The debate is raging on once again.
Are Indians considered Asian or not?
Let's find out.
Andrew, it is very rare that a comedy sketch sparks
an international discussion.
But that's what happened when Ronnie Chang made a joke
on The Daily Show about Indians not being Asian now.
And since then, there are so many other videos and so many clips
and so much debating and so many comments that happened since then.
Guys, we're going to go through them.
We're going to talk about it.
Maybe we'll try to come up with an answer at the end.
So please hit that like button and check out other episodes of Hot Pop Boys.
Let's run the clips.
...is the new prime minister of the week, Rishi Sunak.
And I know everyone is really excited that this is the first Asian prime minister.
But let's be clear.
Indians are not Asian, OK?
OK, there's still people, great people.
They're just not Asian people, OK?
No, no, no. Answer me this.
If this guy is Asian, how come when he became prime minister,
I felt absolutely nothing?
I mean, when I was down at Dim Sum Palace this morning,
me and the fellas were like, oh, shit, that's me up there.
I feel seen.
I love how Indians try to have it both ways, like being Indian and Asian.
Pick a lane, OK?
Yeah, I bet if I show up in a Bollywood film, I'm just going to blend right in.
Right, because we're all just one people just having a good time.
Yo, Ronnie went in on this, and I'll tell you this, Andrew,
this sparked like 300, 400,000 comments, you know, Internet comments globally.
You know, I'm sure at Asian student unions at all of the colleges,
there were heated debates.
There was like just like a lot more that came from this than you would expect.
Yeah, I mean, it was a really funny bit.
But obviously, the reason why people are talking about it
and that's why you have so many comments from India is because,
you know, the Daily Show is such a global and international show.
Ronnie and Trevor are both international people.
So when they say it, it even means more than just like Americans debating it.
And since this clip came out over the past four weeks, bro,
there are so many other Internet channels that have responded
or made videos asking Indians in India if they're Asian.
And I think it's actually more of a legitimate question in Asia
because more of the AAPI sort of like I don't want to say, you know,
Wokie groups in America.
They were more like, oh, my gosh, what Ronnie said is a threat to unity.
And like but then people in India were like, no, let's have this debate.
I think it is worthy.
Like that. It's always been.
Guys, when we're talking about identity
and we're talking about how people feel, I mean, guys, this is the season to do it.
Everybody's talking about it.
So so let's have the conversation.
And I think it's like you said, Andrew, it's interesting
because people in India can speak English as one of their main languages.
So it allows the Internet comments to be representative of a way
that they feel in Asia that like no other Asian country could do.
Let's see some responses from India.
Do you personally see yourself to be as an Indian?
Do you personally see yourself as Asian or Indian?
I would prefer to be as an Indian.
First of all, I'll say I'm an Indian and an Asian afterwards.
Specifically Indian, but Asians.
Indian. And I feel proud to be called or known as Indian.
I think I see myself as an Indian.
If any foreigner would call you Asian?
Not really, because I am an Asian.
I am a part of this continent, so I won't be offended.
I don't think people would think of us as Asian.
They would think of us as Indian, but that's their ignorance, right?
But it makes sense because they're in Asia.
So why call yourself Asian while you're in India?
Because you're already in that country.
So I get it that that's why there's a rift between the Asian-Americans
who want to use a unifying term in order to feel together
because we're a minority because they select Asian-Americans have that,
I guess, more and it's not right or wrong, that political agenda.
But I'm saying it makes sense because you're only six percent of the population.
You want to feel like you have a stronger group.
So you try to find the similarities.
OK, we all go to similar schools.
We have similar passions as far as academics. Right.
OK, we eat rice, take off our shoes and we enter the house.
We all have old traditions.
STEM subjects. Right.
So then so you unite on that.
And I'm not saying that there's not actually similarities.
I just think in India and in Asia, like if you're in Japan.
Yeah, I could see Japanese people more even saying like, well, you know,
I am Japanese, but I am Asian.
What you're referring to is more about the context that you're living in.
Obviously, in a Western context, everybody's sort of different
from the dominant group in America, which is represented by Anglo-Saxons.
But like, I don't know, it just shows you a context is everything.
All right.
This is a clip of an Indian-American comedian
who is actually against using the term South Asian and just wants to use India.
Ronnie, I'm with you, brother.
I've been saying this for almost 10 years now.
I am Indian. We are Indian.
Why are we so afraid to use this term?
Indian Hindu. There's nothing wrong with that.
OK, there are 1.3 billion of us.
We don't need a cardinal direction.
That's what's up. Chinese, Japanese, Korean.
They're not calling themselves East Asian.
We're the only ones who put a cardinal direction on 1.3 billion people.
Why do we need this kind of permission?
OK, I mean, I could see why Rajiv said y'all is a comedian, by the way.
He does. He has a very funny way of just speaking.
Yeah. David, what do you think about what he said?
He said Indians need to own up to being Indian and not need to say South Asian.
But I guess my question is, what about like Bengalis and Pakistanis?
Should they should just go by their country and the nation name, too?
Yeah, I think later in the video, he says, use Desi as the unifying term.
I mean, I agree that, you know, I think that being Indian is different
enough from being, I guess, like a mongoloid Asian
because of the separation of the Himalayas.
I totally see where he's coming from.
But my only thing is like, hmm, like it's hard to fully expect that
just because Indians self-identify like as Indian, right,
that everybody else in America is going to give them the nuance
of identifying them as their like their own continent.
I guess, you know, his point was a little bit confusing
because he's like saying a lot because he's like, yeah, we are Indian.
And I don't like the term South Asian and then we are Hindu.
But if you're not Hindu, then just say you're Desi.
But here's the only thing is, is like it's hard to expect Americans
because Americans sort of like the prison tribes, you know, black, Latino.
White, Asian. Those are the only ways they see it.
They only want to see four.
They want to put people together.
They would see four major prison groups because that's how it was.
David, David, you know, listen,
I only got enough space in my brain for four or five categories max.
All right.
You if you try to make it 12, 13, 14, I'm not even going to address.
Yeah, because not everybody is like an educated comedian in New York City
where you've probably got like 200 different colors in your mind.
Other people got to think about your average American is painting
with the most basic crayon package you could possibly buy in elementary school.
So I think that's the only aspect he would need to address the mechanics
of how you're going to get everybody in America to refer to you as Indian
or are Desi over being part of the larger Asian subgroup.
Yeah. By the way, he was saying that a lot of East Asians
don't use the term East Asian.
I'm actually OK with using that term.
I think that's a term that maybe people could use more if they want to.
Instead of just saying the specific country,
because the East Asian cultures are very similar, right?
They're more closer together.
So I guess like South Asian also includes the Bengalis, Pakistani,
Sri Lankans, et cetera, et cetera. Right.
So that's easy. Yeah.
Daisy countries, you know, the brown countries, the the people.
But then he said, don't use brown either, because he said Latinos have brown.
Well, I don't know.
You guys let me know.
I don't know where he's coming from, though,
because I think that Desi people came to America.
One of it's one of the most like recent groups to come in large numbers
to America, even more recent than East Asians or Southeast Asians.
So they're more like thinking, like, should we use the predetermined terms
or should we try to just forge ahead with our own?
All right. Moving on to the next clip.
Andrew, this is actually from another Daisy comedian.
You know, this application doesn't even have my ethnicity.
All right. I'm just going to put other Indian.
It says Asian right there. So.
So you're Asian? No, I'm not.
What is this? Asia?
And what is that? India? So you're Asian.
Do you just keep a map of Asia with you?
That's not the point.
I'm just saying when people say Asian, they think of you guys.
What do you mean, you guys, you know?
What the ****?
I'm just saying the East Asians kind of hijacked the word.
Oh, we hijacked the word. That's ironic.
What the ****?
I think you're wrong here, man.
OK, watch this.
Hey, Phil. What's up, man?
OK, so I was walking down the street and I saw this Asian guy today.
All right. OK, what are you imagining?
All right. Gently look him up.
Thank you. Exactly.
See? All right. I'll see you later, man.
Oh, man. You know, I was really impressed by this comedy sketch,
and that's why it has like, you know, a half million views,
because it dressed a lot.
It like got into, you know, larger stereotypes about people
thinking that Indians are more like Middle Eastern, possibly,
you know, more, I guess, terrorist jokes.
It was talking about how Asians are always identified
by their squinty or slanted eyes or whatever like the Mongoloid eyes.
Or possibly the monolith.
And then, of course, they left it up to the black American guy
who's just like, I don't know, man.
You look like Jet Li. That's.
Yeah, I mean, I think what the point is, is that a lot of it is context.
I think in America, right, we want to focus on the similarities.
We want to focus on our parents being strict.
You take off your shoes. We all eat rice.
We all want to get good grades.
We're academic focused.
But yeah, there are a lot of cultural differences.
Religion, look, I mean, phenotype, the Himalayas split us up like whatever.
And kind of Nepal is kind of like this blending part in between Bhutan as well.
I saw this really interesting comment, and this was from Indian.
And he was like, you know, it's very complicated
because North Indians are Indo-Aryan or mixed with Middle Eastern genes.
The South Indians are Dravidian.
And then mixed are the Northeast Indians who are Mongoloids
are also mixed with those different bloodlines.
Because India is a very diverse country
with a wide variety of face structure and skin color.
So he was saying that India is in a very unique sort of position.
And I will say this.
I did hear an Indian comedian friend tell me one time,
we got Indians that could pass as white.
We got Indians that could pass as black.
We have Indians that could pass as every single type of Asian in Asia as well.
And then, of course, you've got an overall, I guess,
what you're thinking of a classic Indian Dravidian look,
which could be anywhere from like darker to lighter. Right.
So what if you're like a very East Asian looking Indian person,
which there are essentially East Asian bloodlines in India.
So nationality wise, you're Indian, you speak Hindi,
but then you like look Chinese. Right. So it's complicated.
So I guess. Yeah, I guess.
What would you say?
Like, but I guess anybody commenting, like, what would you put?
But obviously, at the end of the joke, they were bonding over,
you know, STEM subjects, strict academic standards from the parents.
Rice probably, you know, taking off your shoes, things like that.
And Lexus. All right. Next up, Andrew, we don't have a video.
We actually have a meme that went really viral on Reddit recently.
Andrew, what is it trying to say?
OK, so Asians, according to Americans, are Korean, Thai, Cambodian,
like mongoloid, East Asian looking people, right?
Like people who kind of look like a version of us, David.
Oh, man. Why'd they pick the thug for Cambodian, man?
Ah, they put they put Filipino under John Cho.
So I think they're just throwing it around.
I mean, all these people could be Chinese, to be honest.
And then on the British side,
you have mostly desi looking people.
Now you have like more, I guess, lighter skin.
Almost more of a Middle Eastern desi mix look.
And then they do have one, I guess, oriental guy.
I heard, Andrew, that the older people in England, maybe like above 60,
they would refer to them as oriental.
Yes, bro. I was working in L.A.
once and there was an older British lady.
She called you oriental, right?
Yeah, she was. And then she told my coworker that she was looking for me.
She goes, Oh, yes, I was talking and speaking to that oriental man.
And my coworker comes back and is like,
Hey, that lady just called you oriental.
Like, is that right? That's pretty racist. Right.
And then I thought about I was like, I think she's old school.
You know what the interesting thing is, Andrew?
Oriental, I believe, was also used in America.
And that was a more specific term because you would like
probably only say that East Asian people or that look
Southeast Asian or oriental, even though I heard even like in the 1400s,
the Middle East was the Orient.
You know, like Persian rug.
A lot of these terms even change, you know, whatever Asia was
or whoever invented that term Asia from the Greek or the Latins.
Like that wasn't always referring to East Asia.
Yeah, you know why it was.
But it was like because Iran was there, right?
And Iran was still the end of the Silk Road.
So they still were getting silk and all this fine China.
So that's like I could see why the Western Western people got confused.
Because, yeah, it's like it's almost like Asia for a while was more Western.
And then we're like Asia, Asia.
That's where we're from.
Yeah, that's the Orient. Orient.
What what is he to you?
Oh, he's a man.
No ethnicity. What's my ethnicity?
What's your ethnicity?
Like, what would you call people that look like you in the Asian market?
Hold on. I just need to understand a thing.
So you're ordering a hooker, right?
And your description is I want an Asian girl
and then some of it looks like him shows up with a beard.
And at no point are you like, what the **** are you doing here?
How do you say the Asian that we're all thinking about?
Um, I'll just say Asian and just roll the dice, bro.
Do you guys identify as Asian?
No. That's what they called you in Texas.
No, they call me different things.
They just became Indian.
And what did you start as before?
What did they call me in Texas?
They called ice on me in Texas.
OK, so this was a pretty funny clip from flagrant podcast
Andrew with Andrew Schultz.
Basically, he's asking KSI, who's British.
What does he consider Akash?
And he was like, you know, something in the Asian market,
which is a really funny British way of something like something in that zone.
Right. And then Akash goes off to say and Akash is Punjabi, by the way.
He says we don't identify as Asian.
I actually found.
And by the way, guys, don't crucify me, Internet.
I'm just saying what I noticed.
I noticed that northern Indians, specifically Punjabis,
are less likely to call themselves Asian than someone who's like South Asian.
Yeah, from like way down south.
And you know what I got to say?
I feel like that this is a conversation that South Asians or Indians
need to have even more, I guess.
That's why I guess the comedian Rajiv was like talking to the Indian market
and his Indian fan base about it, because I think it's an internal conversation
because I think there's a disagreement.
Some people say there's a line between North Indians
who are more potentially Anglo or Aryan Indian, right?
Mixed with everybody up there.
And then there's a line that's drawn or an invisible line.
And then the southern Indians are more Dravidian,
which is generally like darker skin like Aziz Ansari.
Yeah. I mean, like I said, guys, we're not Indian experts
about the Indian sphere.
That's just what I know.
But that would be an interesting like internal debate.
So like I think terms that I think are useful nowadays
and maybe these are too many terms.
You let me know in the comments down below if you guys are like,
ah, I don't want to be too exact or. Yeah.
All this talk is already getting confusing, man.
I'm going back to the four colors.
Hey, Billy Bob, I can't believe you even watch as much of the video.
But like terms like Desi, Desi, Desi and then Pan-Asian,
which is like all Asian.
So maybe in America you're like, I'm Pan-Asian American.
I, I, I relate to everybody.
There's East Asian, which I'm OK with using Southeast Asian, of course.
And then there's Anglo-Aryan Indian, which is a new term
that people started bringing up a little bit more Dravidian Indian.
You know what I notice is like on subtle curry traits,
they use curry as a bonding way to bond all South Asians.
But I totally understand why they wouldn't.
They probably would not want people outside of the group
identifying them that way.
Oh, it's almost like, you know, in Asia, you can identify
with using, I guess, like chopsticks and rice,
but you wouldn't want other people to identify you that way.
Yeah. Well, you know, I think this brings up a conversation of like,
what are you willing to take from outsiders calling you that?
Right. Because within the group, you can say whatever you want.
You can go hard, make fun of people because it's all in the family.
Yeah, you can. Oh, yeah, it's all within the family.
You can talk about hierarchy.
But then when people on the outside
who are perceived to be on the outside or actually walking by,
hey, subtle curry traits, yeah, people would be offended.
Yeah. And then they're like, what are you talking about, man?
Like, you can't say that.
And then I'm like, I'm from India, man.
I'm from I'm from eastern northeast India.
What if I said that?
Like, I'm from I'm from the Assam region, you know, Calcutta, Chinatown.
You know, I've been there.
This is a clip of Asian boss asking Indian people to respond
to the Ronnie Chang clip.
This time where he's coming from, because if I see some person
who doesn't look like me become
get into a power position of authority,
I won't really relate with him.
I relate with Rishi Sunak because he looks like me.
If he didn't look like me, I probably would not relate with him.
So I don't really mind this.
I think it's funny.
He made a he made a joke, and I think it's a good joke.
He's a great comedian.
He's playing to the American stereotype of Indians versus Asians.
In America, you think of Asians as East Asians,
and you think of Indians and Pakistanis and Bangladeshis as Indians, right?
He's just playing to that stereotype.
It's got no global context.
I don't think any Indian should ever worry about it.
And I actually think it's a funny joke.
He's quite hilarious.
So when you travel overseas, have you ever been called Asian by foreigners
or do they call you entirely different?
I haven't been called Asian.
I've been called Indian, in fact.
Yeah, I mean, I think that that guy summed it up pretty well.
In America, people sort of use Asian as a substitute for the word,
I guess, mongoloid or oriental, because those words are like, you know,
even though they're very specific, the connotation has been negative at points.
So those are like outlawed words to use.
But it is true that the term Asian is way more amorphous and way more vague
because it's more wide encompassing.
And that's what's causing the confusion.
So that's the dynamic that Ronnie was joking off of.
Yo, how weird would it be if like white people or black people
started coming up to us and being like, hey, you guys are mongoloid, right?
That would be funny because we use this term amongst ourselves.
At least amongst people who are into this type of anthropology, biology talk.
Right. And like, you know, culture talk.
But like if you had an outsider just come in and like, yeah,
you're East Asian mongoloids. Yeah, that's right.
And then I'd be like, yeah, yeah, yeah, I guess.
Yeah. Well, it's because the term mongoloid for a while,
I guess like 100 years ago was used to describe people with Down syndrome.
Or I don't know, guys.
To wrap this up, David, what is the answer to the question?
Are Indians considered Asian or not?
OK, so we just watched a bunch of videos with their opinions, right, Andrew?
But I actually did some scientific research.
OK, so here's the funny side.
This random Korean guy just wanted to say, listen,
if you can do basic calculations without a calculator to me, you're an Asian.
That's a funny way of saying it, right?
Like that. That's bonding us all together.
Like you said, as long as you can just do the basic, basic arithmetic,
something to bond us. Yeah, OK.
But then I read this other thing that said it really has to do with the Himalayas.
India is certainly part of Asia.
However, there are different geographical and physical constraints
that also led them to have a different like cultural development in India,
even though there was, you know, the passage of Buddhism
through the Himalayas from Nepal over to obviously East Asia and Southeast Asia.
There's different political concerns.
There's different countries that we think about.
People in India are much more likely to think about the Middle East
than people in East Asia or Southeast Asia are going to think about
what's going on in Britain in the Middle East.
So there's yes, but it's also different.
That's the answer. Yes.
But Indians are definitely Asian, but it is also different
due to the Himalayas and just more interaction with other groups.
You know, my opinion is and just speaking from an American standpoint,
being around other Asians in America, it's like when you have a common goal
and you want to align yourselves politically and get something done,
you team up as Asian.
We're all Asian.
We are from Asia and we do share similarities.
We are fighting discrimination at the Harvard admission.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
My Asian brother, our kid, they studied so hard,
but they said they got too many Asians at Harvard.
Mess up.
And don't worry, men, the Hindus are being discriminated against, too, men.
They don't want us playing the venue flute.
They don't want us playing that.
And I think that when you want to get something done, you team up.
But internally, you all know each other's different.
And I don't think that the two communities,
if you want to call just the Asian community, one community, right?
And then the Indian community, I don't think our South Asian community,
I don't necessarily think they mix as much as they could.
But I think at the end of the day, you know, it just takes time.
I think India has a lot of conversations to have amongst themselves, too,
because they have a lot of different shades of each other.
So, yeah, I think it's a cool conversation.
Like we said, I don't know the answer.
The answer is yes, Indians are Asian.
No, using the term Asian.
But there probably should be some more specific terms, Andrew.
What terms could be better?
Because Mongoloids out, you know, Daisy or Dravidian,
that's going to be tough to get people to use it.
Orientals out, even though nobody wants to use the word chinky
because that's like, how about this?
How about this?
If you're Indian or brown, but you know how to use chopsticks
and you drink boba, you're Asian.
Um, if you're Nikki Haley and you're Punjabi, not.
Yeah. And then what about countries like Cambodia and India?
I mean, I'm sorry, Cambodia and Thailand, where they're there.
They've got a pretty decent amount of exposure to the Indian sphere
where they like, you know, they have Hinduism and things like that.
Yeah, I mean, I think people like Tim Grover, who is Punjabi,
he might just consider himself Indian and not Asian.
You're saying Nikki Haley and Tim Grover probably would do not see themselves
as would they even more specifically consider themselves just Punjabi?
Yeah, it's I don't know.
It's possible based on what I know. I'm not speaking for them.
I'm just saying that these two people do not look like typical Asian Indians at all.
Yeah. I mean, listen, guys, I think that this discussion could go on forever.
And that's why it's a fun discussion to have.
But at the end of the day, you know, it's all love.
You know why the Ronnie clip went viral is because Ronnie gave an answer to this.
While a lot of people don't want to give the answer,
that's the joke, is that Ronnie had the answer.
The truth is, it's complicated.
But of course, it's funny.
Yeah. Much love to everybody, guys.
Like we said, we're just trying to review the clips
and just do some basic research off Google.
I don't know. You can identify as anything you want, man.
You know, at one point in history, the Japanese,
they didn't really want to call themselves Asian.
Yeah. Just consider themselves Japanese.
Yeah. It's still to this day.
I would say the older ones definitely do not want to mix with everybody else.
We are not Asian.
I mean, it almost has to do with like the separation from the pack.
I would say like Japan and Korea, obviously, they have a certain level
of like success, you know, that, you know, other Asian countries don't fully have.
You know, I know Singapore is very rich as well, but they don't
maybe don't have like the sports teams and stuff like that.
So it's like it just has to do with like how much are you with the group
or how much are you feeling like you're elevating beyond it
or how much are you treated different?
The last thing that I would say that is my major takeaway
is you really have to look at these like really interesting British colonies
in Asia, whether we're talking about Singapore, Malaysia, Hong Kong.
You know what I mean?
Like that's really where you saw Indians and Chinese mix.
And maybe to some extent term Asian in America, whatever that means.
It's just not that serious. Yeah, it's not.
It's not that serious, maybe because it's such a broad term encompasses everybody.
So anyways, guys, let us know what you think in the comments down below.
Thank you so much for watching.
We are the Hot Pop Boys.
And until next time we out. Peace.