What I learned about the hamon on my Chinese-made katana

Ancient Edge 1
3 followers
17 Video ViewsยทJan 6, 2025
This is the Bamboo Warrior Sword. In the advertisements for it, it said it had a clay coat
that would reveal a true Hamon. So that's why I got it. I wanted a real, true Hamon.
And it does come with a beautiful Hamon. You can see it's right there, the transition lines
between the hardened steel and the softer steel. But this is not the original Hamon that it had
when I got it. And that's because this sword was given to students, and it got dinged up,
and it needed to be re-sharpened. And when I re-sharpened, I sharpened by hand,
wet, dry sandpaper. So I erased all of the Hamon that the sword came with. But I wanted a Hamon
on it, so I dipped in an acid again. And this is what was revealed. It's a real Hamon. It shows
the transition, but it's not the original one that it came with. And most importantly,
it doesn't even close to resemble now, the Hamon that I got with the sword. This
Hamon is way better. So what that means is that the skill of the person who puts the acid on
was different. They were different. And the type of acid we use, I just used an etchant from
Radio Shack, and I doubt that's what they used in China. And my etch is not as reflective
as the etches that you see out of China. They use some other type of stuff, and it's a beautiful,
beautiful Hamon, but it looks totally different than mine. This is a real Hamon.
Now the next sword, this is a Hanwei T10. Again, it came with a beautiful Hamon,
a beautiful Hamon. But like with the Bamboo Warrior, this sword was used, and I had to
sand it by hand. Again, I erased the Hamon that I got with it, and I ended up having to acid etch
this one. I did this because I was curious to know if the Hanwei Hamons were real, and this one
it is. As you can see, this is my job, my etching, and it reveals the difference between the hardened
steel and the soft steel. So that's T10. The next sword is one I got from swords from Northshire.
It's a match set, this one, and another long one I got. It came with what looked like a Hamon.
You'll notice it's missing now. There's no sign of it. And the reason is that, once again,
I sharpened the sword because it gets used. And then I tried to do an acid etch after I
did, just like I did with the others, to reveal the Hamon, and none was revealed.
And so I just kind of buffed it sharp to get rid of the discoloration. Because the etching that I
use, it'll leave it discolored, which is why my Hamons don't really match what you get out of
China. I'm using probably a stronger etch. But anyway, this is the swords of Northshire. It
came to me with a Hamon. It doesn't have one really. So it was not heat treated, and quite
frankly, even though it says it's 1060 steel, I'm not really sure it was even hardened. It seems to
sharpen pretty easy. Now the next sword, I'm not even sure the name of this sword. I ordered it
in a plain, unvarnished, unpolished case. But it has a fantastic Hamon. Again, it's revealed via
etching. This is not a polished, but it is real. It's a magnificent, magnificent Hamon.
But it's revealed through an etch. It's not revealed through polishing.
Polishing, if you polish this sword, you get a Hamon. But it would look drastically different
than this. Both of them are real. They just look different. Now on the next swords, I guess one
more. This sword, I forged myself and did all this. It doesn't have any, I guess I got it buried in
oil here. There's no visible Hamon on it right now. Because again, I use this sword. I made it,
you know, so I use it all the time. And I have etched it when I made it, and it revealed the
Hamon. I just used a straight line Hamon. But because I sand it all the time, I just don't
bother with trying to put a beautiful Hamon on it. Why get emotional about it? It's, you know,
I don't get too involved. I get sanded all the time. But the deal is, if I were to take this to
a hand polisher, he would reveal a beautiful Hamon. Also, at the same time, if I took this sword
just to an acid bath, and I did another etch on it, it would reveal the same type of Hamon that
I have on my other swords, more or less. I know that because I did the clay coating on this. I
know it was clay coating because I did it. So that's the difference here in how you can expect
to get a Hamon out of China. Some are fake, like the one that came with this sword. Some are totally
fake that once I rubbed it off, and I tried to do an etch over, you know, to see if there was one,
there was none. And some are real out of China, like these, the T-10 and the Bamboo Ward,
were confirmed by an etch that really was clay coated at some point in its life, and
it has two different types of steel, and that transition line shows up in Hamon.
I guess that's all I have to say about it. That's how you can tell and what to expect out of China.
Thank you.
