In this video, Dr. Stephen Meyer and Dr. John Ankerberg examine challenges that some scientists and philosophers believe DNA presents to traditional Darwinian evolutionary theory. The discussion focuses on the origin of biological information, the complexity of genetic code, and questions surrounding whether random mutation and natural selection alone can fully account for life’s diversity.
Drawing on arguments from molecular biology and information theory, Meyer outlines why he believes DNA raises unresolved issues for classical evolutionary explanations, while Ankerberg guides the conversation through broader scientific and philosophical implications.
This program presents a critical perspective on evolutionary theory, encouraging viewers to engage with ongoing debates about the origins and development of life.
Today, on the John Ankenberg Show, where did we come from, how did we get here, what brought
us into existence?
In most high schools and colleges, Charles Darwin's theory of evolution is presented
as an established fact of science rather than a theory.
But today, many leading scientists, in their peer-reviewed literature, are rejecting Darwin's
theory for many reasons.
One of the most important being the Cambrian explosion of animals, where complex, fully
formed animals suddenly just appeared in the fossil record, with no prior ancestors before
them.
Why do some scientists believe that these animals present compelling evidence of an
all-powerful designing intelligence in the history of life?
My guest today is Dr. Stephen Meyer, who received his Ph.D. in the philosophy of science from
Cambridge University, as the author of the best-selling book, Darwin's Doubt.
We invite you to join us.
Welcome to our program.
I'm John Ankenberg.
Thanks for joining me.
Our topic is, why are many scientists today rejecting the standard textbook theory of
evolution known as neo-Darwinism, and where did the problems with the contemporary evolutionary
theory begin?
Dr. Meyer, I'm really glad that you're here, and I want to start this program by asking
you to explain how the fossil record poses a problem for Darwinian evolution.
It actually poses two big problems.
Right.
Well, we've been talking about a doubt that Darwin had about the adequacy of his own theory,
its ability to explain all the evidence.
And his doubt concerned a major event in the history of life known as the Cambrian explosion,
in which the first major groups of complex animals arose very abruptly in the fossil
record.
And this posed two problems, two mysteries, that were really unresolved by Darwinian theory.
The first I like to call the mystery of the missing fossils, because these animals appear
very abruptly in the Cambrian layers, but as you go back into the lower pre-Cambrian
strata, you don't find any evidence of the ancestral forms of those animals, the simpler
forms you would expect to find according to Darwin's theory.
Because Darwin expected that the first complex forms of life would have emerged very gradually
as a result of the accumulation of numerous slight variations or changes generation to
generation.
You just don't see the accumulation of those changes in the lower strata.
So that was a problem.
That was a big problem.
But there's an even more fundamental problem, and one that we've grown to appreciate in
much more depth in the 20th century and 21st century.
And that's essentially an engineering problem.
How would the evolutionary process have built these complex forms of animal life, especially
since they arose so abruptly in such a narrow window of geologic time?
And that's, in my book, I look at both of those two mysteries, but the second mystery
is more fundamental.
And it's grown very much more acute because of things that we've discovered in modern
biology during the second half of the 20th century, since the 1950s.
And in particular, things that we've discovered about the information-bearing properties of
living organisms and the information-bearing properties of the amazing molecule known as
DNA.
Yeah.
When Crick and Watson came out with this discovery, what did they show us?
Well, Watson and Crick made the extraordinary discovery in 1953 that is world-renowned.
They were able to elucidate the structure of the DNA molecule.
And they showed that the DNA molecule had this famed double-helical structure with four
chemicals running along the inside of that helix.
And as most of us learn in biology class at some point, the DNA is a molecule that contains
hereditary information, and it has a helical structure.
Along the outside, there is this winding ladder, double-helix ladder, made of sugar and phosphate.
On the inside of the molecule, there are these four chemicals called bases or nucleotide
bases.
And in 1957, four years after the structure was discerned, Francis Crick put forward,
I think, what was one of the most important hypotheses in the history of science.
It's called the sequence hypothesis.
And what Crick proposed was that these four chemicals that chemists represent with the
letters A, T, G, and C are actually functioning like alphabetic letters in a written text
or like zeros and ones in a section of computer code.
That is to say, it's not their chemical shape or structure that matters.
What matters is the arrangement of those chemicals such that they are able to convey instructions
for building all the important proteins and protein machines that keep cells alive.
So what you have on the DNA molecule is literally digital code that provides instructions for
building the crucial parts of cells that allow all life to exist.
When you go down that spine, how much information is there?
Well, in the human genome, there's about three billion nucleotides.
And even in a single one-celled organism, there is enough information to build...
A minimally complex one-celled organism requires about 500, 400, or 500 proteins.
And that's going to compute to several hundred thousand what are called base pairs or individual
nucleotide letters in that genetic message.
That all have to be arranged precisely.
They have to be arranged precisely so that the instruction set will direct the construction
of these proteins, these various kinds of proteins that are needed to keep cells alive.
And proteins are essentially the toolbox of the cell that some of them process information,
some of them build structural parts, little miniature machines.
We're discovering inside cells there are literally little tiny machines in the form of nanotechnology,
sliding clamps and rotary engines and robotic walking proteins.
And then some proteins catalyze reactions.
These are the enzymes that we hear about.
So proteins do all the jobs that keep cells alive and animals alive, but they can only
be built if the instruction set is right and that instruction set is stored on DNA.
Even Bill Gates, when he looked at this, what did he say?
Well, Bill Gates has said that DNA is like a software program, only much more complex
than any we've ever been able to create.
And many biologists have made similar observations.
The famed biotech pioneer Leroy Hood has said very, very directly that DNA contains digital code.
Alright, explain how DNA relates to the Cambrian Explosion and what we're talking about.
Well, right.
I used to ask my students a question, and if you want to give your computer a new function,
what do you have to give it?
And they'd say, well, code or instructions or software or information, and all those
are correct answers.
And it turns out that the same thing is true in life.
If you want to build a new form of life from a simpler pre-existing form of life, you need
new information, or rather, to put it more precisely, the evolutionary process would
need to generate new information, new code.
And that raises a big question.
How does it do that?
How would it do that?
How could it do that?
And one of the reasons that's such a big problem, a big question, is that the mechanism, the
evolutionary mechanism, the driving force of the evolutionary process is thought to
be natural selection acting on random genetic mutations, changes, random changes in the
arrangements of A's, C's, G's, and T's, the digital characters in the DNA molecule.
But what we know from experience, experience of computer code, for example, is that if
you start making random changes to digital characters in a message-bearing sequence,
you're going to degrade the information that's present in that sequence long before you're
ever going to generate something fundamentally new and useful.
I mean, just ask yourself a question, if you're a computer programmer, if you've got a functioning
computer programmer and you start randomly changing zeros and ones, are you going to
generate a new program or operating system, or are you going to introduce glitches and
bugs into the program you already have?
Yeah.
All our techies in the room are saying, keep the bugs away.
Yeah.
Keep the bugs away.
And so there's something fundamentally disquieting from the standpoint of information science
about the idea that random changes in a functional section of code or text could generate something
fundamentally new.
And so that's been a kind of general concern that scientists have had about the creative
power of the Darwinian mechanism.
Can the Darwinian mechanism of natural selection and random mutation really generate new functional
code?
Because to build a new animal, you need new code, you need new DNA with digital information
stored in those molecules.
All right, let's go to the clip where you show what is happening in the cell and how
it's programmed with this code.
How do you explain the origin of the Cambrian animal seemingly out of nowhere?
This isn't just a problem of explaining the absence of evidence in the fossil record.
It's also a problem of explaining everything we know about life right down to the level
of molecules and cells.
The biological structure of a Cambrian trilobite was as complex and sophisticated as a modern
crab.
Its organs included a brain, gut, heart, and compound eyes.
Each organ was constructed from specific types of cells.
Each cell type was made from dozens of specialized protein molecules.
And each protein was assembled from a four-letter chemical code in a section of DNA called a
gene.
Now, for the evolutionary process to transform a simple pre-Cambrian organism like a sponge
with four or five cell types into a Cambrian trilobite with at least ten times that many
different types of cells, that's a huge leap in complexity.
And to make that leap, you need a vast amount of new genetic information.
Where does that information come from?
That's the central mystery of the Cambrian explosion.
So, Dr. Meyer, help us understand this.
Go back to this thing now of chance.
I think Murray Eden at Worcester Institute called a conference in the 1960s, and he was
a mathematician, and he called evolutionary biologists, and he had people that were working
on the atomic bomb.
He had all kinds of scientists there, and he had a question that was bugging him.
What was it?
Well, Murray Eden was a computer scientist at MIT, and there was a picnic in 1965 where
the computer scientists and the physicists and the mathematicians and the engineers were
talking with their biology colleagues over lunch.
And all these scientists with mathematical training were expressing skepticism about
the creative power of the mutation selection mechanism.
They didn't believe that it could generate new genetic information on the scale that
was required to explain things like the Cambrian explosion.
And their main reason for thinking that was they realized that random changes in any formal
language system will inevitably degrade meaning.
And that is because there's a lot more ways to go wrong than there are to go right.
If anyone's played Scrabble and you have a pile of letters, you know that if you just
reach in and start picking the letters out at random, you're overwhelmingly more likely
to get gibberish than you are to get a word.
And that's actually because people have worked out the math on this.
The ratio of functional words of any given length to the ratio of sequences of characters
that give you gibberish is really minuscule.
In the case of a 12-letter word, I think the ratio is 1 over 100 trillion.
One word for every 100 trillion arrangements of characters that give you nothing but gibberish.
So if you start with a word or start with a section of functional genetic text or a
section of computer code and you start randomly changing it, you're overwhelmingly more likely
to end up with gibberish because most of the sequences are gibberish.
And that's the problem that the engineers were concerned about at Wistar.
And so this is just not a good way to think about how genetic information originated.
This mechanism simply is unlikely to produce anything good in the time we have available.
Or as Murray Eden says, it's improbable, it probably couldn't happen.
It's improbable on a cosmic scale.
Alright, let's go to the clip where you show what is happening in the cell and how it's
programmed with this code.
In 1957, Francis Crick first proposed that chemicals called bases along the spine of
the DNA molecule function as alphabetic characters in a written language or digital characters
in a machine code.
This animation shows how this digital information directs protein synthesis.
First a large protein complex separates the tightly wound strands of the DNA to prepare
it to be copied.
During this process of transcription, a protein complex called a polymerase produces a single
stranded copy of the original instructions.
Here we see this copy, a messenger RNA molecule, being constructed inside the polymerase as
individual bases are positioned and added to the growing strand.
Now we see the polymerase in action from the outside as it spits out the messenger RNA
transcript.
Next this RNA transcript approaches and passes through a molecular machine called the nuclear
pore complex, an information recognition device that controls the flow of information in and
out of the cell's nucleus.
Now we see the genetic assembly instructions on the messenger RNA approaching and arriving
at a two-part chemical factory called a ribosome, the site of protein synthesis.
As the messenger RNA transcript passes through the ribosome, the process of translation begins.
During translation, a mechanical assembly line builds a specifically sequenced chain
of amino acids in accord with the instructions on the transcript.
These amino acids are transported from other parts of the cell by molecules called transfer
RNAs, which link specific sequences of bases to corresponding amino acids.
The sequential arrangement of the amino acids determines the type of protein constructed.
When the construction of the chain is complete, it is transported to a barrel-shaped machine
that helps fold it into the precise shape required to perform its function.
After the chain is folded into a protein, it is released into the outer cytoplasm to
do its job in the cell.
Now Stephen, looking at that wonderful clip, I bet you that 85% of our audience didn't
understand what they were looking at.
But they did pick up a couple things.
First of all, all of that was happening in one single cell.
All of those little machines that you were looking at are in one little cell that interconnected.
Then they saw a code.
Your point is, if that code's not right, those machines aren't going to do their jobs.
Because that code, that information, makes them do what they do.
And the question you're raising is, where did this complex code come from?
Well, right.
And what we've understood since the time of Watson and Crick, and from what's called the
period of the 1950s and 60s, which we now refer to as the molecular biological revolution,
is that information is running the show inside living systems.
It's a little bit like what goes on at the Boeing plant up in Seattle, where I live,
where the engineers use a technology called CAD CAM, Computer Assisted Design and Manufacturing,
where an engineer will sit at his or her console, write some code for building a particular part
of the airplane at an assembly center, and the code will go down a wire.
It will be translated into another machine code that can be read by the assembly center.
And then, for example, if you're building an airplane wing, the assembly arm may take
the instructions and put the rivets at exactly the right place in accord with the engineer's
instructions.
So you have digital code being written by an engineer directing the construction of
a mechanical part.
And inside cells, what we have is digital information directing the construction not
of airplane wings, but rather of proteins.
And proteins, again, are the toolbox.
They're the molecules that do all the important jobs inside cells that keep us alive.
So the recognition that information is running the show inside living systems has also made
us aware that if you want to build a new form of life, like a Cambrian animal, you've got
to have a lot of new information.
Every new Cambrian animal required a bunch of new dedicated cell types.
Each type of cell required dedicated proteins.
Each new type of protein requires, in turn, new code.
So the Cambrian explosion isn't just an explosion of new forms of animal life.
It's an explosion of information.
And yet there are really big reasons to doubt that the neo-Darwinian mechanism can generate
that new information.
And in my book, Darwin's Doubt, I go into, I explain the math as to why it's so incredibly
improbable to think that a random search for new sections of a functional genetic text
could produce, even on the scale of the entire history of life, even one new gene or protein.
Stephen, illustrate that with your story about a thief trying to break into a lock.
Let me give you a homespun illustration.
Imagine we've got a bike outside the building here, but it's locked with a nice four-dial
bike lock.
Is it more likely that a thief will be able to open the lock as a result of a random search
for the combination, or is it more likely that the thief will fail?
Now, in a way, it's a trick question, because it depends on how much time the thief has
to try to open the combination.
We know that there's a lot of different combinations.
In fact, with a four-dial lock, there's 10 times 10 times 10 times 10, or 10,000 possible
arrangements of those digits, only one of which will open the lock.
If the thief only has a couple minutes, the thief will, by random means, only be able
to sample a very small number of those combinations.
And so it's overwhelmingly more likely in that case that the thief will fail.
But we could imagine a situation where, say, we gave the thief several days to do it, and
he was able to sample more than half of the combinations, in which case it would become
more likely that he would succeed than he would fail.
But what if we change the illustration a little bit?
What if we give the thief that same, say, 24-hour period, and now we confront him with
this lock, a lock with 10 dials on it?
Well, with 10 dials, you're not just adding combinations, you're multiplying by 10 with
each new dial.
So for a 10-dial lock, you actually have 10 to the 10 possible combinations, or 10 billion
combinations.
So even in a day, a full 24-hour period, the thief is only going to be able to sample a
very tiny fraction of that total 10 billion.
So in that case, it's overwhelmingly more likely that a random search will fail to find
the meaningful combination that will open the lock.
Now, the question in biology is, is the situation for finding a new gene or protein more like
the first case, where the lock has a reasonably small number of combinations in relation to
the time available, or is it more like the second case, where the number of combinations
is so vast that even with a great deal of time, there's not going to be enough time
to sample more than a small fraction of the combination?
What is it?
Well, it turns out that the biological system confronting us is not like the 4-dial lock
with the day, it's much more like the 10-dial lock.
In fact, there's a scientist named Douglas Axe, who's given a very precise estimate of
this, and he has shown that it's much more like a bike lock with 77 dials, which is one
for every functional arrangement of those letters in the DNA code, there are 10 to the
77th arrangements that will give you gibberish, that is a non-functional, non-folding amino
acid change rather than a functional protein.
And so with that many combinations to search, even if you have 3.5 billion or 4 billion
years of biological history to do the searching, by a random means, you're not going to have
enough time to sample but a small little fraction of the different combinations.
And so it's going to be overwhelmingly more likely that a random search, when relying
on random mutation, will fail to find even one functional gene or protein in the known
history of life on Earth.
That's the upshot of Axe's calculations.
And I go into this and explain this in more detail in the book Darwin's Doubt.
We all kind of grew up in public schools and were taught that evolution and life arose
by chance, okay?
But I can hear some folks saying, you know, there's a small probability that this could
have happened, so why isn't it possible?
Well, people will look at a number like one chance in 10 to the 77th power and they'll
say, ah, so there's a finite probability that a new gene or protein could arise in
the known history of life on Earth.
And there's a flaw in that reasoning.
We can never say anything is impossible because there's always a finite probability of any
event happening.
But the question is whether or not this is a good explanation or a bad explanation.
And I have an illustration for why this is a bad explanation.
There's a famous comic named Jim Carrey who, in a particular movie, is playing a character
who's kind of a goober.
And he approaches a young lady that he fancies.
And he says to her, what are the odds that a girl like me and a guy like you could get
together?
And he botches his pickup line.
And she says, well, not good.
And he says, what do you mean not good?
Like one in a hundred?
And she says, no, like one in a million.
And he starts jumping up and down.
He gets all excited.
He says, oh, so there's a chance.
There's a chance.
And I sometimes think this is the way our Darwinist friends reason that just because
there's a finite probability doesn't mean that the event is at all likely to happen.
And in the case of the idea that random mutations have generated the new genetic information
that we need, it's overwhelmingly more likely that such a mechanism will fail than it will
succeed.
And so the hypothesis that such a mechanism succeeded is actually overwhelmingly more
likely to be false than true.
So in science, we don't want to choose a hypothesis that's more likely to be false than true.
We want the best and most likely explanation.
So clearly, we should be looking someplace else other than the Darwinian mechanism to
explain the origin of information.
Yes, there's a finite probability.
But it's overwhelmingly more likely that that is not how it happened.
And therefore, we should be looking for a better explanation.
All right.
Now, you've listened to what Stephen has said today.
And next week's program, we're going to test this out with what evolutionary biologists
are saying today, such as Richard Dawkins.
They're saying that life still arose by natural selection and random mutation.
And we're going to illustrate what they're saying.
And I'm going to let you respond to it next week.
So folks, I hope you'll join us then.