Seattle has become the first city outside of India to ban any sort of caste-based discrimination.
And a lot of people are like, oh, that sounds good. But what does this all mean?
Yeah, this is going viral right now. Like we said, guys, Seattle, the first place
outside of India, the entire world to ban this. Andrew, it's been banned in India for 70 years.
I'm telling you, a lot of people were debating this law, not just the law itself,
but some people were like, why do we even have this in America? I don't know what's going on.
So we got to get into some of the reactions and then some of our takeaways, guys. So make sure
you like, subscribe, and turn on your notifications, Andrew. Let's get into it,
Andrew. What is going on with the caste system? Because I didn't know that this was an issue in
America. Right. Well, I guess apparently, and I guess through reading the articles,
there's a lot of immigrants coming over, and particularly maybe in the tech space,
where the tech industry hires a lot of people from India, and maybe people get promoted,
and then people of the higher caste get promoted, and they're in charge. And then I guess there are
some cases or reports of people discriminating against people like employees from a lower caste.
Right. And that is the whole concept behind the law, right?
Right, right. And the whole law is supposed to prevent this, but it doesn't just apply to the
tech space. But I would suspect that that's where it kind of comes from and steps from.
Right. And there's just so much argument about this from within the Indian community,
but also outside of the Indian community, but for like different reasons, right?
Yeah. So we had to talk to some brown friends about this, and they were different types of
brown friends, by the way. So I got an opinion. And overall, from our friends who are more
Americanized, they were like, you know, this is good. It's progressive. But like,
if you didn't bring this up to me, I would have never heard about this, because I don't even
think about the caste system. Like, I don't even know what caste I am. And I'm like, yeah,
that's true. I think most Indian Americans don't think about this kind of stuff.
And I guess other people were bringing up, though, that because they need so many tech workers,
brain workers, people who can code, work in software that are straight from India,
you may need to legislate it, or at least that's the concept behind the law, because they're more
bringing the old world dynamics because they just came from there versus coming from like 30 years
ago. And by the way, a lot of immigrants do still bring over like motherland dynamics from the
motherland across the ocean to America. Just because you cross the ocean and immigrate here
doesn't mean you leave everything behind. By the way, not saying we agree or disagree with
the concept of the law, just like trying to explain it. Moving on to number two, someone
was like, man, classic woke Seattle, fixing tiny niche issues that impact only a tiny,
tiny portion of the community instead of the real issues like crime, homelessness, drug use,
messed up highways. This is classic Seattle, just not fixing anything that everybody needs,
but just doing this. You know, I'm not going to like vouch and say like the Seattle,
I agree with everything they do. But now for as far as this law, I think that one,
it was an easy sell because it's an anti-discrimination law. And if you're bringing
this up in Seattle, who in Seattle is going to deny this? Well, yeah, it's very like, I guess,
liberal, a lot of white people, right? That probably are like, yeah, I'll sign it. Obviously,
it was pushed forward by an Indian council woman. Yeah. I mean, I think maybe passing this law was
fairly easy. It didn't take up too many resources. I do not think that passing this law took all the
resources away from trying to solve the drug use and homelessness problem. But do you think it is
accusing it of being performative in the sense of like, they're like, how are they going to
legislate this? Like, it's going to be too murky and convoluted on execution. I do think as far
as enforcing it, just even having the law is going to scare people from discriminating against other
people. So maybe that's it. It does make me go, hey, guys, I'm not saying these little wins are
not wins. You know, it's good to put out little fires. But what about these gigantic fires? Is
it because the gigantic fires are just too complicated to navigate? So you focus on like
the media blowing up. It could be a media thing, too. It's not necessarily them just like blowing
it up their wins to make it look like they're doing a good job. Maybe the media is like, oh,
yeah, this story looks like it's definitely going to get a lot of hits. But if it's this easy to
scare people out of discriminating against each other, I guess do it. Yeah. So why even recreate
these old world rules, man? I thought all the immigrants used to come to America and assimilate.
Now you're telling me they're not even assimilating anymore where we got to put together
laws to legislate like the laws like they have back in the old world. I don't like this type of
immigration anymore. I mean, I even want to talk about like Chinese immigrants because we know a
lot of Chinese immigrants. And I would say that, you know, depending on the province you're from,
certain Chinese people will kind of discriminate against you a little bit like they'll say
stereotypes. Yeah. In a low key way. For example, if your family owns property in Beijing or Shanghai
and you meet somebody from like Hubei province, for sure, you're going to think maybe you're
cooler than them. Right. Right. I don't I don't know how to what extent I think different people
feel it at different levels. But because if you're like a rich fob in a Ferrari from Hubei,
well, yeah, you just only have a Lexus and I have a Ferrari. So even though you're from Beijing,
I am from Hubei. How can you say that Beijing is better than Hubei? Yeah. I mean, I know Chinese
immigrants that do and don't care about this kind of stuff. You know what I mean? I mean,
it even happened with white people, right, with like Irish and Italians coming to New York in
I want to say the late 1800s. That's what the whole movie Gangs of New York was about. Dude,
they didn't even like JFK because he was an Irish Catholic and he was the president of the United
States. So discrimination will not really stop. Right. To be honest. But I can totally understand
like why people are like, yeah, man, why do we even need laws about something I don't even know
about now? I got to think about laws of stuff I'm not even aware of. I don't know. Yeah, I can see
both sides moving on. And some people said, well, you know, there's real need for these laws, guys.
So whether you understand them or not, because it's not a part of your culture, we're just trying
to protect people from their world. I mean, maybe this was just something that I wasn't supposed to
care about, man. I wish I never read or watch this video. Doggone it. Now I got to think about
this stuff. But I wish I wish I just didn't think about it. Yeah. I mean, to be fair, I think that
laws have always been hyper localized. Like it wouldn't surprise me if Salt Lake City had some
like Mormon based laws that don't exist in other cities where there's not a high property. You know
what I mean? Like they're not dealing with this situation as much. Yeah, I don't think every law
was meant for us to understand, to be honest. And because it doesn't concern a lot of us. You know,
the people who are outside of these circles are like one percent Indian, I believe. And actually,
America is about less than one percent Indian. So theoretically, and even of that one percent,
only like a certain amount of people even pay attention to this. You know what I mean? Like
it's kind of like a fraction of a fraction. Sure. But I will say this. Once your population in
America, like Hindus are like estimated to be like two point five million in America. And then
like South Asians as a total are like four point five. There's millions of these people that may
or may not abide by these dynamics. So the last group was like, man, this law is terrible. And
this opinion was obviously from a variety of Indian people say some people said, man,
it's just going to be used to settle personal beefs. Nobody even knows how the caste system
works in America. So how are they going to legislate it when it's so convoluted and
multilayered now? It's not even clear cut. Sometimes it's just tribalism between castes,
different castes. It's not even about who's higher and who's lower anymore. This this whole
thing is a mess. Just keep this out of America. Yeah. And so, yeah, I had these are opinions from
Indians. Yeah. Yeah. An Indian friend was just like, man, like, honestly, I wish people would
just stop thinking about the caste system. So now you're making people think about it more and then
they got to know what caste they are. I don't even know what caste I am, you know? So I guess
there's always going to be criticism of every law. But overall, I guess if it's to stop
discrimination, that sounds like a good thing to do and you should do it for sure. And I just think
with any laws, man, it's always like so many pros and cons. Like, for example, let's say,
for example, there's a group that's being discriminated against. That's wrong. Good
that they have a law against them. But then maybe that law could be jujitsu and used against other
people unfairly. So then that's like, I guess, the convoluted mess of it all, right? Yeah,
it's possible. David, what are the overall takeaways? Because we want you guys to leave it
in the comments down below what you think. Because we really don't know. To be honest,
we are complete outsiders looking in. Like I said, I think most people in America,
their knowledge of the caste system is zero out of 10. My understanding of it is like 1.5 out of 10.
And maybe even the people who pass this law do not have a 10 out of 10 understanding. I mean,
here's my thing. Discrimination is not going to end. I mean, you can post up laws. I think it
helps. I think it scares people. And I think it does punish people who do it and that you can
prove that do it. But it's not going to actually stop like personal discrimination. I mean,
it's kind of weird. Like in England, Andrew, if you have like a cockney accent, people are going
to judge you for having the cockney. They're going to be like, I don't really trust this fella.
Or if you're from Birmingham, London, you know, which is the city outside of London,
they got like a bad accent. Or if you're from Birmingham, Alabama, where you're like.
Nate, the comedian Nate is always talking about a man in Louisiana. Everybody thinks when you talk
like this, you're stupid. You can be the smartest guy in the whole entire world. You go to New York,
people are going to think you're dumb. Yeah, I mean, think about it. If you got this voice
and you're trying to make it in like New York, you know, the finance world or somehow in the
tech industry, people are not going to take it seriously. In China, if you tell people, oh,
yeah, yeah, I have a hedge fund, but I'm from Guizhou. Some people are going to be like,
like, we don't know if we're going to trust a Guizhou guy or like people in South Korea.
Right. If you don't have the soul accent, you have like a really rural, like countryside accent.
So then you maybe have to change your accent. I don't know. It's tough to say, man. Like,
yeah, you know, I think the truth is that there's always hierarchies in this world.
And I guess I guess this was just I think it was an easy path, a lot of past. I hope it didn't take
up any resources. I hope it doesn't cost the state too much. But I think if it was to stop
some discrimination in a very popular industry that has a lot of money and power in Seattle,
the tech industry, then perhaps it's a good thing, you know, so why not? But
your nose, man, like I said, is, dude, no law is perfect. And maybe there's some side effects,
but you guys let us know in the comments down below. Again, guys, we're just on the outside
looking in also wondering what this all means, too, because it's interesting to us. But let us
know in the comments down below. We are the hot pop boys. And until next time we out peace.