Ranking Member Scott Speaks in Opposition to H.R. 1048, the DETERRENT Act

Committee on Education & the Workforce Democrats
55 followers
6 Video Views·Mar 26, 2025
thank you Mr Chair I rise in opposition
to HR 1048 the the deterrent act Let's
acknowledge first of all the elephant in
the room Just last month the Secretary
of Education fired half of the
department staff and last week President
Trump signed an executive order aimed at
dismantling the entire department This
administration is actively working to
eliminate an agency that has long been
the cornerstone of ensuring that every
child in America has access to a quality
education Today we're discussing a bill
that would add even more responsibility
to the very department that you're
trying to destroy It's almost as if
you're trying to dismantle the agency
but at the same time recognizing its
critical role and and piling on
additional duties Uh this is not only
nonsensical but reckless You can't argue
that a department of education is
unnecessary and then hand it more work
expecting it to function without staff
resources or the leadership that it
needs This Congress has a responsibility
to address the many pressing issues that
students face like closing the
achievement gaps improving college
affordability and ending gun violence in
schools Instead we find ourselves
considering bills that target vulnerable
groups And now this bill which risk
isolating America from the global
partnerships in research and education
Instead of requiring institutions to
report foreign gifts or contracts large
enough to exert any influence the bill
before us would require institutions to
report gifts of any value from people
who are not US citizens if they are from
a list of quote countries of concern a
list that is difficult to find and will
be very difficult to keep track of
because it is subject to change The
Department of Education has already lost
half its staff and if this bill passes
it would have to process an
exponentially larger number of reports
than it has to process already Now how
can we place these new responsibilities
on an agency that's being hollowed out
And how can we expect it to manage these
complex issues when the institution is
being dismantled HR 1048 would also
impose burdensome and unnecessary
penalties on institutions for working
with international scholars and
organizations Since faculty really don't
know their colleagues citizenship t
status it is reason to believe the
discrimination will follow and
institutions will be incentivized from
hiring talented international faculty Uh
now Mr Speaker present law already
requires reporting of any gift large
enough to exert any influence over a
university And this bill requires a
reporting of gifts of any value That is
cup of coffee a donut from people who
are from so-called countries of concern
and requires the Department of Education
to process all of those reports The same
Department of Education that just lost
half its staff And if the problem is
millions of dollars in unreported gifts
requiring the reporting of free donuts
cannot be the answer Mr Speaker I
reserve Mr Chairman I reserve the
balance of my
