Mayim Bialik, who holds a PhD in neuroscience, says people declared clinically dead for hours are coming back with strikingly similar reports of consciousness existing outside the body. If she's right, science still doesn't know where consciousness actually lives — or whether it can be located at all.
Mayim Bialik is a neuroscientist and co-host of "Mayim Bialik's Breakdown" alongside Jonathan Cohen.
We cover: - Why patients pronounced dead and revived describe experiences that shouldn't be possible - The theory that some people can tune into "a plane" of information most of us can't access - Why certain people can physically sense frequencies under 20 hertz that others can't hear - What dark matter and dark energy reveal about how far we still are from a theory of everything - Why I think God's existence should be open to scientific testing, not just faith
🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
The speaker argues that the existence of God should be subject to scientific inquiry rather than blind faith. By examining near-death experiences, consciousness, and the limitations of current physics, the discussion explores the tension between religious dogma and intellectual honesty, suggesting that a mature perspective on spirituality requires questioning rather than calcified beliefs.
God's existence should be subjected to scientific tests.
People say, no, you should have perfect faith.
I'm sorry, I can't do that.
You might be able to believe that.
I don't like to have beliefs.
This is a question that we ask a lot of different ways when we talk to people.
We ask astrophysicists.
It's at the basis of also the lay people that we speak to
who travel to dimensions that we cannot understand.
So when people are declared dead and zipped into a body bag for two hours
and some EMT in the back of an ambulance decides,
I'm going to see what happens if I unzip and shock.
That's astounding.
And when people come back from those experiences and say,
I got to tell you what just happened.
And it is beyond articulation.
And it shares so many threads in common.
That's what we're asking.
How are you reporting things that happened in a room that your body was locked in?
Where is consciousness?
Like, where is it?
Is it literally this entity that can float around?
And also when you speak to any educated hippie who will say,
there's a plane that I can tap into that many people cannot.
And there is information in that plane the same way.
If you have bad hearing and you can't hear the radio,
if it's not turned up enough, they don't need it turned up as high.
And this is this notion we were just talking about the infrasonic range.
It turns out it's a thing.
And there are people who are more sensitive to sounds under 20 Hertz.
Like this is news to me.
I mean, maybe it was taught to me sometime,
but I'm thinking, what does that mean for our conscious experience?
There are people who are more sensitive.
There is this variation in the human experience.
And for some people, they will call it God and other people will not.
I mean, the thing that I always say is like, I don't really care what you call it.
Like if you drop something, it's going to drop at 9.8 feet per second.
You're like, that's it.
And that's kind of what you were talking about.
It's not about belief.
I don't have to believe in gravity.
It just is.
When people say like, oh, why do bad things happen to good people?
I say, well, those are human words that you have human judgment on.
You don't know the path of the larger universe.
I'm not saying I don't have a God that cares, but those are also human concepts.
Like we're just anthropomorphizing the hell out of God.
This also ties back to the notion of the theory of everything,
because there are elements that seem to be still.
We're not able to describe them.
We're not able to understand them.
There are phenomenon like the people who are claiming to have near-death experiences.
Well, even dark matter, dark energy, where does it go?
All that, all of that stuff that's in the universe that we don't understand what it is
or where it came from.
Like we're not able to yet to pull together a theory of everything.
How do you reconcile not your proof in God,
but your faith and your personal experience outside of religion?
Can you speak to that?
To me, there's, you know, first of all,
we have to think about like this notion of belief.
Like I said, in addition to not looking for things I believe in as a scientist,
I also feel like just as a, in common sense, like is God sitting around like,
wait, I hope Brian believes in me today.
Like this would make my day.
Oh boy, my CV.
No, I'm totally inconsequential on one hand.
On the other hand, we're supposed to have these,
these two different pockets, right?
There's a great Talmudic sage.
His name was Shlomo of the Bardisha of Polish,
like some Ukrainian name that I can pronounce, but I can't pronounce it right.
And he said, a man should have two pockets.
And in each one, he should have a note in one pocket.
He should have a note that says the whole world was created for me.
And the other hand, when he feels too haughty, too cocky,
he's looks maxing too much.
He should pull it out and say, I am nothing but dust and ashes.
They should have these two opposing forces.
And it's very difficult for the human mind.
As you said, the human mind likes to create patterns,
to draw extrapolations, to do induction, you know, scientific method,
inductive version, deductive version.
And, and we love to induce patterns because that helps us survive, right?
You see the squiggle on the ground.
Is it a snake or is it a steak?
You know, it's not going to keep you alive.
He thinks every stick is a snake.
I don't like snakes.
He's very, he's very tuned in.
First of all, I think that God's existence should be subjected to scientific tests.
Now this, I get into trouble, you know, I'm wearing this funny hat, right?
So like people say, like, no, you should have perfect faith.
I believe in, you know, any mommy,
I believe in perfect faith of God and all these things are going to happen.
And I'm sorry, I can't do that.
You might be able to believe that.
I don't like to have belief, but I don't think we should limit God by saying what he,
what evidence he should, should be subjected to.
So, you know, kind of assert that you're basically saying you can't question God.
And there are a lot of bad things said, you know, by, by, you know, religious atheists,
by atheists that are almost religious in nature.
Like some of those dogmatic people, Sam Harris.
So I know you've had on, I've had him on my show.
Richard Dock.
I hosted him in person in your home nation last year.
None of them without exception have a familiarity beyond like the basics that you might get in a
yeshiva or in a Sunday school, because what did they do?
Most people like Lawrence Krauss, the most famous, you know,
kind of the militant new atheist who wrote a book called a universe from nothing,
which we'd later come to find nothing.
It ain't nothing, but, but we'll, we can discuss that some other time, right?
His, his main notion is that this is religion is damaging and surface.
So he's Jewish.
He had a bar mitzvah.
And then for most Jewish boys, Carl Sagan, Stephen Jay Gould, Sam Harris,
the bar mitzvah that they have had that I never had that they had is the graduation.
It's the getting out of prison.
It signifies I'm never setting foot in that temple.
All the boys left synagogue.
But you know, for me, I came back to it very late in life.
And so I think I have a deeper, more adult perspective on it,
but they're left with this frozen calcified sclerotic view.
But I always say to them, I said, Lawrence, would you,
cause I've interviewed him many, many times and I love these people,
but I have to be honest with them.
I can't, I'm not going to pull punches.
Cause I want to have some big name guests on my show and say, look,
would you accept this refutation of a universe from nothing from some 13 year old Pisha?
You know, as my grandfather used to say, may he rest in peace.
No, you wouldn't accept that.
Why not?
Cause he hasn't done the research.
He hasn't had enough experience, but you here,
you are accepting this refutation of the existence of God based on the
testimonials and the evidence of a 13 year old, IEU 50, 60 years ago, it's infantile.
You would never do it.
And so I think it's intellectually dishonest.