A two-part event: (1) Nicole Gonzalez talk: Sediment gravity flows construct a prodelta-to-shelf depositional environment: Coaledo Formation, southwest Oregon
Nicole Gonzalez (M.S., UT Austin) shares her work exploring how sediment gravity flows construct a prodelta-to-shelf depositional environment. She presents a revised storm bed depositional model for the shallow marine storm deposits of the Coaledo Formation in southwestern Oregon.
(2) Panel Discussion: The importance of fieldwork for a geoscience education
A moderated panel discussion on the importance of fieldwork for geosciences education, addressing topics such as which valuable skills students learn in the field and access to opportunities.
Panelists: -Nicole Gonzalez (M.S., UT Austin) -Dr. David Mohrig (Professor, UT Austin) -Dr. Randi Martinsen (Principal at Hydrocarbon InSight, LLC; former AAPG President)
Hosts: -Dr. Rebecca Caldwell -Sharvnee Raja Mohan
All right, let's just go ahead and get started. For those of you that are here already,
thank you so much for joining us for the second AAPG Women's Network technical webinar of 2022.
In order to see past technical webinars, as well as other AAPG Women's Network events,
which would include a variety of events, such as discussions on diversity and inclusion,
or even an event on the geology of beer, please check out our YouTube channel.
And that link will be dropped in the chat right now. And this event will be uploaded to the
YouTube channel in the near future. Furthermore, please consider registering for the AAPG Women's
Network, which includes signing up in order to receive our communications for future events.
And that link will also be dropped in the chat. All right, so today's event is a two-part event.
We're going to start with a technical research presentation by Nicole Gonzalez,
who I will introduce in a minute. And after that, we will have some questions and answers
from the audience. And then we will transition into a panel on the importance of fieldwork for
geoscience education. For that panel discussion, Nicole will be joined by Dr. David Morick,
her advisor, as well as Dr. Ron B. Martinson. And I will introduce those panelists further once we
get to the panel. So my name is Rebecca Caldwell. I am the AAPG Women's Network Technical Program
Director. I'm also a research geoscientist at Chevron. Today, I am subbing in for Tara George,
who was advertised as being our moderator today. Unfortunately, she can't make it due to a last
minute work commitment. But this is a good reason, as she reminded us that she is partly able to
enjoy her current career because of the things she learned when she was a master's student
by Dr. David Morick, who is one of our panelists today. And so she was happy to report that she
was able to learn a lot, including a lot of fieldwork experience. And that is why she has
this great career that has unfortunately meant she cannot join us today. I am joined today by
Sharvani. You can go ahead and wave quickly, Sharvani. She is an AAPG Women's Network
Webinar Committee member, and she will be helping me by dropping things in the chat and
monitoring the participants as they enter. All right. So during the event today,
whenever you have questions that you want to ask Nicole during her research presentation or the
panelists during the panel, when it comes to time for Q&A, you can please go ahead and raise your
digital hand, and I will call on you and ask you to unmute yourself, turn your camera on,
and go ahead and ask your questions directly to the speakers. We do highly encourage this level
of engagement. However, if you'd prefer, please feel free to drop questions in the chat, and I
will read them to the speakers. All right. Now let me quickly introduce Nicole. And as I said,
I will introduce the other panelists when we get to the panel. So Nicole Gonzalez is receiving her
master's this Friday at the Jackson School of Geosciences at UT Austin. So congratulations,
Nicole. At the Jackson School, she worked with her advisor, Dr. David Morig, on research that
she'll be presenting today. She is highly involved in the geosciences in many other ways, including
being a GeoForce Texas alumni, a UT geoscience ambassador, and she is highly involved with the
AAPG Women's Network by being on the webinar planning committee and also one of our social
media chairs. I am also saying, just adding here, that Nicole has been a mentee of mine
through a GSA program for many, many years now, and it's been really exciting to see her
finish undergrad, apply to grad schools, and complete her research and get an internship
with Hillcourt, which she is taking this summer. And so I'm really excited to see everything you've
been working on, Nicole. And so with that, I'm going to pass it off to Nicole. Everyone,
please make sure you are muted and your cameras are off for this portion. And one last reminder
that this is being recorded and will be shared to YouTube. All right, go ahead and share your
screen, Nicole. Okay, great. Thank you so much. I'm going to share this screen. I'm going to,
I'm giving away, can you see my screen? Yes, that's good. Okay. No,
giving away some of the presentation. That's okay. I'm going to minimize this. Okay. Thank
you so much, Rebecca, for that really nice introduction. Good afternoon, everyone.
My name is Nicole Gonzalez. Thank you for joining our webinar today.
I've had the pleasure of working under Dr. David Mooring here at UT and developing this project
for my master's thesis. It's a super neat project, and I'm excited to share our findings
with you today. So the title of my project is The Evidence for Multiple Styles of Sediment
Gravity Flows Constructing a Pro-Delta to Shelf Depositional Environment,
Caledo Formation, Southwest Oregon. So the motivation behind this work was to refine
the interpretation of shallow marine storm beds in the lower Caledo Formation to better understand
how sediment gravity flows, specifically hyperpycnal flows, aid in constructing delta
front and pro-delta to shelf depositional environments. And this work is important
because these deposits serve as potential oil and gas reservoirs. So first to orient ourselves,
this work took place near Coos Bay, Oregon, which is located here in between Eugene and Medford,
and is located on the southwest Oregon coast. In B here, you can see a zoom in on Coos Bay,
and then we have to the west of that, Sunset Bay State Park, which is where our field site
is located. So the exposures of Caledo Formation in the sea cliffs and wave-cut platforms of Sunset
Bay State Park preserve world-class examples of shallow marine bases ranging from deltaic to
outer shelf deposits. The eocene rocks of the Caledo Formation were deposited in the Taihorak
Basin in the late early eocene to middle eocene, following the deposition of the Tai and Elkton
formations. The red arrow on this figure from Santra et al. is an approximate location of our
depositional system. So the Caledo Formation is divided into three members, a lower, upper,
and middle member. However, for this study, we focused on the lower member, which is superbly
exposed at Sunset Bay State Park, which is right here. So my work was entirely field-based, so it's
perfect that I'm participating in this webinar about the importance of field work. We measure
10 stratigraphic sections that encompass three parasequences. So this is a figure by Channon
Dodd that shows the four uppermost parasequences of the lower Caledo. Parasequence one was not
measured due to pore exposure. We focused on parasequences two through four, and while we were
in the field, we used drones to image these outcrops and collected hand samples. We then
separated the beds within the three studied parasequences into nine depositional bases.
We also studied the vertical and lateral distributions of these bases within parasequence
two and three. And so the overall goal of this project was really to connect our field observations
and process-based interpretations to support a depositional model
for the storm beds of the Caledo that include sediment gravity flows. And so for this talk,
I'll go through the faces that make up three types of sediment gravity flows we identified
in the lower Caledo and then dive into our depositional model that focuses specifically
on river-fed hyperpycnal flows. So river-fed hyperpycnal flows occur when the density of
the incoming flow is greater than that of the standing water in the reservoir. This is a figure
by Zavala 2020 showing the incoming flow plunging into the open basin and generating an undercurrent.
They're linked to exceptional river floods and results in increased suspended sediment
concentrations. The properties of hyperpycnites include, or the properties of hyperpycnites,
which I should mention are the deposits of hyperpycnal flows, include fine-grained sand
with an upper grain size limit of lower-medium sand, tidally modulated laminate, and abundant
organic detritus in aggregational bedforms. So keep that in the back of your mind as we
go through these bases. So of the four perisequences exposed at Sunset Bay, I'll be
focusing on the shallowing upward patterns of Perisequence 2 and Perisequence 3, starting with
Perisequence 2. So this is a stratigraphic log of Perisequence 2 measured at North Sunset Bay,
which you can see here in this little index map. So we're going to start at the bottom of the
perisequence with our pro-delta to shelf bases and work our way up. So the lower half of
Perisequence 2 consists of thinly bedded silt to very fine sandstone with rippled and planar
laminated beds. The ripple beds are dominated by combined flow and climbing ripple frost stratification.
These thin beds are separated by structuralist mudstone intervals, as seen here, and burrowing
is common in this species. So the abundance of very fine sand and the thin bedded nature
of this species suggests distal deposition on the pro-delta or shelf, and we interpret these beds as
being the distal end of our hyperpigment flows. Above the pro-delta to shelf bases, and again
here is that stratigraphic log of Perisequence 2 from North Sunset Bay, above that, or above our
pro-delta to shelf bases, we observe load structure beds. And so this space is really, really cool.
It's built from an underlying muddier deposit and an overlying sandy deposit, commonly composed of
ripples. And so what happens here is the muddy structuralist basal deposit represents a low
strength of eight booster debris flow, which we interpret as remobilized delta front deposits
that were homogenized during transport. So as this deposit was being emplaced,
a suspension-driven undercurrent was depositing suspended sediment on top of these debris flows,
and over time that suspended sediment created a more dense sandy deposit that then sunk into the
fluidal debris flow underneath, producing these floating nodules of laminated and rippled strata.
And so as you can see here, the ripple nodules, they range in size and shape, and they're oriented
randomly in the muddy deposit. However, in some cases, the ripple nodules appear reoriented by
horizontal shearing, as you can see here, which indicates downslope creep of the debris.
So atop the load structure beds, we observe medium to thick beds of hummocky cross stratification
composed of fine sand containing abundant mica. There are two commonly observed basal boundaries
for the HCS beds, those with concave up lower bounding surfaces due to scouring, as you can
see here in this beautiful photo. And we also have, and so these are erosive and laterally
restricted and exhibit this channelized nature. And then we have those that are hummocks with
sharp horizontal bases that appear non-erosive and are laterally persistent, as you can see here.
So both types of these basal boundaries, these hummocks with these two types of basal boundaries,
are both overlaid by beds of a gradient unidirectional to oscillatory ripples that are
equal to or less than the HCS beds in thickness. So in this photo here, we can see combined flow
ripples that appear pretty symmetrical. And in the upper left hand corner, we have climbing ripples
here, again capping those hummock beds. And then here we have a set of gradient ripples. And so
the interpretation here is that these beds are generated by hyperpycnal combined flows that
include a wave and a unidirectional component. And we'll dive more into that when I talk about
our depositional model in a little bit. So part of that section of hummocks and ripples,
we have our rippled bases, which consists of a grading beds of ripples composed of oscillatory
climbing and combined flow ripple sets. So we interpret those bases as being deposited by
hyperpycnal flows with current velocity sufficiently low enough to maintain bed conditions associated
with the ripple stability regime. And so the occurrence of a grading ripples requires a
continuous advection of suspended sediment, which to us is strong evidence for a hyperpycnal source.
And again, we'll dive into this a little bit more when I talk about the depositional model.
So continuing up this vertical section, we have the soft sediment deformation bases,
which is tied to slumping. So this encompasses a range of deformation styles. This figure here
shows a common suite of deformation that we observe in perisequence too. So we have recumbent
folds typically at the base here. And here's a profile view of what these folds look like.
And so you can see that their axes are actually oriented parallel to the slope.
And the folds are typically encased in this convolute bedding. And that convolute bedding
is usually overlaid by the structureless layer. And so we interpret these beds as being gravity
driven releases of previously deposited delta front faces. And the presence of the folds in
the subsequent convolute bedding suggests that we had higher surface gradients than
a typical continental shelf. And so based on the grain size and the relic stratification,
we infer that these beds were either originally hummocky cross stratified beds
or are planar laminated bases, which I'll discuss in a bit. And so in perisequence three, we also,
this bases also includes brittle faulting features and fluidization, fluidized beds
that we observe in two, but in three, these two styles of deformation definitely dominate.
So the last two faces I'm going to talk about dominate the upper portion of perisequence three.
So we were taking, we looked at the log at North Sunset Bay of perisequence two,
and now we're going to jump to perisequence three, particularly here at North Tree Robe Cove.
We've nicknamed this cove Tree Robe Cove. And so like in perisequence two, we observe
hummocks capped by ripples. We have load structure beds that are present and laterally continuous.
We also have, as I mentioned in the previous slide, these soft sediment deformation beds,
but we also have interestingly in this perisequence, three to five meter thick
sections of planar laminated bases, which is then overlaying by meters of what we interpret
to be shore face deposits. So I'm going to go through those two bases. So our planar laminated
faces consists of fine sand interbedded with a lot of fine organic detritus. Our planar lamina,
or the planar lamina, is sometimes interrupted by isolated ripple forms. And when within the
repetitive lamina, we have thicker strata that is commonly coarser grained, while thinner strata
are fine grained. So this is what I'm trying to show here. This thicker lamina here is coarser,
and the thinner lamina here is finer. We also observe centimeter scale wood fragments that are
oriented parallel to the lamina. And so these beds are interpreted as purely depositional,
low density hyperpigment flows not linked to ocean storminess. And by low density, I just mean
that they're non-erosional. We're saying this is all purely depositional. So again, kind of like
the hummocks, these are sharp based bases. We infer the repetitive thickening and coarsening
followed by thinning and binding of the lamina to be a tidal signal described as a characteristic
of these mixed alluvial tidal and wave tidal deltas. So now onto our shore face bases. Now,
this last base is not linked to the identified sediment gravity flows that I've discussed.
However, it does dominate that upper portion of Periscope 3, and I want to highlight the reasons
we've distinguished it from our sediment gravity flows. So the first reason is that it's coarser
grained compared to our hyperpigmental flow deposits that have that like upper grain size
limit of fine sand. The second reason is we have these basal lags that are pretty persistent. We
see them in every location. The second reason is our hummocks and our swells that we see in our
hyperpigmental flow deposits are replaced by trough crossbeds. And those trough crossbeds
typically have these pebble stringers at their bases. And we also observe varying intensities
of bioturbation. And so we interpret these basal lags and pebble stringers that we interpret them
as being indicative of bed load transport. And then the increasing degree of bioturbation and
the coarsening suggests a shallower marine environment. I also want to add that this photo
here is what we call our capping shore face deposit. Both perisequences 2 and 3 are capped
by this coarse grained fossiliferous rich shore face deposit that you see here. Okay, so as I
mentioned at the beginning, you know the motivation behind this work was to understand how sediment
gravity flows aided in constructing the shallow marine delta A system. And it's evident through
our sedimentological analysis that hyperpigmental flows were the dominant source of sediment
constructing the delta front and the pro-delta of our study perisequences. So our depositional
model breaks down deposits of hyperpigmental flows into two types. Type A hyperpignites are
wave influenced and represented by hummocky cross stratified beds and beds of climbing ripples,
which you can see here and here. We interpret the hummocky stratification generated by these flows
to have been deposited below fair weather wave base where the suspended sediment fallout was
reworked as bed load by a combined flow produced by water surface waves and then the unidirectional
flow of the undercurrent. Capping the hummocky beds, we have those aggrading ripples and so those
aggrading ripples require continuous advection of suspended sediment to the site of deposition,
which again is taken as very strong evidence for a hyperpigmental sediment source.
And then out here, distal to the river mouth, we have these thinly bedded planar and ripple
laminated facies, which represents the distal ends of those flows. And so we have
fine-grained sand, very fine-grained sand, and a lot more mud out here than we do in these largely
sandy deposits. And I do want to mention that another piece of evidence for our riverbed
hyperpigmental source is that our deposits are very fine-grained. You know, these plunging
hyperpigmental ferns, they owe their excess density to suspended sediment, which can range
in particle size up to medium sand. However, fine and very fine sand is the most common course
material. And so the interpreted hyperpigmental deposits of the Caledo certainly possess this
upper grain size limit, just reinforcing our interpretation. So the next type is type B,
and our type B hyperpignites are non-wave influenced and characterized by planar laminated
strata. And so by non-wave influenced, I mean that this facies was deposited during periods
of stormless activity or potentially in locations that were sheltered from waves. You know, we don't
know. It just depends on the configuration of the shoreline at the time. But these beds
contained a lot of leafy detritus and the largest organic fragments out of all our hyperpignites,
which suggests that they were probably more proximal in setting relative to our type A
hyperpignites. However, the most compelling evidence for a hyperpigmental source is the
repetitive thickening and coarsening followed by fining and thinning of lamina, which we interpret
as a tidal signal. So just to dive into that a little bit more, here we have this super cool
picture of these rhythmites. And so during flood tide, water moving inland causing a decrease in
river velocity, which results in the transport of finer grained suspended sediment from the river
mouth and thinner lamina, which you can see here. And then, well, ebb flow adds to the river
discharge. So that increases velocities and promotes transport of greater volumes of coarser
sediment and thicker lamina. And so since each of these like different lamina sets here
represents part of a day as the tide moves in and the tide moves out, these packages can represent
several days to weeks of sedimentation. And so although we see evidence of other sediment gravity
flows, our study shows that hyperpignal flows are the dominant source of sediment constructing the
delta front and the pro-delta of the study pair of sequences here at Sunset Bay.
So I will take any questions, but first I just want to acknowledge, you know, the village that
made this possible. First and foremost, my advisor, David Moorig, for his mentorship and his guidance.
I couldn't have done it without him. My committee members, Cornel Leroux and Zoltan Sylvester.
I also want to thank Tim Gouge and Mariel Nelson for helping me construct the 3D drone models that
unfortunately did not make it into this presentation. The Morphodynamics Group. Of
course, this work would not be possible without the funding and support of the Jackson School
of Geosciences and the Rio Mar Consortium. And I want to acknowledge the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service and the Oregon Islands National Wildlife Refuge because they allowed us to drone these
outcrops and collect hand samples and made this study possible. So thank you so much to everybody
and thank you to you guys for listening to my talk today. Thank you so much. Okay, now you
can see me. Thank you so much, Nicole. I'm going to go ahead and clap because I think one of the
most disappointing things about virtual talks is you don't hear the applause at the end. But I see
some virtual applause symbols coming up. So I think everybody's doing their best to say you did
a great job. Thank you. I do have a question I kind of want to start with. But in case
if anybody else has a question, I would like people to go ahead and I see some cameras turned
on. If you want to ask a question, please raise your digital hand or you can raise your physical
hand. That's fine too. I think you all have the ability to unmute yourself. So if you want, you
just unmute and ask your question. Yes, ask away. So many cool rocks. One of the things I was going
to ask was, you mentioned at the very end that, what was it, drone footage? Yes. Didn't make it
into the talk. What exactly, do you want to maybe briefly say what would have been included if you
had the ability to put that in here? I mean obviously you can't describe a picture, but how
would that have helped your study? Yeah, I know it certainly helped our study. So we use
drones to image these outcrops and then we used a program called Agisoft to create a 3D drone model
of these outcrops. And so the way that that's helpful is understanding how these things are
laterally continuous, like how these deposits are laterally continuous. So I created actually an
orthomosaic, which is kind of like a picture of the 3D model of our south sunset bay outcrop, which
is beautiful. It's got like the best hummocks you've ever seen. And that was really helpful for
me because you can just see not only how everything stacks vertically, but just the lateral continuity
of these deposits. And it actually does change across the coast, and that's one of the benefits
of the study areas, that we can really look at the lateral distribution of these beds. In my thesis
we do talk about those lateral relationships, and David and I are in the process of, you know,
of completing this manuscript that we hope to submit to a journal soon. And we will certainly
be touching on, you know, how these deposits change in space laterally because it's really
cool. They change a lot. All right, so that sounds like a perfect advertisement to keep our
eyes open for the paper, and then maybe think about how this fits into concepts for reservoir
characterization. Absolutely, yeah. I sort of stole the first question, and there's probably time
for at least one more question if anybody has anything additional they'd like to ask.
And if not, that's okay. I often say, I might be wrong, but I often say please feel free to contact
the speaker separately if you have additional questions later, or you re-watch this recording
on YouTube and you're like, oh yeah, why didn't I ask that? All right then, I would like to go ahead
and transition into a discussion about fieldwork. As Nicole mentioned, this was a entirely or close
to entirely field-based project, and thus was quite important for this research project in
general. But I'd like to expand the discussion to discuss how field experiences are important
for geoscience education in general. And just letting the audience know, the
panelists already know this, but we are, we mean all levels of geoscience education.
So, not just graduate school education, but how does field experiences impact education from, you
know, young children all the way up to people that are in their careers, and how does this help us as
we continue to grow and develop. So, our panelists today are Nicole Gonzalez, who you've already met.
We are also going to be hearing from Dr. David Morrig, who is Nicole's advisor and a professor
at the Jackson School of Geosciences at UT Austin. And we are also lucky to be joined today by Dr.
Rondi Martinson, who is a principal at Hydrocarbon Insight and a past APG president. And so, I'm going
to add you all to the spotlight so that you're big for everybody. All right, so now you, our panelists
should be the people that you can see the most on your screen. And so, we're really hoping to get
questions from the audience. And so, please do drop, raise your hand throughout this discussion,
but especially at the end, and drop questions in the chat. But we're going to start off with a
couple questions to get the conversation going. So, I'd like to ask the panel, oh no, wait, I'm
going to let the panelists introduce themselves. I forgot, I didn't let you all do that yet.
How about David, let's start with you. Please introduce yourself, tell us a bit about yourself
and your experience and observations on the importance of fieldwork in education.
Okay, well, hello everyone. My name is David Morig. I'm a professor of geology,
really sedimentology and geomorphology at the University of Texas at Austin.
And I find going out in the field with students so valuable because it immerses
all of us into the natural system where there is really everything available to observe and
evaluate. And so, that means that we have to think hard when we have certain questions that we're
trying to understand, what is the kind of data that we have to collect? Learning what is important
versus what is not important for a particular set of questions is a really powerful skill to take
forward with really anything to do with the earth's system itself. And it means that learning
how to extract that necessary information from a complex system is really a uniquely field-based
experience. So, you can't get that experience from a book, from a lecture, even from a simplified
laboratory or numerical experiment. You really need to go to the place where it's all available
and you make the decision about what to focus on. I'll turn it over to one of my other,
how about you, Rondi? I agree with you a lot, David. I love going in the field and I love
seeing the lights turn on students' eyes. Another thing in terms of, and I agree,
the being able to define a problem in a specific problem and then knowing what data you need to
collect to solve that problem is a critical skill rather than, you know, just kind of doing a
machine gun approach to things. Particularly in time-constrained problems that a lot of people
work in industry, you can't collect all the data. It's always that data that needs to be,
that you can see has some economic impact, mostly that it benefits as opposed to just
really understanding the system. So, I agree with you wholeheartedly about that. Plus,
you know, I no longer teach at the University of Wyoming. I taught there for nearly 40 years
and it was a great experience. I valued, I had wonderful colleagues. The department was very
diverse in terms of gender, so I never had issues with that and was always,
there was never an issue that a woman could or couldn't do anything. So, that was fortunate
because that isn't always the case. I retired a couple years ago. I still consult and I still
go in the field and I teach professionals to look at rocks. As a matter of fact, I have a course
coming up in June taking a number of professional geoscientists around and hopefully some engineers
too. They may need this to be able to look at the rocks. And I teach it with a colleague of mine
and we have a longstanding joke that's he or she who sees the most rocks wins. So, I mean,
I could go on and on. I don't want to hog things, but one of the things I didn't mention earlier to
you, Rebecca, was observational skills. It's so important in so many things. It's critical in
geoscience. And when you're out in the field, and particularly when you're on your own,
you have to make the observations. You might have a colleague or a prof point out and help some
things with you, but you really do that. It's up to you. And honing your observational skills
allows you, I think, to be more observant in any kind of data set you're looking at,
not just the rocks. The recognition of the importance of bright spots was basically based
on observation. People had been looking at them for years and it took someone to say,
hey, you know, I noticed that. Well, those things are important. Thank you. We are going to touch
more on the different skills and their importance, but I'm going to give Nicole an opportunity. You
already talked a bit about how important fieldwork was for your research project. Did you have
anything to add just generally in your entire geoscience education? Yeah. So, you know, I had
a very unique experience of being introduced to the geosciences early on in high school. And I
think through the GeoForce Texas program here at the Jackson School. And so what that program does
is it exposes high schoolers to the field. And so we get to travel to a place in the United States
and for a week and study geology, which is so neat. And so I think something that I would add
is it's really important to gain that exposure early. You know, I think it's kind of sad that
the curriculums vary so much between states and cities and that whole thing.
But it is really important to introduce geoscience, I think, at the high school level. And,
you know, it's not just about, you know, going to the Rocky Mountains or something like that. I mean,
you can do that. But even in places that are a little bit more secluded or whatever, like you
could go to a road and observe the rocks there. You know, just any kind of field experience,
I think, is really valuable and from a young age is really useful. So, yeah. So I definitely agree
with the points that David and Rondi have said. But I think early exposure and then consistent
exposure, right? Like I have had multiple field experiences from geoforce to my undergraduate
research at the University of Colorado Boulder to, you know, my graduate studies that I just showed
you. Thank you. Yeah, I think I agree. Early exposure is super important. I know for me,
it started in the Girl Scouts, just being a young little Girl Scout going out and looking at rocks
and other environmental scenarios. I wanted to, yeah, that early exposure. One of the things I
didn't realize growing up was I spent my summers in the wilds in New Jersey. Me too. Well, it does
have wilds. And I remember in the brooks there, I would pick up rocks. They were limestone and
crack them open. And lo and behold, there were fossils inside. So I think this, even if it's not
necessarily geology, because I didn't even, I mean, I knew they were fossils, but being exposed
to outdoor activities, you said Girl Scouts or anything, just being out in nature is beneficial.
This actually, this transitions quite smoothly into one of the main first topics we wanted to
talk about, which was what are the valuable skills that students are learning in the field?
And how can students take these skills and apply them in their future career? And that could include
not just being successful at the career, but how can they also explain the importance of
these skills when they're interviewing for jobs and applying for jobs? And so there was sort of
a bunch of questions there, but people are really interested recently in understanding how to take
their experiences, really focus on the valuable portion, and then communicate it in order to
progress in their career. So I don't know, Randy, did you have some thoughts on this?
Yeah. The skills you learn in the field, besides already mentioned, improving your
observational skills is scale. Scale is so, so important in all aspects. When we learn things,
either whether it's in a lecture, in a classroom, or in a book, or anything, or maps or cross-sections
you make, the scale is not real. It's not a true scale. And the only place we can really
understand a true scale is in the field and looking at rocks, looking how they behave, looking at
thicknesses, how rock types change from one to another, whether they're sharp or whether
they're gradational and things like that, that Nicole was talking about, that she observed in
her field area. And in the subsurface, if we're going to make interpretations and correlations,
we need to understand the scale of the types of units that might be present in a certain
depositional system. For instance, you have that beautiful, Rebecca, that beautiful, looks like a
fluvial-dominated delta or something behind you. It's got a lot of distributary channels anyway.
Maybe they're tidal channels, I don't know. But the reservoir architecture, the sand bodies in that
is going to look very different than, say, something like a wave-dominated delta of the Nile.
And so without understanding these complexities, you know, we look at well locks.
You can, you know, something that's a hundred feet is an inch on a lot of well locks.
What is a hundred feet on a seismic wavelet? I don't know. And what's the resolution there?
But we have to be able to understand true scale and how it relates to the data sets we're looking
at. And I'll say one last thing. Companies value that. When sometime, I can't remember when it was
that I was at APG, but APG has a corporate advisory board called the CAB. And they were
discussing the possibility of APG developing a field course for professionals because they were
finding their very bright, very talented young hires were making interpretations that weren't
realistic. They didn't have an appreciation, all of them, for what rocks can and can't do and what
they really look like. And so they were, they wanted to, they thought then this field experience
would be, is almost necessary. That was kind of the, they were quite upset that a lot of the
students they hired, now they did not hire them because they didn't have field work, but they
found that that was a part of their education that was lacking. That's very interesting, Rondi.
It's unfortunate that it seems that we're lacking some of those skills.
David, did you have anything to follow up on or have any additional comments?
Yeah, I'll build on what Rondi said, agreeing with everything that she said and highlighting
again this point of, you know, going into the field, you have the whole natural system
in front of you, and you get to really hone your skills in what to observe, how to observe it, what
to analyze, how to analyze and synthesize that, and that, and to solve the problem in hand, the
questions that you're asking. And that's really important when thinking about the
earth system, you know, understanding how to, what the necessary amount of complexity to include
in your description of a system is critical for any kind of modeling or just defining
of the problem that you're looking at. And that necessary complexity and getting good
at saying, well, I need to include this much, actually makes students much better at approaching
the topics and the techniques associated with data analytics and machine learning
and using those algorithms instead of just blindly using them. They've developed a certain
amount of intuition about what degree of complexity are they actually looking for
in processing vast quantities of data using those techniques. So, I think it makes
students much more marketable as a result. I'll stop there.
I appreciate that. I only left because we don't necessarily want you to stop,
but luckily this conversation will continue. I was just dropping a comment in the chat that I
think that's very insightful, David, and my comment is always trying to connect it back to
decreasing costs and decreasing time, but that early understanding of the complexity that's
necessary for a problem severely cuts down on costs in the long run. And so,
I think that is a very valuable skill to have and what I've observed in my own work.
Nicole, did you have anything to add or said another way, which skills do you think you're
going to be taking to your internship this summer? Sorry, I shouldn't have threw you
that curve ball, but I'm fascinated. No, that's fine. I completely agree with
Brandi and David, and honestly, I can't imagine going into this internship without
my master's work. I think this project has really allowed me to hone and better those skills that
Brandi and David were talking about, especially those observational skills. It is intimidating
when you first go out there and you're kind of like, whoa, like Brandi was saying, the scale,
right? You're like, okay, this is talking about kilometers. We're talking about meters
of height and everything, of thickness. And so, definitely, like they mentioned, just
determining what's important and what's not and what to focus on is definitely something I'll
carry over to my internship. And just to highlight that when I was interviewing
for these oil and gas companies, I was actually surprised by how excited they were about all the
different field experiences that I had, because I had GeoForce, obviously, but then I also,
during my time at CU Boulder, I got to do an undergraduate honors thesis
with Jim Metcalfe, who's actually on this call right now. Hi, Jim. And he was my undergraduate
research advisor, and I got to go out to Nevada and look at metamorphic core complexes there,
and we did a lot of really cool fieldwork. And so, that's an experience. I also, with CU's
program, I got to go to Australia, to Southern Australia, and do fieldwork there. I got to do
hydro fieldwork north of Boulder, like up in the mountains. So, I just think that what Brandi's
saying is right. The more rocks you look at, the more you know about these different systems,
and the better off you are. And so, yeah, that was something that I wasn't expecting when I
interviewed. They were so interested. Like, tell us about your fieldwork. What did you do? What did
you see? Which was cool, because I love the field. And so, that was nice. Yeah, that is really
exciting when you get to be interviewed by somebody who understands the importance of all of your
experiences. Right. It was like, oh, I do have, like, the seismic interpretation skills, and I've
looked at that stuff, but they were like, oh, you have all this fieldwork. Tell us about it.
Well, hopefully, you continue being able to directly apply it, as well as indirectly.
Yeah, for sure. So, Nicole, I was just, Nicole, you have seismic interpretation skills. So,
how do you, did your fieldwork and looking at the scale of things help you be able to understand
the scale of things on seismic? I mean, you have to upscale some from the field,
but at the same time, I think, like, the example of, you know, if you see a great big channel fill
in a seismic, a big scoured surface, are you going to interpret that as a channel?
Well, yeah, so that's a good point. Right, that's a good point. It's all about scale, right?
Yeah, no, I mean, I think David teaches a 3D seismic stratigraphy course here
at UT, and that was super helpful, and we do look at these cool delta systems. We look at
submarine channels, and I mean, that was like my first semester of graduate school,
and I hadn't really even fully grasped kind of what we were doing for the project, but looking
back, now with, you know, all of this fieldwork and having completed this project, I feel like
I can go back and do that, those activities, a lot better, interpret that a lot better, for sure.
This actually quite nicely transitions into some of the next things that we were hoping to talk
about, and that was asking about current trends that you all have observed in terms of access
and potentially also inclusion to field opportunities, and maybe not just field
opportunities, but maybe also some of that seismic interpretation experience you're
talking about and how they may or may not go hand in hand. So, I'd like to hear from you all
and what your observations are, and maybe if you have any suggestions for people for how to
increase their access to opportunities. And David, let's start with you.
Sure, thanks. Yeah, I want to discuss a couple points in this regard, and first by coming back
to something that Nicole touched on in some of her opening comments about early and often
access to the field. It is really important, and I see a growing, a groundswell in promoting
early access to fieldwork. It doesn't make much sense to me that we, you know, we wait until
the latter half of one's undergraduate career to really share with them immersive field experiences,
and as a result of that, a few of my colleagues and I have started teaching an introductory
geology class that in the very first semester of their freshman year, we go out and we introduce
the field of geology in the field. So, every Friday, we go out and learn together about
how to read the earth system, and that is, you can just see that come alive to all of the students,
and it's a way for them to fully grasp how things are connected that is harder to do when you're
talking to them in a lecture hall or in a classroom. I think this is so important because
the big questions that we have today, you know, that society faces, you know, whether they're
land-use decisions or water or energy transition decisions, all of these are really best understood
and best handled by those who have been trained in looking at the earth as a system, and looking
at the environment itself really requires you to get out in the environment. So, if we want to train
the next generation and continue training ourselves in these things that we need to be
working on so critically, we really need to get out in the field as often as possible.
And that really brings me to my second point about field experiences. I think that
field experiences are actually much broader than what any one of us, you know, any of the
number of us on this, you know, on this webinar consider them to be. We have so many different
styles of field experiences. Really, almost any discipline, at least in the earth sciences,
could be taught and should be, have an element taught in the field. And there is an ever-increasing
range of tools and technologies that can be applied to studying in the field. And
what that provides then with all the different technologies and all the different disciplines
is it maximizes the potential for each student to find her path, her or his path, and develop
their passion in this field. You know, it's not just one shoe fits all anymore. We should be
doing this in such a way that we can have many shoes, and that hopefully will bring us, in fact,
more than hopefully, I have found that it does provide a much more inclusive environment to
attract students to the earth sciences. I, yeah, I can't say what Wyoming is doing. We did have
kind of an earlier field course, and in our intro classes, we always went out because we had
fabulous geology right around us, but not all universities get to have that. One thing I did
suggest at one point was, you know, most, a lot of geology majors don't come in as geology majors.
So we really do need to get it out somehow about the earth before then so they can know about that.
But if, and the questions that society faces, the environment, energy, that, those are the big
societal issues, and a lot of that, yeah, is based on looking at our earth system and seeing how it
all fits together. A suggestion I had was to, at Wyoming, was to take both incoming freshmen with
majors who had designated a major in geology, as well as inviting some undeclared majors
going into the honors program to participate in a summer field camp to go out and look at whatever
the natural wonders are and study them in the region of that college. You know, in Wyoming,
there's all sorts of natural wonders. We could hit, you know, in a couple of weeks, a couple of
national parks and show them the beauty of the earth, as well as the mysteries of the earth,
and get them on the road to discovering their passions.
I like that. And it doesn't need to include such a fantastic setting, as Randy mentioned, you know,
you mentioned New Jersey earlier. I also grew up in New Jersey, and my high school had a campus
ecology class. And there's, I don't know, there's nothing too impressive of the ecology of a random
location in New Jersey, but it was enough that it got me excited. And I wanted to do earth science.
So I think these things are possible all over the world.
Most regions, you know, have something of wonder that they can go and see, even if it is just a
road cut, Nicole. I mean, it's to get out there and show them something, you know.
Sure, or even if it's not a road cut, I've met plenty of people who became geologists in Florida
that didn't even have those. You know, they have beaches, or if you're in Miami, I believe there's a
couple meter, you know, exposure of carbonates. Yeah, Nicole, did you have anything to add
on this topic? No, you know, I agree with everything that's been said. I think
near to my heart is also just that push to that early exposure, bringing it, you know, pipeline
programs like GeoForce, and not just GeoForce, but I mean myself, you know, I'm a UT geoscience
ambassador, and part of that is, you know, I'm a connector, if you will. Like, I like to go into
my community and talk about, like, what I do as a geoscientist. And, you know, it's a, and I've
worked at the Boys and Girls Clubs of Greater Houston for many years, and that's something that
I do with them. Like, I go and just talk about earth science, and again, that might not be
directly field-based, but even now, there's so many cool, like, interactive field, like, programs,
and so just putting that on the screen, and having them look at it, and bringing some rock samples,
and fossils, and things that they can look at is really exciting. You know, they're kind of like,
you study rocks, and then I tell them, yeah, you know, there's more than that, but yes, okay,
let's start there, and then by the end of the, you know, the workshop, they're, I'm gonna be a
geoscientist. You know, they're excited about just the natural world, and so, so yeah, I think that
early exposure is really important. I mean, I wouldn't be here without that early exposure,
so that's why it's so dear to me. I'm gonna take that as a good opportunity
for everybody who's watching this currently, or watching this recording in the future.
These themes that we're talking about are really tying quite heavily into some past
webinars we've held, and that are on our YouTube channel. So, Nicole, you were just talking about,
I don't think you used the word digital, but you were talking about access to,
maybe it was digital material, and we had a great webinar last November on digital geology,
and how to educate through it. We also had a webinar in October on how academia is responding
to an evolving geoscience world, and evolving needs, and we touched a lot on early exposure
and education, so I'm just making this observation that it seems like every event we hold is just
kind of coming back to the need for exposure to geology, at all across ages, and all across people,
and so we do have those other resources on our YouTube channel, so I encourage everyone to check
them out. We are at the end of our time, and so rather than asking another question, which I'm
sure we'd want to talk about forever, I'm going to wrap this up. I think we've touched on a lot of
really great themes, and we've addressed topics that we've heard from previous webinars, as well
as what we've heard from our membership throughout time, and I really appreciate all the speakers
coming here today and sharing their thoughts and views. Once again, I always encourage people to
reach out to our speakers. I probably should ask the speakers in advance if they're okay with me
suggesting that, but I'm going to go ahead and suggest it, because all of these speakers are very
friendly and happy to discuss further, so reach out if you have additional thoughts, or you want
additional advice, or if there were any resources you heard them mention and you can't find.
Also, please be on the lookout for future AAPG Women's Network events. We have a lot going on
at Image in Houston, so please be on the lookout for that. We are also in the process of
planning the Geology of Coffee, an educational and networking experience, and that will be fully
digital, and that's in response to the successes we've had from the Geology of Beer and the
Geology of Wine and Cheese, so check out those online and keep your eyes open, also for upcoming
technical events. And with that, I'm going to say thank you for coming today, and I look forward to
seeing everybody again soon. Thank you. Thank you. And thanks to everybody dropping comments in the
chat. If you're watching the recording of this later, I don't think you can see the chat, so I'm
just going to briefly mention that we're getting a lot of good feedback in the chat right now,
saying that there's a great discussion and presentation. Someone mentioned, I have a
feeling you're preaching to the choir on the importance of fieldwork, and I think,
Michelle, I think you might be true, or you might be correct on that.