There’s an aspect of our conscious understanding that exceeds computational limits. The quality of human understanding, the examination and reflection of our own thoughts, emotions, and experiences when the mind turns inward to examine its own states, aren’t bound by any rule and can’t be calculated. They’re beyond computation. These are defining features of human consciousness.
A quantum theory of consciousness, proposed by Nobel laureate Sir Roger Penrose, tries to explain how quantum processes in the brain might lead to the emergence of conscious experience.
Chapters: 00:00 Intro 00:25 Introspection 04:24 Computational VS Non-Computational 09:16 Quantum Consciousness 12:56 Orch OR Theory 15:30 Retroactivity 17:43 Microtubules 20:40 Gravity 22:19 Skepticism 24:28 Further Analysis 30:46 Credits
Imagine you're engaged in a game. After a while, you might take a step back and reflect on the
rules in the game that you have to follow, or why you're participating in this game in the first
place. This self-reflection process aligns with a sense of truth and points to a deeper level of
understanding. When you step back and thinking about your own thought processes, you're no
longer bound by the rules in the game. But what causes you to think in such a way? This reflection
touches on a fundamental question. Why do conscious beings seem to have the ability to step back and
contemplate? How do you imagine things beyond the game or anything similar in daily life that
follows certain rules? The answer lies in our grasp and awareness of what that game really is.
Understand the rules themselves. This quality of understanding, the examination and reflection of
our own experiences is called introspection. It's not bound by any rule and cannot be calculated.
It's beyond computation. It's the defining feature of human consciousness. It's the ability of a
to reflect on its own thoughts, emotions and experiences. It involves a self-reflective
process where the mind turns inward to examine its own states. Consciousness is not just the
result of complex computations performed by the brain, but rather involves processes that
goes beyond traditional algorithmic computations following predefined set of rules, procedures
or calculations. And introspection plays a crucial role in illustrating that non-computational aspect.
This ability to step back and consider one's own mental processes is the signature of human
consciousness. It's a deeply subjective experience that involves awareness not just of the physical
world, but of one's internal mental state. Traditional computers which operate on fixed
rules and algorithms lack the ability to introspect. They cannot step outside their
programming to reflect on or alter their own operations in a meaningful way. Human introspection
allows us to grasp truths and understand concepts that go beyond following rules. For example,
when a mathematician grasps a new theorem, they're not just following a set of rules.
They're engaging in a form of understanding that involves creativity and insight,
processes that are believed to be non-computational in nature. In the game example,
understanding why the rules give us truth enables us to surpass or go beyond the rules themselves.
This understanding, whatever it is, somehow involves consciousness. The game player can't
comprehend the game if it's unaware of its existence. This is the quality of conscious
experience. Consciousness can go beyond any rules because it exists beyond them.
Computational and non-computational are two broad views about the nature of consciousness,
how it comes into being, and how it can be understood. Consciousness, based on computational
theory, can be explained in terms of computational processes in the brain. The brain does information
processing analogous to a computer, and consciousness emerges from these computing
mechanisms. This means that consciousness might be understood and replicated through
computational models. Non-computational theory says that consciousness can't be fully explained
or replicated through computational processes alone. The theory says that there are aspects of
consciousness, like subjective experience, that can't be captured by computational models.
Consciousness might arise from non-computational processes or it involves elements that are beyond
the scope of computation. Going back to math example, the ability to understand allows
mathematicians to go beyond any specific set of rules they use for proving mathematical concepts.
Artists create innovative and original works that go beyond conventional techniques and rules,
doing art with their intuition and inspiration rather than predefined algorithms. Human
consciousness, particularly in areas like mathematical understanding, goes beyond
algorithmic processing. While a computer follows a set of predefined rules to solve mathematical
problems, a human mathematician can often see the truth of a concept intuitively without relying
strictly on step-by-step computational procedures. This ability to grasp the essence of a mathematical
idea or to understand the relationships between concepts, it's not something that can be easily
replicated by a machine following fixed algorithms. People often make complicated
ethical decisions that cannot be reduced to a simple set of computational rules.
Imagine a moral system, a set of principles or rules that guide what is considered right or wrong
in every possible situation. This system is intended to provide clear moral judgments for
any ethical dilemma. Now imagine a moral dilemma that the ethical system struggles to resolve.
The classic trolley problem is a good example of this, where a trolley is headed toward five
people on the tracks, but you have the option to divert it to another track where it will only
hit one person. The system might have rules like, it's always wrong to kill an innocent person,
but also, it's always right to minimize harm. The problem arises when these principles conflict.
Should you act to save five by sacrificing one, or avoid acting altogether to avoid directly
causing harm? This moral system may be internally consistent, covering most situations, but in
certain complex dilemmas it might reach a point where it cannot provide a clear or definitive
answer. There may be situations where no action seems morally justified, or where different moral
principles lead to contradictory conclusions. These situations are true but unprovable statements,
ethical truths, or judgments that the system recognizes but can't resolve within its own rules.
The ethical system is incomplete because it can't provide the moral resolution to every
possible dilemma. So the non-computational nature of consciousness, a form of understanding that
involves insight, creativity, and intuitive grasp of truth, can't be fully explained by
computational models. The comprehension that game players, mathematicians, or artists hold
doesn't follow or abide by the rules. It goes beyond them. What is it about consciousness
that grants this advantage? There's something more here. What this shows is that there might be more
to uncover about the nature of consciousness and its role in our understanding of the world.
Seems like there's a gap in the existing theories. If consciousness or understanding is not
computational, what is it then? Our ability to think introspectively points to a unique aspect
of consciousness that cannot be fully explained by classical physics or traditional computational
models, and might have a deeper quantum mechanical basis. Classical physics deals with the laws of
motion and energy that we can observe in everyday life. Quantum physics explores the strange
behaviors of subatomic particles, where things can be in multiple states at once and can act like
both particles and waves. Essentially, while classical physics explains the world we see,
quantum physics reveals a more complex and often counterintuitive underlying reality.
Internal conscious experience could be a kind of quantum reality. The brain cell or neural
activities, especially those related to consciousness, may involve some quantum effects.
These effects could play a role in explaining the mind's ability to process information,
perceive the world, and generate conscious experiences. The best way to perceive this
is to imagine a cloud representing a space where you might find an elementary particle,
like an electron. The cloud demonstrates how electron can be in many places at once.
But there are certain areas where it's more likely to be found, like the wider areas,
and areas where it's less probable to be found, like the darker areas. It's impossible to predict
the exact outcome of any measurement. What quantum mechanics has to offer are probabilities.
Until a measurement is made, the system is not in a definite state,
but rather exists in a superposition of all possible states. This superposition is described
by a mathematical description called a wave function. It contains all the information
about electron's state, including its position, momentum, and other properties.
After the measurement, the particle seems to end up in one fixed state,
a quantum phenomenon known as the collapse of the wave function, or the reduction of the state.
In the context of classical physics that describes the world in the macroscopic scale of humans,
planets, and galaxies, we perceive objects as singular entities rather than multiple
possibilities simultaneously because of the wave function collapse. When observed with the naked
eye, objects appear as definite singular entities. The collapsing process is fundamentally random,
but influenced by probabilities. This is what Einstein famously compared to God playing dice
to determine what turns out to be real and what we observe in our classical world. On one side,
we have the superposition of a particle, the quantum realm. On the other, there's the familiar
classical reality, where things exist in a single definite state. Wave function collapse is like a
bridge connecting the realms of quantum and classical realities. This is the relationship
between quantum and classical physics. The question of what triggers the collapse of a state's wave
function stays open in quantum physics, the measurement problem in quantum mechanics.
It's been argued that consciousness impacts quantum effects, that it somehow influences
quantum particles, a phenomenon known as the observer effect. The speculation is that consciousness
itself might play a role in the wave function collapse. The act of conscious observation,
rather than any physical interaction or measurement, might be what causes the
There's an alternative view that's the exact opposite of the observer effect.
Consciousness depends on the wave function collapse. The wave function collapse is not
caused by the conscious observer. Rather, it's an inherent process related to the nature of
consciousness. It's not a conscious observer that causes the reduction. Rather, the state itself
reduces in some way, transitioning from a superposition of possibilities to a specific
outcome. When this occurs, an element of proto-consciousness comes into play.
Proto-consciousness is the fundamental building block from which actual consciousness forms. It
can be thought of as a basic form of awareness or potential consciousness that emerges during the
The act of selecting an outcome might involve some level of proto-conscious awareness,
which then lays the groundwork for the emergence of actual consciousness.
This is what's known as ORQ-OR, short for Orchestrated Objective Reduction.
Consciousness in this theory is a quantum effect that emerges at the quantum scale.
It's the physical mechanism necessary for consciousness to occur. It arises from quantum
computations in the brain, which could influence how wave function collapses in a way that is
orchestrated or organized. Hence the name Orchestrated Objective Reduction.
Objective means that it's a physical process. Reduction stands for the wave function collapse.
Objective reduction is the part that we experience. The orchestrated is the most mysterious part.
How does the brain coordinate different individual processes to form a coherent
conscious experience? At the moment of consciousness, the emergence of the
chosen fixed reality is seen as if it has always been the case, even though it's only
defined or realized at the moment of collapse. It's as if the collapse of the wave function
reaches back in time to determine the state of reality, even though according to quantum
mechanics, the state of reality was uncertain or in a superposition of states before the collapse.
This mysterious phenomenon is known as retroactivity. We may on some level be
Experiments demonstrate that the collapse instantaneously reduces multiple quantum states.
Even the concepts of before and after could be nonsensical in quantum reality due to different
phenomena, including superposition, particles existing in multiple states simultaneously
which complicates the notion of a clear sequence of events.
Particles instantaneously connected regardless of distance. Another quantum fact known as
entanglement that challenges our classical understanding of causality and timing.
The fact that time may not be a fundamental component of reality in the way we typically
understand it. Before a decision is made between let's say two possible actions, the brain can
exist in a quantum superposition where those two actions are simultaneously present. This occurs
at an earlier stage in the brain's processing. When you make a decision, it retroactively
eliminates, meaning jumps back and overwrites multiple quantum possibilities, creating the
impression that there was always only one definitive choice. Classical fixed reality
emerges retroactively from the collapse of the quantum wave function.
Superpositions based on Orkovar are coordinated by protein filaments within brain cells or neurons
known as microtubules. These orchestrated vibrations, meaning variations in the state
of the microtubules, entangle together, process information, and terminate in the collapse of the
wave function, leading to a series of Orkovar moments. The process is theorized to give rise
to moments of conscious insight and deeper understanding, setting human consciousness
apart from other forms of information processing. The non-computable or non-algorithmic moment in
brain, the wave function collapse, reduces the superposition of many states into one fixed state,
the measuring process in quantum mechanics. That's when conscious awareness, the orchestrated
conscious experience within the brain, kicks in. This reduction or collapse is thought to
orchestrate cognitive functions in a way that allows for the rich subjective experience of
self-reflection and awareness. For any quantum particle to maintain its superposition,
quantum coherence needs to be maintained. Any interaction with the environment causes decoherence,
which causes the superposition to collapse. Many scientists argue that the brain's warm
and wet environment makes it unlikely for quantum states to influence neural activity,
because quantum coherence typically requires highly isolated and cold environments. The
symmetrical structure of neuron microtubules could effectively preserve quantum coherence,
preventing it from leaking into the surrounding environment. In the Orkovar framework,
introspection could be seen as a direct manifestation of quantum processes.
When we introspect, meaning thinking about our own thoughts and feelings, we might be accessing
deeper levels of consciousness that are influenced by quantum states. This process is inherently
non-computational, because it involves the reduction of quantum states that can't be
simulated or predicted by classical algorithms. The ability to introspect is linked to human
creativity and the ability to understand complex concepts. It's not just about processing
information or running computations. It's about experiencing awareness in a way that
involves quantum-level phenomena, which are beyond the scope of conventional computational
theories of mind. There's an objective phenomenon that causes the wave function to collapse.
One speculation? Gravity. Gravity is a key factor in classical physics that's absent from quantum
mechanics. Each state in quantum superposition may sense the others through their gravitational
interactions. It's as if this attraction makes the object measuring itself, and the act of
measurement triggers the collapse. In the context of classical physics or Einstein's general
relativity, a superposition of localities deforms the fabric of spacetime in multiple ways at once,
a situation that general relativity cannot account for. This has been illustrated as a clash,
in which quantum mechanics will bend before general relativity does. A gravitational field
can't exist in a quantum superposition, and that results in the collapse of the particle's
wave function. Gravity-induced wave function collapse reverses time, retroactively erasing
possible quantum realities in less than a second. This backward elimination of realities gives the
illusion that only one fixed classical reality has ever existed. This reflects the influence
of gravity on quantum mechanics. Each gravity-induced collapse generates a small spike of
proto-consciousness. Orkoar has been met with skepticism from the scientific community due to
its departure from mainstream neuroscience and quantum physics, and the lack of direct empirical
evidence. The theory begins with the assertion that consciousness is not a product of computation,
and that extends beyond the insights provided by neuroscience, biology, or physics. Critiques
argue that while the theory is intriguing, it needs more research to demonstrate how
those quantum processes could give rise to the introspective capabilities observed in human
consciousness. Some researchers believe that introspection can be explained by more traditional
neurological processes without invoking quantum mechanics. They argue that complex neural
networks could, in theory, simulate introspective experiences, even if they do so in a computationally
intensive way. The majority of scientists view quantum mechanics as irrelevant to our understanding
of brain function. Critiques argue that linking strange phenomena in quantum mechanics to
consciousness lacks sufficient scientific support. Proponents of Orkoar, on the other hand, believe
that measuring the wave function collapse is the most important experiment anybody should be
working on, and yet there aren't many. The good news is Orkoar is falsifiable. There are three
primary hypotheses for experimental testing. 1. Gravity causes the collapse of the wave function,
a core aspect of the theory, implying that gravitational effects play a role in quantum
state reduction. 2. The collapse includes retroactivity, meaning the effects of the collapse
may influence past states, a more speculative element of the theory. And 3. Consciousness
emerges from this process, the fundamental claim of the theory, suggesting that consciousness is
a product of these quantum processes. Orkoar invites objective experimentation and observation
from various scientific disciplines, including neuroscience, quantum mechanics, and theoretical
physics, like examining whether microtubules indeed demonstrate the predicted quantum behavior
under specific conditions, or if altering microtubule function affects consciousness
in expected ways. If we go back to the wide spectrum of theories reviewed in previous episodes,
ranging from purely physical to more metaphysical, the speculation could be that Orkoar
belongs under the category of emergentism, the idea that consciousness arises as a complex
phenomenon from simpler processes in the brain, a case in which consciousness is not a fundamental
property or substance, but rather a result of the interaction and organization of simpler,
non-conscious elements. But that's not the right category. Orkoar offers a specific mechanism for
consciousness that involves quantum processes in the brain's microtubules. While Orkoar does
suggest that consciousness emerges from the complexity of quantum processes in the brain,
it does so in a way that implies a fundamental role for these processes which are not just
emergent properties of simpler components, but rather intrinsic aspects of how consciousness
arises. This distinction implies that although Orkoar is in line with non-reductive physicalism,
the idea that consciousness is fully dependent on and arises from physical processes in the brain,
it can't be completely reduced to or fully explained by these physical processes.
There's an aspect of our conscious understanding that exceeds computational limits.
Given that all physical theories are computational, there must be a process in the reduction of
quantum states that leads to a non-computational understanding. Something fundamental is missing,
the part of the theory that can't be put on a computer. The gap might not be about how we
understand quantum mechanics, but rather in the theory itself. How could the collapse of
the wave function caused by gravity result in non-computational consciousness? It seems like
consciousness goes beyond the current quantum theory. According to the creator of Orkoar,
the Nobel laureate Sir Roger Penrose, quantum mechanics might need modification. It has to
make room for understanding. So essentially, as Penrose claims, we need a new scientific
discipline that hasn't yet been established. We could be far from grasping the nature of what is
happening, mainly because we lack a complete understanding of the physics involved. So will
we ever develop the ultimate theory of consciousness? We might, but according to Penrose,
we're far from achieving that. Assuming this is the right approach, consciousness should be
included in physical theories, and those theories might be able to offer an explanation for what
consciousness really is. Non-physicalists, the group that see consciousness as metaphysical,
fail to provide convincing arguments regarding the non-physical elements of consciousness.
We have no solid basis for dismissing physicalism, the philosophical theory that
claims everything is ultimately physical in nature. It remains the only theory that offers
some hope in our understanding of consciousness and its nature. Our experiences and consciousness,
according to physicalists, are not separate from the material world. They're part of the
same fabric of reality, deeply rooted in the physical universe. The laws of physics
seem nonsensical at subatomic level, where the smallest particles follow different principles,
quantum mechanics, than those governing the world around us, classical physics,
or general relativity. This gap creates a division between two distinct forms of reality.
The search for the theory of everything continues. A framework famously known as
quantum gravity that will eventually integrate gravity into quantum mechanics and hopefully
connect those two theories, quantum mechanics of the microscopic and general relativity of
macroscopic world, into a single unified theory. An endeavor that started with Einstein and still
continues to this day. The physical process linking these two realities might have the
potential to eventually reveal insights into the mystery of consciousness.