When the United States entered World War I, its military had only a small number of machine guns, spread across four different models. Due to a limited defense budget and low prioritization of automatic weapons, the U.S. had not heavily invested in machine gun development.
Meanwhile, following the limited success of his gas-operated Model 1895 machine gun, John Browning had begun developing a more reliable recoil-operated design. By 1910, this effort became serious, and in 1915, Browning partnered with Colt, granting them exclusive rights to his new design. Together, they refined and improved the weapon.
In 1917, as the U.S. prepared to enter combat in Europe and urgently needed machine guns, the military held open trials for new designs. Colt and Browning submitted their prototype, which proved to be the clear standout—firing 40,000 rounds with only a single part failure and no malfunctions outside of ammunition or belt issues. The military quickly adopted the design and rushed it into production.
Colt later authorized Remington and New England Westinghouse to manufacture the guns, while Browning patriotically accepted a lump-sum royalty payment from the government—approximately $3.5 million less than he was contractually owed—to avoid profiting excessively from the war effort.
Although Browning’s M1917 machine guns saw limited combat before the Armistice—first used in September 1918—they became a mainstay of U.S. military firepower, especially during World War II. The original M1917 would later be upgraded to the improved M1917A1 model.
The example featured in this video is an original World War I M1917, mounted on a rare M1917 tripod—an exceptional piece of military history.
Hi guys, thanks for tuning in to another video on ForgottenWeapons.com.
I'm Ian McCollum, and I'm here today at the James D. Julia Auction House
taking a look at some of the guns that they're going to be selling
in their upcoming Spring of 2018 Firearms Auction.
And today we have a Browning Model of 1917.
Now this is a little bit special because it is still an original M1917.
The vast majority of these guns were either reworked
... after World War One and before World War Two,
or were physically updated to the new pattern of M1917A1.
This one is still in its original World War One configuration, and that's pretty cool.
It is also sitting on an original M1917 tripod,
which is perhaps even more difficult to find. These are very rare today.
Again, the vast majority of them were replaced with M1917A1 tripods.
So, a little bit about the history of this gun.
This is John Browning's first recoil-operated machine gun.
Browning had originally developed a gas-operated machine gun in 1895
that was manufactured by Colt. It has a big swinging lever under the barrel up here.
And it got the affectionate name of Potato Digger,
because if you mounted it too low to the ground,
that swinging hammer would dig a hole in the ground like it was going after potatoes.
That gun was not particularly successful.
They did sell, they weren't a flop, but nobody on a large-scale military sense,
nobody was really all that interested in them.
And so Browning took that lesson to heart and decided that
really the method to use for a good machine gun was recoil operation.
That's what Maxim had used, and Browning took to that pretty well.
So he actually started his first experiments with what would become this gun in 1901.
But he didn't get really serious about it until 1910.
He took some time in there to develop the Browning Auto 5,
the world's first recoil-operated semi-auto shotgun, you know, little stuff.
In 1910 he really started perfecting what would become the Model of 1917 machine gun.
He was meeting with Colt, and in fact by 1915 he had the design well enough established
that he went and talked to Colt and started to work with them in tandem
to develop not just to finalise the gun, but also to develop the production tooling
and to get ready to actually produce these guns.
Both Browning and Colt could clearly see that with World War One raging,
there was going to be an interest in modern machine guns.
If it wasn't the United States, somebody would be wanting these guns.
So he and Colt together spent a couple of years perfecting the design.
And when the ... US government finally realised,
holy crap, we need machine guns, they actually adopted the Vickers gun in 1915
and contracted with Colt to start making them.
But then in 1917, realising that the Vickers was huge and expensive and really kind of out of date,
they held a major machine gun trial at Springfield Armoury, had like 14 different guns show up.
And the winner of that trial, by a long shot, was John Browning's Model of 1917 machine gun.
It was so good that like the head of the testing board wrote a letter,
not just approving the gun, but emphatically urging that they immediately buy 10,000 of them,
and describing John Browning as, I don't remember the exact words,
but something to the effect of the world's master machine gun mechanic.
The test required a 20,000 round endurance trial,
and the Browning handled that so successfully
that just for kicks they put another 20,000 rounds through it.
The whole time they only had one malfunction that couldn't be traced to either bad ammo or bad belts.
That's not too bad.
So the gun ... was formally adopted in 1917 by the US military.
And one of the issues they then immediately had was one of production,
because Colt was making Vickers guns and making a bunch of other firearms,
and didn't have the production capacity to make as many of these guns as the US military wanted.
So ... the government convinced Colt to give up its exclusive licence to the gun,
which it had gotten from John Browning.
In exchange for a million dollar lump sum payment, which honestly Colt thought was way too low.
But as a result, Colt allowed other companies to manufacture 1917s for the US government.
Remington and New England Westinghouse would both take up production.
Westinghouse in particular was well suited to the job because in 1917 the ... well,
Russia dropped out of the war as a result of the Communist Revolution.
And that left Westinghouse, who had been making Mosin-Nagants for the Russians,
with a lot of excess production capacity.
So they were able to start making 1917 Brownings.
The Colt company actually manufactured the tooling and the gauges
for Remington and Westinghouse to use.
That was part of their payment, and they got royalties on the guns as well.
One of the government requirements was that parts from all three manufacturers
had to be completely interchangeable,
so that there would never be any issue of trying to sort Colt parts from Westinghouse parts,
from Remington parts, and trying to deal with the logistics of repairing and replacing guns
when you couldn't actually count on any part being fitting in any gun.
So the way to do that was to have one company make all of the tooling and gauges,
and that's what Colt did.
As a result, Colt was actually the last of the three companies to get the guns into production.
And they made the fewest actually during the war.
Westinghouse was the first to have guns actually produced,
and Westinghouse ended up making the most of them.
By the end of 1918 it was like 56,600 of these guns had been manufactured.
Now they started shipping over to France in 1918,
and they were actually demonstrated to a group of French Ordnance Officers
in late June of 1918 in France.
And both these and Browning Automatic Rifles actually.
And they met with a tremendously positive reception.
Apparently they ran a few thousand rounds through each of the guns,
and they all ran absolutely flawlessly.
And apparently the French officers were quite taken aback by this.
They apparently had never seen automatic firearms that actually ran without any stoppages.
So, cool, good on us, good on John Browning.
First actual combat use of these guns was with the 79th Division,
the US 79th Division in September of 1918.
So right at the end of the war they actually managed to get the guns into combat.
And apparently they did remarkably well.
You know, basically as long as the gun continues working,
what more do you expect from it?
And these guns just continued working.
So, one interesting little point.
When the US started sending over Brownings,
of course the US troops had been training on other firearms,
and so they needed training,
introduction to how these things actually worked and how to operate them.
And one of the officers who went over to do that training
was none other than John Browning's son, Val Browning.
So there are a number of pictures of Val Browning in France
instructing American troops on how to use both the Browning automatic rifle
and the Browning water-cooled heavy machine gun.
As Val commented later, he was probably the ... person on earth
most familiar with these guns, with the sole exception of his father, John Moses.
Alright, a couple of features to take a quick look at here.
Starting at the front, this is of course a water-cooled machine gun.
So this water jacket is filled with a couple of pints of water.
And ... not everyone understands exactly how water cooling works.
What this does is it keeps the barrel's temperature limited to the boiling point of water.
Once this water jacket hits 212 degrees Fahrenheit, or 100 Celsius,
the water will start boiling.
It turns into steam, it comes down this hose and into this condensing tank,
where, because it's not being heated any longer by the firing and the barrel,
it recondenses into liquid water where it can eventually be poured back into the jacket.
There is no circulating system on these guns,
nor in fact on virtually any water-cooled machine guns.
Now because once water hits the boiling point,
any additional thermal energy that it gets doesn't actually increase the temperature,
it just converts the water into steam.
So as long as there is water remaining in this jacket,
it doesn't get any hotter than 100 degrees Celsius.
People think that like the water cooling jacket means that this thing stays cool to the touch.
It does not.
With the guns firing, you know, in a sustained roll,
this thing is going to be about 212 degrees Fahrenheit to the touch,
and it will burn the crap out of you.
However, that's not a dangerous temperature as far as the barrel and the metallurgy is concerned.
So that's how water cooling actually works.
We have a little plug here that goes in this vent.
There is a tube inside that prevents this from leaking.
We have a fill plug on the back, which you can't see from there.
We have a drain plug right here on the bottom.
And then a condensing hose that you use with a condensing can.
By the way, this is like a piece of a lead sinker weight or something.
This should be a cork, which normally would go in here when it's not in use.
You can use this gun without the condensing hose or can set up.
It just means that ... what happens is as the water starts to turn to steam,
it comes out here as steam, and then goes straight up,
and makes this big steam plume telling the enemy exactly where there's a machine gun.
The reason for using a condensing can, in addition to conserving the water,
was to prevent there from being any sort of signal showing where the gun was.
So typically using the can, you'd actually put some liquid water in the bottom
so that steam came out under the layer of the liquid water,
and that immediately recondensed it so you didn't have any big plume of steam coming up.
The Browning had a fairly complex rear sight.
This big knob is windage adjustment, and you can see how that pivots the sight from side to side.
And then you have, push this button, slide it up and down,
and that goes out to something like 2,800 yards.
And then you have your choice of five different rear apertures.
So that one there at the bottom is actually a rear notch style of aperture,
and then you have four round apertures that you can use as you prefer.
There was also a plain rear open notch if you left the sight folded down.
That's your battle sight zero if you don't want to have this thing up in the way,
or you don't need to be firing at extended range.
The side of the tripod mount has a bracket for holding an ammo can.
I don't have the appropriate can to go in there, unfortunately, but that's what this is for.
And then ammunition fed in this side of the gun on the left.
We can go ahead and open the top cover here, and you can see inside the action.
If you're into machine guns, you will definitely recognise this system.
This peg travels in this track on the bolt.
So as the bolt goes back and forth, this arm is shifted side to side,
and this pawl picks up a round from the belt, pulls it into the gun,
and then, being held in place by the extractor,
this then snaps down over the round to repeat the cycle each time it's fired.
You can see notches on the barrel here.
That is for adjusting headspace of the gun, which is something you have to do
when a new barrel is put in, or if a barrel's chamber becomes excessively worn.
This is a recoil-operated gun, so when I pull the bolt handle back,
you can see that the barrel actually reciprocates slightly.
And that's what functioned the gun.
Unlike many machine guns today, the Browning actually fires from a closed bolt.
So this is the standard firing.
This is what it would look like when it's ready to fire with a round chambered,
and then the extractor here hooked over the next round in the belt right there.
There's an opening on the right side of the receiver,
so the empty belt continues out the right side.
This used solid cloth belts, typically 250 rounds in length.
The tripod allowed precise elevation adjustment.
You can see this is in mils, and it gives you nice solid clicks as you rotate it.
And you can see that this elevates the gun as I turn it.
And the trigger on the back is actually styled very much like the Browning 1895,
the potato digger.
A single pistol grip, there was some debate over whether to do this
versus a twin pistol grip like on the Vickers, and a trigger that lifts up.
There's also a sliding safety on the back here.
That is the fire position, and that's the safe position,
which simply blocks the trigger from moving.
Browning 1917 kind of seemed to appear fully formed out of thin air in World War One,
at least as far as the public was concerned.
Basically because Colt and Browning had the foresight to put it
through a lot of its development before the military actually expressed an interest.
However, as anyone familiar with firearms manufacture would expect,
there were a lot of hiccups getting the gun actually into production,
especially coordinating between three different companies.
The difference between a handful of handmade prototypes
and an actual production line producing tens of thousands of guns is a very substantial one.
And there were a bunch of small changes that had to be made
in order to actually scale this up for mass production.
In addition, once the guns actually got some field combat use in Europe,
there were a couple other problems that were discovered.
The most significant one was a weakness in the bottom plate of the gun.
So when firing, because of the mechanics,
there's some energy that tends to be dumped down.
The bottom plate of the gun kind of gets battered on.
And it turned out that they hadn't really made that part strong enough.
So when the 1917A1 update was done, that was ... one of the major things that was addressed.
So that's something to look for on these guns.
If you see just a plain square receiver like this,
right here, without any reinforcing, that's an original 1917 receiver.
One of the other problems they had was leaky water jackets.
That's something that any ... water-cooled machine gun shooter will be used to.
But in this case the problem actually came from poor quality control,
especially by Westinghouse, on the soldering of the water jacket onto the trunnions.
So some of the guns in Europe leaked fairly badly.
A lot of them leaked a little bit.
It was something that was not that difficult for armourers to fix,
but they had to take off and re-solder the water jackets.
And that would also be addressed in the 1917A1 improvement program.
We will take a look at a 1917A1 at a later date,
along with the mechanics of how this disassembles,
and what all of the internal pieces are doing.
But I think that's about it for this time, that's about all we have time for.
Well, if you collect World War Two firearms, especially machine guns,
and you want the absolute cream of the crop, this is quite the rare one to find.
In its actual original World War One configuration.
So if you take a look at the description text below,
you'll find a link to the James Julia catalogue page for this guy.
That'll give you their pictures, their description, their value estimate,
everything else you would need to place a bid on it in the upcoming auction.
It is of course a fully transferable, Curio and Relic eligible,
NFA registered machine gun.
So as long as you're willing to go through the NFA process to own it,
it could be yours.
Thanks for watching.