Today I am speaking with Ken Hackathorn about submachine guns - specifically the Thompson and the MP5. Mr Hackathorn has an extensive resume that he is quite humble about, but I will point out that it includes being a US Army Special Forces Small Arms Instructor. He has a great deal of practical knowledge about military small arms, and an unusually insightful perspective. So if you want to know why the reality of the Thompson is not the same as it's image and reputation, or why the MP5 is the best submachine gun that has been or ever will be, then settle down for a fun half hour!
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This discussion examines the M1 Thompson and the H&K MP5, contrasting the Thompson's status as a heavy, culturally iconic WWII relic with the MP5's technical superiority. While the Thompson is praised for its historical value and role in specific combat scenarios, the MP5 is highlighted as the evolutionary peak of the submachine gun due to its precision, durability, and engineering.
Hi guys, thanks for tuning in again. I'm Ian McCollum, and I'm here today with Mr. Ken Hackathorn.
And we're taking a look at this pig of a submachine gun, Thompson.
What we have here is an M1 Thompson, the simplified World War Two version.
And this is an interesting firearm in that it has a tremendous popularity in just American pop culture.
This is like the quintessential American submachine gun.
Gangsters, John Wayne, Marines, everybody. It must be a fantastic gun.
And yet, amongst a lot of people who are serious firearm shooters, not collectors, but shooters,
that's not really how the Thompson's seen. I personally really dislike...
And by the way, it's actually image-wise almost universal.
You go all over the world, and the image of a Thompson submachine gun is kind of like...
It's like the image of, say, a single-action Army Colt. People see that, and they think,
American cowboy. It's American. Believe it or not, the Luger has an image. At least it did at one time.
The Thompson is a uniquely iconic American firearm.
And by the way, probably more mythology to it than most American small arms,
in the sense that people accredit it with things that it can't do.
The people brag about it. I'll give you an example. One of the classic ones.
I, as a grown-up, used to, again, talking to World War II vets,
and you would ask about the Thompson submachine gun.
Oh, you know, if you shoot that thing, if you weren't careful,
you know, it would just climb clear up over your head.
Well, that tells you they never fired one. It's a heavy gun.
This thing weighs more than an M1 Garand.
Yeah. I used to do a demo where I would take it out and say,
okay, you all heard that, right?
And with one hand, and dump a magazine, a 30-round magazine.
It'll go up a little bit, but it just stays right there and chugs away.
So, again, everybody likes to claim, well, when I was in the Army, I carried a Tommy gun.
I love the guys that, Vietnam vets, yeah, I carried a Thompson when I was in it.
And you go, really? That is a heavy slug.
Yeah.
And when you carry the spare magazine support, it's a lot of weight.
They were not as popular as everybody thinks.
I tell people, when you talk to Samuel World War II vets about the Thompson,
what they thought about it is, the guys that were tankers,
or the guys, the guns carried in a jeep or in a vehicle,
it was a popular weapon.
The guy that had to hump it, I never talked to anybody that said,
gee, that was my choice in a weapon. Nobody.
I remember one of my buddies in high school, my early shooting buddy,
I mean, Mike Patterson, and his father's name was Gerald Patterson,
and he fought in the Pacific Marine.
And he was not a very big fan of Thompson.
He was actually somewhat, believe it or not,
he liked the M1 carbine far better than he did the Thompson.
He was not a big fan of the Thompson.
He said, but you know, we carried it for one reason.
One guy in the squad would carry the Thompson.
It was such a slug, you rotated that responsibility on a daily basis.
But when it came time that somebody had to go up and clear a Japanese pillbox,
you passed up the Thompson, a couple spare mags you stuck in your pocket,
and a handful of grenades you get to them,
because the guy who had to crawl up, pitch the grenades through the firing slit,
and then run around the back and clear it with a firearm,
the Thompson was a gun of choice.
It worked superbly.
After that, nobody had any use for it.
You know, I think there's, getting slightly off topic,
I think there's a bit of a misconception about how combat in the Pacific often worked,
in that it was kind of like specific directed target objectives.
Like, we're going to clear that pillbox.
We don't have, it's not like World War I,
where this whole line of guys trying to go forward simultaneously.
And it tended to be, by nature, jungle terrain.
Yeah.
Now, in Europe, the same thing I've talked,
like, as most people know, when we conceptualized the airborne divisions,
as kind of, if you will, shock troops,
the submachine gun initially, probably more and more issued and deployed on D-Day
by the 82nd and 101st per capita than any other time in American history, of submachine guns.
Okay.
And if you look at any of the old footage or still photos,
you'll see guys loading on the C-47s with Thompson submachine guns strapped.
And the Grease Gun had not come online yet.
So they were used.
But one of the guys learned is, you know, yeah, if you're fighting it out at 20 meters,
a Thompson can be pretty efficient.
If you're fighting it out at 100 meters,
you know, it's got a trajectory like a loaded toolbox, let's be honest.
And it's just not a very...
They're heavy.
They're heavy and clumsy.
Another thing, by the way, like we talked about the carbine,
we accepted a level of reliability in an unloaded weapon in that era,
but we wouldn't accept today.
They were never as reliable as people want you to believe.
Again, they have to be well lubricated.
So, again, the springs were better then, and the guns were probably more reliable.
But, you know, that one, for example, has a fixed sight.
You can't adjust the sights.
My experience with those, I've got one.
Mine's a great old gun.
Doesn't shoot to the sights.
And there's not much in the way to fix it.
I've actually bent the front sight here,
but not enough to change the point of impact to where it needs to be.
So, and I'll tell you one unique thing about the Thompson.
A lot of people don't...
If you look at it, the design and the angle of stock,
there's a lot of drop for a conventional firearm.
So to fire, it's not really that comfortable.
If you tuck it under your armpit and fire it like they do in the movies,
believe it or not, with a little practice, you can do pretty well with it.
Surprising.
I mean, I love demoing it, again, at what we'll call CQB distances.
This technique is kind of, it's the old deal.
Wherever your eye looks, you keep the muzzle where your eye is,
and you can shoot it fairly effectively.
As you all know, long bursts with a .45 caliber submachine gun
is not a real good idea.
But if you're shooting two, three, four, five round bursts,
it's, you can do fairly well with it.
But I've yet to meet anybody that said,
The reason we had that thing is because it was really the only practical choice.
That's all we had in the war.
And they pretty much immediately started looking for alternatives.
And it's kind of interesting.
I mean, the cost of making this one, this is back in the day,
one of these machines had to be...
It was terrible then, and imagine what...
I remember some of the data when Thompson was selling them to the Brits.
It was $200 a piece.
And they were charging gold bullion.
Yeah, they weren't getting that.
The Brits weren't getting them on credit.
I tell you, it's an iconic weapon.
Its image is projected in movies and television.
It's not what everybody thinks.
It's actually more complex than people believe.
Now, this was certainly a simplified version.
Right.
Yeah, the early ones with the Blishlock, there's a lot going on.
Very, very...
And by the way, they always played around with cycler rates.
Original .21 Thompsons that we all think about, the gangster guns,
cycler were too fast.
The .28A1s were basically...
The government, the Marine Corps bought them.
As you know, actually, the Navy was approaching.
And one of the things was, you've got to slow it down.
And one of the things they did do with the .28A1s,
they reduced the cycler rate from, say...
.21s are close to 900 rounds per minute.
Most people don't realize that.
They're really fast.
They slowed the .28A1s down to about seven.
Okay.
And if you shoot one, it's dramatically more controllable.
And by the time they simplified this gun to a direct blowback
without the Blish system and all that,
actually, the cycler rates tend to be a bit more like 800.
It's like an MP5.
And a .45, it's a lot of movement.
So I tell people, yeah, these guns were around.
We gave them to everybody after World War II.
Every other country got a bunch of them.
But I don't know anybody that will say,
I carried one in combat exclusively and I loved it.
I've never heard that.
The grease gun, for all that it looks like a horrible plumbing disaster.
Actually, it's far superior.
It's a great gun.
Yeah.
One of the interesting things with submachine guns,
all submachine guns of this era,
is if you look at original .21 or .28,
remember it had the Lyman sights.
Actually, the sight system was pretty worthless.
If you fold it up for percentage...
Aperture is so small, you couldn't see anything.
If you fold it down, it's not very good.
In many ways, this aperture sight was better.
And if you've ever looked at an M1,
it has a hole, which basically is for like 50 meters.
And then on the top, it's got a notch, which is like for 100 meters.
Okay.
Because a .45, you know, has got that...
Substantial.
...that rainbow trajectory.
But again, I always tell people,
this set the stage for a submachine gun.
We would call this a first-generation gun.
Right.
We quickly discovered that, in this case, the MP40, MP38 and .40,
really were, again, the nucleus for the future development of submachine guns.
Yep.
Stampings, simplicity.
The box magazines, you know, this system in World War II,
the drum was not...
Looks good in the movies, not very practical.
Drums fell off.
They had problems with the magazine catch not being strong enough.
And so this gun was set up for box magazine.
Again, everybody I ever talked to, 30s were the norm,
20s nobody had much use for.
If I remember correctly, they started with 20s and then went to 30s?
That was an early complaint, we need more rounds.
And so they went to the...
But you can imagine, if you had a 20-round mag in this gun,
at the cyclic rate, probably four or five pulls of trigger, you got an empty gun.
Right.
Yeah, that's not much.
So putting another 10 rounds in,
maybe you got a couple, at least two or three more trigger pulls.
Yeah.
The UD-42 was the same way.
High rate of fire, 20-round mags.
But if you're a gun guy, you look at all steel, beautiful walnut.
I mean, probably the butt plates, they're only stamping an entire gun.
And that might even be milled too.
And this thing is obviously stamping.
But I mean, overall, it's a cool gun from a collector standpoint
or from a historical standpoint.
Everybody I know used to say, you ought to shoot one once.
Right.
And I tell people, if you get a chance to shoot one,
buy the ammo, buy good quality ammo.
I get people say, I want to shoot a Thompson.
Fine.
I don't want to shoot your reloads in my gun or commercial reloads.
I want good quality ammo.
These things are brutally expensive today.
And so, but I tell them, buy enough ammo so you can load a 30-round magazine
and put it like this and do a movie.
Just burn, I mean, burn a magazine.
If not, without practice, it's a waste of ammo.
But God, it's a good feeling.
You know, it's kind of say, okay, this is part of being an American,
to be able to go out and run one of these.
But having said that, as submachine guns go,
it was really obsolete by the time it was that this gun was an issue.
Right.
And after World War II, World War II and after,
we saw the submachine gun's popularity peak.
Development went way, you know, way up.
Through the 50s, submachine guns still were popular around the world.
I told her about it.
The MP5 was the final, to me, evolutionary step in submachine guns.
And it's, without a doubt, the best one that's ever been made.
I'm a huge fan of it.
But let's be honest, it's still popular in many places in the world, as you know.
Yeah, very.
But having said that, especially the more compact,
short versions of various assault rifles have basically made that an obsolete platform.
Right.
Yeah.
People are kind of going away from submachine guns in general these days.
You still see them in Europe in the law enforcement applications quite a bit.
But, you know, even they're starting to evolve towards the super compact,
let's say 5.56 carbines.
5.56 and stuff.
But yeah, that, to me, is as good as the submachine gun has ever been.
And this, from a historical context, is way cool.
Well, you think about that.
1921 is when the first commercial Thompsons were actually being sold.
That's three years after the first submachine guns ever.
Yeah.
It's a really early gun.
I think a lot of people think of it as a World War Two gun, but it's not.
That's really more like a World War One gun.
Yeah, and most people, if you're a firearms buff,
you know that this gun was designed originally as a concept of the trench group.
Right.
That once the troops get into the trenches,
then the .03 Springfield with a bayonet was really not a very handy weapon.
Germans let it field again, if you go back and look at the MP18.
They were actually used in combat.
Unfortunately, the tide had turned.
But we quickly said, we've got to do something different.
And Colonel Thompson, or General Thompson at the time, to his credit,
said, I've got an idea.
And he made the first prototype, I think, in 1919.
Yeah, the Annihilator.
And so he was thinking in terms, this is our response.
And of course, we were a .45 caliber pistol, right?
So he built it for a .45 cartridge.
And by the way, once it was introduced, the military lost all interest in it.
They didn't get it.
He kind of struggled.
Yeah. Oh, yeah.
The company did not do well.
They eeked by on a few little orders for a long time.
And sadly, a lot of people remember this thing as a gangster gun.
Right.
Yeah.
Well, that's why the British didn't buy them in the first place.
The British looked at these in particular, and kind of submachine guns in general,
as the guns of ne'er-do-well gangsters.
Yeah.
As a matter of fact, you remember, there was a famous picture of Winston Churchill
holding a .28 A1 Thompson with the drum.
Yep.
You know, the cigar.
And a cigar.
And he was portrayed in an image.
Because remember, in England, like America today, politics were, you know,
there were two parties.
And some people, the opposite party was a very conservative, a very anti-conservative party.
And a lot of them are very anti-Winston Churchill.
And he was portrayed as a gangster.
Yeah, for sure.
So, I tell people, cool gun, but it's kind of like the O3 Springfield.
Yeah, that's a good comparison.
It's a cool gun, beautifully made.
In its time, it was really a good weapon.
But in a lot of ways, you look at the O3 Springfield,
candidly, by the time it was kind of, its involvement,
and it went through a lot of stages.
But by the time in World War II, when we basically entered World War II
with O3 Springfield, most people don't realize that.
It was already an obsolete.
Long obsolete, yeah.
It was obsolete in World War I.
They had their 1917 Enfields that were better.
And again, if you look at the, again, to kind of diverge,
but if you look at the 1917 Enfield, if nothing else,
from the sight picture, this is a superior weapon.
Yeah, oh, absolutely.
I think in a bunch of ways it was.
So, for people who aren't maybe intimately familiar with the MP5,
what is it that makes this the best submachine gun ever?
One is, again, the H&K, basically, you know,
this is a, in essence, an involvement of the G3 concept,
the roller-locking systems, shrunk down to a pistol cartridge.
And because Germany was still very,
and Europe was very submachine gun oriented,
they said, well, we've got to build a compatible submachine gun
to our product line, and the MP5 was the end result.
One of the most unique things that made it different
from submachine guns that were common is its closed bolt design.
Most open bolt guns, like a Thompson,
you've got a real heavy mass to the bolt.
That's part of the retardant and controls the cycle rate.
Lighter the mass, the faster the guns are.
Well, the problem is when the gun's, the bolt's back,
and you've got, say, a three pound chunk of steel,
and you pull the trigger, and the gun is disturbed.
And you'll see that at the end of someone's magazine.
And that's not a flinch.
That's three pounds of mass going forward.
You see that in all of them.
This thing, because it's closed bolt, eliminates that issue.
Right.
So it's far more accurate from an accuracy and control standpoint.
This is gun range supreme.
It's got a good trigger compared to other submachine guns, typically.
You know, the selectors mounted on,
this is a later one with the anti-controls,
but the selectors, you've got safe all the way down.
You've got semi, one shot.
This one's three round burst and then full auto.
And the bottom line is, so the one drawback to this weapon platform,
and I've trained a few folks with MP5s over my life,
and the one of the drawbacks design-wise,
if you hold an MP5, it's like you would normally grasp it.
Reaching the safety, and I've got a big hand,
so I can actually reach it, but it's not easy to disengage.
It's hard.
You have to learn, another trick to the MP5
is you put the buttstock on the outside of your arm.
This allows your hand to roll around and get good leverage on the selector.
So this is your ready gun position.
And what you do is when you want to deploy it,
one click, somehow you're ready to go.
With the Anvi, a lot of guys run the safety with the trigger finger.
And it's easier.
But the standard MP5 SEF group is on the left side.
And some of us say, well, I want an extension.
And they did actually make an extended selector,
but most places in the world, you get the standard one.
And you just got to remember, if the buttstock's inside your arm,
you're going to have a hard time taking off safety.
The buttstock on the outside allows your hand to roll around right to there,
and you can drive it.
So control-wise, accuracy-wise,
by the way, the lifespan of these guns is amazing.
I've trained places around the world where the MP5s, the guys were using,
and in some places, well, they do keep accurate records
of how many rounds the guns fire.
And I've had guys in classes with guns that have 75,000 rounds.
Now, they've had to replace some parts,
but the guns really do hold up well.
It's not bad for a standard receiver.
And again, remember, the Germans, H&K is an interesting company.
They over-engineer everything.
And for example, one of their requirements is
that you can lodge a bullet in the barrel of any HK firearm
and shoot a bullet behind it,
and the barrel will not fracture or rupture or cause any damage.
And even that goes to the 556.
That's one of the requirements.
Most cases is if you drive...
A lot of times, you'll drive both bullets out.
And you have the balls in the barrel, but guess what?
Guns still work.
They're that anal about this stuff.
They designed a magazine, probably, in my opinion,
the best submachine gun magazine in history.
The original ones were straight,
and they learned that feed angle was better with a curved mag.
It's a dual feed.
It's easy to load.
You know, single feed submachine gun magazines are a bitch.
They kind of suck.
You don't have to be using the Thompson.
It's dual feed.
Yeah.
Easy to load.
But these things, my experience is they're incredibly rugged.
It's rare to find a bad one unless they've been allowed to rust.
Okay.
Or abused, or the lips are bent.
Every once in a while, I've seen ones with a cracked lip.
But most times, these things are incredibly reliable.
Now, you can't really load that with a full mag on a closed bull, can you?
Yeah.
The system that routinely taught, I mean, I've taught for years,
is, by the way, it doesn't have a hole open.
The way you know your gun's empty, you get a clip.
And the first thing is, hand locks the bolt through here.
Old magazine out, fresh magazine comes up.
Remember, you always in and give it a tug.
Right.
And then back into the fight.
If you practice it, you can do it really quick.
Okay.
That actually is a place where that freaking stupid forward charging handle is kind of
convenient because your hand's already out there.
And in the latter years that I was teaching MP5,
particularly out of the United States,
was in the era which red dot sights were becoming the norm.
And you mount a red dot sight with any kind of an HK claw mount or whatever.
One hand, when you do this, your hand hits the mount or the red dot.
And it becomes not as hard to do.
I see guys that terribly ---- on their hand because if it's got like a pick rail type
thing, oh, man, you're bleeding like stuck peas.
Design-wise, I don't think anything will eclipse this.
I think the era of submachine guns has passed by us.
Still popular in European police circles.
Some places in Asia, they're still real popular.
But most places, the assault rifle, particularly the compact ones,
these things are becoming kind of pieces of history.
And I don't know that there's a whole lot more improvement that can be made on a submachine gun.
No, I think this is, to me, is the epic center.
It really is the closed bolt nature of that.
That makes the gun lighter because you no longer are just dependent on bolt mass
to keep it closed when it's firing.
Actually, I've trained a few folks with these.
And one of the things that I always say is, look,
I'm going to teach you to shoot at full auto.
There's a technique to control at full auto.
Remember, technique.
It's not the gun.
It's technique.
And it's different than semi-auto.
I'm going to teach you because if you're overly aggressive and you go to semi
and you go past it and you don't have time to correct in a fight,
you've got to go.
So I'm going to teach you how to control that burst for effective hits.
The system I teach works pretty good.
That's about 20 meters for a competent shooter.
But ideally, you want to be on semi and I teach three shots,
not double taps, three shots, bam, bam, bam.
And it's got to be fast, pop, pop, pop.
And with practice, you can do exceptionally well.
You're shooting for a grapefruit-sized target in the real world.
That's what you're shooting for.
And to pound three rounds in somebody's stern, pop, pop, pop,
is generally real effective.
Even with ball ammo, it's pretty effective.
I believe that.
But I said, well, you're going to learn to shoot full auto,
but that's not going to be your primary method.
And since these guns were particularly in the hands of counter-terrorist or
anti-terrorist units, that's who I was training.
You're responsible for every bullet you launch.
And I said, you know, if you manage to shoot the wrong person or whatever,
that the whole society will be down on you because you were reckless.
So you've got to account for every round.
Look at Beslan or the Paris shooting.
You know, you've got an entire concert full of good guys.
Yeah, I got shot.
You don't want to be chewed up.
So in my mind, I mean, I'm a big MP5 fan.
I've got, you know, I got a few good investments, by the way.
I told you, there's certain things about it.
One is you always want the aperture set on the biggest hole.
Because you want to see as much of your zone as you can.
And I have guys argue, well, if you're on the small aperture,
you shoot more accurately, so it's not a target match.
And there's been a lot of upgrades.
You know, a lot of different sight configurations, tritium front.
You've surefire made a flashlight hand guard,
which everybody's using in the real world, everybody.
Because you've got to ID your target.
Yep.
That one's set up with a nice quick detach mount for a suppressor.
Yeah.
And yeah, a lot of people like cans on them, which became all the rage.
HK, of course, had their flash hider component and stuff.
Over the years, the negatives I've found with this gun is
that you use them a lot.
Eventually, this gets real rocky.
You can still use it because when you basically,
to control a submachine gun,
your shoulder presses the gun forward, muscle tension.
And these two fingers primarily is what pulls back, equal tension.
Now, all this hand does is manipulate and fire the gun.
It has nothing to do with control.
And push-pull, equal muscle pressure both ways.
You basically rob the inertia of this gun to bounce around.
And one of the things with an MP5, of course,
if you've got the bend in the A3 stock, with use, they do get worse.
I mean, this one's got a little bit because obviously they've been shot some.
When they're new, they're real tight.
And when they've been used a lot, man, they got a lot of play.
The other thing is you've got to be careful.
If you use this technique,
remember, a lot of people want to hold a sub gun like this.
If you're holding any magazine-fed weapon at the magazine,
that's the pivot point in the gun.
So you're going to allow that muzzle to go up.
The closer you get to the muzzle, the better control you have.
Also, the closer your fingers are up here.
Yeah.
And I've actually been present.
It didn't happen on my range,
but I've been present when a guy was shooting one of these and did this.
Self-correcting, by the way.
You probably only did that once.
Remember that deal, a far motion built thing that Jim Carrow used to do on TV
about, you know, getting hurt or whatever.
I mean, that's kind of what you see as a,
oh, you know, and holy ----, it's gone.
To the point where actually there were some companies that made
little guards passing on the front of the hand guard
that had a shield that kicked your hand from going up.
Yeah, a little hand stop.
So, and then a lot of guys early on converted to pistol grips.
They would take like a M16 pistol grip and bolt them on here.
And with, you know, DEVCON plastic steel or something,
and by the way, it worked quite well.
SAS were some of the first to do that stunt.
Of course, red dot sights became the norm.
The A2, the solid stock is actually a better shooting platform.
But dude, it ain't cool.
It's not cool.
And I always tell people the trick with a MP5, guys like to walk around.
In the movies, they're shooting blank, so it doesn't matter.
But the technique is you unlock it and pull it back a little way.
So, when you're in a vehicle or where you want compactness,
but when you need to deploy it, once it's unlocked,
you do that and you're in action.
So, there's a soft spot in my heart because I made my living
teaching people to use these for quite a while.
But I'll be the first to tell you,
I don't know if I would reach for one unless it was the only thing I had.
There's probably other ones that would get the job done better.
But again, another icon.
And in the movie, thanks to the movie,
these two guns in many ways are the most recognizable popular image
submachine guns in history.
Yeah, absolutely.
Yep.
Well, cool.
Hopefully, you guys enjoyed that little romp through the Thompson and the MP5.
Stay tuned for more cool stuff.
Thanks for watching.