Stephen Hawking Was Wrong About Black Holes! | Brian Cox

Decoding Life's Mysteries
11 followers
27 Video Views·Feb 3, 2025
Brian Edward Cox (born 3 March 1968) is an English physicist and musician who is a professor of particle physics in the School of Physics and Astronomy at the University of Manchester and the Royal Society Professor for Public Engagement in Science. He is best known to the public as the presenter of science programmes, especially BBC Radio 4’s The Infinite Monkey Cage and the Wonders of... series and for popular science books, such as Why Does E=mc2? and The Quantum Universe.
in understanding exactly, in a sense it was what's wrong with Stephen Hawking's calculation,
which is a weird thing to say sometimes because people think Stephen Hawking,
sure he didn't get his math wrong, but he did actually in his calculation.
So what he calculated back in 1973-1974 is that a black hole, so we picture this thing
from which nothing can escape, even light, so when you go in you're gone basically.
What he calculated is that even though these things are just
a distortion in space and time, that's the description of them,
so it's almost as if there's nothing there apart from a distortion in space and time.
He calculated that they glow, so they have a temperature,
so they emit radiation, it's called Hawking radiation, and so important was that discovery.
If you go to Westminster Abbey in London, look on the floor of the Abbey,
on his memorial stone, and he's in there next to Newton and Shakespeare and all these people,
and he's there, and chiseled in stone on the floor of Westminster Abbey is his equation for
the temperature of a black hole. So it was this tremendously important discovery.
So he discovers these things glow and he calculates how they glow,
very low temperature, but they emit things, which means that they shrink,
because they're emitting stuff and so they're shrinking.
So that means they have a lifetime. So first of all, one day they'll be gone.
So that means that you have to address this question of what happened to all the stuff
that fell in. And his calculation said that there's no record at all of anything that fell
in, in all this radiation that's come off the black hole. So it's purely information-less
radiation. So what that means is that black holes destroy information, according to that
calculation. And that's a big deal, because nowhere else in all of physics does anything
erase information from the universe. So it's really true that if I got this notepad and pen,
right, and I wrote some things on it, and then I set fire to this, even, just incinerated it,
put it in a nuclear explosion, whatever, in principle, according to all the laws of nature
that we know, if you collected everything that came off, all the radiation, all the bits of ashes
and things, and you could just measure it all, then just in principle, the idea is you could
reconstruct the information. So it all gets scrambled up and thrown out, and so in practice
you can't do it. But just in principle, the laws of nature say that information is not destroyed,
it's just scrambled up in a way that you can't reconstruct. But this calculation that Stephen did
said there is no information in that radiation at all. Zero. Just nothing. So it seemed that
uniquely in the universe, black holes erase information.
When you say there's no information, how are you measuring whether or not there's information in it?
So really in bits. I mean the idea is, and I should say it's very much in principle this,
so no one thinks in practice you could reconstruct what I wrote down on this if you set fire to it.
But in principle...
Well maybe sometime in the future, a million years from now.
In principle, you could just collect everything. Then somewhere in all that radiation and ashes
and light that's come off the thing, is the information. It's there. So you could reconstruct
the book, or what I wrote on this page, in principle. But the thing about Stephen's
calculation was that even in principle it said there is no information. And by the way,
it's kind of easy to see why actually. Because this radiation, this Hawking radiation that
comes off the black hole, it's coming from the horizon of the black hole.
