Future of health care lies in individual insurance market, says Oscar Health CEO Mark Bertolini
Nov 24, 2024
Joining us right now is Oscar Health CEO Mark Bertolini.
Of course, he is the former chairman and CEO of Aetna,
and he also served as a director of CVS Health Corporation.
And Mark, it's really great to see you this morning.
Thanks for being here.
Great to see you, Becky.
John Lennon, good to see you both.
We have been trying to figure out what this new administration is going to mean for health care.
One thing seems certain, that there will be changes.
A lot of what's been focused on so far
is what the potential will be for the pharmaceutical companies.
But between the choices to lead health and human services,
between what you might expect to see from the Department of Government Efficiency,
where are you thinking changes will come in the insurance market?
I think in the insurance market, what we've seen over the last four or five years
is a stability in the individual market.
Actually, today, the individual market has 22.2 million people,
and it has an ongoing cost trend of 3.5%.
So that makes the ACA market, the individual market,
the largest and most stable market in America.
And I think that is where the future lies for health care,
getting more people into the individual market that meets the needs
of what the Republicans have talked about for a long time,
which is how do we get competitive products at affordable prices
in ways that people like the products they're buying.
So I think we've got a good future, actually.
The Speaker of the House and others have mentioned that they're looking at ways
to either change or roll back parts of Obamacare, which is the ACA.
How do you think those changes will take place?
You point out that it's more than 22 million Americans that are now living there.
The reason it didn't get changed probably under the last Trump administration
is people like their health care insurance.
But there's a lot of problems with health care.
It's a huge and expanding part of the federal budget,
and there are some serious problems with the entire system,
people trying to figure out how to make that system better.
Well, when you look at small group and middle market,
which are fully insured products today, Becky,
what you have are trends that are in the double digit year over year
in rate increases.
We have been keeping mid to low single digits in the ACA.
So I think that's positive.
So I think finding ways that we can change the regulations
to actually get more people into the individual market.
Things like ICRA, the Individual Consumer Health Reimbursement Account,
built by the prior Trump administration,
has a way of moving all those people into the individual market
where they can buy what they need instead of being, in most cases,
chronically overinsured.
Mark, the problem with that, let's just talk about that for a second.
ICRA had some huge proponents,
and there is something to be said for getting gig workers covered
when they don't have coverage at this point.
But let's just talk about what it is.
It's a way that an employer can say,
okay, I'm going to give you X amount for this.
And you buy health insurance for what you need.
If something happens that you are catastrophically injured,
you have big bills that come through, you get a cancer diagnosis,
something else that comes through,
you as an employee think you're covered,
but it turns out it is not going to cover the cost overruns
on any of those issues.
That, to me, seems like the opposite of what insurance should be.
If you don't have a catastrophic component,
it means you have coverage for the little stuff
but not any of the big things that might come along.
Well, you do have coverage for the catastrophic component
when you buy in the individual market today.
ICRA, the employer can lay out and say,
I'm only going to spend this much.
They can only say they're going to spend this much,
but then the person can go shop and buy a policy,
which are cheaper in the individual market today, including subsidies.
But if you know something is bad happening, that's one thing.
If you don't realize that you could be in for, let's say, a cancer diagnosis,
you could be out of luck.
I think the plans today are largely zero premium plans,
are bought by a lot of people who want a safety net
whenever they have a catastrophic event.
And so we see a lot of people purchasing that way.
They like the product.
It has deductibles.
But with an ICRA account, if you buy down,
you have extra money left in your defined contribution amount
that you can buy or pay for those deductibles and extra costs.
But it's still all those policies have catastrophic coverage.
And they have out-of-pocket limits.

