I believe the Chinese Communist Party's (CCP) downfall is imminent due to two recent developments: young Chinese are organizing to overthrow the CCP, and businesses are engaging in quiet resistance, defying the government. Meanwhile, local governments have lost their ability to govern, and the top leadership is trapped in a delicate yet fragile position.
1. Chinese Students’ Movement to Overthrow the CCP 2. How the Ministry of Public security handles it.
3. Local Governments Are Dysfunctional
4. Xi Jinping Is Trapped With No Way Out
Hi, everyone. Welcome to Ladies World Talk.
Happy Sunday.
Well, first of all, I want to thank you for
doing my survey yesterday.
When I said I was tied up, some people literally thought that I was physically
tied up. They were concerned about my my safety.
I thought that was that was quite, quite funny.
I'm well. I was just a little busy with other things.
All right. It feels great to do a live stream on Sunday morning.
It really feels great. I'm more energetic in the mornings.
All right. Let's get started. What a topic we have picked for ourselves.
Based on the survey, you guys are really interested in what's happening in China
in terms of social movements.
So so we're going to answer the question.
So the question is why the CCP downfall is imminent.
All the answers are one student revolt and two business resistance.
I said in my post yesterday that I really get the sense that the CCP regime won't
be around for a long time because.
A few transformative events have occurred.
The first is that in the past week, not even past weeks, in the past
week, Chinese students are getting organized to send a message.
Which is that it's time to end the CCP regime.
Secondly, local governments, bad policies have given people the chance to
effectively disable their government.
And this is also unprecedented.
Both events indicate the beginning of the CCP's downfall.
So today, I'll first talk about the Chinese students movement to overthrow
the CCP and and then the CCP's response.
And then I'll talk about.
Why I say.
The local governments are being disabled by the people, and then I'll give you an
update on Xi Jinping's status in the power struggle, because we've been saying
that his power has been weakened.
So many of you want to know where he stands or what's what's happening in the
leadership compound in Zhongnanhai.
So that's the program today.
All right, let's get started.
Now, for the for the past two years, protests over back pay, failed
investments or undelivered real estate have become a daily occurrence across
China. Every day, you're going to see protests of various scale
breaking, breaking out in China.
Most of these protests have been financial, economic in nature.
However, things have shifted in the last week as Chinese students have begun
protesting with a clear political message.
Now, let's revisit what has happened in the last week.
So on November 16, four desperate students from the Wuxi Institute of Arts and
Technology went on a killing spree.
Some people call it the Wuxi massacre.
The students protested their school for coercing them to work in a sweatshop for
16 days a week and 30 days consecutively, and also maliciously withholding their
diploma if they don't cooperate.
And one of the students wrote a letter explaining their motives and said that
he's willing to sacrifice himself to raise awareness of labor issues.
I covered this topic in my Thursday's program.
So if you want to get the details of what happened in Wuxi, watch my program on
Thursday, which is the 21st of November.
Now, his message, the students' message has a reverberating effect among students
and laborers in other areas.
Handwritten flyers titled like a letter to the people of the nation calling for
the overthrow of Chinese Communist Party have been widely distributed in densely
populated labor markets in southern China around the Guangdong area.
So I have images, some images of them for you.
So you have seen these handwritten messages, like for this one, a letter to
the people of China.
So they have been showing up in southern China.
And it was reported that vocational school students in Guangzhou organized
themselves.
It started from them.
They organized themselves in dormitories and hand wrote these flyers and
distribute them.
Now, vocational school, the school, the Wuxi Institute of Arts and Technology
was a vocational school years ago, and I think it has been elevated to it's still
a vocational school.
It teaches people how to make, I mean, that Wuxi school teaches people how to
make the Yixing, the Chinese clay pot.
And so it was a school that focused on making these art crafts.
So the students in the vocational schools in southern China reacted to that mass
killing.
So they put out these flyers, handwritten flyers in Guangzhou and some other
regions.
Now, the flyers openly state that commemorating the victims of the Wuxi
massacre means overthrowing the system that indirectly caused their death.
The letters called on workers, students, and the people nationwide to take action
and urge the overthrow of the Communist Party.
And that's very direct.
They're not shying away from their message.
And according to a post on X, because these images are posted on Twitter, so
students who signed, they signed a letter as Guangzhou's social revolutionary or
revolutionaries, review that their vocational school students who have been
paying close attention to domestic mass killing incidents, they acknowledge that
Chinese society is not like a giant pressure cooker ready to explode.
And they said under the CCP's rule, no one can escape.
And so here's what they wrote.
They said, quote, we vocational school students are at the bottom of the bottom
on the fringes of society.
We are the expendable workforce, the fuel for factories, and subjects of the
CCP's enduring endless sufferings.
And they said, and continue to say, the regime used to exploit us in the name of
communist ideology, but in reality, it was for the enrichment of its bureaucrats.
Now, it is promoting bureaucratic capitalism.
And then it calls, it says, fellow citizens, it's time for us to rise up and resist.
And the students, that's what the students wrote.
And so these students, think about it, they are about to enter factories, right?
I mean, they are, after graduation, they're going to work in these workshops or craft
shops to make these craft.
I mean, these, yeah, these, whatever they're making, potteries or ceramics.
So they're concerned about their well-being, you know, or their work
condition at those workshops after learning what the students in Wuxi, you
know, went through.
And they've all, these students have also heard from their senior class, you know,
members of their senior classes about the work conditions.
And they, what they've heard is they're as bad as the condition in Wuxi.
So what, and then, so they proclaimed, they said the sweatshops in the Pearl
River Delta are a global human rights disgrace, right?
We know the Pearl River Delta is the area in Guangzhou where 20% of China's
export is based in.
So they say the sweatshops in the Pearl River Delta are a global human rights
disgrace.
And the students said, we decided not to become the next killers and certainly not
to be slaves of the government.
So we organized ourselves in the dormitories to write and distribute flyers
and the emotions were high.
And they concluded with a call to action, join forces to overthrow the Communist
Party and build a new life.
Now what's shocking is that these handwritten flyers, that calling for the
overthrow of the Communist Party has appeared not just on school campus or
campuses, but also appeared in labor markets across Southern China.
And they went on to say, the Chinese people must stand up today, speak your
truth, don't let others speak for you anymore.
One flyer declared and included with the slogans, long live the people, long live
the workers, down with the Communist Party, down with the government-protected
capitalists.
Now this movement has spread to inner provinces.
Chongqing high school students were inspired and took action too.
They also distributed these handwritten flyers, which can be seen in dormitory
and spots, you know, outside, right?
And the high school students in Chongqing explained that they avoided using
printers so that they won't be tracked.
They handwrote the posters with the left hands so that the handwritings cannot be
traced.
And the students are very strategic about their move.
So when asked, why not, you know, why not organize a white paper style protest?
Let me come back.
So, you know, people ask them, why don't you organize a white paper movement type
of protest?
And these students responded, they said, no, in the current semi-closed school
environment, distributing flyers and small group activities or publicity are
more effective than holding large assemblies.
And they emphasized, they said, we hope people don't underestimate our momentum.
And they said, we won't become isolated warriors calling for more people to stand
up.
And they said, success doesn't have to come from us, but we must raise our voices
And finally, they declared, we're not afraid of the enemy's threats.
Guess who the enemy is?
And they said, we want more domestic and international advocates for democracy to
hear us.
I mean, I was amazed by how clearheaded these students are.
I mean, these are high school students.
They're, what, 16-year-old, 15-year-old, 17-year-old.
But they're very clear, very strategic about what they want to accomplish.
And then listen to this one.
This says, stand up and refuse to be slaves.
We don't want reforms.
We want revolution.
You know, it really struck me about how clearheaded they are.
In the past, and every time when CCP ran into this type of opposition, or if they
sensed some kind of opposition like this, they will make some compromises by
promising reforms.
Every time, this is the trick CCP has used to fool the rest of us, I mean, the
rest of the world, by promising some liberty or some freedom and some reforms.
But the Chinese young people are very clear.
We don't want reforms.
We want revolution.
We complete, we want a complete revolution.
We don't want a modified version of the CCP.
No, and they're very clear about that.
I am very, very encouraged by what I saw.
So the flyer also commented on the recent rise of violence in public spaces.
And it says, in fact, the capitalist communist government, they call the Chinese
government, the capitalist communist government.
And they say, that government is the only undeniable culprit.
And this system is a machine that produces tragedies.
And the flyer calls for rekindling the insuviatum from the white paper movement
two years ago.
And it says, rebuild up the strength of solidarity, starting with ourselves.
So, now this is not the first time the Chinese citizens have called to end the
communist regime.
We heard it during the Foxconn employee walkout.
Remember two years ago?
In Zhengzhou, I think it was in November, about this time in 2022, there was a
massive employee walkout during the lockdowns in Zhengzhou at the Foxconn
facility.
And at the time, we've heard people shouting slogans, you know, down with the
CCP.
And also during the white paper movement, we've also heard, I think it was in
Shanghai, someone shouted, you know, end CCP.
However, this time, the call to end the Communist Party is significantly
different from the previous times, or from before.
And there are four differences.
The first one is, it's more organized.
It appears in the form of flyers and letters addressed to the nation, rather
than in isolated protests and demonstrations.
Number two, it's no longer anonymous, as the flyers are clearly signed, some by
China's revolutionaries, and others by Guangzhou's revolutionaries.
Right, so that's the second difference.
Third is, while chanting down with this Communist Party, the protesters directly
target the CCP's rule.
They explicitly point out that the CCP is the cause of all sufferings of the
Chinese people.
This is also a change.
Number four, they gave a clear call to action message, telling people to rise up
and resist, take action, change the world and build a new life.
We have not seen this before.
So there's clearly a change from all the protests we've seen, you know, in the
past.
So in short, this movement is more than an emotional outburst, arising from
massive suffering.
Instead, it's a conscious political action based on a clear vision.
So it's not difficult to imagine the shockwaves this has sent to Zhongnanhai,
the CCP leadership compound, and the terror it has instilled in the leaders.
One can only imagine the bigger political storm this might trigger in the near
future.
So now let me talk about CCP's response.
On November 14, this was before this kind of handwritten flyers appeared.
So on November 14, China's Ministry of Public Security held a press conference
warning people against the dissemination of gun making instructions online, stating
that such activities will result in criminal prosecution.
Because there have been people, you know, sharing information on how to make guns.
However, this announcement sparked widespread discussions.
It actually caused more people to discuss, you know, to have a discussion on the
subject.
And people definitely noted the regime's fear.
And so other people remarked, you know, water can carry a boat, but it can also
overturn it.
Right?
I mean, water is usually a metaphor meaning the people and the boat is the
government.
So they say water can carry a boat, but can also overturn it.
And some Chinese discussed online how to divide the tasks.
So they're like, okay, if you don't let us make guns, so we're going to divide the
tasks among people and each do a smaller part and then collaborate to make guns.
I mean, these discussions are certainly scary.
And then a week later on November 21st, I think that's after, I think that's after
these handwritten notes have appeared.
Wang Xiaohong, the minister of public security, hosted a video conference with
his subordinates across the country to address public security issues.
And according to the press release, his speech had several highlights.
I just summarize, I think there are five points.
Number one is he told the local police force across the country to take charge.
He told them, quote, to take the initiative, to assume responsibility, act
proactively and collaborate actively.
Now, you know, for those of us who, we know how to read these meeting minutes
because these jargon tells us that the local police force is not very actively
taking charge.
They are probably a little too laid back because they don't know how to handle it.
I mean, they're scared of themselves, too.
So that's why, you know, the minister has to emphasize, you guys need to take the
initiative to assume, to be responsible, to act proactively and to collaborate
actively. Well, there are a lot of active.
Yeah. So they mean they're very passive.
And the second point from his speech is he said to focus on two areas.
One, identifying and resolving conflicts and disputes.
And two, addressing and rectifying safety hazards.
Everything is about putting out fire, right?
Identify conflicts and disputes before they erupt and also addressing and
rectifying safety hazards.
Probably. You know, once you identify those
troublemakers, quote unquote troublemakers, and then you want to rectify them, I
don't know, lock them up.
That's what he's implying.
And third, thirdly, he said, fully take advantage of the new policing model that
integrates control mechanisms with big data to implement their action.
So this suggests that they will monitor people more closely using their
surveillance apparatus and big data.
Number four, he said he specifically mentioned a winter action.
There is, I think, a winter action.
Be organized.
And he also gave a time frame of the work he wants his his police force to
focus on this winter and next spring.
This suggests that they're not looking for the long term.
They must have felt the urgent threat.
They must feel the imminent threat.
And the urgent need to ensure stability in the next four to five months.
So so he's not talking about stability for the long term.
He did not mention any of that.
He mentioned, first of all, a winter action or winter task force, and then put
the focus on this winter and next spring.
That tells me they're really, they're really, they're really worried.
They worry about the short term.
Number five, he stressed the importance of adhering to the Fengqiao experience.
Fengqiao jinyan.
The Fengqiao experience is a strategy that Mao Zedong came up with in the early
1960s that centered on mobilizing the masses and strengthening the
dictatorship over class enemies.
Basically, it's calling the masses to spy on each other.
Okay, so based on one speech, I think the CCP feels very threatened by the
latest social development in China.
I think they realized the winter things were getting uglier, and the winter
will be very difficult.
So they're putting out all their efforts trying to get it under control in the
winter and possibly into the spring.
But I don't think the five tactics that Wang had spelled out will work because
people have already disabled local governments and also their functions.
Let me give you an example to explain why I say local governments have been
dysfunctional or have lost their control.
People who visited the southern city of Chaozhou in Guangdong province were
surprised to see the city in a quasi lockdown mode.
I actually have pictures.
Yeah, people were very surprised to see the city overnight are all closed.
And tourists who looked for restaurants to eat couldn't find them.
And you'd never imagine how it had happened.
Well, on November 20th, the municipal government issued a notice announcing a
citywide fire safety, environmental protection, and sanitary inspection.
The notice said that businesses deemed non-compliant were required to suspend
production or business temporarily, and violations would result in a fine of
50,000 yuan.
That's saying that if you're not compliant, your business would be shut
down, and you'll be fined 50,000 yuan.
Following the announcement, a large number of businesses and enterprises in
Chaozhou immediately closed their doors.
They want to avoid inspections.
Some said that 98% of the businesses were closed.
And not just the mom and pop shops, all businesses, including international
brands like McDonald's and KFC.
People say the situation is worse than the COVID lockdowns, because during COVID,
you at least have some supermarkets or some essential businesses open.
And they say it's worse than COVID.
And tourists and local people complained that they can't buy anything.
And this led to the city issuing an emergency notice the next day, demanding
businesses and shops not to deliberately close without a legitimate reason, or
refuse inspections.
Despite this, by the evening of November 21st, right, that's the next day of the
day, because the original notice came out on the 20th.
So the 21st, they issued another notice.
But that evening, and also the morning of November 22nd, 90% of the shops in
Chaozhou's historic district remained closed.
They continued to refuse, continuing to refuse inspections.
So on November 22nd, the businesses in Chaozhou received another notice stating
that they were not allowed to arbitrarily close or suspend operations.
Deliberately closing business to avoid inspections would still result in
inspections being conducted as usual.
It almost sounds like the inspectors would, what, just open the door?
I mean, if you close, they're going to just force you to open your door and do
the inspection.
I don't know what would happen.
They say, if you remain closed, we're still going to do our inspection.
And then the government would conduct even more thorough and stringent inspections
with more severe penalties for violations.
So they basically intimidate the business.
Like, if you remain closed, we're going to do more inspections on you and give
you a bigger fine.
Now, here's the situation.
With the central government funding being reduced, local governments have been
granted more power to figure out solutions on their own, to look for more
money.
So basically, the implication is clear.
The central government basically has been telling the local governments, make
your own way forward, even if it means fighting tooth and nail.
So increased inspections and fines have been a revenue-making business for local
governments.
Exorbitant fines have become increasingly common.
So, for example, I think the most scandalous scandal was an elderly peasant
who made 14 yuan from selling substandard celeries in the market, received two
separate fines totaling 100,000 yuan.
From the local market regulatory authorities, he made 14 yuan for selling bad
celeries, but he was fined 100,000 yuan.
I don't think this man has 100,000 yuan.
But that's the kind of, this kind of, you know, quote unquote, regulatory
supervisions have been going on in the commercial space.
So that's why people reacted, right?
People reacted by closing down their business.
And people put on signs, people put on signs saying, business closed because I
had a fight with my wife.
People put on all kinds of excuses on the closing business notice.
And some said, it's a bad day for me because I fear ghosts, you know?
You know, like I almost say like I'm superstitious.
I fear it's not a good day for me to do business because I fear ghosts.
And then the next door business said, I closed my business because my neighbor
said that he fears ghosts, so do I.
So, I mean, people just put out these, you know, random notes or notes with
random excuses to explain why they closed the business.
But I think this trend is likely to spread across other cities in mainland
China, where the collapse of fiscal revenues is forcing local governments to
recoup their deficits by extracting wealth directly from local businesses.
But people will, that decision will effectively shut down the city overnight,
as we've seen in Chaozhou.
But if you really think about it, this is scary because one inspection notice
from the government has completely wiped out all commercial activities in the city.
What does that mean?
That means the local governments can't do anything, right?
They have already lost their power because people don't care.
I mean, in the old days, if people still want to make some money so they don't
want to shut down their business, they still want to make money so they remain
open, even though they don't like the government, you know, taking money from
them. But now it's so bad that they would rather not do any business than
having the government come in and take their money away through, you know, some
kind of a fake inspection.
So what can you do?
This is very similar to the random acts of violence.
When people are fearless, when people don't care, then that's that's that has
effectively disabled the government because the government can't do anything.
So now let's talk about the status of Xi Jinping's power.
We've discussed the signs that Xi Jinping's power has been weakened,
particularly his control over the Chinese military, right?
I did a number of programs on that.
We came up with a conclusion based on a number of facts.
One is that some of his close allies and loyal associates have been either
removed or demoted.
Some of the official jargons defining his supreme leadership status has
disappeared from official narratives such as the Xi Jinping thoughts.
That's officially removed.
The app to study Xi Jinping thoughts has been disabled.
So that's the second sign.
And then also his policies, we've witnessed again, 180 degree turn on his
policies, the abandonment of the wolf warrior diplomacy when it comes to
Western adversaries and also the sudden onset of economic stimulus programs.
And also things or jargons that weren't his favorite have returned.
To official narratives, things that he didn't like now have returned,
such as the expression, 民族集中制, which means a centralized or
collective democratic process.
It was a term used by Deng Xiaoping to mean a group of leaders sharing
power in decision-making.
That's not something that Xi Jinping is crazy about, but it has returned to
official narratives in CCP publicity.
But then we've also seen Xi Jinping attending AIPAC summit, G20 summit,
holding bilateral talks with other heads of state as if he's still in power.
He's still fulfilling his duty as the number one guy in China.
So what's the status of CCP power struggle?
Where does he stand?
Or how are we going to interpret everything in front of our eyes, right?
On one hand, his power seems to be reduced or weakened.
On the other hand, he's still doing what he used to do.
Here's my analysis of the situation.
There are a lot of people within the party who oppose Xi Jinping.
And whether it's due to this opposition or his health problems,
Xi Jinping has compromised.
So he has made, he has stepped back.
He has made significant compromises due to this opposition and possibly due to
his health problems, as we have witnessed in the above mentioned changes.
There's no doubt that Xi Jinping's power has been weakened.
However, no one who has challenged him has come up with a plan or a solution to
save the regime, nor does anyone who opposes him want to, wants to take on Xi
Jinping's role because they understand the damage has been done and it's
impossible to save the regime.
With everything that's happening now, I mean, it might've been different two
years from now, two years ago, even a year ago, but with everything that's
happening, with what's happening in the US, right, you have Donald Trump who's
elected and who's about to levy heavy tariffs on Chinese imports.
And with everything that's happening, no one is interested in his job.
The opponents, now think about it.
His opponents within the party are also people who have benefited from the
regime, so they're not necessarily interested in overthrowing the regime.
So the problem of the CCP has right now is that there's no one leader, including
Xi Jinping, knows how to fix the problems, how to get themselves out of the
predicament that they're in.
So with that said, Xi Jinping has remained in power.
Those who oppose him can't remove him because they don't have a solution and
they haven't found a replacement.
So that makes Xi Jinping still the most powerful leader, even though his power
has been reduced or weakened.
So I think the CCP leadership is currently stuck in a delicate and fragile
balance of impasse.
So somehow it has remained intact for the outside world, because they understand
if a drastic change is made, you know, whether you get rid of Xi Jinping, have
someone else, it may cause the downfall of the regime.
So they all fear that, even those who oppose Xi Jinping fear that.
So they're just not, they're still trying to figure out what to do.
Or maybe they're just, they don't have, they haven't found the solution yet.
So they're stuck in a, in this perfectly delicate, but delicate, fragile balance.
It's somehow it's balanced, but it's a form of impasse.
For now, he will continue to play the role as the leader while he and the rest of
the CCP leadership tries to figure out what to do.
And they will, and they will continue to fight.
While he, while they don't know, while they don't have a clue on what to do,
people, the Chinese people will become more and more clear about the future they
want, as we've seen in the, in the open letters written by those students, the
Chinese people will become more and more clear about the future they want and the
direction China should head into.
So if no one within the CCP has, has, has the vision or the courage to end the,
the, the CCP's rule and steer China into the, in the right direction, then the
regime will be overthrown sooner or later as the call to end the CCP is already
heard loud and clear, because if the, if the leadership doesn't have the guts and,
and the, and the vision to make a decision, then people will make the decision for
them, right?
And we just don't know how long that process will be.
But during the process, CCP's grip on Chinese society, their, their governance
will be gradually weakened, as we've seen in the, in the city of Chaozhou.
I mean, one order, one citywide inspection caused the entire city to, to stop
function, cause, you know, the, the suspension of all commercial activities
in the city.
Who could have imagined that?
So we just don't know how fast, how fast things will move.
I think this winter will be very difficult for people in Zhongnanhai.
Now, if you think about it, it's only been a week since the Wuxi campus
massacre happened, but within that week, so much has, has developed, right?
I mean, based on the notes, the handwritten notes I shared with you.
Meanwhile, the, there's an outburst, outburst of auto-related incidents in
China.
The first time we saw this car ramming incident was November 11th.
And yesterday, three car ramming incidents occurred.
The first was in Foshan city in Guangdong.
And then the second one was in Liaoning, in Liaoyang city in Liaoning province,
which is in the Northeast.
And the third is in, in Yangzhou, in Jiangsu province on the coast, on the
East coast.
And there are similar, similar incidents where, you know, people, you know, these
are random acts of violence where people want to take revenge against society.
I mean, it's, it's very sad.
But that's where the Chinese society is right now.
I think every week, I mean, I just couldn't believe how much has, has
developed in the past week and two.
So we should definitely keep a close eye on what comes after this.
I think the CCP's judgment is right.
They worry about this winter.
So if they can survive this winter, they probably can survive this crisis.
If not, things can develop very quickly for them.
All right.
That's all.
All right.
Wow.
It's a lot of information, but I feel very, very encouraged by the notes that the
students shared.
I mean, those are amazing.
All right.
Let me quickly go through the super chats.
Let's see.
Charles Womack.
How do I help the people of China to free themselves of the CCP?
Give them encouragement, share their information on X.
So if you're on Twitter, you will see there, the Chinese students use X as a
platform to send out their information.
So a lot of these information are shared on Twitter.
So you can help them spread the information if you can.
That would be a great form of support.
And thank you for your support to me.
All right.
Let's see.
All right.
Let's see.
Chinese want freedom?
Yes.
Okay.
All right.
Oh, here's a question.
I'm just...
Will Parker.
Question from Joe Nevin Inspiring.
But how does this end up any different from the Tiananmen Square massacre?
Oh, this is very different from Tiananmen Square massacre.
The Tiananmen Square pro-democracy movement in 1989 had large groups of
students and citizens gathering in public squares.
And usually it's in front of the government and demanding freedom.
And people gather, students went on a hunger strike in these public places.
And they don't leave.
So their presence threatened the regime and the regime used the excuse of public
order, or you're blocking public space.
We need to drive these students away.
And so the government had an excuse.
They said, well, you guys illegally occupy this public space and you shut down
traffic.
But this form, the white paper movement, and I think the Chinese have learned
from that lesson.
So they're very smart.
And so it's almost like a decentralized approach to public protest.
And in one of the notes that I read, and the students even saying that, we don't
even want to do what the white paper movement did.
They say the white paper movement was actually much smaller in scale when
compared with the 1989 student movement.
But it's still too big for the Chongqing high school students.
They want to do even smaller.
I think what they're focusing on is people's thinking.
Because if every Chinese is no longer afraid of the CCP and they speak up, and
they speak the truth, that will effectively disable the government.
So I think the students have learned from 1989.
So they're very smart about it.
They're very strategic and smart about it.
So they focus on these small scale publicity.
They call small scale publicity to put out these notes everywhere throughout
the city so people read about it.
Because the Chinese people are all thinking the same thing.
It's not like you're telling people something like so forward, so far
fetched, and the people don't know what you're talking about.
Everyone is thinking the same thing, but they cannot communicate amongst
themselves because the social media is monitored.
And so by using this handwritten flyers, then they're effectively organizing
people through their thinking, through their mindset, and that's empowering
people, that's empowering people without a significant form of organization.
And you can't even stop people.
How are you going to stop people from just writing some handwritten notes
and put it up on a tree or on a billboard?
Anyone can do that.
Anyone can do that, and anyone can do that at anywhere.
And the government is not able to stop people.
Because if you start doing print shop, if you start doing printing, then that's
more of an organized activity, and they can ask the print shop to monitor you.
So the fact that it's handwritten notes, anyone can do it.
They can't stop you.
So this is more threatening.
Actually, this is more threatening than the 1989 student movement.
Mint creative gifts and ideas.
If CCP collapses, do you think those countries whose governments, such as
Singapore, who is actively acting like CCP propagandists, will they go down with them?
I don't think so.
What I've learned is people in today's political climate switch sides so fast.
I have talked to people.
About 20 years ago, or even maybe 10 years ago, I asked some die-hard CCP loyalists.
And I asked them this question.
I said, what if CCP is put on trial one day?
What are you going to do?
And they said, oh, that's not a problem.
I'll just switch to the other side and start condemning the CCP.
People are so practical today.
I find it hard.
People, I mean, we've seen people on the left who all of a sudden can switch to the
right or at least switch to the middle overnight.
So it's almost like publicity.
I mean, I think the profession of publicity, public relations or publicity, it used to
be a profession that I'm proud of because I used to be in public.
But now I'm a little ashamed of what we do, you know, people in PR, because it's
like you could just adopt a completely different set of a narrative overnight as
if nothing matters, like what you really, what you feel strongly in your heart does
not matter.
And so I do not think these governments will feel anything.
If CCP goes down, they will join the side to say, yeah, let's condemn CCP.
Let's expose what the CCP has done to harm all of us.
That's what happened to those countries.
If someone who if someone who actually truly believes that the CCP is good, they
actually truly believe that and actually follow CCP all the way to its grave.
Then I'm just I'm saying that, I mean, I'm amazed by their stupidity, but at least
they're true to how they feel.
You know, they're they're they're they're they're true to their to their thinking,
to their feeling, although that thinking is is nonsensical.
But I don't expect these people will will will defend CCP in any way.
No, they will not.
They will jump the ship the last minute before it sinks.
Trust me, we've seen that.
All right.
Let me see.
Questions, any questions?
Wow, this is a lot of great discussions here.
I just don't see any.
Oh, there's a question.
Will Parker is helping me gather gathering questions.
Question from N544 Anon.
Why are they saying Elon Musk has a small government in China?
I did a program on the relations between Elon Musk and the Chinese government.
It was, I think, a week ago, Tuesday on Tuesday.
And and I think that I was surprised by the lack of views on that program.
You should you should take a look at if you want to understand the relationship
between Elon Musk and the Chinese government, take a look at that program.
It's very it's very in-depth.
I covered so much, so much points in that program.
Someone asked me if I was tired after that program.
I told them, yes, I was exhausted.
So that was last Tuesday, November the 19th.
Yeah, take a look at that program.
All right, let's see.
Alan Mandel, you previously said international media are in Beijing.
I noticed Bloomberg on X reports China.
News in a neutral or most positive framework.
Would the U.S. media face retribution if CCP falls?
Very good question.
I think I think some of the U.S.
media, particularly the ones that have clearly done the dirty work for the CCP,
will be will will face retribution once CCP falls.
I think Chinese people will will not let them go.
You know, media like The New York Times.
I mean, come on.
The New York The New York Times is like.
Is, you know, is doing the dirty work.
I mean, New York, the fact that New York Times is allowed its website,
that its Chinese website is allowed in China or parts of it is allowed in China
smells fishy, you know, to me.
That means they have colluded with the CCP.
Otherwise, how could they allowed the Chinese edition of New York Times in China?
Bloomberg, all Western media that are allowed in China
have to compromise, have to call out to the CCP.
Otherwise, they will be kicked out.
Grandma, Jim, is that grandma or grandpa, Jim?
Sorry, grandpa.
Do average Chinese people know how much better life is for people in Taiwan?
Some do and some don't.
Yeah.
Some happy freight to walk the Elon Musk program was very good.
Thanks. OK, thank you.
Thank you for noticing that.
Will Parker comment from Crypto Nobody.
I have in-laws living in China.
They have barely make ends meet.
Yes, it reminds me of the fall of the USSR.
Well, thank you.
I'll take a few more questions.
John Johns.
What countermeasures will the CCP do to prevent this trend you are describing?
They would just be more they're just doing everything they can,
like what the the minister of public security said.
Just. They're going, you know, really hardcore to to put everyone
they're trying to, you know, identify all the troublemakers using
A.I. and big data to identify all the troublemakers before they become.
And they're doing these grassroots home visits to identify those people
who don't have family, don't have a spouse, don't have children,
who don't have income or people who are unhappy about their relationship,
unhappy about their job.
They're trying to use grassroots
staff to identify those people
and probably register them in their big day in their database
and then monitor their activities,
because everyone use like these social apps like WeChat.
So everything they do.
Your life, their life is transparent to the government,
so the government can watch them 24 seven.
And they hope hopefully they want to use this to prevent
to identify people before they strike.
That's what they're doing.
Alan Mandel, well, thank you for the support.
Hi, thank you for providing the first and second most insightful program.
My students of critical thinking appreciate it, too.
Oh, thank you. Thank you, Alan.
Thank you, Alan. OK, that's all. That's all.
I'll take one more question.
Semtex86, how much power does India have over China?
They export a lot of food to China.
Then why does China antagonize them so much?
Well, the two sides have reached some kind of agreement
over the border disputes.
I remember the CCP has realized its crisis.
So it has tried to.
I don't think India is what China,
what the CCP is most concerned about at this point.
All right, so I'll end it here.
I wish everyone a great weekend and I'll see you next week.
Thank you for joining me.
And thank you all to those who who supported me financially.
Thank you. All right. Bye.