Adam Savage Learns How Armored Helmets Are Restored

HISTORIC Weapons
3 followers
3 Video Views·Dec 18, 2024
At the Metropolitan Museum of Art's Arms and Armor conservation lab, armorer Ted Hunter shows Adam two examples of conservation on historical helmets--an early 17th-century Italian helmet and a late 16th-century German helmet. Ted shows Adam how he brought back the detailed gilding in the helmets as well as the hardware he had to make to match the original rivets and washers. Plus, the story of how the M1 US Military combat helmet originated at the MET!
Hey guys, Adam Savage here in the Conservation Lab at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Armor
Conservation Lab. Ted, you've got two beautiful helmets here. Tell me their stories. Okay, so this
is an Italian helmet, early 17th century. This is a German helmet, late 16th century. And I picked
these two out as kind of sort of modern conservation example and a little more craft
conservation example. Like the older style? Yeah. Okay. So I'll leave with this one. So this came
into us, I don't know if you can see in the photo here, it's a little dark and crusty and the gold
is pretty worn. This is gilding, is that right? It is gilding. And it's really worn away here,
whereas not here. So this is the before and an after, okay? Now the reason I like this one here,
this was cleaned, it was covered in rust and grime and dirt and accumulations over the surface.
All of the crevices were full of accumulated and compacted dirt and grease and oil and wax and what
have you. From centuries of people handling it and... Sitting on a shelf or in a drawer,
God knows where it's been. It's had a lot of wear, you can see because of all the loss
of the gilding, which would have been amalgam gilt. And so this is a real careful cleaning
process, right? I'm using surgical scalpels to scrape rust and grime off without... Without
marking. Without marking it. I don't want to score it or scratch it. Wow, so that's rust that
is creating some tiny layer and you're trying to scrape that while not scraping what's underneath.
It takes a lot of practice. You just get the scalpel at just the right angle and you've got
your magnifizers on and you just shave off to take off the rust and leave behind the browned
surface. So does that take like six months, two weeks? No, not that long. A couple of weeks I
spent on cleaning it. And then I'm going in with little wooden toothpicks and things to get all
the crevices. Sometimes I have to resort to a stiffer tool. But the point is, do no harm, right?
Right. Get all this grime and grut off of there and leaving behind what we call a conservation
surface. So you're not using Gugon or... I've got some solvents, you know, mineral spirits, acetone,
things like that. Light use of cotton swabs. Real gentle, go slow. But at the end of that,
I come to a point where I don't have a lot of gold that's left. It's pretty worn off.
But what I was able to find is exactly preserved. That was how it was when I cleaned it. Because it
was protected behind the visor. Which we often find. That if you lift apart two lames, you'll
find underneath, oh look, it's still blue and gold under there. And that's how you can determine
original color and finish. We have a helmet in the collection that if you take off the
visor and so on, you'll find it's still mirror polished under there. You can read your watch in
it. And that's the original mirror polish. So this was very good. I was like, okay,
that's a nice bit of gilding that's preserved. It looks really a lot better than most of the
helmet. We're going to use it as a guide. And so most of the gold you're looking at on here
is actually pigment that I applied in the lacquers. So I spent some time with different
mica pigments of gold. Trying to work out the right tone and color. Putting it into a lacquer
and painting it on and saying, well, that looks too yellow, too orange, too thick, too thin.
Once I kind of got it, I did a test section. I pitch it to the curators. I say, look,
this is what I can do. It'll make all of these monograms more legible. We use this as the sort
of guide. And what we can put on display is a helmet that doesn't look brand new. I haven't
restored the gold, but it is legible to the visitor and it's totally reversible.
And it's telling the story of the helmet. I mean, these look like almost like
gang tattoos, right? Like they must tell a specific story about the wearer or the maker.
Our assumption is that they are monograms that are significant to the owner. But we haven't
worked out who it is yet. It's a huge mystery. One kid's name, the other kid's name, the city
some phrase, a prayer or religious thing. It might just be last name and some family symbols.
It's not quite certain. The fun thing I did was I did half the helmet and I left the other half
undone and I used it as a teaching tool for three or four years before the curator said,
no, we really want to put that on display and maybe finish it. I was so mad because it was
great to pull this out and I could have the unfinished side and then I could dramatically
turn it to the finished side. And it was a lot of fun to have on there, but it's quite heavy.
It's a cross-ears helmet and would have been with a really beefy armor that presumably would have
been monogrammed and decorated similarly. So I'd love to know where the rest of the armor is.
That is, I just want to say from a scenic standpoint, replicating what you had is so
non-trivial. Did you do, you must've done tons and tons of practice
bits to kind of get that layout of the light and the dark and the model texture?
I had a set of brushes and swabs and things and I'd apply it, brush it on and then remove it and
smear it, you know? Yeah. Was a protective layer put underneath the lacquer? Yeah, it's coated,
then I apply the lacquer and then I have another coating over the top of it just because I don't
want it to rub off. So that the lacquer can come off and it's still, there's still a barrier coat
Yeah, I take the whole thing down, back down to bare metal. It's all reversible coating and
reversible pigment. And so that, I feel like that's a pretty good sort of representation of
kind of how we can take care of a piece of armor with just kind of modern thinking, okay? This guy
is a little bit different. So this one, he came in, he was really, you know, you can see we had
a lot of rust going on and bad leather straps that were not on there properly. And when you
see stuff like this, this is, I mean, within a hundreds of years time span, that's an emergency,
right? Like you don't want that rust to keep on. Yeah, I don't want that leather to stay on
because that's what's causing the rust, right? And the rivets, there were some original rivets
left on this, but it had been redone a couple of times, right? So when you, you know, have the
cheek pieces on there, there's a rivet that are holding the leather straps on the helmet and on
the cheek piece and the cheek piece was all wonky and falling off and the leather was crummy and
they were stretched out and there were, you can see here, maybe it's a little closer up here,
that big piece of preserved gold. Yeah. There was a humongous, chunky, solid brass rivet over that
for no reason. That's not even an original hole. They, these two pieces should support another
little bit here that would have been part of the chin strap and they, that was gone and they just
crunched this thing in to put a strap on there and it was
so wrong. So the curator said, look, this, this needs new riveting. Okay. These are horrible.
They're wrong. They're ugly. So I took out, I don't know, a few, you can see here a little
chart of everywhere I put a new rivet or removed a rivet or put a new cap on. So wait, a rivet and
a cap? Yeah. So like, for example, every one of these rivets is a steel rivet with a brass cap.
And is that, is that how the originals were done too? Yeah. Wow. So sometimes that brass
cap will pop off and you'll just see this kind of lumpy, soldery steel rivet underneath it.
So in some cases. Oh my God. New cap, for example, that's a new brass cap over an original
rivet right there. Okay. And there were others where the rivet was just gone and other places
where I had to remove an incorrect rivet. So the process was, okay, clean it, take out the bad
leather. Yeah. Take out the bad rivets, clean everything up again. Okay. And then I said,
Hey, remember this helmet? Let's, I could try, there's a lot of gold that's gone. I could try
and, you know, do something. And man, I spent months trying to work out how to do it. Yeah. I
had different formulations and color, you know, trying to get the right color. To bring it back
to like that. I wanted it to look like that, but I couldn't really reguild it. Right. So I tried
all kinds of things and everything I did looked like I was faking it. Yeah. It looked wrong.
Right. And so we eventually said, you know what? There's a lot of fine detail in here that the
visitors maybe just not gonna be able to see that well. I could, I could pop it out. I could
enhance it. Yeah. And then it looks like I reguiled the helmet. Right. I feel like I'm faking it to
the audience. Yeah. Right. So we decided we did, we're going to do it. I cleaned it off again and
I built a bunch of rivets and this, you know, there's a sort of, here's one that I've, I've
started kind of shaping the head. Right. And I'm trying to like get a kind of profile that matches
some of its neighbors. Right. And some of them are more mashed than others and I'll sand it a
little bit and then I'll put the cap on and clean up the edge. And it's kept glued on, soldered on?
Soldered on. Silver solder. Yeah. And then here's the really awful bit. That's the shanks of the
rivets that I'm starting with, but all the holes are a lot smaller. Right. So I'm putting these on
the lathe and milling down the shank a little bit. You're holding onto the head on the lathe.
It's not easy. I was going to say. A lot of rivets go like that. So in fact, I do,
I don't put the cap on. Yeah. First I go. Yeah. Then I put the cap off. Um, and you know, I just
punched these out and I was, I had to make a punch at first before I, I said, this is the
heck with this. And I bought a nice one, but I was punching out my caps and dapping them by hand.
Because it took forever. Uh, and so then every one of these holes is slightly different. So every
rivet was fit for the hole. So we've got a combination, right? Of like, I'm making rivets,
you know, sort of the old fashioned way, but I'm not going to change the helmet. I have to be very
careful about not enlarging holes and things like that. And then the last thing I made my own
washers and the washers, then this is sort of, you know, just cut it out, starting to shape it.
And then I've stamped it MMA. So in addition to my little handwritten picture there, if you turn
this up inside out, which I can do, you can see the inside of the helmet, if you like. Yes. You'll
be able to see where original rivets and old leather is and new rivets. And there's little
MMAs on there. So this is the thing, like people may look at this and be like, well, those little
rivets look pretty crunchy, but like that's exactly how, sorry, those washers, but that's
exactly how they made them. I was copying what was in there. That's incredible. At least enough. Yeah.
Right. So you don't look at it and think, oh, what's going on? But you do look and you say, ah,
okay, that one's modern. And then, you know, we, we made the leather and made them fit a little
better and they've got a little play. So they're not so stiff. Do you treat the leather to keep it
from imparting moisture to the steel? We're using leather that is cured. It's not vegetable
tan leather. Okay. And then I saturate it and waxes and things like that and color it. Plus
there's wax barrier layers between the leather and the steel. Everything's coated. Right. Right.
It is the sort of thing that we need to keep an eye on, you know, like, but as you can see,
it's been now on display a good five or six years and seems to be doing all right. So I've been
handed some pieces of mushroom leather lately that are incredibly realistic feeling and no
actual leather. I haven't had any in hand yet. I'd be curious to know how that stands up. We have a
whole science department that specializes in, you know, oh, here's a piece of leather. Can you run
it through the tests? And I'll tell you, oh, this is full of acids and chemicals. Don't put this
anywhere near the art or this, this fabric you've chosen for your case is perfect. You can put
anything in that case you want or, okay, we're going to build these cases out of only these
materials so that the gas buildup inside of a sealed case doesn't cause my, isn't causing more
to corrode. I don't want that. Now I'm really fascinated by this little spring piece because
it looks clear to me that there was some visor that clipped in a nose piece, actual nose piece
would have had. So this, this is an interesting helmet. This is a German, but in the sort of
Ottoman style, right? So at the time this was made, Suleiman the Magnificent was still the
Sultan of the Empire. And at the kind of the height of the power, right? The Ottomans were
really, uh, all over the place. And, um, so this is not only is this their enemy, right? But they're
emulating their enemy because their enemy is so powerful. The Ottomans are so influential
throughout the, you know, Eastern Europe and the Mediterranean song that this, this style of
Zizek becomes synonymous with power and, and style and everything, you know, and so they were copying
these and you find a lot of these kinds of German Zizek with this flared neck and these cheek pieces
and rather than a full visor, you simply had a nose piece and you could lift it up and down.
And this clip spring clip really just sort of held it in place and they're often gone or broken or
these things are gone. I'm looking at these and I'm seeing all the institutional knowledge
you get from them and impart to them. Okay. And I once visited a tank museum and found out that it
was so extensive. The military sent new tank designers to this museum to learn what they
could from the art of making tanks. You guys, do you guys ever participate in such a, an exchange?
Like do modern armorers come and look towards this stuff? Yes and no, not in a while. Okay.
We have learned a lot about body armor and protecting the body, which is knowledge that
people learned the hard way, a long time ago. Yeah. You know, for example, you know, a helmet
like this, it's, it's not just shaped like this for fun, right? There's certain features of it.
You want this extending over the neck, right? You want this brow here over your face, peaks
and ridges give strength to the dome. Right, right. Okay. And these are lessons, as you say,
learned the hard way. So, you know, if you look at helmets, just as an example across history,
you know, from the ancient Greeks to modern day, you will see certain features that persist and I
can show you some examples. Yeah, please. Okay. Ted, I didn't expect to see modern military
helmets in this shop. Yeah. So, you know, Tesho started as the armor in the department. Yeah. He
left in 1919, left us all his tools. I know you've seen those and you like them. Yeah. And there were
a few other armors kind of came along and then we got a guy named Leonard Heinrich. Now the story
of these is about Heinrich, but we have to go back to Tesho to tell the earlier part of the story.
Basher Dean was commissioned by the U.S. Army for the First World War to study body armor
because, as you know, the trench combat was terrible and the soldiers were being wounded
in terrible ways because, honestly, they didn't have any kind of real protection. Yeah. They had
those little soup bowl helmets. Yeah. And they were not up to the task. The dough boy, is that? Yeah.
Yeah. So, they, you know, before the America got involved, the army came to Dean and they said,
you're like the only guy that knows anything about armor. What can you do? And he said,
right. And he said, too. And he was very, very methodical, very serious about it. After the war,
published a fantastic treatise on all of his research and knowledge. But he developed all
kinds of ideas about armor, looking at what kinds of wounds the men were getting, what kind of
weapons they were up against and what he could learn from older armors. Yeah. Right. He noticed
certain features that all helmets had. You know, they had strength in certain ways and coverage in
certain ways. And he was applying all these ideas. And he came up with some. This is just one example
of the kinds of prototypes that he was developing. But 1917, 18, that looks like such a modern
helmet. It does. It does. Unfortunately, it also looked a lot like the German helmet.
And the War Department saw a problem with that. Sure. They did not approve his helmet design.
They did not want to emulate their enemies. They did not want to emulate their enemies. But you
can see there's this sort of ridge that comes out, the brim flaring. It covers the neck. It's higher
up over here and then it goes down over the ears and covers the neck. Actually, a little bit like
the Montevertino helmet that you were looking at earlier. Yeah. Right. So he had this idea and a
few other prototypes that he worked on. Some were like far more sort of flared out. Others had real
peaks and combs and things on it. And he did came up with some prototype ideas for body armor as
well. Oh my goodness. Yes, yes, yes. Would not seem out of place 300 years previously in terms
of its construction. These prototypes, however, really didn't make it very far. There are some
stories of prototypes being sent into the field for testing and with no explanation, no scientific
rigor, no industrial process. Right. So the guys would apparently set up against a tree and shoot
at them from 20 feet away and they're like, oh, they're not bulletproof. What the heck? Right. And
so helmet didn't take off. Armor didn't take off. A few things did get adopted. He had some
eye protection ideas that were adopted for machine gunners. Right. In any case, he's very upset. He
writes his whole treatise at the end explaining everything. World War Two comes along and his
successor, Stephen Grancy, is given the same job. And this time we had some success. The armor at
time was Leonard Heinrich. And with this hammer, he banged out the first prototype of this helmet,
the M1. This is the actual hammer. This is the actual hammer, which was Tasho's. Right. OK. Yeah.
And he banged out these. He was working in aluminum. Right. Just to get the shape right. Right. Yeah.
And they would send these off and have them processed industrial in steel and, you know,
so on and so forth. And there were variations. Right. But this one here, this is the 1941 M1
first version, which still has the paper liner instead of the phenolic resin liner. The paper
liner is very fragile. Yeah. Totally inappropriate to send into the field. Not sure whose idea that
was. It wouldn't have been Heinrich's. But what I want to call your attention to is the German helmet
Now, this one we picked up in an antique store in Queens. OK. Ten bucks. This one, my father-in-law's
uncle brought back from the European theater. Wow. He was a tank crew. He picked this up. And
so they look pretty different at first glance. Yeah. But I want to call your attention to
the flared brim, the drop. Yeah. You're getting it. You're getting. Yeah. The neck. The features
are all there. All the same features that you'll see in the previous versions. Yeah. And in
helmets of the 15th century or earlier. Right. The same ideas. So they're clearly
they're clearly following the same path of discovery. Right. And they recognize that
these are the sort of parts that you need to protect. Yeah. Yeah. This is the coverage a
helmet needs to have to be effective and to be usable. And then they have some refinements,
like, for example, this comes in small, medium and large. And this came in like 20 different
sizes. Oh, it's the Germans, right? They had also you could you'd say you'd measure your head and
you'd get a 41 or a 42 or what have you. This has their movable liner. And, you know, we've seen in
all the movies how handy it is for shaving and your helmet and that kind of thing. So versatile.
The primary thing I think is really interesting is that this took something like a 30 step
industrial process. And this was like a 10 step process or something like that. This was way
cheaper to produce. Yeah. They made like 60 million of these things. They were still in use
in the 80s. Yeah. And you probably could find them in use today. But the original prototype
done here at the Met, we still have some of the prototype examples. What a thrilling story. I just
love that. I mean, I have so many friends who whose obsessions have turned into their careers
because of the institutions, the institutional knowledge they gleaned and gained over
researching their obsession. And now they are a source that people go to for the information.
That sounds like you. I'm trying, Ringo. I'm working on it. Yeah. I mean, that's the thing
is it's like none of this sits wholly in one bucket. Right. No, absolutely. Absolutely. Move
around. And I can I hold the hammer? Oh, yeah. You can hold the helmets to look inside, whatever.
That's incredible. Are these all vice marks? They are. Yeah. Yeah. I'm not sure exactly what they
were doing, but sometimes I can see put it in a vice and then you can work against it. It becomes
its own state. Right. Yeah. I have definitely done this with some of my hammers. I try not
to treat our hammers like that. Ted, thank you so much.
