Why You Shouldn’t Keep Your Mortgage for the “Tax Benefits”

The Ramsey Show Highlights
1.8K followers
3.5K Video Views·Dec 2, 2024
[Music]
brought to you by the Ramsey Network app
download today to go further with ramsy
today's question comes from Jamie in
Minnesota she said my husband and I are
51 and 53 we're debt-free and have three
cars that are fully paid for with a
household income of $150 $50,000 we are
debating whether or not we should sell
one of our cars worth $50,000 and apply
that to our mortgage we owe about 90,000
on our mortgage and we'll be paid off in
one year if we sell the car versus three
years if we do not sell the car my
husband thinks you should not pay off
your house early because we can't deduct
the mortgage interest on the tax returns
and he's afraid we'll owe the IRS last
year we paid $
33,976 in mortgage interest can you
provide some feedback on that and what
your recommendations
are okay um well the mortgage or the tax
deduction in general including mortgage
interest is the biggest piece of
Mythology in all of personal
finance because it requires that people
forget how to do sixth grade math let me
walk you through it if Jamie if you
actually
itemize then you can claim your
charitable deductions and your mortgage
interest rates by the way last year
because the standard deductions are so
high almost no one itemized including
you you probably didn't even itemize so
your husband is completely unaware of
how this whole thing works because you
didn't take a deduction for your
mortgage interest unless you itemized
nine% of Americans itemize
91% do not
if you do not itemize you do not get a
tax deduction for your charitable or for
your
interest so 91% of the people this
doesn't even come up for it with right
so that's just dumb not you not you
Jamie but when people are saying well I
don't want to lose my you're not taking
it anyway you just don't even know how
your taxes work you're that g plug into
it all right now if if you do if you did
itemize then you sent the mortgage
company $3,000
$3,097 $3,100 bucks and that reduced
your income your $150,000 income by
$3,000 a tax deduction is not a tax
credit it lowers the amount of income
that is
taxed so the tax savings is not
$3,100 the tax savings is $3,100 times
your tax rate which is 32% your your
case okay and so you saved
$1,000 in
taxes if you
itemized so here's how this works your
husband is
suggesting
absurdly that you send the government
$3,100 or you send the mortgage company
$3,100 to keep from sending the
government $11,000
you're trading dollarss for
quarters dumb
trade so always pay off your mortgage
never keep it for the tax deduction if
you send somebody $10,000 to keep from
sending the government
$33,000 by definition that's
mathematically
stupid and then I call myself
sophisticated because I didn't pay off
my mortgage because I had the tax
deduction but I don't even take the text
deduction cuz I'm not even one of the
people that itemized and I just didn't
even know that that's most people with
this opinion around the Thanksgiving
table they're just absolutely do not
know how to do math and they don't know
the reality of the situation now worse
than that worse than your broke
brother-in-law telling you this at
Thanksgiving you're silly Dave Ramsey
doesn't worse than him the one that
pisses me off to no end are people that
do taxes for a living and they tell the
small business person or they tell you
to not pay off your
mortgage because you'll lose the tax
deduction or to run your expenses up on
things you don't need to buy you need to
spend some money by the end of the year
otherwise you're going to get taxes well
that is
asinine it's
ridiculous you own a a hair care place
and you spend 10,000 bucks you don't
need to spend because your tax preparer
is a who told you to do that
that's
dumb let me help you you got two words
for these people that give you that
advice you're fired the taex right off
it's like the shits Creek uh episode
where he's like well just it's it's a
write off and he's like yeah but who's
writing it off he's like I don't know
the write- off people it just gets
written off it's like this like mystical
idea of the tax write off like it is
like a it justifies all my stupidity
it's like I don't know it's a tax write
off it's a write off toay know the write
off people that's great I haven't seen
that episode so listen if your tax
person is telling you to run up your
expenses or to not pay off debt because
you're getting a tax deduction they're
telling you to trade dollars for
quarters you don't need someone that
can't add to in your taxes you need new
tax people go to ramseys solutions.com
and get with one of our tax people they
do not make this mistake believe me we
would they would not have a Ramsey
trusted sign on their door if they made
this mistake cuz they wouldn't be
trusted by me cuz they don't trust
people that can't do math so there you
go that's what we're doing here so guys
whatever you do don't fall for the tax
deduction myth and the irony of ironies
is all of these people discussing it
91% don't
itemize in America today that's
everybody y'all I mean so because you
because for majority of people you get a
better deal if you just take the
standard deduction anyways that's what I
mean that's why you don't they don't
need you don't need to yeah your stupid
actually under under the Trump tax code
in his last Administration he ran the
standard deduction way up yeah you get
an automatic deduction just because you
breathe Y and your real deductions don't
add up to that so you're better off to
take the big one right right ex the
breathing deduction yes from the write
off people that's right from from
them but they're there that's the
standard deduction has changed the game
and it's made the tax filings very easy
and that's probably up more in the last
what 10 years in the last what 10 years
this used to 15 years ago if I was
talking about this it have been 70% cuz
this was a main point back in the day at
our live events back in 20 you know 2004
y this was a big discussion and now it's
not you don't hear it as much anymore
because the standard deduction was
raised and the number of people there
that that don't itemize is so few yes
it's it's it was absurd back then
because you're trading dollars for
quarters and we used to cover it in the
live events in those older Arena events
that's right that's right and it was
absurd back then it's just as absurd now
for the same reason but it's doubly
absurd because it really doesn't apply
to hardly anybody anymore Y and I'll bet
you money Jamie doesn't itemize y 91%
does and so it doesn't even come up so
her husband's arguing a a theory that
he's not even doing uh and then if he
was doing it he's trading dollars for
quarters yes so don't trade dollars for
quarters pay off your mortgage and the
other the other argument for not paying
off the mortgage is I can make more in
the market versus what I'm paying in
interest yeah said no millionaires ever
right the millionaires that we the
10,000 millionaires that we studied none
of them precisely zero said I became a
millionaire by not paying off my house
and investing the difference into the
market none of them say that it's always
broke people that say this stuff the
broke people that don't want to lean in
and do the SMART long-term Financial
plays like getting your home paid off y
so yeah it's it's it's asinine you guys
the data does not back it up the math
does not back it up pay off your house
people when you get to baby step 6
finish the baby steps and pay it off and
don't deal with tax people that can't
add please God brought to you by the
Ramsey Network app download today to go
further with ramsy
