Budget Pumpkin Pie Recipe - Less than $6!

Bigger Bolder Baking
1K followers
6.1K Video Views·Nov 22, 2024
So I recently learned that at Erewhon here
in Los Angeles, they are
selling a slice of pumpkin
pie for $10.
This is absolutely shocking.
I thought to myself, I can make a pie
from scratch with real
ingredients for way less
than that.
The pumpkin pie recipe I'm sharing with
you is made with all-natural, good
quality ingredients.
And the entire pie costs $5.53.
I mean, you can't get better than that.
So let's get started.
The first thing I'm going to start out by
making are homemade pie crust.
So in a nice big bowl, I have my
all-purpose flour, which costs 26 cents.
Into this, I'm going to add in some
powdered sugar, which costs 2 cents.
And then we're going to add
into this a little bit of salt.
Salt is very important in pastry, and
it's only a smidge, so
that costs literally like
less than half a cent.
Lovely.
Next, very important ingredient in
pastry, butter, salted butter.
All of this butter costs 93 cents.
We're going to rub
this in with our fingers.
You can also use a pastry blender.
Once your butter is in, it should
resemble coarse bread
crumbs, just like this.
Big lumps and small lumps.
So to these dry ingredients,
we're going to add in our wet.
Here I have an egg yolk,
which enrichens the dough.
This was 31 cents.
We're going to add a little bit of water
in there, which is free.
And we're going to whisk those
ingredients together.
So let's pour that
into our dry ingredients.
And then just mix it
together until it forms a ball.
If you feel like it's a little bit dry,
you can add a splash more
water, but just a little
bit.
If you've never made your own pie crust
before, it is superior to store bought.
It's flaky, it's buttery,
you can taste the quality.
It's just so much better, so I hope this
inspires you to make your own.
I'm just going to shape that into a ball.
I'm going to wrap it in cling wrap, and
then I'm going to pop
it into the fridge for at
least 30 minutes.
You can leave it in
for 24 hours if you want.
Let it get nice and cold, it'll be much
easier to roll afterwards.
So once your pastry has chilled, roll it
out on a floured
surface and line your pie pan,
and this is what you end up with.
You're not going to believe this.
This pie crust all together costs $1.52,
made from scratch with
all natural ingredients.
And that's pretty shocking considering I
checked some store bought
pie crusts, and the Pillsbury
pie crust costs $4.24.
You could get three almost of these pie
crusts for one Pillsbury
pie crust, and I guarantee
you the quality is not nearly as good.
So we're going to pop this into the
fridge right now, let it
stay nice and cold, and
then we're going to make our filling.
So for our filling, we're going to start
out with pumpkin puree.
This was $1.47 for the can.
Sometimes you can find it cheaper.
Next we're going to add in our eggs.
Two eggs, 61 cents.
We have our eggs in there because a
pumpkin pie is kind of
like a pumpkin custard pie,
so they are in there to set it.
Now we're going to put in a
whole can of evaporated milk.
$1.22.
Next we're going to
add in some brown sugar.
I love dark brown sugar because the
flavor is so much better.
All of that brown sugar is 50 cents.
Next, of course, we have
to have pumpkin pie spice.
This can be a little bit pricey.
This was 20 cents for this amount.
You can make your own, and I have a
recipe on my website,
BiggerBolderBaking.com, of
how you can make that also.
And it's pretty cheap to
make and you get a lot.
And lastly, salt, which is a cent.
Salt is very important,
especially in pie making.
And then we're going to whisk all these
ingredients together.
So what I just showed you are very common
ingredients in a
traditional pumpkin pie, and
I checked the Erewhon recipe, and its
filling is pretty much the exact same.
So how they're charging $10 for a slice
is beyond me, but now we know.
And here I have my pie crust, and just
pour in your filling.
Not only is it inexpensive to make your
own homemade pumpkin pie, but it's easy.
The last little step I'm going to do is
I'm just going to egg
wash the crust to make sure
it gets a lovely golden brown.
And our homemade pie is ready, so let's
get it into the oven.
So we're going to bake our pumpkin pie on
a preheated tray at
425 degrees Fahrenheit,
220 degrees Celsius
for around 15 minutes.
Then don't forget to turn down the
temperature to 350 degrees Fahrenheit,
180 degrees Celsius,
for roughly 40 minutes or so.
We just want that custard to set.
If your pastry starts to get too brown,
just cover it up so it
doesn't continue to get
darker.
Here we have it, our
homemade pumpkin pie.
And guess what, it cost in total $5.53.
That's absolutely incredible.
A fraction of the Air One price, and also
compared to other store bought pies, they
can be $8 to $10, and they're
not as good quality as this.
This pie is really big, and it feeds 10
people, which makes each slice $0.55.
You cannot beat that for a homemade pie
with good quality
ingredients made with love.
So here we have both pies.
Now we definitely know which one is
better value for money,
but let's see which one holds
up the taste test.
Erewhon tastes good.
It's a little bit spicy, a little bit too
spicy for my liking.
I know I did make this pie, but I have to
say it is superior
compared to the Erewhon.
You cannot argue with making a whole pie
for half the price of
one slice of pumpkin pie.
If you're in the mood for more holiday
recipes, then stick around.
I have loads of videos
for you to check out.
Thanks so much for watching, and I'll see
you back here again really soon.
