Ranking Member Scott Led Opposition to Extreme Republicans’ H.R. 5339

Committee on Education & the Workforce Democrats
55 followers
Oct 25, 2024
rise an opposition to HR 5339 the
so-called protecting Americans
investments from work policies act this
bill packages four separate bills that
the committee on education and Workforce
reported on Partyline uh votes the uh HJ
uh
5339 relates to what's known as
environmental social and governance or
ESG investing many of us believe that
workers should be able to invest in a
way that reflects their values whether
combating climate change or promoting
health and labor standards without
sacrificing investment returns and to be
clear this kind of investing is not at
odds with making a profit in fact it
makes good Financial sense to carefully
consider Investments that account for a
company's uh exposure to such liability
is is high liability risks fossil fuel
dependent business practices or
vulnerability to sea level rise like
whether or not an asset is going to be
underwater in 15 years it' be nice to
know that but you couldn't shouldn't be
prohibited from even considering it
these are among the factors that could
cause the stock to suffer in
longterm over the longterm Horizon and
consider that workers often contribute
to their retirement accounts for decades
before drawing down their savings and it
makes perfectly good sense for the
managing those managing the workers
accounts to consider long-term impacts
when making investment decisions ESG
investment is sound profit centered risk
mitigation strategy in the financial
services industry recognizes it for
example State Street Global advisors one
of the largest asset managers noted as a
fiduciary they have and I quote a duty
to act prudently and in the best
interest of their clients which
increasingly includes consideration of
environmental social and governance
factors relevant to the performance of
the companies of which our clients
invest unquote Trump Administration
issued a rule that impove impos needless
barriers and onerous requirements
related to ESG investing fortunately the
Biden Harris Administration reverse
course and finalized the sensible rule
clarifying that a planed fiduciaries may
consider ESG factors when they make
decisions retirement plan participants
and let's be clear the rule is not a
mandate HR 5339 codifies the Trump era
ESG rule it also codifies the Trump eror
rule that would disenfranchise Fran
fiduciaries from exercising their
shareholder rights on behalf of workers
the bill also undermines efforts to
increasingly to increase diversity among
asset managers this is a worthwhile
Endeavor as as the GAO noted a few years
ago that only 1% of the7 trillion dollar
in global assets under manage under
management are managed by firms owned by
women or people of color there's also
research to suggest that non-diverse
firms do not outperform firm outperform
diverse uh firms across all asset
classes and some HR 5339 takes us
backwards and under retirement
professionals who are legally bound to
make prudent decisions for workers and
retirees so I urge opposition to the
bill and Reser and reserve the balance
of my town
