Pal(a)eoPERCS Special Fieldwork Seminar - Anjana Khatwa

Discovered in China
13 followers
1 Video View·Nov 6, 2024
Special Pal(a)eoPERCS Seminar initiative on Inclusive Fieldwork
"Black and Brown Faces in Green Spaces"
Anjana Khatwa - Wessex Museums (UK)
Weekly Feedback Form:
https://forms.gle/KP2zJojeqgfQnimd8
For more, visit our website: https://paleopercs.com/
Okay, so welcome everybody to this week's edition of Paleo Perks. My name's Reema and I will be your
host for today. So we're really excited to welcome Anjana Catworth from Wessex Museums in the UK
and this is one of our inclusive fieldwork special seminars, so we're very excited. We're doing a
number of these this season and we hope that you can join us for those ones as well. So Anjana's
talk today is called Black and Brown Faces in Green Spaces. So the format of today's seminar,
if you haven't been to a Paleo Perks seminar before or if you haven't joined us for one for
a little while, so we have a little welcoming announcements for about five minutes followed
by Anjana's talk with a moderated Q&A and then Anjana's very kindly agreed to stick around for
tea time, so we very much encourage you to stay for this and ask her questions about her work
and don't forget to send your questions in directly to me via the chat, so I'm also a
questions host today. So a bit of housekeeping, Paleo Perks values the participation of everyone
interested in paleosciences and please remember to abide by our code of conduct during today's
seminar. If you somehow found yourself here without having signed up, please take a moment
to go to our website and have a look at this and familiarise yourself. Please remember to
the duration of the talk, you shouldn't be able to unmute yourself but if you find that you can,
please don't so that we have a nice quiet environment for our speaker. Just a reminder
that you can ask questions by chatting directly to me at questions at Paleo Perks or you can also
use the raise hand function and we will allow yourself to unmute you. Any technical issues
should also come directly to me as questions host. We also have closed captions built into our Zoom
and you can use the CC button to show or hide them, so this is at the bottom of your screen
in the little ribbon. You can also remember to nominate all of your outstanding early career
friends and I'll drop that link in the chat very shortly and also remember to fill in our
weekly feedback form for demographic information so we know a bit more about who's attending.
So this is anonymous optional but very much encouraged and I'll drop those very very shortly.
So now it's my great pleasure to introduce this week's speaker Anjana Katla. So Anjana did her
Bachelor's in Earth Science at Kingston University in the UK, followed by a PhD in Geography at the
University of Southampton also in the UK, followed by two postdoc roles, one at the
University of California Santa Cruz in the US and the University of Sheffield in the UK.
She then undertook a role as a National Park Service Geoscientist within the US
and then a postdoc and adjunct professor role at the University of Utah. She then moved to work
with Dorset County Council and the Jurassic Coast Trust to help develop and manage their education
and learning programme for the Jurassic Coast World Heritage Site and she's currently an
engagement lead at Wessex Museums in the UK and also is a visiting fellow at the Open University
and a freelance Equity, Diversity and Inclusion consultant. So Anjana over to you for your talk.
Thank you very much. It's always a little bit worrying when you see yourself,
your biography up there. Right, a little bit tricky here so I'm just going to just share
this screen here with my talk slides on so hopefully everybody can see that. Can they
see that right now? Yes? Are we good? Yeah, great, excellent. Let's just get rid of that.
Thank you very much for joining me this afternoon. I am indeed a person of many,
I have a lot of stuff going on in my life and one of the more important things I would say is
inclusion in heritage spaces and as was said in the introduction, I have a variety of hats that
I wear. I kind of spread myself in both natural and cultural heritage sectors at the moment and I
entered the museum space with Wessex Museums about two years ago but prior to that I kind of
have about 20 years experience of working in protected landscapes. As you can see on the
slide, I have lots of responsibilities. I work as a trustee for various charities, I'm on their boards
but probably the one that's most relevant for this talk is that I'm a trustee for the National
Association for the Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty in the UK and these are places that are
protected landscapes like national parks so I'm a trustee for that organisation.
I also work as an ambassador for the Dorset Race Equality Council which is a lobbying organisation
in the county of Dorset that represents the rights, the human rights of people of colour
who live in this area and in 2020 I was awarded the National Diversity Award for being a positive
role model in race, faith and religion and a lot of that is associated with the work that I do in
geosciences and the natural heritage sector. So why do we need to talk about representation
in heritage spaces and particularly natural heritage spaces? It's a real issue. If you look
at someone like me and where I've been through the journey of my career, I am very much an anomaly.
My love for earth sciences and sciences in general was stimulated at school actually,
probably like most of you. I was about eight years old, I think, when I started to really
get interested in science and that wasn't through my mum and dad or anything like that,
it was a teacher at school and I was learning about space and all of that was just amazing
and I thought at the end of primary school, I thought this is brilliant, I'd like to be an
astronaut, thank you very much. My parents had different ideas entirely but that love for science
really blossomed and grew into something quite special and in 1988, you can probably
see this picture here, I'm about 13 years old so now you know exactly how old I am,
which is a bit frightening, but in 1988 I went on holiday as a 13-year-old to Kenya,
which is where my mum and dad are from. There's my dad, he's standing next to me,
I'm the strange girl wearing her Sunday best dress on a geological field trip, so never say
that you're never dressed glamorously for field work because even at 13, I kind of need the right
clothes to wear and the right shoes because I'm wearing these really slim rubber plimsolls.
I'm standing at a place which is really extraordinary actually, it's called the
Shetani Lava Flow and it's in between Nairobi and Mombasa and the lava flow is about two or
300 years old, it spreads for about 50 square kilometres over the national park and it's a
flood battle, so the lava would have welled up from the fissure in the earth and just kind of
literally just spread over the landscape, burning everything in its path. When I walked across
those deposits, I really didn't know anything else apart from having grown up in a very urban
environment in Slough and in those days, in the 1980s and even in the early 70s,
Britain was a very difficult place to live if you were a person of colour, there was a lot of
racism. This was the years after Enoch Powell's Rivers of Blood speech, this was the time of the
National Front and as a kid growing up in Slough, on the way to school every day, my sister and I
would have to walk past National Front skinheads every day on the way to school. It was a very
hostile environment to grow up in and so it was very rare that we would actually go out to green
spaces in Britain and when we did, it was extremely difficult and I'll come on to some examples then.
So for me as a teenager to go to somewhere amazing like this, it was transformational
and on that day, I picked up two pieces of rock actually from that lava flow. I still have them
today but they were responsible for helping me to connect with the rocks that I was walking over. I
thought it was amazing that molten, semi-liquid rocks could come up from the middle of the earth
and spread across the landscape and you could then walk on them. I just thought that was incredible.
I took those rocks away and went really through a lot of battles with my family
to become someone who wanted to become someone that was working in the earth sciences. It has
not been an easy journey for me but I think nowadays, if you follow me on social media,
I'm known as Jurassic Girl so if you want to follow me on Twitter, the details will be at
the end of the talk but I'm probably best known now for talking about rocks a lot whether that's
on television or radio or wherever it might be in talks like this. I'm very much known for that.
Also, I'm known for fighting for more diversity in earth sciences and sciences in general. So where
is the representation? Where do we see ourselves? How are our voices heard in those spaces?
That's what I do. I talked a little bit about where the cycle starts and for me,
because I grew up in a town called Slough which is on the outskirts of London,
it's not a particularly green place. I mean, I loved growing up there, don't get me wrong,
but when I was about, I think, how old was I? Probably 10 or 11. My dad was a sign writer
so he concreted over our back garden so he could bring in vans and lorries, not lorries,
sorry, because our garden wasn't that big. I didn't live in a mansion. I lived in a semi-detached
house in Slough but he concreted over our back garden so he could bring vans in to sign write.
So any semblance or understanding I had of nature, I mean, this was literally a lawn in our back
garden. It was gone. So the only exposure I really had to nature was the school playing
field or the local park and those days, those few occasions where we did go out,
it was very, very difficult. So you're looking at two pictures here. One is probably even earlier
than 1988. That's a picture of my family and some of my extended family at the Isle of Wight and if
you know the rocks, you'll know that this is Allan Bay on the Isle of Wight and these are beautiful
Cretaceous rocks and probably I wouldn't recommend standing that close to the cliffs anymore but it
was trips like this, the very, like one or two days a year where we left Slough and went to the
coast or somewhere amazing where I'd be exposed to places like this and this was an amazing
experience but my memories of that trip are A, the rocks were brilliant because we'd fill up
little glass bottles with the coloured sand and that was fantastic and they're probably still in
our house somewhere in the corner, dusty corner. The other memory was how we were welcomed or not
welcomed into this space. So the Isle of Wight is a small island just off the coast of the
southern England coast and in the 19, I would say in the early 1980s, it was a very, very
and for a family of South Asian people to go there was very unusual. You really stick out
and my brother and my sister and I, I remember this occasion like it was yesterday really and
we would pile into a paddling pool and we'd think it was lovely, brilliant, okay, summer holiday,
go and paddle in this pool that's shaped like the island and then all of the white parents
would be pulling their children out and as a child you don't really pick up on that but as
a parent, as my parents must have because we were just thinking, isn't this brilliant, we've got
more space to play now because all the kids have gone, not being aware of the reason why they had
gone and then the other picture is, I'm a lot older in this picture and it's because you can
see how my hair's blown up and giving me a bad hair day but you can see my mother there, my
grandmother, my brother and my sister, we're kind of sitting on our living room rug because this is
how diverse communities, particularly South Asian communities, enjoy nature. It's all about the food
and you bring everything with you because when you go to places in nature, there's so much
hostility that you don't feel comfortable going into a fish and chip shop or a restaurant, you
just bring everything with you because you're self-sufficient, you don't need to interact then
with people who are going to be unkind to you and on this holiday, we had plenty of unkind comments,
plenty of racist comments about the way we were dressed, the way our food smelled
and it was successive experiences like this that my parents went through that then broke the cycle
of my contact with nature and it was only until I really, I had that experience in Kenya walking
across that lava flow and I had to hold on to that as a source of inspiration to help me go
where I wanted to go like a beacon in the night and it was really interesting because my parents
grew up in Nairobi and both my parents had amazing experiences in nature and I've spoken to
them since because I'm writing a book and trying to understand where that cycle got broken but my
dad lived in a neighborhood in Nairobi where the neighbor across the street had a charcoal lorry
and once a month, all the community would come together, clean out the lorry and they'd all
pile in and the driver would take them to these amazing Lake Nakuru or I can't remember some of
the other places they went but my dad said it was amazing, he saw rocks, he saw waterfalls,
he saw flamingos and he just said it really helped him to connect with a space outside of the city
and my mum was the same, her dad used to borrow a car of somebody and they all used to pile in
and then drive off to see amazing places outside the city so they always had this amazing connection
with nature and they would put together a brilliant picnic, go off, explore, come back
and the week started again but when they came to this country in 1970, 1969, they met so much
hostility in green spaces, they just couldn't and also they didn't have the time because both my
parents worked full-time, they didn't have the time, they didn't have the money, they didn't
have the means or resources plus there was racism in those spaces, there's an additional trauma there
so they just didn't go and that cycle was broken and it's really interesting because I would need
to go back, all the way back to Kenya where they kind of started their journey to love nature,
I would need to go back to the start of their cycle to begin my own process of loving nature.
So when we talk about that emotional trauma that diverse audiences bring with them in whatever
spaces they are but particularly natural spaces, take a look at this headline, this is from
The Times and published in February 24th 2021 and this is on the back of the post-lockdown crowds
that kind of flooded to the UK coast once lockdown restrictions were lifted so this is a picture
taken after the summer lockdown restrictions eased in summer 2020. Now this is on the Dorset
coast, if you know the rocks you'll know it's Lulworth Cove and Durdle Door and the owner of
the site, the whole of this area Durdle Door and Lulworth Cove is owned by a private family,
it's called the Lulworth Estate and it's owned by the Weld family and I know the owner, the land
owner really well, when I was working at the Jurassic Coast, I worked alongside him, he was
one of our, he was actually the chair of our steering group for the Jurassic Coast World
Heritage site so I know him really well but 15 years on, 17 years on, he then wrote a statement,
these are his words and I was really angry because I thought I've worked with you for this long and
you don't understand how offensive these words are, the culturally diverse crowds blamed for
seaside litter and vandalism and so it was really upsetting because I thought to myself and actually
I went on radio and talked about this at length actually for BBC Asian Network and had to field
all of these angry people on the radio station and I agreed with them, to be labelled as responsible
for the vandalism that the British coastline but also other part of the experience, to be put into
that category was incredibly offensive and we're almost going back now to my experiences in the
1980s, are we revisiting that now because if we're putting out these messages as natural heritage
organisations that you are to blame for the state of nature at this moment in time, why would we
ever go there? Why would black and Asian families, why would they go to these beautiful natural places
if this is the response that they're going to have? So I just wanted to kind of give you that context of
this was my life growing up in Britain in the 1970s and the 80s and full circle back to that now which
is questioning where the black and brown faces are in nature, if they're not there, why are they not
there and is it because of these attitudes that persist and pervade. Here's another example here,
so there are assumptions made about who enjoys nature, who belongs in nature and if you can't
read the tweets I'll read them out for you. This is in response to a television programme called
which usually airs on a Sunday night on the BBC and it's a programme focused on nature,
essentially the countryside. This is one of my very good friends I follow on Twitter and
Instagram called Dwayne Fields and he presented a piece which was off the back of a government report
that began to, well it was the beginning of the conversation that started to talk about where are
diverse faces in nature, why is it that only one percent of visitors to national parks
come from black and Asian origins and when he talked about this in the programme he
went on Twitter by a lot of racists and these statements are quite interesting, let's read them
out. What exactly prevents a person from enjoying the countryside? Maybe they find it boring, they're
not interested in nature, flora and fauna, that kind of thing. To suggest the countryside is a
white thing is absolutely absurd, so that's one person on Twitter. Another says, but surely that
says more about some of those from the BAME community, black, Asian, minority, ethnic
community, who have created their own artificial barriers. Maybe some communities find the
countryside boring, maybe more Caucasian people go to the woods as we tend to be dog lovers,
where the black, Asian, minority, ethnic communities are less so. So there are two
myths there really that I have spent pretty much my entire career trying to challenge. One is that
the majority of the sector, and we're moving towards a different space now, but for a long
time the majority of the sector saw black and Asian communities as an additional effort, you
know, why would we bother trying to put the effort into helping these people feel included in nature
when actually the status quo is fine? Let's just go as we are because that's less effort for us.
And that is actually, I have actually heard that in meetings and people I've spoken to in the
Twitter. Why would we do that? Why would we bother? Why would we invest so much time into
your community when actually the status quo is fine? And then the second comment about maybe
some communities find the countryside boring. Well, actually this is a very colonial view
in the way that opinion that, you know, we must interpret nature through one single lens. And
usually that's one white lens. And in the time that I've spent working in protected landscapes
and natural heritage, I'm only now beginning to challenge the dominant narrative of actually,
if you come from a diverse community, you experience nature in a different way. And
that way is just as valid as this way. And it's been a real education for me,
and I do a lot of EDI consultancy. It's been a real education for the organisations I work with
to begin to almost open their eyes as to how diverse people experience nature.
This is a really wonderful image. This is from Amandeep Nadra, who's an OBE because of his work
in uncovering hidden histories in World War II and World War I. And this is from 1918
and here are Indian soldiers skimming stones in the Dead Sea. And when you read that Twitter
comment from that person, maybe they're not interested in nature. I mean, yes, yes, we are.
And when I spoke to my parents and they told me about their, you know, jaunts in charcoal
lorries and a borrowed car out into the beautiful landscapes of Kenya, I understood. I understood
that this is not you not interested in nature. This is you trying to tackle the barriers that
stop you from accessing nature. And, you know, for much of my career, I've really
tried to focus on how do we begin to dismantle those barriers? And I just love this picture.
I think it's really beautiful. I think the question we have to ask ourselves is that's
all very well and good. We know that black and Asian communities, diverse communities have a
love and passion for nature. But how do we begin to create the change we need to see?
Who has the power to create that change? And I've used this example just to kind of show you.
We've got a portrait of Dido Elizabeth Bell here painted with Lady Elizabeth Murray. And
she's got a really fascinating story. Dido Elizabeth Bell is a mixed heritage young woman.
She was born in the Caribbean and then was brought to the UK by her father who was white.
He was a merchant seaman. Now he left her in the care of her grandfather who was a high court judge
because he needed to go off and do his seafaring. And from the painting, you can see she's dressed
in a really opulent way. She's wearing silk. I mean, there's a slight exoticism to her pose,
which art historians will debate over no end. But to all intents and purposes, she was given
an education. She was taught how to play musical instruments. She was even a ledger for her uncle,
looking at his accounts in his books. She was given all of the privileges that a young woman
could enjoy. However, when we look deeper into the archives and the records of her life,
something is very clear. There were some spaces where she was absolutely welcome,
and then other spaces she wasn't. And in this statement from Francis Hutchinson,
who wrote diaries about his visits to these two young women, he speaks of a black came in after
dinner and sat with the ladies and after coffee walked in the company of the gardens.
So what we can elucidate from that statement is that she was welcome, absolutely educated,
beautifully dressed. But when it came to sitting at the table as an equal with others, particularly
those coming into the house, she wasn't. She had to go and eat her food with the servants in the
kitchen. And then she would come and join the group. God forbid she should sit at the table
with other guests and enjoy that conversation and contribute as an equal. That was not the done
thing. What does this mean, though, in terms of the power structures and the constructs we work
in? Well, let's have a look at the statistics in terms of protected landscapes. If you work,
if you are in the UK, many of the protected landscapes are divided into two spaces. There
are World Heritage sites like the Jurassic Coast, but we also have national parks and
areas of outstanding natural beauty, which are on a level with national parks in terms of planning
law. Now, all of those areas are managed by boards. And by these, we mean a group of people
that are brought in to guide the strategic programming for that natural heritage space.
In 2019, a DEFA report, this is the Protected Landscapes Review Report, found that only 0.8%
of national parks and AUMDs had board members that were from black, Asian and minority ethnic
backgrounds. So, when you're talking about some of the most valuable natural landscapes in the
country, many of which are very popular for field work or leisure and tourism, the voices around the
table are not reflective of the diverse audiences that would like to be there. And when we even dig
down a bit further, and we look at this policy exchange report from 2017, 0.6% of the workforce
working in the environment sector are black and Asian. And so, when I talk about my career, my
20-year career in natural heritage and working in protected landscapes, I am an anomaly. I am
incredibly rare to have gone from, you know, a postgraduate degree to then, you know, postdoc
and then a career, you know, at the Jurassic Coast. I'm an incredibly rare specimen in this
sector. And when we put those two figures together, what it does is it defines how the parks are
managed, it defines what the engagement programs look like, and it defines the culture that persists
within those environments and how they are blind to the needs of diverse communities.
Essentially, that the whiteness that pervades the natural heritage sector blinds the ability to then
work effectively with underserved audiences. And in my work in Wessex museums, what I do is I very
much look at the systemic barriers that essentially restrict and keep out underserved audiences from
our spaces. And actually, I did a three-month consultation with community groups and our
museum staff and other partners, and this is what I found. Basically, that our staff, and I find that
this crosses over very well into protected landscapes, our staff, our colleagues, those
that are working inside the system are incredibly nervous about working with underserved audiences,
and particularly those from Black and Asian backgrounds. And it's principally because
they are lacking in confidence and knowledge of how to speak to those audiences, how to engage
with them, and how to listen to their stories, and then bring those audiences into spaces where they
will have programs that are developed that are meaningful to them. And quite often what we see,
particularly with national parks, I would say AUNBs are doing a little bit better,
but particularly with some areas, the programs that are created are very much
through a white lens. So, they almost don't reflect or resonate with the interests of
diverse audiences. There's a lack of awareness of what the programs offer, but also when those
groups go to these spaces, they don't see themselves reflected in the staff or the volunteer
frameworks, and they certainly, there are experiences of microaggressions in the
countryside. So, I gave you a little bit of examples of my historical experiences.
Why does this matter? The experience in nature at a very early age, particularly within your family
unit, matters because that is where the journey begins. And I know that journey began for me
when I walked across those rocks. When we look at who is actually studying the degrees that then
fuels the sector, as in the environment sector, let's look at the statistics here. Physical geography,
which is a very, a kind of a degree that the sector looks at to recruit from, sits at 7.5%
Black and Asian minority ethnic representation. Geology is a little bit better at 9.4%,
and then environmental science at 8.2%. So, we're looking at a huge disparity of representation
at degree level, but then what we're looking at is this then funnels through to the sector
and the employment, which then currently is stagnating at 0.6%. What are we changing? If we're
not drawing and enticing those audiences into nature, we're then not encouraging our parents
and carers and our children to see nature as a career, and they are then not moving into the
degree spaces, and then they are not entering the sector in order to promote that environment to
people that are coming up through the system. It is a negative feedback loop.
So, how do we begin to dismantle this? So, you know, it's about breaking the cycle,
and what we're doing in our museums at the moment is that we are trialling and piloting lots of
programmes to raise the voices, particularly at the moment I'm working with a lot of disabled
young people, and how do we bring them into our spaces in order to empower their voices so they're
driving forward that change? The representation within volunteers and staff matters a lot,
but also critically, we are where we are. It's going to be decades before we change
what the face of the sector looks like. So, at the moment, I'm doing a lot of work with
a lot of different organisations in changing systemic frameworks and the composition of
boards to begin to help to open out and build their confidence in working with diverse communities.
This is all critical, but beginning to break that negative feedback cycle.
Where are we now? What's actually happening out there? So, I'm currently a visiting fellow at
Open University working on a NERC, well, it's just completed a NERC-funded programme.
What we did was we worked with four people of colour-led walking groups across the country,
and what we did was we trained the walk leaders all about earth sciences in the landscape,
and it was incredibly effective, and the results for that programme will be out shortly. In fact,
we've just secured some funding for our next round of training. Incredibly effective,
and the reason why is because we have greater ownership over the landscape as diverse people.
Now, this photo was just taken on Sunday, and if you follow me on Twitter, you'll be able to read
a lot more about this event, but this event was created by Gita Ladra, Dr Gita Ladra,
who has set up a people of colour walking group in the Chilterns, and what she's doing is, for two
years, she's been supporting South Asian communities in particular to walk in the Chilterns,
to be encouraged and supported and have confidence to be in nature, and it's not just adults,
it's grandparents, and it's very young children as well. So, what we're seeing is an intergenerational
sharing of nature and being in nature, and, you know, it won't surprise to hear you,
you won't be surprised to hear that food is a really critical part of this group's connection
with nature. It's quite often people will bring food into the walk, and we'll sit down and share
stories and share our food, and that's all part of the experience of being in nature.
It's a really, really wonderful project, so I encourage you to go and follow her to find out
more about the work she's doing to encourage diversity in nature. So, that's it from me.
Here are my details, if you would like to follow me or talk to me about some of the work that I do.
I'm going to hand back over to Reema, so thank you very much.
Great, thank you so much for your talk, that was really awesome. So, a quick reminder to
the audience to send in your questions directly to me. So, there's questions at PaleoPax within
the participants list. So, we have some questions in already. So, from one of the
projects that you're working on at the moment, which one are you enjoying the most?
Oh my goodness, oh my goodness, let me have a think. I think it's got to be the Walking the
Walk project with the Open University because I'm really starting to see tangible change
where we are transferring our knowledge about and love of sciences and landscape evolution to
people who really don't know about science, they are new to science.
It's been quite magical and quite transformative to take that into the landscape, talk about the
geology. And I do this with Professor Claire Warren and Dr Marcus Badger at Open University,
they're geologists there. The three of us go out with the groups and when we talk to them about
the rocks under their feet, the landscape and how it's formed, you can see the spark in the eyes
of our participants, you can see them falling in love with the landscape. That, for me, is the
winner. You can't beat that feeling. Thanks. So, with this project, it's all ages and stages or
particular ones? We are working with parents and carers. So, our objective is to encourage
parents and carers, particularly those, they're all from diverse backgrounds, to see nature as
a career, to see earth sciences as a career that they would like to encourage their children to
enter. So, it's breaking down the barriers that if you study geography or earth sciences, you're
never going to get a job because this is very much a line of thought that is prevalent in,
particularly in immigrant communities, where there is a strong focus on economic viability
in terms of choices for education. You've heard the classic doctor, lawyer, teacher.
What we're trying to do is help our parents and carers understand that nature can be a career,
it can be a rewarding and valuable career for their children. And then on our walks, we have
children of all ages. I mean, there was a two-year-old on one of the walks and there was a
15-year-old. So, what we're trying to do is build a relationship that those families have with nature
so it's part of their lives. And so, when it comes to choosing GCSEs or A-levels or even degree
choices, that it suddenly becomes an option. That's super exciting. It's nice that you're
able to work on a family basis as well. Yeah. So, we have another question through. So, with the
work that you're doing with Wessex Museums, how does the work that you're doing with the
NERC Thunder Project relate to that or is this one completely separate? They exist in two different
spaces, but what it is is that they blend into each other. So, some of the lessons I learned
from working with the Dadimars community, the Dadimars walking group and the Chilterns or with
Black Girls Hike, all of that is based on effective community engagement and listening and learning
and co-creating. And in the museums, my whole job is all about guiding four learning teams across
four museums to deliver effective community engagement and projects that are very much
co-created with those communities' voices at the centre. So, although they are in two different
spaces and often about different narratives and discourses. So, one project we did with
young people last summer was all about climate change, related but not related. But what we
was, you know, it's really important to just be guided by the voices of the audience you want to
work with. So, in this case, we had a group of young people from Salisbury, from a very deprived
area. And when we kind of approached them with the project and said, this project is all about
climate change. Actually, these young people, they're 14 to 16, 17 years old. The first thing
they said was, we've never heard of climate change and we don't care because how does it impact on
us? We don't really care. What we're worried about is food poverty, the state of our local
environment, the state of this green space that keeps getting vandalised, the litter around our
estate. That's what we're worried about. And that's what we would like to work on with you.
And so, as a museum, what we did was we're like, okay, all right, let's go with that. So, we adjust
and flex according to what our audience needs and what they would like to talk about. And I think
that's a really important approach to building trust with communities because then, of course,
once we do a project like that, maybe next year, maybe the year after, we can maybe delve into the
deeper issues of climate change. And I kind of apply that learning to the projects that I work
on in both sectors. So, we have another question in that asks, have you seen an improvement in
terms of seeing more people from ethnic minority backgrounds in earth sciences slash nature careers?
I think in earth sciences, yes, I think there are a lot of hashtags running at the moment,
particularly post Black Lives Matter. You can even just look at Black in Geoscience on Twitter
or hashtag Black in Geoscience. And I think when that went live last summer or the summer before,
to be honest, it was amazing. I met and heard so many incredible stories of Black people studying
and researching earth sciences from all over the world. I mean, it was absolutely brilliant.
I think in nature, the same thing is happening. I think people are starting to claim the space.
So, if you follow Muslim Hikers, that's run by Haroon Mota. If you follow Black Girls Hike,
that's run by Rianne Fatinikun, even Steppers UK, Maxwell Iamber at Black Men Walking,
and Geeta Ladra at Dadimars, Mohamed Darlek over at Mosaic Outdoors in the Lake District
and Peak District. The voices are coalescing. There is a movement. And I think what we have
to be careful of is there is a lot of movement. There is a lot of lovely Instagram kind of faces
out there. What we have to be really mindful of is what is the level of engagement with nature
and what is the change that we're seeing? So, a lot of the work that I do is not so much about
the passive engagement with nature or earth sciences, which is I'm going to climb to the
top of Scaffold Pike, take a nice picture and walk down again. Where I'm interested more is
if you're walking to the top of Scaffold Pike, do you know or are you open to understanding
how that landscape formed? And what can we do to help you become empowered to tell that story
to your community? So, there is progress, but we can always do more.
Do you find that working with the Dadimars project that you see that change in sort of
parent mindset where they're encouraging their kids who are also there to sort of grow into nature?
Yeah, we have a project evaluator on that particular programme. And even on the WhatsApp
chat that I'm involved in, there are various families coming back with their children. And
one in particular, I think after one of our walks, she then went and climbed Snowdon with her two
children. So, it's a trickle effect, I think, for a lot of diverse communities. It's all about
word of mouth and trust. And if you trust someone, if you know someone and you trust them and you see
them doing something like walking up Snowdon or going for a walk in the countryside, the pattern
is that that trust makes you feel like you belong there. And so, you will try to reflect that
activity within your own space. I hope that answers that question.
Yeah, that's encouraging that that happened as a ripple with the project. So, we have another
question through. Thank you so much, Anjana. How do you see the higher education sector's role
in this work? Are there changes to curricula you'd like to see in the earth sciences, for example?
Yeah, I think some level of understanding, and I'm writing a lot about this at the moment,
is the decolonisation of the curriculum and being aware of what the lens is through which
geology is presented. And it's really interesting because I've just finished a sample chapter for
my book, and spoiler alert, so if you ever read it, you'll know that you heard it first here,
but I was looking at a particular feature in North America that was clearly a very natural
feature. And I was looking at some archive records of a geologist from 1875 who wrote about this
feature. And he basically said, well, it clearly isn't natural, it's clearly evidence of Celtic
people having come to this continent, to North America. And essentially, what he was saying was,
it was a glacial erratic, it was balanced on a number of stones, and he compared it to dolmens,
which are megalithic structures in Wales, in Scotland, in Britain. And this geologist said,
well, there's no evidence that this is a geological feature. How could it be? It must
be evidence of Celtic culture in North America. And he wrote that, but then 80 years later,
people were still talking about it. And even now, when I went to go and research the site,
there are still questions about whether it's a Celtic structure. And what's really interesting
is when you delve deep into that narrative, it's all coming from a colonialist point of view of
saying that, A, the Native American people, the First Nations people couldn't possibly have made
this themselves. And also, that our presence in colonising this space is justified, because look,
generations ago, this is a piece of evidence that proves our existence here. So these are the kind
of stories that I'm uncovering. And I think we would be mindful as earth scientists and geologists
to look at how history and science has been abused and misused willfully, in some cases,
to further the cause of colonial narratives. I don't know if that helps or answers that question.
But I'm quite passionate about that.
Are you working with any groups that are doing decolonisation work at the moment?
No, this is all research that I'm doing for my forthcoming book. But in the museum sector,
I am part of, well, we are funded by the Arts Council. So we're a partnership of now five
museums, and we have a big decolonisation programme running across all of our museum
partnership. And what we do is that we have lots of training, and we're working with the
Museums Association to really examine the way we talk about objects. And I think it's really
important, because there is a different lens through which these objects can be looked at,
and the same applies to nature. And what I find really interesting, and this is again,
this is all part of the research for this book that I'm doing, is that folklore and cultural
narratives have a very strong link to the science. When I read about some of the Native
American folklore about geological features, and the stories they tell about how these features
have formed through their voices, actually, they're not far off from what the science is saying.
So from my point of view, we should be embedding that rich cultural storytelling into the teaching
of science. I don't think the two are actually very separate. And I think what that then does,
is it begins to place a greater respect on how those indigenous communities and diverse
communities engage and think about nature. And that science isn't just this kind of
process that exists in isolation to those voices. I think hopefully in my book,
this will make more sense, and it will begin to allow us to question and respect the views and
contributions of indigenous communities to landscape evolution.
It'll be really exciting to see your book when it comes out.
I think you've got to wait another three years.
So we have another question. So thanks, Anjana. How much of financial barriers affecting BAME
communities acts as nature, and how could that barrier be removed?
That's a really interesting question, because yes, it does. Of course, right now we are in,
you know, we're facing a recession. It is extremely difficult for families out there.
And we know from statistics from COVID, that black, Asian and minority ethnic communities
were hit the hardest during COVID in terms of job loss, in terms of impact of COVID on health
and health inequalities. So this is what the community is already dealing with.
Then when you add on, hey, go into nature, because it enhances your health and well-being
and connection with the planet. You know, it's probably the last thing on these communities'
list of priorities, just like even going to a museum. So finance is a huge issue,
because for a lot of these national parks and areas of outstanding natural beauty, you need a
car. And I'll be honest, you do need a car. I live in Dorset, and you can't get anywhere unless you
have a car. The public transport system is so bad. But if you are in a city, and we know statistically
that in the United Kingdom, many black and Asian communities, actually, they are in urban
populations or urban fringes, nature is on your doorstep. And so what we have to do better is,
and I work with the Ramblers on this, actually, on a study that we published last summer,
there should be somewhere that you can go within five minutes walk of your house that immerses you
in nature. And we lobbied the government on this in the Environment Bill to really begin to build
in places where people can access nature, can enjoy nature, especially if they don't have a
back garden. And I think that's probably what I would say is finance is always going to be a
barrier. But if we can have nature within five minutes walk of our house, that's the next best
thing. You don't have to go to a national park. You don't have to see Durdle Door. You can go
to your local park and still see butterflies and wildflowers, and that will still give you
the benefit and enjoyment that going to the Lake District would have. Controversial, I know.
It's definitely a good thing to do if you have the local museums you can just go to.
Definitely without a car. So, last call for questions. Okay, we don't seem to have any
more questions through. So, thanks so much again for your talk. It was really, really cool to see
everything you're working on and to learn more about inclusive fieldwork within the spaces that
you're working in. So, I'm just going to quickly take over the screen share from you and close out.
So, thanks everyone for joining us. Please remember to fill in the weekly feedback form.
This will be in the chat very shortly so that we can learn a bit more about who attended
today's seminar. And join us next week at the same time to hear Taylor Fabry from the
Field Museum of Natural History in the US to talk about diving behaviour amongst dinosaurs.
We haven't had a dinosaurs talk at Paleo Perks for a while. So, up next we have tea time with
Anjana which we really encourage you to stick around for. So, this is just an informal conversation
about the talk, Anjana's career in a relaxed setting. And our question of the week is
if you had to do fieldwork anywhere in the world, where would it be and why? So, we have a
quick break before tea time. So, remember to get up, walk around, have a quick drink of water,
come back in two minutes. And if you have paleo pets, bring them to tea time as well.
We really like to meet them. So, we will see you in two minutes.
