U-DRAG RACE: BMW M4 Competition vs. Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio | Quarter Mile, Handling & More

Cars Arena
18 followers
I'm Alistair Weaver.
That is the iconic Jonathan L. Farlan.
This is an Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio.
And that is a BMW M4 competition.
And this is Edmund's U-Trax.
Let's get on with it.
This will be good.
Today, we have the 2024 Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio
with 505 horsepower and 443 pound feet of torque.
It's running on Pirelli P-Zero Corsa ARs.
Going up against the 2024 BMW M4 competition
with 503 horsepower and 479 pound feet of torque.
It's running on Michelin Pilot Sport 4S.
These two are going head to head
under Edmund's U-Drag track,
which starts with a quarter mile drag,
then they hit the brakes, do a 180,
and power back to start finish.
At the end of the first run, we'll swap drivers in lanes
and do it again.
I know you want to buy one of these.
If you do, head on over to edmunds.com.
So the Alfa Romeo Quadrifoglio, which
means four-leaf clover in English.
What do we do to set it up?
Well, we twist this little knob here into race.
That turns off the stability controls.
Different sort of suspension gives you maximum attack.
There is no launch control.
So all I'm going to do is put my left foot on the brake,
right foot on the throttle.
And I reckon I can dial up about 1 and 1⁄2,
2,000 RPM before the whole thing starts to move.
He's got carbon ceramic brakes.
I don't.
I have slightly stickier boots, but he's got bigger boots.
He has better power-to-weight ratio.
But I have style, brio, panache, and character.
Let's get to it.
All right, how to launch this thing.
So we can pre-program all of our settings
into one of two M buttons on the steering wheel.
And then all we have to do is shift to drive,
make sure we're in manual mode.
If it's not already up,
we have to turn the drive shift logic all the way up to three,
and then we're good to go.
Hard on the brake, floor the accelerator.
I'll get an indication that launch control is preparing,
and then it's active, takes a couple seconds,
and then I just let it rip.
So I think this M4 has a bit of a power-to-weight advantage.
Not a huge advantage, but it is an advantage.
So I think it's the M4's race to win.
I think it has a really good chance of pulling out a win over that Alfa.
But let's see.
Go, go, go, go, go, go!
Ah, not the best of starts.
Ah, rubbish.
He's just gone.
I feel kind of bad almost.
Whoa!
A little bit squirrelly.
Slowly on the brakes.
Need the power.
Bit of oversteer.
Well, that was a slow exit, but a fun one.
Ah, it's not even a race!
I mean, it didn't even feel like a race.
This is pretty good on the braking, despite the lack of carbon ceramics.
But it did move around a little bit.
And then I got a little bit of oversteer
as I kind of went back on the gas.
Bit of a no contest, I'm afraid.
Well, you kind of ruined my joke set up,
because I was going to ask you if you smelt anything burning.
Because you just got smoked!
I was halfway down the straight.
And I mean, it just feels like this car has so much more power
by the looks of it.
I also didn't get the cleanest of exits out of the corner.
Got a little bit of oppo on the way out.
But it's got a little bit of a power to weight advantage,
but not by the same margins that we saw in this race.
I think the other big thing is you've seen BMW's launch control
is pretty much good on every M car.
This doesn't have it at all.
And I was trying to build it up on the throttle
and just to almost like get to the brakes
to the point where they're about to give.
And that didn't really work either.
I will say that these carbon ceramic brakes
do not feel quite as good as they should.
I didn't feel like I had the bite that they normally offer,
nor the stopping power.
So I'm wondering if there's something up with these brakes.
But yeah, I don't know.
Or maybe they're fine.
And that's the way they're supposed to feel.
But sounds good.
One thing I do like about the Alfa is just the steering.
It has a very kind of nice, precise turn in.
There's plenty of steering feel.
And it's kind of a nice, sounds weird,
but it's a nice steering wheel rim.
It's not too thick.
It has a good feel about it.
Anyways, I don't know.
Why don't you say we swap lanes, swap cars,
and give it another go.
We saw what happened to this thing.
It got slaughtered by that M4 competition.
I remember when I first drove this,
I thought it was like top of the class.
It was an amazing piece of engineering.
It still is, but it's starting to fill its age,
especially compared to something like the M4 competition.
I'm going to try and get the best launch I can
with the power it has.
It does not have launch control.
I don't have really positive predictions
for the outcome of this race.
But I do plan to have fun.
So at least there's that.
So into the M4, all Germanic efficiency, carbon brakes,
they're an option, of course, and launch control
and everything else that you might want.
But what it doesn't have for over $110,000
is adaptive cruise control.
And on the drive here, that drove me mad.
Come on, BMW, sort it out.
That, ladies and gentlemen, is proper consumer advice.
Now let's race.
5, 3, 2, 1.
Go, go, go, go.
Oh, hook up, hook up.
Oh, come on.
Come on, buddy.
You got this.
OK, OK, OK, OK.
Patience now, patience.
Turn around, turn around.
A little bit of oversteer.
There's no way I'm catching him.
Decisive win for the M4.
Yeah, I mean, I had a ton of wheel spin.
I was trying to manage it as best I could.
And it seemed like it was going to be a good battle.
And then same place, about halfway down the track,
the M4 just started pulling away.
I'm like, ah, well, there goes that.
Tried to get it back under braking.
I do like the brakes.
I feel like the brakes bite a little harder,
even though they're steel rotors.
They just have a better feel in this car.
Although, I also feel like the pedal is harder to modulate.
It's more kind of on-off.
And so really just trying to find that balance.
I don't love either brakes.
But I think I prefer the Alpha over the BMWs in this case.
The other thing you just have to be conscious of,
they're both big, relatively heavy rear-wheel drive cars.
So you just have to be so patient getting back on the power.
And it's kind of frustrating, because you just feel like
you're giving away so much time.
Yeah, I mean, you said it.
Patience is key in both of these.
And if you don't have a fancy traction control system
to sort of like meter out that horsepower,
you really have to be patient, especially
at these slow corners.
So what do we think?
Well, it's a clear win for Germany
over the more stylish and charismatic Italian.
This thing is just a weapon.
It really is.
I think we've seen we've now done lots of M cars in new drives.
The launch is fantastic, at least when it works.
It's a triumph of engineering.
Now I can put the air conditioning back on.
Well, that was exhilarating.
Here's the track conditions.
And for the best numbers,
zero to 60 goes to the M4 at 3.8 seconds.
Quarter mile also goes to the M4 at 11.7.
Max cornering goes to the Alfa, pulling 1.13 Gs.
And the win goes to the M4 at 33.9 seconds
at 132.7 miles an hour.
If you want to check out the official leaderboard,
head on over to edmunds.com slash udrags.
The Alfa was able to improve on its previous best time
and is now in 24th with a time of 35.5.
But the M4 couldn't beat its previous best time,
so it stays put in 15th.
So Jonathan, not much of a contest in the end.
The German juggernaut beat the Italian stylist.
I honestly thought it would be a lot closer.
But as we found out, it didn't seem like these cars
were even in the same league.
Because the Alfa hasn't had any significant changes
since 2017, 2016, when it first came out.
So technology has moved on since then,
and it is a prime example of it here.
Although it was cheating a little bit
by having carbon ceramic discs,
which are a $8,500 option.
I mean, yes.
But the Giulia has more aggressive tires,
and I really didn't like the feel of the carbon ceramics.
I felt like they didn't quite give the bite
that I was looking for.
So even though it did have that brake advantage,
I don't think it actually played out as an advantage.
I think its main advantage was power and technology.
Yeah, and I actually braked at the same point in both cars.
But yeah, having launch control, like $90,000,
no launch control, but that's progress.
Anyway, I hope you enjoyed this no contest.
If you'd like to see more contests
that are a little bit closer,
then be sure to subscribe to the channel.
Check out our Udrags page on edmunds.com.
That's edmunds.com slash udrags.
And be sure to check out everything else
that we have to offer.
Thanks for watching.
Goodbye for now.
