Lecture 09: Propagation Through Medium Boundaries: Oblique Incidence

IIT Roorkee July 201
61 followers
1 Video View·Dec 26, 2024
Hello and welcome to lecture 9 in the series on Noise Control in Mechanical Systems, and
I am Professor Sneha Singh from IIT Roorkee. So, to sum up, till now we have studied about
sound wave propagation, sound wave propagation in homogeneous medium, where we studied about
the different wave fronts, and then we have also studied about sound wave propagation
through a planar medium boundary, when wave is incident normal to the boundary, to the
plane of the boundary. And we have been able to solve some numericals based on this interaction,
but in real life the sound waves can be coming from various directions depending on the location
of the source, and they may be incident at various varying angles at different planar
boundaries. So, we need to solve and see what happens when a sound wave is incident obliquely
or at a random angle to the plane of the boundary, which we will cover in this particular class.
And while we discuss this phenomenon, we will come to know of the Snell's law of wave refraction,
we will do some special cases and then solve some numerical problems.
So, let us see, this is our medium 1, this is our medium 2, and some sound wave, and
again for solving all these interactions, we have chosen that the wave is a harmonic
plane wave, but the relations derived in general hold true for spherical and cylindrical waves
as well, because they can be decomposed or they can be thought of as a special case of
harmonic wave front. So, here I am representing this using this arrow, the arrow represents
the direction of propagation of the harmonic wave, and this indicates the wave front from
the top view. So, this schematic you can look at it in my lecture on harmonic plane wave,
where I have discussed what this arrow and the perpendicular things mean. So, what is
this notation or what is the meaning of this symbol, you can see in that particular lecture.
So, here we see an incident wave at some angle theta i with the normal to the surface, and
then it is getting reflected and transmitted. So, let us represent, so here our incident
wave, let us take first of all our x and y axis, this is our x direction and y direction.
So, if this is the axis we are choosing, then in that case the incident wave is propagating
in the forward x and y axis or the plus x plus y direction, it is propagating in that.
So, forward in x and forward in y, so accordingly for a harmonic plane wave, we can represent
it as the amplitude into e to the power j omega t minus the x component of the wave
number times x minus the y component of the wave number times y. Now, let us see this
is the x component of the wave propagation vector, and this is the y component of the
wave propagation vector, and what is the propagation vector, it has the magnitude of the wave number
which is omega by c, k 1 is omega by c, in our case we have two mediums, so we can represent
it as omega by c 1, because in these interactions omega which is the frequency remains the same.
So, both f and omega remain same for such interactions, it is only the speed of the
sound that is changing from medium to medium, so this is our overall k 1, and the k 1 vector
is something with the magnitude as omega by c 1 or rather this. So, for k 1 vector the
magnitude of this is omega by c 1, and the k 1 vector direction is along wave propagation
direction. So, this is our k 1 vector, and as you can
see the wave is propagating with an angle of theta i with the x axis, so this becomes
the direction of our k 1 vector, and k 1 x is the x component, and k 1 y is the y component,
so here just to just so that this thing is visible to you I am going to erase this part.
So, this is our k 1 x which is the x component of the k 1 vector, and k 1 y which is the
y component, we are using k 1 because it is the k of medium 1. So, what is the relationship
between the two as you can see from the figure and simple trigonometry k 1 x is k 1 times
cos theta i, and k 1 y is k 1 times sin theta i. So, let us replace this in the above equation,
so this is the after replacing this is the equation we are getting.
In the same way we can do for the transmitted wave, transmitted wave itself also is travelling
in it is travelling forwards in the x axis and the y axis, so here that is why we have
the negative sign, and we have the symbol k 2 instead of k 1, because it is in a different
medium. So, here k 2 is omega by c 2, just like how we had found out the relationship
between k 1 x and k 1 y in terms of the overall k 1.
In the same way we find this we sort of solve it, and we come to this format where it is
e to the power j omega t minus k 2 x cos theta t minus k 2 y sin theta t, where theta t is
the angle between the k 2 vector and the x axis. In the same way let us derive the equation
for the reflected wave, now as you can observe the reflected wave it is travelling sort of
forward in the positive y direction, because this is our x and y coordinate which I will
draw here as well. This is our x and this is our y, and what is happening to a reflected
wave it is travelling in positive y, but negative directions that is why we have a plus sign
in the x component and a minus sign in y. If you again dissolve this and write it in
terms of k 1, and here because reflected and incident wave are in the same medium, they
both have the same wave number k 1 which is omega by c 1. So, you resolve it and the wave
vector of the reflected wave is making an angle of theta r with the x axis. So, ultimately
this is the relationship we get when we resolve its x and y component.
Now, let us see the same continuity of normal pressure on the boundary as we have been doing
for the case of normal incidence. So, at x equals to 0, we add up the pressure just on
the left hand side of the boundary and the right hand side of the boundary, and the pressure
is continuous. There is continuity of the pressure at that point. Hence, p at the limit
of x tends to 0 negative should be same as p at the limit of x tends to 0 positive. We
are not suddenly creating a new pressure at this point. So, when you solve it and put
the x as 0 in these above equations that we have found, you will see that we arrive at
this particular format. Now, in order for this equality to hold true,
because here what we have is we have got certain numbers and then we have certain exponential
terms and they are being equated. So, for that all exponents may need to be equal, so
that this equality can hold true. So, in that sense, we have already stricken of this
e to the power j omega t from everywhere and this is what we are arriving at. So, we equate
these exponents. So, all of this has to be equal to each other. So, this thing here,
this new equation that we get by equating the exponents on the left hand side and the
right hand side. So, every term's exponent has to be the same for the equality to hold
true. So, with this what we get from the very first
two equations? We get sin theta i is sin theta r and given that we are dealing with the period
between 0 to pi, both theta i and theta r will be same because their signs are coming
out to be same. So, what does it mean? That the reflected wave and the incident wave just
like in the case of light waves, where they are reflecting from a mirror, they both have
the same angle with the normal. When you solve these two equalities, so you write it like
this and see over here, this is the final equation we are getting, sin theta i by c
1 is equal to sin theta t by c 2. Now, this is very important because this is what we
call as the Snell's law for sound wave refraction. Now, there is a Snell's law for light waves,
there is a Snell's law which is applied to an electromagnetic wave in general, but because
the context of our lecture series is the acoustic wave of the sound waves, we are referring
to this as the Snell's law for the case of sound waves.
So, let us state the Snell's law. So, verbatim what it says is that when a sound wave, when
a sound wave enters a different acoustic medium, the medium having different sound waves velocities,
then the frequency remains the same. So, always remember that the frequency of the sound wave
is independent of the medium it is travelling in and the various kind of boundaries and
the various kind of elements it encounters on the wave. It is independent, it remains
the same, the frequency only depends on the source that is creating that sound wave.
So, till the source remains the same, it does not matter how it propagates and what path
it takes, the frequency remains the same. So, the frequency remains the same, but in
this interaction, the speed is changing and c is equal to, so lambda, this is the wavelength
is c by f, this is changing and this stays the same, so lambda changes. So, the wavelength
even changes and at the same time, the direction of the wave propagation is also changing and
what is the manner in which it is changing? It is changing, so that this relationship
is satisfied. So, the signs of the angle of incidence and angle of transmission, they
are equal to the ratio of the phase velocities in the two media.
So, now we have found this relationship between theta i, theta r and theta t. Let us now again
apply the continuity of normal pressure, but now we equate it at one time instance, which
is t equals to 0 at the boundary. So, once again this is our equation and in this equation,
because we have already established that for this equality to hold true, all these exponents,
they must be same. So, let us just strike them off, this is a common term we are removing
from the equation. So, we end up with overall this particular equation here. So, this is
the equation of the respective pressure amplitudes, if you divide it throughout by the incident
pressure, you again get the same relation as you got for the normal incidence.
Now, once again have a look at these equations, we have these equations for pressure. Now,
let us find out the equations for the normal component of the particle velocity at the
medium. The normal, because here in the previous case, when it was normal incidence. So, in
normal incidence, v n was same as v and we did not have to use any cost term in that
and we directly derived everything, but over here v n is not equal to v. So, the normal
component of the velocity in terms of the v would be cos times that angle, it is the
cos component. So, velocity is in a particular direction, we want to decompose it along the
x axis, so that is what we get. So, for the incidence angle, the normal velocity is given
by, so also we know that v is equal to p by rho c.
So, let us do that. So, this magnitude of v is p by rho c. So, here for incidence wave
it is p, we write the format of p here. So, this long expression for p i, we are writing
it here and then divided by rho 1 c 1 for the medium 1 and because here the incident
wave is travelling forward in space. So, the normal component is along the positive x axis,
so we have a plus sign and then this times cos theta i. In the same way, we can find
out the normal component of reflected wave. So, once again we use the equation of the
reflected wave, we divide it by rho 1 c 1 for that medium and then cos times of theta
r and then we place a minus sign here because the wave is propagating like this.
So, if you dissolve and find out the normal component along the x axis, the wave is actually
propagating along the negative x axis. So, the normal component is opposite in direction,
so we put a minus sign here and how can we write this? So, in the same way, we just like
how we did the derivation for normal incidence, we will do it in the same way. So, this can
be written as r times of p i max. In the same way, the normal component of the transmitted
wave velocity, once again we write the equation of the transmitted wave, this one here divided
by rho 2 c 2 because it is in the medium 2 times cos theta t and we have a positive sign
because the normal component of it is along the positive x axis. So, this can be written
as t times of p i max. You see here, we have already found this equation 1 plus r is equal
to t. So, here we can replace this t as 1 plus r.
Now, applying the continuity of normal particle velocity at the boundary, let us just equate
that. So, we are adding up these velocities. So, here we add up with the magnitudes, so
plus minus like that. When we did the same thing for pressure, we did not use minus sign
because pressure is a scalar quantity. It anyways gets added, but in the velocity, we
consider the direction as well. Now, let us remove all the common terms. We remove that
all of this is the common term. We have already found that these exponents are equal. We remove
the common term and this is another common term we are removing. So, after removing these
common terms, this is the equation we are ending up with 1 minus r times of this quantity
here and 1 plus r times this quantity. Now, rho 1 c 1 is what? It is z 2. So, rho 1 c
1 is z 1 and rho 2 c 2 is z 2, which is the characteristic impedances. So, if you replace
this, ultimately this is what you are getting. If you solve by component and dividend, finally
this is the result of your reflection coefficient, which is z 2 cos theta i minus z 1 cos theta
t divided by z 2 cos theta i plus z 1 cos theta t.
Now, if you see here, if you take that this is a generic equation and normal incidence
becomes a special case of this generic equation. So, at normal incidence, which is a generic
case, which is one particular normal incidence, a special case of oblique incidence. So, for
this generic case, normal incidence now becomes a special case, where theta i was equal to
0 degree and this is same as theta r. So, if you equate this and if you solve using
the Snell's law, then ultimately you would end up with z 2 minus z 1 upon z 2 plus z
1. This is for you to solve and see for yourself that the normal incidence can be thought of
as a special case of the oblique incidence. So, now because it is a oblique incidence,
the specific acoustic impedance, it is z, the normal specific acoustic impedance is
not same as the characteristic impedance. This is the normal specific acoustic impedance
by the definition. It is the normal component of the velocity, which is p by mod v times
cos theta. So, you can say that and this quantity here is your z s a or small z. So, the z n
becomes z by cos theta. So, the same equation that we had found, if we divide by cos theta
i cos theta t in the numerator and denominator, this is the expression we end up with. So,
this is what? This is the normal specific acoustic impedance of the medium 2 and this
is the normal specific acoustic impedance of the medium 1. So, ultimately you get the
same format. The normal specific acoustic impedance, they follow the same format as
in the case of normal incidence and this is in terms of the characteristic impedance,
this particular format here. Now, let us do some special cases of oblique
incidence. So, by Snell's law, this is what we are getting. So, sin theta t we obtain
in terms of sin theta i and cos theta t is under root of this 1 minus sin square theta
t. So, this is the expression of sin cos theta t in terms of c 1 c 2 and sin theta i. So,
if these quantities are known, let us consider the first case when c 1 is greater than c
2. So, as you see here, if c 1 is greater than c 2, so this term here would always be
less than 1. So, in that case, the variable inside the, the expression that is inside
this square root would always be positive. So, a square root of some positive number,
so which means that in this case, theta t is real and by this relationship, theta t
is smaller than theta i. So, what is happening here? We are getting a real transmitted wave
and because theta t is smaller than theta i, you can see this particular case here.
So, the wave front is bending towards the normal while transmitting into the other medium.
Now, let us see the second case which is slightly more peculiar. Here, c 1 is smaller than c
2 and this is our expression. Let us say, we have one critical angle. So, theta c is
the critical angle in our situation and this is defined as sin theta c is equal to c 1
by c 2. So, if you replace this expression here in terms of the critical angle, what
you get is cos theta t is equal to under root of 1 minus sin square theta i divided by sin
square theta c. In the first case, our sin theta, our theta
i is greater than, is smaller than theta c. So, overall this term here would remain smaller
than 1 and hence, this entire term inside the square root would be positive and hence,
we will get a real transmitted wave. Theta t would be real in nature and by the Snell's
law, because c 1 is smaller than c 2, theta t becomes greater than theta i. So, here what
happens in this case? As the wave is incident, it transmits or it is transmitted into the
other media while bending away from the normal as represented here.
Now, this is the third case which is the most peculiar case. What happens here is that,
now we have once again c 1 smaller than c 2, but now theta i is becoming greater than
theta c. So, in this expression now, what happens to this particular thing? Theta i
is greater than theta c. So, this would become greater than 1. So, then the entire thing
inside the square root, it becomes negative. So, this means that cos theta t becomes some
kind of imaginary quantity. How do we interpret this? We interpret that the incident wave
is now getting totally reflected and we are getting imaginary transmitted wave which means
that in reality, there is no pressure wave that is transmitting into the next medium
and at the same time, what is happening? Because there is no transmitted wave, so t is becoming
0. So, 1 plus r is equal to 0. So, r is coming out to be minus 1. So, once again that same
case we have discussed, when r is minus 1, what does it mean? It means that the reflected
wave is having the same amplitude as the incident wave, but now it is shifted by pi. Wherever
we are getting a peak in the incident wave, we are getting a trough in the reflected wave
and vice versa. So, they cancel each other out. So, this is what we obtain.
Now, with this understanding, let us solve one problem on oblique incidence before we
close this lecture. Let us say a plane wave is incident at 60 degree and the boundary
between the same air and helium are the same old friends. So, here the density and the
respective speed of sound for the two mediums is given to us. Now, we want to find out the
magnitude of reflection coefficient. Now, if it is some student, they without thinking
want to solve it, they would just go ahead and start solving because it is an oblique
incidence case. They will first of all find out what is z 1 rho 1 into c 1. They will
find out certain value z 2 rho 2 into c 2 and then again they will find out certain
value. Then, r they would find as z 2 cos theta i minus z 1 cos theta t. So, this is
z 2 divided by z 2 cos theta i plus z 1 cos theta t like that and all these calculations
they will do, but I have already taught the special cases of incidence. So, before you
do all of this manual calculations, you have to see whether it falls under a special case
or not. So, here and so wherever you know the speed
of sound in the medium 1, it is larger than the speed of sound in the second medium. You
can stay cool and you can just go ahead and solve the case because it will always be the
same way. The wave, there will be some reflected wave and transmitted wave and the transmitted
wave will be bending towards the normal, but here it is the other way round. Here, c 1
because our medium 1 is air, medium 2 is this helium. So, c 1 here 343, c 2 972. So, what
is happening here? c 1 is coming out to be smaller than c 2. So, it is following the
special case either 2 or 3. So, in special case 1, nothing to worry about, but when it
is special case 3, then you have to see. So, you have to first ensure that it is whenever
c 1 is smaller than c 2, you have to first ensure that the incidence angle is below the
critical angle. So, let us find out what is the critical angle for this particular interaction.
So, the critical angle defined here as c 1 by c 2. So, let us see this. So, here first
of all, before doing all of this, we begin like this. Here, the theta c is c 1 by c 2
which is 343, 972. So, sin theta c. So, theta c is sin inverse of this quantity here. So,
if you solve it, you get the answer as 20.67 degrees which is way smaller than the theta
i. So, what you are getting is that theta i is greater than theta c. Let us see what
is happening here. If you see, this is the case we are talking about, c 1 smaller than
c 2 and theta i greater than theta c. So, now, our angle of incidence has reached that
critical angle zone where the transition takes place and beyond that, there is no reflected
wave. So, you do not need to solve anything. You already found that here, this is a special
case where c 1 is smaller than c 2 and we have reached the critical angle and we are
beyond that. So, no transmitted wave. So, what is happening here? Since no transmitted
wave, what is the magnitude of the reflection coefficient? R is coming out to be minus 1.
So, in that way, you can solve this particular problem and with this, I would like to close
this lecture. So, thank you for listening.
Thank you.
