Ce mercredi 13 novembre, la ministre de l'Éducation nationale a été interrogée sur l'attractivité du métier d'enseignant et l'Acte 2 du « Choc des savoirs », initié en décembre 2023 par Gabriel Attal. L'occasion pour Anne Genetet de rappeler que « la réussite n'est pas le privilège de quelques-uns ».
Les députés ont également abordé la situation de l'agriculture face au Mercosur, de la pêche française « trahie » par le gouvernement et de l'élevage face à la menace du loup. Tour à tour les ministres ont rappelé leur engagement dans ces sujets.
Le gouvernement a également été interrogé sur le démantèlement de Fret SNCF, prévu pour le 1er janvier prochain, ayant donné lieu à un préavis de grève illimitée par les syndicats cheminots à quelques jours des vacances de Noël. La ministre Catherine Vautrin a alors tenté de rassurer : « aucun licenciement n'aura lieu dans ce projet » de démantèlement.
Le gouvernement a également été interrogé sur l'enquête de France 24 ayant mis en lumière l'utilisation de munitions françaises lors de la répression des manifestations iraniennes en 2022 ; sur le budget des collectivités locales pour 2025 ; sur la liberté d'expression quelques semaines après une vague de suppression de comptes sur la plateforme X ; ou encore sur la lutte contre l'immigration illégale comorienne à Mayotte.
Les députés interrogent les ministres sur l'actualité en exclusivité sur LCP-Assemblée nationale.
the agenda calls for questions to the
government and following yesterday's session
my dear colleagues I
invite you to please measure your words
and to remain courteous with your colleagues
I will not allow
inappropriate words to be uttered in this
enclosure which is certainly the place of
freedom of expression but which is also
the place of listening and
mutual respect the first question is asked
by Mr. Laurent for the
spanning group and
territory my question is addressed to
the Minister of Europe and
Foreign Affairs, Mr. Minister,
a France 24 investigation
highlighted the use of
hunting rifle ammunition from the
Franco-Italian company Chedite during
demonstrations in Iran aimed at repressing
demonstrators by force or Iran
like you the know is under embargo
the investigation finds its sources in
forums of Iranian hunters who
themselves regularly photograph
their M
also used by the
Iranian security forces and soldiers who
use it on demonstrators
causing serious visible injuries on
very numerous videos but
French and European legislation
prohibits the sale, supply,
transfer or export directly or
indirectly of equipment
likely to be used for purposes
of internal repression or not to any
person, entity or organization
in Iran or in end of use in
Iran questions were asked
directly to the cheedit company which has
already been the target of identical criticism
in the Birm file the said company
responds that it sells its products while respecting
the Iranian embargo and is not
responsible nor be responsible for it after
the sale the cartridges nevertheless
transited to Iran in particular
through Turkey it turns out that the
company shéit sells its cartridges to a
Turkish company called yavascalar which
is the largest supplier of
cartridges to Iran but it appears that
among the shareholders of the
yavascalar company we find the shedit company
with 50% of the shares, in addition
members of the management of shéit
are also members of the board
of directors of yavascalar including the
CEO of shedit itself the ministries
of Foreign Affairs, Interior,
Defense and Economy were
informed in order to initiate
investigations in December 2022 the
investigations were underway on a
possible diversion of equipment
exported in violation of
European rules sir the minister
can you please tell us where
this investigation is at, let us know
the results and tell us what has
been taken or on the point of a letter
in order to stop its actions on
the part of the chit company and
thus restore a effective embargo
against the Vanda àirci, Mr.
Deputy, the floor is given to Mr.
Jean-Noël Barot, Minister for Europe and
Foreign Affairs, Madam President, Ladies
and Gentlemen, Mr.
Deputy, Laurent Mazori, France has taken
note of the allegations made by France
24 relating to the use of
hunting rifle and sports shooting casings
produced by the
Franco-Italian manufacturer dit in the repression
of demonstrations in Iran we
recall a simple principle: France
does not authorize any export of
explosive firearms products or more
generally war material to
Iran in strict compliance with the
sanctions and embargo existing particularly
at the level of the European Union everything
suggests that these cartridges
would have ended up in Iran at following
a diversion most probably
from Turkey, France has in any
case never authorized its
exports
a joint approach was carried out with
the Italian authorities to determine
whether its exports to Turkey
were carried out via the Italian side of
the company during the investigation
the shedit company indicated that it
had never exported equipment to
the Turkish companies mentioned in
the France 24 article it
was also heard by the
Italian Chamber of Deputies which would have made it possible
to rule out its responsibility and
to increase the rigor of its fight
against the misuse of sanctions,
thank you, Mr. Minister, the
floor is given to Mr. Syvain Berios for
the Horizon and
Independent group, thank you, Madam President
Naima mchou, allow me to
associate you with the question relating to
local authorities that I would like to
ask Madam Minister partnership
with local authorities on behalf of the
Horizon Independent group chaired by
Laurent Marcangi for 15 15 years and
particularly under the mandate of
left-wing governments,
local authorities have suffered the full
brunt on the one hand the savings that
the State was unable to make with a
drop in the general
operating allocation of more than 14 billion
and on the other hand by
an incredible normative inflation
correlated with development of an
administrative milfeuille that has become
sprawling, a veritable
absolutely unfathomable labyrinth where
decisions and public money are lost during
the examination of the 2025 bill, we
wanted to maintain the level of
reimbursement of the FCTVA in order not to
break the dynamic of investments
by the communities which represents 70%
of public investments in our
country, it is in this same spirit that we
wanted the contribution of
communities to the recovery of
public accounts not to be an
arbitrary drain on their taxation
but to be the subject of a
contractualization like the
Kaor contracts this would make it possible to
support the communities which
embark on the path of the control
of public expenditure by
the establishment of a system of bonus
malus this contactualization also has
the virtue to respect the
constitutional principle of free
administration of communities also
Madam Minister during the meetings
that we had with the Prime
Minister he welcomed our proposals with interest
can you as
the budgetary discussion begins in the Senate
confirm to us that the
local authorities will not be
the bouques emissaries of the government
but also partners and that
administrative and territorial reform work will be undertaken
from
2025, thank you, Mr. Deputy, the floor
is given to Mrs. Catherine Vterin, Minister
of Partnership with the Territories and
Decentralization, thank you, Madam
President, Mr. deputy Sylvain
berrios Mr. President marcangéi
I take care to cite those
that you were kind enough to quote Mr.
Deputy you are questioning me Mr.
Deputy on two subjects ultimately on the one
hand the inflation of standards and
millefeuille and on the other side the
budget on the inflation of standards and this
subject of the cost of the standard as you know
with the Minister of Public Accounts
we wanted to entrust a mission
to the mayor and president of the agglomeration
of Charleville Maisière Boris Ravignon
to actually take a deeper look at
the report that he was kind enough to
produce in order to go very
concretely towards a simplification of
the standard with a reading which is
much more a reading around the cost
of the standard than one of
potential effectiveness what could be that of
the standard and this is the reason
why Mr. Ravillon began
his work and that from the beginning of
the year 25 we will be able to
respond on this first point on the
second point which concerns the budget of the
communities the Prime Minister you
said the version which was examined
by the National Assembly was in
a way a zero version of a
context which is that of the
public debt 3228 billion of a
debt interest of 55 billion euros per year
2nd budget behind that of the
national education assembly and the work that
we are carrying out is indeed with the
associations of elected officials with
parliamentarians the means to improve
this copy by putting in place
responses for the communities, this is the
work that we we will continue with
the Senate of course the desire
is to contribute to the reduction of
public spending because this concerns
everyone but behind providing
concrete answers for the
communities we measure the weight of the
communities whatever the
different strata in the economy of
our country and this is therefore the meaning of
our commitment, I thank you, Madam
Minister, Mr. Deputy, thank you,
Madam Minister, the Horizon group
will be very attentive to the reduction in
public spending as it will
also be attentive to maintaining
confidence in
local authorities, thank you, I
thank you for the floor to Mr.
Nicolas sensu for the group of the
Democratic and Republican Left thank you
Madam President Mr.
Minister of Transport a year ago a
commission of inquiry into
rail freight reported by our excellent
colleague Vulfran demonstrated the impasse of
dismantling of the public
rail freight operator already in 2019 the
government was alarmed, I quote, the
liberalization of the sector was
largely to the detriment of the
modal model share of rail freight at a
time when the transport of goods
by rail is an imperative necessity
to respond to the climate emergency the
taken path is madness ahead of the
European Commission when we
could still negotiate the death of
the historic operation proposed by the former
government is more than an aberration
it is a crime against the environment and
the entire sector will be destabilized
how can France achieve
doubling of the modal share of
rail freight by 2030 by liquidating its
own operator in favor of the
liberalization of
goods transport favoring road how can we
accept that the new entity created
is prohibited from applying for the 23
circulations delivered to cutting which
have not yet found any takers
among other railway operators
how to announce
reindustrialization objectives by not preserving
this precious tool of
rail transport which meets the needs of the large
sectors of metallurgy,
nuclear chemistry but also isolated wagons,
how can we not hear the employees of
their union organizations who
show the inconsistency of
dismantling at a time when the need
for 'an integrated group fried traveler
infrastructure is the only one capable of
responding to the deep demand for
carbon-free travel by train,
Mr. Minister, the so-called process of
discontinuity which is none other than the
breakdown of the public rail freight service
is a major failure question
will therefore be simple, will the new government
pronounce a moratorium on this
process in order to give itself time and
get back in touch with the new
European Commissioner, thank you,
Mr. Deputy, the floor is given to
Madame Catherine Vterin, Minister of
Partnership with the Territories and
decentralization thank you Madam
President Ladies and Gentlemen
MP Nicolas sANSU
thank you MP for your
question you know the transformation
of rail freight responds to an
obligation which is a
European operation and a European obligation
you come yourself to do allusion
to the work of the European Commissioner
the subject is being followed today with the
greatest attention by the
government my colleague François
durovvret is listening not only
to the commission we have in accordance
with what the
Prime Minister asked us all made an appointment
with our respective commissioners which will
not prevent us from
obviously discussing each of these subjects with the
commissioner but of course
François dur revray is also
attentive to the SNCF establishment,
including of course its
social partners I would like ladies and
gentlemen the deputies be perfectly
clear no layoffs will take place
in this project the 500 railway workers
concerned whose
know-how each knows will be taken over in the
activities of laasncf in the same way
and you insisted, Mr. Deputy,
rightly the modal shift will not will not take place
towards the road all flows will be
maintained on the rail it is a
major issue of decarbonization for our
country the financial commitment of the State at
a time when public money is rare
we evoke it through many
questions is extremely important I
remind you that it is unprecedented 370
billion euros from 2025 including 100
million specifically on the
isolated wagon finally the Ulis freight program
will mobilize 4 billion euros surpassing
precisely to modernize the network
so not only is the Minister of
Transport continuing this
constructive dialogue but the government is
determined to make railway fries
a major pillar of our strategy of
decarbanization of transport this
transformation with social guarantee is
an essential step thank you madam the
minister thank you thank you thank you
madam president madam the minister
it is not true today there are
five circulations which have not found a
buyer and which are postponed on the road
then the debt which you are talking about could have
been negotiated and if is requested it is
a moratorium because that there is a new
government and a new
European commissioner I thank you the floor
is Mr Charles Aloncle for the
UDR group thank you Madam President my
question is addressed to the Prime Minister
Mr Prime Minister in
the general indifference our country aacu
a real
digital coup this summer the American giant M
carried out on Instagram an
unprecedented wave of deletion of
information accounts of the media ocidentis followed
by 160,000 people to the
ecolucide environmentalist account including the
feminist Alice Cordier all saw their
accounts deleted in one day without
any
explanation their only obvious wrong to
say the real and defend France and
yet
here in the land of the Enlightenment of Voltaire and
Charlie this attack on freedom
of expression has not moved anyone or the arcom
too busy placing C8 and C news under
the supervision of the
priesthoods nor you elected left and
professional censor who only climbed the
barricade to defend
anti-Semitic remarks nor you elected and
Macronist government complicit by your deafening silence
where were- you to call meta to
account for his interference where
were you to defend the islamologist
Gilles kpel and vincé de sciencep for
dissidence where were you finally to
denounce the ban on the
national gathering of the daily broadcast and the
advertising boycott of Jordane
Bardellaa to all censors know
that an idea is never as strong as
when it cannot be
defended each time you try
to chase away reality through the door he will
come back even more brutally through the
window so Mr Prime
Minister when you stand up as a child
to defend freedom of expression
the French have not said their
last word so give them back the floor
I
thank you the floor is up to Madam Rachida
Minister of
Culture thank you Madam President, ladies
and gentlemen, Monsieurput, I
don't quite understand the question to
tell you everything because if it means
avoiding fake news, well, we are against
fake news, that's after if it's is to
say freedom of expression is to
make comments which are
criminally qualifying well I will fight against
comments which are criminally qualifying
if freedom of expression is to say
the opposite of the truth of reality
which leads to the Stig of a part of
our compatriots I will fight against this
there it is there the reality after
on you spoke of C news and
certain media or of C8 you
alluded to the arcom I simply remind you
that the arcom is an
independent authority which allocates frequencies
according to criteria and a procedure
defined by the legislator therefore in complete
independence either it renews or
allocates it or it does not renew
frequencies then with regard to the
media that you have indicated there's has
appeals whether it is C8 Energie 12 or the
media which is called the media moreover
they have all appealed moreover
the appeals will be examined on
November 15 precisely for freedom
of expression and respect for State of
law await the outcome of its appeals
thank you Madam
Minister the floor is given to Mr. Joseph
Rivère for the national gathering group
president my question
is addressed to the Minister of the Interior
Bruno Rotaillot Mr. Minister
since you took office you
have of the fight against
illegal immigration your hobby horse
Mr. Minister chin thrusts
are good but geography is
better in your policy
overseas France is the great forgotten one
especially in the Indian Ocean before our
eyes the Comoros have declared war
on France by dumping all its
immigration and that of Africa among
our brothers in Mayotte and by ricocheting to
the meeting the territorial waters of
Mayotte are a real sieve and our
police and customs officers are
disbanded the Magiavo Reg prison
is full of criminals of foreign origin
and just last month
you transferred 27 of them to Réunion
in the port prison which is
itself overcrowded. All these
people in an irregular situation are roaming
in the wild. and remains on
French soil illegally squatting our
ravines and organizing itself as a counter-
society track of wild animals theft and
torture of domestic animals assault
of women and old men in
public and private places occupation of the
streets with machetes in full view day the
prefectures of mamoudsou and
Saint-Denis are overwhelmed by applicants
for paper that entered
our soil illegally at a time not so long ago
these illegals were sent home to
the commort the instructions were clear
zero tolerance Mr. Minister we
all understood that you have an
agenda
we also in the name of the French people
could you include in your agenda
the fact that the overseas territories are not the
trash of the Republic but that the
departmentalization of Reunion and
Maotte also implies rights,
Mr. Minister when will you
stop subsidizing
jeercie orders, Mr. Deputy, the
floor is given to Mr. Nicolas, Minister
Delegate in charge of
daily security, Madam President, Ladies
and Gentlemen, Mr.
Deputy, yesterday your question aims to
remind us of the need to fight against
illegal immigration that France is undergoing
and I thank you for it and
obviously I reaffirm here the commitment
of Bruno Retaillot under the authority of the
Prime Minister to fight against
irregular immigration whatever
the territories as you know Mr.
River since 2018 the Réunion is
faced with a new phenomenon
of irregular immigration from Sri
Lanka following these events we
have taken up the task with the
Sri Lankan authorities and obtained some progress
also with the United Kingdom since
we know that a certain number of
boats make a stopover at the
Chagos Islands before going to the meeting
with regard to the other
overseas territories Mayotte and the
French community most affected by
immigration from the Commores, as
you have just recalled, Mayotte
is experiencing
growing diversification. flows
irregular immigration entrants Guadeloupe
and Martinique are also subject to
Haitian Cuban
Dominican and Dominican immigration since the law
of January 26, 2024 the government
must submit a report that we
will present it is being
developed here with in particular the
presentation of additional technological and
human resources to fight
against immigration I had the opportunity
to say it here and I will say it again here in
response to your question you know
the government's position you
know in particular the mine
illegal immigration obviously
we are opposed to it foreign
delinquents or criminals you know
where they must be
outside thank you Mr. Minister
Mr. Deputy thank you Mr.
Minister I understand your answer clearly,
in particular the prefects of meeting and
maotte quickly await your
instructions and your means in order to
defend our population thank you thank you
the floor is Mr.
Bertranort for the group Together for
the
Republic thank you Madam President
my dear colleagues my question
is addressed to Madam Minister of
Education national I associated
all of my colleagues in the
Ensemble pour la République group for C years
the school constitutes a major element of
our political DNA myself a teacher
for more than 30 years I want to begin
my remarks by saluting the remarkable
work of all the actors of the
school world and affirm that teachers
are there 24 hours a day, 365 days
a year as they are committed to the
success of each of their students our
world is disrupted by populism decline
separatists and to combat these
excesses everything starts at school since
2017 the budget of the schools of the
Republic has increased by more than 14
billion euros it has made it possible in particular
to split the classes of large
sections CP CE1 to preserve positions
in rural schools to revalorize the
profession of teacher strongly
moreover for the beginning of the career these
efforts produce positive effects
in 6th grade the results of the
national evaluations are in constant progress
the students of priority education
who have experienced the doubling are those
who have progressed the most in French
the gaps are finally narrowing but the
challenge of success for all students
remains before us a 4th grade student/does
not master basic skills the
college must stop being a large
marshalling yard that leaves students in
difficulty on the edge of the road upon
arrival in second grade a gulf is
irremediably widening between the vocational high school
and the general high school faced with
these findings we will continue to
mobilize against all inequalities
of destiny because the republican promise
begins at school Madam Minister
you presented yesterday act 2 of the
shocks of knowledge it is part of
the ambition driven by Gabriel Atal
to win the battle for success
the pr group salutes this
renewed ambition can you, Madam
Minister, give us the vision and
objectives of this plan can you
present to us the measures most likely
to restore the authority of knowledge in
all classes I thank you I
thank you the floor is given to Madame
Anne Minister of
National Education thank you Madam President
Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament,
Mr. Deputy, come out, yes, you said it,
our school is clearly a
turning point, we have 12 million students
who expect us to either make
a start or to move towards
decline, and I am
convinced of that, the school and I am sure that
everyone here on C ban you are
also convinced if the school succeeds behind
it is the whole Republic which triumphs
we need this success of
the school and we are in fact for a
moment we have conspiracy theorists
separatists facing us and in front of
them school is never a problem
it is always always the solution
so when I said that is
school going well everywhere no we know that
you recalled the points on
which we have still
important steps of progress to be made we
know that students stagnate in middle school
it is unacceptable I do not accept that
success can be a privilege it is
not acceptable that is why I
wanted this act 2 of the shock of knowledge
it is ultimately necessary that no
student remains on the edge of the way I
am committed to the school so that
we can relaunch this
educational elevator so what are
the key measures it is in fact to
continue this tailor-made support of all
our young people of all our middle school students of
all our students also in school in
primary school pardon and nursery and
then we also have the subject of the
certificate which must become a diploma which
makes you want to succeed which makes
our students want to project themselves which is
why it will be compulsory for
students who today are in
5th grade will be the first to have
benefited this year from the
needs groups set up by my
predecessor Gabriel Attal last year,
it is therefore a real plan of
reconquest but which does not stop there
which goes further with in particular
the test of mathematics we are
capable of taking an entire generation
to an anticipated common
French test in first grade why
couldn't we do it in
mathematics there is no reason there is
not a bump in mathematics all
world can have a common level in
math reached in class first year and
then there is also the school climate
which is very important on which I
will work to be able to provide a
serene and peaceful climate with a
strengthening of the workforce, particularly in
school life. See that at the end of the day
when the Republic responds,
well my time the school is capable of
reversing all the fatalities I
thank you thank you Madam
Minister the floor is Mr. ARN
legal for the group France
[Music]
insonise Mr. Minister of
Foreign Affairs yesterday the Minister of
Agriculture claimed here to be
totally opposed to the
mercosour free trade agreement but
last week, invoking a spurious reason,
the government deemed inadmissible the
proposed resolution against this
agreement that insoumise France intended to
present during its niche on
November 28 at a time when the
European Commission is accelerating the negotiations
to conclude the agreement as quickly as possible you
censor Parliament why this
censorship is the government is
really opposed to this
agreement no one is fooled at each
electoral deadline Emmanuel Macron
pretended to oppose this agreement from
another age but nothing has been done to
put an end to the negotiation because instead of
really opposing this agreement
you maintain the mirage of close
mirror and other conditions in practice
inapplicable for example the
General Directorate of Health of the
European Union itself has just
recognized that we cannot detect
hormones in Brazilian meat
among other consequences with or without a
new clause this agreement would cause
the destruction of
family farming for the benefit of a few
agribusiness multinationals or
services it would result in a massive flow
of poor quality foodstuffs produced
in the worst social and
ecological conditions this treaty massively rejected
on both sides of the Atlantic
will only serve the interests of a few
large firms it is anachronistic the
time of triumphant free trade and
gone time has come for a policy of
reindustrialization and
ecological planning in the service in particular of our
food sovereignty, so do you
commit yourself directly to preventing
this agreement from being adopted, are you ready to
block the negotiations and if, despite
all this agreement is adopted will you
once again say that we can only
do anything in Brussels descid our place
or will you
finally disobey the floor is given to Mr. Jean-Noël
barreot Minister of Europe and
Affairs
[Applause]
foreign countries they have not yet been ratified
Madam President, Ladies and
Gentlemen, Deputy
Arnaud Legal, I share some of the
terms that you used,
reindustrialization,
food sovereignty, this is the agenda which is that
of France for 7 years in the
European institutions and with regard
to the agreement with the Mercosour countries,
France's position is clear and
it is constant this agreement is
not acceptable as it stands the President of
the Republic 'recalled on many
occasions the Prime Minister is
in Brussels today to
repeat it to ourursou la vaner Leyen and
many parliamentarians spoke out
very recently in a
forum that more than 600 of them
signed firstly because the guarantees
that we have been demanding since 2
have not been met today the
Paris agreement must be an essential element
of the agreement and in the event of a violation of
the Paris agreement the agreement must be able to
be suspended the agreement must
also include, as you mentioned, safeguard clauses
and sanction mechanisms
when the clauses of this agreement
are not respected finally the CA must
the agreement must respect the
environmental rules in force and must not
grant no exemption and in particular
in terms of deforestation guarantee that
our commercial partners respect at
all points the constraints that we
impose on our producers it is a
question of consistency and justice but
if we refuse the agreement in state it is
also for a second reason it is
then because we refuse to allow the
Commission to deviate from the mandate that the
Council gave it: to negotiate
an association agreement which requires
the unanimity of the Member States and
ratification by the
national parliaments, it is a question of
democracy, rest assured that below
the authority of the Prime Minister with the
Minister of Agriculture we are
mobilized on all fronts and with
parliamentarians to guarantee that this
agreement, if it were to one day be signed,
guarantees the interests of our
farmers, our industrialists, our
companies and our jobs thank you
Mr. Minister Mr. MP
you continue to say that another
Mercosur agreement is possible we do
not want at all to block the
negotiations be clear
by is to Mr. Pierri Courourbon
for the socialist and
related group thank you Madam President my
question addressed to the Minister
of National Education, Madam
Minister, you presented yesterday what
you called act 2 of the clash of
knowledge, thus continuing the
unanimously contested orientations of
your predecessors, you notably
expressed your desire to give a
boost for the college to,
I quote, relaunch the
educational elevator by maintaining the
very controversial system of GR gr level in
6th and 5th and worse by extending them in a
different way in 4th and 3rd this
declaration is in the image of your
overall working method we decide to
generalize a device which
is far from having proven itself and which
in the field does
not work or works in a
very imperfect way too bad if everything the
world is opposed to it, you are convinced
as always to be right against
everyone and against the entire
educational community when there is an
act 1 which does not work and Don we have
not been able to carry out the slightest evaluation or
the slightest assessment we avoid making an
act of with measures to
the cookie cutter you have also
announced that you want to make leet
the pardon certificate compulsory for admission to
second grade, here too a provision
described as an unacceptable historical regression
by certain
trade union organizations in that we can see in it a
logic of banishment of students the
most in difficulty who are, as you
know, mainly students
from the poorest families because
too often academic difficulties
are the mirror of social difficulties,
these are thousands of young people that you
want to ban from the 16 year old school system,
Madam Minister, more what a shock
repeated knowledge our school
above all needs a shock of means quite the
opposite of what your
austerity budget provides and the
scandalous elimination of 4000 positions in
National Education Madam Minister when are
you going to stop bleeding our
school and to want to build the school of
tomorrow systematically against all
those who bring it to life on a
daily basis
thank you the floor is given to Madame Anne young
Minister of
National Education thank you Madam President
Ladies and Gentlemen Members of Parliament
Mr. Deputy Courbon I hear your
words you will agree I cannot
quite relate to them you have
comments which are really quite
declinist and you see I believe that
I prefer to pay tribute
today to all these teachers that
I have met who are in the field
who are very committed who are
determined who have a
significant workload but who are there at the service
of the success of our students because
you see Mr. Courbon me what
I observe today 'today for several
years it has been that in reality our school
no longer keeps its republican promise
and today we do not have a
school which responds to all our students and
I have a school which on the contrary is in
a situation where success is
reserved for a few some this is no longer the
Republican promise it is unacceptable
and the measures that I presented yesterday
which are in fact part of the vision
that the President of the Republic has held
since 2017 and which continues today
continued last year with what
my predecessor Gabriel wore Atal and
that I announced yesterday is precisely
for example how can you give up
having tailor-made support
of personalized support of
individualized individual support a patent which
ultimately makes our students want to
succeed which allows them to project themselves
and which allows everyone to succeed and
not leave a few on the
side of the road because that is what is
unacceptable and which you left
behind you particularly in 2017 and then
a high school behind behind behind the
college in which in indeed an
anticipated mathematics test will allow
all our students to have a solid common core
of mathematics yes I am
for a single college I am for an
education with a framework with
programs which are clear which many
declinist and conspiratorial countries
do not have today so Mr.
Courbon I do not recognize myself in your
words I consider that our teachers
have an
admirable attitude I also want to tell them
that I will always
support our teachers at a time when
precisely what you have mentioned it’s
clinicists it’s
lounge and counter and media conspirators
precisely contest them constantly and
that is unacceptable I will always be
in support of our teachers and
I expect the entire society to
support
teachers thank you Madam Minister
please my dears colleagues
can we listen to the answers
of the ministers since we are asking
[Applause]
questions we listen to the answers
since we are asking questions absolutely
the floor is
Madam
go ahead thank you Madam President the
decline of the school Madam Minister c is
your balance sheet for 7 years and if you do
not find yourself in our words the
educational community does not find itself
in your budget thank you
thank you the floor is given to Mrs. Josiane
cornelou for the group of the republican right
thank you thank you Madam President my
question is addressed to Madam Minister
of Agriculture and Food Sovereignty
for many years the
agricultural world has oscillated between revolt and
despondency in the face of the major challenge of the
renewal of generations that we
have the duty to promote. I would like to
welcome your first announcements of a leave
there establishment of a single
administrative control of
agricultural holdings per year is a positive step forward
eagerly awaited by farmers
who can no longer juggle between
European and French regulations
while undergoing controls that are too
often the responsibility of agents armed with
the French Biodiversity Office
on the other hand measures to
support the cash flow of farmers
in difficulty finally there are many of us
on these benches to approve your
resolute opposition to the
Mercosur free trade agreement which would destabilize our
sectors however serious concerns
remain following repeated attacks
by large predators, particularly in my
constituency of Sonéloire due to
a parceled bocage that is very
difficult to protect. Breeders
mainly of eggplant are faced with
wolf predation which creates
permanent stress for the breeder and his family
and cause of very significant losses not
compensated by the payment of
too restrictive compensation, the Council of
Ministers of the European Union adopted a
few weeks ago a proposal
from the Commission aimed at changing
the status of the wolf in Europe from
strictly
to protecting this proposal would allow
more room for maneuver in
wolf hunting, do you think, Madam
Minister, to support this
European awareness by authorizing
the killing of wolves from the first
attack as is the case in Bavaria?
thank you thank you Madam Deputy the
floor is given to Madam An Jeev Minister of
Agriculture,
Food Sovereignty and
Forestry thank you Madam President
Ladies and Gentlemen Deputy Madam
Deputy Josiane Cornou first of all
thank you for your encouraging words on
the measures that I put in place upon
my arrival, I think it is good to
recall them at a time when
the agricultural demonstrations are beginning to flourish, we
must also be able to say what has been
done, the commitments that have been made. been held
and those which will still be held tomorrow you
mention the mercossur my colleague
Minister of Foreign Affairs
expressed himself very clearly on the
subject I reiterate my firm opposition
resolute for all the reasons that he
explained regarding the wolf madame
MP I would like to tell you that you
alerted me to the situation of a
breeder in your constituency who has
suffered this
wolf attack on his livestock since May, uh ladies and
gentlemen deputies I would like to
make you aware of the state of
absolute distress in where
our breeders find themselves when in the morning they
open the door of the sheepfold and they
notice the mortality due to
health crises or in the pastures
the mortality of animals which have been
predated by the wolf it is
unimaginable violence also and you are right
to point this out, Madam Deputy,
the announcement of the agreement of the Member States
for the declassification of the wolf as a
protected species which will probably be accompanied
by a vote in favor of the
Berne Convention, we will have to complete the journey
at the time of the examination by the
Habitat Directive it will make it possible to change the
perspective of reversing the burden of
proof, if I may say so, we
must now think about protecting
the breeder and the farms before
protecting the wolf which today is
in a state of
satisfactory conservation which authorizes
larger harvest quotas we would
therefore move from the notion of ceiling to
the notion of quota but for this we
must collect at the level of the
Habitat Directive a unanimous opinion of the
countries there are three countries which are hostile to
us we have undertaken
diplomatic work with them I
thank you Madam
Deputy uh thank you Madam Miler I
am obviously very sensitive to
tell you uh it is urgent to act
because the farmers deplore that the
promised effects of the runoff from the
three lagalim is not there
and it is their income which is
impactedci the floor is given to Mr.
Damien Girérard for the
ecological and social group thank you Madam
President dear colleagues my question is
addressed to Mr. Minister Delegate
for the Sea and fishing Mr.
Minister Fabrice ler why did you
betray French fishing the anéli silena
is a gigantic Dutch factory ship
which flies the Polish flag this
145 m monster is capable of catching
up to 400 tonnes of fish per day
on November 5 you affirm in the Senate
that no decision has been taken
concerning a transfer of
fishing quotas for the benefit of this vessel a few
days later you confirm an
exchange of quotas of 20 22000 tonnes of
Merland bleu this vessel is so
large that it cannot access the port of
Saint-Malo where the processing plant is located.
the merlbleu will therefore be
unloaded in the Netherlands then partly brought back
to Saintmalot by
road transport, Minister, if this
agreement is indeed an exchange can you
enlighten our assembly on the coasts
recovered by France, what
concrete quantified benefit for
French fishermen after having made them
abandon 2% of their quota of Merl
bleu to Poland, are these operations
carried out in transparency and with the
validation of the European Commission
as required by the common
fisheries policy, Mr. Minister, you are
referring this decision to your
predecessor, however, the quôas transfer order
was taken on November 4, one
month after you took up your post, you
had this month to cancel the
decision and adopt a
responsible line, one that protects the ocean and
biodiversity, one that defends
artisanal fishing, one that rejects
the monopolization of our resources by a
handful of industrialists to the detriment of
French fishing, why not have
made this choice courageous, I thank you,
I thank you, the floor is given to
Mr. Fabrice Toer, Minister Delegate
for the Sea and
[Applause]
Fisheries, Madam President, Ladies and
Gentlemen, Members of
Parliament, well, I do not object to the
very excessive nature of your remarks.
full of approximations and
untruths and I will even
thank you for your question which will
allow me, I hope, to bring
some calm to a subject which I am
aware of arouses concern for me I have just
been effectively received a
new request for quota exchange by
the company despechees de saint-malot
to exploit in the North Sea a quota
of bluebird that it historically targets
by the BIA of a Polish flag fishing vessel
the anéise Hena the group has in
fact invested 15 million euros on this
ship by installing an
on-board factory. The previous ship, the Joseph
RTI 2, having reached the end of its life after
50 years of operation, I want to say this
very clearly, the government takes
full responsibility. that quota exchanges
be carried out between the Member States
of the European Union as long as their
terms generate sufficient economic benefits
for the French sector,
which is the case, these exchanges are provided for
by the common fisheries policy and
are essential to optimize there
consumption of our quotas two exchanges
of blue have been validated since the beginning
of 2024 by my predecessor whom
I salute for a total of 22,000 tonnes
allowing the Emerald vessel under the
French flag to fish several
hundred tonnes of Arctic toggle
the new exchange which I have just
asked my administration to validate
concerns 15,000 tonnes of Merland bleu
and will allow the emerald ship under the
French flag to access a new
quota of 500 tonnes of
additional toggle I therefore say it with clarity
that these exchanges do not constitute a
definitive transfer of fishing quotas
which must remain under the
national flag and they are not done without
compensation in the same way on the
environmental level I specify that the stock
de merlbleu is in a good state of
conservation and is the subject of
controlled exploitation on the basis
of scientific advice ladies and
gentlemen the deputies the great fishing
is an integral component of the
French fishing the compag des pê de
saint- malot uses nearly 300 employees
including 70 sailors these jobs all depend
directly
thank you MP
yes thank you for your answer you
therefore confirm that France exchanged
22,000 tonnes of Merl bleu for less
than 1000 tonnes of macro it is totally
unfair and very bad for
French fishing I thank you,
Mr.
Deputy, the floor is given to Mr. Laurent
Croisier for the
Democratic group, thank you, Madam President,
Madam Minister of National Education,
a former President of the Republic
should not say
that, pretend that
primary school teachers only work 6 months
per year nor the work of preparation for
nursery school testifies to a
profound ignorance while
national education is going through a crisis
of evocation measuring the violence of its
words disconnected from reality of the
profession of
teacher teachers deserve that
we respect them it deserves that we
support them in the name of the
democratic groups I would like to reaffirm our
confidence in all the teachers
of our country to those who doubt
their commitment to teaching even if
only 'a week in a nursery school
you will then understand the requirements of this
profession the teachers are the pillars
of our Republic they are the
guardians of the promise of emancip
the front line fighters against
social assignment a bulwark against
obscurantism none of the great
challenges of this century cannot be met
without them understand that our fight to
preserve the 4000 teaching positions
of which the finance bill is
not just a budgetary question it is to
fight to offer teachers
good working conditions. teaching to
students of good
learning conditions it is to guarantee that the
teacher will be in front of each
student by making the decline in
demographics an opportunity it is finally
to preserve the classes and the schools
particularly in our
laughing communes madame the minister to place
the school in the heart of the Republic raise
its level and its standards restore
the authority and respect of teachers
and the heart of the commitment that we
have in common what concrete measures do
you intend to take to respond to the
challenges of the attractiveness of the profession
teacher thank you Mr.
Deputy, the floor is given to Madame AG,
Minister of National Education
[Applause],
thank you Madam President,
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Mr. Deputy Croisier, I do
not agree with the remarks that you
mentioned, in fact I do not I do
n't recognize it I have been in the field for a
while and I have only met
teachers who are very committed who
are very passionate who do not spare
their time who do not spare their
efforts who spare no effort to
support our students And accompany them
on the path to success I am
convinced that with, as you said,
with a very strong school we will
obviously have an entire France
which will be much stronger and my only
objective as you have said it is
clearly to raise the level I
announced a set of
ambitious measures a set of measures
intended to support each of our
students on this path to success because
clearly I want to repeat it here
success cannot be cannot
be in our schools the privilege of
a few the budget today of
our school it is 63 billion
euros it is still 834 million
more than last year it is
still a first victory
obviously I would have liked to be able to
debate with you about this budget in
the hemicycle I understood that it will not be
possible but I saw all the
amendments you had tabled with
your colleagues and I saw them well I
saw how much you and your colleagues
had therefore contributed to this debate and
other groups moreover have done the
same you ask me in particular about
the attractiveness of the profession it is a real
challenge we started by
increasing the salary of our
teachers it is a first step we
still have one more step to go do to
work on what we call
career environments we also have
to work on the conditions of the
profession you mentioned which are
very difficult and I myself will open
a project on respect for our
teachers authority of our
teachers who must be respected I
hope that the entire nation
moreover, respects our teachers, we
have important work to be launched on
this subject and then the social agenda of my
ministry will also be reopened to
discuss more widely all
the conditions for exercising the profession
like you, I hope that the school be
this place where we can break down the
inequalities of destiny and truly say
that success once again should
not be the privilege of a few
but our school must be an
opportunity for all to succeed tomorrow,
thank you, thank you, Madam
Minister the session of questions to the
Government is over next
session Tuesday 19 November at 3 p.m. question
to the government draft
end-of-management finance law for 2024
organic law proposal reforming the
financing of public broadcasting law
proposal aimed at securing the
mechanism for purging nullities and
law proposal aiming to extend the
exemption of use of restaurant vouchers
for any food product thank you for
listening the session is adjourned