Can Health Insurance Ensure Your Health? | Cracknomics Ep 18
3 Video Views·Nov 26, 2024
What is Aishmaan Bharat and can a health insurance scheme like PMJ improve our health services?
If you have a fridge at home, you can't be a part of it.
If you have a two-wheeler at home, you can't be a part of it either.
In the name of health budget and health services, you have been given a card.
Go and get yourself treated.
12 children died in Jhansi hospital.
55 children were present in the neonatal intensive care unit with a capacity of 18 beds at the time of the incident.
It is being said that the fire started from the short circuit.
The fire extinguisher kept in the hospital had expired four years ago.
Investigation is going on.
But will the children's life and the happiness of the parents ever come back?
Prior to this, 63 children died due to lack of oxygen in Gorakhpur's BRD Medical College in 2017.
Dr. Kafeel Khan, who had raised the issue of hospital problems, was targeted and put in jail.
If medical facilities and hospital conditions had been considered then, perhaps the Jhansi incident could have been avoided.
It's not just about UP.
Today, our country is in a bad state of health services.
It is becoming impossible for poor people to afford good health care.
The COVID-19 pandemic had also opened the doors of our hospitals and health services.
Since then, have we taken any steps to improve them?
There are still lines outside the hospitals.
Accidents keep happening.
After all, what is the plan?
Do you have any vision or not?
The government has only one answer to all this, which it keeps praising at every opportunity.
Ayushman Bharat.
What is this Ayushman Bharat?
And can a health insurance scheme like PMJ improve our health services?
Last week, news came from Gujarat that a hospital was doing fake angioplasty to steal money from the Ayushman Bharat scheme.
The question is, why do all these fake cases start in Gujarat?
Not only this, but the question is, why was the hospital doing this?
19 people were done angioplasty.
And a stunt was put in the mother-in-law's heart.
The specialty of the Gujarati Multispeciality Hospital was that it organized health camps.
And trapped such potential people who could become beneficiaries of PMJ.
Fake health reports were made before the fake surgery.
And did the surgery without telling the family.
Instead of patients, the hospital is taking advantage of this scheme.
Ayushman Bharat is a government scheme launched in 2018.
Its vision is to provide universal health coverage.
Now let's see how.
The first is to make 1.5 lakh health and wellness centers.
By transforming existing sub-centers and primary health care centers.
The government has told only one meaning of transform till now.
And that is to change the name.
I am not kidding.
Really, this year the news came that these health centers will now be called Aarogya Mandir.
A few months ago, there was a ruckus on it.
Every center was asked to give 3000 rupees and rebrand.
But their condition did not improve at all.
There is a shortage of staff, there is no medicine, and there are no good doctors.
Maybe after giving incentives to private hospitals for the rich.
This Aarogya Mandir will just be a place to pray for the poor.
The second component of Ayushman Bharat is the Prime Minister's Public Health Scheme.
In short, PMJ.
Meaning, whatever the scheme is, get it done first.
It has been said that this is the world's largest health insurance scheme.
It will definitely happen.
The country with the largest population is also ours.
Anyway.
Its idea is to give insurance claims of up to 5 lakhs to the poorest 12 crore families of the country every year.
And in Gujarat's Khyate Hospital, we saw how to get the claim.
It is interesting that the government gives the premium of enrolled citizens in this scheme.
And the claim settlement is done by private companies.
About 50 different companies are empanelled from this scheme in different places.
Its funding is done jointly by the central government and the state government.
In a ratio of 60 to 40.
This year, the Union Government has allocated 7500 crore rupees to the PMJ.
The enrolment conditions of the PMJ scheme are also very strict.
If you have a fridge in your house, then you cannot be included in it.
If you have a two-wheeler in your house, then you cannot be included in it.
Yes, but you should definitely have a phone.
It is difficult for many people to enrol in this scheme.
If by mistake your name is changed to Mukesh instead of Mukesh in a document, then your card will not be made.
If there is an age mismatch or a fingerprint mismatch, then also the card will not be made.
And if you do not have a phone or do not have money in the SIM, then neither will the OTP come nor will your Ayushman Card be made.
Even if you cross so many hurdles and get a card made, then insurance fraud can happen with you.
Government figures say that 35 crore Ayushman Cards have been made.
But in 2023, the report of the ICHE found that there is fraud in the registration of this scheme.
750,000 people were registered with the same number.
Guess the number, 99999999.
1,49,000 beneficiaries were linked to this phone number.
And 96,000 beneficiaries were linked to this number.
Which families are these who are sharing the same number?
Even they are such unique numbers.
Does this mean that this family is fake?
Or their registration is fake?
Didn't Digital India even identify some simple digits?
Are so many fake registrations being done to facilitate people or to increase the numbers of the scheme?
In the report of the ICHE itself, it was found that in about 43,000 households, the number of family members was 11 to 201.
The best example of the Great Indian Joint Family was found here.
But no one was able to find out about these 200 family members.
Why? Because they must not have got their number.
Even if you get the PMJ card, there is no guarantee that you will get treatment.
Many private hospitals avoid patients with the PMJ card.
Today, about 30,000 hospitals are unpaneled from the PMJ.
There are 13,700 private hospitals in this.
But private players are not very excited about this scheme.
Their profits are reduced, there is a delay in getting reimbursements.
So what is the use of treating such patients?
Another factor is out-of-pocket expenditure.
Even if you have a PMJ card, it does not mean that you will not have any expenses.
The government report says that the out-of-pocket expenditure has reduced.
Because the government's funding has increased.
The share of health expenditure in the country's GDP from 1.3% to 2.1% in 2022.
Wow! What an increase!
No one was ashamed to say this.
When inflation is increasing by 6 to 7% every year, does the 0.8% difference matter?
WHO says that it should be at least 5%.
And the government's target for next year is to make it 2.5%.
When the government does not spend, people have to spend from their pockets.
This is called out-of-pocket expenditure.
Undoubtedly, this has reduced in figures.
But in 188 countries around the world, we are at 161.
Even now, we are doing 50% out-of-pocket expenditure.
This means that despite having a PMJ card, you will have to spend from your own pocket.
This is the country where 10 crore people are going to poverty by filling medical bills every year.
This year in July, the news came that in the fraud cases of Ayushman Bharat,
ED put a raid in Himachal, Punjab and Delhi.
What? Really?
Did ED put a raid on anyone other than the opposition leaders?
Yes! There are many big hospitals in this.
Shri Banke Bihari Hospital, Fortis Hospital, Shri Balaji Hospital, Sood Nursing Home, etc.
Here, 373 fake Ayushman cards were caught,
on which 40 lakhs of reimbursement claims were filed.
In this way, it seems that the business of private hospitals is flourishing.
But have health services improved?
Once again, remember the vision of Ayushman Bharat.
Provide universal health care.
But will everyone get good health only by providing health insurance?
In reality, with a scheme like PMJ, instead of building infrastructure for health,
the government has moved towards health insurance.
This means building hospitals, taking care of hospitals,
hiring doctors, providing cheap medicines.
All these have become useless things.
Health activists, doctors and experts working with the people on the ground say
that health services are being privatized.
Big corporations are being prepared to hand over.
The meaning of health care is also being changed.
Niti Aayog had already clarified its intention towards the market.
In fact, the health care system is planned to be integrated into the tourism and market system.
In March 2020, Karwa magazine reported that
this insurance-based private health care model has weakened our ability to fight COVID-19.
During the pandemic, we all saw the terrible condition of hospitals.
We saw lakhs of people dying without treatment.
Maybe you have forgotten the fight for the oxygen cylinder.
Even after paying lakhs of rupees in hospitals, beds were not available.
It was difficult to get treatment for non-COVID patients.
Today, the whole world is talking about health insurance.
In the US, top health care companies are making crores of profits.
The world's largest health insurance company, United Health Group,
has a profit of $14 billion in 2024.
This year, a study by Lancet said that
health care is not getting better by privatizing, but getting worse.
The study in high-income countries said that
the public hospitals that were privatized, their profits increased.
How?
By taking selective patients and reducing staff.
But it is not necessary that their services have improved.
In fact, it has become difficult to access private hospitals and services for marginalized communities.
Despite so much privatization in our country,
today, the common man is the first to go to a public hospital.
He knows that if he gets a bed,
it will be a cheap and good treatment.
Private health providers themselves surveyed and said that
6 out of 10 Indians prefer private hospitals.
Yes, they can prefer, but they go to public hospitals
because they don't allow pockets.
NSSO data shows that for almost all kinds of health services,
the utilization of public hospitals has increased.
Rural and urban in both areas.
Despite the terrible challenges and failures of insurance in health care,
a new insurance scheme was launched a few days ago.
Ayushman V Vandana
This is for 70 plus senior citizens.
10 lakh elderly people have enrolled in it in 3 weeks.
In the true sense, universal health care means
that good health services reach till then.
To the poor, Dalits and Adivasis.
To remote areas.
To every needy woman.
But can we say that this has really happened?
Or is there a chance?
The tax you pay, you want good roads,
good education,
and good hospitals.
You don't have to go to private hospitals out of helplessness for treatment.
In the name of health budget and health services,
you have been given a card.
Go and get yourself treated.
But where will you go?
Because every road to good treatment passes through insurance.
The health crisis is very big.
And in this video, we were only able to talk about health insurance.
Do share your experiences related to this crisis.
Thank you for watching Cracknomics.
See you next week to Crack more Economics.

