the number.
And whichever one has the highest top 3 will go to a blind.
And again, we'll do that.
We've given negatives, but I doubt we're going to get any of these ones.
These are all good enough.
Today, who's supporting us?
Marty Megson.
What's up, Marty?
Can we call you little Meg?
Beautiful.
He wanted single barrel, 13-year-old Old Carter Kentucky Straight Bourbon.
Barrel 75, if you're wondering.
It's probably going to be fantastic.
This might be a bad thing to drink before this flight.
But here we are.
Shout out to Marty. Thanks for supporting the channel.
Man, it is something special when they had that top band there.
You know the Carters with the age on the top.
That is such good whiskey.
Oh my gosh, dude.
This should be direct number one.
This is going to be easy.
Because we're going to like all these.
Before, which one wins?
Probably Birthday Bourbon out of this lineup.
Out of this?
I think King Ranch has a great shot.
Yeah, it is definitely.
The 117, bottom line, you haven't had yet.
Oh shit, true.
Really good.
Little whispers.
Oh, well, hello beautiful.
Vanilla, sweet cream.
Oh, that smells phenomenal.
I love everything about that.
It's marshmallow-y.
You know what? 1910's got a shot here.
I forgot about 1910.
That's really nice.
Got my number.
Marshmallow-y.
Dark, like real dark, charry flavors.
That is like perfect Brown Foreman.
Or Old Forester.
And like at a not a million dollar price tag.
Okay.
That's really good.
I hate starting on like this because that's a good one.
I don't want to be like 89.
Then the next one's way better.
I'm going to go with 80.
89.
Oh, dude, are you serious?
You do this every time we do these lists.
Sean comes out of the gate hot.
If it's a good one, he's like 105, 105, 107.
When you were like, I'm not going to go 89.
I couldn't keep a straight face.
I gave it exactly 89.
All right, B.
Oh, that's good, too.
Oh, that's, whoa, that's banana.
Whoa.
Hold on.
That's fruit cocktail-y.
It's like citrus-y.
There's like acidity bite on the nose I really enjoy.
This is like the stewed-est fruit I've ever stewed.
Ever.
You don't eat fruit?
I've never.
I do eat fruit.
I don't stew them, though.
But this smells like that.
If not.
Oh, that's fantastic.
It's got a little tingle down there, too.
Yeah.
That's really good.
Their well-aged product always has that really deep honey note.
Oh, my gosh, dude.
See, that might be better than the first.
This is the problem.
That's very close.
81.
Burp on that.
81.
I went 85, slightly lower than the first one.
See, this is, what was my first one?
80.
80 on the dot?
Yep.
Glass C.
Oh, that's.
The, what?
Banana Laffy Taffy?
Is that the most, or is it my situation here?
Oh, that tastes youthy.
Very youthy, considering.
Way thinner.
Oh, yeah.
Viscosity's low.
That's good tasting, though.
A and B were hitters.
That tasted great.
Unfortunately, it is a lot thinner.
Flavor's good.
Way younger than what we had.
Flavor's good there.
Still flavors really solid.
I'm going to go 67.
I went with 70.
Oh, yeah.
I should have went 69.
All right, we're on glass four.
What?
That smells like cola.
That smells old, too.
It's like it's spicy.
It's almost tobacco-y.
That smells literally like cherry grenadine in a fresh McDonald's Coke.
But you threw a little bit of root beer in there.
Yeah.
Oh, my God.
That's so good.
93.
90.
That's phenomenal.
90.
Oh, come to find out, we like Old Foster.
Weird.
That one is built different, though.
This is built different.
That has a lot of oak.
It is complex all the way through.
It is very viscous.
I like that one a lot.
Man.
I don't know what to do with myself right now.
And rich.
Very oily.
I like that one.
Two, three, four.
We're on five.
We are.
Fifth glass.
All right.
Glass five.
Syrupy.
Almost floral.
A little bit.
Yeah.
This is more.
A little rosy.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
It's bright.
It is.
This is springy.
This is like when you go outside after winter.
Fresh garden smells.
Yeah.
Not vegetal, but like.
No, no, no, not vegetal.
Like you walk out and you can smell like some like nice fresh strawberries and stuff.
You smell the grass.
This smells like nature in a good way.
Like.
Mm-hmm.
Is there like a punch of ethanol in the front?
But it's a low proof, though.
It's like mid, I would say.
But it's.
Like I think that's what the sharpness is.
That tastes like malted barley now.
Like a lot of it.
It's oily as hell.
Plantain, malted barley.
I'm 47 on that.
Man, I don't.
That's my least favorite so far, for sure.
That might be the first one I would pick up and be like, I'm okay.
I'll get something else.
I went 55.
Man, I feel like that's too high.
That's the first one.
Yeah, I do, too.
That's the first one I would just pass on.
What was this?
One, two, three, four, five.
Glass number six.
Six for.
Pretty good.
Back to that fruit cocktail.
That.
Six for pretty good.
I hate you.
It does smell very fruit cocktail-y.
Not as thick as some of the other ones.
Less on the butter.
This is a great middle of the road.
Tell me this isn't like a staple bourbon.
Yeah.
Or whiskey, whatever it is.
Very sweet, though.
Yeah, but I feel like, dude, this has got to be a pretty solid getting into whiskey nose.
That's sharp.
I just saw your face as I was.
I was trying to.
Yeah, I was trying to not.
No, no, no.
Banana cream pie.
100%.
What is that?
Cool whip or vanilla.
I would.
Banana pie crust, literally.
Like, that is, that's banana cream pie.
I'm going to rate that way higher than you if you didn't.
I like that.
I like that a lot.
I'm going to go 79.
42.
I, something about that done for me.
For me.
It was sharp twice.
You just kicked it in a nut.
Really?
You did.
It tastes like bananas, dude.
I didn't like that.
You ever had a banana moon pie?
Yeah.
You like it?
Yeah.
Me too.
They make a chocolate dip version that's even better.
Talk about ******* game changing shit.
Double dipper.
Seven.
Oh, this is different.
Oh, oh, this is darker.
It's got a lot of that syrup, you know?
Yeah, it does.
This has, um, not, this has, we're back to not right banana peel.
This has like the core, not a core, what, the inside of a banana peel that's not the part you eat.
The banana.
Yeah, but the banana is the part you eat.
You eat the banana.
Go, go ahead.
You peel, and then banana.
But the inside of the peel is different than the outside of the peel.
The inside of the peel's got a little nanner on it.
But it comes off, I think.
Am I just way off?
I don't know.
Maybe.
Way off.
Dude, do I not understand bananas?
It is a really simple fruit, honestly.
Oh.
That's flavorful.
Yeah.
That's a lot.
There is a lot.
Caramel, banana.
Like, that is very on-profile Old Forester.
That's the first.
At a higher proof.
Oh, wait, not the first one.
That's, um, one of the biggest evolution of flavors, I think, in a drink that we've had.
That's one of the best ones.
That it, like, rollercoasters you a little bit.
Yeah, as an experience, that's high.
That's a 90.
Oh, I went 85.
That's a top three so far, for sure.
I did like that one a lot.
Just 10, 9, 8.
I don't like to do that.
I get confused.
10, 9, 8.
I don't like that.
I don't like counting backwards.
It's like doing your alphabets.
Oh, holy sweet.
Pineapple juice.
Straight up.
Whoa.
All right.
That doesn't taste like any of the other ones.
It's really marshmallowy up front.
It is all a honeyed citrus fruit on the palate.
Not complex.
Doesn't linger.
But the flavor that exists is great.
I love it.
But that black pepper note goes through.
Goes away too fast.
That's sad.
I poured Barrel King last night.
On my counter, Adrian Orniglas walked away.
Literally probably 10, 15 minutes.
Came back, three flies on that.
Yeah, you live in a swamp.
Hey, man.
I'm in my home.
Okay, Shrek.
I'm in my home.
That makes you donkey.
You know that?
Dude, it's so good.
And it disappears.
That's so great.
That's like a creed song, dude.
Because I'd love to take it higher.
I think probably a 77.
69.
Damn, you put it lower than I did.
That's good whiskey.
Look at that.
Yeah.
Holy.
Oh, my gosh.
I felt like you looked the first time you smelled Matt Porter's Whiskey King II.
Yeah.
And the only reason it says really, really, really recent in my brain.
That is like pancakes, syrup, bunch of fruit.
That's the sweet bread part of it.
I get that whipped cream on top.
Butter.
That is so well balanced.
Front to back.
And it just finishes like syrup.
It's so thick.
That's a nice one.
That literally feels like there's syrup just running down my esophagus.
I feel like there's five hitters so far, which is a problem.
Yeah.
The problem is if I could remember the first one, I'd love to compare it to the first one.
I'm going to give that an 80.
91.
I'm going to give it the same grade I gave the very first one I loved.
Now that I've smelled this one, I don't know which one birthday bourbon is.
Legitimately, I have no idea.
I thought I was going to be like, one of these is going to be so honestly just easy to pick out a birthday bourbon.
Yeah.
I feel like three of them could be birthday bourbon.
Which is a problem for birthday bourbon.
Huh?
Yeah.
Like honestly, because the rest of them in theory, like on a secondary value, wouldn't compete.
You know what I mean?
On a marketplace.
It smells a little youthy.
You think so?
I think I get ethanol.
Maybe.
There's something in it that just feels like a younger barrel.
Good job, buddy.
Picking that out on the nose because it shrinks youthier.
Yeah, it does.
Thinner.
Oh, yeah, it does.
Younger.
Not very one.
It's banana, oak.
That's it.
Like a little wood.
I don't even.
It is oak, but I don't want to say oak.
It's not mature oak.
There's nothing wrong with that.
No, it's.
I bet that that's the only one I could tell you what it is.
I bet you money.
I give that a 50.
No, I give that a 60 on the dot.
60.
50 on the dot.
And that's got to be Old Forest or 100.
That was what my guess would be.
It has to be.
I mean, that's the only one I think I get right.
I'm going to total these up real quick.
Find our top four, we'll call it.
So we're going to do this blind, so I don't know which sample is which.
And then I'm going to close my eyes.
Sean's going to hand me one, take a drink, give him a score.
And then after I'm done, we'll do the same.
Sean will do the same.
I'll show the camera what number I'm throwing up.
And I'll throw the bottle on screen or the name on screen.
So you guys know what we're drinking.
All right.
You ready?
Let's do it.
It's one of the first glasses.
84.
OK, you can.
Yeah.
You ready for the next one?
Yeah, I'm no Matt Porter.
I can drink whiskey.
Oh, my.
Holy shit.
Man, it's not as complex, but it's better.
Man, that's hard, because that's like apples to caterpillars thing,
where they're just not in the same place.
Man, I have to give that an 89.
I have to.
That's too good.
That whiskey's so good.
Oops, sorry.
How do you know I'm actually blind?
Don't mind me.
Just trying to grab a glass.
Oops, was that your dick?
I'll just, to be safe, I'm going to give that a flat 80.
OK.
That's worse than the other two I drank.
That is.
All right.
Last one right here.
OK.
Fourth glass.
Everybody knows the rules.
I'm going to go 86.
Oh, OK.
These are close.
You have a very tight spread.
Three of these are close.
One of these isn't.
OK.
Here, they're in order.
So you got one, four, seven, and nine.
All right, cool.
Stand here, do the...
This is how we become one.
Oh, that is good.
That's a 90.
That is so good.
When you held your fingers up to the camera,
was it the glass order, or was it the numbered glass?
I gave the number of the glass.
I didn't do it for the first one.
I was using two hands for two of them, obviously.
OK.
Yeah, number one, or whatever you just handed me.
The first glass you drank.
The first glass you just handed me.
That's like a perfect drink of whiskey.
I'm going to go 87.
I'm going to go a little lower.
Slightly lower.
Yeah, that one is really good, though.
Two left.
Shit's close right now.
This smells a little simpler in the nose.
OK.
I'm going to give that an 80.
80?
Yeah.
OK.
I'm going to pad my stats on this one.
Last glass.
Now, see, that's good.
That is good.
86.
I'm going to go slightly lower.
Oh, man.
I'm going to go slightly lower than my second place.
We both had very similar ranges.
Oh, my God.
Coming back on line with the eyes.
All right.
We have everything tabulated.
All right.
Let's get these out of the way.
I'll pick up the bottles as we go.
Oh, I got the answers.
Shit.
I was going to say, you have the answers, my sir.
Are you ready?
My sir?
Oh, my God.
My dear.
All right.
Last place with 102 points.
We have number five.
Number five.
I think it's over here.
Orange top.
Really?
That actually surprises me.
That's not what I thought.
Which number was that?
Five?
I guess that was glass 10.
That was the one that I thought should have been lower.
Oh, my.
All right.
Number nine.
We have glass 10.
1897.
Bottled and bond.
Ninth place.
Okay.
Next one.
We have number six with 121 points.
1870, which used to be one of Sean's favorites.
Yeah, it used to be.
The red label.
When we were getting into this, this was Sean's favorite whiskey row.
Right.
Number seven.
We have glass number three.
137 points.
Well, that'll.
That one.
The blue top.
The 86 prover.
It beat.
This is $22.
22 bucks.
Right here.
Number six.
We have glass number eight.
With 146 points.
So Statesman.
People always say Statesman isn't good.
Statesman's not bad.
Statesman's pretty good.
Statesman's not bad.
It beat two of the whiskey rows.
Statesman.
Number five.
We have glass number two.
166 points.
Man, I want to get that two better.
Old Forrester 117.
Bottled and bond.
This is the newest one.
That was not far off of actually being fourth.
Okay.
So this is the thing.
Top five was really competitive.
When Sean was adding up the scores, top five were close.
Yeah.
That only lost by three points.
From four.
To fourth place.
Originally.
No, actually.
Fourth place is literally now the exact same score.
Is this?
As what we gave that one.
It's glass number one.
Fourth place is glass one?
Glass one.
This performed worse than I expected.
Man.
That's good though.
I thought this would almost win.
King Ranch.
Old Forrester King Ranch is what this is.
It was only in Texas.
I believe you can only buy it in Texas.
When we reviewed it, we liked it a lot.
I really do enjoy that.
It's still good.
It should have beat a bottle on the floor.
Now we have a tie.
Yeah.
Two and three is going to be a tie.
That's going to be glass seven and glass nine.
These tied, buddy.
1910 and 1920 tied.
Which one is?
Both the new labels.
Which one is glass seven?
Seven was 20.
1920 was seven.
Okay.
Would that come in the first round?
Glover below this 1910, which is glass nine.
Just above.
Four points.
So 1920 really won.
This actually won by four points on our first go-around
and tied on the second go-around of 1910.
Well, hey, good news is.
First place.
176 points.
2022 birthday bourbon.
Really good.
Here's the thing.
The biggest shocker for me in 1920
and its current position.
I'm kidding.
If you would have switched King Ranch in 1920,
I would have been less surprised.
I didn't get anything off of what I used to with this one.
No, no, no.
It wasn't like aggressively youthy or weird.
We thought it was young and harsh.
That was glass seven.
Man.
Yes.
In 1910 was glass nine.
Wow.
1910 was nine.
That just hit me that that's not what I would have guessed for 1910.
Me either.
Okay.
If we would have, this would have been a blind competition.
We shit the beds.
As some would say.
Yeah.
Old Forest birthday bourbon won 1922, 1910, third King Ranch,
fourth, and then the rest are the rest.
I believe this is also like the closest running of like a flagship.
Yeah.
Like.
Easy.
Product.
Yeah.
100%.
Winning over the rest.
Yeah.
When we had WLW and Georgie Stack, those were.
Apparent and not close.
Oh, so much higher.
Yep.
Echelons higher.
Yep.
Yeah.
This wasn't that close.
I think the best thing in this whole thing means that it's 1910.
Because this, the proof gives this an same here.
Yeah.
This was a limited.
This is a hyper limited.
This is a limited.
This is the best model here in 1910.
From a value, taking all things into consideration.
Findability.
I'm gonna go with either of these right now.
Gosh dang it, dude.
Yeah.
If you want low proof, go here.
If you want high proof, go there.
Like, all right, we're the bourbon junkies.
Thanks for watching.
Like, comment, subscribe.
Bye.
Old Horser's good whiskey.
Yeah.
We like it a lot.
We just like old folks.
We know we like it.
