Does Consciousness Survive Death? | Donald Hoffman

Science & Spirituality
12 followers
10 Video Views·Jan 19, 2025
Donald Hoffman (@donalddhoffman) received a PhD in computational psychology from MIT and is a Professor Emeritus of Cognitive Sciences at the University of California, Irvine. He is an author of over 120 scientific papers and three books, including The Case Against Reality: Why Evolution Hid the Truth from Our Eyes. He is the recipient of the Distinguished Scientific Award of the American Psychological Association and the Troland Research Award of the US National Academy of Sciences.
His writing has appeared in Scientific American, New Scientist, LA Review of Books, and Edge, and his work has been featured in Wired, Quanta, The Atlantic, Ars Technica, National Public Radio, Discover Magazine, and Through the Wormhole with Morgan Freeman.
How do you think of death, given all that we're talking about and the first order,
second order, third order implications of all of that? How do you think about death?
So, physicalism has a very clear implication for death. Space-time is fundamental,
and elementary particles like electrons and quarks and protons and so forth
are the fundamental nature of reality. And what you are, what your body is,
is just an assemblage, a complex assemblage of particles. And your consciousness is somehow an
emergent property of certain activities of those particles, say brain activity.
Then it's very, very clear that in death, when the brain dissolves, your consciousness dissolves,
and that's the end of the story. That's the end. That's it. That's a very,
very clear implication of physicalism. We can talk about panpsychism, but physicalism,
strict physicalism, that's the end of the story. If consciousness is fundamental and space-time
is just an interface, and our bodies are merely icons that we use to represent
certain interactions of conscious agents, and we can go into how I think about that, then
on that approach, there is the possibility that some aspect of my consciousness survives death.
Now, there I have to look at the mathematics of the model and go into it, but it may be,
for example, that the bare awareness that's associated with me, just awareness without
content, that survives. But all the details of Donald Hoffman and his life story within this
interface, maybe that all dissolves. That's a story about what is consciousness up to,
and we can talk about if consciousness is fundamental, what is it doing and why?
What is the dynamics of consciousness about? To answer the question about death,
we might have to answer that question, too.
Petey It's a big one. Please continue.
Richard So, I'll try a stab at that question,
because I think it relates to the death question. So, what is consciousness doing and why? The right
answer is I don't know, and I've only seen one idea that seems deep enough to at least be worth
thinking about. I'm not saying it's the right idea, but only one idea that seems deep enough
to at least be a candidate, and it again comes from Gödel's incompleteness theorem.
Gödel says that essentially, no matter how much you explore within a particular conceptual system,
you can't get all the truth. There's always going to be more to explore mathematically.
So, if consciousness is the fundamental nature of reality, and consciousness is all there is,
then mathematical structure is only about the possibilities of consciousness.
That's all that there is to be about. And so, what if what consciousness is doing,
since the exploration of mathematical structure is in principle unending, then perhaps the
exploration of the possibilities of consciousness itself is in principle unending. And therefore,
consciousness, what it's up to is exploring all of its potentialities,
and the reason it's continuing to do that, from our perspective it's continuing to do that,
is because there's no end to it in principle. So, consciousness itself is in some sense
always learning about itself. And so, perhaps then what we are, what people are, and what cats are,
and what dogs are, and what amoebas are, and so forth, is consciousness trying on different
headsets, different realities, and exploring and losing itself. So, this is a very interesting
idea, that consciousness chooses to really explore so deeply that it loses itself in
the exploration, doesn't even know what it is. It becomes a physicalist. It actually thinks
that consciousness isn't fundamental. It goes through the whole bit and then slowly has to
wake up. In so doing, it really explores what it's not and what it is. In some sense, to know
what you are, you have to know what you're not. And so, on that point of view, the Hoffman icon
is simply consciousness taking a perspective on itself, looking at itself through a particular
space-time headset, taking a little projection. And from that headset, there was a birth,
there was growing strong until your 20s and 30s, and then after your 40s, you start declining,
and in your 80s and 90s, you die. And that whole process is just consciousness exploring itself
from a particular perspective, in which case, maybe the Hoffman icon and maybe a lot of stuff
can be left behind, but in some sense, consciousness itself has learned something
through that experience and the eight billion other people and the quadrillions of amoebas
and the who-knows-how-many viruses and so forth. Consciousness is just trying on
innumerable headsets, and when it's done with that headset, it takes it off.
And awareness is perfectly fine. The raw awareness is fine, but the detailed icons
that happen to appear, space-time icons, objects in space and time, brains, neurons,
all those things, those were just icons, and you studied them, and then you realized,
pretty cool, Mount Everest, what a beautiful icon. Death Valley, what a beautiful icon.
But I'm not that. I'm something even more transcendent than space and time. I'm more
transcendent than Death Valley. And so consciousness is just waking up. Again,
I'm trying to tell a story. I'm not saying that it's correct, but it's the only story I've seen
so far that at least is deep enough that it's worth taking seriously.
Who is the origin of this story, and can you ever know that it's accurate, do you think,
through testing or experimentation?
The story that I'm saying right now has an interesting way that you might be able to
test it. So this dynamics of conscious agents that I mentioned is a Markovian dynamics.
Right.
You can make it so-called stationary dynamics in which the entropy of the dynamics doesn't change.
But you can show that even if you have this Markovian dynamics of consciousness in which
the entropy never changes, any projection by conditional probability, any projection
looking at that dynamics will see it as increasing in entropy. In other words,
the arrow of entropy, the arrow of time, is an artifact of the projection.
So consciousness itself has no arrow of time, but you can prove from this mathematics that you get
an arrow of time by projection. The proof is trivial, it's like two or three lines.
So here's a project that I think would be really fun. Can we show that when you look at all the
different ways that you could project consciousness in this mathematics, the conditions under which
all these different arrows of time, the entropy that you get, satisfy the Lorentz transformations?
In other words, can we get special relativity out of this? We would have to model also the
space aspects of it, what's happening to space as a projection of the dynamics of these conscious
agents. But we see the time aspect, so could we actually show how special relativity arises as
just different perspectives that consciousness can take on a fundamental dynamics of consciousness
that has no arrow of time? That's the kind of thing where we could start to make
brand new predictions that could be testable.
