With North Korea blowing up roads near its southern border and issuing war warnings to South Korea, there is growing anxiety over the possibility of another regional conflict. Meanwhile, South Korean sources report that North Korea is ready to deploy up to 12,000 troops to assist Russia in the ongoing war in Ukraine. This raises critical questions: how do China, Russia, and North Korea's relationships influence the current conflict on the Korean Peninsula?
1. What does Kim Jong-un want?
2. Kim’s 3 major fears
3. The China-Russia-North Korea Triangle 4. Will a war break out in the Korean Peninsula?
Hi everyone, welcome to Lei's Real Talk. Thank you for joining my Saturday night live with Lei.
Okay, how's everyone? Good? Wow, I think I saw some Wu Mao here with us today.
We haven't had them for a while. Well, there's one.
All right. Okay, let's get started because we have a fascinating topic.
I even surprised myself with the amount of information I found today. So, I look forward
to sharing that with you. So, you know, North Korea recently became the center of
attention in geopolitics. In early October, tensions on the Korean Peninsula suddenly escalated.
North Korea not only blew up the connecting roads to the south, but also issued a war warning,
declaring that its 1.4 million soldiers were ready for a major conflict. North Korea also
declared that South Korea is a hostile country, and that if the south sent another drone,
the north would launch attacks without further warnings. And also yesterday, I think it was
yesterday. Yeah, less than 24 hours. The South Korean intelligence agency has said that the
north has started sending troops to help Russia in the Ukraine war, with 1,500 troops having already
been deployed or having already arrived in Russia. And the final number could be as high as 12,000.
So, that raised a critical question or a series of critical questions. What's China's role in this?
How do China, Russia, and North Korea's relationships influence the current
conflict on the Korean Peninsula? So, that's what we'll discuss. All right, let's see.
How's everyone doing? Good? People still joining?
Behaving? People are behaving? Okay, good. All right. All right. RK Jr. I just want to
see how the chat room is going out. Okay. All right. That looks good. So, tonight, I will discuss
four topics, or I'll divide my talk into four items or four topics. First, we'll talk about
what does Kim Jong-un want? And then to further illustrate that, I'll talk about his three major
fears. And then we'll talk about the convoluted China-Russia-North Korea triangle. And then last
but not least, we'll address the question, will a war break out in the Korean Peninsula?
So, first things first, what does Kim Jong-un want? Well, first of all, North Korea needs to
assert its influence in international affairs, particularly before major events
like the U.S. election and the potential ceasefire in the Middle East.
Kim Jong-un has always adopted brinkmanship diplomacy and relies on conflicts or tension
to get attention and bargain for what he wants. So, in the past two years, the world has been
consumed with a few regional conflicts—the Russia-Ukraine war, the conflict in the Middle East,
and the tension in the Taiwan Strait. So, Kim felt a little left out. In the past,
whenever North Korea launched missiles or conducted nuclear tests, world powers paid
attention and negotiated with Kim. Now the world has been preoccupied with other affairs and ignored
North Korea. For more than two years, Kim needs some attention. Also, this is the U.S. election
year, and every time before a major world event like that, Kim wants to remind others of his
existence. Now, we know that's just a very high-level explanation. However, let's get serious.
Much of Kim's need to have, shall we say, a temper tantrum, for lack of a better term,
is driven by domestic issues. He wants or needs to send a strong message to the South.
And what does this mean? Well, in order to explain that, we need to
discuss Kim Jong-un's three fears. They're important in understanding his actions
and also his relations with China and Russia.
So, he has three levels of fear—immediate, intermediary, and long-term.
So, for years, South and North Korea have been engaging in a balloon warfare.
South Koreans, including some defectors from the North, have regularly organized efforts to drop
leaflets or flyers near the North Korean border. This year, North Korea escalated its efforts by
sending balloons filled with feces into South Korea—the dirty balloons. In early October,
South Korean drones reportedly flew to Pyongyang at night and dropped a large number of leaflets
in the capital city. Some were dropped right above Kim Jong-un's residence, I heard.
Kim became furious this time because of the content of the leaflets. The leaflets contained
photos of Kim and his daughter. The focus was Kim's watch, which was identified as a Patek
Philippe, priced at US$12,000, which isn't bad for the brand. I mean, some of Patek Philippe's
watches are six-digit or seven-digit. So, it's a US$12,000 watch, and his daughter,
11-year-old daughter, Kim Ju-ae, sounds similar to Chinese. She wore a Dior down jacket during
the North Korean intercontinental missile test in March, and the jacket is priced at $1,900.
To help the starving North Koreans understand the cost of their beloved leader's watch and his
daughter's jacket, the leaflets converted the prices of the items into the amount of corn a
North Korean farmer needed to sell in order to afford them. The leaflets also showed the average
monthly salary of ordinary citizens in Seoul, South Korea, a measurement of corn, of course.
So, Kim was furious because the flyers helped North Koreans realize that their
benevolent leader's watch was worth more than their lifetime income, and that an ordinary
South Korean citizen makes more money in a day than an average North Korean makes in a year.
The daily salary of average South Koreans is more than the average annual salary of North Koreans.
Now, military confrontation and economic sanctions are not what communist regimes or
communist dictators fear the most. Freedom of speech, free flow of information
terrifies them. What a communist regime fears the most is independent thinking.
South Korea's balloon leaflets greatly empowered North Korean people with the knowledge about the
Kim family's wealth and their Western lifestyle. This knowledge is more frightening to Kim
than guns and artillery. This was Kim's immediate fear. The expose of the Kim family's wealth
and lifestyle enraged Kim Jong-un, prompting him to convene a national security meeting and
instruct immediate military retaliation. This goes back to the strategy I always said. I said,
the West needs to focus on a strategy that ties to the people of China. In this case,
the South Korean leaflet strategy was for the people. It was addressed to the people. It's to
empower people with the knowledge about the information their leader has been hidden from
them. This is precisely the people's strategy, but it got Kim very, very concerned.
The next is his intermediary fear, and that's related to the recent development in the Middle
East. Israel has been using drones to take down leaders of Hamas and Hezbollah successively.
Dictators always use innocent citizens as human shields to protect themselves. Israel's tactic
in eliminating the top leaders without focusing on the people has been successful, or very successful.
The fact that South Korean drones dropped leaflets over Kim Jong-un's head in Pyongyang
has dealt a significant blow to him. If South Korean drones drop leaflets today,
it can drop bombs tomorrow, targeting Kim. Kim therefore vented his fear by threatening South
Korea. If you dare to send another drone, I'll turn Seoul into an ocean of fire.
He hopes to intimidate the South by stopping the drones, and that's his intermediary or midterm
fear. His third fear is a long-lasting one, and that's related to his political instability within
the regime. In this information age, it's more and more difficult to block the North Koreans to
access programs from the South. As a result of this, more North Koreans are waking up.
At a press briefing held in Seoul on August 22, South Korean unification minister Kim Jong-ho
revealed that among the 196 North Korean defectors last year, more than 50 percent were young people
aged between 20 to 39. According to the minister, North Korean youth are significantly influenced
by the Korean wave culture, or what you call Haoyu. In Chinese, we say Hanliu. In Korean,
I think it's Haoyu. In English, it's Korean wave culture. He said North Koreans received the Kim
family's Juche ideology. Basically, it's Kim family's ideology during the day. So,
North Koreans receive Kim Jong-un's ideology during the day and consume South Koreans'
Hanyu culture at night, which has created cracks in the strong walls of the North Korean ideology.
Recently, there has been an increasing trend of North Korean elites, including students studying
abroad and diplomats, defecting. The influx of external information has led to more elites
understanding the true nature of the North Korean regime. So, defections among high-ranking
North Korean officials are likely to continue. In the information age, South Korea's culture and
wealth, including its drama, music, lifestyle, cosmetics, food, everything is eroding North
Koreans' faith in the Kim family, in the communist regime. This cultural influence from the South
is more threatening to Kim Jong-un than the guns and artilleries.
In October 2022, he executed two teenagers for watching and distributing South Korean drama.
Since the beginning of the year, Kim has changed the constitution by removing the language
pertaining to national unification. He dismantled a monument called the Gate of Unification
that was built by his father. Kim declared South Korea as an enemy country, and the North has
completely abandoned unification. He sees the two Koreas as two independent countries.
As he blew up the roads connecting the North to the South,
after he blew up the roads, he reiterated that the two countries are independent of each other
and that he's not interested in unification.
I have to explain that during the early days of Kim's rule, he's only been ruling for the past
12 years. In the early days when he was in his 20s, he often quoted his father and grandfather.
He often said, this is my grandfather Kim Il-sung's last words, or this is my father Kim
Jong-il's last wishes. He had relied on their legacies to prop himself up and legitimize his
rule. Now he found their last wishes and last words becoming more difficult to mention,
or become more of a liability. This is because the previous two North Korean leaders
had their biggest wish set on Korean unification. However, Kim Jong-un understands unification is
impossible if the Kim family wants to rule North Korea indefinitely. The wealth disparity between
South and North is day and night. Average salary in South Korea is $2,500 to $3,000 a month,
and an affluent monthly salary in North Korea is $50, while most people live with a few dollars
a month. North Korea is no match for the South in terms of economic, military, and technological
strength. Unification only means the end of Kim family rule in the North. Unification means the
Therefore, Kim must cut the ties with the South and the democratic world behind South Korea.
That is the reason why he changed the constitution by removing all phrases pertaining to
unification. He also removed the monument. He removed all the texts mentioning unification from
textbooks because it's threatening. The very idea of unification with the South
is threatening because he sees the cultural influence coming from the South.
That brings us to the next question. How is he going to survive? His country is plagued with
poverty and suffers a severe food shortage. Some experts say North Korea is on the brink
of a famine. If North Korea cuts its ties completely with the South and with the rest
of the world, it only has two countries that it can turn to—Russia and China—for assistance.
On North Korea's relations with Russia and China, Kim has also taken a different approach
from that of his father and grandfather. In the triangular relations of Russia,
China, and North Korea, Kim's father and grandfather preferred closer ties with China
as opposed to Russia, than with the Russians. However, under Kim Jong-un, China and North
Korea weren't as close. For example, in 2017, that's under Xi Jinping's time,
during the UN Security Council's vote on sanctions against North Korea for its nuclear tests,
China surprisingly voted in favor of the resolution.
Now, Xi Jinping didn't visit North Korea until seven years after becoming the CCP leader.
I think he went to visit Putin in Moscow, in Russia, immediately, as soon as he became
the leader. But he didn't visit North Korea. You would think that he would visit his
communist neighbor. I mean, he shouldn't wait seven years.
But he didn't. He didn't until, I think it was June 2019. It wasn't until the U.S. trade war
broke out and China needed to leverage Sino-North Korean relations to counter the U.S.
when Xi Jinping visited North Korea in June 2019. Kim also didn't visit China until 2018
and 2019. He visited China four times within that short window of time.
He was coordinating with Xi Jinping for the summit with the U.S. Remember, he met with
President Trump. Was it in Singapore? Somewhere? Was it in Singapore? Okay, that's not important.
The two didn't really meet until 2018 and 2019.
Now, when it comes to China's financial aid to North Korea, it has appeared haphazard.
China's strategy is it will feed North Korea just enough, or it will aid North Korea just
enough so its people won't die from hunger, but will never feed them enough until they're full.
China has been using its aid as kind of the carrot in front of the donkey
to keep it going. China never wholeheartedly aided North Korea.
Because of its own selfish thinking. Now, Kim needs food, energy, and military technology.
Russia is in a much better position than China now to offer that. In exchange, Russia needs
Kim's support in the war. So Kim again veered off the path that his father and grandfather
had set for North Korea and turned to Putin, who offers North Korea the much-needed agricultural
products, energy, and military technology, while Kim supplies Putin with munition and personnel.
Now, interestingly, after Putin's visit to Pyongyang in June and signing a comprehensive
strategic partnership agreement, China-North Korea's relations soured terribly. In early
August this year, while floods ravaged northeastern China, the North Korean regions
along the Yalu River also experienced flooding. On August 3rd, Putin expressed his
condolences to Kim over the floods and offered assistance. The telegram was posted on Kremlin's
website. Interestingly, Putin didn't send a similar message to Xi Jinping for the floods in
China. Strangely, China didn't offer assistance to North Korea like Putin did. In fact, ever since
North Korea and Russia established a comprehensive strategic partnership, there have been signs of
discord between China and North Korea. According to a July 31st report by South Korea's
Yonhap News Agency, Kim Jong-un issued an order to North Korean diplomats
based in China to, quote, not cater to China. Another unusual occurrence was during the July
27th evening event in Pyongyang commemorating the 71st anniversary of the end of the Korean War.
Ambassadors from Russia, Vietnam, and Cuba attended the event, but not the Chinese ambassador.
Wang Yajun was notably absent. Normally, considering the significant support China
provided to North Korea during the war, you would think that the Chinese ambassador would be expected
at the event, as he had always been before. His absence has triggered a lot of speculation.
Was it North Korea that didn't invite him, or was it China that deliberately
wanted to miss the event? Another South Korean newspaper called
Joongang Ilbo quoted sources from the North saying that recently, North Korean authorities
have restricted Chinese nationals living in North Korea from leaving their residences,
and also limited North Korean residents from visiting Chinese families in North Korea.
It also reported that while it used to be possible to settle transactions
in Chinese yuan in North Korea's domestic markets, this is no longer allowed.
And also, in recent months, North Korea has banned its residents and soldiers
from watching Chinese movies. Now, China has reciprocated that. In July, China urged
North Korean authorities to promptly recall North Korean laborers working in China making money.
I think there are a large number of North Korean laborers
working in China, and China wants them to be sent back.
All right, so with all that said, now let's talk about, will a war break out in the Korean
Peninsula? The answer is no. It's a loud and clear no. For the reasons I've explained above,
the North is interested in cutting the ties with South Korea and the democratic world behind South
Korea, but doesn't want war. It wants to coexist with the South as two independent countries.
Now think about it. Kim blew up the roads on his side, which was built with financing from the
If he wanted a war, he would need to keep the roads open to move his troops.
So he isn't interested in having a war. Putin also doesn't want Kim to start a war,
because that will seriously interfere with Kim's effort in supporting Putin's war in Ukraine.
Now, the CCP isn't interested in seeing a war in the Korean Peninsula either.
For the CCP, Mao Zedong's famous phrase, quote,
The greater the chaos in the world, the better it is for us, end quote.
That expression always applies to the CCP. CCP might prefer chaos in Europe,
the Middle East, or the Americas, or even Africa, but not on the Korean Peninsula.
If a major war breaks out on the peninsula, the US, NATO, Japan, Australia, Canada,
and even Southeast Asian countries will likely form an alliance.
The CCP doesn't want the Korean Peninsula crisis to become an opportunity for a large-scale Western
military buildup in the region. Also, the Korean War of the 1950s caused the CCP to lose its best
chance to take Taiwan. If another Korean War breaks out, Xi Jinping's 10-year plan to reclaim Taiwan
could be derailed once again. Also, if North and South Korea really go to war,
no matter who wins, Beijing won't benefit from the war because it could lose a useful pawn,
which would be totally unfavorable to the CCP. If the North wins, which is unlikely,
the North is up. But if, let's say, North Korea wins, then North Korea will become so powerful
that it will not be submissive to the CCP. The CCP would lose a useful pawn. If the South wins,
North Korea would be gone. So it does not want to see a war.
However, this is the most important part of my presentation. CCP may use the potential military
conflict on the Korean Peninsula as a cover to secretly support Russia. I do believe that China
is behind North Korea's military assistance to Russia. In the past few days, social media
videos show large amounts of trucks transporting tanks near the northeast border with North Korea.
I forgot about the videos. You see these videos showing tanks. This is all in the northeast
China. You see these trucks crossing the border going into North Korea. Take a look at how many
trucks. There's a line of them. There's a huge line of them going to North Korea.
Take a look at how many there are. And then people are saying, oh, the war is going to break out.
Take a look at all the tanks. These are just Chinese citizens saying,
we're going to have a war. A war is going to break out. Take a look at all the tanks. That's
what people are saying. I'm going to mute this because it's kind of loud. So think about it.
If there's no war in the Korean Peninsula, what are these tanks for? Where is China sending them to?
What's in the trucks crossing the border to go to North Korea? Supplies for Russia?
It's very possible. So I think this Korean Peninsula crisis may be used as a smokescreen
for China, for its aid to Russia. Because after all, the three countries do belong to the same
camp. The dynamics in their relationship has shifted, but they still need to depend on each
other to carry forward their geopolitical ambitions. So in some way, they will still
help each other. And here's the other video. I don't know if you have seen this. This is the
showing North Korean soldiers being sent to Russia. I think this is obviously in Russia.
So these videos have been showing on social media.
And also, I think there's already 18 or 20 of them who have already defected
to the Ukrainians already. So that would be interesting.
Okay, let me answer a question because someone has sent me this question, which I think is
very applicable. Let me tell you what the question is. I'm going to stop this video.
Okay. All right. So the question is related to how Xi Jinping having made concessions to the
reformists, he may have decided to retire soon or step down and find a successor. So I dedicated
three live streams to cover that topic. So people now ask me, so with Xi Jinping having made
concessions to the reformists, is there a growing possibility for China to suddenly
reshape its economic policies and bring back people like Wen Jiabao and Hu Jintao,
or have people like Wen Jiabao and Hu Jintao step back into politics in order to kickstart
the economy once more on the mainland? So that's a good question. So here's my answer.
Wen Jiabao and Hu Jintao will not return to politics. First of all, their age, who is old,
I think his health isn't doing that well, health-wise. I don't think they're interested
in returning. But what they will do is install their people into leadership roles,
as opposed to returning to politics. Because they want to protect their prestige. They're already
retired. In Chinese, we call that Tai Shang Huang. You are the parents of the emperor,
so you actually rank even higher than the emperor. So you get to control the emperor.
So they're not going to return to politics. But they may want to install one of their people
to run the show. So that's that. And the second question is,
he asked me about a sudden return to old policies. Well, Xi Jinping and Li Jiang have tried to do
that. In this year, we've already seen they've made some U-turns. But so far, the policies
haven't worked. This is because people say, well, maybe the timing is off. No. It's because CCP's
economic policies never worked. CCP never had good, productive policies to begin with.
The flourishing era of the 2000s and the 2010s were the result of massive foreign investments.
With the injection of massive amounts of foreign capital, the Chinese economy looked good. But
it wasn't a healthy one, in essence. Look at all the problems that were left behind now. The real
estate bubble, the local government debt. So what I want to say is the problems were covered up in
the past 20 years. And the investors were made oblivious of them. The CCP never had any good
economic policies to begin with to build a robust economy. So it does not matter who do you put in
place and what kind of policies they come up with. And even if they do return to the
2000s and 2010s, they can't hide the problems anymore. Because the good old days, the crazy
days were built on the blind faith that the West has in the size of China's economy
in the Chinese market. But that perception is gone. That perception is completely gone.
So there's no way China can go back to that era again. So that's my answer to the question.
All right. That's all. Let me see if people have questions for me.
Okay. No, let me get rid of this. Let me come back. All right. Let's see.
All right. There seems to be a lively
how you, how you, how you, juche, juche. I'm trying to pronounce these Korean words.
They're similar to Chinese, but they're not, you know, they're not Chinese. So I'm
sensitive to the different pronunciation. It might be easier for a native English speaker
because you have no preconceived notions about how to pronounce them. And I do.
Okay. Let me see questions. Okay. Well, no questions. Wow. Did I do really that well?
Okay. There will be. All right. St. Louis, St. Louis. Do you think that the CCO may invade,
CCO, you mean CCP, may invade Taiwan soon? I think that with the power shift in Zhongnanhai,
I think there might be change. I think we need to do a program on that,
because I think there may be some strategy shift in the military. Now that Xi Jinping is not
interested in being the top guy, or he's forced to find a successor, or his control over the PLA is
waning. So I think there may be a strategy shift within the party. But I don't think the CCP will
ever give up the idea of taking Taiwan. But it may not be as pressing, because they have other
issues they need to deal with. But we should revisit that topic at some other time. Zhang Zhang
asks, what chapters of Sun Tzu should we read? Sun Tzu Bing Fa, The Art of War?
You should read all of it. The first one is the most important. The Art of War, the first one is
most important. Actually, Westerners see that book as a strategy book in competition, in geopolitical
affairs, or even for battlefield. But actually, it's very philosophical. That book also talks
about interpersonal relationships. And the first chapter is the most important. Nick Fury,
since China needs 10 to 15 trillion yuan to revive economy, how is China able to print that money?
It can. It has printed a lot of money. But when China prints that much money,
but I don't think 10 to 15 trillion is enough. I think China needs more than that.
But as China prints more money, it will make the people at the bottom of the social strata
miserable. Because these people are already struggling with the prices of things.
And then when inflation hits, it will be impossible for them to live.
And that could cause social instability. Daniel Dornas, which possible successor do
you think the PLA boss supports? Which possible successor do you think the PLA boss supports?
I think the question ought to be asked this way. Which possible successor does the PLA boss
respect? There has been overwhelming evidence that Zhang Youxia, the vice chairman of the CMC,
is now controlling the PLA. So the question is, of the two likely candidates that I presented,
when was that? Thursday? The question is, who will he respect more?
And then that will be the one he supports. So I can't answer that yet.
All right. Let's see. All right. CCP. Yeah, I know. Someone said I meant. Okay. Let's see.
How can Elon Musk cozy up to Xi and the CCP and Trump at the same time?
He's Elon Musk. So I think, you know, the world politics, CCP has turned. Everyone is acting now.
I think Elon Musk knows how to put on a good show in front of Xi Jinping.
I think Elon Musk is very smart. He is very smart. He understands one thing about,
he has a very good understanding of the CCP, or one trait. That is, CCP
is nice to people who has more strength. Right? So if you play tough,
Elon understands that CCP wants something. There's something that Elon has that CCP wants,
or ultimately envies. And so Elon plays that to his advantage. But if Elon doesn't have
the X platform, or doesn't have SpaceX, doesn't have some of his other projects,
if all he has is the EV, the Tesla, the EV car, I think the CCP has already butchered him by now.
But I think his ability in running so many successful enterprises is what made CCP fears
him. And Elon has used that to his advantage. Damon, do you think South Korean will join
Ukraine forces? I don't know. I can't. I don't know. It will be a question to ask them.
Okay. All right. Let's see. NTN. CCP just urged the PLA to prepare for war. So that seems to
contradict your previous analysis. That's ongoing. He has always urged the PLA to prepare for war.
It doesn't matter what he says. I think he's going to stick with that rhetoric
for a while because he cannot afford to back down. If it's something he has said,
as long as he appears to be in power, he will stick with his narratives. He won't back off
from it. That's just to save his face. But in essence, if he doesn't have full control over
the PLA, then it's not up to him anymore. It doesn't matter what he tells the PLA to do.
But I'm not surprised if he keeps talking about it because it's very likely just to save his face.
Jeff Rambles. Well, thank you. If you know, how much money China pumped into the economy
2007, 8, 9? Did it matter nowadays? Is it 4 trillion yuan? It was 4 trillion yuan.
Did it matter nowadays? It's not enough. It's not enough now. In 2008, China's economy was still
booming. So it was enough to save the economy. But now, no. 4 trillion is not enough, not even
10 trillion. Because the problem is inherent. The problem cannot be solved with just printing money.
Without a real political reform and systemic change, the economy cannot be revived.
The political system has to change. There has to be a comprehensive change. They need to install a
real market economy, which means the CCP, the political infrastructure has to be completely
uprooted and reinvented. So, all right, that's all. I will end it here and start my weekend.
Well, thank you for joining me. Enjoy the rest of your weekend. I'll see you next week. Bye.