When antique swords suck! 10 examples of bad sword design.

Ancient Edge
3 followers
Mar 12, 2026
Not all antique swords are wonderful, many feature bad designs, bad choices or quality control. Here we look at some deeply flawed swords.
When people handle antique swords that are hundreds of years old, they tend to be awestruck
by them and overlook some of their shortcomings.
The truth is there are plenty of antique swords that are rather rubbish or have poor features.
So I'm going to show you 10 swords that are poor or have bad features that I think are
just generally a bit junk.
Let's go.
Hi, I'm Nick Thomas and welcome back to the Academy of Historical Fencing.
So somebody recently posted on one of our videos to say, how about doing a video on
swords that you don't like, antique swords that you don't like, because so often I feature
antique swords where I really appreciate their designs, their features or their history.
But the reality is that when it comes to antique swords throughout history, whatever type there
are, there are swords that have poor design features or are bad examples, are badly constructed,
have flaws.
And that's what we're going to delve into today.
Now I think it's really quite an interesting topic because yes, there's this assumption
today that, you know, a sword is something you're going to depend on in battle, used
to protect your life.
Surely everybody would have a high quality sword, particularly if they had the money
to afford it.
And the reality is that was not always the case.
Now I'm going to only show you swords that I own or have personally handled because I
don't want this to be a speculative video where I just judge it based on photos of examples.
I want to know how they handle and so I can tell you exactly why they suck.
Let's kick off with this British infantry officer's sword.
So this is sometimes called a flank officer's sword, but it's a type of non-regulation infantry
officer's sword that was common in the Napoleonic period for infantry and naval officers.
Now why does this really suck?
Well, it simply comes down to this outrageous amount of curvature and it looks cool.
A lot of people really like very curved swords and there are parts of the world where extremely
curved swords were popular.
Things like the Killich and the Chamshir, but the way that British ones were often done
is kind of rubbish.
So if you look at a Killich, for example, typically the blade will be relatively straight
for the first half to two thirds of its blade length and then it'll go into an extreme curve.
What that means is that this straight section gets you some of the advantages of putting
the blade on target in a straight line whilst having the advantages of a well-curved blade
that delivers a really vicious long cut.
But when the British were inspired by the Killich and the Chamshir and they started
making their own, they tended to curve them immediately from the guard so it's kind of
an even curve from here and it ends up with not just an outrageous curve, but a curve
that is actually directed so far back that it's kind of easy to stab yourself with the
point.
Now that's not the biggest issue with this sword.
The biggest issue is that if you have this much curvature and badly designed curvature
as I've explained, it's very hard to get the point on target quickly because the point
is basically the edge here is trailing well behind you.
You lose an awful lot of reach.
It's simply a bad design for a well-curved sword even though well-curved swords can be
quite good and most importantly, British military systems at the time were teaching a lunge-based
system where you use reach and try and reach for your target and fight them at the maximum
of your distance.
This kind of blade, you lose a massive amount of reach and is really suited to close-in
fighting as nothing like at all the way that the British were being taught.
So it's both a badly designed blade, misinterpreted from some of the Kilich and Shamshir type
swords, and completely ill-suited to the British style of combat.
Now at number two is this Cup-Hilt Rapier from the Royal Armouries collection which
you can see me handling in some of these photos.
Obviously I don't have it to hand but I've got an equivalent of my own from my antique
own collection of the same sort of time period Cup-Hilt Rapier and you can already see the
big difference is there's a pommel here.
That's really significant to why this sword really, really sucks.
So Cup-Hilt Rapiers, we tend to think of them as very, very long, very, very agile, nimble
kind of thrust-focused mostly swords.
It's not entirely accurate because there were beefier bladed military types of Cup-Hilt
Rapiers as well.
But in this particular case, look how decadent and elaborate this rapier is.
This is surely the kind of rapier that you're going to wear day-to-day in civilian life.
And yet, because it has no pommel and this kind of pierced metalwork that's hollow, there's
very little hilt weight.
So this sword, this rapier, weighs just over one kilo which is pretty much exactly what
my one here weighs but it has no pommel counterbalance and the blade is relatively broad for this
type of sword.
And that means the balance is out there at seven inches from the crossguard, which my
example here is five inches which is more typical of what you'd expect of a rapier.
And so it feels very cut-centric.
So maybe the owner of this sword preferred cutting but ultimately a rapier, even when
it can cut well, should still be agile, nimble with the point.
And this rapier in the Armory's collection is so cumbersome, it's so front-weighted,
it's so awkward to get the point online that I think it is a massive compromise for the
fashion of having that pommel-less design which I think massively compromised the handling
characteristics of this sword.
So it looks beautiful but, yeah, what a compromise for fashion.
On to number three, a British Spudroon or 1796 Patent Infantry Officer's Sword.
Now it's really common to hate upon Spudroons and sometimes it is justified.
There are actually good Spudroons, so these three examples here are examples, all of them,
of actually really good Spudroons that are well made and I would actually depend upon
in a fight.
But they're also, the design is prone to bad examples and there are many of them.
This one shows you so many of the awful features.
Now it's not an especially lightweight example.
Sometimes Spudroons are excessively light and we'll get on to that in a sword later
on in this video.
But this example has all of the other bad features.
So let's first talk about this, a folding guard.
Now the reason for the folding guard is simply so that it can sit flush and flat against
your uniform.
So this is a comfort issue from day-to-day life.
Although ultimately it's a massive, massive compromise because it's a very, very weak
hinge.
It's very easily broken.
You find lots of antique examples where this is missing and also they get a bit floppy.
It's quite lame.
And realistically it's not that big a shell.
Small swords were worn with fixed shells all the time and if you have the correct belt
you can have a fixed shell design.
Loads of these Spudroons were fixed shell, you see in my good examples there.
So I think this is a ridiculous compromise just for comforts that was unnecessary.
It's terrible.
Next thing, the grip here.
So the grips on these Spudroons were originally wire wrapped and they feel really comfortable.
They grip really, really well.
But for economy measures during the Napoleonic Wars, bear in mind the Napoleonic Wars were
a massive escalation of conflict in Europe, they started making economy versions and that's
what is on this one here.
So this is just a flat piece of metal that has been pressed into shape to give the illusion
of being a wire wrap and they are prone to slipping, breaking, tearing off and most significantly
they're really smooth so they don't have the sort of grip retention that you would want
out of a wire wrap grip.
So it kind of looks the part but it doesn't actually do the job properly as a fighting
sword.
So, those are the couple of issues with the hilt here.
Now let's get on to the blade.
So the idea of the Spudroon is that it's incredibly agile, it gets to the target first whether
it's cut or thrust.
But when it comes to the thrust, you need relative rigidity in the blade.
If you look at the Napoleonic period, thick fabrics were often being worn.
In fact, it's one of the coldest years recorded in recent history.
Great coats, for example, were often worn.
Thick layers of wool fabrics.
You're not going to penetrate those kind of fabrics if you have a particularly flexible
sword.
And some Spudroons, this one is a perfect example, are outrageously flexible, okay?
Now that is absolutely horrific for a sword where you're going to do lots of thrusting.
So just all round, this is a disgusting example of the Spudroon.
It's way overly flexible, the handling isn't particularly great, the shoulder is too thin
at like 6mm.
You'd often expect 8 or 9 on a good sword at this period.
The folding guard is absolute rubbish.
The economy of grip feels terrible.
This is never the sword that you'd want to rely on.
It's absolute junk.
On to number four, this foot artillery gunner's sword from, again, the Napoleonic period.
So this is British once again.
Now these are actually quite rare pieces and they're really quite interesting is that they
are both a weapon and a tool.
And that compromise is why they're not especially good as a sword.
So the compromise comes from the fact that they are built incredibly thick.
So they're designed as like an entrenching type tool.
Incredibly thick in the blade here, like you might make an axe blade, for example.
So this, in fact, is as heavy and heavier than many cavalry swords of the period, despite
the fact that it's so tiny.
It has an incredible amount of mass here.
Now that amount of mass means that it works really well as a heavy-duty machete if you
want to clear gun positions, for example.
But if you want to use it in a sword fight, it lacks the agility that you'd want.
So when it comes to swords, agility is so vitally important.
It's one of the core characteristics of most sword designs.
So say an axe might hit harder, but it's clumsy and cumbersome in mass distribution.
Swords you expect to be nimble.
And the perfect example or comparison with this is this is the same hilt type of the
same era.
But this sword above here, forget the fact that it's curved versus straight, that doesn't
make a massive difference, is this one has been built as a fighting sword with a lot
of distal taper towards the tip.
So they're roughly the same thickness down here at the shoulder, but this one tapers
massively towards the tip, and this one barely tapers at all.
So this is built as a heavy-duty tool for clearing gun positions, and this one's actually
built to be a fighting sword that can move nimbly.
And so this compromises a lot to be able to do two different jobs, and that's so often
the case with so many weapon designs is when you want to create a hybrid that does multiple
jobs, it tends to be kind of bad at multiple jobs rather than good at all of them.
So yeah, kind of an interesting sword, utilitarian, robust, clears positions well, handles like
an absolute dog, is really, really slow, is not the kind of thing you'd really want to
be fighting with.
On to number five, we're looking at another Spadroon, in fact an earlier example.
So this is an example of a British 1780s period or into the 1790s Spadroon, and you can already
see there's something unusual about it.
It has no shell here, and that is a stupid design feature.
And it only is there because of fashion, and that fashion is trying to mimic or copy the
Hussar-style light cavalry sabres of that era, which were incredibly fashionable and
are kind of acceptable when it's a sort of a cavalry trooper's sword, which is being
more intended to sort of go and harass skirmish in infantry, for example, than an infantry
officer's Spadroon, which you'd expect to be used in duels potentially, but also fighting
against other swords on the battlefield and fighting against muskets.
And we can see here in this other Spadroon from the era an almost exact copy of the light
cavalry guard and pommel type construction, although this one at least has a little bit
of side guard to protect the side of the hand.
Let's get back to the example this video is actually about.
So this Spadroon in the 1780s, they were very, very lax on what it was supposed to be.
They just said the blade had to be 32 inches by 1 inch wide, and left everything else down
to whatever the officer wanted to buy.
So you can find lots of different hilt types, but it's really common to see just a simple
stirrup guard like this.
And in this particular case, the blade is a double-edged example, so it's actually been
designed more like a small sword.
So in this particular case, whoever this officer was, they thought to use their sword more
for point work.
It's very narrow down at the tip here.
It's better suited as a thrusting sword than a mixed cut and thrust sword.
And without those shells, which a thrust sword like a small sword will always have, there's
a reason you have those.
If you're going to rely a lot on point-forward guards and thrust work, you really need some
protection to the front of the hand here.
So if you design a sword that you want to do lots of thrusting and point-forward actions
with without the shells, your hand is massively vulnerable.
And for the only reason that it was copy in the fashion of the Light Cavalry, which is
an incredibly stupid reason to go for a hilt that is completely unsuited to the blade that
you're using.
On to number six, the so-called Rhythm Sword from the Royal Armouries.
I think this one's going to break some people's hearts because this is an absolutely beloved
sword that so often people talk about.
There are recreations made of it.
The armouries even sell a nice recreation of it themselves.
And admittedly, it is a fantastically beautiful sword.
Now I have handled this.
You can see it during a handling session almost 20 years ago that I was looking at this sword,
weighing it, balancing it, and looking at the characteristics.
And I'd always admired it as well from seeing it from afar.
And then when I got it in hand, it's kind of rubbish, unfortunately.
So this sword, again, I think sacrifices so much for fashion.
And it has quite a number of issues.
The first thing, which is quite surprising when you see it up close, is it's way smaller
than you think.
So if we look at this feather, for example, this modern day long sword that I've got,
and it's not a huge example, this Albion Maia, the Rhythm Sword is about three inches shorter
on the hilt than I've got here.
So if I put my hands as close together as they can be, what's left there is about three
inches roughly.
So that's basically as large as the Rhythm Hilt is.
Now look at the pommel.
You can barely grip that pommel well.
It's a very, very stylistic pommel, but it doesn't grip very well.
It really gets in the way.
It's really quite awkward.
So you're very cramped in terms of hand space.
Now this has clearly been designed as that sort of hand-and-a-half type sword that we
call it often in Britain, or bastard sword.
So it's a very, very small long sword that could be used in one or two hands.
But the truth is it doesn't actually handle that well.
It feels a little bit clumsy.
The blade doesn't have, I prefer basically a much more acute taper to it.
So if you're going to go for that kind of flattened diamond section blade, I would have
gone a little bit wider at the base to a more acute taper towards the point.
And it just feels a little bit clumsy.
So it's bad in one hand.
It's too short to be used well in two hands.
The pommel gets in the way of using that other hand.
It's an awkwardly small and awkwardly shaped hilt to be used any way that you possibly
could think of.
So what this sword does is compromise, I would say, massively for fashion.
It would look absolutely fantastic being worn on your side.
It's nice and compact, so it would be comfortable to wear, and it will be very, very stylish.
But in terms of getting it in the hands and trying to fight with it, it feels absolutely
horrible.
So sorry about that.
It's not exactly a great fighting sword.
On to number seven, the 1885 Patton British Trooper's Sword.
So what is wrong with this?
Well, first, the 1885 Patton had a lot of issues of snapping and breaking, and they
had to redesign it very, very quickly.
So in 1890, they revised the blade, they changed the construction, the metal, and the fuller
to try and make it stronger, because they were actually breaking on cuts during impacts.
So it had some durability issues.
But beyond that, the grip also was controversial.
So this type of pinned grip, which is very, very thick, so it's a full-width tang, like
a mezzer, for example, or a knife.
Big full-width tang to try and make it nice and strong, and then pinned grips.
But the way they designed it, and it didn't have to be this way, but the way they did
design it is the grip is incredibly round, if you like.
So most sword grips tend to be narrower on the sides of the grip than front to back,
and that gives you a nice, comfortable grip, and it tends to align the edge of the blade.
Because if you can't align the edge to the target, and you hit with the flat of the blade,
you're doing nothing but slapping somebody with blunt steel.
So edge alignment is incredibly important, and a lot of soldiers at the time complained
about these grips, which first came in in the 1853 Patton, and were used until the end
of the 19th century, and they turn in the hand.
Now, what do I personally think about that?
Well, I can actually tell you, because I actually blunted one, an original, this was a bad condition
original, that I blunted, and I use this for sparring, even to this day occasionally.
So I do actually have some experience of using one for sparring, and what it would actually
be like.
So curiously enough, this has actually held up really well.
It's actually really quite tough, so I've not had any durability issues with it, which
for a sword that is, you know, pushing close on 150 years old, is really quite impressive.
But the grip is, as they reported at the time, frankly, horrible.
If you use a thumbs-up grip on it, it's kind of okay, but on quite beefy cavalry swords,
it's not always ideal to do that, and a lot of sources at the time recommended more a
closed hammer or handshake-type grip to try and control a heavier sword.
And yes, this turning of the hand, it is bad in terms of getting edge alignment, and it
fatigues the hand.
When you have an excessively thick grip, it does fatigue the fingers quite quickly.
So this sword, some manufacturing issues early on, and this grip, they just made it way too
thick, which meant it just turns in the hand.
So for that reason, aside from the fact that the blade is actually okay and the guard's
nice, the grip is just terrible.
On to number eight, and we're back to another spadroon.
And yes, I know, this is the third spadroon in the video.
And as I said, there are good spadroons, but it is prone to having also really bad examples.
So I've shown you three really bad examples for different reasons, and this one comes
down to weight.
So a good spadroon is usually in around the 700 to 750 gram weight range.
You need it to be that heavy to be durable enough to withstand parries against heavier
swords and against muskets and bayonets, and also to be able to deal a bit of percussive
force and be stiff enough to be able to punch through uniforms.
Now this example is 590 grams.
It feels like a child's sword.
So this is actually a Sargent's variant.
And there's a Sargent's variant in my good spadroon photo there that is actually a very
good sword.
That one's about 720 grams, by the way, compared to this 590.
And it is just incredibly flimsy, very, very light, very, very flexible.
It doesn't have any authority in the cut.
It doesn't have any authority in the parry.
It's just horrible.
You know, if this was for, you know, a child to wear as a fashionable sword, for example,
or maybe an officer could wear it to the dance.
But these are designed as battlefield swords, and this is a Sargent's sword that he might
have to rely on in battle.
It's just disgusting.
At least it has a fixed guard.
But beyond that, it is so light and so pathetically flimsy.
This is an awful military sword.
At number nine, we have a variant of the British 1796 Heavy Cavalry Sword.
This is the Horse Guard's variant.
Now, the heavy calves, like you see in the shop, for example, are notoriously heavy,
and people tend to think of them as quite clumsy.
That's not entirely fair.
Most of them are around about 1 to 1.1 kilo, and they're not so different to many of the
cavalry swords that followed.
So they're not as bad as you think.
But this one is the absolute beast that you think it might be.
1.4 kilos.
It is an absolute monster of a sword, and I tend to find that it's a Marmite sword.
When you hand it to people, they either think that it handles like a complete crowbar or
a dog, or they smile and realize that it can destroy basically anything, because it is
a very, very brutish sword.
But what is the fault with this?
Because, you know, in terms of mass, if you're strong enough to use it and you're happy to
use a beefy cutting sword, that's not necessarily a bad thing.
The fault with this sword is this tip.
So all of the British Heavy Cavalry Swords of the 1796 pattern had what we call this
where the back of the blade is completely straight, and the front of the blade tapers
in to a very, very blunt point.
And these have exactly the problems that you've probably realized just by looking at it, is
that blunter tip, it's hard to get it to align correctly to a target, and being so broad
and so blunt, it's hard to get it to penetrate into targets, and particularly through, again,
greatcoats, even uniform jackets.
And it's no surprise that in period they started to reshape these.
So they either trimmed this down to make it a gentler asymmetric tip, or they ground from
the back and made it into a symmetrical spear point, and that was done commonly by actual
soldiers in the field, by the regiments.
But you can see that some examples remain exactly as they were built, and this blunt
hatchet tip.
So this is a formidable fighting sword, the guard is good, the blade is a real destroyer,
but all of these Heavy Cavalry 1796s were manufactured with this incredibly blunt tip,
and it is absolutely terrible.
So once modified, it's a good sword, but as standard, and this is the way they were used
for many, many years, for thrust work, it's terrible.
And we finish up number 10 with this Italian mounted artillery sword, although it's basically
the same to general Italian cavalry sabers of the late 19th century.
So this is from the 1870s, and I just, every time I handle this sword, I just absolutely
despise it, and that's unfortunately the case with most Italian cavalry sabers.
It's a real shame, because actually I really enjoy earlier Italian swords, but Italian
military sabers of the late 19th century tend to just handle disgustingly.
So this is a pipeback blade, you'll see it featured on my recent videos about pipebacks
and whether they're good or not, and overall they can be good.
This one is not bad because it's a pipeback, this one is bad because many things.
Let's firstly, let's talk about the hilt here.
Plain wood grips is just cheap, and smooth, and just not well suited.
It needs some grooves or wire, just something to get a bit more purchase on it, so a smooth
wood grip is just not good.
Then this sort of lug section that sticks out, the reason that's there is so that the
thumb can go into the guard here a little bit, and the idea is that you get more control
over the sword by pushing the thumb and a thumbs-up grip further past the guard, closer
towards the balance point, and it's sort of to give you more control.
Does it do that?
No.
By moving the thumb, you know, half a centimetre, a centimetre up, it makes no difference whatsoever.
And what it does do is push you further away from the pommel or backstrap area, and sabers
so often rely on their agility and rotation at the wrist, and by having this much huge
bulbous pommel sticking out, it just gets in the way of the wrist and feels really,
really awkward.
Now, Italian stars at the time were relying a lot on throwing from the elbows, so the
cutting style changed a little bit, but that doesn't change the fact that from a saber
enjoyer's perspective, that is weird, okay?
It just is really awkward.
Now, Richard Burton, who famously wrote about swords and wrote sword manuals and tried to
get them into the military and never got accepted, he actually loved these Italian-type hilts
and banged on about them and tried to get them adopted into the British Army, thought
they were fantastic.
But ultimately, all of his ideas on swordsmanship were kind of weird, so I wouldn't take too
much stock in that.
What else is wrong with this?
Well, the guard, it initially looks like it's got loads of hand protection, but the inside
is incredibly narrow, so you're actually very, very exposed on the inside here, and the outside
of the guard is really compact, so although it does close in around the fingers quite
well, that provides very little protection to the wrist area during parries, so the guard
is nowhere near as protective as it necessarily looks.
And then in terms of the handling characteristics, this saber is, it's almost a kilo in weight,
and it's not especially a long saber, it just feels cumbersome and awkward.
It's got to feel like some of those sort of, you know, heavy, hilted French swords, but
it doesn't have the big protection of those big, hilted French swords.
This just feels like a cumbersome dog designed by somebody who doesn't understand how a saber
should feel, using a grip feature which does nothing for you, with a grip that is not going
to do well, particularly with sweat on your hands, with a pommel construction which just
gets in the way, it's just a horrible sword.
It also has an annoying shape to the tang, so when we look at the shape of the grip,
or the alignment of the grip to the blade, generally speaking on a saber-type sword,
you want the grip to be in line with the blade, or canted this way, and by canting the grip
a little bit that way, so basically bending the tang so that the blade comes forward,
you actually align the point a little bit better.
You can also help align a curved blade to be better suited for thrusting.
And this Italian sword, the tang is actually set back in the wrong direction, which means
the point is going offline, the edges arrive in later.
So you'll see certain swords throughout history, like many Japanese swords actually have the
tang just in line with the curvature of the blade, and that can work kind of well for
certain sort of long drawing cuts, but it's really poorly suited to getting to the point
on, or the thrust on line, and getting quick cuts onto a straight target.
So having the tang set this way, the cant in reverse, is usually a sign of bad sword
construction.
At least in the case of sabers.
And there you have it, that's ten swords that I immediately thought of, that I rather dislike,
possibly even hate in some of them.
Some of the swords I actually like, but they have certain features like that heavy calve
which just make it incredibly ineffective in its current state.
And there's a lesson for you there.
Don't look at antique swords and be wowed by them automatically.
It's the same when you look at guns or cars in the modern world.
They're not all good.
There are bad designs, there are compromised designs, there are middling designs, there
are bad examples, there are bad apples, there are ones that come off the production assembly
line and just always have faults and issues, there's poor quality control.
All of these issues that you see in modern day manufacturing happened back then with
the swords.
And there is this assumption to think that surely people would design swords that are
best suited to the job.
Yes, if they knew what was best suited to the job, and they weren't just trying to profit
off you.
So for example in the 19th century a lot of British officers went and bought bad quality
swords because they didn't know better.
So there was a common term for example, the tailor's sword, which is when rather than
going to a swordsmith like this, this is a Woolley, a good quality Birmingham manufactured
smith, you just go to a tailor's shop and you buy your uniform from the tailor, whilst
you're there you buy the sword from them as well.
Where does the tailor buy their swords from?
Wherever they can at the cheapest price.
And so all of those tailor's swords are absolute junk.
So there you go, lots of antique swords are absolutely rubbish.
Don't always assume that just because it looks pretty or is hundreds of years old that it's
a fantastic sword.
There are of course loads of great antique examples, I've shown many in recent videos,
but here are some swords with some real issues.
I hope you enjoyed this video and if you've got any more ideas that you'd like to see
put into video format, put them in the comments.
I will do the best I can to get to them if I think I can do them justice.
I hope you enjoyed the video.
Thanks for watching.
Please like and subscribe and join our membership program if you want.
I'll see you in another one.
