ELON vs. MAGA: Indian Tech Workers Can Save America?

FUNG BROS.
592 followers
586 Video Views·Jan 7, 2025
Elon Musk and vivec ramaswami just went
to battle within their own Republican
party over H1B visas and listen guys the
internet was talking about it the media
was kind of talking about it but then
there was a bunch of terrorist attacks
in 2025 anyway guys is this a big deal
not a big deal or is this just what the
internet needed to talk about this week
and what does this mean for the vision
of America that different people have
make sure you like subscribe turnning
your notifications a lot of you guys
wanted us to talk about this so I'm
going to talk about it long story short
Elon and vivec were talking about
increasing the need for H1B visas now
72% of H1B visas primarily go to Indians
from India filling in like I would say
middle tier roles to like bottom High
tier roles in the tech sector now a lot
of the Maga crowd was saying why don't
those jobs go to Americans the VEC
responded by saying the key word is C
Americans don't have the culture they
don't care about math they only want to
be cool and beautiful and uh party kids
at school and be the jock and be the
cheerleader nobody cares about stem
subjects basically pulling the Asian
parent card and then that tweet got 120
million views it's still going up right
now and a lot of people are like well I
voted for you guys but I don't really
trust Elon V anymore Trump got their
back I thought you guys were America
first but a lot of people are like what
does it even mean to be America First is
that American companies is that American
citizens which type of American citizens
and why does it seem like it's become so
fragmented um listen guys let's we just
pull some qu um choice choice quotes
from the Vex tweet they got 120 million
views he basically says in America we
have a culture that celebrates the prom
queen over the math Olympiad champ and
The Jock over the Val Victorian we will
not produce the best Engineers that's
why we have to get the H1B visas from
India that's what sort of what he was
implying he doesn't go out and say it of
course a lot of people being Indian
himself and being like an elite Hindu
Brahman you know what I mean it is a lot
of like there was some unspoken stuff
because people would just be like yeah
but you're just supporting people who
look like you to come in and take jobs
but then also what Vive said was true
like my dad was saying that my whole
time growing up and especially going to
like the the you know the very
questionable public school education uh
systems that we were put into my dad was
constantly saying that so vvec is both
right but it's also right to question
Vic motives whether on a corporate level
or on an ethnic level right if if you
are not Indian yourself I mean like even
if a Chinese guy said it I would say the
same thing guys literally so basically
everybody's right to some extent like
the people criticizing VI are right but
Vive is also right for sure Stefan gets
valued over Urkel I don't even know why
Vive was making so many 90s like
sitcom's references like I guess he was
speaking to people who really watch TGF
and stuff like that but anyway let's
break it down the top five countries of
origin for H1B Visa this is by from 2019
by the way 72% % of H1B visas went to
people from India 12% went to CH uh
China obviously right now those Chinese
numbers are being um like going down due
to China being labeled in a security
threat uh the Philippines had 1% and
then 15% of the other H1B visas went to
Canada Korea Mexico Taiwan and others
however look's look at stem graduates as
if we look at globally China produces 4%
of the stem graduates in the world uh
India also produces a tremendous volume
between China and India they produce
more than the rest of the world pretty
much combined so you got a lot of nerds
in China and India okay guys like we
said academically those are probably two
of the most hyper gladiatorial
environments to be that you could
possibly come from yes Chinese do more
go towards Hardware Indians do tend to
go more towards software Indians tend to
be better at English and like leadership
and managing a lot of like uh conflicts
in the workplace political workplace but
essentially those two places have very
very deep educational stem roots and
they lean into them like historically
those are places that graduate a lot of
stem people you know what I mean um so
basically a lot of people on the
internet are discussing this I think
this issue was actually a little bit
like quote unquote what we call like
high minded for like mass media because
it's it actually gets into economics and
now Paul Paul krugman's in there and all
these other people with like five
degrees so here's this real quick
economic article that's breaking it down
here's what economic gurus are saying
Paul Krugman who was uh a famous New
York Times Economist said well foreign
workers I feel like they're more
complimentary they're more like side
dishes rather than the main dish we
should keep them side dishes But
ultimately it's a pro even though but I
do disagree with muskus squami that
Americans are stupid all right Americans
are not actually stupid I disagree with
VI but they are the the the Smart Ones
are unmotivated like the really like
Native American talent
that has the stem mind would rather go
into management because it pays more you
work less and it's more like using soft
skills combined with some hard skills
nobody wants to do the grunt H1B
hardcore like super hardcore stem work
anymore like even for people who have
the capacity to do it they don't want to
do it generally some of them do but
generally not and then of course the
companies they don't want to pay a
Native American and then have to deal
with like the Native American person uh
when I say Native American I mean native
born American person being able to jump
ship to another company obviously if you
are on H1B Visa it earns you a lot of
loyalty and you get paid less and you
got to work like at least 1.5 times as
hard so the companies actually love H1B
visas even though they got to pay a
small fee as well but it's like you get
a better worker for cheaper but this
goes to the next Robert reich's uh
perspective saying yes these workers are
better and cheaper and more like
compliant and submissive to the company
however this will deinen divize the
United States to educate Americans and
will also deinen divize companies to
treat workers good basically so this guy
was a was another Economist that is
against it uh Paul Krugman would said
yeah there's pros and cons but I'm
ultimately for H1B visas being increased
um Florian Eder said why handicap
ourselves as a country let's just get
the top talent from around the world and
then this last guy said immigration is
overall good but it does need to have
strict guidelines on who is being led in
and what value they're supposed to
provide we should analyze everybody so
those were the opinions from economists
okay guys um so let's just take a look
at some Layman comments that I pulled
off Reddit that represent a different uh
a large swave of different opinions guys
listen I I actually think a lot of these
comments can be right at the same time
but it's like everybody's just looking
at how the issue affects them directly
they're not thinking about everybody's
perspective they're just thinking about
their own perspective but their own
perspective is valid of course it's
valid because it's valid to yourself
right everybody is self-interested in
how things directly impact them in their
own cultural socioeconomic positioning
etc etc etc um this guy said I'm
Canadian and mass Indian immigration
ruined Canada for native born Canadians
even native born Canadians of ethnic
Indian origin yeah I mean that's a
perspective yeah like just because like
people you could be it's just the same
way with Chinese Americans like a lot of
Chinese Americans that came that are
fifth generation or even their parents
came uh after the heart seller act post
1970 they're not going to support like
illegal Chinese pouring over the Mexican
border you know what I mean a gry market
Chinese that are involved in a lot of
like very uh potentially illicit
Enterprises like it's different just
there there's your e just because
somebody looks like you does not mean
you are absolutely going to support them
coming in in large numbers seriously
because it that doesn't mean these are
large countries China and India you know
not everybody relates to everybody and
they're from also we we can't even we're
not even getting into talking about the
complexities of India with the cast
system and uh State ISM and which state
are you from and etc etc anyway um
somebody just said it's about tradeoffs
yeah I mean obviously duh it's about
tradeoffs and who is taking the
tradeoffs like basically what I'm saying
is like obviously the H1B Visa are going
to be good for the companies right and
they're going to be bad theoretically
for Americans that want to get into Tech
work however it's also true that the
people who come in generally on the H1B
visas are going to work harder and be
more motivated and pretty much only
focus on work and not demand like work
life balance as much literally that is
just the facts I'm not saying 100 out of
100 but I'm saying that literally that's
just like the in incentive structure
that is built into it it's pretty
obvious
um somebody said I support doubling the
H1B visas and some this guy said you
know I work my way up to a managerial
level within Tech so I don't really care
because I'll be managing the h-1bs and
basically the entry level jobs have
already been offshored completely so
basically he's basically saying like as
long as he uh you use your soft skills
and your native management or
communication or delineation skills that
you learn for being an American you
could still position yourself to win to
winning in a tightening Global Tech game
where obviously everybody is trying to
get the hardest working cheapest workers
at the best price with the most hours
that they possibly can literally that is
the name of capitalism you can't blame
capitalism like my only thing about is
like this listen people love
billionaires they love
multi-millionaires they love these
companies they love it when they're
investing in Tesla and stuff like that
but now the Tesla CEO wants to do
something that is very Pro company and
now they're acting all surprised like
Elon is who Elon always was and Vic is
certainly a super capitalist right if
you look at how he got rich in the sort
of like buying out the defunct drugs
thing anyway anyway here let's take a
look at some Asian responses those were
non-asian responses so this guy said why
do whites want reverse Dei for high-
paid mid-tier tech jobs get real skills
like the Asians we grow up basically
indicating that we don't have like the
coolest lives in high school we're not
like thinking about too and the the prom
and like who we're gting as much because
we're studying so hard to get like
perfect SAT scores and really good GPA
and stack all these accolades so why
would white Americans who it is true
holistically tend to focus on having a
fun life more so in ski trips and stuff
I'm not saying they don't do work as
well but they seems like they care more
about sports and stuff in 2024 to VI's
point I do generally agree with him I
don't agree with his tonage or like
maybe what he's trying to uh self get
his own self incentives in it but what
he said was to Super not wrong but it's
like he's basic this was Asian-American
response saying well why would white
Americans deserve these cushy high-paid
tech jobs just for being native born
American if they're not doing the work
right because this is a global even this
is an Asian-American say this not even
somebody who's an Asian Asian um this
guy said both sides hate Vic for
speaking the truth both the left and the
right hate him yeah it was interesting I
felt like you know from just the quick
research that I was able to do I didn't
see the left have a cohesive response on
this it just depended like we said there
are micro factions in subsets within a
larger narrative as you see as the
Republicans come into power you see
different factions within uh the Trump
Camp going to war with each other over
list of priorities right like the Maga
people are more concerned about the
social Fabric or like how um amican
families I don't necessarily think only
white but I do think they're thinking
about a lot of like maybe like eth to
10th Generation white Americans like
they're like oh well how are they going
to get good jobs cuz I know the tech
jobs are the ones that pay the most and
then Vic and Elon are basically like
well they can't do the job so we're
going to replace them we're going to
bring in people who can't do the job
because it's a race to the top and it's
not just about you know whether these
people who like NFL and NASCAR and stuff
and and can throw a spiral you know can
be participating in the tech industry
and like we said literally guys those
are just two different perspectives like
I hate it when everybody's trying to act
like one was right and one was wrong
they're just different lenses on the
world with different positioning right
like you know what I mean like maybe
you're let let's say for example you're
not involved in the tech sector you make
your money doing something completely
different but you have a lot invested in
American tech companies you might
support H1B visas because you're like oh
yeah that'll allow them to lower their
overhead and their operating costs and
increase profits thus creating the
disparity the disparity goes back to the
shareholders so like I said it all
depends on individual positioning um and
increasingly so in this life but
everybody selling it here's the problem
Elon and especially viveet because vve
is like super salesy he's selling it
like it's a total
win he it's not a total win the magga
crowd has a point that it's not going to
be good for them but then VV is trying
to sell it like it's a total win but
everybody's basically just out for their
own skin in the game basically and
everybody has skin in the game in a
different part of the game um of course
some people didn't like uh vivec's tone
they were just like dude the '90s
sitcoms metaphors or like you know what
I mean like what what did you think that
everybody this is just nerd rage against
the jocks like Revenge of the Nerds 2024
you know there's there was this old '90s
series called Revenge of the Nerds I
mean I will say this it's like there is
certainly his tone even though he wasn't
wrong is tinged with some revenge of the
nerdism because I don't think VI is very
good at team sports to be honest um if
you made me bet money I don't think so
um so basically here's a few points guys
Trump's not even in office yet and
different factions within his party are
going at it I I guess this is kind of
normal even within the left you know you
had your Hillary Clinton uh more like
Warhawk Democrats than you had Nancy
Pelosi which is more like I don't know I
guess like maintaining money I guess and
then you had like aoc's and the IL Hans
and it was like those are more like
societal you know what I mean so it's
like even within the left there are
different subsets and different factions
within any sort of larger party
denomination of course right um you know
nobody's acknowledging the salience in
each other's arguments and and actually
a lot of people can be right but it's
just driven like I said from their own
positioning and their own exposure to
something and there's pros and cons and
the pros and cons are going to vary you
know what I mean and it's just like I
just think that long story short
guys global capitalism W right you could
AR argue that whether left or right
there's a corporatocracy and sometimes
that corporatocracy goes left like Elon
did for a number of years and even Vive
was like more on the left for a while if
you look earlier in his career and
sometimes the corporatocracy goes right
and I would say that the corporations
generally went a little bit right this
time you know what I mean um and it's
very rare for like big Tech and you
could argue that elon's in big Tech you
know what I mean whether or not you know
um Hardware because they do a lot of
Hardware stuff is like fully on the big
Tech side but like you know it's rare
for it to shift right but that's where
the momentum is right now and that's
maybe whatever due to the left messing
it up and I don't even know doing all
the whatever they did but I'm just
saying that listen guys late late late
stage capitalism brought us here it is
true Americans were like more enjoying
their wealth that they had around the
world uh in terms of like an advantage
or Arbitrage against the rest of the
world and they took that advantage and
then they created things like
influencers America had the best
influencers right you see twitch and all
this kaat and all this stuff like that
and um was it Emma Chamberlain and I'm
saying that that's amazing because that
also dictates a lot of culture around
the world that's soft power but it is
true that Americans really got away from
doing hardcore stem studying like
seriously like we really really got away
from it so now the companies are saying
how can I be competitive as Tesla versus
like Neo or byd or all these upcoming
Chinese EV Brands if they are graduating
40% of the world's stem people but we
can't trust the Chinese so we need to
bring in all the Indians cuz those are
the only nerds that we can trust to
bolster America but then the mag is
saying well one you're not hiring us or
you're not hiring anybody that looks
like us and number two then all the
money will be belonging to noncitizens
and the uh the profits potentially could
be repatriated or at least it just going
to somebody who lives like a wildly
different lifestyle than me whether in
terms of cons media consumption or
actual lifestyle expenditure right so um
obviously I I here's a funny thought I
think that most Maga people would want
like hot Asian women like East Asian
women's specifically like Chinese women
or maybe like Korean or Japanese women
uh some you know Filipino and Vietnamese
as well you know but uh Tai you know but
I'm just saying that like actually I
think that's what Maga what Maga would
want I think if Maga truly had its way
it would want petite thick Latinas and
would want you know thin Asian women but
of course you cannot that that also had
stem degrees I really think that that's
what they would want but at the end of
the day since that's like a joke on the
internet even though it's actually real
to the core and that's not possible on a
policy level you're more looking at like
dudes right realistically Indian guys
from like whatever state whatever
Technical Institute that they graduated
from so I'm saying that it's just this
hilarious situation and like I said
that's why I don't know if we're really
like people don't everybody late late
stage capitalism is the American
economic system wrestling with a bear
you're already wrestling with a bear now
some people are trying to be like oh you
got to wrestle with it this way you got
to Jiu-Jitsu and roll the bear left you
got to roll the Bear right you got to
try to get Arm Control you got to get in
a in a leg lock basically everybody's
arguing over different um techniques but
the here's the truth this hyper late
stage capitalism is here and when you
have a a like a long-term consequence
which is like Americans no longer caring
about stem and then you have a
corporatocracy that develops from it and
now the corporatocracy is basically like
hey guys listen we try to make with uh
work with Native americ uh native born
Americans for as long as we could now we
can't anymore now it feels like the
corporatocracy is quote unquote flipping
on the um on the nativist crowd so like
we said we it's just people that were on
the same team for the election now
having their more individual interests
at odds with each other so anyway guys
listen you're going to see more of that
stuff going on I mean my general take is
this I think that American companies you
know do have a right to be strong but
interestingly enough when you know like
you you you could do something like
Japan where people are not allowed to
become citizens they're just they just
have to work and then leave you know
what I mean but then I don't know if
that de incentivizes people to even come
in the first place and then there's
Birthright citizenship and stuff like
that but basically it's like we in a new
Global world and the companies are
already living in that new Global world
but a a lot of Americans mentally and
emotionally are not living in that new
Global World so I I would tell any
American that's smart listen guys the
corporations do run a lot more than you
think they do and dictate a lot more
stuff whether it's obvious or not
obvious so you might as well go Global
yourself and uh you know what I mean
like whether it's in skill set or just
position yourself in a way that's going
to be beneficial because like we said
Trump already said he's supporting vvec
and elon's perspectives because at the
end of the day the American economy runs
on money and it runs on cash flow when
it runs on people making money and
spending a lot of money and uh if the
H1B Visa is increasing it in a large
number is going to do that that's what's
going to happen I think that it's
unfortunate that almost like the magga
crowd like didn't really I don't know
what they were voting for you know what
I mean like at the end of the day you
know this it's like America is not
really run by the left or the right it's
more so run by the companies and the
companies have the most outside say
Beyond these like philosophies or
principles that people are supposed to
stand for usually people stand on those
principles or philosophies to get
elected but when you see on the
execution side it'll ultimately come
down to shareholders and money and these
like hyper macro you know capitalization
numbers so anyway guys like I said I
it's interesting as an Asian-American
whose like Dad basically came on a H1B
Visa you know what I mean uh but you
know what I mean like yeah like I said
it's going to happen regardless I think
Americans should focus more on education
but it almost seems like it's too far
gone have you ever seen how hyper
gladiatorial and how hardcore stem India
and China are it's almost like
unbelievable it would take like that
would be like asking India and China to
catch up with the US on being cool which
is what kids are focusing on over here
it would be impossible anyway guys let
me know what you think in the comment
section below it is what it is listen I
know people wanted me to give an answer
I'm just explaining what's happening
like in terms of like whether I think a
should happen or not I
mean that's just the system that we run
like I that's just not how I think
anyway guys let me know what you think
in the comments section below until next
time with the hop out boys live from
Bangkok one take I'm out peace
