Consciousness and the Mystery of Existence Documentary about Consciousness and Reality

Explore the Metaphysics of the Body
16 followers
3 Video Views·Mar 15, 2026
There are two great mysteries which have captivated the human imagination
for thousands of years. The first of these is why the universe exists at all.
Why is there something rather than nothing? In many ways this is a primordial question
and has been raised by thinkers of every culture. And yet this ultimate mystery of existence
is orbit eclipsed by another mystery. That conscious minds exist to perceive it
and bear conscious witness to the universe. While it is present to every waking moment of our lives,
nothing is more mysterious than the fact that reality allows for conscious experience.
Consciousness is the gateway of all value, meaning and significance in the universe.
And yet no scientific consensus has ever been reached about how and why we have it.
An ancient idea is that the mystery of consciousness and the mystery of existence
are intimately connected. And perhaps surprisingly there are now growing numbers
of philosophers and scientists who take this possibility very seriously. It is this
possible connection between these two great mysteries that we will explore today.
The mystery of existence. Over the last century cosmologists have learnt a great deal about the
early universe. By analysing cosmic background radiation cosmologists peer deeply into the past.
Inferring the state of the universe in what is thought to be its first fractions of a second.
But where did it all come from? What caused the universe? What happened before the big bang?
The physicist Stephen Hawking cautions that this is the wrong question. The beginning of the
universe was itself the beginning of time. To ask what came before time is meaningless,
like asking what is north of the north pole. And yet for many this answer fails to satisfy.
Why did the universe burst forth into existence? And what shaped it to be the way that it is?
Physicists have proposed that the spark of existence had its origin in a quantum fluctuation.
Triggering an explosive chain reaction leading to the still evolving universe we inhabit today.
This narrative of existence however presupposes the laws of quantum mechanics. It leaves entirely
unexplained why the primordial situation should be constrained by quantum physics.
It is here that we encounter the central problem which haunts the mystery of existence.
Every time we propose the existence of a new initial state or cause another one is required
to explain that. Instead of explaining existence we find ourselves simply adding more to that which
needs to be explained. The same presumably goes for consciousness. To those who claim consciousness
to be fundamental to reality there is the challenge of explaining how consciousness
might avoid the same problem of infinite regress. Why placing it at the foundations of nature
doesn't simply add yet more to that which needs to be explained. In recent times the possibility
that consciousness is fundamental to reality has re-entered the academic conversation and gained
new respect from philosophers and scientists alike. There are a number of reasons for this
which I've explored in other videos but to summarize very briefly in recent decades it has
grown ever more conspicuous that the materialist understanding of science seems entirely unequipped
to explain how and why consciousness exists. That our consciousness the most undeniable fact
of reality could so entirely evade our scientific paradigm has been taken by some as a conspicuous
sign that materialism while fantastically useful is not an exhaustive account of nature and that
what we have called consciousness may in fact represent a deeper part of reality than previously
imagined at least by most modern scientists. If you can't explain consciousness in terms of the
existing fundamentals space time mass charge then as a matter of logic you need to expand the list.
The natural thing to do is to postulate consciousness itself as something fundamental
a fundamental building block of nature. Part of the motivation for this view comes from the fact
that standard science provides only an external and behavioral account of reality. Its intrinsic
nature, what reality is in itself, is unprovided by physics. Furthermore the imminent reality of
consciousness is the only intrinsic nature we know of and in several respects it seems to be
an attractive candidate for also being the intrinsic interior nature of reality itself.
But if consciousness is in some way fundamental to reality how might this shed light on the mystery
of existence? This question was explored by philosophers in the late 18th and early 19th
century when a movement known as German idealism rose to prominence in Europe.
As the movement progressed a core circle of thinkers argued for the absolute primacy of
consciousness. Among other notable thinkers philosophers Johann Fichte, Friedrich Schelling
and Georg Hegel urged that a deeper understanding of consciousness is necessary to understand why
anything exists at all. It was Friedrich Schelling who first drew a direct parallel
with the absolute ground of existence and the essential structure of consciousness.
Existence, Schelling theorized, must be self-grounding. What this means essentially
is that the primordial basis of reality must somehow be the cause of its own existence.
To avoid the problem of infinite regress an ultimate ground must be supposed of which
self-existence is part of its intrinsic nature. So what does this have to do with consciousness?
The philosopher and mentor of Schelling, Johann Fichte, had previously argued that a unique
feature of consciousness is that it does not appear grounded in anything beyond itself.
The conscious self is self-producing insofar that it exists only in and to itself.
As the contemporary philosopher Douglas Hofstadter has put it,
quote, it is almost as if this slippery phenomenon called self-consciousness lifted itself up by its
own bootstraps, almost as if it made itself out of nothing, end quote. In a similar way,
the philosopher Peter Sass described self-consciousness as like a, quote,
magical matryoshka, a Russian nesting doll which also magically contains itself.
It was precisely this quality that Schelling realized must be an attribute of the ultimate
ground of existence. Furthermore, this was a quality that could be found nowhere else but in
consciousness. Today, centuries later, the philosopher Freya Matthews defends a position
very similar to Schelling. Matthews has pointed out that the self-causing principle behind existence
must be reflexive, meaning that it directs back into itself. Any truly self-causing principle
must be, in essence, about itself. And yet this property of aboutness, known to philosophers as
intentionality, is another property found nowhere else but in consciousness.
Could anything ever really come from nothing? Perhaps the concept of a true nothing is simply
an idea, represented nowhere in reality. Perhaps instead of beginning with nothing, the challenge
of explaining existence should instead focus on defining a self-existing ground at which
explanation can finally end. As we've already seen, physicists have proposed that the true
ground floor of reality is the seething quantum realm of particles foaming in and out of existence.
While this level of reality surely exists, there is no clear reason why the primordial situation
should be constrained by quantum physics. A deeper level of explanation seems to be required.
One possibility is that consciousness is the absolute ground of existence. And while this
would add yet another level of existence, as we have seen, it offers the benefit of actually posing
an explanation for its self-grounding self-existence. How quantum physics came to be
the ground of reality calls out for explanation, whereas consciousness, in theory, can explain
itself. If this is the case, we might wonder how such a necessary self-grounding consciousness
could give rise to quantum physics and everything else. How could something as intangible as
consciousness ground and connect with the laws of physics? Respected physicists have long defended,
albeit controversially, that a connection point does exist between consciousness and quantum physics,
notably in relation to observation. It seems that in all quantum experiments,
the state of a system is always defined by the information that can be made available to
observers. In quantum experiments, the choice to observe has the effect of defining the state of
the system, which would otherwise present itself in a superposition of all possible states,
and in which producing very different experimental outcomes. While the interpretation of this very
strange finding is hotly debated, leading physicists, both past and present, have pointed
to consciousness as playing a central role in quantum measurement. Is it possible that the
Is the universe, as the physicist John Wheeler once called it,
a self-excited circuit, in which consciousness gives meaning, and thus reality, to the world?
In the past, arguments that consciousness is fundamental to reality have been dismissed
because, in the physical world, there is simply no room for consciousness to play a role.
No consciousness forces or mental particles have ever been discovered. But as the philosopher
David Chalmers has pointed out, in the quantum world, this is simply no longer the case.
And while a taboo surely exists around the subject, in quantum physics, there nonetheless
exists, quote, a giant causal opening that is perfectly suited for consciousness to fill,
end quote. A role for consciousness in quantum measurement, Chalmers points out,
finally provides this fundamental property of consciousness with a fundamental role to play.
It is worth keeping in mind that it remains a complete mystery what physical laws are actually
describing. The intrinsic nature of the world, what reality is in itself, is entirely unexplained
by physics. It is therefore at least possible that physical laws, including quantum mechanics,
are in fact rooted in consciousness. While the infamous claim that consciousness collapses the
quantum wave function may be wrong, it is a possibility we cannot yet rule out. And as we
will now explore, it is one which offers a unique account of existence as arriving in a mysterious
way from its future, future origins. Another baffling discovery of quantum physics is that
in the quantum world, future events can affect earlier events. Time can effectively double back
on itself. More broadly, this opens the striking possibility that the birth of the universe could
have been caused by its future. This was an idea proposed by the physicist John Wheeler, and later
developed by the physicist Paul Davies. Wheeler pointed out that observation of a quantum system
not only defines the state of the system in that moment, but also defines its entire history.
It is as though the act of measurement produces histories which are consistent with the present
choice to observe. As Wheeler once famously remarked, quote, we decide what the photon
shall have done after it has already done it. End quote. In recent decades, this surprising
fact of quantum physics has been demonstrated many times in laboratories, and as Wheeler argued,
there is no reason to doubt that this principle is true of the entire universe. That observations
made now, or perhaps even in the distant future, stretch all the way back to the beginning of the
universe, and thereby establish the necessary conditions in which observers can exist.
If so, we as observers are in a mysterious way participators in the existence of the universe.
Along these lines, Davies has also argued that it is at least plausible that the long-term
evolution of consciousness will one day pervade the entire universe. That through the spreading
and development of conscious minds, perhaps over billions of years, the universe is destined to
eventually realize its total mental potential. In a resulting cosmic omega point, the entire universe
finally becomes fully self-observed, thereby satisfying the conditions of its own existence,
and retroactively creating itself. Part of this, the weirdness of this quantum physics is that
observations which are made now can affect the nature of reality as it was in the past,
and in the same way observations made in the very far future, maybe a trillion years hence,
can affect the nature of reality today and back in the Big Bang. So if you buy this whole quantum
physics package and you have this universe saturated by mind or saturated by observers,
then indeed the whole character of the universe, including the emergence of its laws and the
nature of its states, become inextricably intertwined with its mentality, with its mindfulness.
Davies admits that this is a highly speculative idea, but it is nonetheless consistent with what
we know about quantum mechanics, and not an idea we can yet rule out. Existence from value.
Another possible connection between consciousness and the mystery of existence
lies in the relationship of consciousness with value. Philip Goff is among the recent wave of
defending the fundamentality of consciousness. Goff has also suggested that the animating
force of reality may be mysteriously connected to its value. Goff reminds us of an insight
first made by the philosopher David Hume in the 19th century. Hume observed that we simply do not
While we perceive a flow of events, our apparent perception of causes is an illusion.
Similarly, science does not actually reveal causes in the world. Goff points out that once
we truly recognize this, we are free to consider an alternative possibility, that natural necessity,
the animating force of existence, is not material or mechanical, but in fact follows
from its value. Goff considers that such a view might also help to explain why, against all of
the odds, the universe seems finely tuned to allow for what he calls, quote, a universe of great value
in which conscious value-sensitive beings can evolve. In the last century, cosmologists have
learned that slightly changing any number of precise values in the laws of physics
has the immediate effect of obliterating all possibility of life. Among all of the
intelligible arrangements of nature's laws, the probability of a life-friendly universe
is, in fact, trillions to one. This provocative discovery has led to the proposal, by some,
of a multiverse, trillions of other universes, the existence of which can nullify the apparent
specialness of the universe. But as Goff and others have argued, fine-tuning may actually
be an indicator of the deeper significance and necessity of consciousness on the metaphysical
landscape. The philosopher John Leslie explored this possibility in his 1979 book, Value and
Existence, where he argued that because of the problem of infinite regress, no physical mechanism
will ever be adequate to explain the universe's existence. To solve this mystery, we must go
beyond materialism and consider that something very different, more akin to value, is the animating
force of reality. If so, a universe capable of supporting value-sensitive conscious minds
might have been a metaphysical necessity. Is it possible, as the 20th century philosopher
Alfred North Whitehead believed, that, quote, existence itself is the upholding of value
intensity, end quote. The view that value is the animating force of existence is a perspective with
deep philosophical roots both in western and eastern systems of thought. Plato, in particular,
believed that the animating first cause of existence was its goodness. For Plato, existence
itself held intrinsic value over non-existence, and that this latent value was the generative force
of reality. While the human understanding of the universe has progressed a long way since the time
of Plato, there are nonetheless philosophers today who argue that Plato was essentially correct,
that the underlying nature of the universe is more mind-like than classically physical,
and the true creative force of this reality is its value. Consciousness is the vehicle of all value,
meaning, and significance in the universe. To put it bluntly, without consciousness nothing matters.
But is it also possible, as we have explored today, that without consciousness nothing would exist?
Hi everyone, I hope you found this interesting. Another highly speculative episode. Of course,
it is impossible to completely explore an area like this in a relatively short video,
but I am very curious to know what you think about this deep question of existence and
the possible connection to consciousness. So, let's talk about it in the comments.
If you enjoyed the video, please give it a like, perhaps consider sharing it. I also really want
to thank my supporters on Patreon, who are helping me to turn Waking Cosmos into a full-time project.
Thank you very much to those of you who are subscribed over on my Patreon. If you're not,
but you'd like to support my work, the place to go is patreon.com slash Waking Cosmos.
All right, that is about it from me today. I will see you next time for another episode of
Waking Cosmos, exploring the nature of consciousness and its place in reality.
Until then, I hope you have a beautiful day.
