Psychology of Influence - The Science behind the "YES-STREET" (mere agreement)

www.LearningPsychology.net
87 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 29, 2025
Many sales people are convinced of the power of the "Yes Street". But for a long time there was practically no evidence for the efficiency of mere agreement...
Author: Eskil Burck (degreed psychologist)
www.learningpsychology.net
The last series of experiments I want to present to you
are quite crazy.
I mean, the results were really surprising to me.
And the experiments I want to present to you
are those from Pan de Leere and colleagues
published in 2010 in the International Journal
of Research in Marketing.
The title of the study is
Better Think Before Agreeing Twice.
Mere agreement, a similarity-based persuasion mechanism.
What they claim and what they tried to prove
with their experiments was that
the more often you agree with somebody,
the more often you say, yes, I think you are right,
yes, I absolutely agree,
the more you get the impression,
well, we are somewhat similar.
And maybe you remember some of the studies
we discussed before in which as soon as the participants
thought, well, the other person
has somewhat the same personality as I have,
the more compliant they became.
But the new thing about this study is
that this procedure is in fact quite suitable.
I mean, would you think that when you say four times,
yes, I absolutely agree, yes, you are right,
would you think that this makes you
more compliant to a request?
I personally wouldn't.
And therefore, it's quite interesting to see
what they exactly did in their experiments.
And let's begin with their first experiment.
All in all, they conducted five.
And I want to present to you the three, in my opinion,
most interesting experiments.
But let's begin with the first one.
In this first experiment, they had 66 students
and all they had to do at first place
was to answer eight different questions.
For half of the participants,
those were questions to which they could totally agree.
Like for example, I can really look forward
to having a nice meal.
Or I think women should receive equal pay to men.
So these were questions to which they now had to say
whether they agreed or not.
I absolutely agree or I absolutely disagree.
And the second half of participants
received somewhat different questions.
Four were exactly the same.
Like for example, I can really look forward
to having a nice meal.
But now four questions were a bit more questionable
and maybe you couldn't agree on these questions that easy.
For example, the question,
I think it is allowed to pay women less than men.
Do you still agree with that?
Probably not.
And after answering these eight questions,
they were afterwards shown
who had designed this questionnaire.
And I mean, it was just a scientific questionnaire
and of course there can be questions to which you agree
and to which you don't agree.
But when they were told,
okay, this is the person who designed the questionnaire
and this person needs some help
because he's conducting another experiment
for which he looks for volunteers
who were willing to conduct telephone interviews.
You won't get paid or anything.
So this is really voluntary.
And it's turned out that the group
who had agreed more often
was indeed more than twice as often
to help this guy who designed the questionnaire.
In another experiment they conducted,
they used exactly the same procedure.
Again, the participants were given eight questions
that they had to answer whether they agreed or not.
And again, there was the more agreement condition
and the less agreement condition.
But this time after they had filled out their questionnaire,
they were shown their answers.
They were shown, well, obviously I agreed quite a lot
with this guy.
Or, well, obviously I did not agree that often.
Another group of participants did not receive this feedback.
What do you think?
Which group showed more compliance afterwards?
The group that got the chance to deliberate
or the group that had no chance to deliberate?
Well, it turned out that the group
that could see how often they agreed
or how often they did not agree,
in this group, the effect was no longer present.
And maybe the reason is that they now became conscious
of their decisions and they could take
their previous decision into account when they were asked,
well, would you help the guy who designed the questionnaire
with another experiment?
Of course, now you might say,
well, quite artificial situation here.
I mean, the participants were sitting at the university,
they got the questionnaire and afterwards
they were shown the picture of someone they didn't know
and they were told, well,
this is the guy who designed the questionnaire.
This is all quite artificial.
What about the reality?
Would this work in reality as well?
And therefore they conducted a fifth experiment
in which they used the technique
in a real life situation with normal participants
because they called 92 subjects and in one group,
they asked the participants exactly the same questions
as in the other two experiments.
And after they had finished their survey,
the critical question was whether the person they had called
would be willing to participate in future surveys
as well.
And you might know that from your own
when somebody calls you from a marketing institution
and they ask you some questions
and often in the end they ask you,
well, is it okay if we contact you again?
And it turned out that when the participants
more often said, no, I don't agree.
No, no, I absolutely disagree.
The more often they disagreed,
the less the probability that they said,
okay, you can contact me in the future.
The exact percentages were 29% in the control condition
when there was a lot of disagreement
and 47% in the experimental condition
when there was a lot of agreement.
So this is quite close to what salespersons
always call the yes street.
Some salespersons tell you,
well, it's always good to ask the customer questions
to which they answer with yes.
And you should avoid to ask questions
to which they answer with no.
And the results from this study
indeed seem to support this strategy.
So that's it for today.
I hope you enjoyed this episode.
And if you want, we will see you next time.
Bye.
