Scientist vs. Scientist #4 - Werner Heisenberg and Ernest Rutherford

Werner Heisenberg (1901 - 1976)
3 followers
In this episode, we will discuss Werner Heisenberg and Ernest Rutherford.
First, we will discuss Werner Heisenberg.
Werner Heisenberg was born in Würzburg, Germany on the 5th of December in 1901.
His father was Caspar Ernesta August Heisenberg and his mother was Annie Wecklein.
Both of his parents specialized in the study of Greek culture.
Werner Heisenberg also had an older brother, named Erwin Heisenberg.
As a young child, Heisenberg took a very active interest in playing the piano
and by the age of five was able to memorize and play entire songs.
However, his piano lessons were interrupted by his father's Greek philology textbooks,
which he perused daily.
His interests slowly turned away from piano and into the sciences.
Werner and Erwin Heisenberg were raised in a strict but competitive household
as their family was in the upper middle class.
Their father did not tolerate laziness and treated both of his sons like he treated his students.
Werner and Erwin Heisenberg constantly competed to outdo each other on assignments,
particularly math and science assignments given to Erwin in school.
Werner also competed against himself in sports
His passion for achieving personal goals matured with him into his later life
and became a significant part of how he tackled problems in both life and physics.
In 1910, Heisenberg's family moved to Munich after his father received an appointment
to the only professorial chair in Germany for Byzantine philology.
In Munich, Werner attended the Maximilian's Gymnasium,
a preparatory school headed by his maternal grandfather,
and that had been attended by Max Planck,
Heisenberg's predecessor in the field of quantum physics.
The Maximilian's Gymnasium took a more traditional approach to its education
and Werner was forced to study more Greek and Latin and less mathematics or physics.
However, when World War I started in 1914,
the school turned its attentions towards the sciences.
The war took its toll on the Heisenberg family in many ways,
one way being Kaspar Heisenberg leaving to serve for the Prussian army.
The Maximilian Gymnasium was also forced to make cutbacks on many supplies
and one of the school's buildings was turned into barracks for the Bavarian troops.
Erwin and Werner Heisenberg were required to labor out in the fields
to sustain themselves and their mother.
Despite the effects of the war,
Werner Heisenberg completed his education and even went beyond requirements,
learning calculus at age 16.
Heisenberg also led a youth group focused on discussing current politics,
enjoying their separation from the rest of the world,
and talking about abstract topics.
The youth group had a significant impact on Heisenberg's intellectual development,
pushing him to question traditional values and to prove things for himself.
When Werner was 18, he was planning on studying mathematics,
but decided instead on studying both mathematics and physics
after talking to one of the professors at the University of Munich, Arnold Sommerfeld.
While attending the University of Munich,
Sommerfeld became one of his professors along with Wilhelm Wein.
Heisenberg also studied at the University of Göttingen
under Max Born, James Frank and David Hilbert.
While studying at the university, he got to meet and work with Wolfgang Pauli.
When Heisenberg had come to the University of Munich,
Sommerfeld had been working on explaining light emitted by different atoms.
When given energy, atoms would not emit light of every color on the spectrum,
but only a select few colors.
Furthermore, the light split into groups of lines
and then returned to the normal spectrum when exposed to a magnetic field.
This phenomenon was known as the Zeeman effect.
After working for a year on the Zeeman effect,
Heisenberg proposed a new atomic model that effectively explained the Zeeman effect.
However, it also contradicted many properties of atoms
that both Arnold Sommerfeld and Niels Bohr had proposed earlier,
and most scientists expressed dislike towards Heisenberg's model.
Werner Heisenberg's interest in physics, particularly quantum physics,
was spurred by his meetings with Niels Bohr.
Arnold Sommerfeld had known about Heisenberg's interest in Niels Bohr's lectures
and had taken him to a Bohr Festival,
where Bohr gave a series of lectures on quantum physics.
After the festival, Bohr and Heisenberg discussed topics of both science and philosophy,
and Bohr became a mentor and close friend to Heisenberg.
In 1923, Heisenberg finished his dissertation paper on the topic of hydrodynamics.
He also took oral exams on both theoretical and experimental physics.
While his dissertation was not bad,
the results of his experimental physics exams shocked him and his professors.
Heisenberg was ill-prepared for the questions on the exam
and could not use a significant number of instruments key to answering other questions.
His experimental physics professor was unwilling to give Heisenberg his degree,
but after discussing it with another professor,
he finally gave Heisenberg a passing grade.
Combined with the stress of examinations,
Heisenberg also had to worry about the political and economical situation in Germany.
Inflation had been taking its toll on German scientists, Heisenberg included,
and many were seeking help from America.
At the time, Heisenberg had polished his theory on the Zeeman effect
and sent a copy to Niels Bohr, who invited him to Copenhagen.
During his time there, Heisenberg assisted Bohr with teaching
at the University of Copenhagen and worked on his own papers.
One of the most important topics Heisenberg worked on while in Copenhagen
was his famous uncertainty principle.
The Heisenberg uncertainty principle states that for a given particle,
a limited amount of knowledge can be obtained about its position and velocity,
and as more knowledge is gained about one variable, less can be known about the other.
This is attributed to the disturbance when a particle is observed,
similar to the observer effect.
In the late 1920s and early 1930s, Heisenberg worked on atomic structure and properties,
such as his model of the nucleus of an atom
and his explanation of ferromagnetism with Pauli's exclusion principle.
Working with famous physicists such as Albert Einstein, Niels Bohr,
John Slater and Hendrik Cramers, he developed the BKS theory
on the interaction of matter and electromagnetic waves.
He also traveled to the US, China, Japan and India to give lectures on quantum physics.
Hans Cramer and Heisenberg also collaborated on a paper
about dispersion of radiation from atoms which are smaller than the wavelength of the radiation.
As per Heisenberg's reputation of casting out traditional values for new ideas,
he implemented the virtual oscillator model to calculate spectral frequencies.
When Heisenberg's friend Max Born read the paper,
he saw the importance of matrices in Heisenberg's method.
This use of matrices sparked the use of matrices across many branches of physics,
particularly atomic physics.
For his work, Heisenberg received the Nobel Prize in Physics in 1932.
In 1935, Arnold Sommerfeld retired from his job as teacher at the University of Munich
and nominated Heisenberg to be his successor.
However, Heisenberg was instead put in charge of education
for the German nuclear project by the head of the SS.
Although he did not want to work for the SS,
Heisenberg was forced to lecture other workers in the program on nuclear physics
and eventually help with the atomic bomb himself.
Heisenberg was sent to occupied Copenhagen by the nuclear program
to collaborate on some of the aspects of nuclear fission
that would be utilized in the bomb with Niels Bohr.
Bohr hoped to find out Heisenberg's opinion on the project from his visit
and Heisenberg expressed his opinion quite clearly.
He did not want to help the Germans build the atomic bomb.
Him and tens of other scientists had been working on nuclear physics,
but it was clear that the bomb would not make a great contribution to ending the war.
In 1945, Project Alsos, the American project to investigate whether the Germans had an atomic bomb,
captured Heisenberg and relocated him to a facility in France,
then another in England.
Under Operation Epsilon, he was transported back to Germany after the war.
In his last years, Heisenberg continued to lecture physics at universities across Europe,
published papers on topics of physics he had previously done,
and delved deeper into new topics.
Werner Heisenberg died on the 1st of February in 1976 at 74 years old in Munich.
For his contributions to science, he received the Nobel Prize and the Max Planck Medal.
Now, let's discuss Ernest Rutherford.
Ernest Rutherford was born in Brightwater, New Zealand on the 30th of August in 1871
to James Rutherford and Martha Thompson.
He had 11 siblings and was the second son.
James Rutherford was a flax farmer and received small pay from his job.
Martha Thompson was a school teacher.
It was Rutherford's mother who placed a strong emphasis on education,
especially the education of Ernest and his siblings.
As a child, Ernest spent most of his time tending to the farm or doing chores.
He would also spend his free time, mostly on the weekends, swimming with his brothers.
He also found creative ways to make money for his family.
The environment Ernest grew up in affected his later interest in science.
Ernest's father once found Ernest outside during a thunderstorm,
counting seconds to calculate how far away the lightning was.
Ernest Rutherford attended the public Foxhill School at age 10,
where he was given his first science textbook.
Rutherford promptly attempted to replicate some of the experiments done in the book,
such as constructing a miniature cannon.
He also experimented with the household clock,
tinkering with, disassembling, and reconstructing it.
His teachers at school realized he was fascinated with science
and gave him extra material on the subject.
When Rutherford was 11 years old,
his father moved to Havelock to pursue the job of flax milling,
a job that got him more money, something the Rutherford family needed.
As a result, James Rutherford was hardly at home to see his children.
Tragedy struck the family after James Rutherford changed jobs.
Three of the children died,
one from an illness and two from drowning during a fishing trip.
In 1887, Ernest Rutherford was awarded a scholarship
to attend Nelson Collegia School,
a private school which overjoyed his mother.
He attended Nelson Collegia from 1887 to 1889,
where it became clear that he had a bright future ahead of him.
Not only was he top in all of his classes,
he was an excellent rugby player.
His success in Nelson Collegiate was also spurred on by his principal,
who gave him books on physics to read.
In 1890, Rutherford received another scholarship,
this time to Canterbury College in Christchurch.
Similar to Nelson Collegiate,
Rutherford excelled at all of his classes at Canterbury
and achieved first class honors in math and science.
He received his Bachelor of Arts and Master of Arts degrees at Canterbury
and a Bachelor of Science degree
after conducting independent research on electromagnetism.
That same year, he won a third scholarship,
now for Trinity College in Cambridge, England.
During the first weeks of his stay at Trinity College,
Rutherford, working along with J.J. Thompson,
discovered an easier method of detecting radio waves
than Heinrich Hertz's previous method.
He found that by using magnetizing coils
interspersed with bands of magnetic iron,
he could make detecting radio waves simpler
and therefore more commercially viable.
Rutherford and Thompson also conducted research on x-rays,
particularly the effect of x-rays on gases.
Rutherford then studied radioactivity on his own,
preferring it over the study of x-rays.
Using uranium and gold foil,
he found that one type of radiation could penetrate the gold,
while another would be absorbed by it.
He named the two types of radiation alpha and beta radiation.
Along with naming types of radiation,
he also created the term half-life
after experimenting with the radioactive element thorium.
In 1900, Rutherford left Cambridge
to work at McGill University in Canada.
At McGill, he was joined by Frederick Soddy,
a chemist who was also interested in researching radioactivity.
Soddy and Rutherford worked on identifying the gas
that emanated from the radioactive decay of thorium.
They identified it as a new element, named thoron,
which was later identified as an isotope
of another radioactive element, radon.
In 1902, Rutherford and Soddy published their findings in a paper,
summing up the work they had done in two years.
One of the most important topics in the paper
discussed the destruction of atoms into different particles,
which was thought to be impossible,
as atoms were considered the indestructible building blocks of all matter.
The paper on atomic disintegration,
as Rutherford called it,
introduced the idea that atoms could be broken up.
After the publication of the theory of atomic disintegration,
Rutherford took up work with Bertram Boltwood
on creating a chart for the decay of radioactive elements,
which they called the decay series.
The decay series showed the decay of a radioactive element,
what it would decay into,
what radiation it would emit, and the half-life of the element.
Rutherford also had to introduce a third kind of decay,
gamma decay, for the decay series.
After moving to Manchester in 1907,
Rutherford carried out his most famous experiment,
the gold foil experiment, with Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden.
He fired alpha particles at a piece of gold foil
and observed the deflection when some of the particles did not make it through.
His work showed that an atom
did not consist simply of a cloud of electrons,
but of one center, or nucleus,
with an orbiting cloud of electrons.
His model of the atom was the most accurate to date,
and was drawn on by many other scientists to create the current atomic model.
In his later years,
Rutherford became the first person to transmute one element into another,
converting nitrogen into oxygen
by bombarding it with alpha particles.
He also hypothesized the existence of the neutron
as a particle to counteract the repulsion between protons in the nucleus,
which was proven by James Chadwick in 1932.
Leaving a legacy in the field of nuclear physics,
Rutherford was the father of atomic energy
and redefined the structure of the field of physics.
Ernest Rutherford died on the 19th of October in 1937
at age 66 in Cambridge, England.
For his contributions to science,
he received the Nobel Prize and the Romford Medal.
As both of these scientists contributed great things to the understanding of physics
and left behind legacies that affect us today,
the result is a tie.
However, you are free to decide on your own opinion.
Thank you for watching this video, and as always,
if you enjoyed, leave a like or a favorite,
share the video with your friends,
or even subscribe for more educational videos.
Check out some of the other videos in the Scientists vs. Scientists series,
or check out the featured channels for extra content.
