The Landsknecht ("servant of the country", a German mercenary) is mostly known for his flamboyant outfits and the iconic Zweihander, AKA greatsword, a large two-handed sword. On the battlefield they supposedly used those to chop pikes and break up enemy formations. The evidence we have for this is surprisingly limited though.
So let's take a closer look at some historical depictions and written reports from the 16th and 17th centuries. I also added some personal speculation and an improvised demonstration for visual reference. Take it with a grain of salt, as I'm not an expert on military tactics of the time.
** Time Stamps **
00:00 - 01:02 Introduction 01:02 - 01:48 The Pike Square 01:48 - 02:38 What is a pike? 02:38 - 03:55 "Academic" fencing masters & skill vs. battlefield chaos 03:55 - 04:41 Spadone vs. polearms 04:41 - 08:10 Evidence for chopping pikes with greatswords 08:10 - 09:36 Shock troops, discipline, unit cohesion 09:36 - 10:17 More realistic movie battle: Alatriste (2006) 10:17 - 11:42 Pike squares: Not homogenous! - Mixed weapons 11:42 - 13:02 How pikemen might keep themselves safe 13:02 - 19:30 Practical demonstration (sword charge / binding pikes / cutting in confined space) 19:30 - 21:21 Conclusion / outro
All right, here's part two about two-handed swords, which in this video I'm going to refer
to as great swords, considered a controversial term by some, but it's quicker to say and more
distinctive than two-handed sword, which could simply be a long sword. So if you haven't seen
part one yet, in which I showed you some giant swords in history and talked about the difference
between ceremonial and functional designs, the link is in the description down below.
Check it out if you haven't already. The flamboyant German mercenaries called
Landsknecht, meaning either country vassal or servant of the country, are generally associated
with the iconic great sword. Despite this association, the primary weapon of the
Landsknecht was a polearm. So it could be pikes, glaives, halberds, partisans, etc.
When people think of the great sword on the battlefield, they have the notion that they
used to chop off heads. Pike heads, that is. Probably also other heads.
The pike square was used famously by the Swiss in the Battle of Nancy in 1477 to devastating effect.
This is generally seen as one of the turning points that made infantry more essential than
cavalry from the 1500s on. The pike square typically consisted of 100 men in a 10x10
formation, which could be combined with other squares to form a battle line.
Well-trained soldiers were able to point the pikes in all directions if surrounded.
So basically they fixed one of the two main weaknesses of the Macedonian pike phalanx,
being vulnerable to the flanks and rear. The other weakness is limited mobility, which still
applies to a large extent to pike squares. What even is a pike?
Basically it's a spear on steroids. Much stouter and very long. How long exactly?
By the way, don't type just average pike length. The search results are fishy.
Apparently the length could vary drastically depending on country, time period, individual
battle, who knows what. Anything between 3 and 7.5 meters or 10 to 25 feet. The Italian fencing
master Alfieri in 1641 says the pike should be made of well-seasoned ash wood, about 6 meters
or 20 feet long. He also mentions that it was originally carried by itself, but then later a
sword was worn along with it as a sidearm, for reasons that will become obvious later on.
Interestingly, he also, from the grave, addresses a common criticism of keyboard
internet scholars, who like to say that all these fancy techniques that you show,
that's all bullshit. Back then the battlefield was pure chaos. You couldn't use any fancy
techniques. It was all just manly strength. What Alfieri talks about basically amounts to
what good is an untrained peasant who doesn't even know how to properly hold the weapon or
thrust with it effectively without getting caught up and hindering everybody else.
Let alone things like marching in formation. Something as dense and coordinated as a pike
square has to be disciplined, otherwise it will just fall apart. So you need trained soldiers
who know what the hell they're doing. A number of 16th and 17th century manuscripts show fighting
with a pike or a long staff as a substitute. And if you practice this in a one-on-one setting,
academic fencing if you will, you can familiarize yourself with the weapon and the body mechanics
involved, which would then carry over to the battlefield. Alfieri describes the use of the
pike and also of the spadone, the italian two-handed sword. Unfortunately it's not the
best source for us today, because he uses only a few pictures, he doesn't define the terms or
describe techniques in enough detail. He tells us how to use the spadone in confined areas,
which he says can be used to defeat pikes and other polearms. Now the only thing I can gather
from it is basically you walk forward while keeping the sword in motion using repeated
flowing cuts. How exactly is a different story. Either way this sounds like a one-on-one scenario
or perhaps a small group melee rather than battlefield. Most treatises deal with dueling
or self-defense. If you think about it, soldiers were drilled in military exercises. They didn't
really need written reference material. So back to the pike chopping business. There's a great
article on the spadoneproject.com which found only a handful italian sources mentioning this.
By the way, I would recommend reading the article. I'll link it down below in the description
along with other resources I've used. So to sum it up about the battle of Fernovo in 1495,
one source written six years later describes 300 men armed with great swords that cut the
opposing pikes and routed the enemy. There are two other sources about this battle,
one written a year after, which don't mention this. It's kind of odd. This seems like it would
be an important event to report. One author wrote about the battle of Soriano 116 years after it
happened and suggests that if the losing side had deployed great sword wielders in the front line,
they could have turned the tide of battle by cutting pike heads without being hit. So keep
in mind this is speculative musings a century later. There's a source about the battle of
Marignano 1515 that mentions two big courageous swiss soldiers armed with great swords who fell
after having cut many pikes and enemies. And the final source about the siege of Calais in 1558
describes one german soldier with a great sword who behaved as Roland, which is a mythical hero,
and cut pikes. We always have to be careful with heroic deeds. Is this reality? Is it embellishment,
especially when they even refer to mythical heroes? So this could have happened or it could
have happened somewhat differently and been exaggerated or it couldn't have happened at all
and just been an addition. We don't know for sure. The article also points to an italian book about
military tactics from 1566 where the author apparently prefers halberds over great swords
because they can chop pikes. And this seems commonsensical as well. I mean, if you're trying
to chop a wooden pole, would you rather use an axe or a sword? He also claims that great swords
couldn't properly damage pikes due to the lack of space. So what other references do we have? I found
a picture of the battle of Pavia, painted a few years after it happened, which shows a soldier
with a great sword and a broken pike in front of him. There are just a few men here, so it doesn't
look like a full pike square, but I imagine the painter might have omitted most of it to show
more detail. And you see that a lot in especially medieval paintings where you just have a few people
representing a much larger group. Among the german mercenaries you have the doppelzöhner, which
translates to double mercenary, who fought at the front lines, received twice the payment, basically
hazard pay because of how dangerous this was and the high casualties that they suffered. Another
term was forlorn hope, which was a group armed with great swords whose goal was to break up
enemy formations. I couldn't confirm this, but I'm assuming the forlorn hope were double mercenaries.
By the way, keep in mind, breaking up the enemy formation isn't necessarily the same as breaking
pikes. Shock troops were meant to disrupt formations and reduce cohesion. In order to be
fully effective, a pike square, and any formation really, needs cohesion in the sense that the men
need to work as a unit. They need to be disciplined enough to coordinate. They can't just
willy-nilly do different things at different times, so pressuring them beyond their ability to stay
coordinated and shocking and demoralizing them enough that individual soldiers start looking
out more for their own hide, which ironically they're less able to. If individuals start to
try to run away and get out of the formation, disrupt everything, they're extremely vulnerable.
That's where they get cut to pieces. But of course, if you panic, you forget that.
Now, the way most movies depict field battles, where everything decays into a chaotic mess of
individual melees and even duels, basically that's how you lose a battle. If that happens,
if you have no unit cohesion, each man for himself, then yeah, you're screwed. If the
soldiers don't even respond to commands, you as a commander can do absolutely nothing,
you can only watch them get slaughtered, basically. There's an interesting scene in
the historical film Alatrist from 2006, which shows how fighting could be mostly disciplined
but still contain elements of chaos. The pikemen themselves are generally
steady and disciplined. Their pikes keep them safe, but within that, anyone who manages to
get past those into the forest of pike shafts, basically, now you can have individual fights
where somebody within that formation needs to respond and protect the pikemen and fight with
a sword or a shorter polearm, things like that. And this is the deal. Pike squares weren't
homogenous. In 16th century depictions, there's no sign of entire homogenous greatsword regiments.
Where you find the sword wielders is inside the pike square. They're on the front line,
but between pikemen. And you also find other weapons as well. Halberds, glaives, etc. And I
think that's also what the earlier source meant. 300 men who got out from the one and the other
flank of ordnance. Within the pike square, they're safe, but then they can emerge to try flanking
the enemy or disrupting the formation. The main function of the pike square is to defeat cavalry
and to protect gunners and other infantry. Pitting it against another pike square is
really not a good tactical use. They would have more value in other roles, but it happened anyway,
sometimes. So when you get the push of pike, as it was called, anyone who manages to get past the
points could attack the pikemen directly. So that's why you had other weapons within the
formation to defend them. Historical pictures like this show the juxtaposition of the orderly
disciplined pike square and the chaotic fighting that went on inside of it, or in between, or
however you want to look at it. This is where you see two-handed swords, single-handed swords,
daggers, etc. There's a video of a HEMA group experimenting with a pike formation, where you
have 20 people on each side, and it turns into a push of the pike. When you think about this kind
of situation, if everybody just marches at each other and they all just thrust forward, it's
basically luck. Whether you survive or not is quite a gamble. You essentially have to rely on
either the opposing pikeman missing you, or it glancing off your armor, if you have enough armor,
things like that. So I would think they were probably trained in a little more than just
thrusting forward. The goal, I imagine, would be to control the enemy's pikes.
Like, with your one pike, you want to bind up as many of theirs as you can to allow the other
pikeman next to you to attack them. Now you can actually do something actively to try to keep
yourself safe, rather than just stabby-stabby and hope for the best, basically. Take this with a
grain of salt. It's just my personal speculation. Obviously, I can't travel back in time and
witness a pike battle in action. And also, I'm not an expert on battlefield tactics. I've always
more interested in the dueling side of sword combat and other weapons. Anyway, let's just
dive deeper into some speculation, for fun, if nothing else. Behold my ultra-professional setup
for visual reference. That's a mercenary, and that's a mercenary. Of course, the Landsknecht
would have fancier hats than these, but, you know, and we've got pikes here. There's a pike,
there's a pike, there's a pike. Just pretend they're pike-sized. Basically, I see two options
here for dealing with that if we have two-handed swords. One option is essentially kind of a
suicide charge. It's particularly dangerous, and this would be the highest risk, sort of high
reward option. They were using breastplates, typically. So, if you're lucky, a pike thrust
would glance off the breastplate, and you would be okay. If you're thrust in the face, of course,
or in the arms, not so good. But here's the suicide rush. We just want to run at the pikeman
and try our best to avoid the pike thrust. So, if I run here, and the pike thrust comes in,
I need to, you know, do something about that. And, you know, this one is also pointing at me.
The moment I'm just past the point, I don't really need to be worried about the pikes anymore.
However, again, with a pike, the user would be further away than with these things. So,
I could now cut. I'm just past the point, but I'm still far enough away from the wielder that I can
cut them. Even if I'm too close to cut the guy directly in front of me, I could probably cut
the guy next to him. So, once we're past this, we have a chance to just hack away and disrupt
their formation, because the pikemen are bound up. Again, this is an extremely risky version of
it. The more plausible version is, if there's a pike person on my right and on my left,
now those two with their pikes can give me coverage against those pikes, and they can try to
bind them, keep them busy. And now, as we move forward, I actually have some cover,
and as soon as they get a hold of this pike, I might be able to come in here, cut at that pike,
maybe grapple it, you know, move in. And again, as soon as I'm past the points,
now I can really work with the sword. Keep in mind, in an actual pike square, it's even worse,
because not only do you have to deal with the front row, you have to deal with the one behind,
because, guess what, the pike is long enough to reach. There's going to be a limit how much they
can turn with their pikes, because, you know, the rear end of the pole is going to start hitting
someone else. So, there's going to be a limit, but they can definitely not just thrust forward,
but they can adjust a little bit. So, I have to deal with several of them. So, I need to somehow
get in here without getting stabbed to pieces, which is difficult. So, the ideal is that I swipe
two pikes. So, if I manage to cut one of the pikes, and I don't mean necessarily cut as in sever, but
just cut so that you kind of bind against it, now you can control it. Hopefully, I can bind up more
than one, and this is probably also where the parrying hooks come in handy, because not only
can I bind like this, I can also catch it on there or between the top parrying hook and the guard.
Try to keep them busy, basically. That's really what I want as the guy with a sword. I want
everybody else with a pike to be able to have a clean direction of attack, you know, be clear,
and be able to thrust them. So, I need to do something about this while to my sides stuff
is happening. Pikes are shooting back and forth. It's madness. So, no wonder that they were paid
extra. Here's another question. How can I even use such a large sword in a tight formation?
Isn't everything bound up? Like, how do I even swing? But you can adjust for that. So, if I have
a pike next to me and there and everywhere, basically, I'm not going to swing like this,
you know, like they have the sword raised above their heads. I don't have enough ceiling height
here, but basically like this. So, I'm not actually threatening anybody behind me because
it's pointing upward. So, if I want to cut in all of this mess here, obviously, I cannot
do like a sweeping, horizontal, or steep diagonal cut. If it's going to be diagonal,
it's going to have to be pretty tight. So, it's going to have to be something like this sort of
angle here. Almost vertical, but it can't be vertical because then I wouldn't be intercepting
the pikes. So, I can, as this is going on, I can absolutely move like this and I do not need to
retract it that far. These guys would have been trained with the sword. They're not just some
random peasants. So, they would know how to engage their core and cut strongly without
needing all of this arm movement. Particularly, if it's a heavier sword, even though this is a
synthetic practice sword, it's pretty hefty. It weighs almost as much as a steel sword. So,
with this, I don't need to be swinging wildly. For one, the weight is going to do part of the work.
And if I engage the core and cut down like this, this is going to have quite a bit of power. The
paring hooks and the blunt ricasso, which was sometimes bound with leather, would be quite
useful for half-sorting. So, in whichever configuration you want, really. But again, I have
not been able to find a single picture where they actually do that. Doesn't mean they didn't,
but you could argue, once you're at this point, once you're this close, you would draw your short
sword, which the Lanzknecht typically had. So, overall, there is evidence of the use of great
swords against pikes. It's limited, and some of it can be questioned. But I think it's enough
to think that it did happen, just not in the way we sometimes imagine. It was not just
one unit of great swords that counters a unit of pikemen, you know, like rock-paper-scissors style,
or, I guess, fire emblem style. But if pike squares could contain mixed weapons anyway,
it makes perfect sense to throw in some great swords. Now, each weapon has its own strengths
and weaknesses, so you can try to even it out. In different situations, one weapon might be better
than another. In some situations, a halberd might be more effective. In others, the sword might do
better. Either way. So, yeah, that's about all I've got. It took a lot of diving and digging
into this. I'm pretty sure you can come up with a whole lot more. And feel free, by all means, to
contribute to the discussion down below. If you have other sources, let us know. And, again,
take all of this with a grain of salt. But I hope you found it interesting. Either way,
thanks for watching, and have a good one, folks.