What Will It Take to Find All The Exoplanets? MAUVE and Beyond

Fraser Cain
378 followers
30 Video Views·Jan 16, 2025
we're now firmly in the era of
exoplanetary astronomy where we know of
thousands of planets orbiting around
other stars and the variety and
complexity of the planets that
astronomers have been discovering is
just beyond anyone's expectations we see
hot Jupiters we see Rocky worlds
orbiting around red dwarf stars and of
course the dream is eventually to be
able to find that other Earth orbiting
around a sunlike star now much of this
work has been done by missions that are
doing large surveys like Kepler and Tess
but you're also having James web and the
Hubble Space Telescope that are
observing these exoplanetary systems to
understand now that gets you infrared
that gets you visible light that even
gets you into the ultraviolet but there
is a part of the far ultraviolet that
can give really important information
about the escaping atmosphere coming
from these exoplanets and this is a
field that astronomers would like to
learn a lot more about my guest today is
Dr Emily Rickman she is an Issa
astronomer at the Space Telescope
Science Institute she works with a bunch
of the space telescopes Hubble James web
but also was the project manager for a
mission concept called the mission to
analyze the ultraviolet universe or move
and this is a probe class Mission think
of it like a billion dollish mission
that potentially could investigate that
far ultraviolet part of the spectrum
that would give you really interesting
information both about exoplanets about
planets here in the solar system as well
as other places of kind of extreme
ultraviolet Spectrum out there in the
universe now we talk about the move
concept and what ultraviolet gets you in
terms of planetary science but then also
we talk a lot about direct Imaging which
is really Emily's specialty what is it
going to take for us to directly observe
Earth siize worlds orbiting around some
like stars as well as just the other
interesting exoplanets that are out
there so enjoy this conversation with Dr
Emily Rickman Emily we're all familiar
with infrared astronomy thanks to
everything that's happening with James
web we're seeing Discovery after
discovery but what can we learn from
ultraviolet astronomy which is different
from infrared invisible light any other
Spectra that we are familiar with yeah
so the UV is really powerful because
that's where a lot of the really highly
energetic things are happening in the
universe so the things that we really
cannot capture with the infrared with
the visible and things that are really
exciting events so big explosive
energetic events that we just don't see
as bright in those infrared and visible
wavelengths so it's really important to
capture what's happening in the UV to
really get a scope and understanding of
like the diversity of wavelengths and
what's happening all of these different
wavelengths and they each tell a
different part of the story and so if
you could swap out your eyes with
ultraviolet eyes what could you see in
the universe what would it look like oh
you would see all of the really exciting
explosions that have that are happening
or have happened in recent at least
recent on astronomical time scales um
you would see things like atmospheric
escape on planets you would see perhaps
active Aurora on more locally within our
solar system on planets like Jupiter so
lots of these really exciting um
energetic events happening in the
universe uh but we also have to be
careful because uh UV detectors are
actually often quite sensitive and so we
actually don't want to look at things
that are too bright and accidentally fry
the detectors on board our on board our
telescopes so that's something we
actually have to take into consideration
uh when we observe these kind of things
uh because there's so much energy from
these wavelengths it becomes quite a
fragile thing so we actually have to
protect our detectors when we when we do
these kind of observations I didn't
realize that okay so I mean there are
these classic images taken by both
Hubble Space Telescope and James web
where you can compare them right with
James web you can actually see through
the gas and dust to see the stars and
such forming inside with Hubble with
ultraviolet you're seeing those really
bright stars and so how do we mitigate
the damage to the telescope potentially
if we're going to look at those really
bright regions yeah so one of the
important things is is the number of
phot that reach our detector in a given
amount of time so we discussed this in
terms of counts uh like per second and
there's basically a limit of any UV
detector of how many photons can be
received into that detector at a given
time otherwise you can basically fry
your detector you don't want to be doing
that um so we we know these limits these
are well defined and we also have a
buffer um so you know there is sort of a
leeway room within there that we that we
know and when you planning your
observations as an astronomer you have
to make sure that you're under that
count limit essentially so if you're
interested in looking at a bright Target
that might mean using a certain
observing setup so it's a certain filter
or a certain grating or a certain
exposure time that means that the counts
that you're receiving are not so high
that you're in that risky category that
might end up causing um some damage that
doesn't need to be done and actually
it's part of my job as someone who works
for hub to assess these programs and
make sure that we don't go over those
limits and that our observers are within
that safe regime so like when I do
astrophotography and I'm looking at some
really bright object and you get this
sort of oversaturation where one part of
the CCD fills up and goes into the
neighboring regions then that means that
you can't sort of see one specific part
but like you're saying that in fact if
you get more and more exposure it's
actually causing damage to the
underlying Electronics yeah exactly so
yes we have CCD on Hubble as well and
the CCD exactly as you say that these
buckets the photons fill up their
buckets and can overspill and then
you're in that saturated regime and
although that's less than ideal that
doesn't necessarily cause damage you
might have um instrumental effects like
persistence where if you take uh an um
an image of a really bright object and
saturate the detector if you then take a
follow-up observation you might see
these sort of ghosts that are
persistence from a previous observation
where you've been staring at a really
bright object but they're not damaged
they they go away with time and and
these are known artifacts whereas on the
UV side um the detectors are quite
different and I I will admit I'm not
enough of a detector expert to go into
the physics of it but you you don't have
the same physics that's required like in
a CCD where you essentially have a
bucket that fill ups with photons but
rather if you go above a certain count
rate of photons you actually just reach
a point where the detector will not will
not behave and will essentially get
fried yes so it's a little bit different
yeah yeah okay that's really interesting
I mean I know that you can't get a sort
of a traditional telescope mirror with
the higher end of the spectrum when
you've got sort of a dish that's
reflecting infinid light or visible
light but with x-rays and Camera Rays
you have to switch to a different
methodology is is there sort of like a
place where UV fits along that range
yeah right and even within the UV
there's quite a wide wavelength range
and we talk about different aspects of
the UV regime in itself so that there's
the extreme UV the far UV and a near UV
and so if Hubble we kind of capture the
um far UV or fuv for short and then near
UV or nuv for short um but with move or
mauve as our American viewers will call
it that's when we really probe into the
extreme UV that was part of this
proposal uh from for this Mission so
even within the UV the there's quite a
wide wavelength regime and as you say
you also can go down to the X-ray gamma
ray and then you really start talking
about different detective physics and
the ways that we capture those really
important wavelengths as well all right
so I think we've jumped to the part in
the conversation which is why I
originally reached out this idea of move
mauve
I I forget how we pronounce it in Canada
uh you know we're still part of the
British Empire sort of and do we
pronounce it like the Americans I'm I'm
confused now it was a source of
discussion on our team I was I was the
only foreign National everyone else was
from the US and so it it became a bit of
contention friendly
contention yes but you held your ground
you didn't let it bleed into your brain
and change the way you pronounce it so
so what is this yeah so um move or Mau
is um stands for a mission to analyze
the ultra violet Universe um in
astronomy we love a good acronym so it's
it's not too bad of an acronym actually
but the idea is that it's a proc class
Mission uh that was designed as part of
the inaugural NASA astrophysics Mission
design school so um just to give a bit
of context to that so NASA hosts the
these Mission design uh schools every
year and they usually alternate between
planetary science so missions and probes
that would um look at planets within our
solar system and also Helio physics so
things focusing on looking at like solar
physics for example and and our son um
but they hadn't done an astrophysics
Mission design school before and so this
was the first year that they decided to
to do it and it's a pretty extensive
program uh it lasts a few months and it
brings together a team of uh people who
some with more of an expertise in
science some with more of an engineering
background and basically become a
mission design team to pull together a
hypothetical propos proposal for a
mission and that's what this Mission
ended up being and so we essentially
identified a a science area that could
be captured by a mission that maybe
isn't currently capturing that kind of
science to the extent that would be
needed to answer the questions that we
were interested in and we came up with a
few different uh science questions and
sort of based these to come up with
hypotheses of how we would answer those
questions and then that's how move came
to exist as a concept and was our
response to that and that also included
you know assessing what the current
missions are either previously or
ongoing or potentially future missions
as well um but we identified that there
was this area that wasn't quite being
captured at the moment in the extreme UV
and that became a real focus of this of
this Mission design so help me
understand this like where is the UV
spectrum and does this fall outside of
the ability of Hubble yeah a little bit
so the extreme UV as we've identified it
within this Mission concept is when
within like 50
to20
nanom um so this Falls a little bit more
extem than what Hubble covers and also
to be clear as well this Mission concept
wasn't like to replace Hubble but more
so to be complimentary to the science
that Hubble does and other UV missions
as well but Hubble Is is the big one um
and it's to kind of just push down in
that wavelength regime at the resolution
that um move would look at which is
about R of 1000 in spectral resolution
uh which I will also note is a lower
resolution then Hubble I don't want this
whole thing to become into a big
comparison between Hubble and but
there's but there's certain aspects that
are you know that they're complimentary
to Hubble so and sort of are perhaps
better or worse or different
specifications to to what Hubble
provides in its science okay so I
understand that web is a larger
telescope and it uses the infrared it
has this larger collecting area but that
also infrared is sort of slower and more
difficult to be able to produce an image
and so do you have sort of like a
similar situation with ultraviolet like
how does the the size of the mirror
compare to sort of the expected outcome
of your Observatory um I mean you
ideally you always want a bigger mirror
just so that your sensitivity is higher
like in an in an Ideal World given
infinite money and resources you would
have a giant giant mirror because that
is really about capturing the
sensitivity so that's what one of the
really key things in going bigger and
it's and bigger bigger is always better
in that sense because then you can just
capture more phons so um but in this
particular case because this is like a
probe class Mission there there is a
restriction on the amount of
hypothetical money that would be poured
into this and that puts a restriction on
how large your telescope can be as well
like with any project including cble
including JW
So when you say a pro class what are the
restrictions that are put on so the proc
class within NASA is a billion dooll um
Mission so just to put that in
comparison so jwst is what's part of
NASA Flagship so these are the very
large missions that get designed over a
number of years a number of decades even
as a concept that would have been
designed for the past 30 years at least
for jwst and similar for Hubble and and
soon for the Roman Space Telescope that
will be launched in a couple years from
now so those flagships are really order
of magnitude higher so there're
something like $10
billion um and that's really and also
contributions from other space agencies
so like the European space agency that I
work for for example whereas these
smaller class missions and I say smaller
they're not small they're still like
billion dollar that's still a lot of
money um that's what we kind of call the
probe class missions so these are
missions that are designed by scientists
and science teams and they usually have
like a principal investigator or Pi who
uh will be based at like a US
institution who's interested in
answering a particular science topic and
maybe some auxiliary science that's
associated with that and NASA will put
out a call asking the community to say
Hey you know we're interested to hear
the input from the astronomical
Community what kind of science questions
would you like to answer and that's when
a science team with a pi will put
forward their idea and say this is what
we're interest in answering and in order
to answer this these are the kind of
requirements that would be necessary so
that might be uh spectral resolution
might be mirror size might be yeah
wavelength range or what kind of
detector you would need in order to
answer that um might be Imaging versus
spectroscopy or both potentially um but
you really are sort of Nar down in that
probe class by the by the budget it's
it's always by the budget um and and
that's really what defines the probe
class yeah it's funny that people are
excited about various missions but they
don't realize the scale of the mission
are they a flagship class are they a
discovery class are they a probe class
like a classic example of this is the
test mission which has found a ton of
new exoplanets and actually is a fairly
lowbudget Mission so it's a probe class
not a flagship and yet there were these
Flagship missions like Kepler which
delivered a tremendous amount of science
so were you going into this trying to
figure out like what are the kinds of
scientific outcomes that we can produce
with a spacecraft of these constraints
what we did was looked at What's called
the astro2020 decadal survey and this is
a report that comes out from the
astronomical Community about once every
10 years hence the name and it's
basically a big uh survey of the
astronomical community that are asked to
put forward white papers to say hey this
is a science um question that's really
important to to me and what I work on
how can we answer that and and what
resources and what facilities are we
missing in order to answer that and so
we use that 2020 decadal survey as a
starting point to say these are the big
questions that the astronomical
Community asking right now and have
listed as their priorities so there is a
committee that takes on board of these
white papers looks and sees maybe what
the recurring themes are like what maybe
there's a substantial number of white
papers covering a similar topic and that
committee compiles all of those things
into one large report uh that anyone can
go and read if you're interested it's a
very large document but if you want some
bedtime reading go ahead and read it um
I've skimmed it you know do a keyword
search for habitable world I I love that
that's what you brought up so we can
definitely talk about that
um but yeah so it's basically presented
by the National Academy of Sciences and
we use that as a starting point to say
this is what the committee have
highlighted as the priorities and the
broad questions that the astronomical
Community would like to answer and of
those topics which ones would we would
we want to focus on which do we think
are important and which ones can we also
sort of Clump together in a way because
not all wavelengths are going to answer
all questions because you're probing
different physics so if if you're going
to focus on one wavelength then you're
going to start answering a cluster of
questions that might not answer another
cluster of questions that you might need
a different wavelength range for like
the infrared for example so the things
that our team highlighted that we were
interested in happened to sort of be in
this UV realm um and then that ended up
being a couple of topics covered by the
astro2020 that ended up being the
questions that we wanted to answer for
this for this mission so when you think
about a mission like James web or Hubble
you have these science goals you're
trying to look into regions where new
exoplanets are forming or you're looking
at the very beginning of the universe so
what were the science goals that you
were looking to put into move as you
were doing this design yeah so I I'm
going to focus mostly on the planetary
ones because that's what my expertise is
but the um some of the science questions
that we really had in mind were related
to looking at atmospheric Escape of
exoplanets um and this in order to do
this you specifically want to look at
the Lyman Alpha line which exists in the
sort of border between the extreme UV
and far UV so you really need the U UV
wavelength range in order to do that so
basically that's looking at transiting
exoplanet so as a planet transits in
front of its host star you can assess
the atmospheric properties of that star
um and a lot of the work that goes on in
the infrared for example looks at the
atmospheric composition of the the
planets you can also do this in the UV
as well um but you can also assess if
the atmosphere of that planet is
escaping and that really presents itself
in that Lyman Alpha regime and so one of
the really key topics that we were
looking at with the mo mission was
answering looking at do we see escaping
atmospheres and what could that mean for
the habitability of planets that we're
looking at helping us assess where could
we potentially find life in the universe
you have to understand the kind of
environments that these planets exist in
um you know if you are trying to look at
rocky planets around M dwarfs like the
trapis system for example or um any kind
of planetary system for that for that
matter then you really need to
understand like what the impact of of
the star and and how that might impact
the atmosphere of the planet orbiting
that star obviously if you're losing the
atmosphere of the planet that you are
actively trying to live on that's not a
good sign for life so these things
really help us understand habitability I
mean if we could build a time machine
and go back in time and look at Venus
Earth and Mars at the beginning of the
solar system and then watch as they
progress through time and we see how
Venus becomes drier how Mars loses its
atmosphere but obviously we can't do
that but maybe there's a way we could
see this happening in other star systems
exactly and actually often like using
these space telescopes is really a way
for us to sort of treat them as a time
machine in a way not only are we looking
back potentially when we're looking in
the outer reaches of the universe we are
almost looking back in time because of
the amount of time it's taken for that
light to uh to arrive at us but also in
the way that you're absolutely right
it's like comparative planetology when
you're looking at other systems you can
if you're looking at a system younger
than our own solar system then you can
start to um hypothesize is this similar
to how our solar system look like at
that moment in time and now we're at
this point in our in time could that
system that we're looking at
comparatively end up looking like our
solar system or not we and these are
some of the questions that we're trying
to answer um you do also have to take
into account different spectral type so
our star is a certain spectral type some
of these planets that we look at are or
around stars that have different
spectral types um but they're also
really important for us to understand
more globally like how these planets
form and evolve and what the atmospheres
look like but you're absolutely right
like it would be fascinating to have uh
to be able to look back in time on our
own planets especially our own
terrestrial planets here and understand
how their atmospheres evolved and so
what kind of limiting spectral types are
you looking for is it more like red
dwarfs or stars like the sun um it's
more so with atmospheric Escape it's
more of a question of like how close the
planets are to the star because ones
that are highly irradiated by the from
from the UV from the Star itself are
going to be very um hot planets that um
are more likely to show signs of these
atmospheric Escape but things like M
dwarfs um which is what the the trapis
star is an M dwarf you have to be
careful with those spectral types
because they M dwarfs are very active
they have a lot of activity going on in
the star they have a lot of flaring um
and these high energetic events like
flaring that we see on M dwarfs can
cause things like that we believe to
cause things like atmospheric Escape so
that's very different to our own Sun
that is quite honestly a pretty boring
star like we don't I mean I love the Sun
but it's it's not very exciting it
doesn't have a lot of these done for us
lately
yeah which is good for us because it
means that we exist here and we we live
here and it's and that's good but it's
really important for us to understand
these other spectral types and
especially these highly energetic
spectral types like M dwars but could
you use this as a method of planetary
discovery that you're seeing the
atmospheric escape and so you're able to
infer the presence of a
planet so we see the atmospheric
atmospheric Escape like after or sort of
like during the transit of the planet
itself so I couldn't Envision that we
would just see atmospheric Escape
without already having seen the planet
or seen the transit of the planet um so
I don't see it as a way to discover
planets um unless there's anyone
watching this who has a really excellent
idea of how we could Implement that I
would love to hear from you um but it's
more of a way of like we go from
detecting planets to characterizing them
right so not only discovering them but
actually understanding what their
properties are and that includes the
but the other thing that you mentioned
is being able to detect auroras on
exoplanets yeah so I I'm not sure the
sensitivity that would be required to do
this for extra planets but we certainly
see this in our own solar system so for
example in Jupiter we see this active
Aurora um in the UV that was actually
something that was quite unexpected when
this was first discovered um this is
still something that I think the
sensitivity of seeing this on exoplanets
with them being so far away might quite
difficult but I think this is something
that we could definitely think about in
the future and I know uh again different
wavelength ranging with jwst but we
actually do see some we see this on
Brown dwarfs where we're seeing Aurora
um that could be caused by like a sort
of equivalent of a moon alting around W
I know that story yeah right and so
that's a really exciting case and we
could if we had the sensitivity then
that could be something that that maybe
we could see as well yeah I like this
idea of potentially detecting exoplanets
by the emissions from the magnetosphere
of the planet you know perhaps you put a
radio telescope on the far side of the
moon it's protected from emissions from
the earth and so it can look out and see
these auroras interacting with the solar
wind of the star and that tells us that
the planet is there and you know maybe
there's a version of that where you
could do that with ultraviolet but I can
see that maybe that's a flagship and not
a probe yeah and I I think it's
something to to think about for a future
Flagship um
so um but yeah I think I think the
sensitivity of something like Mo just
wouldn't given the size of it being a
proc class Mission I just don't think
would be substantial enough to to get
those kind of observations I've done a
lot of reporting on the life mission the
large interferometer for exoplanets and
they've got two modes like one mode is
they can examine known exoplanets but
the other mode is they can start to
search for potential candidate exoplanet
so that they could then study further
and so do you think that we're going to
have to get to this place where we've
run out of candidates we're going have
to build a Kepler 2 to do this really
widescale search for more potential
candidates to then hand over to those
detailed telescopes like life or hwo so
I think right now we are still actively
looking for all of those candidates so
you know like I said KLA has been a part
of that Tess continues to be a part of
that and and Plato will also be a part
of that as well um but I
think like yeah there are lots of
missions that are really sort of looking
for those candidates right now so you
think by the time that habitable worlds
will be uh getting close to a real real
concept and a real design and a real a
real Mission we're still talking like
decades at this point so you we've still
got a lot of science to do between now
and then when that actually gets refined
in order like what will we look at um
Roman is going to have such a huge
impact on this like the number of exra
planets that Roman is is destined to
find is is going to be really impactful
and I I don't know if the community is
even ready for that in terms of that I
think that's really going to shape the
discussion around what the candidates
might be for habital worlds I think
we're still a little bit premature in
having that discussion right now if I'm
honest um you know we do we are basing
it on what we currently know and also
bearing in mind as well it's not just um
space missions I mean there's a lot of
groundbased work that's going on
complementary to space-based missions as
well so the radial velocity technique is
very powerful in monitoring planets over
a long period of time and there are many
different facilities around the world
that are doing this and this is really
important to do this High Precision or
extreme Precision even radial velocity
from the ground and that's being used as
precursor measurement technique in order
to select the candidates that we may
ultimately end up observing with
habitable worlds Observatory so I think
we're still relatively early days in
terms of uh what the target list might
look like for habitable world's
Observatory I know there are some
preliminary Target lists that have been
sent around and are a really good
starting point for that discussion um
and it's not to say that those targets
will or will not be observed it's just a
starting point for the discussion um but
I think Roman is going to change so much
like I I I really do think that so I'm
very excited to see over the next five
or so years um like what that's going to
look like after it launches yeah I've
reported on these Target lists and it's
like a really nice list of like it's a
good Planet it's around the right kind
of star it's in a nice orbit but we
don't know for sure that this really is
an earth 2.0 I want to go back to
talking about direct Imaging because you
know with the transit method you can
only see when the planet is passing in
front of a star with the radial velocity
method gives you a leeway you know
you're measuring
the movement of the Star as the planet
is pulling it around with its gravity
with astrometry you can see the planet
when it's sort of moving and making the
star form a little circle in the sky but
direct Imaging would let us see all of
the orientations you just block the
light from the Star and then you see all
the planets I want to see all the planet
what would it take for us to see all the
planets time money
resources coronagraphs yeah coronagraphs
um yeah I mean the biggest limitations
with direct Imaging is really the
contrast that we can achieve between uh
the contrast of the Stellar host so that
the star that the planets are orbiting
around and the planets themselves so
direct Imaging really lends itself to
more massive more luminous planets so if
you're more massive you give off more
light more flux it's much easier you're
in a much easier contrast regime in
order to directly image those things H
planets are also much more luminous when
they're younger so it lends itself to
much younger systems which is the
opposite of what the radial velocity
method typically favors Aller systems
because you want to look at stars that
don't have a lot of Stellar activity
because you're looking at the star
itself um but really actually a lot of
the things I work on are very
complimentary in nature and so high
contrast Imaging I would say is my is my
realm and my expertise but I use a lot
of radial velocity observations and
astrometric observations to as precursor
to find the targets that I then go on to
directly image and that's really
powerful if you can combine all of these
techniques because you start removing
some of the limitations of each of those
things and actually use that to your
advantage to understand the systems that
you're looking at um and really
understand the things like the masses of
the planets that you're looking at and
the orbital configurations of the
planets that you're looking at which you
need more than one observation technique
in order to do that because there are
there are too many unknowns if you just
use one technique but Imaging yeah like
our limitations are the chronographs and
there's a lot of Technology development
that's going on right now I mentioned
previously the tech demo for Roman for
the CGI coronograph but there's a lot of
future technology development that's
going on Beyond even what Roman's doing
but what a future chronograph might look
like to get down to those really extreme
contrast ratios to start looking and
imaging potentially terrestrial planets
and then that's when things are going to
get really exciting I've asked people
this question before and I've been told
no but I'm always going to just keep
trying so we think back Kepler right he
was looking at this wide field of view
watching all of these stars to see if
any of them Dim when you think about Gia
watching all of these Stars I'm watching
to see if any of them have this Telltale
signature of a planet moving the star
but is there an analog in direct Imaging
where you could just like look at a
whole bunch of stars all at the same
time and see if any of them have planets
moving around them you know is there a
way to quickly sort through that hay
stack to to find the needle or do you
have to like pick up the hay one piece
at a time yeah that's a really
interesting question uh because we do
have to take on this very targeted
approach just because of the nature of
the observations if you have one
chronograph that you can put over one
star then and you also need to stare at
the system for a very long time in order
to get the sensitivity required um in
order to pick up the photons from the
planet orbiting the star um I'm not sure
what a potential architect of
architecture of a mission would look
like in order to or architecture of a
telescope would look like in order to do
like a multi-target approach to
chronographic Imaging um you could
there's also non- chronographic Imaging
where you don't reach the same
sensitivity but you could potentially
Envision a wider field of view trying to
just capture images of companions around
stars um without a chronograph but the
sensitivity there really wouldn't be
substantial and actually you'd probably
just capture a lot of binary systems
which is something we already do with a
lot of other telescopes um but that's a
good that's an interesting point one of
the other things as well because of the
observational setup of doing
chronographic observations is you really
require the angular diversity and what I
mean by that is when you take an
observation you want to take an
observation at one angle and then at
another and you use both of these angles
in our data processing techniques in
order to increase the sensitivity that
we get of these observations and because
that is unique to each system that we
look at I don't know how you would take
that into account to do this across
multiple stars at a given time I mean I
see hints of it I think about say the
very large telescope has this sphere
instrument that allows it to measure the
polarized light that comes from the
atmosphere of an exoplanet compared to
the light that's coming from the Stars
you can imagine if you could observe
this wide field of the sky and and only
look for that polarized light that would
tell you was coming from the planets
themselves but but you know I'm just
sort of thinking this through yeah
that's a good point and maybe the other
way you could think about it is if there
was a way that we could look for a
unique atmospheric feature that you
wouldn't expect to see on the star but
you'd only expect to see on planets and
you would just able to pull out that
very specific molecular feature for
example that could show you hints of
where planets are existing without
having to rely on kind of similar to the
polarized light aspect but just looking
for features that are unique planets
that we don't see on stars but again the
issue You' run into is the sensitivity
of doing that we're back to atmospheric
Escape like maybe there's a way to
perceive the atmospheric Escape coming
from all of these star anyway I will
keep asking the question and I'm sure
like somebody will eventually say oh
yeah no we could just do it with a
quantum computer pick up a quantum
computer and it'll be done always the
answer actually had a chance to talk
with Lee fineberg about quantum
computers in our interview and he's
really excited about like he's one of
the main people behind both James web
and the Hubble Space Telescope and I
think you know if he's excited about
quantum computers then maybe that's what
comes next Emily what are you obsessed
with right now so I I I've kind of
hinted to this a few times but for me
it's so yes I love discovering planets
but for me it's really understanding the
planets that we look at so understanding
their atmospheres understanding what's
going on uh within the layers of the
atmosphere so for the first time we're
starting to see like silic Cloud
features directly on planets for the
first time and starting to get these
real hints of things like disequilibrium
chemistry happening on these planets and
I am obsessed with really understanding
what the atmospheric processes are of
these planets and how we understand them
so I that's really where my Avenue is
going right now and I'm really excited
to start learning more about these um
planetary atmospheres there's this quote
that resonates with me that the universe
is weirder than we can imagine that you
know we astronomers are looking for
things and then stuff just pops up that
nobody ordered and so when you're making
these observations are you surprised at
what you see yeah I think we're
definitely starting to see a molecular
features on some of these planets that
we didn't necessarily expect to observe
or we didn't necessarily expect to
observe them at such a um like frequency
or such a large amount and so that is
really starting to challenge our idea of
some of our atmospheric models that we
have currently and I think we're really
in this data Rich regime right now like
we're actually at a point where we
really need the modelers to catch up or
we need more people working in mod
working in modeling in order to
understand the things that we're looking
at um because lots of these obscurities
are coming up where we're trying to
fully understand what's going on and
there's lots of different components of
that atmospheric models are very
complicated and they take you know
there's a lot of physics under the
surface under the hood so to speak and
uh but it's really exciting because it's
really starting to challenge our
conception of what these atmospheres
look like and and JW is really opening a
new chapter on that and really helping
us to understand different layers of
atmospheres that we haven't been able to
probe previously and different molecular
features especially at those longer
wavelengths that midinfrared regime that
Jost is you know designed for and it
perfect T that's really where we're
starting to see these obscurities of
things that we perhaps didn't expect or
didn't expect to the level that we're
seeing and so do you think it's a planet
in a situation that we just don't have
here in the solar system you know if you
have this planet that's Incredibly Close
to the star then you can have clouds of
molten metal and that makes sense but is
it also maybe strange chemistry that's
behaving in ways that you weren't
expecting I think um so I guess it's not
it's it's strange chemistry in the fact
that like you know perhaps why is that
molecule there in that amount at that at
given like the age of the system for
example we're not seeing strange
chemistry is and like I don't think
anything is breaking our physics quite
yet but understanding or at least not
yet I will say um but at least
understanding why is that amount of
molecule on this planet at this given
time and where did it come from and what
process what process is under happening
in order for that to be produced um you
know sometimes we see molecules that we
would expect to be um completely gone by
the time a planet reaches a certain age
um like radiated because of its star for
example because of its Stell host um
could come from things like it could be
signs of life but it could also come
from things like geological activity or
we could be probing just a wavelength
that we haven't been able to really see
before because we haven't had access to
that wavelength regime with previous
facilities um or that particular object
hasn't been observed in that wavelength
before and then that could start opening
up like a different layer of the
atmosphere we're looking at which gives
us more clues to things like thermal
inversions that are happening on on the
atmospheres of these planets which is um
something that we need to take into
account and potential um interactions
between planetary interiors and their
atmospheres that we haven't really been
able to probe so much before so you know
strange chemistry and strange is a
really difficult word because it it's
not strange in the sense that like well
we don't the physics to explain that but
it's more like Okay so this thing must
be happening we know the physics but we
need to understand what exactly is
happening on this planet um in order for
that to come about well it's a
fascinating time to be an exoplanetary
researcher Emily thank you so much for
your time and good luck searching for
Earth 2.0 thank you I hope you enjoyed
that conversation with Dr Emily Rickman
now we talked a bit about direct Imaging
of exoplanets but Emily and I imagined
potential spacecraft missions uh ways to
go much further into direct Imaging what
is it going to take for us to be able to
directly image planets orbiting around
sunlike stars and so uh if you want to
see this longer conversation special
behind the scenes you can definitely
check that out over on patreon.com
universetoday and this is just available
free you don't have to give us any money
but you can go over sign up for patreon
and then be able to watch that part of
the episode now I'm going to give you
some additional resources related
interviews that I think you'll find
really interesting but first I'd like to
thank our patrons thanks to Abe Kingston
Adam Schaefer andream gross Bar Lake
Roofing David Gilton and David mats
Dennis Liberty Dustin cable James Clark
Jeremy M Jim Burke Jordan young Josh
Schultz Paul robach Science World
rec.org spiders swap. Steven Kaki Steven
fer Munley and Vlad chiplin who support
us at the master of the universe level
and all of other supporters on patreon
now there was a lot of Concepts that
came up during this conversation and a
lot of topics that I have done existing
interviews about that I think you would
find really interesting now we're going
to put the links down in the show notes
because there's like too many to put
links here up on on YouTube but I
interviewed the people behind the
coronograph for the Nancy Grace Roman
telescope I interviewed the people who
are working on Next Generation ideas for
the habitable world's observatories
coronograph I've also talked to people
who are attempting to image uh planets
orbiting around red D Stars s people who
are working on trying to characterize
the atmospheres of red dorf Stars I've
interviewed people who are working
behind the Plato Mission the Gaia
Mission as well as I mentioned Lee
feberg who is sort of one of the key
people behind both Hubble and James web
Space Telescope so we have a lot of
interviews that you can then follow and
sort of build a more complete
understanding of this topic which
obviously really fascinates me all right
we'll see you next time
