Sword Review - Cold Steel Kriegsmesser

Ancient Edge
3 followers
14 Video Views·Jan 16, 2025
I review the recently released Cold Steel kriegsmesser. This sword/war knife has an interesting history, transitioning from a future Balaur Arms product to Cold Steel. With a decided lack of good production messers on the market, aside from Landsknecht Emporium, this sword is a welcome addition to Cold Steel's catalog.
There's a real dearth of Kriegsmessers available on the budget market. While both Cold Steel and
Condor have some that could qualify, they're not really designed according to historical norms.
And frankly, there's not much available at the high-end market either.
You're looking at basically Lands Connect Emporium or a one-off custom.
It's into this void of a market that Cold Steel brings their new Kriegsmesser.
Hello, this is Kyle, also known as AlienTube, and today I am reviewing that Cold Steel Kriegsmesser,
which I bought recently for $380 US dollars. Now chances are you're already familiar with
Cold Steel. They have an extensive catalog of items and an aggressive marketing style that
tries entirely too hard to be cool, in my opinion at least. What you may not know is that they don't
actually make any of their own swords, knives, blades, whatever. They contract that out to a
variety of forges. Most of their Japanese-style swords are made by Wanwo Forge, I apologize for
my pronunciation, and their medieval swords are generally made by Windlass. This Kriegsmesser
is a departure from those traditional sources and its roots trace back to Cult of Athena.
Now as you're probably aware if you've watched my channel, Cult of Athena had designed a variety of
and contracted out to a forge in India, creating the Balor Arms brand. And in late 2020 that forge
teased out images of a new Kriegsmesser for the line. But shortly after that, Cult of Athena and
the forge had a falling out, mostly due to the forge not using the steel that they said they
were using, but there were also some undisclosed reasons as well. The owner of that forge attempted
to sell several of these Kriegsmessers to people on Facebook. They paid him via PayPal and then he
ghosted them. So they ended up getting their money back through a PayPal dispute, but ever since then
it kind of felt like this sword was never going to happen. And then Cold Steel's 2022 catalog came out
and lo and behold the Kriegsmesser was in it, along with a single-edged viking sword that looked
identical to the Balor Arms version. It wasn't available immediately, but when it popped up
on MidwayUSA's website a few months ago, I jumped on it. So let's talk about the purchasing
experience. MidwayUSA offered free fast shipping, and they're not joking about fast. I got a tracking
number the same day and it arrived just a couple days later. Now both the listing on Midway's
website and on Cold Steel say that the Kriegsmesser comes complete with the scabbard.
It doesn't. It comes with a simple leather frog here. So I contacted Midway asking about the
scabbard, and they offered to let me return the sword. I didn't want to do that though. I liked
the sword from what I saw of it, and I just wanted the scabbard they said it came with.
So they said they didn't have any of the scabbard, so I contacted Cold Steel instead.
Their representative also suggested I return it at their cost, and they would ship me a new one.
Now at the same time, somebody else who bought one of these Kriegsmessers from Midway
contacted the forge that makes them, and that forge confirmed that they are not making scabbards
for it. So in the end, I decided not to send this back to Cold Steel because I knew I wasn't going
to get a scabbard, and I didn't want to risk any shipping issues or anything like that.
So if you do end up buying one of these Kriegsmessers, don't believe the listing,
which still says it comes with a scabbard. It doesn't. It comes with this frog, which
I suppose it does work. You know, you can put it in, and I've tried it out, and it works. But
frankly, I don't really want this bare blade attached to me. I want a scabbard if I'm going
to wear it. So now let's take a look at the hilt. The grip is composed of two rosewood scales pinned
to the tang via four copper pins. I find there are no uncomfortable ledges in here at all,
and in fact, I find this grip incredibly comfortable to use. I really enjoy the feel
of it. I always have a good idea of where the edge is, so indexing the blade works very well.
I have seen some people who say they consider the grip a little bit too smooth, but I think
that's personal taste, because for me, it's perfect. The pommel here is traditionally
shaped with a little beak on the end. I will say that I assume the purpose of that beak is to help
keep your grip from slipping off, but I think it's a little too small to do that. I mean, if I
threw it out there, I could slide my hand past that very easily. But it's, you know, it's a
traditional shape, so that's good. And while the polish is all right, one thing I've noticed about
all the swords I've received that were sourced from the original Balor Arms Forge, the pommels
rust really easily. Like, this one, this is the second time this pommel has already developed a
little bit of rust on it, and I keep this oiled. I don't know how it is constantly getting rust on it,
but even when I keep it oiled all the time, it seems like a week or two later, if I look at the
sword, the pommel has rust on it. This is true of not just this Kriegsmesser. Every sword that I
have owned from that forge does this specifically with the pommel. Not the crossguard, not the blade,
just the pommel. I don't have this issue with other swords, just this company's swords and
their pommels. It's a very weird situation. I'm not sure what's causing it, but I might end up
switching to Renaissance Wax instead of oil to help protect the pommel. The other thing to note
about the pommel is it is peened. I don't know if you're going to be able to see that here. It's
smoothed out very, very well, but there is a very slight trace of peening on it. Now, the nagel here
is also peened, which is a nice touch. I know some budget messers don't actually peen it, and it
should be peened. The shape of the nagel is pretty nice. I like the scallops here. It is a bit on the
chunky and oversized side. The crossguard is a very simple design with a rectangular shape that
flares out and then has just a little bit of detailing here to make it octagonal at the very
tips of the quill ends. I think it would do a lot to improve the look of the crossguard
if they took the time to kind of put in a groove right here and make it more octagonal
across the entire crossguard. I think that would both look better and just bring the whole
hilt together better. Looking at the gap between the crossguard and the blade, it's there
and it's bigger than it needs to be, but it's not too bad. If you also look at the nagel where it
meets the crossguard, you can see some asymmetries right in here, and that's not a big deal, especially
at this price range. And frankly, it's probably more true to the originals than perfection would be.
Now it's time to talk about the business end, the blade. As always, here's my measurements.
As you can see, this sword features a lot of distal taper. The spine starts at about seven
millimeters thick at the guard, and then for every six inches down the blade, it thins another
millimeter for about half the length. And then at that point, it starts slowing down the taper
all the way down to the tip where it gets to just below three millimeters. This leads to a blade that
is pretty flexible, actually, perhaps a little too flexible for my taste. You'll see in cutting
footage later that when I quickly change directions on the sword, it does flex quite a bit.
Now, one sword that this is inevitably going to draw comparisons to is the Albion Connect,
which is no longer available. Sadly, I don't have a Connect to compare it to, but I did manage to
find some measurements of its distal taper, and I'll put up a comparison on the screen here.
You can see that the Connect definitely is a thicker blade at the start, starting at eight
millimeters thick, and generally it seems to maintain a thicker spine than the Cold Steel
Kriegsmesser pretty much throughout the entire blade, except right at the very end where it gets
a little bit thinner. But anyways, this isn't a review of the Connect, and let's go back to the
Cold Steel Kriegsmesser. It is finished in a nice satin finish that, like pretty much all
Balor Arms swords I've had, shows scratches and scuffs and use very, very easily. It's not a
perfectly even satin finish, but it is nice. There's a lot of rippling if you look down the surface of
the blade, which again is very normal for this forge's swords, and to be expected at this price
point. The fullers are ground pretty evenly, although they do wobble here and there and finish
in slightly different places on the blade. Now, the sword does have a secondary bevel rather than one
smooth bevel all the way from the spine to the edge. This is very, very common in India. Now,
while it is possible to ship sharp blades out of India, I believe the company needs a specific
and expensive license to do so. So, most forges just make their swords blunt and will have them
elsewhere. That is true of this Kriegsmesser, and the secondary bevel is actually quite even for me.
It doesn't really wobble much at all. Right here towards where it starts curving, it gets a little
bit uneven, but it's not bad at all. I have seen some people who bought one of these Kriegsmessers
say that their sharpening job was a lot more uneven. I guess it probably depends on who sharpens it.
It also came very sharp. It's paper cutting sharp right out of the box,
but it is still feel... the edge still feels rough. I think they put a strong edge on it
with lower grit belts, but then didn't do much job polishing the edge with higher grit belts.
I think about 10 to 15 minutes with some of the higher grit belts and some stropping,
and this thing would be ferociously sharp. So, let's take a look at some cutting footage.
So,
this Kriegsmesser cuts very well, even in my amateur hands. With my poor accuracy, I took
a pretty big chunk out of my cutting stand, and the Kriegsmesser took no damage or was not bothered
by that at all. So, handling, this Kriegsmesser weighs about three and a quarter pounds. It's
balanced around four and a half inches out from the cross guard, and generally speaking, it feels
quite nimble. I know where my... where the edge is at all times, thanks to the... what I consider to
be the excellent shaping of the grip. I don't need to worry about indexing the blade. It works
perfectly. I can throw the tip out there quite easily. I can change directions easily, although
I will say that the flexibility of this does make it wobble quite a bit when I change directions.
I don't know if you can see that there, but it feels good. You know, it has authority in the cut,
but it doesn't feel clunky in the slightest. You know, I have reviewed the Condor Grossmesser,
and I've also owned the Cold Steel Grossmesser, and both of them felt a lot clunkier than this.
This feels the way I think a Kriegsmesser should feel. I have here my Heron Mark sword, which is
a pretty similar blade, actually. It's a little bit thicker. It's actually overall a little bit
lighter, which is actually kind of surprising when you consider the extra hilt components, but
you know, when I pick this up, it feels very similar, but I will say this one doesn't wobble
nearly as much as the Kriegsmesser, and I think that's because Kriegsmesser tapers just so...
it gets so thin here quite quickly. I really think if this had started just like a millimeter
thicker and kept that thickness a little bit longer through about the first half of the blade
and then starting tapering better, I think it would actually be a little bit better in terms of
stiffness, which you want the sword to be flexible enough to, you know, not take a set as soon as it
you have a bad cut with it or something like that, but you also want it to be
relatively stiff, not just for thrusting, but when cutting, the stiffness aids in
powering through the target some, and it especially aids, like I said, when you are changing directions
because if you start a cut in one direction and quickly switch to another,
if it's flopping around, it's going to mess up your edge alignment a little bit and maybe not
cut quite as well. One thing to note though is that I don't actually know any Messer techniques,
you know, I'm basically using this like a single-edged longsword, and I know when I was
doing my cutting, there were a few times when I did what I consider to be longsword techniques,
and it ended up not quite working right because, you know, this is a Kriegsmesser, not a longsword.
The nagel could potentially get in the way a little bit. All that being said, you know,
there was a lot of, I won't even call them caveats or criticisms, they're just comparisons.
All that being said, I do really like the way this sword handles. It feels really good in the hand.
Again, I want to stress that this grip I find to be exceptionally comfortable. I love the way it
feels. It is by far and away the best grip that I've experienced that uses this style of
construction with the two slabs attached to the tame. Most of the time when I've handled
swords like that, there's ledges in here that get uncomfortable. Now, there are very,
very slight ledges here. It's not absolutely perfect, but I don't feel them at all when I'm
using it, and that's really all that matters, isn't it? So let's talk about a few areas that
Cold Steel could improve on. First off, the secondary bevel. It'd be great if they could
get this sharpened with one smooth bevel all the way from the spine to the edge.
Secondly, the missing scabbard. Both Midway and Cold Steel still have their listing saying that
this comes complete with the scabbard, and, you know, it doesn't. It'd be really nice to
have that scabbard so that you could actually wear this sword safely. Lastly, the crossguard.
I think just a little bit more refinement here, trimming down these edges a little bit,
would make this Kriegsmesser look a lot better. So now it's time to talk bottom line. Is this
sword worth the $380 I paid for it? Based on the one I received, yes, it is. There's, again, not a
whole lot of Kriegsmessers available on the market, so it's nice to be able to finally have a good one
available. But even putting aside the fact that there's not a lot of these on the market,
just as a sword in the $380 range, I think this is worth it. It's a lot of fun to use.
It performs very well. It has a good overall look. Frankly, I just think it's a fun sword to use,
and it's a good sword. And that's going to bring this review to a close.
Thank you for watching, and until next time, Alien 2 out.
